I Am Gotham

Follow I Am Gotham
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

"I Am Gotham" is a weekly exploration of the Bat family of books from a long time Batman geek as he attempts to read every Batman appearance since 1939.

iamgothamshow@gmail.com

  • Jan 26, 2018 LATEST EPISODE
  • infrequent NEW EPISODES
  • 42m AVG DURATION
  • 24 EPISODES


Search for episodes from I Am Gotham with a specific topic:

Latest episodes from I Am Gotham

When Being A Batman Fan Becomes An Episode Of The X-Files

Play Episode Listen Later Jan 26, 2018 35:06


Welcome back to I Am Gotham, the show that explores Bat-family history from 1939 to the present. In this episode, Martin sits down to address some of the controversies cropping up around the Batman books. First up, a discussion about the petition over whether the Joker should be made gay. Then, people are up in arms over the similarities between Batman #39 (2016) and Action Comics #761 (1938). Finally, Batman is getting a new costume and people are...confused? Thanks for listening!You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Batman #6 (1941)

Play Episode Listen Later Jan 16, 2018 12:51


I Am Gotham returns with a brand new episode as Martin dives deep into Batman #6 from 1941! Will we read another gangster story? You bet! Will there be weirdo villains? Maybe! Can we expect some moral lessons? Of course! Is the issue any good? Tune in and find out!You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

The #Batman Challenge

Play Episode Listen Later Dec 25, 2017 22:51


In a special Christmas episode of I Am Gotham, Martin is joined by his Nerdy Legion cohost, Nick Wetmore, to talk about his recent experience rereading the first six issues of Batman: Rebirth and whether he still feels as strongly about the book as he did when it first launched.You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Batman Vs. Two-Face Animated Film Discussion

Play Episode Listen Later Dec 11, 2017 62:46


Welcome to a special episode of the I Am Gotham podcast. For this episode, Jay Loving from the Best of the Rest podcast, and Ronnie Barron from the Absolute DC podcast join Martin to discuss "Batman Vs. Two-Face", the latest DC animated film which also happens to take place in the Batman '66 universe. Get ready to dive in deep on this one as we even manage to tie in much of the film to Golden Age Batman stories, the TV series, modern iterations and more!You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Batman: The Animated Series, "The Last Laugh"

Play Episode Listen Later Dec 7, 2017 20:11


Jay Loving returns to I Am Gotham to discuss another Batman: The Animated Series episode with Martin. This time, it's episode 4, "The Last Laugh" which is an all out insane story feature the Joker and his crew. How will the boys feel about this episode? Tune in and find out!You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

World's Finest Comics #3

Play Episode Listen Later Dec 4, 2017 15:22


Welcome to another episode of I Am Gotham, as we take a step away from our usual Detective Comics and Batman discussion to talk about World's Finest Comics #3, the first appearance of the Scarecrow from 1941! Martin read the book in preparation for his discussion with Jay from last episode on the Animated Series' introduction of the character and just had to talk about it! Be sure to send questions to nerdylegion@gmail.com so we can prepare another Q&A episode in a few weeks.You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Batman: The Animated Series, "Nothing To Fear"

Play Episode Listen Later Dec 1, 2017 29:21


Jay Loving from the Best of the Rest podcast returns to I Am Gotham this week to discuss Batman: The Animated Series episode 3, "Nothing To Fear", the introduction of the Scarecrow into the animated universe. Jay and Martin have a great time dissecting the Scarecrow character and why this episode is so important in humanizing the Batman persona that is Bruce Wayne.You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Detective Comics #51 and #52

Play Episode Listen Later Nov 27, 2017 21:06


Welcome back to another episode of I Am Gotham, as we return to our Golden Age Batman discussion with a look at Detective Comics #51, "The Case of the Mystery Carnival", and Detective Comics #52, "The Secret of the Jade Box". We hope you enjoy these stories, and we'll be back in a few days as Jay Loving returns to I Am Gotham for a look at Batman: The Animated Series episode 3, "Nothing To Fear".You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Listener Questions

Play Episode Listen Later Nov 24, 2017 26:25


I Am Gotham returns to your ears with a listener question episode! In this episode, Martin tackles some corrections, Batman: White Knight, Elseworlds stories, a few thoughts on Justice League, favorite Bat stories, his creative dream team and more! We'll be back next week with new episodes starting off with a look at Detective Comics #51 and #52. Thanks for listening!You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Gotham By Gaslight

Play Episode Listen Later Oct 30, 2017 51:25


Welcome back Gothamites! On this episode, Paul Tesseneer from the Valiant Central Podcast joins Martin to have an in-depth discussion at what is considered the first Elseworlds story, Gotham By Gaslight. This episode was originally published as a Patreon exclusive a few weeks back so if you'd like to get episodes early, consider joining!You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Batman: The Animated Series, "Christmas With The Joker"

Play Episode Listen Later Oct 17, 2017 38:28


Welcome back Gothamites, to another episode of I Am Gotham. In this episode, Jay Loving joins Martin once again to dive deep into Batman: The Animated Series episode 2, "Christmas with the Joker".You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Batman/Harley Quinn

Play Episode Listen Later Sep 22, 2017 51:15


Welcome to a special bonus episode of I Am Gotham! For this episode, Martin is joined by Jay Loving from the Best of the Rest podcast, and Aaron Bell and Ronnie Barron from the Absolute DC Podcast (formerly Rebirthically) to discuss the latest DC animated film, Batman/Harley Quinn. Did the film live up to the hype? Was the return of Bruce Timm to the animated universe all we had hoped for? Listen in and find out!You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Detective Comics #49 and #50

Play Episode Listen Later Sep 18, 2017 20:32


Welcome back to another episode of I Am Gotham, the show where we explore Batman family history from 1939 to the present and beyond. In this episode, Martin discusses Detective Comics #49, Clayface Walks Again, and Detective Comics #50, The Case of the Three Devils. Before that though, Martin talks a little bit about the latest Batman movie news and script rewrite and why casting should be a more important consideration for DC and Warner Bros. We'll be back next episode to discuss Detective Comics #51 and #52, and stay tuned at the end of the week as we return with a round table discussion for the latest animated film, Batman/Harley Quinn!You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Batman #5

Play Episode Listen Later Sep 11, 2017 24:04


Welcome back, Gothamites! It's time to dive back into another fun Golden Age Batman story as Martin discusses Batman #5! This issue includes "The Riddle of the Missing Card", "Book of Enchantment", "The Case of the Honest Crook", and Linda Page's first appearance in "Crime Does Not Pay".You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Batman The Animated Series, "On Leather Wings"

Play Episode Listen Later Sep 8, 2017 39:43


Hello fellow Gothamites! This episode of I Am Gotham is a little different. Martin recently had the itch to start watching the Batman: The Animated Series again so as a result, we'll be having a recurring discussion of every episode in the series as guest cohosts, Jay Loving, of the Best of the Rest podcast joins Martin for this adventure. In this episode, we are discussing season 1, episode 1, "On Leather Wings."You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Detective Comics #47/Detective Comics #48

Play Episode Listen Later Sep 5, 2017 26:43


Welcome to another episode of I Am Gotham, the show that explores Batman family history through the ages. In this episode, Martin goes in depth on Detective Comics #47 and #48 from January and February 1941. Before that though, Martin goes in a short discussion on upcoming "Elseworlds" style stories coming out from that DC that should be of interesting to Batman fans including White Knight, Creature of the Knight, and The Dark Prince Charming.You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

The Case of the Joker's Crime Circus

Play Episode Listen Later Aug 28, 2017 34:31


Welcome back to another episode of I Am Gotham, the show that explores Batman history and dives into what makes Batman so great. In this episode, Martin talks about Batman #4 from Winter of 1940 with four new stories, THe Case of the Joker's Crime Circus, Blackbeard and the Yacht Society, Public Enemy Number 1 Starts Jail Sentence, and Touchdown For Justice. This issue is fascinating for Bat-history afficionados as it's the first appearance of Gotham City, and sets up many of the tropes we come to known and love in Batman lore. Martin also answers a listener email and talks a little bit about the structure of the show. Thanks for listening!You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

The More Things Change, The More They Stay The Same

Play Episode Listen Later Aug 21, 2017 16:27


A new week means a brand new episode of I Am Gotham, an exploration of Bat-family history! In this episode, Martin wraps up Batman stories from 1940 by discussing Detective Comics #43-46: "The Case of the City of Terror", "The Land Behind The Light", "The Case of the Laughing Death", and and the return of Hugo Strange with "Professor Strange's Fear Dust". If you're reading allow, get in touch with us and let us know what you think about these stories!You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Nobody's Puppet

Play Episode Listen Later Aug 17, 2017 23:34


Gather 'round Gothamites, it's time for a few episode of I Am Gotham, a podcast exploring Bat family history from 1939 to the present and beyond! In this episode, Martin discusses Batman #3 from the fall of 1940. Enjoy the show!You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Return of the Joker

Play Episode Listen Later Aug 14, 2017 25:28


Welcome back to an all new episode of I Am Gotham, an exploration of Bat family history. In this episode, Martin talks about Batman #2 from the summer of 1940. This issue contains four stories: "The Joker Meets Catwoman", "Wolf, The Crime Master", "The Clubfoot Murders", and "The Case of the Missing Link." Thanks for tuning in, and be sure to let us know what you think of the format change for upcoming issues!You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Return To Gotham

Play Episode Listen Later Jul 17, 2017 32:16


After a long hiatus, I Am Gotham is back to explore Batman history! In this episode, Martin discusses Detective Comics #39-42 from 1940 in an episode dubbed "Return To Gotham'! Are you reading along? Let us know! We'll be back in a few days to discuss Batman #2 and #3.You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Batman and Bill

Play Episode Listen Later May 11, 2017 214:07


It's been so long but you eyes and ears do not deceive you, I Am Gotham is back! Hulu recently launched "Batman and Bill", a Hulu original documentary about the journey to get Bill Finger credit for his collaborations to Batman history and we just couldn't not talk about it! The documentary chronicles Marc Nobleman's years long journey into discovering who Bill Finger was and how his contributions shaped the Batman mythos, so who better to join Martin on this discussion than Gotham By Geek's Darrell Taylor! Sit back and enjoy the ride and be sure to check out the documentary!We'll be back next week with a discussion of Batman #39-42 as well as Batman #2 and #3!https://www.hulu.com/press/show/batman-and-bill/You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

The Rebuttal

Play Episode Listen Later Jan 17, 2017 92:33


Welcome to another episode of I Am Gotham! Friend of the show and podcaster extraordinaire Darrell Taylor and I got a chance to go in-depth about the current state of Batman on The Nerdy Legion podcast recently and I wanted to put out the discussion as a standalone I Am Gotham episode for Batman fans. Do you agree with the current direction of the book? Do you have strong feelings either way on the book? Let me know on Twitter @geekvine or email hello@nerdylegion.com. I promise, we'll return to our regular episode discussions next week!You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Get Out Of Arkham

Play Episode Listen Later Jan 1, 2017 79:02


Could it be true? Are you imagining things? Is the podcast back? It's true! Welcome back to I Am Gotham, a podcast exploring Bat family history. This episode is a little different than what we usually do on the podcast and was originally recorded as an episode of The Nerdy Legion podcast as part of a larger discussion. Martin is joined by Nick from Nerdy Legion and Mike from Gotham By Geeks and Retrocast to finally share our thoughts on the latest arc of Batman, I Am Suicide (issues #9-13). How is Tom King's vision of Batman different from what has come before? Why do Mike and Martin have such issues with this portrayal of the character? Find out about this and much more on this episode!Note that the show will be back with six brand new episodes this coming week. You can support this show by visiting our merch store, directly through Patreon, or by leaving us an Apple Podcasts review.

Claim I Am Gotham

In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

Claim Cancel