Melissa & Tara discuss all the strange, creepy, and murderous things that happen in small towns.
Melissa and Tara are back with a new episode! Wisconsin's Sheboygan Insane Asylum
Melissa and Tara record in front of their first LIVE audience! Suzanne disappeared on Mother's day. Her bicycle was found, but suspicious circumstances surround her disappearance.
Joy was murdered, but why haven't they caught the killer?
Joanne was shot at about 4 a.m. Sept. 26, 1993.
Joan disappears one day from her kitchen, which is covered in blood.
It's 1987 and Don Henry & Kevin Ives are hit by a train, but they are laying on the track, no movement at all.
The Gee family was murdered in a tiny town in Rural Illinois.
Was it self-defense? Trigger warning - allegations of child abuse.
Audrey Marie HIlley murdered her husband, and poisoned her daughter.
Adrianne Reynolds was the new girl in town. Unfortunately, she found the wrong friends.
Young Ryder was murdered, and his mother held responsible.
Reilly James Scarbrough, Acelynn Wester, Bethany Jo Wester, Steven Payne Polk County Arkansas 2017
In 1922 five family members and a maid on a farm in Germany are BRUTALLY murdered.
Kim Jackson was murdered by his wife, who was involved in a threesome.
Heather Quan is found dead in her apartment, Ryan Waller is believed to have killed her, but he's acting very strange. What happened to this young couple?
Discussing the horrors of the Crownsville Mental Hospital
Lisa Stebic disappears one night. She left her house on foot with her purse, keys, and phone, all of which have never been found.
Part two of the Villisca Axe Murders, where Melissa tells of her time in the house.
In 1912 a family of 6 with two overnight guests were murdered by an axe.
Curt Thompson is a bully. In part 2 we talk about his trial and mental illness.
Curtis Thompson was well known around Toulon IL, but on March 22, 2002 he became infamous by killing 3 people.
Melissa White and her husband (ex or estranged, not sure) are having domestic issues.
Ron Ellis murders his wife, two daughters, and three bystanders.
New Year's Eve 1964 3 young people were murdered at a rest stop outside of Watertown, NY.
From 1979 to 1981, Thomas Richard Bunday, a technical sergeant who was stationed at the Eilson Air Force Base near Fairbanks, Alaska, he murdered 4 women and an 11 year old girl.
In 1982 seven people died from poisoned tylenol. Listen as our guest and Melissa's father tells his account of that day.
Episode 4 of Nothing Happens in a Small Town. Talking about serial killer Arlie Ray Davis.
Katie DeWitt James goes missing a few days after filing for divorce from her husband.
Tara & Missy talk about the Woolley Case in Kewanee IL
Talking about small-town Kewanee, IL and the murder of Jami Sue Pollock.
© 2020-2025 Ivy Podcast Discovery LLC
