A podcast hosted by two best friends who like laughing and talking about true crime and other spooky things.
Amber Scribbick & Lesley Gregg
In this week's episode Amber and Lesley talk about the infamous cold case, The Boy in The Box. Big updates have been made in the case and Amber shares the breaking news! The Mystics give the runaround on the evidence, the boy's injuries and case theories!
The Grimm Mystics are wishing everyone a safe and Happy Thanksgiving and Indigenousness Heritage Day
In this week's episode Amber and Lesley talk about Christopher Scarver, the man who killed the infamous serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer! The Mystics forget that Chris was in prison in the first place and only applauded him on killing a POS like Dahmer! But Amber reminds all of us that he was a killer before.Sources for this Episode:WikipediaLadBibleFollow us on Social Media!@thegrimmmystics on Facebook and Instagram@thegrimmmysticspod on TikTokHave a paranormal story or a connection to a true crime case? Even something you think The Mystics will find funny? Email us! thegrimmystics@gmail.com
In this week's episode Lesley and Amber talk about the origins of Jack the Ripper and the Whitechapel Murders. The Mystics dig deep into the culture that was Whitechapel in the 1880's. This Week's SourcesJack the Ripper ToursStrawberry London Tours Jack the Ripper Wikipedia JacktheRipper.orgCase BookAngel Alley
Lesley and Amber look into the mystery of the Lost Boys of Hannibal Missouri. Go cave exploring with the Mystics and tell us what theory you believe!
In this week's episode Lesley and Amber talk about the online religion known as Snapeisim. What happens when a group of middle aged women get together on the internet? They fan girl over Alan Rickman of course! The Mystics touch on some deep and passionate vows to spicy fan fiction
Lesley and Amber dive into the case of Mary Blandy and her fathers murder. Who is really at fault? Mary or the Captain? Listen to the pod to see what Lesley and Amber think!
Today Lesley & Amber let the explorers in on a secret!
⚠️ READ ME FIRST ⚠️On June 24th, 2022 the United States Supreme Court in a 5-4 decision overturned Roe vs. Wade. This episode was recorded two days later. We were angry, and grieving the loss of a human right women before us fought for. We will continue to fight for women in the present and future. Click Here to find the Take Action Tool Kit Click Here to find Resources for WomenClick Here to find More Resource HubsOn this week's episode, Lesley and Amber talk about the folklore behind Doppelgangers. From finding folklore and urban legends of cryptid creatures who act like doppelgangers to Abraham Lincoln's death being prophesized because of his doppelganger you'll become a fellow Doppleganger Expert. The Mystics finish the episode with a tale about a woman in France with a terrible job history. Is she just a bad employee? OR does she have an evil double to blame? Follow Us on Social Media!@thegrimmmystics on Facebook and Instagram@the grimmmysticspod on TikTokDo you have a connection to a true Crime case? A personal paranormal story? Even a story you think The Mystics will find funny? Email us! @ thegrimmmystics@gmail.com SourcesYouTube Videos Used: Buzzfeed Unsolved , Hailey Reese , Mr. Davis , Mr. Davis' Second VideoThe Westport LibraryUnilaterally Felt Presences Peter Brugger's PatientAbraham Lincoln's Story
Lesley and Amber explore the uncomfortable world of Todd Kohlhepp. His life is full of contradictions and annoying quotes. Come with us as we look into the Amazon Killer!
In this week's episode, Lesley and Amber talk about the murder of Rob Knox. Rob, who played Marcus Belby in the Harry Potter franchise, was one of many victims of knife violence in the UK. The Mystics get all excited they get to talk about Harry Potter and not look like complete nerds... maybe..Follow Us on Social Media!@thegrimmmystics on Facebook and Instagram@thegrimmmysticspod on TikTokDo you have a connection to a true crime case? A personal paranormal story? Even a story you think The Mystics will find funny? Email us! @ thegrimmmystics@gmail.comSourcesListen to True Crime Fix hereListen to Lady Justice hereListen to The Student's Verdict Part One hereThe Rob Knox FoundationThe Guardian article written by Mark TownsendThe Kent Live News article written by Harry Higginson
This week Lesley and Amber finish the trifecta, by discussing a 300 year old werewolf that likes to drink blood.. They'll dive into a case that has young love, myspace, and chat forums. We're getting nostalgic with this one!
This week Lesley and Amber finish the trifecta, by discussing a 300 year old werewolf that likes to drink blood.. They'll dive into a case that has young love, myspace, and chat forums. We're getting nostalgic with this one!
In this week's episode Lesley and Amber talk about the Houses of Evil in Fiji, and the church that brought evangelism to a small village. The Mystics keep it real and get deep and have some thought provoking conversations. Read the Sources from this Episode:https://www.cmfi.org/about-us/who-is-cmf/our-history/https://www.mindat.org/feature-2199821.htmlhttps://fijisun.com.fj/2018/07/14/houses-of-evil-burn/https://www.pressreader.com/fiji/fiji-sun/20180714/282243781365044https://fijisun.com.fj/2018/07/15/police-will-only-probe-if-theres-official-report/Follow us on Social Media!@thegrimmmystics on Facebook and Instagram @thegrimmmysticspod on TikTokDo you have a connection to a true crime? A personal paranormal story? Or just something you think The Mystics will laugh at? Email us! @ thegrimmmystics@gmail.comNext Week's Clue....Vampires and witches and werewolves ... oh my!
So we don't get sued: Worlds Most Evil Killers: Season 4, Episode 8: Richard Trenton Chase.Does anyone read these? Amber and Lesley dive into the icky, gross, dark world of Richard Chase. Trying to get into the mind of this Dick is going to be a wild ride. Join us as we try to forget his story. If you got the the bottom of this leave a witch emoji in the comments on Instagram or Facebook!
This week Lesley and Amber discuss string theory, the number 11, and hippie cults. Don't forget to make a wish!
The Mystics are wishing all of you a Happy Thanksgiving and Native American Heritage Day! However you are celebrating, we hope you and yours have a safe and happy holiday.In this week's episode Lesley and Amber talk about serial killer, Joe Methany aka The Human Hamburger Case. The Mystics have all sorts of opinions and the rants are H E A V Y!Follow Us on Social Media!@thegrimmmystics on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter@thegrimmypodcast on TikTokDo you have a connection with a true crime case? A paranormal story? Or, even a story you think The Mystics will find funny? Email them to us @ thegrimmmystics@gmail.com
Amber and Lesley discuss the interesting life of John Gotti, learning that there are always two sides to every story... and there isn't always a good guy at the end of it.
In this week's episode, Lesley and Amber keep the case local! Lesley tells us about the Loveland Riverhouse Incident. While there wasn't a lot to go off of, The Mystics still manage to find plenty to talk about!
Amber and Lesley discuss which Spice Girl they "used to" dress up as when they were kids. After a few distractions they look into the life and legend of Salvatore "Sammy The Bull" Gravano and the Italian Mob families he spent his time with.
In this week's episode Lesley and Amber talk about the unsolved murder of Jakeob McKnight. This case hits close for The Mystics, and after a double true crime whammy they're feeling it by the end of the episode! If you or anyone you know has information on Jakeob's murder you are urged to contact Crime Stoppers at 720-913-7867 or the Lakewood Police Department. You can also submit tips online. Follow Us on Social Media!@thegrimmmystics on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter@thegrimmmysticspodcast on TikTokDo you have a connection with a true crime case? A paranormal story? Or, even a story you think The Mystics will find funny? Email them to us @ thegrimmmystics@gmail.com
Amber and Lesley dive into the murder of Catherine "Mrs. Cathy" Davis, the problems with the legal system in the US, how much they dislike Scientology and David Miscavige, and their plans for a zombie apocalypse.. The tangents are all over the place with this one!
In this week's episode Lesley and Amber talk about one of the most infamous cryptids...the Skinwalker! The Mystics can manage to make it through most of the episode without scaring themselves. So that's progress, right!?Reddit Stories and Authors:The Mojave Phonebooth posted by u/darthvardaI was in Prison for 15 Years, There was a Skinwalker in There with Us posted by u/InukShakenFollow Us on Social Media!@thegrimmmystics on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter@thegrimmmysticspodcast on TikTokDo you have a connection with a true crime case? A paranormal story? Or, even a story you think The Mystics will find funny? Email them to us @ thegrimmmystics@gmail.com
Blink 182 was about to send out a search party. Lesley and Amber are back, and here to tell you wbout the break they took!
In this week's episode Amber and Lesley talk about the murder of Skylar Neese. The Mystics come to terms that they're obsessed with kid murderers, and this case is no different! Follow Us on Social Media!@thegrimmmystics on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter@thegrimmmysticspodcast on TikTokDo you have a connection with a true crime case? A paranormal story? Or even a story you think The Mystics will find funny? Email them to us! @ thegrimmmystics@gmail.com
In this week's episode, Amber and Lesley wrap up their coverage on the Keddie Cabin Murders. The Mystics dive into the biggest known conspiracies about the case and basically end up solving the whole thing. You're welcome.Follow Us on Social Media!@thegrimmmystics on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter@thegrimmmysticspodcast on TikTokDo you have a personal connection to a true crime case? What about your own paranormal story that you want to share? OR even just a story you think The Mystics will find funny? Email them to us @ thegrimmmystics@gmail.com
✨ disclaimer ✨ We know this audio quality isn't like the rest of our episodes. We were proven once again this week that we are not smarter than technology
In this week's episode, Amber and Lesley talk about Russia's infamous Chessboard Killer Alexander Pichushkin. Of course The Mystics have opinions and feelings on the matter. And somehow decide they want to be flies on a wall in a Russian prison. What do you think?Follow Us on Social Media!@thegrimmmystics on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter@thegrimmmysticspodcast on TikTokDo you have a personal connection to a true crime, a paranormal experience, or a story you think the Mystics will find funny? Email them to us, thegrimmmystics@gmail.com !
In this weeks episode, Amber and Lesley talk about the possession of Elizabeth Knapp - a 16 year old Puritan girl in the 1600's who supposedly is under a demonic possession for three months. Both the Mystics have a pretty good idea to what actually was going on, but like always the ghost in Lesley's house has some opinions on the matter too...Follow Us on Social Media!@thegrimmmystics on Facebook, Instagram & Twitter@thegrimmmysticspodcast on Tiktok
Amber and Lesley talk about the infamous Mary Bell and Norma Bell! While Amber can see the gray spots in this case, Lesley struggles to just see the black and white of a true crime.Follow Us on Social Media!@thegrimmmystics on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter@thegrimmmysticspodcast on TikTok
In the wise words of our girl, Hannah Montana...nobody's perfect. Amber and Lesley unfortunately hit the first snag this week - which means no new episode. Here is a "quick" explanation of what's going on and the plan to move forward.We appreciate the understanding and can't wait to be back next week! We'll spook you then!
Amber and Lesley talk about the infamous Ken and Barbie killers this week. There may be a detour to Justin Trudeau shirtless.... But you'll get a pretty good idea as to how The Mystics feel about Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka.We remember the victims in today's episode who lost their lives.Tammy Homolka, Leslie Mahaffy, Kristen FrenchFollow Us on Social Media! @thegrimmmystics on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter
Tagalong with us while we talk about Samoa true crime cases! Amber and Lesley talk about the case that could have inspired the show, Courage the Cowardly Dog. When a couple from El Paso disappear without a trace the townspeople have A LOT of ideas as to what it could be...Follow Us on Social Media!@thegrimmmystics on Facebook and Instagram
Amber and Lesley talk about the women and their true crime cases that inspired the musical, Chicago! You may think you know the backstories of these characters, but a good old fashioned Nonna might change your mind!We remember the victims who lost their lives in the Boulder Shooting on March 22Denny Stong, Neven Stanisic, Rikki Olds, Tralona Bartkowiak, Suzanne Fountain, Teri Leiker, Eric Talley, Kevin Mahoney, Lynn Murray & Jody WatersIf you are needing support from the trauma caused by gun violence you can visit everytownsupportfund.org or text/call the Colorado Crisis Hotline at, 1-844-493-8255 or text TALK to 38255Follow Us on Social Media!@thegrimmmystics on Facebook and Instagram
Amber and Lesley talk about the homicide of Natalie Mirabal. It takes a second to decide, is the cult like church she is apart of responsible? Or her weird and sketchy husband? The drama seems to never end!
© 2020-2025 Ivy Podcast Discovery LLC
