Rothman & Ice

Happy Thursday! We got a 2-hour show today with 3-hours worth of football and jokes. We begin the show discussing the most clueless pop culture conversation we've ever had that took place an hour before the show. Buckeye players spoke to the media yesterday leading up to the Indiana game. We revisit our preseason NFL division winners from early September, and we did okayyyyy. Some of the preseason award winner predictions were a flop, though. And Warren Moon joins the show for Gold Jacket Thursday.

Happy Wednesday! We have a very newsy show today as we begin with a Ryan Day Signing Day press conference that was unknowingly scheduled right on the heels on the breaking news that Brian Hartline would be leaving his role as OSU OC to take the HC position at USF. Deshaun Watson is set to practice with the Browns as he works his way back from injury. We play In or Out. Adam Schefter joins the show. Multiple WR recruits show uneasiness as they second-guess whether or not they want to play for Ohio State following Hartline's departure. We react to the 4th installment of the 2025 CFP Rankings. Ben Roethlisberger has a crazy idea for who Penn State should target for their head coaching vacancy. Zach Werenski joins the show for Hockey & Hounds. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Tuesday! We begin the show with a Ryan Day press conference followed by an instant reaction. We play Fool's Paradise. The Floor is Yours. We play Party Like a Rothstar. We Break Down the Browns with Tyvis Powell. The spread of the Big Ten Championship game is moving. Bobby Carpenter crashes the studio to help us discuss the impending CFP Rankings that will set the stage for conference championship weekend as well as discussing the NFL MVP race. We go Day Trippin' with Austin Ward. And the people of Twitter have voted on yesterday's groundbreaking debate.

Happy Monday! We now have 2-hour shows on Mondays as The Jake Diebler show has conquered the noon hour. Ohio State beat Michigan in case you hadn't heard. The monkey is off of Ryan Day's back, and this team is playing with confidence. The Big Ten Championship is on deck. Jim Lachey joins the show. Ian Fitzsimmons joins the show. Adam King joins the show. And there may never be a debate on this show as fierce as the one that overtook the final few segments.

Happy Friday! It's Michigan Eve around here. We make our NFL Picks for the weekend which has technically already started. Bobby Carpenter joins the show. We play Overs and Unders. Nick Saban calls Ohio State fans psychotic, and Urban Meyer agrees to an extent. We play Under Pressure. We make our CFB Picks. Tim May joins the show. Joe Burrow kept the Bengals alive at least for one more week, and Bengals fans are now eyeing the playoffs this morning. Brady Quinn joins the show to discuss The Game. And Al Pacino gets us motivated for a big matchup in Tell the Truth.

Happy Wednesday! It's Michigan Week Pt. 3 as we follow up The Ryan Day Show. TLC embarrassed the show in Jake Diebler's press conference last night after the Buckeye basketball game. Urban Meyer joined Bishop and Friends and had some thoughts on how Ohio State should strategize against Bryce Underwood. Adam Schefter joins the show. Michigan RB and Cincinnati native Jordan Marshall throws some jabs at the Buckeyes when explaining why he left the state of Ohio to commit to Michigan. Joe Burrow is back!!! We pick the NFL Thanksgiving games. Damon Severson joins us for Hockey & Hounds. And we get way out of control in Tell the Truth.

Happy Tuesday! We begin Michigan Week Pt. 2 with a Ryan Day presser and immediate reaction. We play Fool's Paradise. Julian Sayin's Heisman buzz has really dipped, and some of it makes sense, but does the Big Ten Championship game hold all the cards? We Break Down the Buckeyes/Browns with Tyvis Powell. Former Buckeye Matt Finkes joins the show. Ja'Marr Chase apologizes to everybody except one person, and that one person is kind of important. We go Day Trippin' with Austin Ward. And Oz the Mentalist got Oz the Mentalisted in Tell the Truth.

Happy Monday! We begin the show with a surprise birthday celebration for our guy AR including a special guest of honor making his R&I debut. Who cares about Rutgers, it's Game Week now. Jim Lachey joins the show. We play Party Like a Rothstar. The Floor is Yours. Shedeur Sanders made his debut as an NFL starter over the weekend, and he's already celebrating what his future success will look like. We host A-dumb's King-dumb. Ian Fitzsimmons joins the show. The Bengals season is over. Former Buckeye QB Greg Frey joins the show. And we swap birthday gifts in Tell the Truth.

Happy Friday! The Jackets picked up a W last night in OT. Ohio State plays Rutgers tomorrow. Sam Monson of The 33rd Team joins the show to talk NFL. We play Overs and Unders. Should athletes still play when their wives are giving birth? Ice's car got broken into by a potential listener of the show earlier in the year. We play Under Pressure. We make our CFB Picks. Tim May joins the show. We find ourselves discussing the weight of the Michigan game following Rutgers. Jeff Lloyd joins the show to talk Browns in the Big Game Preview as Shedeur gets ready for his first career start. And we shame three NFL QBs in Tell the Truth.

Happy Thursday! We have 3 hours of fun packed into a 2-hour show, and we begin the show with ENERGY. Bill Simmons irked Blue Jackets fans. Joe Burrow is a full participant in practice, much to our surprise. We make our NFL Picks. Some new Buckeye receivers are going to have to step up. Ian Fitzsimmons joins the show to talk college football. Bill Rabinowitz joins the show to discuss his new book Buckeye Brotherhood: How Ohio State navigated a new world to win a National Championship. And we discuss movies in Tell the Truth.

Happy Wednesday! The CBJ drop last night's game in Winnipeg. Somehow we find ourselves reliving Nipplegate. We react to the third edition of the CFP rankings. Adam Schefter joins the show. Shedeur Sanders is getting all the reps this week. We play In or Out. Bobby Carpenter joins the show. Ryan Day isn't overlooking Rutgers. Which current NFL division leaders are safe and which ones are in danger? Zach Werenski joins the show for Hockey & Hounds. And we Tell the Truth on football topics we didn't get to earlier in the show.

Happy Tuesday! We begin the show with a Ryan Day Presser and instant reaction to his balking at injury questions. We play Fool's Paradise. The NFL has ruled on the Ja'Marr Chase spitting dilemma, and Ja'Marr is contesting the ruling. The Shedeur conspiracy theorists just won't stop. Tyvis Powell joins us from the eye of a hurricane to Break Down the Browns with us. There are two important aspects to focus on in tonight's CFP rankings. Either the Chiefs or the Ravens are missing the playoffs in the AFC... we think. We go Day Trippin' with Austin Ward. And James Franklin's new job in Blacksburg headlines today's Tell the Truth.

Happy Monday! The Buckeyes destroyed the Bruins. We have a new drop from a piece of audio that has been rediscovered from 4 years ago. Jim Lachey joins the show. We play Party Like a Rothstar. The Floor is Yours. A Shedeur Sanders discussion gets stampeded by a debate about Myles Garrett and whether or not he deserves all of the losing he is experiencing this season. It doesn't matter how much you love or hate Adam King... you need to listen to what happened on today's A-dumb's King-dumb. Some fishy injury news with the Buckeyes. Ja'Marr Chase is lying about not spitting on Jalen Ramsey, so what's next now that there is video evidence? Double down or apologize? Ray Fittipaldo of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette joins the show. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Friday! You're in the office baby. The Blue Jackets got revenge on Edmonton last night. Ohio State plays UCLA tomorrow. Cam Mellor of PFSN joins the show to talk college football. We play Overs and Unders. The Bengals have no chance to make the playoffs... or do they? We play Under Pressure. We make our CFB Picks. Tim May joins the show. We reminisce about John Tortorella's weekly appearances on this show when he was head coach of the Jackets. All hope is lost for Justin Fields. Wayne Cook of the UCLA Radio Network. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Thursday! We got our usual 2-hour Thursday show following The Ryan Day Show. Damon Severson joins the show for a unique edition of Hockey & Hounds (usually on Wednesdays). We make our NFL Picks. We discuss Bo Jackson's role on the Buckeyes. We discuss the current state of quarterbacking in the NFL with a focus on three guys in particular. Earl Campbell (yes, that Earl Campbell) joins the show for Gold Jacket Thursday. And we kinda sorta play Tell the Truth.

Happy Wednesday! Our celebration of the Blue Jackets' win last night gets derailed by Kim Kardashian failing the California bar exam. We have a second batch of CFP rankings. Adam Schefter joins the show. Is Brian Daboll flirting with Penn State? The NFL MVP race is between two guys at this current moment. We discuss an article about 100 skills that every man should know. We don't have those skills, but we learn that Bobby Carpenter has all of them. Ryan Day discussed what makes Arvell Reese great. Where do we stand on Caleb Williams at this point? Should we just assume Kansas City is grandfathered in as the Super Bowl favorite until further notice? And we discuss the appropriate plan of attack when getting a girl's phone number in Tell the Truth.

Happy Tuesday! Ice is back in the saddle, so we have to catch him up on everything he's missed which was highlighted by Adam King introducing himself to Ian Fitzsimmons on yesterday's show. We don't even mean to, but we find ourselves in a big discussion about last night's Monday Nighter between the Eagles and Packers. Brad Crawford of CBS Sports joins the show to talk college football. We play Fool's Paradise. Do the Bengals still have playoff life? The Columbus Blue Jackets need to get their act together. We Break Down the Browns with Tyvis Powell, and he gives us something to talk about in regard to the Guardians betting scandal. Dan Orlovsky says the Giant should scoop up Kevin Stefanski in the event the Browns call it quits. We go Day Trippin' with Austin Ward. And we Tell the Truth about where the infamous Adam Schefter drop came from.

Happy Monday! Purdue was no match for Ohio State. There were some wild theatrics in the Indiana-Penn State game which sparks enormous debate on the show about Curt Cignetti. Jim Lachey joins the show. We play Party Like a Rothstar & The Floor is Yours. Brian Daboll got fired midshow, so how much longer does Kevin Stefanski have? Ian Fitzsimmons joins the show, and you HAVE to hear what happens as Adam tries to tell a story about once meeting Ian in a Spanish airport. Rothman passes Adam's movie trivia game with flying colors as you knew he would. And Gus Johnson jumped the shark.

Happy Friday! We have perhaps the droppiest show we've ever had today. Traffic in the Starbucks drive-thru almost made Adam late for the show. Ohio State is probably going to rout Purdue tomorrow. Spencer Holbrook of Lettermen Row joins the show. We play Overs and Unders. Remember that time Bill Burr came on the show? We play Under Pressure. We make our CFB Picks. Tim May joins the show. Antonio Brown is back in the United States, but he probably wishes he wasn't. A simple discussion about the Baja Blast Pie from Taco Bell gets personal. Pete Fiutak of CollegeFootballNews.com joins the show. And we Tell the Truth about where we would not want to coach in the Big Ten.

Happy Thursday! Adam King is here to help us knock out a 2-hour shorty following The Ryan Day Show. One of the hosts stayed up for the entirety of the Blue Jackets game, and the other changed the channel quickly. We make our NFL Picks. We discuss the CFP rankings and question if the Big Ten is getting a raw deal. Former Patriots and Raiders cornerback Mike Haynes joins the show for Gold Jacket Thursday. And Julian Saying helps us celebrate the very temporary return of 2 Truths and a Lie in Tell the Truth.

Happy Wednesday! The CFP rankings made their debut. Adam Schefter joins the show hot off an NFL Trade Deadline. Zac Taylor responds to Chase Brown's postgame comments. We play In or Out. Bobby Carpenter joins the show. The Heisman talk is getting hot in Central Ohio. Where are we at on this Blue Jackets bet? We pull a 2-a-day with BCarp. Ice went from hating his Ravens to now asking about their Super Bowl odds. Arvell Reese is almost unanimously a top 10 pick at this point. Zach Werenski joins us for Hockey and Hounds. And we have the most memorable Tell the Truth we've ever performed.

Happy Tuesday. We begin the show with a Ryan Day Presser. We play Fool's Paradise. It's NFL Trade Deadline day, so we have news breaking all throughout the show. Dallas acquired Logan Wilson from the Bengals. We Break Down the Browns with Tyvis Powell. We discuss the Julian Sayin Heisman campaign. The CFP rankings make their 2025 debut tonight. The Jets are throwing in the towel. We go Day Trippin' with Austin Ward. And we play Tell the Truth.

Happy Monday! The Bengals made us so mad that we couldn't even start the show with the Buckeyes like most Mondays, but we got to them quickly. Stephen Means joins the show. We play Party Like a Rothstar. We play The Floor is Yours, and we have a new drop that we're going to hear way too much. Game 7 of the World Series revealed who is and who isn't a big time sports fan. We have A-dumb's King-dumb. Ian Fitzsimmons joins the show to talk college football. We discuss the outlook of the AFC. And will Sir Paul share a mic with Rothman when he comes to town?

You're in the office, baby. Happy Friday! The Ravens ain't dead yet. Ohio State hosts Penn State tomorrow. We accidentally have a hilarious interview with Joe DeLeone. We play Overs and Unders. How much longer are the Browns going to roll out Dillon Gabriel before giving up on him? We play Under Pressure. We make our CFB Picks. Tim May joins the show. The Bengals go against the Bears this weekend. Ben Jones joins the show to give us the Penn State side of this weekend's story. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Thursday! Shortened show following Ryan Day Show. We learn about Michael Myers II actor Dick Warlock. The CBJ destroyed Toronto. We make our NFL Picks. Ryan Day sure is laying it on thick with Penn State. We replay a great interview with Nick Mangold from Radio Row at the Super Bowl from January of 2020. Ian Hartitz joins the show for fantasy football talk. And we Tell the Truth about Matt Rhule's extension at Nebraska.

Happy Wednesday! The Rothdog is back in the studio after his extended weekend in Bloomington with old friends. The Blue Jackets won last night! We have 4 QBs fighting for the Heisman Trophy, and it's kinda being divided into two separate 1v1 battles. Adam Schefter joins the show with an interesting tidbit on Myles Garrett. These CFB HC buyouts are ridiculous. We have two very different voices on this show speaking on whether or not you should donate money to your university. The World Series is a lot better than people thought it would be. Bobby Carpenter joins the show with some great stories about Nick Mangold. Bruce Arians think 3 AFC North head coaches are getting fired after this season. Damon Severson joins the show for Hockey & Hounds. And take a wild guess who we ended up talking about in Tell the Truth...

Happy Tuesday! Dylan Tyrer is filling in with Ice while AR is out for one more day. We begin the show with a Ryan Day press conference. We play Fool's Paradise. Should the Browns trade Myles Garrett? We Break Down the Browns with Tyvis Powell. Lane Kiffin and Brent Venables are beefing. We look ahead to the Penn State game. World Series Game 3 was BALLISTIC! The Bengals defense had a players-only meeting... you know what that means. We go Day Trippin' with Austin Ward. And a coworker of ours gets called out by his wife for putting on a few pounds in Tell the Truth.

Happy Monday! Dane and DeVier are back for more as they 3-man booth this show with Ice. We remember Nick Mangold at the top of the show. Brian Kelly got fired at LSU. Jim Lachey joins the show. We play Party Like a Rothstar. We play The Floor is Yours. The Bengals supplied the Jets with their lone win of the season. Adam King joins the show for A-dumb's King-dumb. Ian Fitzsimmons joins the show. Are the Green Bay Packers in the driver's seat to go to the Super Bowl? And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Friday! AR is out, but both DeVier Posey and Dane Sanzenbacher are in, so we got a 3-man booth! We pickup where we left off on yesterday's NBA gambling bust conversation. Julian Sayin has been added to the Manning Award Watch List. We play The Newlywed Game to discover how much Dane and DeVier actually know about each other after 18 years of friendship. We play Overs and Unders. Rothman calls into his own show from the road to Bloomington to clear the air with Dane. We play Under Pressure. We make our CFB Picks. Tim May comma join the show semicolon. Are NIL opportunities coming to high school athletes in Ohio? Brian Daboll's lack of patience with Russell Wilson at QB just got the team fined. The Dolphins PR team is doing a terrible job of media-coaching Tua Tagovailoa. Ray Fittipaldo of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette joins the show ahead of Steelers-Packers on SNF. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Thursday! We discovered during the Ryan Day Show that Matt Patricia needs a raise. Pitt coach Pat Narduzzi had something ridiculous to say about the landscape of college football. We make our NFL Picks. Ryan Day reveals that sometimes the best lessons are taught by watching others screw up. An FBI gambling probe results in multiple NBA figures getting arrested. Ian Fitzsimmons join the show. And Justin Fields responds to Woody Johnson in Tell the Truth.

Happy Wednesday! The CBJ looked awesome last night in Dallas. Jets owner Woody Johnson blamed all of their woes on Justin Fields. Adam Schefter joins the show. The Cavaliers season begins tonight. There's a new favorite QB for the 2026 NFL Draft who NOBODY was talking about in the preseason. We were supposed to play In or Out, but we really just ended up talking about old flames, and one of us had a stalker. Bobby Carpenter joins the show. Are these current NFL division leaders going to hold? Zach Werenski joins the show for Hockey & Hounds. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Tuesday! Ryan Day begins the show with the shortest press conference ever which means we have to host a podcast before we get to Fool's Paradise. We discuss Curt Cignetti's extension. Rothman has a very out-of-touch-with-the-youth moment on this show. We Break Down the Browns with Tyvis Powell. Jeremiah Smith believes this year's team is better than last year's championship team. This week in the NFL saw one riser and one faller in the MVP race. Are the Seahawks legit? We go Day Trippin' with Austin Ward, and we Tell the Truth.

Happy Monday! Ice got double-birded at a red light over the weekend. Wisconsin never stood a chance against Ohio State. Jim Lachey joins the show. We play Party Like a Rothstar. The Browns somehow didn't get Mike McDaniel fired. Adam King joins the show for A-dumb's King-dumb. Carnell Tate's success is elevating Julian Sayin's Heisman candidacy, damaging Jeremiah Smith's and doing absolutely nothing for himself. Rothman is tempted to cash out a bet that will definitely hit tonight. Brad Crawford of CBS Sports joins the show. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Friday! The Blue Jackets lost to the Avalanche last night. The Buckeyes take on the Badgers in Madison tomorrow. Howard Griffith of Big Ten Network joins the show. We play Overs and Unders. Joe Flacco still has life as he led the Bengals to a TNF victory over the Steelers. We play Under Pressure. We make our CFB Picks. Tim May comma joins the show semicolon. Tony Rizzo of ESPN Cleveland took a blowtorch to Andrew Berry for dealing Flacco. Curt Cignetti got extended in Bloomington. Colten Bartholomew, not to be mistaken with Cole Bartemes, joins the show to give us the Wisconsin perspective. And we Tell the Truth about whether or not Lane Kiffin's body shaming of Kirby Smart was out of bounds.

Happy Thursday! 2-hour compact show today. The Bengals play tonight in "The Unc Bowl." Boomer Esiason pushes for the Bengals to trade Trey Hendrickson. We make our NFL Picks. Does Wisconsin have a prayer against OSU? Former NFL sack leader Shawne Merriman joins the show. Hall of Famer Dwight Stephenson joins the show for Gold Jacket Thursday. And we Tell the Truth.

Rothman & Ice Replay

Happy Tuesday! Ryan Day takes the podium to begin our show. We play Fool's Paradise. The first draft pick in the history of the Blue Jackets organization, Rusty Klesla, joins the show. We Break Down the Browns with Tyvis Powell. A passionate debate breaks out over whether or not college football players should be required to attend classes. The Colts and the Buccaneers are technically the leaders in the clubhouse to make the Super Bowl, but who is actually going to come out on top of each conference? Ja'Marr Chase has a way with words to describe his upcoming matchup with the Steeliz. We go Day Trippin' with Austin Ward. And we Tell the Truth about talking sports with our friends.

Happy Monday! Ohio State controlled Illinois for all four quarters. Jim Lachey joins the show. We play Party Like a Rothstar. We debut our new Monday 1 PM call-in segment "The Floor is Yours." I guess we should get used to the Bengals and Browns losing together all the time. Adam King returns for A-dumb's King-dumb. Ian Fitzsimmons joins the show to talk college football including James Franklin's firing in Happy Valley. An NFL head coach gets fired mid-show. And we Tell the Truth.

Happy Friday! You're in the office baby! Rothman holds Ryan Baker over from Bishop & Friends following their off-air disagreement about the late game management of Adam Fantilli in last night's season opening loss. Ohio State and Illinois square off tomorrow. Cam Mellor of PFSN College joins the show to talk ball. We play Overs and Unders. What are the Browns and Bengals even playing for at this point? We play Under Pressure. We make our CFB Picks. Tim May joins the show. Is there any way that Sayin and Jeremiah both make the Heisman Trophy ceremony? AJ Brown is intentionally being an ass at this point. Scott Richey of The News Gazette joins the show to give us the Illinois perspective heading into tomorrow's game. And we Tell the Truth about cake in quite literally all of its meanings.

Happy Thursday! We begin the shortened show with an announcement about a new call-in segment that we're going to debut on Monday at 1 PM. The Blue Jackets begin their season tonight. We try to make our NFL picks but get sidetracked by random bar trivia. Shedeur Sanders has found his voice. Brenden Deeg of The Score joins the show to talk NFL. And we do a live unboxing during Tell the Truth.

Happy Wednesday! Beau Bishop hangs around after his show for a segment to discuss how the rules of sports TV are completely changing due to the McAfee effect. Deion Sanders doesn't give a darn about the Browns, just ask him. A couple college football coaches are being giant whiners. Zach Werenski joins us for the first Hockey & Hounds of the season. We play In or Out. Bobby Carpenter joins the show. Rothman now has a bet with our boss on the Ohio State-Illinois game. Mike McDaniel has a commanding lead for first NFL head coach to be fired, but a new candidate has joined the race. Tyreek Hill gave us an honest truth that we all agree with, but we still don't want to hear it from him. And we Tell the Truth.

Rothman & Ice Replay