Andrew Makes A Case

Follow Andrew Makes A Case
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

Andrew Makes a Case is bad movie podcast that celebrates the best aspects of bad movies. Host, Andrew Nealis must make an argument on the redeeming qualities of the episodes film as co-host Tom Hannigan doesn’t have like a damn thing about it. If Andrew can’t make a case 5 times, the show gets cance…

Tom Hannigan and Andrew Nealis

  • May 4, 2020 LATEST EPISODE
  • infrequent NEW EPISODES
  • 1h 21m AVG DURATION
  • 22 EPISODES


Search for episodes from Andrew Makes A Case with a specific topic:

Latest episodes from Andrew Makes A Case

Andrew Makes a Case #23: Scooby-Doo 2 Monsters Unleashed Featuring Jack O’Keeffe

Play Episode Listen Later May 4, 2020 93:20


After a long hiatus, Andrew Makes A Case makes its triumphant return with an incredibly delayed episode. Do you remember us? Are we new to you? Are you still trying to forget the Book of Henry? Well, hop on board with this highlight reel of an episode on Scooby Doo 2: Read more…

Andrew Makes A Case #21: Repo Man featuring Olivia Kram

Play Episode Listen Later May 28, 2018 77:03


We’re joined by Olivia Kram (Rockefeller, Windows 98) to watch the Emilio Estevez classic Repo Man. Is this movie about time travel? Emilio is the worst person to ever be tricked into a job and Harry Dean Stanton uses real baseball bats. Just ask Harry Dean Stanton.

Andrew Makes a Case #20: The Emoji Movie

Play Episode Listen Later Mar 15, 2018 82:39


We watched the 2018 Razzie award winning Emoji Movie! It’s soulless garbage that everyone involved got paid a lot to make. We talk about what if scenario’s with this movie and a bunch of completely unrelated things. Enjoy!

Andrew Makes A Case #18: Stolen

Play Episode Listen Later Feb 24, 2018 87:53


Andrew Makes A Case returns to discuss the Nicholas Cage classic, Stolen! It’s like Gone in 60 Seconds but not as fun, in New Orleans, and with Josh Lucas at an 11 the entire time.

Andrew Makes a Case #17: The Super Mario Brothers Movie featuring Brett Rader

Play Episode Listen Later Dec 2, 2017 118:07


We’re joined by the wonderful Brett Rader to talk about the mess that is the Super Mario Brothers Movie. Tom watched a fan edit of the movie on youtube which shaves 5 minutes from the total film. We also go into depth about what an existential nightmare a Waluigi game Read more…

Andrew Makes a Case #16: Geostorm featuring Michael Henley

Play Episode Listen Later Dec 2, 2017 98:35


We’re joined by an actual film critic, Michael Henley, to talk about one of the year’s biggest bust, Geostorm. This movie has ridiculous codes, Jim Sturgess baby mullet and one of the most one-sided boss fights ever filmed. Gerard Butler doesn’t give a damn about the rules, he only cares about Read more…

Andrew Makes A Case #15: The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Next Generation Featuring Shannon Fahey

Play Episode Listen Later Nov 2, 2017 63:57


To celebrate Halloween, we sat down with Stay Dead’s Shannon Fahey to watch what was intended to be the “true” sequel to the Texas Chainsaw Massacre but ended up being a weird movie with future stars and no actual chainsaw related deaths. This movie has psycho hillbilly’s but the absolute worst Read more…

Andrew Makes A Case #14: Disaster Movie Featuring Hunter Steffes

Play Episode Listen Later Sep 10, 2017 79:56


We close our initial episodes by watching one of the worst things the guys who make terrible things ever made. This movie is filled with shit you forgot about 2008. It is not good by any metric and we’re glad these kind of movies aren’t that popular anymore.

Andrew Makes A Case #13: Exit to Eden Featuring Rob O’Neil

Play Episode Listen Later Aug 26, 2017 71:11


This is the first of many episodes where we’ll pick films submitted to us through our social media to watch and record an episode on. Of the many films submitted, Rob O’Neil’s suggestion of the 1994 BDSM comedy was the clear winner. Dan Aykroyd goes way too far undercover in this Read more…

Andrew Makes A Case #12: Return of the Jedi – Commentary Track

Play Episode Listen Later Aug 17, 2017 141:39


We watch Star Wars Episode VI: Return of the Jedi and record a commentary track for what we’re calling this seasons Tommy Teardown. In this episode, Tom makes an argument to Andrew about why this beloved movie actually isn’t that great. You don’t need to watch this while listening to Read more…

Andrew Makes A Case #11: Flubber Featuring Lali Gill

Play Episode Listen Later Jul 15, 2017 76:11


We watch the Robin Williams classic and record from a top secret location you can never guess. Our guest is actual scientist Lali Gil, who helps break down some of the science behind Flubber. A flying Car a much bigger deal than dancing Jelly. Robin Williams the worst Fiance ever. Read more…

Andrew Makes A Case #10: Trans5mers: The Last Knight Featuring Sheila Master

Play Episode Listen Later Jul 1, 2017 112:49


We check out the latest installment in the Transformers series and discuss why it’s terrible overall. For this discussion we’re joined by Sheila Master. Emotions will get the best of us here. Anthony Hopkins did not know what was happening here. Mark Wahlberg hates education and books.

Andrew Makes A Case #9: Beauty and the Beast Featuring Katie Cwirko & Angelina Meehan

Play Episode Listen Later Jun 11, 2017 95:56


This episode features two of the most passionate Disney experts we know. We’re joined by returning guest Angelina Meehan and Katie Cwirko to get into their hatred of live action Disney adaptations. Chip is so off-putting. Lefou and Gaston have definitely fooled around. They really wrote a new song just hoping Read more…

Andrew Makes A Case #8 Cats & Dogs: The Return of Kitty Galore

Play Episode Listen Later Jun 11, 2017 58:33


We play with the format again as we tackle another film with an animal protagonist. Andrew tries to get Tom to watch this turd. Chris O’Donnell’s sad this entire movie. No one wanted to come back for this movie. Who the hell is Kitty Galore?

Andrew Makes A Case #7: Scooby Doo Featuring Jack O’Keefe

Play Episode Listen Later May 23, 2017 92:56


Jack O’keefe joins us to destroy the Scooby Doo movie for its obvious flaws. How does Scooby Doo work in a post 9/11 world? There are some strong lines drawn here on who likes this movie and why.

Andrew Makes A Case #6: Nine Lives Featuring Carolyn Beatty

Play Episode Listen Later May 1, 2017 73:17


Carolyn Beatty joins us to watch Kevin “Cat” Spacey as a talking cat in a non-talking animal movie. Christopher Walken turns people into Cats. How many cat puns can Carolyn make? This movie saved someone’s life. Why does Andrew hate Ian so much?

Andrew Makes A Case #5: Robocop 2 Featuring Jon Plester

Play Episode Listen Later Apr 24, 2017 87:38


We complete the Frank Millogy with the 1990 follow up to RoboCop. Jon Plester joins the show to talk about the insanity that RoboCop 2. Only insane things happen in this movie. There’s a character named, RoboCop 2.and he is addicted to drugs. We think there should be a Lifetime Read more…

Andrew Makes A Case #4: Through The Looking Glass Featuring Angelina Meehan

Play Episode Listen Later Feb 26, 2017 63:39


Angelina Meehan joins Andrew and Tom to discuss the follow up to Tim Burton’s Alice in Wonderland. We play with the format some here by arguing for and against Angelina seeing the movie. Sacha Baron Cohen’s characterization of Time is really interesting. Is Alice insane? She should have been insane.

Andrew Makes A Case #3: Sin City: A Dame to Kill For

Play Episode Listen Later Feb 26, 2017 68:53


Frank Millogy part 2 with the 2014 follow up to Sin City. The late Powers Boothe is amazing in this, we have no idea what the hell is up with Christopher Lloyd here or how many days Bruce Willis was on set. Jessica Alba is a real mess in this Read more…

Andrew Makes A Case #2: The Spirit Featuring Sarah Clemency

Play Episode Listen Later Jan 12, 2017 86:07


We’re joined by our first guest and the wonderful voice behind our intro song, Sarah Clemency. This is the beginning of our Frank Millogy by watching 2008’s The Spirit. It’s a real misogynistic piece of crap that has some cool visuals. No matter how you feel about this movie, Sarah Read more…

Andrew Makes a Case #1: Bewitched

Play Episode Listen Later Oct 9, 2016 56:57


This is the Pilot we recorded for PHIT Comedy’s last year that ultimately didn’t get picked up. That’s fine. Whatever. Here we focus on the the 2004 reboot of Bewitched starring Will Farrell and Nicole Kidman. We talk about Jason Schwartzman’s Name, Magneto Rules and Book Soup Coffee.

Andrew Makes a Case #0

Play Episode Listen Later Sep 20, 2016 3:25


Andrew Makes a Case is bad movie podcast that celebrates the best aspects of bad movies. Host, Andrew Nealis must make an argument on the redeeming qualities of the episodes film as co-host Tom Hannigan doesn’t have like a damn thing about it. If Andrew can’t make a case 5 Read more…

Claim Andrew Makes A Case

In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

Claim Cancel