The Cookie Sheets

Follow The Cookie Sheets
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

Joe and Kurt, two idiots who spend more time watching wrestling than anyone should, team up to talk the stories, matches, and fantasy booking of the week.

Mostly Average Joe & Sub Par Kurt


    • Nov 4, 2022 LATEST EPISODE
    • every other week NEW EPISODES
    • 59m AVG DURATION
    • 15 EPISODES


    Search for episodes from The Cookie Sheets with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from The Cookie Sheets

    Episode 203: Tubthumping

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 4, 2022 49:19


    Joe and Kurt are back this week to get into AEW’s wild surprises from Dynamite. But then, Crown Jewel. The post Episode 203: Tubthumping first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

    Episode 212: But First, Drama

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 28, 2022 56:26


    Joe and Kurt are back this week! On the docket first is an update on Hangman Page and the Elite / CM Punk scuffle. Then it’s a detour into a discussion of problematic wrestlers as well as the PWI Women’s Top 150 rankings. The post Episode 212: But First, Drama first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

    Episode 211: The MOST WWE

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 14, 2022 59:16


    Joe and Kurt need to talk about that ending to Extreme Rules. What does this mean for Bray Wyatt? Who else came back to WWE Monday night? And WTF is up with Bryan Danielson losing in AEW so much? The post Episode 211: The MOST WWE first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

    Episode 210: Actually Extreme Rules!?!

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 7, 2022 44:41


    Joe and Kurt detail the LATEST fight in AEW, before turning their attention to the commentary shakeups in WWE and this weekend’s Extreme Rules Premium Live Event. The post Episode 210: Actually Extreme Rules!?! first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

    Episode 209: Grand Slam Title Swap

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 23, 2022 61:15


    Joe and Kurt are here to discuss all the titles changing hands from Wednesday’s Dynamite Grand Slam event, but first they must talk about the returning Saraya!! The post Episode 209: Grand Slam Title Swap first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

    Episode 208: The Hullabaloo in Hoffman Estates

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 9, 2022 79:34


    Joe and Kurt are back from a weekend of seeing two wrestling shows live to… talk about a fight that happened backstage when the cameras were off. Sigh. The post Episode 208: The Hullabaloo in Hoffman Estates first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

    Episode 207: We’re Not Ready

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 2, 2022 71:14


    Joe and Kurt gear up for the weekend of wrestling ahead: Rampage, Cash at the Castle, Worlds Collide, and All Out! The post Episode 207: We're Not Ready first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

    Episode 206: Returns and Brackets

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 12, 2022 44:12


    Joe and Kurt take time this week to discuss the shock returns in WWE and their WWE Women’s Tag Title tournament, before turning their eyes toward AEW’s returns and their Trios Tag Tournament! The post Episode 206: Returns and Brackets first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

    Episode 205: You’re RETIRRRED

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 5, 2022 54:25


    Joe and Kurt spend the first chunk of this episode diving into Vince McMahon’s “retirement.” Then they get into SummerSlam and the Raw after before discussing AEW and ROH. The post Episode 205: You're RETIRRRED first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

    Episode 204: To PG or Not PG

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 22, 2022 56:30


    Joe and Kurt are back! This week is discussing the potential impact of WWE switching back to a TV-14 rating. Then it’s onto Death Before Dishonor and Ric Flair’s Last Match! The post Episode 204: To PG or Not PG first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

    Episode 203: The Forbidden Door was Inside Us All Along

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 1, 2022 55:02


    Joe and Kurt are here to talk about all the Forbidden Doors opened this weekend and Blood and Guts before discussing this weekend’s Money in the Bank PREMIUM LIVE EVENT. The post Episode 203: The Forbidden Door was Inside Us All Along first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

    Episode 202: Whoah There Pal

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 24, 2022 62:08


    Joe and Kurt are back! This week the show has to start with the current state of the WWE as it pertains to Vince McMahon’s hush-money allegations. Then after that uncomfortableness, it’s all about this weekend’s AEW Forbidden Door! The post Episode 202: Whoah There Pal first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

    Episode 201: Well, That Happened

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 3, 2022 85:46


    Joe and Kurt are back! This week is about MJF and you know, everything going on with that whole situation. Then it’s onto this weekend’s NXT In Your House and Hell in a Cell PREMIUM LIVE EVENTS. The post Episode 201: Well, That Happened first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

    Episode 200: That’s a Working Walk-Out

    Play Episode Listen Later May 20, 2022 60:20


    Joe and Kurt are back! This week’s top story is clearly the walk-out of Sasha Banks and Naomi from Monday Night Raw. After that, they discuss Wrestlemania Backlash, Ric Flair’s last match, and more! The post Episode 200: That's a Working Walk-Out first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

    Episode 199: All the Names, Names, Names

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 22, 2022 47:07


    Joe and Kurt are back! This week they discuss AEW and NJPW’s newly announced co-PPV, HOOK vs Danhausen, and Hangman vs CM Punk before talking WWE and Vince McMahon’s obsession with changing wrestlers’ names. The post Episode 199: All the Names, Names, Names first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com.

    Claim The Cookie Sheets

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel