No True Bill

In this episode, Joe breaks down the disappearance of a teenager from New York on Spring Break. This case, unsolved for years, finally sees a conclusion.  Thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

Ray takes us back to Ohio- Columbus, Ohio- and discusses the violent murder of sweet ol' Anna Mae Florence. How do detectives crack the case after the investigation goes cold for decades? Listen and find out.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

In this episode, we discuss (for the first time) a serial killer- Robert Ben Rhoades. Great communication across state lines helps catch this killer who roams the highways of America.  Thanks for listening. -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

In this episode, Cheryl discusses the untimely death of Leonila Stickney, an immigrant who came to America with big dreams only to die a violent death. Thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

In this episode, Ray tells the survival tale of Mary Vincent and how Larry Singleton tried his best to take her out but she wouldn't quit. To the surprise of absolutely no one, Larry wasn't done with killin'. Thanks for listening,  Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

Thanks for joining us in our sophomore season here at NTB. Ray kicks off the season with the murder of a police officer in Ohio. Initial investigative theories are proven wrong when, years later, the truth about this murder is revealed.     Thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

Ray's rundown of the yogurt shop case reaches it's conclusion--which may not be particularly satisfying. That being said, this episode wraps up our first season and we really appreciate you listening.  Y'all stay outta trouble.    -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

The depressing tale of the yogurt shop murders and criminal investigation continues in Part III.  PLEASE BE ADVISED that the sound on this episode is terrible. The wrong input was selected so the episode recorded from the computer microphone instead of our sound board. My bad. We'll do better.   Thanks for listening,  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

Ray continues his discussion of the Austin, Tx. Yogurt Shop Murders. In this episode, the investigation continues: leads are followed only to frustration. The Yogurt Shop case officially goes cold.    Thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

In this episode, Ray starts his opus:  The Austin, Texas Yogurt Shop Murders. Episode one goes through the first 48 hours of the investigation of this horrific crime in the heart of Texas.    Enjoy.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray. 

This is our year-end holiday extravaganza and review. It's been a long year at NTB and the end of the year has been bonkers but we've survived and so we celebrate.  This episode was recorded at Cheryl's house, with pizza, beer, and piecaken (google it). There's no true crime in this episode, other than what the piecaken did to my glucose levels.    Happy New Year! -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

 In this episode (it's a long one) we look at the case of Brett Seacat, a former police officer accused of a downright awful crime.  Thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

This case was suggested by our former summer intern, Elijah.  In this episode, Cheryl describes the terrible crimes committed by Arron Lawson against his own kin. This one is rough and Arron Lawson is a punk.    Thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

In this episode, Joe walks through the confession and conviction(s) of Eugene Clawson for the WVU Coed murders.  A couple of disclaimers:  1) Joe was full of Covid when recording the intro to this episode, but the rest is normal.  2) This episode includes transcripts of a violent murder confession (which may or may not be true) so be advised: it is graphic.  3) There will undoubtedly eventually be a third episode about this case--just not now.     As always,  Thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

In this episode, Joe tells an old tale from a town close to our hearts- Morgantown, WV.  Part 1 includes the disappearance of Mared and Karen and the frustrating early investigation of the missing WVU coeds.     Thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

In this episode Cheryl wraps up the story of the Sinister Minister, including appellate issues and other post-conviction shenanigans.  Also, we resurrect the use of "great white buffalo" to bleep out names we shouldn't be speakin'.     As always, thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

In this Episode, Cheryl tells us about a deadly minister from Pennsylvania whose wives keep dying.  I think we all agree that these episodes were the most fun to record, and we hope that you enjoy them too.  As always, thanks for listening.     -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray.  

Ray hits us with Part 2 of this series and the story of Sonja Farak, another scientist from a crime lab in Massachusetts.  This one is wild.  Please ignore all of Ray's sniffles, he probably had the 'rona.    As always, thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray.   

In Ray's first episode, he takes on part one of a laboratory scandal that rocked Massachusetts.   This is the story of Annie Dookhan,  a chemist in a State crime lab who caused all kinds of problems for justice.     As always-thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

In this episode we wrap up our discussion of the murder of Mackenzie Cowell.  We also specifically discuss what prosecutors have to consider when offering a plea agreement, especially in serious cases.     Thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

Joe takes a look at the bizarre Washington State murder of Mackenzie Cowell.  Part 1 of 2.  After this episode, you'll find yourself asking, "Do you like teriyaki burgers?"   Thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl and Ray

In the final installment of the Darlie Routier series, Cheryl breaks down the trial of Darlie and the aftermath--followup investigations and accusations.     Thanks for listening. -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

In this episode, Cheryl really breaks down the trial of Darlie Routier--what  evidence was actually presented and some misconceptions in the media about that evidence.     Thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl and Ray

Let the deep dive into Darlie Routier truly begin.  Cheryl continues in Part 2 of Darlie Routier, with in-depth discussion of the players involved and the pretrial of Darlie Routier.     Thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

Our first case is presented by Cheryl and it's a well-known case in the true crime community:  Darlie Routier.  This case involves the brutal murder of two children in the State of Texas.  This is the first of four episodes devoted to the Routier case.  Many people proclaim Darlie's innocence-  Cheryl breaks down the facts, evidence adduced at trial, and the appeals of Darlie Routier.   Thanks for listening.  -Joe, Cheryl, and Ray

In this episode, we introduce ourselves and tell you what we think this podcast is about.  Three prosecutors who are coworkers but also friends who like to talk about true crime, not just our own cases.  This episode was recorded early on and we promise that sound quality will improve.  Thanks for listening.   -Joe, Cheryl, & Ray