You Killed It

Follow You Killed It
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

You Killed It is a podcast devoted to MTV's The Challenge. Hosted by John Chidley-Hill and Sheldon Alexander, a couple of sports journalists based in Toronto, Canada, You Killed It is the thinking person's Challenge podcast.

You Killed It Podcast


    • Mar 12, 2024 LATEST EPISODE
    • weekly NEW EPISODES
    • 1h 7m AVG DURATION
    • 278 EPISODES

    4.2 from 176 ratings Listeners of You Killed It that love the show mention: favorite challenge podcast, challenge podcasts, best challenge, turbo, mature, two people, louis, well spoken, hands down the best, volume, finish, title, season, guys, watch, analysis, opinions, taking, love the podcast, game.


    Ivy Insights

    The You Killed It podcast is a must-listen for any fan of MTV's The Challenge. Hosted by John and Sheldon, this podcast delves deep into each episode, providing insightful analysis, witty banter, and expert breakdowns of the game strategy. With their charming Canadian accents and genuine love for the show, John and Sheldon create a fun and engaging listening experience.

    One of the best aspects of this podcast is the hosts' in-depth knowledge of The Challenge. They provide detailed analysis of the physical challenges, drama, alliances, and politics that unfold on the show. Their dedication to waking up early to watch the episodes together shows their commitment to delivering fresh and timely content to their listeners. Additionally, they have great chemistry and genuinely enjoy talking with each other, which shines through in their discussions.

    Another standout feature of this podcast is its professionalism. While still being funny and laid-back, John and Sheldon maintain a high level of professionalism throughout their episodes. They speak their minds honestly rather than taking it easy to preserve relationships or avoid controversy. This authenticity allows for refreshing commentary on the show without getting caught up in social media minutia.

    However, one downside of this podcast is that occasionally one host may interrupt the other before they finish their thoughts. This can result in unfinished ideas or missed points during discussions. While not a major issue, it would enhance the listening experience if both hosts were given equal opportunity to share their perspectives without interruptions.

    In conclusion, The You Killed It podcast stands out among other Challenge podcasts with its insightful analysis, entertaining banter, and genuine love for the show. John and Sheldon's expertise combined with their engaging personalities make for an enjoyable listen each week. Whether you're a casual viewer or die-hard fan of The Challenge, this podcast is definitely worth checking out for its unique perspective on the show's gameplay strategies and behind-the-scenes insights.



    Search for episodes from You Killed It with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from You Killed It

    You Killed It Ep 280 - Big T Farts

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 12, 2024 51:42


    More drama in part two of reunion and John and Sheldon break it all down on the final episode of the season #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 279 - Will The Real Champ Please Stand Up

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 2, 2024 55:19


    The Reunion part 1 is here and the entire cast is back, including the CHAMPS!!! John and Sheldon break it all down #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 278 - Little Baby Hill

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 23, 2024 62:19


    The finale is finally here, John and Sheldon break it all down and discuss the winner as well as their MVP and LVP of the season #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 277 - I'm That B*tch

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 17, 2024 47:47


    Nurys surprises the house when she returns, but the surprises don't end there as even more friendships get strained before the final #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 276 - Friend Or Foe

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 14, 2024 43:12


    Olivia and Nurys' relationship comes to a head after one of them makes an epic decision that changes the house for good #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 275 - 4th Chihuahua

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 10, 2024 37:24


    The game flips yet again, and Nurys is put in a difficult position that has turns the house upside down. #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 274 - Stalemate

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 2, 2024 51:39


    The line is drawn in the house and the two sides struggle to figure out who will head into the elimination to face one of the greatest challengers of all time. #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 273 - Check With The Boss First

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 19, 2024 38:29


    The Horacio & Kyland beef with Jay kicks into high gear as everyone is forced to show their cards after the daily challenge is sullied. #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 272 - Queen Bee

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 12, 2024 43:00


    Michelle AKA Queen Bee becomes the focus of the house and not in a good way. And that's before a visit from one of the Challenge GOATS #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 271 - Napping Contest

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 7, 2024 66:11


    Eating and trivia rule the day on this episode while Horacio and Nurys continue to try and figure out their relationship. #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 270 - Don't Look Like No Challenge Champions

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 7, 2024 54:55


    Kyland struggles to find his way without Melissa in the house, as another Challenge Great makes his return to try and shake things up #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 269 - I Threw A Drink In The Wrong Girl's Face

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 15, 2023 77:52


    Melissa tries to navigate her way out of being the main target of the house but puts her trust in the wrong people #thechallenge39 #thechallenge #mtv Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 268 - Shoe Laces

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 9, 2023 40:36


    Mellissa and Big T continue to fight off the entire house despite no one having a real reason why. #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 267 - Its Just Counting

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 1, 2023 50:30


    Corey's gameplay continues to make waves in the house, while a Challenge Champion returns and brings the Chaos to the game. #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 266 - I am Panicking

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 25, 2023 50:14


    Mellissa and Big T find themselves in the middle of the house drama as the rest of their house sets their sights on the friend duo #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 265 - I Feel Like A Superhero

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 17, 2023 61:55


    The questionable game play continues as Cory finds himself in the middle of the house drama. Meanwhile a challenge vet returns to add major chaos to the game. #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 264 - Awkward, Sorry Mom

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 11, 2023 66:31


    A double dose of The Challenge means a double dose of You Killed It. Sheldon and John recap episodes 3 and 4, while also wondering if anyone on this show understands how The Challenge works LOL #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 263 - Kiss Her, Kiss Her, Kiss Her.

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 11, 2023 62:23


    The house struggles to figure out the daily challenges while Chauncey struggles to figure out how to stop talking. A brand new season of The Challenge is here and John and Sheldon are fired up. A full break down of the new cast as well as the new twist and turns on this episode of You Killed It. #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 262 - I Have Self Control

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 30, 2023 59:35


    A brand new season of The Challenge is here and John and Sheldon are fired up. A full break down of the new cast as well as the new twist and turns on this episode of You Killed It. #TheChallenge39 #TheChallenge #MTV Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander

    You Killed It Ep 261 - Autocorrect

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 24, 2023 56:58


    The Challenge Finale is finale here, how did the 2nd season of The Challenge USA end and who gassed out yet again? Sheldon and John recap it all on the latest You Killed It #TheChallengeUSA #TheChallenge #TheChallenge38 Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 260 - A Ladder Up To Jesus

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 15, 2023 50:40


    It's the last Challenge day before the Final and so its win and you're in. If you lose, you might end up in a Hall Brawl Elimination. Josh has to make the biggest decision of his challenge career, but did he make a mistake? Sheldon and John debate that and more on the latest episode of You Killed It #TheChallengeUSA #TheChallenge #TheChallenge38 Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 259 - Michelletdown

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 13, 2023 48:17


    Michelle has to deal with her decisions from the last episode, but should there also be other houseguests joining her? John and Sheldon debate that and more on the latest episode of You Killed It Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 258 - Oil Royal Rumble

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 12, 2023 41:35


    Michaela wants to make a big move to target one of The Challenge vets but has trouble convincing the rest of the cast. John and Sheldon debate the merits of her strategy. #TheChallengeUSA #TheChallenge #TheChallenge38 Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander

    You Killed It Ep 257 - No More Heights

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 25, 2023 45:35


    Chris tries to get back in good with the house and his plan has massive implications for the Challenge Vets. Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 256 - Sunshine In Human Form

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 15, 2023 61:26


    Survivor Strong maintaining their numbers is causing drama within the house, while Chris tries to figure out which side of the house is actually on his side. Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 255 - Paws vs Pause

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 10, 2023 31:05


    From a team competition to an individual competition, who will adjust the best? John and Sheldon break down why the advantage was to the Challenge vets. Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 254 - Drunk Uncles

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 1, 2023 53:44


    Now that the vets are pretty much all on the same team, can they stick together to take over the house? That plus a budding romance develops between two of the housemates Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 253 - Words By Shakespeare

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 31, 2023 30:36


    Wes has his entire Challenge career flash before his eyes as the vets continue to be at the centre of the house drama. #thechallengeusa #TheChallengeUSA2 #TheChallenge Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 252 - Operation Hat Trick

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 30, 2023 34:36


    The Vets finally make their move in flipping the game and pinning Big Brother vs Survivor, but will it last long term? John and Sheldon debate that and more on the latest episode of You Killed It #thechallengeusa #TheChallengeUSA2 #TheChallenge Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 251 - Are We In Love?

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 21, 2023 58:48


    The Vets try and get their ish together as Josh of all people spearheads a big time move. Sheldon has not one, but 2 special guests who fill in for John who is away on assignment Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 250 - Obvious Manipulation

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 18, 2023 43:43


    The Vets continue to in fight, while the Survivor/BB Women are taking control of the game. John and Sheldon discuss what Cory and Fessy should do, plus Paulie's return to the challenge as a changed man. That and more on You Killed It #thechallengeusa #TheChallengeUSA2 #TheChallenge Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 249 - Prove It B*tch

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 15, 2023 64:44


    The beef between Michelle and Amanda continues as the first elimination provides an epic twist that changes the way this season will be played. John and Sheldon debate that and more on an all new You Killed It #thechallengeusa #TheChallengeUSA2 #TheChallenge Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 248 - Team Red Flag

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 11, 2023 49:01


    John and Sheldon are back to recap Season 2 of The Challenge USA. The guys discuss the cast and go over all of the different rules for the upcoming season Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 247 - Mean Tweets

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 2, 2023 70:06


    Michele didn't like what Sheldon and John said about her on last week's pod, the boys deep dive into the "twitter drama" and recap night 2 of The Challenge Ride Or Dies Reunion #MTV #TheChallenge #TheChallenge38 Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 246 - It Drips Gold B*tch

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 23, 2023 47:31


    The cast is back to recap the best moments from this past season of Ride Or Dies. John and Sheldon discuss the best fits, best lines and Maria Menounos on this edition of You Killed It . #MTV #TheChallenge #TheChallenge38 Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 245 - Welcome To Hour 69

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 16, 2023 62:19


    The season of Ride Or Dies is finally complete and Sheldon and John recap the epic 3 part finale and celebrate this season's winners #MTV #TheChallenge #TheChallenge38 Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 244 - You Threw Up In My Pocket

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 11, 2023 53:49


    Its part 2 of the finale and John and Sheldon debate the legitimacy of a 3 part final as well as the on-going Aneesa and Jordan partnership. #MTV #TheChallenge #TheChallenge38 Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 243 - Harder In Vegas For 80 Hours

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 2, 2023 47:38


    The Final has begun, deals have been made and one challenger has already been hurt TWICE!!! #MTV #TheChallenge #TheChallenge38 Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 242 - Better Her Than Me

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 26, 2023 53:02


    Who is the bigger threat in the Final, Fessy and Mariah or Bananas and Nani? The house guests debate and ultimately one of the teams goes home right before the Final. #MTV #TheChallenge #TheChallenge38 Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 241 - Oh My Cooch

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 20, 2023 69:17


    Not one but 2 great eliminations in which strategy ruled the day. John and Sheldon discuss one of the best elimination performances of all time. #MTV #TheChallenge #TheChallenge38 Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 240 - No Place For Love

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 13, 2023 70:14


    More twists and turns as Tori and Jordan are finally forced to face their issues, while TJ drops a surprise on the contestants. #MTV #TheChallenge #TheChallenge38 Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 239 - Ego, Ego, Ego.

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 6, 2023 60:22


    The Underdog team should have been on a roll, instead a huge mistake costs them their leader. John and Sheldon discuss that and more on the latest episode of You Killed It. Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 238 - You're A Dog

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 30, 2022 59:27


    The Underdog's get a boost as team work makes the dream work for Team Moriah. John and Sheldon breakdown the moves made by Devin and company. Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 237 - Tennis Sisters From Compton

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 22, 2022 59:23


    The time has come for a Challenge classic...Trivia! The contestants deliver the entertainment but not necessarily the right answers. Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 236 - Kenny Is My Brother

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 15, 2022 72:32


    The new format has the house spinning in circles trying to figure out if they should play for their team or their original ride or die. Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 235 - Make Ups 2 Break Ups

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 8, 2022 62:02


    Jordan and Tori's relationship drama comes to a head, while Fessy struggles with his place Challenge history. And oh ya, the game has completely changed yet again! Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 234 - That's Not Your Mans Bro

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 2, 2022 84:15


    The lines have been drawn in the house, sides have been chosen and Nelson has a major decision to make. John and Sheldon discuss whether or not he did the right thing..... Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 233 - New Champs?!?!

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 25, 2022 70:43


    The challengers set their sites on "The Biggest Snake In The House" but who do John and Sheldon think deserve the crown, Amber or Devin? Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 232 - Jack with 2 K's

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 17, 2022 59:32


    Michelle and Jay continue to be the talk of the house, but are they using their power for good? Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 231 - Stone Cold Laurel

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 11, 2022 71:07


    The house is at odds as Michelle and Jay have a chance to flip the things on its head, but how do Laurel and Jakk fit in to their plans? Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    You Killed It Ep 230 - Nelly-T Takes Flight

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 4, 2022 62:14


    Nelson finally gets his big moment, but the real credit lies elsewhere. John and Sheldon break down who was really behind Nelly-T's big day. Follow us on Twitter: @ShelAlexander @jchidleyhill

    Claim You Killed It

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel