The premise is simple: Listeners share their first date stories with Nancy Wilson in the hopes they can help facilitate a second date with someone. The results can sometimes be outrageous.

Was Nate's competitiveness too much for Jessie?

Did Sophie's bad habit cost her a shot at a second date with Shawn?

Jack couldn't get a word in edgewise, even to order his dinner!

Jared can't let go of something from his past. Was it too big of a red flag for Kaitlyn?

Cole is quite the conspiracy theorist. Was it too much for Kendra?

Jenna is clearly not very good at keeping a secret.

Who would have thought a pay it forward chain would lead to this?

How can you steal something from someone after they invite you in their home?

Peyton took Tara to a place that is very special to him, but she wasn't feeling it. Where did they go and will they go back out?

Paige is worried that Adam may end up in jail. Listen and find out why!

Sierra has absolutely no interest in something that Garrett is very passionate about. Will they overcome it and go back out?

Justin saw a different side to Lindsey on the way to their date. Was it too big of a red flag?

Allison had a night that she can't remember with TJ and she is trying to put the pieces to the puzzle back together.

Sarah and Travis' date at the bar took an unexpected turn.

Emily was not prepared for the type of Game Night Casey invited her to.

Will has a certain type, and Katie was not changing to fit it.

Tyler might be a little too old fashioned for Bella's lifestyle.

We found out that Jacob is not a very good multitasker.

Trying to set up a date with someone while you are already a date with another person usually does not end well.

Dallas thought the date was all fun and games. Did Jenna?

Bella discovered Travis had an interesting way of eating fried chicken at the Super Bowl party.

They met at the gym and had their first date at the gym. What could have gone wrong?

Serena lived a certain kind of lifestyle that Chris was unsure about. Can he look past it and go back out with her?

Travis invited Makenzie over to cook her a family recipe for dinner. What could go wrong?

Will Emma forgive Dustin for making their date a public event?

Jessie met Ryan, and his entire family, on their ice-skating date. Was it too much, too fast?

Olivia left out some very important details about her life before her date with Chase.

Jason may have taken things a little too far during their first date at the movies. Will Hannah give him another shot?

Was Nate's side job too much for Lexi to handle?

This is a third wheel disaster you would never expect.

Caleb thinks he is in "the know" with all of their mutual friends. Was all the gossip too much for Abby?

Who would've thought the lottery would be such a deal breaker? Listen and find out why!

You can't be trying to land a kiss after eating a plate full of garlic...

Trey's table manners, or lack thereof, really caught Alli by surprise. Can he redeem himself and get a second date?

There was one very uncommon interest between Jamie and Dru. Was it too much for Dru?

Amanda was full of questions on their first date. Was it too much for Logan?

Everything was good, until they got to Heather's house. Listen and find out what happened!

Travis invited Jen over to watch football, and it took a very unexpected turn.

Ryan's passion was too much for Abby, despite his adorable dog.

Things are very awkward now for these coworkers after their first date...

Emily didn't seem as ready to settle down as Josh did. Listen and find out why!

Find out why Cory felt used on his first date with Briana.

Nate is not shy when it comes to personal hygiene. Was it too much for Carrie?

Alex kept doing something on their date that drove Zach crazy. Was it too much of a red flag?

Jared is all about being fair and he may have taken it too far on his date with Taylor.

Find out why these two gamers were not on the same page.

An online review of a restaurant ended this relationship before it even had a chance to start.