Supernatural, You're So Stupid

Follow Supernatural, You're So Stupid
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

Two friends re-watch all 15 seasons of Supernatural, we'll review the good, the bad and the, well...stupid. We all love this dumb show let's revel in it together! *Formerly Checking the Rearview*

Sarah and Kiley


    • Apr 12, 2024 LATEST EPISODE
    • monthly NEW EPISODES
    • 58m AVG DURATION
    • 101 EPISODES


    Search for episodes from Supernatural, You're So Stupid with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from Supernatural, You're So Stupid

    Why not just let Dean die?

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 12, 2024 63:37


    We watched The Curious Case of Dean Winchester this week so feel old with me and Sarah! we ask the real questions like why care about secondary characters? Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com Check out our tumblr at spnyoursostupid

    Get this kid a juice box and let him take a nap

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 23, 2024 55:47


    We watched I Believe Kids Are Our Future and then talked about anything but the episode! Check out our tumblr: spnyouresostupid Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com

    House of disorganized wax figures

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2024 67:07


    It's the moment we've all waited for! That's right the Paris Hilton episode! What? is that not what you thought I'd say? We had so much fun with this one! watch season 5's Fallen Idols with us! Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com visit out tumblr spnyouresostupid

    Severe lack of hugs

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 12, 2023 64:55


    We found it the perfect episode! That means the only way to go from here is down! We watched The End this week. Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com Check out our tumblr spnyouresostupid

    Jared's weird shoulder thing

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 27, 2023 65:58


    We are slowly but surely getting into season 5, this time we watched Free to be You and Me and celebrate the destiel aniversary. Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com Check out our tumblr spnyouresostupid

    Do you have the recipe for Bread?

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 3, 2023 66:44


    We watched Good God, Y'all this week and I'm back in Supernatural title hell. Season 5 Episode 2 is full of the end of the world...but like on a budget. Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com visit our tumblr spnyouresostupid

    Sarah Doesn't Know Where Her Ribs Are

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 6, 2023 72:07


    We're back baby! After our long unintentional hiatus we have an extra long episode for the first episode of season 5, Sympathy for the Devil! We had a lot of feelings about this one listen to our (shower) thoughts! Check out our tumblr spnyouresostupid Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com

    Season 4 Post Mortem

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 21, 2023 84:33


    Here it is out final thoughts on season 4!! As you can tell from how we keep talking about Pride Month throughout the episode, we recorded this quite a while ago. Sorry I didn't get to editing until now

    Who Are All These Demons?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 14, 2023 58:53


    We made it! It's time for the finale of Season 4 Lucifer Rising. We thoroughly enjoyed ourselves and feel so accomplished in finally finishing off this season! Drop us a line at: checkingtherearview@gmail.com Check out our tumblr: spnyouresostupid

    Everything I know about Rehab I learned from John Mulaney

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 25, 2023 61:36


    Second to last episode of season 4 When the Levee Breaks, and we are hyped up for the finale!! Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com Check out our tumblr spnyouresostupid

    Are You Talking to God or is it Just Schizophrenia?

    Play Episode Listen Later May 25, 2023 60:11


    We watched The Rapture this week and thanked tptb for Misha! Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com Check out our tumblr spnyouresostupid

    A Cathartic Murder

    Play Episode Listen Later May 4, 2023 75:34


    Hi all! We watched Jump the Shark this week and we loved it! All hail Jake Able! Sorry for the length I didn't feel like editing it down anymore, but it's all good I promise! Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com Visit our tumblr spnyouresostupid

    Catholics Don't Have to Read the Bible

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 20, 2023 61:21


    We watched 'The Monster at the End of This Book' and Grover wasn't even in it once! :( Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com Check out our tumblr spnyouresostupid

    Does He, You Know......Drink Rice Milk?

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 23, 2023 65:38


    We watched It's a Terrible Life this week, and I had some thoughts about Dean Smith...

    I Almost Forgot This Show is Good

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 17, 2023 69:45


    I know I was surprised too! We watched On the Head of a Pin this week and for once we actually stayed on topic! Drop us a line at checkingthrearview@gmail.com Visit our tumblr spnyouresostupid

    Plenty of Time for a Hospital

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 23, 2023 54:48


    We watched Death Takes a Holiday this week, listen to us talk about a whole bunch of stuff that has nothing to do with that! Check out our tumblr spnyouresostupid Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com

    I Can't Hear Over Dean's Siren Being a Big Ol' Dude!

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 9, 2023 61:30


    We watched Sex and Violence this week and it was a good time all around! Sarah and I are also both astounded by the fact that we're still only in season 4. drop us a line at checkingrearview@gmail.com visit our tumblr spnyouresostupid

    High School: Now for 12-24 year olds!

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 20, 2023 63:48


    We watched one of my favorites this week After School Special! Listen to us do some very important math and praise the actors playing young Sam and Dean. Visit our tumblr at: spnyouresostupid Drop us a line at: checkingtherearview@gmail.com

    Spikes of Unknown Origin

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 6, 2023 64:20


    This title is also my new band name lol! We watched Criss Angel is a Douche Bag this week and we had a good time with Mr. Barry Bostwick! Listen to us spend half the time talking about something other than supernatural again. Drop us a line at: checkingtherearview@gmail.com Check out our tumblr: spnyouresostupid

    CSI: This Old House Edition

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 29, 2022 63:15


    We watched the Family Remains this week and it wasn't as bad as I thought it would be. Listen to us reminisce on the 2009 recession. **Warning we do briefly discuss animal cruelty that was in the episode** Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com Visit our tumblr: spnyouresostupid

    Logistics of Car Sex

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 22, 2022 69:59


    We watched Heaven and Hell this week and boy was it better than last week's episode. Listen to our thoughts on the choices that were made over a decade ago lol.  Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com Visit our tumblr at spnyouresostupid 

    I Don't Care What You Did Last Summer

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 16, 2022 40:13


    This week we watched I Know What You Did Last Summer and I can't speak for Sarah but I kinda wish we had been watching the movie instead of this. We had an issue with some lost audio for this episode so apologies this one is short, but brutal. Check out our tumblr spnyouresostupid and drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com

    I Have No Sympathy for Sam Rami's Brother

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 17, 2022 61:41


    We finally come back and audio mites attack! We watched Wishful Thinking this week and talk about it a little bit. I kept in more of our discusion at the top of the episode (that's not about SPN) than I usually would to make up for it! Drop us a line at checkingrearview@gmail.com Visit our tumbr spnyoursostupid Not to do with SPN but I also wanted to add this youtube video https://youtu.be/N6ZhTuhlFtc (so sorry anchor wouldn't let me hyperlink this for some reason) it's Frederic Chen's video on the whole Kit Conner/heartstopper drama and I think it's worth checking out if you want more information.

    Witch Stuff

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 27, 2022 68:31


    We watched It's the Great Pumpkin Charlie Bro...Sam Winchester! lol It was just an ok episode, but we had a great time anyway. Listen too our usual chaos in this spooky episode. Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com Visit our tumblr spnyouresostupid

    Anxiety 101

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 20, 2022 58:27


    We are back with our regularly scheduled programming!! We watched Yellow Fever this week and relived one of Supernatural's most memorable music cues! Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com and visit our tumblr: spnyouresostupid

    More Buzzfeed Quizzes!

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 12, 2022 41:52


    Here is a little mini episode for you, Sarah and I took some more Buzzfeed quizzes and had a blast! Sorry that September was just as much of a wash as August was, real life kind of got in the way, hopefully we can get back to our regularly scheduled program! Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com and visit our tumblr spnyouresostupid

    This is Stupid

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 8, 2022 65:08


    We are back from our unscheduled hiatus with the episode Monster Movie. The best way to jump back in was with a good chuckle! Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com and visit our tumblr spnyouresostupid

    The Real Villain is Cannibalism

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 4, 2022 54:37


    We watch Metamorphosis and it was painful. Listen to us talk about libraries for a long time (because we didn't want to talk about the episode) Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com or visit out tumblr spnyouresostupid.

    Death at the Family Reunion

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 28, 2022 58:41


    We went back in time twice and watched In the Beginning this week! Sarah was shocked even though she swears she's seen this show before lol. Drop us a line at checkingrearview@gmail.com and visit out tumblr spnyouresostupid.

    Angry Ghost Gang

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 21, 2022 63:55


    We watched Are you there God? It's me Dean Winchester, a title so long that I still can't justify why they used it. Listen to us talk about the one good scene! Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com and visit our tumblr spnyouresostupid

    Season 3 Post Mortem

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 13, 2022 70:04


    We have come to the end of Season three (finally)! Hear our thoughts on the season over all and the final ranking of all 16 episodes. We also play everyone's(except Sarah's) favorite game; Does Sarah Remember Supernatural? (No she doesn't lol) Let us know what you think about season 3 at checkingtherearview@gmail.com and check out our tumblr at spnyouresostupid for a full ranking of all three seasons!

    Just Your Average Meet Cute

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 13, 2022 79:11


    It's Season 4 everyone!!!!! We were so excited to watch this one, and we loved it so much that this had to be a supersized episode! So bring on our new favorite Castiel, it's Lazarus Rising! Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com or visit our tumblr spnyouresostupid.

    Care Bear Stare

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 23, 2022 66:46


    We watched the season 3 finale No Rest for the Wicked! A positive note to leave the season on, slightly longer episode as we break down everything that makes it great! Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com and check out our tumblr @ spnyouresostupid.

    What even is plot?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 15, 2022 62:20


    **Trigger Warning** this week we talk about sexual assult** We watched Time is on My Side this week and this may not be a secret but Sarah and I don't really care for horror themes in our horror TV show. Watch us tear apart Sera Gamble's writing yet again! Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com and visit our tumblr spnyouresostupid.

    A Full Can of Soda

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 8, 2022 55:39


    This we we watched Long Distance Call and wish that we had let it go to voicemail. Listen to us try talk about anything but this trash fire episode. Let us know what you think at checkingtherearview@gmail and visit our tumblr at spnyouresostupid at tumblr.

    The Winchesters (aka Jensen's Gamble)

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 6, 2022 13:58


    Giving you a little mini episode before we come back with out regular watch schedule. I made Sarah watch the promo for The Winchesters, the new prequal for Supernatural. Let us know what you thought at checkingtherearview@gmail.com!

    7.6? I've lost all faith in humanity...

    Play Episode Listen Later May 19, 2022 61:38


    This week Sarah and I talk about if binge-watching is a good thing. Oh and we also watched Ghostfacers! It's just as good as we remembered! Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com or check out our tumblr spnyouresostupid/tumblr.com.

    Audible Gasp

    Play Episode Listen Later May 12, 2022 64:24


    There's a reason a Supernatural convention was named after this episode! We watched Jus In Bello and I'm just so happy to have a run of good episodes for a change. Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com or check out our tumblr spnyouresostupid/tumblr.com

    Dramatic Reading of the Credits

    Play Episode Listen Later May 5, 2022 64:04


    It's time for Mystery Spot! The episode that is beloved amongst the SPN family was a good time all around! Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com or check out our tumblr at spnyoursostupid/tumblr.com.

    Dean on Dean Violence

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 20, 2022 57:44


    This week we watched Dream a Little Dream of Me and had a great time! Listen to us talk about anything but Supernatural once again. You can drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com or check out our tumblr at spnyouresostupid/tumblr.com.

    Big Book of Advanced Misogyny

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 7, 2022 60:09


    This week it's Malleus Maleficarum and it's real bad. Join Sarah and I as we discuss witchcraft and why this whole episode didn't need to happen. Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com or visit our tumblr at spnyouresostupid/tumblr.com.

    Stop trying to make Bella happen, she's not going to happen!

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 31, 2022 62:13


    We watched episode 7 of Season 3 Fresh Blood, and it was a mess all around. Join us to watch a sloppy fight scene where Jensen gets punched in the back of the head? Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com or check out our tumblr at spnyoursostupid/tumblr.com.

    The Ghost of Jack Sparrow

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 24, 2022 63:00


    We listened to Season 3's Red Sky at Morning, and it was just okay. Listen to us talk for a long time about how Bella could have been better and how some writers should be allowed to write Dean's dialog anymore. Drop us a line at checkingthereview@gmail.com or find us on tumblr at spnyouresostupid/tumblr.com.

    Checking the Rearview Rebrand!

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 23, 2022 1:05


    Hey all! We have rebranded the podcast! Checking the Rearview is now Supernatural, You're So Stupid! It started out as a joke in one of the podcasts, but Sarah and I both agree that this name is much more accurate to who we are. If you want to visit our tumblr it is now spnyouresostupid/tumblr.com but our email will remain checkingtherearview@gmail.com ... that was a little harder to change. So join us in reveling in this dumb show we all love!

    Astral Projection but Make it Mythical

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 9, 2022 44:08


    We watched Bedtime Stories and it was just ok. Sorry for the short episode this week, this really was...just an episode. Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com.

    This Could Have Been An Email

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 3, 2022 59:11


    Come suffer with us this week friends as we watch Season 3's Sin City. It's a episode where nothing happens and Sarah and I really question what has led us to this. Please drop us a line at checkingthereview@gmail.com or visit us at checkingtherearview/tumblr.com.

    Cobwebs and Bad Ideas

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 25, 2022 62:21


    We watched Bad Day at Black Rock this week and had a lot of opinions. Sarah and don't agree on everything this time around. Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com or visit our tumblr at checkingtherearview/tumblr.com

    Not How 8-Year-Olds Talk

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 17, 2022 59:36


    We watched The Kids Are Alright this week, and we had a good time! Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com or visit our tumblr at checkingtherearview/tumblr.com.

    The Magnificent Dumpster Fire

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 8, 2022 61:37


    We're back for season 3 and we watched The Magnificent Seven. It. Is. Bad. Very really bad. Come suffer with us! Drop us a line at checkingtherearview@gmail.com or visit our tumblr at checkingtherearview/tumblr.com

    Does Sarah Remember Supernatural?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 18, 2022 34:40


    We are taking a little brake, so this is a guessing game I forced Sarah to play! We had a lot of fun doing this see if you can guess along with Sarah

    Season 2 Post Mortem

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 11, 2022 50:13


    We're finally done with season 2! This week we go over our final ratings and discuss what we thought of the season. Checkingtherearview@gmail.com or checkingtherearview/tumblr.com

    Claim Supernatural, You're So Stupid

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel