Let The Good Crimes Roll

Send us a textEveryone's talking about it, so we decided to give it a go! That's right, Netflix's "The Perfect Neighbor." A seemingly idyllic neighborhood becomes the scene of a horrific crime. Was it self-defense? We will discuss!We get a little unhinged in this one with Husband Derek, too.Support the show

Send us a textTune in as Cousin Dawn, Husband Derek, and Casey listen to Cousin Amber catches us up on her love life.Support the show

Send us a textEnjoy part 1 of 2 Friday Follies as we discuss our unhinged lives! Support the show

Send us a textWe have three special co-hosts today! Join Cousin Amber, Cousin Dawn, and Husband Derek as they discuss the case of Cliff Lambert. Cliff was a retired art dealer who went missing. It takes over a decade to discover what happened to him.Source:Dateline, Season 34, Episode 3Support the show

Send us a textCasey reluctantly brings her husband and two of four kids to Barnes and Noble just before closing time, and chaos ensues. Sarah's Disney trip stories never disappoint.Support the show

Send us a textJames Glass was a dedicated Marine, husband, and father. When a coworker asks him to check on suspicious behavior in a bunker, he agrees. A grenade goes off and, to his surprise, it's not the first time someone has tried to take his life. Secrets come out and they're shocking.Source:Cold HeartedSeason 1, Episode 1Support the show

Send us a text

Send us a textCasey and her son, Cannon, talk about how fun being a big brother to someone with Down Syndrome is!Support the show

Send us a textJoin Casey and Sarah as they discuss weekly events and trick Husband Derek into doing random Tik Tok trends.Support the show

Send us a textJoin us as we discuss the case of Kristil Krug. When Kristil begins receiving alarming texts and emails from an ex-boyfriend, she goes to police for help. Her worst fear happens as the investigation is going on. When the culprit is discovered, no one can believe it.Listen to the end for last Friday's Follies (that Casey forgot to publish).The Case of Kristil KrugSource: Dateline NBCSeason 34Episodes 1The Phantom Can be Streamed on: HuluSupport the show

Send us a textWhen a socialite goes missing, Charlston police run into a dead end in search of her. The family, growing concerned, hires an A-Team of lawyers and investigators to find her. What they discover blows everyone's minds.Support the show

Send us a text  Join Casey and Sarah as they discuss weekly events, this week is a bit somber.Support the show

Send us a textWarning: this episode contains quite a bit of explicit content.If you haven't seen it, then you've surely heard about it. Two teens are stalked and harassed via text for over two years and when the truth comes out about the perpetrator, everyone is left stunned.The case of Lauryn Licari and Owen McKennySource: Unknown Number: The High School CatfishCan be Streamed on: NetflixSupport the show

Send us a textJoin Casey and Husband Derek as they discuss the birth of the fourth child, Cade as it is the week of his birthday!Support the show

Send us a textYall are getting a two-fer in this episode. First, Casey and Husband Derek discuss the case of Pamela Carnahan from Louisiana, then Sarah and Casey are going to discuss the case of Carmen Montelongo from California.Sources: Southern GothicSeason 1, Episodes 5 (Bloodshed in the Bayou)Can be Streamed on: HuluSnappedSeason 16, Episodes 4 (Bloodshed in the Bayou)Can be Streamed on: Hulu (Carmen Montelongo)Support the show

Send us a textJoin us as we discuss our lives and laugh away our woes!Support the show

Send us a textIn March, 1998, the Bradley stepped aboard a cruise ship. Four family members sailed away, but only three would return home. 23-year-old Amy seemed to vanish in thin air. Join Casey and Sarah as they dive down numerous rabbit holes to see it they can find Alice in Wonderland.Source: Amy Bradley is MissingEpisodes 1, 2, 3 (Vanished at Sea; I Saw Her; Message in a Bottle)Can be Streamed on: Netflixwww.foxnews.com “Brother of woman who vanished from cruise 27 years ago reveals critical third witness,” by Peter D'Abroscawww.pajiba.com “Netflix's ‘Amy Bradley is Missing' Leaves Out a Damning Revelation,” by Dustin RowlesSupport the show

Send us a textJoin Casey, Sarah, Husband Derek, and Captain Ron (Casey's Dad and Sarah's Uncle) as they interview Fire Chief Ronnie Carrier during his time of Hurricane Katrina.August 29, 2025 marks the 20th anniversary of Hurricane Katrina.

Send us a textJoin Casey and Sarah as they conclude the harrowing story that was Hurricane Katrina in this second part podcast. If you haven't listened to last week's episode, go back and listen to that one first.The source for this episode is Hulu's Hurricane Katrine: Race Against Time

Send us a textJoin Casey and Sarah as they discuss everything from the book Casey desperately needs Beta readers for to Husband Derek's theory about Karen Read.

Send us a textIt helps to hit publish, so, because I (Casey) forgot to check, you're getting a two-fer today. Join us as we discuss life.

Send us a textThis is Part 1 of 2. Tune in next week for Part 2!Join Sarah and Casey as they discuss the mishaps of 2005's Hurricane Katrina. Only an hour and a half away from where they live, Hurricane Katrina struck like a thief in the night and when all seemed clear, the worst happened: the levees that acted as barriers gave way.  In a matter of hours, citizens desperately mounted their roofs, praying for aid. The source for this episode is Hulu's Hurricane Katrina: Race Against Time, episodes 1-: The Coming Storm and Worst-Case Scenario

What happened to John O'Keefe? In this episode, we conclude the case of Karen Read. Was he killed by Karen? Or the people in the house party they were at? What more could possibly come out in trial.Tune in for the conclusion that just took place in June of this year.If you want to watch our source, you can check out "A Body in the Snow, The Trial of Karen Read," on HBO Max.If you like this episode or the podcast in general, please give us a rating anywhere you listen to your podcasts!

What have we been up to over the last year? Tune in and find out! This is a mini episode where we discuss our personal lives.

Welcome back! It sure feels good. In our official re-launch, we discuss the case of Karen Read through HBO Max's documentary, "A Body in the Snow, The Trial of Karen Read." In January, 2022, police officer John O'Keefe was discovered in the snow, later dying from his injuries. The questions begin to roll as we all wonder what happened? Was it Karen Read? His girlfriend who left him at the house? Was it the homeowners, one of which also was a police officer? This is a two-part episode, catch the conclusion next week.

Dave was starting over after a divorce. After trying his hand at online dating, he thought he met a casual, nice lady. When cupid's arrow hits him with a second lady, things become a bit crazy. Lady number two begins harassing and stalking Dave and all of the people in his life. How far will his date go?Reference:Lover, Stalker, KillerNetflix

When Lyntell Washington meets Dr. Robert Marks she thinks she has found her the true love that will take care of her and her 3-year-old daughter. After a year of dating, the shocking truth behind his intentions come to life in the crazy story.Reference:Fatal AffairsSeason 1Episode 1: Lessons in Lust

Brittany Smith was charged with murder after she experienced, what she said, was a traumatic night. Was she justified in shooting her assailant or did the justice system get it right? You decide....you know we will!!Reference:Alabama vs. Brittany SmithNetflix

Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman were brutally murdered outside Nicole's home in June, 1994. All evidence leads to one person....O.J. Simpson.  Join us as we re-visit the evidence and that infamous court case.Reference:ID's "O.J. & Nicole: An American Tragedy"Peacock's "O.J. Simpson: Blood, Lies, & Murder"

In July, 2018, the dead body of an emaciated man was discovered in a tent on a Florida hiking trail. Everything about this death was a mystery, including the manner of death, and, especially who he was. An investigation leads to hundreds of fellow hikers to come forward with pictures and stories of said hiker, but no one knew his name. The only name he gave was "Denham" and "Mostly Harmless."Reference:The Called Him Mostly HarmlessMax

Ruby Franke was known for being a YouTube sensation showcasing her family, including her husband and 6 kids. Soon, viewers began to notice some pretty disturbing behavior aimed at her children. When one of those children turn up emaciated and covered in wounds at a neighbors house, the shocking truth will leave everyone breathless

14-year-old Gloria Pointer is murdered on her way to school. Her mother, Yvonne, promises to not stop until she finds her daughter's killer. It takes over 30 years, but Gloria ultimately keeps her promiseReference:DatelineSeason 32Ep. 22A promise to Gloria

This week we recap the Netflix's 3-part documentary, "American Nightmare." Handsome Aaron calls 911 to report his girlfriend, Denise, missing. The story he tells police is too strange to be true. As police are building a murder case against Aaron, Denise shows up 400 miles away in her hometown. Was this a "gone girl" situation or did the incredible abduction actually happen? Tune in to find out!

Hamed Ghassemi was living the American Dream: an Iranian immigrant who had found success along with his mother in Baton Rouge, LA. When he came home one night, he discovered his mom was missing. After a few days search, he involves police and a scandal will lead us to an insane plot that spans from Baton Rouge to Iran.Reference:DatelineSeason 32Episode 16: The Ultimate Betrayal

In Part 2 of 2023 Headlines, Sarah renames Casey's dog while we cover the biggest true crime headlines in 2023, including Kaitlin Armstrong, Alec Murdaugh, The Utah Mom, & the Idaho Murders. Thank you for listening & please rate us on Apple Podcast/Facebook!

2023 was a crazy time for true crime. In this episode, we are discussing 4 of the craziest crimes/developments that happened in 2023, including: the release of Gypsey Rose Blanchard (eek!), The crazy Carlee Russell hoax (boy were we fooled), Long Island has a serial killer (I thought that was a Baton Rouge thing) , and that darn Van Der Sloot is facing justice in the death of Natalee Holloway (he's such a Sloot).So much happened that we have to have a 2-parter.

Join us as we see the ultimate Mother's love. Gemma went to jail to murdering her husband, Javon. But why? Also, what does Gemma's past have to do with her current status now? And did Gemma's Momma, Margaret, really try to run someone over for Gemma? Find out by listening!References:I Am A KillerSeason 4Episode 2: A Mother's Love

West Virginia is a crazy place! The world was shocked in the 1980's when an 11-year-old girl shot and killed her step daddy and claimed it was at the request of her Momma!Reference:People Magazine InvestigatesSeason 6Episode 2: My Mother's SoldierA Randumb Trio PodcastHello there listeners. Join our weekly podcast where our lively discussions on...Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify

It's a new season of our favorite, Dateline. In this episode, we discuss the case of Jamie and Jennifer Faith. Jamie, a fun-loving goofball, is gunned down at just 49-years-old. When police start to dig into the couple's marriage, they learn it's not quite what it seems.Reference:DatelineSeason 32Episode 1: Losing Faith

This one is off the rails! A man murdered by his wife, who also attempted suicide but failed, and the main witness to the case....an African Grey Parrot Named Bud.Check out this insanity as we dive into the details!Reference:Til Death Do Us PartSeason 1Episode 1: Don't ShootSmells Like HumansLike listening to funny friends discuss curious human behavior.Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify

Welcome Back! It's been a minute, but we are so happy to be back.Join us as we discuss the mean rodeo queen Camie Frazier. Camie had it all: looks, mad skills riding a horse, and cowboys wanted her. What she couldn't handle was her equally beautiful and talented sister coming up behind her and the jealousy that came along with it. Who got the full brunt of her wrath? You'll have to listen to find out!Reference:Mean Girl MurdersSeason 1Episode 5: Mean Rodeo QueenSmells Like HumansLike listening to funny friends discuss curious human behavior.Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify

We are back after taking some time off for the podcast. Join us as we discuss the case of Nick Rossi....or Arthur Knight....or Nick Brown. Whatever his name is. After wreaking havoc in the US he decided to evade legal consequences and move to Scotland where he changed his identity and would have us believe we are mistaken. Are we mistaken? Is this Nick Rossi or do we have it completely wrong? You decide!Reference:Dateline: Season 31, Ep. 28 Dead Man Talking

Goodness...what didn't we talk about?? Our main story we covered was that of Sylviane Finck Lozado, a beloved French Teacher at a Louisiana High School who disappeared. Her husband, Oscar, left 4 days after her disappearance and took their 4 year old daughter to Venezuala. It would take over a decade, but justice would eventually be found for Sylviane.We also talked about the trash reality tv shows: You, Me, and My Ex (TLC); Vanderpump Rules (Bravo); and Jewish Matchmake (Netflix)Reference:The AdvocateWBRZWAFB

Casey is a sucker for trash reality tv, so, when reality tv and true crime collided, it was a great day.  The reality tv show, The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City was rocked when, while filming, one of the main characters, Jen Shah, high-tailed it off their filming location and was later arrested on serious fraud charges. Get ready for Casey and Sarah to break down what happened!References:The Housewife & the Shah ShockerFound on ABC/Hula

We were super chatty in the beginning of this episode, so, if you want to jump straight in to the story, skip to minute 11.We are so happy to conclude this case. In this episode, we follow the trial and discuss the evidence that helped put Alex Murdough away for life! We also talk about Maggie and Paul's murder.Reference:Dateline NBCSeason 31Episode 20: The Trial of Alex Murdaugh

We have 2 more episodes dealing with Alex Murdaugh! Thank goodness! In this episode, Casey and Sarah discuss the death of Gloria Satterfield and the botched attempted suicide of Alex Murdaugh. If you haven't listened to Part 1 and Part 2, go back and listen!References:Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal (Netflix)Low Country: The Murdaugh Dynasty (HBO Max)

We continue our insane deep dive into the Murdaugh rabbit hole. We finish discussing the night of the boat crash and the odd behavior of the Murdaugh's at the hospital and the 2 years following the boat crash. It's during this time that a secret that has haunted Alex Murdaugh starts to come out and his world starts to crash. Could he truly be this desperate?References:Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal (Netflix)Low Country: The Murdaugh Dynasty (HBO Max)

Ya'll...thanks to a tech issue, we had to full-blown re-record the episode--UGH!Ever since the news broke that Alex (pronounced Alec?) Murdaugh was found guilty-of course at Cousin Dawn's rehearsal dinner (cue Husband Derek: can ya'll focus on the wedding??), we have been obsessed talking about the 5 deaths associated with the Murdaugh's. So, whether you know everything or nothing, dive in with us with these insane details.References:Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal (Netflix)Low Country: The Murdaugh Dynasty (HBO Max)

Both Casey and Sarah have been chocker-block full since Cousin Dawn's wedding on Friday, so, enjoy this replay!There will be an episode out this Wednesday, 3/8/23, regarding the Murdaugh's. If you would like to tag along with the episode, we will be incorporating episode 1 of both the Netflix and HBO Max documentaries regarding the case!We will also cover the latest Golden Girl's episode as well.Sorry for the delay!

Donna's life went according to plan: high school, college, married to the love of her life, kids, and career. When she came down with a mysterious illness, the perfect life she had fell apart. What, or who, could be responsible for Donna's downfall?On this week's Golden Girl Minute...or two, we meet Blanche's sister (who she hates!) and the rest of the girls babysit.References:Who the Bleep Did I Marry?Season 3, Ep. 1: Love Sickdonna.earth2.net/index.php?subject=storyThe Golden Girls:Season 1, Ep. 4: Transplant

Judith was living her best life with her husband, but, in 2001, everything changed when she learned she was married to one of the most prolific serial killers in U.S. history. Take a journey with an "Oh, Terri" feel to it with Sarah and Casey.Don't forget to listen to the end when they cover Season 1, Episode 3 in The Golden Girl Minute...or Two: Rose the Prude and a start to a book club that they have no time to dedicate to but would like to try. The book: House in the Pines by Ana Reyes.Show Reference: Who the Bleep Did I Marry?Season 1, Ep. 9: Married to a Monster