Order Up! is a podcast hosted, produced, and created by Matthew Ardill, Cari Haim, Mary Kennedy, and Kelly Zemnickis – four friends who love to talk food. But as much as they love food, they do have some questions. Each episode of the podcast will include special guests and fun questions like, "What's a dish that brings you back to childhood?" but also feature one main question per season. For the first six episodes, they will try to figure out "Is a Hamburger a Sandwich?" with future seasons investigating: "Is Cereal Soup?", "Are Hotdogs Sandwiches?", and "What's Better: Pancakes or Waffles?"
Matt takes the Order Up! Mobile Unit with him on a business trip while Mary and Kelly chat with Sha Rita about the impact of pregnancy on the taste buds and just giving things a try.
Erik Escobar join us and reminds us of the glory of the Jollibee mango pies and got us all hot and bothered for a piece of Tres leches cake.
We enter a state of grace with Grace Fraga who helps us unravel our relationship with cake and pie.
This episode we're joined by the unstoppable Sarah Boston, we dig into who's the funniest, cats or dogs why piecaken is even a thing and a fundamental disagreement about pineapple.
We sit with the hilarious Jason Salmon to talk about the emotional spectrums of cake and pie and how to properly say pecan.
With episode 50 we launch season 9 investigating the hard hitting issues. Friendships are tested and taboos are broken. Sarah Ashby guides us on our inaugrial episode of Cake V. Pie are you ready for the legal drama of the season? It's time for a slice of justice!
We get together to settle the peanut butter controversy once and for all with a wild plot twist!
Here we are, the hard question of if peanut butter is a liquid. We get into the sticky facts and it's a really awesome conversation with improviser, author, and statistician Jeff Rosenthal.
This episode we sit down with Alison Arngrim, stage and screen actor, and writer of Confessions of a Prairie Bitch: How I Survived Nellie Oleson. She gets down to business right out of the gate and goes further than any guest we've ever had before. Sit down and enjoy the show!
Cari brings in her wonderful husband, musician Mark Alexander, to give the lowdown on his feelings about peanut butter.
While Matt is off searching for more epipens Cari, Mary and Kelly are joined by Ava Val! The awesome Ava takes them on a journey of food science and discuses the concussive power of peanut butter.
Celebrity chef Andrew Molen takes time from bringing us delicious dishes and instead brings the facts to this week's Order Up, please refarin from eating your phone during this conversation.
We chat with comedian Desirée Walsh about the wonders of peanut butter and the word viscous gets used by MULTIPLE people. It's that kind of day! Check out this episode of Order Up!
The wait was worth it. Our apologies for our delayed episode, but it's out and ready to rock. We crack open the crackerjack mystery with superfan Esther Serota on our ultimate episode of Order Up! Season 7.
We chat with New York comedian Marcus Monroe, get to the bottom of butter or no butter, and learn of his mastery of the Big Mac Attack.
We chat with the incredible Brian Kiley, a veteran of Conan, Comedy Central, and Dry Bar, as he educates us with all new ways on how to beat the Movie Man at his own game.
Mary, Cari, Kelly, and Matt sit with the awesome New York-based producer Jarel Hill to discuss popcorn, New York cinemas, and the evils of popcorn. That's right, not everyone is a popcorn pal.
KT Zane pops in on us to share their popcorn wisdom and the horrors of Junior Mints. It's a fun episode fighting through technical problems and having a grand old time!
KT Zane pops in on us to share their popcorn wisdom and the horrors of Junior Mints. It's a fun episode fighting through technical problems and having a grand old time!
The Order Up team pop back into action with the question butter or no butter on your popcorn. Our first guest for season 7 is Adam Lieblein. He throws us all for a loop with his mystery topping. Check it out!
We sit with the amazing and talented writer and comedian Vannessa Jackson. We get the dirt on the snack table in the SNL writer's room and get to the bottom of cup or cone.
We sit down with New York based Texan comedian DJ Collins who shares ice cream history as well as the secret of the perfect float.
We sit with the amazing and talented Valerie Landsburg and get her take on cone or cup. Along the way we talk fame, film and fun (as well as the insulating properties of horse hair).
Did you get a chance to go to Tracy Hamilton's album recording? No? Then now's your chance to here her ponder the profundity of frozen treats and rage against Galan Weston's tyranny. Also, has Matthew gone too far? Is he playing God? Only time will tell.
An AI invasion, Tom Carvell takes the mic AND Fishamagigs?! Charlene Ward joins us while Kelly is away and all heck breaks loose!
We chat with the father daughter duo of Rob and Frankie Serra who share their love of ice cream as well as their perfect comedic timing. Find out if they are fans of the cup or the cone on season six of Order Up! If you'd like to learn more about the Ray Pfeifer Foundation, please visit https://theraypfeiferfoundation.org.
We end the season with the amazing comedian Jackie Kashian. You may have seen her on various late night shows, her podcasts The Dork Forest and The Jackie and Laurie Show (with fellow comic Laurie Kilmartin), her multiple albums, or in clubs and festivals around the world. She helps us solve the Soda Conundrum! This episode has the Pepsiman seal of approval.
The order up crew chat with the talented artist Rita Vindedzis and discuss the drink that helps her go.
The order up team chat with Mary's husband Charles Hall, IT specialist, producer and man of mystery. The one person Matt has met who has a soda addiction as strong as his.
The Order Up team (sans Kelly) chat with comedian, writer and performer Crystal Ferrier. It's a fun conversation where Matt gets his mimosas and his samosas confused and we extole the virtues of the Jolibee pineapple pop.
The Order Up team chat with the hilarious George Rivard about soda/pop. We touch on the transformative powers of carrot juice, the existential question that is Diet Doctor Pepper and the coolest pop in town Big K Doctor.
We launch inoto the Soda War with the amazing writer who's work has been seen on Jan, Digstown, Popularity Papers and Shudder's Slasher JP Larocque. JP dives into the deep end with the virtues of Neocitran and thhe disappointment of Ovaltine.
The Order Up crew chat with award-winning novelist and poet Ian Williams. We get his thoughts on pizza, discover his feelings on Pizza Pizza pizza, and even talk a little cereal.
The Order Up crew chat with author of Mothers and Other Strangers Gina Sorell about the nature of pizza, its literary value, and the process of writing a book.
The Order Up crew sit with Cari's friend and amazing film actor Scott Schwartz, seen sticking his tongue to a metal pole in A Christmas Story, palling around with Richard Pryor in The Toy, and most recently tending bar in A Christmas Story Christmas. We hear about his feelings on pizza and his incredible career.
The Order Up team sit down with celebrity chef and awesome guy Chef Joe Gatto to get to the bottom of the pizza debate.
The Order Up crew get creative with producer Jen Pratt the producer of shows including Fire Masters, Great Chocolate Showdown, The Big Bake, and many more. We get into the nitty-gritty of pizza town.
The Order Up team sit down with actor, singer and podcaster (Brentfast with Brent Pope) to discuss the question of the ages. Does pineapple belong on pizza? Please join us for this important discussion.
The Order Up crew sit down with Eric Bauza the owner of Retrokid clothing and voice actor extrordinaire (Bugs Bunny, Daffy Duck, Woody Woodpecker) where we find out what's up with pancakes v waffles.
The Order Up crew chat with filmmaker Cass Gardiner and find out wonderful things to do with soft serve and gluten-free alternatives for the flapjack fan!
The Order Up crew join the inventive Julee Levine, a professional Jewish educator who recently relocated to Memphis, Tennessee after 20 years in Los Angeles, and discuss the wonders of the waffle!
The Order Up team sit down with the awesome New York based comedian Adam Gabel to discuss food, fun and willpower.
The Order Up Squad chat with YouTube and Instagram sensation Scott on Tape about the eternal question pancake or waffle and we get to some deep truths and Mary finds a soul mate. Check his Instagram out or his YouTube channel SCOTTONTAPE today!
Desta Ostapyk an award winning designer who's work has been featured on Love It Or List It sits with Cari, Mary and Kelly to talk about where she lies in the great Pancake v Waffle debate. You can find her on social media on Twitter @destaostapyk and instagram @designbydesta.
The team sits with the amazing Michael Gelman producer of the wonderful Live with Kelly and Mark! We get to hear what gives him the energy to make the magic happen and his feelings about cereal.
Cari, Kelly Mary and Matt chat with the incredible writer, comedian and performer Leonard Chan about the ins and outs of cereal and soup.
We chat with the hilarious Ottawa comedian Simone Holder spilling the secrets around if cereal is soup.
The Order Up crew chats with the hilarious Paul Bates actor, director, and host of the amazing Canadian Podcast Award-winning podcast The Dubious Book of Famous Deeds.
The Order Up crew chat with Rush Kazi, a Toronto-based comedian and hilarious person whose album "About Time" is available online from Howl & Roar Records or at their website rushkazi.com. Their special can be seen on OutTV. Rush passionately shares their opinions about the folly of cereal as soup.
The Order Up team chat with the incredible and funny Karith Foster, opening up season 2 of Order Up! with the topic, "Is Cereal Soup?"
The team chats with sandwich aficionado and tour guide to yummy things in New York (one of the world's yummiest cities), Ben Gollan. More on Ben: https://www.amanandhissandwich.com
© 2020-2025 Ivy Podcast Discovery LLC
