Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast

Follow Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

CURRENTLY ON HIATUS > Welcome to Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast hosted by Vicki James. We cover cases from true crime to mysteries and anything else that tickles our fancy! Some episodes will feature a co-host or Vicki will be flying-solo


    • Jul 20, 2022 LATEST EPISODE
    • infrequent NEW EPISODES
    • 53m AVG DURATION
    • 25 EPISODES


    Search for episodes from Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast

    Charles Cullen [Ep.25]

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 20, 2022 38:03


    On Episode 25, we discuss Charles Cullen, or what some call "The Nurse Killer." He has confessed to 40 murders within a 16 year period, and is still working with police to identify all of his victims. Grab your favourite meatball sub and come have a listen to Murder Sandwich. Link to video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=610AXC2GXN4Instagram: @MurderSandwichPodcast Hosted by: Vicki JamesEmail me! murdersandwichpodcast@gmail.com

    Richard Speck [Ep.24]

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 4, 2022 48:24


    Today on Episode 24 of Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast we cover the American Mass Murderer, Richard Benjamin Speck. Richard Speck was known to be the beginning of the end of the era of love, the glorious 60's. We cover his upbringing, many convictions, arrests and finally the crime and murder of 8 student nurses where he finally got sent to prison for good. Come have a listen to see how his own mistake lead to his arrest. [@MurderSandwichPodcast on Instagram]

    Kendrick Johnson [Ep.23]

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 26, 2022 55:03


    Today we discuss the tragic death of Kendrick Johnson, a 17-year-old high-school student who was found wrapped in a 6ft tall high school gym mat.  It was quickly ruled an accident but the Johnson Family wouldn't let that rest and wanted answers. 

    The Taconic State Parkway Crash [Ep.22]

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 14, 2022 71:30


    Join Vicki James and her guest co-host Devan as they discuss the perplexing Taconic State Parkway Crash. Was it a medical issue or carelessness? The 2009 Taconic State Parkway crash was a car crash that occurred shortly after 1:30 p.m. on Sunday, July 26, 2009, on the Taconic State Parkway, New York, United States. Eight people were killed when a minivan, being driven by Diane Schuler, traveled in the wrong direction on the parkway and collided head-on with an oncoming SUV. 

    HI-FI Murders [Ep.21]

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 26, 2022 33:24


    In 1974, two men entered the Hi-Fi Audio Store in Ogden, Utah and held 5 people hostage in the basement. The rest of the story is shocking and unsettling to say the least. This is one of the most gruesome crimes in Utah and left Ogden shocked and bewildered that it would happen in their town. Come take a listen as we discuss the horrific crimes that occurred at the Hi-Fi Audio Store that fateful night. 

    Brittany Murphy [Ep.20]

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 10, 2022 41:08


    Join me today on discussing what happened to the beloved Brittany Murphy in December 2009 when she tragically died in Hollywood Home. Brittany's widow, Simon Monjack died in the same house only 5 months later. Come listen to the strange story of Brittany Murphy. 

    JonBenet Ramsey [Ep.19]

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 12, 2022 69:28


    Happy New Year from Murder Sandwich Podcast! We are starting off 2022 with one of the first cases I was ever interested in. JonBenet is only 11 months younger than me and I remember when her case was the only thing you'd see at the grocery store on the magazines. This case still haunts me and I am always perplexed on what happened on beautiful JonBenet. Join me today and discuss this infamous but confusing case that just passed its 25th anniversary. [@MurderSandwichPodcast on Instagrm]

    The Watcher of 657 Boulevard [Ep.18]

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 10, 2021 39:14


    Do you ever get the feeling you are being watched when you are in your own house? Do you ever go to the blinds and check to see if anyone is outside but see nothing? Hairs on the back of your neck start to raise? Well this story will make you feel like that. A family of 5 are about to move into their dream house, in their dream town when suddenly they start receiving creepy and disturbing letters. Come listen as we tell the story of 657 Boulevard. [@MurderSandwichPodcast on Instagram]

    Dr. Death - Christopher Duntsch [Ep.17]

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 28, 2021 58:30


    Todays episode is about Christopher Duntsch, or as some know him by... Dr. Death. Christopher Duntsch maimed over 35 patients from 2011-2013 in Texas, and today we talk about how he got there, and what happened to him. This case has twists and turns that not even a scalpel could make. Come take a listen. [@MurderSandwichPodcast on Instagram]

    California Witch Killers - Michael & Suzan Carson [Ep.16]

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 1, 2021 49:54


    Happy Halloween! In today's Halloween Episode [16] we cover the Halloween Witch Killers of the 1980's. The three murders committed during the 80's were committed by Michael Bear and Suzan Bear Carson, two hippies sharing the same delusion that California is riddled with... witches. Grab some spooky snacks and come take a listen to the wild ride about the Halloween Witch Killers. [Follow us on instagram @MurderSandwichPodcast]

    The Candy Man, Martha Moxley & Peter Fabiano - Three Murders on Halloween Night [Ep.15]

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 30, 2021 58:50


    On Episode 15 of Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast we cover three crimes that were committed on Halloween Night. First we discuss Ronald Clark O'Bryan or as you may know as "The Candy Man" or the "Man Who Killed Halloween." The second story is about Martha Moxley, and the third story is about Peter and Betty Fabiano. Come mow down on some true crime![Follow us on instagram @MurderSandwichPodcast]

    Villisca Axe Murder House - Serial Killer or Drifter? [Ep.14]

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 25, 2021 58:33


    In Episode 14 of Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast we discuss the infamous unsolved crime of the 20th century - The Villisca Axe Murders. Said to be one of the most haunted houses in the United States, a murder of 8 people in 1912 shook the community of Villisca, Iowa. Come join us and find out the story of the crime that remains unsolved more than 100 years later. [Find us on instagram @MurderSandwichPodcast]

    Maura Murray - Unsolved Disappearance [Ep.13]

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 29, 2021 42:43


    On  episode 13 of Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast, I review the missing case of Maura Murray from February of 2004. This case is considered the first missing persons case of the social media age.This episode does not end with a resolution to what happened to Maura, but if you want to hear the theories and bizarre things that occurred surrounding this case then grab a snack, or a sandwich and lets mow down on some true crime! 

    Jaycee Lee Dugard - Found after 18 Years [Ep.12]

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 8, 2021 67:55


    Jaycee Lee Dugard was abducted at 11 years old in 1991 in Northern California. She was kept captive for 18 YEARS until her recovery.  Listen as I tell you the story of Jaycee Lee, her captivity and eventual recovery after failures upon failures of the system.  This story thankfully ends in a happy reunion between a mother and her daughter that unfortunately took almost 2 decades. Lets mow down on some true crime! 

    The Survival of Elizabeth Fritzl [Ep.11]

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 26, 2021 64:26


    On Episode 11 of Murder Sandwich I discuss the case of the Josef Fritzl, and the abduction of his daughter. This story is based out of Austria. This is one of the most mind-bending abduction cases that you will ever hear about. A father of 7 children, kidnaps and holds his own daughter, Elizabeth, captive for 24 years in the basement of the family home, and no one has any idea. This story will just blow your mind! 

    The Chicago Tylenol Murders of 1982 [Ep.10]

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 27, 2021 52:18


    Welcome to Episode 10 of Murder Sandwich: A True Crime and Mystery Podcast! Today I am going to speaking about the Chicago Tylenol Murders that occurred in September of 1982. This is my first podcast where I am not joined by a co-host so its just all me babay! Come join me with a sub or sandwich while I go through the tragic Chicago poisonings and the aftermath of the crimes and how it changed a few things that are just a second nature to us now! 

    The Conjuring House - Ed & Lorraine Warren [Ep.9]

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 13, 2021 56:17


    Today we cover the biography of one of the worlds most famous paranormal investigators - Ed and Lorraine Warren. Ed and Lorraine Warren are the paranormal investigators behind the Conjuring Movies and Universe that have been popular since the mid-2000's. We go over their early life, their most famous cases and then some controversies as well. 

    Toy Box Killer - David Parker Ray [Ep.8]

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 1, 2021 55:53


    In our 8th episode of Murder Sandwich we talk about the Toy Box Killer aka. David Parker Ray! I am joined via zoom by one of my best friends who lives across the country - therefore the audio does sound a little bit different than usual. The Toy Box Killer is said to have tortured anywhere from 60-100 woman but unfortunately was only charged for three of them. 

    Ed Kemper - The Co-Ed Killer [Ep.7]

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 15, 2021 58:09


    In Episode 7 of Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast we discuss Ed Kemper III, a horrific serial killer that turned himself in after killing his mother in 1973. Sometimes named the Co-Ed Killer, Ed Kemper and his story was portrayed most recently in the first season of MindHunter which is available on Netflix, 

    John Wayne Gacy - The Killer Clown [Ep.6]

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 1, 2021 63:33


    In Episode 6 of Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast, we chomp down on a famous killer clown whos legal name is John Wayne Gacy. John also liked to go by the names of Pogo or Patches the clown, if thats not frightening enough just wait till you hear the rest of his story. In three short years he murdered approximately 33 young men and buried them in an interesting spot a little bit too close to home. 

    Mindy Tran - Unsolved [Ep.5]

    Play Episode Listen Later May 18, 2021 65:29


    In Episode 5 of Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast, we discuss Mindy Tran who disappeared at 8-years old in my local town of Kelowna, British Columbia, Canada in August of 1994.  This crime shook the community of Kelowna in the 1990's and was the talk of the town for years to follow due to the police work that took place, if we can call it police work. 

    Robert Pickton - The Pig Farm Killer [Ep.4 - Part 2]

    Play Episode Listen Later May 4, 2021 55:20


    In Episode 4 of Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast,  we discuss Robert William Pickton in our second part.  We discuss the trial, imprisonment, and conspiracy theories surrounding the case and ties to RCMP potentially involvement. We also discuss possible links to another serious crime that is ongoing, The Highway of Tears. 

    Robert Pickton - The Pig Farm Killer [Ep.3 - Part 1]

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 20, 2021 44:44


    In Episode 3 of Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast, we dive into Part 1 of our two part series on the Pig Farm Killer,  Willie, Pork Chop Rob, or as others know him as, Robert Pickton. Pickton is believed to have killed 49 women in Vancouver, British Columbia and is labelled as the most prolific serial killers in Canada. 

    Natalie Wood - Unsolved 1981 [Ep.2]

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 6, 2021 47:44


    In Episode 2 of Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast we cover the bizarre and regularly debated case of Natalie Wood. Beloved American Actress whose death was first considered an "accidental drowning."  After 30 years, have we finally figured out what happened on that tragic night of November 1981? 

    John List - The Boogeyman of Westfield [Ep.1 - Premiere]

    Play Episode Play 30 sec Highlight Listen Later Mar 24, 2021 42:38


    Today in our premiere episode of Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast, we cover the unusuak case of John Emil List, or as some call him The Boogeyman of Westfield.An Accountant and Army Veteran that lived in a 19-room Mansion in New Jersey and annihilated his entire family - not being caught for almost two decades! 

    Claim Murder Sandwich: A True Crime & Mystery Podcast

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel