POPULARITY
Chullin Shiur #39 Daf 9a- Kesher Shel Tefillin, Ikur- Rashi, Tosfos, Rambam
Chullin Shiur #41 Daf 9a- Ikur: Rashi, Tosfos, Rambam, Ramban, Rashba
Tosfos explanation in the Gemarah, and finding where this scenario can occur. Source Sheet: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1YEffhTHdWWkCApO-O0AwhNR5qWyYOnwN/view?usp=share_link
The Masechta opens by listing close relatives with whom yibum is not allowed — including cases of eishes ach (a brother's wife) outside the mitzvah of yibum.This immediately raises the core question: How can yibum ever work? Yibum is, by definition, marrying an eishes ach, which is normally an issur punishable by kares.Tosfos based on Kovetz He'aros 9Yibum works through the rule of aseh docheh lo sa'aseh — a positive mitzvah overriding a prohibition.The issur of eishes ach remains fully in place; it is simply overridden in this scenario.Tosafos asks: If yibum overrides ervah, why not apply it to other forbidden relatives, like a wife's sister?Tosafos answers: Yibum is allowed only because the Torah explicitly commands it. The override applies only here, nowhere else.Yad Ramah's Approach (Sanhedrin 53a):Yibum is not based on aseh docheh lo sa'aseh.Rather, the Torah's prohibition of eishes ach never applied to a case where yibum is possible.The issur applies only when the woman has children and yibum is off the table.Ramban's View (Toras Ha'adam):Agrees with the Yad Ramah.Compares it to a kohen becoming tamei for a mes mitzvah: it's not an exception — that case simply wasn't included in the original prohibition.So too, eishes ach simply doesn't apply in a scenario of yibum.Nafka Minas (Practical Differences Between the Views):Kiddushin with a Yevama:Rashi says kiddushin cannot take effect, because the issur of eishes ach still exists (fits with Tosafos/Rav Elchonon).According to Ramban/Yad Ramah, kiddushin might work, since eishes ach isn't present at all in a yibum case.Yibum for the Wrong Reasons:The Gemara warns it's like living with an ervah.Rambam says it's not actually an ervah at all — once the brother dies, the issur disappears.Rambam fits with Ramban: the issur is simply gone in a yibum case.Tosafos/Rashi fit the stricter language of the Gemara — the issur exists but is overridden.This sugya sets up a major theme of Yevamos:Is yibum an override of eishes ach, or is eishes ach simply not present when the Torah commands yibum?
Tosfos's fundamental concept.Source Sheet: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1FjUJfEldOd9Nyz6FB-aCtbAPTPcZFqGO/view?usp=share_link
The Machlokes of the Rambam against Tosfos and the Ramban.Source Sheet: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1FixTf-62bRrBMnXVWgVJQDeKC2HIZWS0/view?usp=share_link
Gittin Shiur #106 Daf 10b-11a- Mezuyaf Mitocho, Rosh, Tosfos
Gittin Shiur #103 Daf 10b-11a- Mezuyaf Mitocho in Shtar Matanah, Rashi Tosfos
The concept brought in Tosfos that one may be successful doing it with an Issur Kollel.Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah%20pdf/pwaqyu1yihj0jwzom9ft.pdf
Tosfos here says that it will be built by Hashem, a discussion.Source Sheet: https://res.cloudinary.com/ouinternal/image/upload/outorah%20pdf/djmwfret9ag4hjomhw2e.pdf
A few notes: 1) As the Maharsha and others point out, there are in fact many sources that attribute the mitzva of אותו ואת בנו to compassion on the animal. The specific question of Tosfos is that the Kalir instituted it to be said by the שליח ציבור during שמונה עשרה, which is precisely what the Gemara forbids and tells us to silence such a person! 2) Now that we have the full text of the קדושתא, it turns out that מחשבותיך לרחמנו is in fact an entirely unrelated phrase, designed to link the last word of the last pasuk (מאוד עמקו מחשבותיך) to the conclusion of the bracha. 3) Even on Rosh Hashana, we do in fact include מעין החתימה סמוך לחתימה by adding the words מלך עוזר ומושיע ומגן after זכרנו. In its original form though, the מעין החתימה of the Kalir substituted מלך עוזר...
5- Arba Kosos- Tosfos and Rambam (5785)
1- Pesachim 2a- Bedikas Chometz- Rashi, Tosfos (5785)
Gittin Shiur #71 Daf 9b- Ksav Al Gabei Ksav Rambam Tosfos Ramban
Send us a textWhat if the key to unlocking a more profound spiritual connection with Torah study lies in breaking away from traditional methods? Join us as we explore the journey of "floaters," individuals seeking true fulfillment amidst the often rigid frameworks of Daf Yomi, Oiraisa, and Mishnayas. Discover how the teachings of Rashi and the wisdom of this week's parasha offer hope and potential solutions, guiding our search for a study method that truly resonates with the soul.Drawing on Rashi's interpretation of "place these laws in front of them," we challenge the notion of rote memorization and instead advocate for an engaging and comprehensible approach to Torah study. Imagine Torah teachings as a well-prepared meal, inviting and methodically laid out for all to enjoy. Through this lens, we delve into the tradition of interpreting Chazal, emphasizing clarity and depth as the pillars of meaningful learning.Structured and clear Torah study isn't just beneficial—it's transformative. By examining the works of Rashi, Tosfos, and the Rambam, we highlight the joy in grasping complex ideas and the profound connection that comes with true understanding. The discussion underscores the importance of foundational knowledge and a methodical approach, likening it to a perfectly arranged feast that nurtures both the mind and spirit. Let's explore how organizing and personalizing your learning journey can turn Torah study into a deeply enriching experience.Support the showJoin The Motivation Congregation WhatsApp community for daily motivational Torah content!Elevate your impact by becoming a TMC Emerald Donor! Your much-needed backing is crucial for our mission of disseminating the wisdom of the Torah. Join today for just $18.00 per month. (Use your maaser money!) https://buy.stripe.com/00g8xl5IT8dFcKc5ky------------------Check out our other Torah Podcasts and content! SUBSCRIBE to The Motivation Congregation Podcast for daily motivational Mussar! Listen on Spotify or 24six! Find all Torah talks and listen to featured episodes on our website, themotivationcongregation.org Questions or Comments? Please email me @ michaelbrooke97@gmail.com
Gittin Shiur #51 Daf 4a- Machlokes Tosfos and Rif, Machlokes Rav and Shmuel
Gittin Shiur #49 Daf 4a- Tosfos Dekayma Lon
Gittin Shiur #50 Daf 4a- Tosfos Dekayma Lon
Gittin Shiur #47 Daf 4a- Mezuyaf Mitocho, Rashba Rif and Tosfos
Gittin Shiur #45 Daf 3b- Shtar Halva'ah B'eidei Mesirah, Tosfos
Gittin Shiur #38 Daf 3b- Ksav Yado, Rashi Tosfos Ramban Rashba
031 Gittin 4a- Yishuv For Rif From Question Of Tosfos
Gittin Shiur #23 Daf 2b- Eid Echod Neeman B'issurim - Rashi Tosfos Rosh Rif Rambam
Eiruvin #4- Maamid B'S'chach Shitas Tosfos (5785)
Gittin Shiur #11 Daf 2a- Sikum of Tosfos, Ramban, Rashba
Gittin Shiur #9 Daf 2a- Taaninan - Tosfos Gittin and Kesubos
Introduction to debate Chachamim (Rambam, Rif)/Chananya (Rashi, Tosfos) regarding Shehiya/Chazara, S.A. quotes first opinion (Chachamim, Rambam+Rif) and elaborates
Shabbos Shiur #136 Daf 106b- Rambam, Rashi, Tosfos
Shabbos Shiur #129 Daf 106a- Ramban, Baal HaMaor Tosfos
Shabbos Shiur #128 Daf 106a- Melocho Sheaino Tzricho Lgufo and Mekalkel - Tosfos
Shabbos Shiur #127 Daf 106a- Shitas Rashi and Tosfos
Shabbos Shiur #124 Daf 105b- Koreiah b'Chamaso Rambam Rashi Tosfos
HaRav Zvi Einstadter suggests a beautiful original mahalach in explaining the shita of Tosfos who hold that Miriam knew that Hakodosh Boruch Hu told Moshe to be poresh from Tziporah.
Shabbos Shiur #113 Daf 103a- Shelo K'derech, Batloh Daato Tosfos Ritva
Delivered in YGW Motzei Shabbos Vayigash 5784 Shiur is sponsored l'eilu nishmas פעסל בת נחמן And l'refuah sheleimah יהודה אריה בן צירל
Dedication opportunities are available for episodes and series at https://ohr.edu/donate/qa Questions? Comments? podcasts@ohr.edu 00:00 How can one be okay with prayers not being answered? How might one "improve the returns", so to speak? 07:01 Is there a source for souls choosing their parents before birth? 11:47 How can we pray if Hashem won't change His mind? And is it possible for Adam & Eve to be a parable? 24:22 Do we introduce all halachos at once to someone interested in Judaism, or do we withhold some and introduce slowly? 30:42 Is it preferable for the only Levi to quicken his Amidah to wash the cohanim's hands, or to forego washing in favor of a better Amidah? 32:25 How can the Zohar claim that there is no teshuva for zera levatala, whereas the Talmud Yerushalmi says that is true only for bitul Torah? 35:23 Is there a source for Lev Tahor's dress code, and how should we react to it? 38:23 If someone is given an interim set of tefillin by the tefillin repair shop, and he has already paid for his fixed tefillin, what type of shomer is he? 40:46 Do the laws to respect the wishes of the dead apply even to those executed by the court? 42:48 What does Judaism say about alien life or the multiverse? 46:07 Does Korach have a share in the World to Come? 47:59 If one regrets his own purchase, does gam zu letovah apply? 52:15 Why do some wait to repeat Vayechulu with another, if they finished the Shabbat Amidah late, while some don't? 54:08 How should one treat non-Jewish family members by intermarriage? 1:00:25 A person younger than 20 suffers-- is this attributed to future sins, the sins of the parents, or a gilgul? 1:04:28 Where does tikkun klali come from, and are there similar formulas? 1:06:45 What mitzvos can one forego for the sake of kiruv, or to what degree can one sacrifice his own spiritual growth for kiruv? 1:16:05 How many praying people can one walk in front of in order to do a mitzvah? 1:18:41 What is the cause of the rise in divorce rate, and how can one avoid divorce? 1:24:50 How did the Sanhedrin communicate their takanos and gezeiros? 1:27:06 What exactly is the sin of complaining in Chukas? And why should a copper snake be a cure? 1:34:26 Are the rules of saying amen from Berachos still applicable today? 1:35:23 Should a baal teshuva start with new growth or with old regret? What about day-to-day? 1:40:24 Was Tosfos' expectation that we know all of Shas before learning Tosfos? 1:45:17 Are there many references to Bar Kochba in Chazal? Yeshivat Ohr Somayach located in the heart of Jerusalem, is an educational institution for young Jewish English-speaking men. We have a range of classes and programs designed for the intellectually curious and academically inclined - for those with no background in Jewish learning to those who are proficient in Gemara and other original source material. To find the perfect program for you, please visit our website https://ohr.edu/study_in_israel whatsapp us at https://bit.ly/OSREGISTER or call our placement specialist at 1-254-981-0133 today! Subscribe to the Rabbi Breitowitz Q&A Podcast at https://plnk.to/rbq&a Submit questions for the Q&A with Rabbi Breitowitz https://forms.gle/VCZSK3wQJJ4fSd3Q7 Subscribe to our YouTube Channel at https://www.youtube.com/c/OhrSomayach/videos You can listen to this and many other Ohr Somayach programs by downloading our app, on Apple and Google Play, ohr.edu and all major podcast platforms. Visit us @ https://ohr.edu PRODUCED BY: CEDAR MEDIA STUDIOS