I Got Your 5 Stars

Follow I Got Your 5 Stars
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

Long-time wrestling fan Jeremy (AKA Professor J) tackles the Indies! I provide in-depth review and analysis of some of the best shows and individual talents on the Indies today, as well as cool interviews with Indy bookers, wrestlers, referees, and more.Support Independent Pro Wrestling!RIP Whackpac…

Jeremy Nickerson


    • May 19, 2022 LATEST EPISODE
    • weekly NEW EPISODES
    • 1h 13m AVG DURATION
    • 261 EPISODES


    Search for episodes from I Got Your 5 Stars with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from I Got Your 5 Stars

    Here Comes "The Ubermensch" Nate Matthews!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later May 19, 2022 59:58


    **Originally aired Sept. 29, 2021 Sean & Jeremy chat with "The Ubermensch" Nate Matthews about New Wave Pro, wrestling Eric Dillinger, fighting for retweets from Omega & Seinfeld, and so much more!!

    It's NOT 'Goodbye' ... It's "See You Later"

    Play Episode Listen Later May 13, 2022 30:58


    Jeremy and Sean say "See You Later" ... but not before we talk about Sean's big summer, our Scenic City vacation, and so much more.

    "Time to do some gangster sh*t" ... with the "Public Enemy" Eric Dillinger!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later May 9, 2022 57:56


    **Originally aired Sept. 25, 2021 Tonight, Prof. J & Referee Sean P. chop it up with rising star Eric Dillinger!! We talk about this weekend's New Wave Pro show, training with Billy Roc, some of his biggest matches so far, IWA-MS, AWR, and more!!!

    Everybody's Gonna Leave Their Seat ... at Harpo's!

    Play Episode Listen Later May 6, 2022 64:52


    Jeremy & Sean kick it with Chris Kohlenberg, owner of Ruthless Pro Wrestling. Together, we get ready for this weekend's huge RPW show at Harpo's in Detroit!

    No Other Place I Want to Be ... West Terre Haute!

    Play Episode Listen Later May 4, 2022 107:22


    Sean & Jeremy bring in "Senior Official" Aaron Grider to help us get pumped for this weekend's STACKED "Right Here, Right Now" show from New Wave Pro!

    Flashing Before Our Eyes

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 27, 2022 95:43


    Tonight, Sean & Jeremy review Unsanctioned Pro's "No One Should Watch This" show. (spoiler alert: EVERYONE should watch that show!)

    "Deathwish" Anakin Murphy!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 21, 2022 60:58


    Tonight, Sean and Jeremy talk to rising independent star "Deathwish" Anakin Murphy! We discuss his career path, from referee to main event star.

    High Voltage!!!! Referee Kat joins the show.

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 19, 2022 59:51


    Jeremy & Sean interview The High Voltage Ref Kat about her journey in and around the squared circle.

    Time to Turn Up ... with ZDP!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 15, 2022 60:51


    Tonight, Jeremy & Sean bring in ZDP to talk about his training at Grindhouse, making noise at New Wave Pro with Dude Baddington, IWA-MS, and so much more!!

    Return of the NWP Roundtable!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 8, 2022 144:51


    Tonight, the NWP roundtable returns!! Sean & Jeremy join forces with NWP Senior Official Aaron Grider, and The Mad Scientist of NWP Earl Joseph!!! We review/recap the show in Paris, and look ahead to this weekend's "Talk of the Town" show in West Terre Haute.

    The BAMF is BACK: A conversation with TANK!!!!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 1, 2022 73:42


    Tonight, Sean & Jeremy chat with TANK ... about his career renaissance, ICW No Holds Barred, The Rev, and so much more!

    Scenic City Violence: Part 2

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 29, 2022 82:43


    Sean and Jeremy are back to review ICW: No Holds Barred 23 from Chattanooga!!!

    Sean's Big Weekend in Indianapolis!

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 27, 2022 112:37


    **Originally aired July 20, 2021 Tonight, Prof. J & Referee Sean P. recap Sean's huge weekend in Indianapolis, including: -Two midnight Paradigm shows -Asylum's two-day Deathmatch tournament -Two huge shows from ICW: No Holds Barred

    "Life's A Mitch ... ": This is Mitch Vallen!!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 27, 2022 102:24


    **Originally aired July 17, 2021 Tonight, Ref. Sean P. and Prof. J have a conversation with Mitch Vallen!!!! Topics include: -Training with Tommy Dreamer -The road to CZW -Meeting Matt Tremont -H20 & The 44OH! takeover -Thoughts and memories of his ICW debut -"Don't be a Malaka!!"... and more!

    Scenic City Violence: Part One

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 23, 2022 95:58


    Tonight, Sean & Jeremy provide an in-depth review of ICW's Pitfighter X10 show from Chattanooga, TN!!!

    Anarchy!!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 20, 2022 115:44


    The Boys are BACK!!! We get with THE Senior Official Aaron Grider to review St. Louis Anarchy's "Motivation" show!

    A Deep Dish Dive Into ICW: NHB 22

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 16, 2022 157:40


    SPO & Jeremy rap with The Struggles about all the happenings, in and out of the ring, during ICW's Chicago show!

    Big Boy S**t: This is "The Head of the Pack" Lobo Okami!

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 10, 2022 52:14


    Sean & Jeremy interview rising star Lobo Okami! We discuss his training at the Grindhouse, New Wave Pro, Paradigm, and so much more.

    Let's Light It Up ... with Landon Hale!!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 5, 2022 80:02


    Landon Hale joins Jeremy & Sean to talk about his career: past, present, and future!! He discusses training with Robert Gibson, wrestling at the 2021 Futures tournament in Chattanooga, earning his spot at Paradigm, and so much more.

    The Voice of New Wave Pro .... Robert Black!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 2, 2022 97:02


    Tonight, we're marching ahead to November Reign, and we talk to one of the best play-by-play men on the indies Robert Black!!!! Hear about his theatre background, his love for pro wrestling, and his role as the Voice of New Wave Pro!!!! *Originally aired 11/22/2021

    The CHAMPS are here: New Wave Pro Tag Team Champions ... The Von Engelands!!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 2, 2022 65:13


    Tonight, Prof J and Referee Sean P. continue our march to November Reign. This time, we talk with the New Wave Tag Team champions The Von Engelands!!! We talk about their transition from the UK to the Midwest, Paradigm Pro, and holding tag team gold!!! *Originally aired 11/25/2021

    Coming Soon to America ... International Deathmatch Star "The Smash Hit" Joel Bateman!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 23, 2022 113:15


    Tonight, Sean and Jeremy talk with an amazing guest. Australian Deathmatch star Joel Bateman is here to talk about his upcoming US dates, the Australian Deathmatch scene, and show off his encyclopedic knowledge of the US Independents!!!!

    The Freebird Rule

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 20, 2022 141:43


    I Got Your 5 Stars joins forces with Faces & Feels to review RPW's "Cold Blooded" event from Maybee, MI!!

    Representing Detroit, Michigan ... This is Isaiah Broner!!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 18, 2022 60:30


    Tonight, Prof. J & Ref. Sean P. interview a true Heavy Hitter ... Detroit's own Isaiah Broner!!! We talk about his debut in The Pit, joining DTA, the Detroit wrestling scene, Paradigm Pro, and so much more!!! *Originally aired Oct. 15, 2021

    HUZZAH!!! Get ready for "Sir Knight" Merrik Donovan!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 18, 2022 63:43


    **Originally aired Nov. 2, 2021 Tonight, Jeremy & Sean talk with "Sir Knight" Merrik Donovan!!! Topics include: -Debuting for Paradigm and Unsanctioned -Training with Team 3D -There's no C in Merrik!!! -ACTION Futures Showcase 2021 -About to get Medieval ...... and more!

    Just Like Old Times

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 15, 2022 134:51


    Tonight, Jeremy & Sean review Paradigm's "Rhymes Like Dimes" show from The Arena in Jeffersonville, IN!!

    Where in the World is AJ Kissinger?

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 9, 2022 107:00


    Tonight, Jeremy & Sean catch up with the Referee f/k/a Max Recon!! He's been putting miles on the car for GCW, and he tells us all about it. Plus, we recap Unsanctioned Pro's "Royal Flush" from the Valley Dale Ballroom in Columbus!!

    Recapping New Wave Pro's Tenth Anniversary Show ... with Senior Official Aaron Grider!

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2022 91:16


    Tonight, Sean & Jeremy team up with NWP's Senior Official Aaron Grider to recap the Anniversary X show!!!

    Mama, ICW's Coming Home ...

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 2, 2022 161:09


    Tonight, Jeremy & Sean are joined by "The Voice of the Violence" The Struggles to recap ICW's return home -- back to the North Jersey/NYC area for NHB '21!

    Kickin' It With a Blue Chipper: This Is KARAM!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 31, 2022 56:03


    On tonight's episode, Sean & Jeremy talk with rising star KARAM about his beginnings in the sport, winning the FIP title, making waves in AAW, Glory Pro, and so much more! **Episode first aired on 12/15/2021

    The Creator of "This is Deathmatch" .. Christopher Macias!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 31, 2022 59:45


    Tonight. Jeremy and Sean chat with documentary filmmaker Christopher Macias about his "This is Deathmatch" series on IWTV!!! **This episode originally aired on Dec. 18, 2021

    Travelin' Men

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 28, 2022 80:45


    Tonight, Jeremy and Sean chat about their recent travels for wrestling shows!! We talk about our experience in Columbus for Unsanctioned Pro, New Wave Pro's Anniversary show, ICW in Newark, and so much more.

    New Wave Pro: Anniversary Panel!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 20, 2022 134:22


    Tonight, me and Sean team up with NWP Senior Official Aaron Grider, and NWP's "Evil Genius" Earl Joseph to prepare for this weekend's huge Anniversary show in West Terre Haute!!!

    "Tennessee Sunshine" Billy Tipton!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 19, 2022 59:41


    Tonight, Billy Tipton brings some of that good old "Tennessee Sunshine" to the podcast. Billy chats with Sean & Jeremy about JPWA, IWA-MS, On Point Wrestling, and more!!! *Originally aired 12/24/2021

    Sean & Jeremy's (long overdue) ETU Review!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 19, 2022 144:42


    Tonight, Prof J & Referee SPO break down the debut show from Expect the Unexpected!!! **Originally aired Dec. 28, 2021

    "Heavyweight Hustle" Calvin Tankman!!!!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 15, 2022 78:46


    Tonight, Sean & Jeremy talk with a legit superstar. It's the "Indestructible" Calvin Tankman!!! We talk about his amazing career to date, including getting his feet under him at IWA-MS, MLW, wrestling Minoru Suzuki, this weekend's big Unsanctioned Pro show, and so much more!

    Representing "Cincinnati's Most Wanted": This is Lexus Montez!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 12, 2022 51:40


    Sean & Jeremy welcome Lexus Montez back to the podcast to talk about this weekend's huge Unsanctioned Pro show in Columbus, joining CMW, working in the six-sided ring at EWE, Roger Ruffen ... and so much more!

    Next Man Up on the Deathmatch Scene: "The Carnivore" Remington Rhor!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 12, 2022 76:57


    Sean and Jeremy talk with rising star Remington Rhor about his matches with Madman Pondo, Mickie Knuckles, making it to the finals of the AWR tournament, his band "Fossilized", and so much more! *Originally aired July 24, 2021

    Tonight's Guest is Seeking Human Victims ... It's THE REV!!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 12, 2022 65:57


    Hear me and Sean mark out at the haunting vocal tones of the Reverend Dan Wilson!!!! We talk with him about his current run with "The Bloodbath Behemoth" TANK, ICW, NWA Wildside days, and so much more!!! *Originally aired July 14, 2021

    "Cosmic Christmas" review ... with Billie Starkz!!!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 7, 2022 78:50


    Sean and Jeremy team up with "Space Jesus" herself to review "The 17th Coming of Billie Starkz: Cosmic Christmas"!! We also talk about her amazing career ... Past, Present, and Future; her thoughts on some of her huge matches, and so much more.

    Recapping KOBK's "Souled Out" ... with Mose!!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 30, 2021 124:35


    Sean and Jeremy bring on Mose to share thoughts on KOBK's "Souled Out" show in Chattanooga!!

    Sean & Jeremy's (long overdue) ETU Review!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 29, 2021 144:42


    Tonight, Prof J & Referee SPO break down the debut show from Expect the Unexpected!!!

    Sean & Jeremy's (long overdue) ETU Review!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 28, 2021 144:42


    Tonight, Prof J & Referee SPO break down the debut show from Expect the Unexpected!!!

    "Tennessee Sunshine" Billy Tipton!!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 24, 2021 59:41


    Tonight, Billy Tipton brings some of that good old "Tennessee Sunshine" to the podcast.Billy chats with Sean & Jeremy about JPWA, IWA-MS, On Point Wrestling, and more!!!

    The Creator of "This is Deathmatch" .. Christopher Macias!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 18, 2021 59:45


    Tonight. Jeremy and Sean chat with documentary filmmaker Christopher Macias about his "This is Deathmatch" series on IWTV!!!

    Kickin' It With a Blue Chipper: This Is KARAM!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 15, 2021 56:03


    On tonight's episode, Sean & Jeremy talk with rising star KARAM about his beginnings in the sport, winning the FIP title, making waves in AAW, Glory Pro, and so much more!

    Closing the Loop on the Biggest Show of the Year: New Wave Pro's "November Reign"!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 9, 2021 114:56


    Prof. J & The Zebros are back ... this time to review one of the most anticipated shows in a very long time. And it delivered ... BIG!! Hear me, Sean, and Aaron give our thoughts on each big match from "November Reign"!!

    "The PERM-inator" Sam Beale!!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 6, 2021 69:00


    On tonight's episode, we talk with IMPACT star Sam Beale about his run through the indies, rocking the perm, being on TV, and so much more! 

    No Holds Barred in the Scenic City!!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 2, 2021 117:50


    Tonight, Ref. Sean and Prof. J recap ICW's monster weekend in Chattanooga!!!

    The KING of New Wave Pro ... "The Samoan Hellraiser" Solomon Tupu!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 26, 2021 47:18


    Tonight, we cap off our journey to "November Reign." This time, with the man who has held the big gold belt for over a year. Solomon Tupu talks about his big defenses in New Wave Pro, training with Seth Rollins, wrestling in Chattanooga, and so much more!!

    The CHAMPS are here: New Wave Pro Tag Team Champions ... The Von Engelands!!!!!

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 25, 2021 65:13


    Tonight, Prof J and Referee Sean P. continue our march to November Reign. This time, we talk with the New Wave Tag Team champions The Von Engelands!!! We talk about their transition from the UK to the Midwest, Paradigm Pro, and holding tag team gold!!!

    Claim I Got Your 5 Stars

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel