Stuck in Stoneybrook: A Baby-Sitters Club Podcast

Follow Stuck in Stoneybrook: A Baby-Sitters Club Podcast
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

Pop culture, gender politics, and developmental psychology in the “Baby-sitters Club”—you didn’t know you needed it.

Stuck in Stoneybrook


    • May 22, 2025 LATEST EPISODE
    • monthly NEW EPISODES
    • 56m AVG DURATION
    • 145 EPISODES

    4.8 from 152 ratings Listeners of Stuck in Stoneybrook: A Baby-Sitters Club Podcast that love the show mention: bsc, ann m, esme, babysitters club, club books, read these books, adulthood, book series, read the books, martin, candy, lens, academic, nostalgia, teaches, characters, pop culture, happening, grew, modern.


    Ivy Insights

    The Stuck in Stoneybrook: A Baby-Sitters Club Podcast is truly a gem of a podcast that keeps me eagerly awaiting each new episode. As someone who grew up reading the Baby-Sitters Club books, this podcast allows me to relive those nostalgic memories while also gaining new insights and perspectives as an adult reader.

    One of the best aspects of this podcast is the combination of humor and knowledge that the hosts bring to each episode. The discussions are both entertaining and educational, with the hosts offering intelligent analysis and dissection of the books through a modern lens. I appreciate the different areas of expertise that each host brings, adding depth and variety to their discussions. Whether it's exploring themes like feminism and capitalism or delving into the psychology behind the characters, there is always something interesting to learn from this podcast.

    Another great aspect is the camaraderie between the hosts. They have a fantastic rapport that makes you feel like you're sitting in on a lively book club meeting with close friends. Their conversations flow naturally and their banter is both amusing and endearing. It's clear that they genuinely enjoy discussing these books together, which adds an extra layer of enjoyment for listeners.

    One potential downside is that sometimes the audio quality in early episodes can be a bit rough, with instances of talking over each other or echoes. However, this improves as the podcast progresses, so it's not a major issue.

    In conclusion, The Stuck in Stoneybrook: A Baby-Sitters Club Podcast is an absolute delight for fans of the Baby-Sitters Club books or anyone interested in exploring how childhood literature shapes our perspectives. With its mix of nostalgia, humor, and insightful analysis, this podcast offers a unique listening experience that will leave you eagerly anticipating each new episode. It's like joining a fun and engaging book club meeting every week with three intelligent and hilarious friends. Highly recommended!



    Search for episodes from Stuck in Stoneybrook: A Baby-Sitters Club Podcast with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from Stuck in Stoneybrook: A Baby-Sitters Club Podcast

    Super Mystery 1: “A Candelabra”

    Play Episode Listen Later May 22, 2025 54:08


    Portrait Collection: Claudia's Book: “All My Tarps”

    Play Episode Listen Later May 8, 2025 55:44


    WTF Spring Break 2025

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 27, 2025 1:38


    Mary Anne and Camp BSC: “Do Hawks Laugh?”

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 13, 2025 48:32


    Claudia Kishi, Live from WSTO!: “Oswald McBelch” (ft. Rob Harvilla!)

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 27, 2025 84:45


    oswald rob harvilla claudia kishi
    M20-Mary Anne and the Zoo Mystery: “Gorilla My Dreams”

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 13, 2025 45:21


    mystery mary anne gorilla my dreams
    Dawn and the School Spirit War: “Go Back to California, You Weirdo” (ft. Dr. Yoel Inbar!)

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 30, 2025 55:30


    Stacey vs. the BSC: “Miss Your Chips”

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 16, 2025 47:28


    M19 - Kristy and the Missing Fortune: “This is a Stakeout Not a Fashion Show”

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 5, 2024 55:27


    Jessi and the Troublemaker: “Elephantic”

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 14, 2024 49:20


    Kristy and Mr. Mom: “I've Got My Jazzercise Class Tonight”

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 31, 2024 51:41


    M18 - Stacey and the Mystery at the Empty House: “Total Surveillance”

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 17, 2024 43:12


    SS12 - Here Come the Bridesmaids!: “Who Says Santa Can't Be Black?”

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 3, 2024 52:42


    Portrait Collection - Stacy's Book: “The Big Ds”

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 19, 2024 46:21


    Mallory Pike, #1 Fan: “Deflaming Our Characters”

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 5, 2024 59:07


    M17 - Dawn and the Halloween Mystery: “Early American Ninja Turtle”

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 22, 2024 59:08


    Mary Anne Breaks the Rules: “I Need Sackbut Lessons”

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 8, 2024 50:42


    Special Edition Reader's Request: Shannon's Story: “These Moms are Killers”

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 27, 2024 51:01


    Anniversary Super Special 4: “Fruit and Flowers”

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 18, 2024 52:38


    Claudia and Crazy Peaches: “Snort, snort, snort”

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 13, 2024 57:23


    M16 - Claudia and the Clue in the Photograph: “The Scarlet Pimple”

    Play Episode Listen Later May 30, 2024 51:53


    Dawn and Whitney, Friends Forever: “A Smorgaspic!”

    Play Episode Listen Later May 16, 2024 51:53


    SS11 - The Baby-sitters Remember: “Weird and Old”

    Play Episode Listen Later May 2, 2024 51:25


    M15 - Kristy and the Vampires: “Daddy”

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 18, 2024 49:45


    Stacey's Lie: “Are You Stupid?”

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 4, 2024 52:56


    Jessi's Horrible Prank: “Wholesome Foods and Great Literature”

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 21, 2024 54:41


    Stacey and the Mystery at the Mall: “Liberated Doll Family” (ft. Jo Piazza!)

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 7, 2024 58:00


    Kristy and the Copycat: “Pop Up Oreo”

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 22, 2024 48:35


    Mary Anne and Miss Priss: “Peanut Butter Tornado”

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 8, 2024 48:35


    M13 - Mary Anne and the Library Mystery: “King of the Waiters”

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 25, 2024 49:40


    Dawn and the We ❤️ Kids Club: “Carol's Red Miata

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 11, 2024 57:34


    December Notice: We'll BRB!

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 14, 2023 1:08


    Claudia and the Perfect Boy: “Just a Dumb Baby”

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 30, 2023 61:30


    M12 - Dawn and the Surfer Ghost: “Hummingbirds at School!”

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 9, 2023 51:55


    Dawn's back in California, surfing, and SOLVING A MURDER?!? (We can only hope that this series has taken a Law & Order turn.) Thrash's board shows up and he's gone! What are they gonna do? Emily talks about surfers' political work in the eighties and nineties, Esme talks about separation anxiety and sports psychology, and Anne schools us on JAMS! Surf's up, tune in!

    Stacey and the Cheerleaders: “Connecticut Journal of Hair Disorders”

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 26, 2023 64:03


    Did you guys know that Stacey is really gorgeous and has an amazing physique? Well, she does. So both RJ Blaser and Robert Brewster are falling all over themselves for her and she decides to try out for the cheerleading team (and thus, for membership in “The Group”). Esme talks about middle school cliques and their influence and Anne and Emily bring us all kinds of nuggets and analysis about cheerleaders. Rah rah *SIS* boom bah! Get it!?!?

    Get Well Soon, Mallory!: “Head Turkey.”

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 12, 2023 62:10


    Mal is felled by mono! No kissing for this girl, just disease and a forced break from the BSC. We discuss the increased risk of depression with mono, settler colonialism, and the Quiz Show scandal from the 1950s. Who doesn't love Snoopy? Also, this is book SIXTY-NINE. Just sayin'.

    M11-Claudia and the Mystery at the Museum: “Valuable old stuff”

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 28, 2023 54:00


    Claudia is truly living her best life in this one! Meet a famous artist she adores? Check. Attend a fancy museum party in one of Mimi's kimonos? Check. Catch a thief in the process of an actual museum heist? Check! It's a fun romp as the New Museum of Stoneybrook takes the town by storm and our girls (led by Claud of course!) catch the culprit! We spend way too long talking about which baby-sitter is which animal, Anne for some reason knows that koalas get chlamydia (or is it syphilis?) and no one wants to take any Pikes to the mall. Join us!

    Jessi and the Bad Baby-sitter: “One way cool dolphin.”

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 14, 2023 52:38


    Jessi invites Wendy to replace Dawn and she… acts 11? But also just doesn't want to work so hard. Same girl. Anne tells us about another white man who stole some stuff while Emily explains taxation to us (again!). Also, can Anne name 100 candies?

    Dawn's Big Move: “You're Burning the Bok Choy.”

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 31, 2023 59:21


    Dawn is homesick and it's Not. Going. Away. Spoiler: she's leaving for six months. How will the BSC survive? Also, can Stoneybrook beat Lawrenceville in the Run For Your Money? Join us to find out! Emily talks about families again, Esme talks about ambivalence, and Anne FINALLY GETS TO TALK ABOUT TOFU. Another white guys is messing with a culture's food, you guys. ZzzzGrrrZzzz.

    Mystery 10 - Stacey and the Mystery Money: “Land of Total Coolness.”

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 17, 2023 49:38


    Stacey and Charlotte catch a counterfeiter! This is one of the few books Emily remembers from her salad days, leading us to wonder why she did not become a counterfeiter. We go over some familiar BSC content in this one— moving, incompetence of police, the carceral state, you get it. Also, lots of candy and a cute boy! Thank goodness floppy hair is finally returning to culture.

    Maid Mary Anne: “Vidding Out”

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 3, 2023 48:00


    LOW-KEY ALERT! This episode includes a spoiler about “The Good Place!” OK, where we were? Ah, yes. Mary Anne gets deep into sewing and needlework and starts a sewing club for kids. It's hard to believe she has time for this given how much work she's doing for poor Mrs. Towne. It almost seems like Moral OCD to Esme, so we talk about that! Emily talks about sissies for a bit and Anne has a bunch of nuggets, including renaming “California Girls.” Also, a BSC Big 5!

    Logan Bruno, Boy Baby-sitter: “Squank!”

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 20, 2023 62:00


    Wow, Logan is… in trouble with a gang of 1950s toughs? In 1993, in Stoneybrook? Follow along as we watch him be an accessory to many crimes. Emily covers typologies of masculinity while Esme tries to learn what we know about shoplifting (in an academic sense). Anne just wants this whole book to be a musical (honestly, it should be). At any rate, we all need nicknames now. Like the Badd Boyz.

    SS10 - Sea City, Here We Come!: “The Old Gather and Slather!”

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 6, 2023 57:35


    It's back to Sea City! For the whole BSC! But… not until 122 pages in. Also, there's a Hurricane. We discuss preparing kids for disaster, whether or not Logan is actually… evolving? And why Ann M. Martin keeps referencing the same 6 texts. Also, the climax of the book comes on page 3: what is superior, Heath or Skor? Listen to find out!!

    Anniversary Super Special 3: "(Fruit) Leather.”

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 18, 2023 52:46


    It's been three years since we took an idle conversational joke and turned it into a podcast! Join us a we play some games (and successfully stump each other), reflect on what the BSC and the podcast have meant to us, and finally answer whether Ted Lasso is really a Kristy or not. Thank you, listeners! We love you!!!

    Summer Break: We're All On Vacation

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 8, 2023 0:50


    GONE FISHIN'. (Well, not really FISHING, but you know what we mean.)

    Mystery 9 - Kristy and the Haunted Mansion: “This room is boring.”

    Play Episode Listen Later May 25, 2023 49:16


    Kristy goes from mansion to mansion as the Krashers get stranded in a big storm that washes out BOTH THE BRIDGES to the old Sawyer place. We discuss whether the daring Dorothy Sawyer really may have had other options, play some get to know you games to make our team stronger, and sing the praises of Charlie's big brotherness. Two pizzas isn't enough, y'all.

    Stacey's Big Crush: “Toyotas are my Favorite Car.”

    Play Episode Listen Later May 11, 2023 57:02


    Stacey falls in LUV with one Mr. Wesley Ellenburg, the Tom Cruisiest student teacher to ever grace SMS. Charlotte crushes on Bruce Cominsky and then gives him the brushoff but also? There's a baby goat. And in case you're unclear, she is CUTE. Esme discusses the psych literature on crushes (and says “fondle” too many times for anyone's liking) and Anne and Emily have a surfeit of delicious pop culture and feminist nuggets (but none as delicious as “all-natural crispy rancho-style veggie rice nuggets with nacho substitute cheese-food flavor”).

    Dawn's Family Feud: “Go Ahead, Be Antisocial.”

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 27, 2023 48:39


    We are on the road with the Spier-Schafers! Sharon and Richard are not equipped and Esme tells us why. Emily wonders what this book (with clear Boston Tourism spon con) would be like if it was written now with, um, ANY acknowledgement of non-white people. And Anne had a whole pack of nuggets! It's a 20 piece! Listen in and say a prayer for Marshall Gaines, family photographer.

    Mystery 8 - Jessi and the Jewel Thieves: “Girls, Rum, Mangos, and Papayas”

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 13, 2023 54:06


    Is this book is about crime? It is not. It's about NYC glamour! It's about dancing! It's about the Palm Court and Zabar's! Emily and Anne have lots of nuggets, and Esme makes them take a Dating Questionnaire for their eleven year old selves. Also, are any actors good? Emily is suspicious. Tune in and find out!

    Ann M. Martin Bio: “Museum of dead stuffed things.”(ft. Dayna Crandall)

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 30, 2023 62:38


    Emily's mom (and Esme's sister) is in town just in time for the publication of this banger by the mysterious Margot Becker R. We discuss Dayna's boomer childhood compared to Ann's boomer childhood, plus what we think was left out of the story when Scholastic pushed this to market in 1993 (and why Dayna's current students that love the BSC wouldn't love this book). Hard work gets you everywhere, people! Plus lots of nuggets including the original Pikes (and Emily MISSED IT).

    Claudia's F̶r̶e̶i̶n̶d̶ Friend: “A Little Tutor Murder, Frankly”

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 16, 2023 57:56


    Have we mentioned lately that we think Claudia has ADHD? In this book we learn that she doesn't have dyslexia, but Shea Rodowsky does. Of course, this is an opportunity for Esme to talk about validation and dialectics, Emily to talk about fictional and proposed “fashion czars/tsars,” and Anne to have a nugget fest, from Whoopee cushions to Jordan Catalano! Join us, won't you?

    Claim Stuck in Stoneybrook: A Baby-Sitters Club Podcast

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel