Milk and Murder

Follow Milk and Murder
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

Have you ever stayed up later than you meant to as you tried to solve the murder of Jonbenet Ramsey from your own bed? Ever have a conversation at a party take a sharp, dark, unexpected turn to Jeffrey Dahmer? Are you outraged at the police 100% slacking on the cases of Mitrice Richardson and Kenneka Jenkins? Do you fall asleep to the sweet, sweet sounds of true crime podcasts in your ear buds each night? Then our love of true crime has brought us together, friend. This podcast is for the true crime lovers who yearn to see murders solved and missing persons found. As a mom and lifelong lover of crime, I share weekly mysteries (with a content guide for little listeners!) that have kept me company as I weather the long days and nights of parenting. Together we’ll play armchair detective and dig into chilling, real-life stories of human behavior.

Bethany Roach


    • May 11, 2022 LATEST EPISODE
    • every other week NEW EPISODES
    • 21m AVG DURATION
    • 25 EPISODES

    4.8 from 146 ratings Listeners of Milk and Murder that love the show mention: also her voice, excellent true crime, lesser known cases, true crime genre, milk, victims, true crime podcasts, murder, crimes, wait for more episodes, details, soothing, well researched, first episode, isn, focus, sweet, love hearing, short, kids.



    Search for episodes from Milk and Murder with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from Milk and Murder

    24. Lindsey Baum - Part Two

    Play Episode Listen Later May 11, 2022 10:29


    Lindsey Baum disappeared on a walk in her small town of McCleary, WA in June 2009. In some creepy developments in nearby Seattle, WA, police finally start to gather some connections to the case before a discovery over the mountains slams on the brakes of the investigation.

    23. Lindsey Baum - Part One

    Play Episode Listen Later May 6, 2022 10:58


    Lindsey Baum went on a walk to her friend's house one evening in June 2009 and was never seen again. The story of her strange disappearance takes many strange twists and turns, but her mother Melissa stands firm and unwavering in her quest for answers.

    22. Ana Taglioretti - Part Two

    Play Episode Listen Later May 4, 2022 10:20


    When the coroner in Paraguay ruled that Ana's death was by natural causes, her friends were suspicious. Some terrifying history about Ana's upbringing sheds some light on what her life was really like, and on some of the worst scenarios that can occur in adoption. Meet me on Instagram: http://www.instagram.com/itwasthehusbandSources - Spoilers ahead:Ultima Hora - https://bit.ly/37fgwsLhttps://bit.ly/3scuH98ABC - https://bit.ly/3y8zVGOhttps://bit.ly/3LOOIKIhttps://bit.ly/3vHJKJYDevio Lines - https://bit.ly/37e1q6EWeb Archive Nanduti - https://bit.ly/3w7381ZHoy - https://bit.ly/385QPuTFacebook - https://bit.ly/3ydJYdyMi Historia Blog - https://bit.ly/3KD5MSAWaPo - https://wapo.st/3y8Bh4mWCNC - https://bit.ly/3P0YuLFhttps://bit.ly/3sbOtSbOregon Live - https://bit.ly/3KHiRKzPeople - https://bit.ly/3yeDyv0

    21. Ana Taglioretti - Part One

    Play Episode Listen Later May 2, 2022 9:17


    Ana Taglioretti was an accomplished violinist who faced endless challenges after her premature birth. When she passes away, those in the music community are devastated and those in her friend circle are extremely suspicious that not everything is as it seems.Meet me on Instagram: http://www.instagram.com/itwasthehusbandSources - Spoilers ahead:Ultima Hora - https://bit.ly/37fgwsLhttps://bit.ly/3scuH98ABC - https://bit.ly/3y8zVGOhttps://bit.ly/3LOOIKIhttps://bit.ly/3vHJKJYDevio Lines - https://bit.ly/37e1q6EWeb Archive Nanduti - https://bit.ly/3w7381ZHoy - https://bit.ly/385QPuTFacebook - https://bit.ly/3ydJYdyMi Historia Blog - https://bit.ly/3KD5MSA

    20. Peggy Lammers - Part Two

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 28, 2022 14:46


    This is Part TWO of a 2-part series. Here is is the link to part one: https://spoti.fi/3LowpfjMargaret Thornton "Peggy" Lammers was a beloved wife and deemed the "best mom ever" by her three adult children. While settling her parents estate in Deltaville, VA, she was staying at her family's vacation river house when someone pulled the rug out from the lives of every person who knew and loved Peggy. Discuss the case and see pics: http://www.instagram.com/itwasthehusbandThank you to my sources for this episode - SPOILERS AHEAD: FBI: https://bit.ly/3EgZ4A5 https://bit.ly/3KMrEMjWTVR:https://bit.ly/38UGmTkNBC:https://nbcnews.to/3xs7rHLSouthside Sentinel: https://bit.ly/3rtiqgmPEOPLE Magazine: https://bit.ly/3JR272V

    19. Peggy Lammers - Part One

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 15, 2022 9:54


    Margaret Thornton "Peggy" Lammers was a beloved wife and deemed the "best mom ever" by her three adult children. While settling her parents estate in Deltaville, VA, she was staying at her family's vacation river house when someone pulled the rug out from the lives of every person who knew and loved Peggy. Thank you to my sources for this episode - SPOILERS AHEAD: FBI: https://bit.ly/3EgZ4A5 https://bit.ly/3KMrEMjWTVR:https://bit.ly/38UGmTkNBC:https://nbcnews.to/3xs7rHLSouthside Sentinel: https://bit.ly/3rtiqgmPEOPLE Magazine: https://bit.ly/3JR272V

    18. Anna Palmer

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 22, 2021 33:40


    In 1998, Anna Palmer was found unconscious by her mother on the front porch of their home. Murdered in just minutes, the Salt Lake City police struggled to find a suspect. Anna's family would have to wait and pray for advancements in science that would finally answer the questions that haunted their every moment. Content Guide to come

    17. Khoi Dang Vu

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 22, 2021 21:39


    Khoi Dang Vu a warm and gentle spirit, his impact on the world has mostly been forgotten. This episode covers the strange case of a missing man whose life was misunderstood and whose legacy should carry on as the FBI seeks information to solve this case once and for all.Running a bit behind on show notes today, will update a link tonight! Very special thank you to Moms and Murder for sharing a Milk and Murder promo and to True Crime Bullsh** for their research into the Boardman Landfill.

    16. April Dawn Andrews BONUS Patron Preview: Cerilla Doyle

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 30, 2021 33:27


    April Dawn Andrews mysteriously disappeared from Pea Ridge, Arkansas while out for a walk one November afternoon. With the weight of the world on her shoulders, some say she ran away but there's so much more to the story. BONUS: Patrons of Milk and Murder will now receive a BONUS episode with each weekly episode. I decided to include this as a general thank you for waiting and a preview for what these bonus episodes are like. Please be aware the topics of alcoholism, policing, chronic illness, and suicide are all discussed in this episode.

    15. Regina Curtis

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 8, 2021 27:36


    Regina Curtis was a 16-year-old girl from Oklahoma City who went missing one night in May 2000. Investigators made assumptions about her case that seemed to cause a delay in progress for 16 years.View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary at www.milkandmurder.com/regina-curtisRead the Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls Report from UIHI: https://www.uihi.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/Missing-and-Murdered-Indigenous-Women-and-Girls-Report.pdf

    14. Mengqi Ji Part Two

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 3, 2021 24:32


    Mengqi Ji went missing from her home in Columbia, MO in 2019. When her husband interviews with local news, clues about what might have happened to her start to surface for investigators. This is Part 2 of 2. View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary at www.milkandmurder.com/mengqi-ji-part-two

    13. Mengqi Ji Part One

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 25, 2021 35:08


    Mengqi Ji is a young mom from Columbia, Missouri who went was not in her bed when her husband woke up one morning in 2019. When her parents fly in from China to join the search, one thread is pulled that unravels this entire missing person case. Could Mengqi Ji have her own nefarious plans and run off with a lover? Or is it possible that she is the victim of a horrible crime? View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary at www.milkandmurder.com/mengqi-ji-part-one

    12. Melody Ann Jones

    Play Episode Listen Later May 6, 2021 21:40


    On the morning of May 5th, 1983, Melody Jones' mother arrived at a home in rural Oklahoma. She found her daughter's car in the driveway and the front door ajar. What she found inside becomes one of Oklahoma's most enduring cold cases. View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary at www.milkandmurder.com/melody-jones

    11. Flossie Wilbur

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 28, 2021 29:20


    Flossie Wilbur disappeared from Angelica, New York on August 24th, 1985. While on the surface this seems like a simple old case solved, Flossie left a legacy in her town that makes her story surprisingly complicated.View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary at www.milkandmurder.com/flossie-wilbur

    10. David Riemens

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 16, 2021 24:34


    Follow me into a dilapidated treehouse in the woods of Watertown, TN. There, a soft spoken and artistic genius named David Riemens lived with his dog and slept under the stars. He opted out of the tech life, choosing instead to communicate with loved ones with antiquated post cards.Though well-loved by his small community, his mysterious ways became a serious problem when he slipped through the cracks of his small town.View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary at www.milkandmurder.com/david-riemens

    9. Margo Freshwater

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 3, 2020 25:01


    As we're all snuggled up inside watching the new season of Unsolved Mysteries on Netflix, most of us are googling "unsolved mysteries solved" with popcorn dust on our fingers. This is an Unsolved Mysteries episode that did get solved and you're gonna wanna buckle up for this one. View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Transcript of the Case

    8. Missing Akia Eggleston

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 5, 2020 27:08


    Akia Eggleston was 37 weeks pregnant when she missed her long-awaited baby shower. When her family rushed to her apartment, they found it half-emptied with a hole in the wall. Despite these troublesome finds and the fact that Akia was on bed rest, the police take their time getting involved and now, three years later, Akia’s family still needs help finding her and Baby A. View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary:  Episode Guide: Missing Akia Eggleston Come chat with me on Instagram! Milk and Murder Contact the Black and Missing Foundation  // Report any information or make an anonymous tip here

    A very quick Milk & Murder update!

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 30, 2020 1:04


    HELLO friends! I just wanted to provide you a quick update about Milk and Murder. What I didn't say in the episode is: THANK YOU. We're just about to hit 3,000 listens, and the news is spreading far and wide about these cases. All of my love to you!   PS: spoiler alert, this podcast isn't going anywhere, we're just learning technology + raising 4 sick kids through sickness season. We're about to be RIGHT back! 

    7. Murdered Jane Does

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 8, 2020 18:07


    While 2020 has been really difficult, it’s a great year for Cold Cases! Several Jane Does have been identified. Here are the haunting stories of two Jane Does whose cases are worth following. View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary:  Episode Guide: Murdered Jane Does Come chat with me on Facebook! Milk and Murder

    6. Murdered List Family

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 29, 2020 22:11


    If you binged the new season of Unsolved Mysteries like I did, you probably caught that episode House of Terror with the french man who killed his family and disappeared into thin air. What they don’t mention, however, is that this crime just like another that happened almost 50 years ago. Could the new murder mystery be solved just like the original? View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary: Episode Guide: Murdered List Family Come talk about this case with me on Facebook! 

    5. Murdered Cheryl Coker

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 16, 2020 24:25


    Dayton, OH mom Cheryl Coker goes missing after dropping her daughter off at school. She posts a few posts on Facebook, her phone pings a few times around the house, and then she’s never seen alive again. Surveillance footage in a grocery store parking lot shows a mysterious person dropping off her car and walking away, leaving nothing but questions and devastation.  View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary: Episode Guide: Murdered Cheryl Coker Support the Show:  patreon.com/itwasthehusband

    4. Murdered Jim and Tina

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 1, 2020 21:00


    Jim Wright and Tina Combs were leaning into their newly blooming long-distance friendship when they decided to meet for the very first time. However, what should have been an exciting new adventure ends up being the most gruesome crime the town of Kyle, TX has ever seen.  View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary: Episode Guide: Murdered Jim & Tina Support the Show:  patreon.com/itwasthehusband  

    3. Murdered Cassie Cotta

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 26, 2020 25:10


    Cassie Cotta was a force of nature from Fort Smith, Arkansas. She was well-loved and resilient, bouncing back after some unexpected life setbacks. When she goes outside of her routine by missing a work shift and not posting on social media, her loved ones embark on a search for her that turns their worlds upside down. View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary: Episode Guide: Murdered Cassie Cotta Support the Show:  patreon.com/itwasthehusband

    2. Kidnapped Bizzy Bone

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 18, 2020 21:05


    Before his rise to fame as Bizzy Bone of Bone Thugs-n-Harmony, Bryon Anthony McCane was abducted as a 4-year-old. His kidnapper told him his mom was dead and drove him over 1,000 miles away. This is the story of how the infamous disappearance and murder of Adam Walsh sparked the creation of America's Most Wanted, the show that brought Bizzy home. View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary: Episode Guide: Kidnapped Bizzy Bone Support the Show:  patreon.com/itwasthehusband

    1. Missing ShyShy Pate

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 10, 2020 26:46


    8-year-old Shy'Kemmia Shy'Rezz (ShyShy) Pate went missing in September 1998. Though her mom calls 911 right away, the police make a critical mistake that leads to a colossal delay in the search. When they finally do begin to look for her, there is one thing standing in the way of her case getting the attention it deserves: her race. Show notes, content guide, and sources can be found at:  www.milkandmurder.com/episodes/missing-shyshy-pate

    Claim Milk and Murder

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel