Preacher Vs Preacher: A Comparison Companion is a podcast that not only recaps episodes of AMC's series Preacher, but also compares it directly to it's source material, the 1990's comic book series of the same name written by Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon published by Vertigo Comics.
his week on the DC TV Report: The Legends of Tomorrow finale brings the usual madness, and Ed and Sara go deep on the Batwoman casting announcement, the history of the Thong Song, and Luke and Owen Wilson as dogs. Spoilers ahead, so jump over the ones you don’t wanna know about. Episode recaps Stargirl 6:05 DC’s Legends of Tomorrow 20:51 News updates Batwoman 38:28 Green Lantern 42:13 As always, Ed and Sara close with the winner of the week: 46:35 Got a burning question or keen observation? Send an email to dctv@wickedtheory.com or chat on Twitter at @dctvreport, @lileddieohare and @SaraNetzley. And don't forget to subscribe, rate, and review. Shazam!
THIS IS THE END! The final episode! Our guest is Agent Palmer from The Palmer Files podcast! He's her to help us break down the episode recap and compare this finale to the comics! Jessie fights Saint Of Killers and makes a deal book readers saw coming, Tulip fights Cassidy and thinks he's funny, Jesus fights Hitler and breaks lots of furniture, Herr Starr fights a Fax machine and plays golf, Featherstone stops fighting and God gets what he has commin'. PLUS our thoughts about a lot of things the show has done over four seasons! Follow Agent Plamer on twitter at @agentpalmer Follow Bill on twitter @wickedtheory Thank you for listening to this show and sticking around! Please don't unsubscribe just yet, be on the look out for occasional samples from Wicked Theory Studio! Specifically the RELAUNCH of The Wicked Theory Podcast!
Steph Muniz is back! She joins Bill to recap and compare another episode or PREACHER to the comics! This time: God gets in everybody's way! Jesse calls out for help! Tulip gets antagonized! Cassidy pulls a double-cross! Jesus and Hitler wrestle! Herr Starr and Featherstone finally get busy! And Arseface hits the road! plus we try to guess the ending that's coming!
Ed from The DC TV Report returns to aid Bill in recapping Preacher season 4 episode 8 "Fear OF God" and compare it to the comic book! Jessie sees God! Tulip, Cassidy and Humperdoo form a family! Herr Starr met some new friends! Stuff from the book happens! We try to guess how they'll wrap it up!
Sara Netzly from The DC TV Report joins us this week to recap and compare Preacher season 4 episode 7 "Messiahs" to the comics! Jesse gets an offer he tries to refuse! Tulip and Cass hit the road with a plan to block God's plan! Humperdoo comes out of hiding! Herr Starr looses a valuable asset! And the Dog suit gets an origin? PLUS: We speculate where the show will go next! What stuff from the book can they still squeeze in before it's all over? Follow Sara on twitter: @SaraNetzly Follow Bill: @WickedTheory Follow PVP: @PreachVsPreach
This week Ed is back as we recap and compare this episode to the comics! Jesse and The Saint have a walk and talk, Tulip and Cassidy tun into 70's cops, Starr gets giddy, Arseface is locked up, Jesus and Hitler have a sit down, and God's plan comes to fruition! PLUS we try to guess how the show will wrap up! Follow the show on Twitter @PreachVsPreach
This week Agent Palmer is the guest as Jesse Custer finally crosses paths with Arseface and The Saint Of Killers! Cassidy hangs out in a bar! Tulip and Jesus hit the road! Herr Starr might just pull off this big meeting! And Hitler gets a beating! Follow us on Twitter: @AgentPalmer @PreachVsPreach and Bill @WickedTheory Email: PVP@wickedtheory.com Search for us and subscribe/review on Spotify, iTunes, Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, Google Play Music, Overcast and many, many other pod services!
This week Ed O'Hare is back! Jessie is lost at sea! Cassidy is still in Masada! Tulip is still trying to get him out! Herr Starr is dealing with a real big summit! Plus Jesus arrives! And Hitler too! Big question: What Is Jesus' Power Set? Some links: Find Ed on The DC TV Report: https://twitter.com/DCTVreport https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-dc-tv-report/id1286955226 https://open.spotify.com/show/6WbvdCmtOWtvnSbhAXcHFQ https://www.stitcher.com/podcast/wicked-theory/the-dc-tv-report
Howdy Pilgrims, this time Bill is joined this time by Steph Muniz you should know her from The Gotham Lights podcast, which became The Orville Lights Podcast and she’s also on Moving The Needle podcast and has a blog at https://FromBrainToKeyboard.com! They’re Covering PREACHER season 4 episode 3 “Deviant”! Besides the recap they also get into what is “morality” on a show filled with deviants like Jessie, Tulip, Cassidy, Herr Starr, Saint Of Killers and the only innocent is a kid named Arseface? Some links: Steph: https://twitter.com/BadWolfBay87 https://www.denofgeek.com/us/tv/amc/282763/preacher-season-4-episode-3-review-deviant https://www.cbr.com/preacher-tv-cassiday-origin-change/ Bill: https://twitter.com/WickedTheory Follow the show on Twitter:@PreachVsPreach
We're back for season 4! Bill is joined by Ed O'Hare from The DC TV Report to breakdown two episodes of PREACHER! "Masada" and " Last Supper"! Yes, two episodes in one, because that's how they aired! Jessie, Tulip and Cassidy are up to their usual madness, only this time we are heading for the end of this crazy road trip! We try to spot the changes from book to show, what did we miss? Let us know!
THE END IS HERE! Well, of this season. But hey, look who came from The DCTV Report podcast - it's Sara Netzley! (And a dash of Ed too.) We all get together and breakdown the Preacher season 3 finale "The Light Above", and compare it to the books! How is it different! What are the changes? Who lives - who dies? What will happen to our heroes, Jesse, Tulip and Cassidy? Plus we give thoughts on the season overall and look to the future of season 4!
Bill and Dom recap and compare Preacher season 3 episode 4 "Schwanzkopf" to the books! Tulip, Arseface and Hitler are heading for hell! Cassidy is headed towards the light! Jesse is headed for Granma! How much of this is actually from the book?? Listen to find out! Follow the show on Twitter: @PreachVsPreach Follow your hosts: Dom @Dom_Torre Bill @WickedTheory Search for us and/or subscribe on Spotify, iTunes, Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, Google Play Music, Overcast and many, many other pod services!
Howdy Pilgrims! Bill and Dom are here again! This time, they're recapping Preacher season 3 episode 8 "The Tom/Brady" and comparing it to the comics! What does that title mean? How many Humperdoo's is too many? How come cassidy can't fly? What phone company does grandma use? We answer none of those questions. Follow the show on Twitter: @PreachVsPreach Follow your hosts: Dom @Dom_Torre Bill @WickedTheory Search for us and/or subscribe on Spotify, iTunes, Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, Google Play Music, Overcast and many, many other pod services!
Bill and Dom are here again to recap and compare episode 7 of season 3 of AMC's Preacher to the graphic novels! Hitler makes sandwiches, Tulip wears Grail colors, TC hears Genesis, Jessie makes a deal, Herr Starr wears a beanie, Cassidy takes bromance to the next level, and Grandma gets her nails done. Follow the show on Twitter: @PreachVsPreach Follow your hosts: Dom @Dom_Torre Bill @WickedTheory Search for us and/or subscribe on Spotify, iTunes, Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, Google Play Music, Overcast and many, many other pod services!
This week Bill and Dom recap and compare episode 6 of Preacher season 3 to the comics! This one's got a lot of Cassidy stuff that in the books was flashback, but here it's present day! Plus, Jessie and Tulip pull a soul heist to save Evil Old Grandma, and TC goes to the petting zoo! Awwwww. Follow the show on Twitter: @PreachVsPreach Follow your hosts: Dom @Dom_Torre Bill @WickedTheory Search for us and/or subscribe on Spotify, iTunes, Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, Google Play Music, Overcast and many, many other pod services!
This PVP episode might have the most rings of the "book bell" so far because episode 5 of season 3 of PREACHER has a LOT taken directly from the books! The Duke! The Coffin! All Father! Goofy hats! Even Billy-Bob! Good thing Bill and Dom are here to break it all down for you!
We're back recapping Preacher season 3 episode 4, The Tombs and comparing it to the book! Jessie puts on an act, Tulip gets the scoop, and Cassidy catches the bus? How much of this episode is from the book? Where do we think this season is going? Listen to find out! Follow the show on Twitter: @PreachVsPreach Follow your hosts: Dom @Dom_Torre Bill @WickedTheory Search for us and/or subscribe on Spotify, iTunes, Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, Google Play Music, Overcast and many other pod services!
The infamous Agent Palmer is the guest this week as he and Bill recap and compare episode 3 of Preacher season 3 to the comic book source material! Jessie and Cassidy are on-again/off-again BFF's, Tulip has another chat with god-dog, Grandma reopens the Tombs, Jody & TC figure out Cassidy's secret, and some of that was actually in the books! Thanks to @AgentPalmer for going us! Follow the show on Twitter: @PreachVsPreach Follow your hosts: Dom @Dom_Torre Bill @WickedTheory Search for us and/or subscribe on Spotify, iTunes, Stitcher, Google Play Music, Overcast and many, many other pod services! Visit Wickedtheory.com
We recap Preacher episode 2 "Sonsabitches" and compare and contrast it directly to the books - well, as much as we can. As we do that, we also theorize on where the show is going in season three and beyond, including the shifting dynamic between Jesse, Tulip and Cassidy. We breakdown the changes as we see them, tell us what you think in an email! Or tell us about Your Crazy Grandma Stories!
PREACHER is back and so is PVP! And boy have things changed on this podcast for season 3! Is it a reboot? New music, new graphic, new approach. Wait, what!? Well, yeah, kinda, but not really. You'll see. Anywaaay, all you book readers should be happy as Jessie, Tulip and Cassidy finally meet up with Jody, T.C. and Grandma and things get spicy while setting up the season ahead! We give our thoughts on how it compares to the books! It's the on-going adventure of what happens when a thing you love gets adapted. Hey, we want your "Crazy/Evil Grandma" stories! Email 'em! Follow the show on Twitter: @PreachVsPreach Follow your hosts: Dom @Dom_Torre Bill @WickedTheory Search for us and/or subscribe on Spotify, iTunes, Stitcher, Google Play Music, Overcast and many, many other pod services!
To wrap up the season of Preacher Vs Preacher we brought in both of our regular guests, Sara Netzley and Agent Palmer! It's the Season 2 Finale! How does it compare to the book? Well, we talk about that A LOT! We talk season highlights and theorize Season 3! Thanks to @SaraNetzley and @AgentPalmer for joining us! Follow the show on Twitter:@PreachVsPreach Subscribe to the show on iTunes, Stitcher and Google Play Music
Howdy Pilgrims! Sara joins us again! This time to recap Preacher season 2 episode 12 and compare it to the books because that's what we do! We recorded it live and got questions from the chatroom (at www.mixlr.com/wicked-theory)! Plus an honest email and some twitter questions! Thanks to: @SaraNetzley for joining us! Follow the show on Twitter:@PreachVsPreach Subscribe, rate and/or review the show on iTunes, Stitcher and Google Play Music
This time Bill, Dom & Bob breakdown episode 11 of season 2 of Preacher and compare it to the book! Lots of book stuff this week as we get some Jesse flashbacks, Herr Starr schemes and more! DING! PLUS: #AbsolutePVP contest announcement! What is that? Full details at http://bit.ly/PVPcontest2
Well this week brought one of the craziest story points from the Preacher books to life as Jesse meets.... well, you know. Thank god Sara Netzley is back to break it all down with us as we also follow Tulip, Cassidy, Denis, plus Featherstone and Hoover! Listen to us recap, theorize and speculate episode 10 of season 2!!
Hey look! @AgentPalmer joined us to breakdown Preacher S2E9 "Puzzle Piece" and compare it to the book with us! Yayyyy! Listen as we talk about Jess, Tulip and Cassidy's ever changing dynamic, Denis and his new outlook, Herr Starr's hole-y adventures, and more! How many times do we ring the bell? We theorize where the show might go next and answer an email from an old friend. Follow the show on Twitter:@PreachVsPreach And the team: @Dom_Torre @BobWTPC @WickedTheory Subscribe on iTunes, Stitcher and Google Play Music
Here we are again and we dragged Sara Netzley back too! We're covering episode 8 of season 2 of Preacher! Jesse, Tulip and Cassidy are still in New Orleans on the hunt for God and gettin' into trouble along the way. We theorize where it's all going, we compare it all to the book (where and when we can) and we have some laughs along the way. Apollogies for the volume issues, we'll be sure to fix that next time around. We went live and you should have been there, go to Mixlr.com/wicked-theory NOW to sign up, and click follow to get notifications whenever the show goes live! Be there!
This week the world got to meet Herr Starr - in full! Ring The Bell! Yes, we were pretty pleased with episode 7 of season 2 of Preacher, titled "PIG"! Also in this one Jesse, Cassidy and Tulip also play with guns! For Fun and Profit! PLUS we find out more about Dennis. Follow the show on Twitter:@PreachVsPreach And the team too: @Dom_Torre @BobWTPC @WickedTheory Subscribe to the show on iTunes, Stitcher and Google Play Music
We're back to breakdown episode 6 of season 2 of Preacher, titled "Sokosha" and compare it to the book! Jesse, Tulip and Cassidy finally run into the Saint Of Killers and big things happen! How many times do we ring the bell?
Howdy Pilgrims! This week Sara Netzley is back to help break down Preacher season 2, episode 5, "Dallas", and compare it to the books! Does this put an end to the whole Tulip/Dallas/Carlos/Viktor past history story line? Is the show starting to follow the book? How many times will the bell ring this week? Listen to find out! Follow Sara on Twitter: @SaraNetzley Follow the show on Twitter:@PreachVsPreach And the team too: @Dom_Torre @BobWTPC @WickedTheory Subscribe to the show on iTunes, Stitcher and Google Play Music
This week we're up to episode 4 of AMC's Preacher, titled "Victor". Tulip's past is haunting her, again. Jesse gets a lead on God, kinda. Cassidy keeps a secret, for as long as he can. And Arseface meets Hitler, because, why not? How does it compare to the book? Listen to find out!
Welcome back Pilgrims! Here we are breaking down Preacher Season 2, Episode 3: Damsels, comparing it to the book and adding in our theories and analysis! Some interesting stuff this week including the arrival of The Grail along with Agent Featherstone and the big bad himself, Herr Starr! Oh yeah, Hitler pops up too. Weird.
Here we go, Pilgrims! The gang is finally on the road and we're psyched to talk all about the first two episodes of Preacher season two! Jess, Tulip, and Cassidy have set out to find god and we do our best to break it down as only we can! We recap the episodes, compare as much as we can, and speculate where the show is going in the future. BTW we've changed our stance on "Book Spoilers" so listen closely buckaroos!
Season 2 of AMC's Preacher is right around the corner! A short trailer has been released along with a few official photos and some casting news! We break it all down, reflect on season 1 and look forward to speculate where Season 2 will go in comparison to the books!
The season wraps up here! Sara Netzly, Entertainment Weekly's online Preacher recapper, joins us AGAIN! Why would she do that to herself? We don't know, but we're glad she did! She helps us break down the last episode this season as Jesse Custer, Tulip O'Hare, Cassidy, Arseface, Sheriff Root, Donnie and Besty, Odin Quincannon and the whole town of Annville comes to a crossroads!
We went live again! This time we pregame the Preacher Season 1 finale! We speculate and theorize about the finale and the road ahead, also we look back at some of the highlights for the season! And Bob Skyped in from Florida! Dedication! We apologize for the rough skype connection with Bob as the show progresses.
This week the boys recap episode 9 of Preacher "Finish The Song" Jesse, Tulip and Cassidy are one week closer to lining up with the original story. The ABSOLUTE PREACHER GIVEAWAY continues! plus email and a poll!
This week we breakdown episode 8 of Preacher, "El Valero" with Sara Netzly, a freelance writer for Entertainment Weekly who writes the website's weekly Preacher recap! And saves our butt's twice! We had a lot of fun with her and look forward to having her back on. ALSO, we announce our ABSOLUTE PREACHER BOOK ONE GIVEAWAY, the super deluxe Preacher collection: hardcover, slipcase, collects issues 1-26 & more and retails for $150.00! Want it? Listen for details!
This week we recap and discuss episode 7 of Preacher, "He Gone". Jesse, Cassidy and Tulip are all here, but where's Eugene/Arseface? What did we like, what did we hate? How does it compare to the book? Listen to find out...
This time we recap episode 6 of AMC's PREACHER and it must be our favorite so far! We break it down, read some emails, give results of our Twitter Poll and read a few tweets. AND WE APOLOGIZE! We forgot to add in the SPOILER BELL! again. OOPS! We mention it though, so there's that!
This week we bring in our friend Tony, from WCBJ RADIO the @ComicBookJones podcast, He's a big time fan of the Preacher books who's digging the show so far. Agent Palmer is back as well and we all had a bit of of a hoot. We hope you do too. Also, while we still maintain that our show is for readers of at least book 1, we separated out Spoiler Talk for books 2 through 6 at the end, after the recap.
Howdy Pilgrims! Welcome back! Some say this week Preacher was slower - but we say it was just better! Jesse Custer and Odin Quinncannon! Tulip and Cassidy! Lacey and her demise! Wait… who's Lacey? Follow us on twitter @PreachVsPreach
Hello pilgrims, here's our second attempt at recapping Preacher Episode 3! Yup, Bill botched their first recording and the team had to re-do the whole thing! At least it ended up shorter the second time! What did we think of Jesse, Cassidy and Tulip this week? Listen in! Follow us on twitter: @PreachVsPreach
We invited Agent Palmer to help us breakdown episode 2 of PREACHER and we had a blast! Yes opinions vary on how we feel about the series but, overall, I think, we're liking it more? I'm not sure. Yes. Maybe. Before we get into the recap there's some kerfluffle with Entertainment Weekly "Borrowing" our show name and we get to know our guest a little bit! The recap starts at 17:00 with our first impressions and then we go into the full breakdown at 35:00 and then at some point, we get to an email!
Since the show went and took a week off (already?) we decided to not miss the chance to do something so we did a live episode! We did some Q & A, some dream casting, and much more with listeners in a live chat! Check it out - a lot of laughs were had! Special guest Stefanie from the Gotham Lights Podcast joined us to mix it up! Thanks for listening!
S1E1 - PILOT BEHOLD! The first episode of Preacher has aired and not only do we we break it down beat for beat, but we also make an announcement about a live episode next week (see below), we sample some ugly tweets, discuss how people are receiving it, we shout out some listeners and also throw theories around! C'mon, let's do this! Let's meet Jesse Custer, Tulip O'Hare, Cassidy and Arseface! REMEMBER: Join us LIVE on Sunday, May 29th at 7pm set over at Mixlr.com/wicked-theory to live chat and interact with us (and a friend) before the replay of Preacher ep 1 on AMC! Go set yourself up there, FOLLOW our page/account and you'll get an email reminder when we turn on the mics! Thanks for listening! Until the end of the world, pilgrims. Follow us on twitter: @PreachVsPreach Email us: PVP@wickedtheory.com
We're back! Just in time for the series launch of Preacher on AMC! Jesse Custer, Tulip O'Hare and Cassidy are coming! In our second episode we take stock of the early buzz for the show, get up to date with some new photos, hear a couple of interview clips , and read a few emails! All the while we share our hopes, fears, and predictions for the pilot episode and the series as a whole, come listen! Thanks for checking us out! Find us on iTunes, Stitcher and Google Play Music - be sure to subscribe, rate and review us! Follow us on twitter: @PreachVsPreach Email us: PVP@wickedtheory.com
Have you read #Preacher? Going to? Plan on watching the show? Then take the journey with us! Wickedtheory.com presents Preacher Vs Preacher, a podcast dedicated to breaking down AMC's new show Preacher and comparing it to the comic book it is based on. In this installment we introduce ourselves, explain what this pod will be, how much we love this story and tell you what the story is really about. We also try to not give away too much - yet - because we'd like you to go get the books, read them, and then in May you can dissect right along with us! Show twitter: @PreachVsPreach Email: PVP@wickedtheory.com
© 2020-2025 Ivy Podcast Discovery LLC
