Friends and co-hosts Drew Shulman and Marie Vigouroux explore TV show Supernatural. With a focus on character narrative, growth and relationships, they offer a critique of the show’s lore, production and writing decisions. Whether you are a long-time fan
Canada
The Carrying Wayward podcast is a must-listen for any Supernatural fan. As someone who felt cynical about the show after the season finale, this podcast brought back my excitement and love for the story. The hosts, Mary and Drew, offer fresh energy and insight into the characters and plots. I appreciate that each episode is split into two halves - one for enjoying the show at face value and another for critical analysis. This allows fans to have fun discussing Supernatural while also having serious conversations about its flaws and creation. Fridays are always something to look forward to because of this show.
One of the best aspects of The Carrying Wayward podcast is the unique perspective it offers on Supernatural. Even if I don't always agree with the hosts' opinions, I love hearing a different take on the show and its characters. It's especially interesting because I don't have anyone around me to talk or analyze these characters with, so listening to other people's opinions is refreshing. Marie and Drew bring up thought-provoking insights that make you question your own perspective on the characters' actions and motivations. Whether you agree with their conclusions or not, it's a great listen for in-depth analysis.
While there aren't many negative aspects to The Carrying Wayward, one potential downside is that some listeners might not appreciate if they heavily disagree with the hosts' perspectives. However, I believe that open-mindedness can allow for interesting discussions even when opinions differ. Another aspect that could be improved upon is occasionally delving deeper into specific topics rather than briefly mentioning them during episodes. However, given that this podcast covers every episode of Supernatural, time constraints are understandable.
In conclusion, The Carrying Wayward podcast is an amazing listen for any Supernatural fan. It goes beyond surface-level enjoyment by diving deep into character motivations, themes like bisexuality and misogyny, and problematic aspects of the show itself. The hosts, Mary and Drew, have a great dynamic - one being a long-time viewer and the other watching for the first time. Their analysis has given me a new appreciation for the series and allowed me to enjoy each episode on a whole new level. I highly recommend this podcast to anyone who wants to explore Supernatural in a more nuanced and insightful way.
In this special episode, Drew and Marie answer some voicemails from listeners.---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this special episode, Drew and Marie answer some voicemails from listeners.---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this special episode, Drew and Marie answer some voicemails from listeners.---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 23 of Supernatural: Sacrifice. They talk about the confessions we hear in this gorgeous season finale. ---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 22 of Supernatural: Clip Show. They talk about the havoc brought upon Sam, Dean, and Cas in this penultimate episode!---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 21 of Supernatural: The Great Escapist. They talk about how Sam, Dean, Kevin, and Cas perform roles and tasks in this episode.---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 20 of Supernatural: Pac-Man Fever. They talk about how Charlie, Sam, and Dean experience escapism. ---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 19 of Supernatural: Taxi Driver. They talk about the different passages represented in this episode.---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com.Music by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 18 of Supernatural: Freaks and Geeks. They talk Sam and Dean's reactions to the child exploitation they witness in this episode.---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 17 of Supernatural: Goodbye Stranger. They talk about the various pieces of information that come out during this episode.---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 16 of Supernatural: Remember the Titans. They pick back up the theme of tragedy and foreshadowing. ---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 15 of Supernatural: Man's Best Friend with Benefits. They discuss Sam and Dean's relationship to doubt. ---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 14 of Supernatural: Trial and Error. They discuss when and how the brothers display eagerness. ---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com.Music by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 13 of Supernatural: Everybody Hates Hitler. They discuss the complexity of inheritance. ---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 12 of Supernatural: As Time Goes By. They discuss the things that are lost, passed on, or created between generations of Winchesters.---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com.Music by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 11 of Supernatural: LARP and the Real Girl. They discuss how escapism shows up for Sam, Dean, and Charlie. ---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 10 of Supernatural: Torn and Frayed. They discuss what (or who) Sam, Dean, and Cas need to release.---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com.Music by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this special discussion, Marie is joined by friend of the podcast JJ to discuss the power of allowing network TV characters to come out in their 30s and 40s in a special episode focusing on ABC show 911.JJ's twitter: https://x.com/JJBwayWatchJJ's TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@jjbwaywatchSupport us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com.Audio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 9 of Supernatural: Citizen Fang. They discuss the presumptions under which Sam, Dean, Benny and Martin are operating. They also curse John Winchester. A lot. ---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie are joined by Jeremy Greer of Monster of the Week and Non-Human Biologics as they dive into Season 8, Episode 8 of Supernatural: Hunter Heroici. They discuss how Sam, Cas, and Dean play make-believe in this episode and in other moments in the series.Jeremy's twitter: https://twitter.com/jggreerJeremy's podcasts: https://creepybutnecessary.cool/---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 7 of Supernatural: A Little Slice of Kevin. They discuss the trauma experienced by the many characters in this episode and reflect on Dean misremembering his. ---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.comMusic by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 6 of Supernatural: Southern Comfort. They discuss Sam and Dean's relationship thorough the theme of grudge and marvel at Garth and Mr. Fizzles. ---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com.Music by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 5 of Supernatural: Blood Brother. They discuss Dean and Benny's relationship through the theme of bonding and explore queerness in Bruce Springsteen lyrics. ---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com.Music by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 4 of Supernatural: Bitten. They take a Doylist approach as they discuss the main media references in this episode and what they say about the story at hand. ---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com.Music by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 3 of Supernatural: Heartache. They discuss the legacy Sam and Dean honour, reckon with, and consider leaving. ---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com.Music by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 2 of Supernatural: What's Up, Tiger Mommy? They discuss what or who is valuable to and for the brothers. ---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com.Music by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 8, Episode 1 of Supernatural: We Need To Talk About Kevin. They discuss responsibility and how Sam and Dean have taken on or abdicated responsibilities in the past year. ---Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com.Music by Jake LionheartAdditional sound editing by Jacqueline TucciAudio provided by zapsplat.com
In this minisode, Drew and Marie look forward to Season 8 with some changes, resolutions, and predictions! Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com
In this special minisode, Jason from 'Gateleapers' joins Drew to pitch a fan-written episode of Supernatural. Join our Ko-Fi or Patreon for perks and extra content like access to our exclusive Discord, post-show chats, and monthly live events: carryingwayward.comJason's twitter: https://twitter.com/JayNguyen_CStudio Munchie Food Truck: https://www.studiomunchie.comGateleapers (twitter): https://twitter.com/gateleapersGateleapers (website): https://linktr.ee/gateleapers
In this special minisode, Matt from 'Gateleapers' joins Drew to pitch a fan-written episode of Supernatural. Join our Ko-Fi or Patreon for perks and extra content like access to our exclusive Discord, post-show chats, and monthly live events: carryingwayward.comMatt's twitter: https://twitter.com/MattWWriterGateleapers (twitter): https://twitter.com/gateleapersGateleapers (website): https://linktr.ee/gateleapers
In this special discussion, Marie is joined by Dr. Sadie Witkowski of In Defense of Fandom to discuss parasocial relationships in the SPN fandom.Sadie's twitter: https://twitter.com/SadieWitIn Defense Of Fandom: https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/in-defense-of-fandom/id1674695211 - Episode 1 of Season 2 dropping March 26th! Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie are joined by patrons of the podcast from all around the world as they recap the seventh season of Supernatural. Recorded live on Zoom, they discuss family as the main theme of the season, and explore what family means to Sam and Dean, and how that meaning shifts through the season.Check out the recording on our YouTube channel: www.youtube.com/carryingwayward.Join our Ko-Fi or Patreon for perks and extra content like access to our exclusive Discord, post-show chats, and monthly live events: carryingwayward.com.---Audio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 23 of Supernatural: Survival of the Fittest. They discuss Sam, Dean, Bobby, Cas, Kevin, and Crowley's relationship with distress. Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com"Southern Gothic" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 22 of Supernatural: There Will Be Blood. They discuss all the treachery that is uncovered in this episode.Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com"Shadowlands 7 - Codex" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 21 of Supernatural: Reading is Fundamental. They discuss the feelings of sorrow that show up from the different characters in this episode.Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 20 of Supernatural: The Girl With The Dungeons And Dragons Tattoo. They discuss courage and how Sam, Dean, and Charlie (!) leverage it in this episode.Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com--- Audio provided by zapsplat.com"Adventures in Adventureland" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 19 of Supernatural: Of Grave Importance. They discuss Sam and Dean's expectations and how they are met or subverted. Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com"Welcome to HorrorLand" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 18 of Supernatural: Party On, Garth! They discuss connection and how Sam and Dean can connect to others at this point in the series. Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 17 of Supernatural: The Born-Again Identity. They discuss reclamation and what it means for the show and the brothers.Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 16 of Supernatural: Out With The Old. They discuss what things are creeping up on or creeping out Sam and Dean this week.Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 15 of Supernatural: Repo Man. They discuss how Sam and Dean's life and identity has been fragmenting.Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com
In this special minisode, William from ‘Hello From The Hallowoods' joins Drew to pitch a fan-written episode of Supernatural. Join our Ko-Fi or Patreon for perks and extra content like access to our exclusive Discord, post-show chats, and monthly live events: carryingwayward.comWilliams's twitter: https://twitter.com/TheHallowoodsHello From The Hallowoods: https://www.hellofromthehallowoods.com
In this special minisode, Katie from 'Making It Up As We Go' & 'The Gentleman Pirate's Library' joins Drew to pitch a fan-written episode of Supernatural. Join our Ko-Fi or Patreon for perks and extra content like access to our exclusive Discord, post-show chats, and monthly live events: carryingwayward.comKatie's twitter: https://twitter.com/DustyLCanonThe Gentleman's Pirate's Library: https://t.co/zrvumIG5DpMaking It Up As We Go: https://t.co/CibuhMffaDKatie's AO3: https://archiveofourown.org/users/NerdyNerdenstein/pseuds/NerdyNerdenstein
In this special discussion, Marie is joined by tiktoker JJ to discuss the parallels between the relationships of Achilles and Patroclus, and Dean and Cas. JJ's twitter: https://twitter.com/JJBwayWatch JJ's tiktok: @jjbwaywatch Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com. Audio provided by zapsplat.com.
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 14 of Supernatural: Plucky Pennywhistle's Magic Menagerie. They discuss neglect and how it shows up for Sam and Dean.Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 13 of Supernatural: The Slice Girls. They take a more critical approach as they discuss the misogyny present in this episode.Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 12 of Supernatural: Time After Time. They discuss the different ways that time shows up in this timey wimey episode.Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 11 of Supernatural: Adventures in Babysitting. They discuss how Sam and Dean deal with the grief of Bobby's death.Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com
7x10In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 10 of Supernatural: Death's Door. They revisit the theme of memory through Bobby's heartbreaking passing. Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com
7x09In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 9 of Supernatural: How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters. They discuss Dean's depression and Sam and Bobby's reactions to it.Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com
In this episode, Drew and Marie dive into Season 7, Episode 8 of Supernatural: Season Season Seven, Time For a Wedding. They discuss important issues of consent in this episode and Sam's memories of the cage.Support us on Ko-fi or Patreon: carryingwayward.com---Audio provided by zapsplat.com
© 2020-2025 Ivy Podcast Discovery LLC
