Not Penny's Probst

Back for another quick recap of the last few episodes of Survivor 41. We've got some twists to unpack, some moves to critique, and some challenges to judge. Matt searches for his own Survivor legacy in case Ricard ends up being the first player who is deaf in one ear to win the game before he does, and reminds us of how he was "almost" cast in a facebook version of The Real World.

SURVIVOR IS BACK and we're here to talk about the first three episodes of season 41. We're running some fantasy leagues that we have no idea how to score, but mainly just catching the vibe for all the new players and all the new twists that Probst has introduced after this long gap between seasons. We discuss our top picks for potential winners this season, let's see if anyone can call their shot.

Turns out scheduling a podcast is hard. This week we wrap up chat about our watch through Survivor: Panama with a live react to Shane's FTC strategy, do a little sh*t talking on Manifest, and start a watch of The Mole. Jake made some major upgrades to our Survivor: LOST RPG and we turn it up post-merge. We'll be back later this month after the season premiere of Survivor season 41!

This episode is (dare I say) a treat! Lyrsa Torres from Season 37 of Survivor (David vs. Goliath) joins us to talk about her experiences while playing Survivor and a lot of the psychological stress that follows you home after playing the game. We get some super secret naughty info that I don't think we're technically allowed to talk about so please PLEASE don't tell Jeff. She hasn't seen Lost, but we got her to put the pilot into her watch queue. Listen to Lyrsa's horror podcast at: https://bit.ly/3r0XXxT and find her art at: https://etsy.me/3r2eq4M Email: notpennysprobst@gmail.com | Twitter / IG: @notpennysprobst

On our last episode, Adam McIlwee suggested that we check out Survivor: Panama since none of us had seen it, so we all did our homework and figure out who's on team Shane. We also drop a little hint about an upcoming guest on the show before combing through some more Survivor 41/42 rumor news. It's been a minute since we did a deep dive into LOST story beats, so we check in to see who loves love the most. In our Survivor: LOST RPG, 2 people go home even though only one of them was voted off, and a rat man with a rat plan stirs up some trouble by hiding a secret rat in the woods. notpennysprobst@gmail.com | Twitter/IG: @notpennysprobst

Our good friend Adam McIlwee (Wicca Phase Springs Eternal) joins us after he let us know that he just binged 20 seasons of Survivor. He talks about how Jeff is a game warden puppet master akin to an X-Men villain and that he's now watching every UFC fight has overtaken his Survivor marathon. We also revisit his experience watching LOST on network TV as it originally aired. But first, we pick back up on our Survivor: LOST role playing game where a third person is voted off of The Island and players are starting to break down. Follow / listen to Wicca Phase Springs Eternal at wiccaphasespringseternal.com notpennysprobst@gmail.com | Twitter/IG: @notpennysprobst

We interrupt our regularly scheduled programming to bring you a special episode of NPP rounding up all of our thoughts, hot takes, and fantasy twists for The Circle. Season 1 and season 2 spoilers ahead… “Circle - play the newest episode of Not Penny’s Probst.” notpennysprobst@gmail.com | Twitter/IG: @notpennysprobst

Everyone is back on the sauce tackling the backlog of Survivor seasons, so we finally set up a watch log so we can all keep track of which seasons we have and have not seen. After running through the latest news and some follow ups from previous episodes, we pick up our role playing game of Survivor: Lost where Probst himself gives us a challenge description that ultimately sends a new tribe to tribal council and we say goodbye to another beloved character. notpennysprobst@gmail.com | Twitter/IG: @notpennysprobst

Let's make friends and influence people. We play our first round of "Survivor: Lost" where we role play for the cast of Lost in a fantasy season of Survivor. Personalities clash as players head into their first immunity challenge which ultimately sends somebody home. Influence shifts up and down after every interaction and tensions are already running high at camp. Jack takes the lead, Ana Lucia gets soft, and Sayid makes it weird. Jake wants to know if you'd come back after losing Survivor, Dane wants to know if you'd ever throw a challenge, and Matt wants to know what's up with the copious amount of hashtagging in the new season of The Circle.

The Fantasy Draft is here! Jake built out a whole computer system which we'll be using to help us role play and compete in our dream season of Survivor featuring 18 characters from Lost. We set up some of the rules and parameters for the game, and then we all pick our tribes which will compete head to head for immunity in future episodes, until one is ultimately awarded the title of Sole Survivor. We also run through some corrections and forgotten details from NPP002, decide where Woo went wrong, discuss who we would bring with us on a season of Survivor: Blood vs. Water, and figure out what Ron Weasley thought about recently watching Lost for the first time. notpennysprobst@gmail.com | Twitter/IG: @notpennysprobst

On the second episode of Not Penny's Probst, we accidentally change the format of the whole podcast. While running through some scenarios that we think might take place if the characters from Lost were on a season of Survivor, we back our way into an idea for a fantasy draft / fan fiction / role playing game that we'll be bringing back over the course of many future episodes. We also analyze some tabulated data from the online community about who from Lost they think might win a season of Survivor, and wrap it up talking about our (so far) unsuccessful audition strategies to get casted on Survivor. notpennysprobst@gmail.com | Twitter/IG: @notpennysprobst

In the pilot episode of Not Penny's Probst, Jake, Dane, and Matt list their show watching credentials and talk about why they decided to start the podcast. Jake wants to know what everyone would bring to the island if they were on Survivor. Matt gives his take on The Bye Bye Man which was directed by Jonathan Penner (Survivor), and Dane starts at The End of Lost by addressing the divisive series finale. Sam Yarmuth (Triple B Records) joins us to answer some questions about a record he is releasing for a Survivor supergroup called Dragonz, a Rock Band inspired project from Benjamin "Coach" Wade, Courtney Yates, and James “J.T.” Thomas spawned during their time on Ponderosa while filiming Season 20 of the show (Heroes vs. Villains).

Welcome new recruits to the most ambitious Lost x Survivor crossover event in podcast history. Jake, Dane, and Matt will be cruising through whatever hot gossip and juicy tidbits they can cook up about their favorite early 2000's television programs based on strangers trapped on an island. In this promo teaser for our very first episode, we find out from our friend, Sam, that in one of the greatest Survivor seasons of all time (Heroes vs. Villains) the castaways spent their down time watching LOST on DVD after they were voted out. A serendipitous introduction foreshadowing many more conversations about how these two shows may or may not intersect.