It's Not Natural

It's Not Natural

Follow It's Not Natural
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

Join professional Supernatural fangirls Mandi Heesh and Sydney Hayes as they take you on an emotional journey through metas, parallels, gossip, and fandom news.

It's Not Natural Podcast


    • May 6, 2019 LATEST EPISODE
    • infrequent NEW EPISODES
    • 1h 23m AVG DURATION
    • 23 EPISODES
    • 1 SEASONS


    Search for episodes from It's Not Natural with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from It's Not Natural

    23. It's Like the Santa Claus

    Play Episode Listen Later May 6, 2019 72:56


    In episode 23, Mandi and Sydney discuss the unexpected finale of season 14, briefly recap Awesome Con weekend, and somehow seamlessly transition into a conversation concerning a throuple with Castiel and Anael.    Warning: Spoilers for the season 14 finale!

    22. Interview: Briar from Nerds and Beyond!

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 20, 2019 76:53


    Mandi and Sydney interview Briar, creator and owner of Nerds & Beyond, following the news of It's Not Natural joining the website's podcast network. We discuss Matt Cohen, the website's growth and success, and learn that there are entire fandoms dedicated to...theme parks??

    21. Supernatural Episode 300 Discussion

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 7, 2019 29:54


    Mandi and Sydney record their immediate reactions to Supernatural's emotional 300th episode, and Mandi reads a fandom story from Kara. MAJOR SPOILERS FOR EPISODE 300.   Pod Notes: The audio for Sydney the first 3 minutes was slightly low, we apologize for the technical difficulties, but it is fine the rest of the episode.

    20. Limp Ball Pit

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 1, 2019 58:52


    In episode 20, Mandi and Sydney give you their recent non-SPN recommendations, discuss the last two episodes, and speculate about the 300th episode milestone.   Show Notes: Shows/Movies mentioned as suggestions: Abducted in Plain Sight on Netflix, Miranda on Hulu, Roswell: New Mexico on CW, and Sex Education on Netflix.

    19. I'm Never Happy

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 21, 2019 75:42


    Mandi and Sydney are back with the first episode of the year! They announce their merging with Nerds & Beyond, discuss the first half of season 14, and answer questions from listeners.    

    18. Game of Awkward Chicken

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 9, 2018 71:41


    After an unplanned four month hiatus, the girls are back! Mandi and Sydney discuss their favorite characters the three leads have played (besides themselves), and Mandi reads a fandom story from Amanda.

    17. A Lot Of Wine

    Play Episode Listen Later May 25, 2018 63:59


    Episode 17: Mandi and Sydney podcast all the way from beautiful Roma after attending JIB9! A lot of wine was had. They make absolutely no logical sense. Unintentional special guest appearance: David, Sydney's husband.  

    16. Tentacle Porn

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 8, 2018 89:49


    Mandi and Sydney are back after another hiatus! The girls discuss episodes 11 through 17 and Mandi reads a fandom story from Nate.    

    15. Wayward AF

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 28, 2018 48:16


    Mandi and Sydney discuss the Wayward Sisters episode and the potential for the spin-off, answer questions from Lauren, and Mandi reads a fandom story from Trista.   **SPOILER WARNING FOR WAYWARD SISTERS BACKDOOR PILOT EPISODE**

    14. Satisfying Climax

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 18, 2017 70:20


    Mandi and Sydney frantically recap the last 5 episodes of Supernatural before The Walking Dead midseason premiere (R.I.P. [redacted]) and Mandi reads a fandom story from Lauren.

    13. That Accent Can F*** Me Gently

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 13, 2017 35:07


    In episode 13, Sydney and Mandi discuss episode 4: The Big Empty and the infamous accent. Sydney reads a fandom story from Mo.

    12. Owls or Disgruntled Cats

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 3, 2017 106:54


    In episode 12, Mandi and Sydney delve into season 13's "The Rising Son" and "Patience". Mandi reads a fandom story from Sissa.

    11. Castiel, You ARE the Father!

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 18, 2017 62:54


    Finally reunited on the same coast for episode 11, Mandi and Sydney podcast from the interior of Mandi's car, analyzing the season 13 premiere. Disclaimer: The sound quality is shit (hello, podcasting from a car beside a busy highway in D.C.) and there is heavy Destiel discussion.

    10. If Dicks Could Kill

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 3, 2017 106:46


    Episode 10 is our first Sam appreciation episode! Mandi and Sydney discuss their favorite Sam episodes, some memorable con moments, and some of their favorite con stories as told by actors from the show.  

    9. 3 More Inches of Weiner for $1000, please?

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 28, 2017 122:12


    Angelina (Atc74) guest hosts in episode 9, where she schools Sydney in trivia and answers fanfiction interview questions. The girls discuss season 13 promos, more thighs and a newfound love of [watching] acroyoga, and Mandi reads a fandom story from Ashley.     DISCLAIMER: We do not own Supernatural or the title cards and dialogue featured on Supernatural. This podcast contains spoilers and language that may be considered offensive to some. Mandi and Sydney would like to express their sincere appreciation for allowing them to corrupt your general outlook on life.

    8. Who's Yawning Now, Bitch?

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 11, 2017 80:20


    In episode 8, Sydney discusses Dean "Sublimation" Winchester and Mandi reads the very first 'It's Not Natural' iTunes review!   DISCLAIMER: We do not own Supernatural or the title cards and dialogue featured on Supernatural. This podcast contains spoilers and language that may be considered offensive to some. Mandi and Sydney would like to express their sincere appreciation for allowing them to corrupt your general outlook on life.   Art done by Caty Cain  

    7. Throwback Toilet

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 5, 2017 91:47


    In episode 7, Sydney reads a follow-up email from Lauren, Mandi discusses Tactile Dean, and the girls air a recorded fandom story from Bethany.   DISCLAIMER: We do not own Supernatural or the title cards and dialogue featured on Supernatural. This podcast contains spoilers and language that may be considered offensive to some. Mandi and Sydney would like to express their sincere appreciation for allowing them to corrupt your general outlook on life.   Special thanks to Caty Cain for the cover art!

    6. Hellatus-induced Five Alarm Trash Fire

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 31, 2017 102:35


    In episode 6, Mandi discusses Minncon and her unwavering love for Gil McKinney, Sydney introduces interviews with fanfiction writers Jill and Nicole, and Mandi reads a fandom story from Lauren.   DISCLAIMER: We do not own Supernatural or the title cards and dialogue featured on Supernatural. This podcast contains spoilers and language that may be considered offensive to some. Mandi and Sydney would like to express their sincere appreciation for allowing them to corrupt your general outlook on life.   Special thanks to: Nicole (aka iwantthedean) and Jill (aka sis-tafics) for letting us interview you! Thanks to Ang (atc74) for helping set it all up!

    5. We're No Longer Friends

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 23, 2017 99:08


    In episode 5, Mandi and Sydney suffer from technical issues, give a dramatic retelling of The Scorpion and the Frog, and speculate on the first part of season 13. Sydney reads a fandom story from Taylor.   DISCLAIMER: We do not own Supernatural or the title cards and dialogue featured on Supernatural. This podcast contains spoilers and language that may be considered offensive to some. Mandi and Sydney would like to express their sincere appreciation for allowing them to corrupt your general outlook on life.

    4. What Fourth Wall?

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 15, 2017 79:05


    The girls contemplate Supernatural's inability to be contained by four walls, Sydney cries over pasta and Misha (as per usual), and Mandi reads a fandom story from Liz.   DISCLAIMER:   We do not own Supernatural or the title cards and dialogue featured on Supernatural. This podcast contains spoilers and language that may be considered offensive to some. Mandi and Sydney would like to express their sincere appreciation for allowing them to corrupt your general outlook on life.   CREDIT: Artwork done by the lovely Caty Cain. Twitter: @cbcain  

    3. Two Brothers, One Impala

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 7, 2017 112:40


    Episode 3: The girls discuss the voted-upon season one episodes, fall down a John Winchester rabbit hole, flail over J2M and their wives, predict the future of Rogue Events, and Sydney reads a fandom story from Ladypoly.   DISCLAIMER:   We do not own Supernatural or the title cards and dialogue featured on Supernatural. This podcast contains spoilers and language that may be considered offensive to some. Mandi and Sydney would like to express their sincere appreciation for allowing them to corrupt your general outlook on life.    

    2. You Know What Satan Says

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 7, 2017 115:13


    Episode 2: The girls discuss the Pilot, Woman in White lore, how fandom has inspired them, and Mandi reads the first ever fandom story from Angelina.     DISCLAIMER: We do not own Supernatural or the title cards and dialogue featured on Supernatural. This podcast contains spoilers and language that may be considered offensive to some. Mandi and Sydney would like to express their sincere appreciation for allowing them to corrupt your general outlook on life.    

    1. We're Here for This

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 7, 2017 142:13


    In episode 1, Mandi and Sydney discuss what got them into the Supernatural fandom and their Top 10 Favorite and Least Favorite episodes of the show.   DISCLAIMER: We do not own Supernatural or the title cards and dialogue featured on Supernatural. This podcast contains spoilers and language that may be considered offensive to some. Mandi and Sydney would like to express their sincere appreciation for allowing them to corrupt your general outlook on life.  

    Claim It's Not Natural

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel