Crime Time Cafe

Follow Crime Time Cafe
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

A true crime and haunted history podcast hosted by bff's Amanda and Cayla. Grab a cup of your favorite beverage and sit down with the girls as they tell some wild stories and a few laughs. For episode suggestions or requests please email crimetimecafe@gm


    • Mar 16, 2022 LATEST EPISODE
    • infrequent NEW EPISODES
    • 1h AVG DURATION
    • 11 EPISODES


    Search for episodes from Crime Time Cafe with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from Crime Time Cafe

    Episode 11: The White House

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 16, 2022 62:23


    Was Washington D.C. built to include Masonic and satanic symbols as a way to harness evil and power? Cayla tells the story of DC and what it was before Washington decided he wanted that land for his new nation's capitol. Why isn't there more history and information on the enslaved human beings who built the White House? Who is the obstinate Mr. Burns and why can't his soul leave the White House? George Washington really expected landowners to simply give their land to him because he was a hero - is this why the White House is one of the most haunted places in the US? Join us this week as we talk about the many ghosts of Washington DC and the White House, including some former presidents!

    Episode 10- John Demjanjuk

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 14, 2021 50:15


    Episode 10 is Amanda telling the story of John Demjanjuk. John was living a simple life in America when all of a sudden 40 years after the holocaust ended he was on trial in Israel for being Ivan the Terrible. Was he really just a simple family man, or was he the monster in charge of the gas chambers in the death camp Treblinka that holocaust survivors claimed him to be? This story follows the Netflix mini series The Devil Next Door. Come hang out with us as we discuss the evidence, the lack of evidence, and holocaust survivors testimonies.

    Episode 9: Alcatraz

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 23, 2021 51:39


    Alcatraz, San Francisco Bay, California - Cayla tells the story of one of the most haunted places in the entire world! Alcatraz, La Isla de los Alcatraces, the Island of the Pelicans, has been around for hundreds of years. So how did it get so haunted? Alcatraz held confederate soldiers, civilians accused of treason, Native Americans who had land disagreements with the federal government, and starting in the 1930's the US' most ruthless criminals, killers, kidnappers, mobsters, bank robbers, and depression era gangsters. One of the most famous anti-heroes who called this place home for four and a half years was Al Capone. Numerous deaths occurred at Alcatraz and it was said to be designed to break the spirits of the most unmanageable criminals. One of the most haunted locations inside of Alcatraz is the Spanish Dungeon located deep within the rock. Water seeps inside the cold, damp walls and prisoners were sent here in complete darkness as the ultimate punishment. They would be stripped naked and handcuffed to a bar with nothing but a hole in the ground to use as a bathroom. Locals call Alcatraz Evil Island, prisoners call it Hellcatraz. Join us this week for an exclusive and close up look at one of the world's worst prisons.

    Episode 8: Rodney Alcala

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 16, 2021 58:56


    Somehow about halfway through this episode his name changed from Alcala to Alkaka... Just roll with it and come listen about The Dating Game Killer. Rodney made his way state to state all throughout the U.S.A. raping and killing young girls. How does a man that is on the FBI's Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list end up on a game show and not get caught? In this episode you hear about gut feelings, good friends, killings, girls "asking for it" by the way they dress, bizarre court testimonials, and much more. We hope you enjoy!  

    Episode 7: Haunted Hollywood

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 10, 2021 63:42


    Have you ever wondered where Hollywood gets its' inspiration from? Dive into the real stories behind some of the most prolific horror movies to ever be produced. In this Halloween follow-up Cayla tells the back stories of your favorite classic horror movies, the ones that were groundbreaking and changed the genre forever. The ladies discuss a handful of the real events that transpired and the subsequent set hauntings that ruined and took many lives.

    Episode 6: The Salem Witch Trials

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 31, 2021 95:32


    What in the world was going on in Salem in 1692? Ergot poisoning, attention seeking teens, young women being given power, vindictive neighbors? We may never have the real answer or it could have been a combination of the aforementioned. Cayla tells the world history of witches and witchcraft before diving into Salem, Massachusetts' most haunted history. The trials are what Salem is most known for, however, an in-depth look at the details reveal something very sinister was most definitely going on. The devil may have been at work in 1692 Salem but in the form of jealousy, resentment, and a yearning for power.

    Episode 5: Shauna Howe

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 27, 2021 55:17


    Episode five features Amanda talking about a case that literally cancelled Halloween. Shauna Howe was walking home from a Halloween party when she was kidnapped and murdered just minutes after leaving the party she was at. With a witness statement and a DNA match, how does a case take over a decade to solve? Come listen to the story with us and see what was missed in the investigation. 

    Episode 4: Pennhurst

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 12, 2021 69:09


    How did Pennhurst in Chester County, PA come to be one of the most haunted places in the US? Step back in history with us as Cayla tells the story of Pennhurst State School and Hospital (it was NEVER an insane asylum until it opened in 2010 as a Halloween attraction). Eugenics, teeth removals, lobotomies, assaults, patients being pushed out windows - just a regular day at Pennhurst. How did this premiere institution become "The Shame of Pennsylvania?" Greed. How many souls still roam there today? Too many to count... This episode also features a surprise cameo by two of Cayla's dogs, Jack and Bear, sharing their passionate feelings about Pennhurst. Roxy was sleeping at the time of this recording.

    Episode 3: Grace Packer

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 5, 2021 48:22


    Amanda talks about the murder of Grace Packer. Grace Packer was a beautiful 15 year old girl who was abused for almost her whole life. Regardless of what she went through she was always kind to others. There were reports of what was going on inside Grace's personal life long before she was murdered. Could this crime have been stopped? In the end she was murdered while the person who was supposed to love her more than anything in the world just held her hand and watched. Come listen while we talk about our thoughts on the case, foster care and adoption agencies. 

    Episode 2: Matthias Schambacher and Hawk Mountain

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 28, 2021 46:45


    Episode two features Cayla telling the story of Matthias Schambacher and the haunting of Hawk Mountain in Albany Township, Pennsylvania. Schambacher may very well be America's first serial killer...that is, if all the legends are true. Dive into this horrifying story that intertwines Native American curses, the French and Indian War, and possible cannibalism. Hawk Mountain is one of the most beautiful places in the U.S., and also one of the most haunted. If you are brave enough to hike Hawk Mountain use #CrimeTimeCafe on Instagram and tag us in your photos! 

    Episode 1: The Shorts and The Bissingers

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 7, 2021 60:34


    Episode one features Amanda telling the true crime story of the Short family from Sinking Spring, Pennsylvania. Three weeks before Megan Short and her young children were murdered she called 911 to say she was scared of the man who would end up murdering her entire family - her husband. Leaving no real reason as to why he committed this crime we have to wonder what it was that drove him over the edge. Cayla tells the haunted history of Reading, Pennsylvania's most famous ghost family, The Bissinger's. Pregnant Louisa and her three young children took a stroll down the beautiful Union Canal. Moments later witnesses saw a horrifying sight, forever embedded in their minds and nightmares. This is no cut and dry murder-suicide; was Louisa's mental illness to blame? Or could the sinister Mr. Bissinger been the driving force behind this horror? The ghosts of Louisa and her children STILL haunt Gring's Mill and the Union Canal to this day...over 150 years later.

    Claim Crime Time Cafe

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel