Try Trial Again

Follow Try Trial Again
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

Try Trial Again re-argues controversial court cases for our guest jury of one, and covers developments outside the courtroom that might have impacted the verdict.

Try Trial Again


    • May 24, 2022 LATEST EPISODE
    • weekly NEW EPISODES
    • 1h 6m AVG DURATION
    • 116 EPISODES

    5 from 38 ratings Listeners of Try Trial Again that love the show mention: law, crime, smart, funny, interesting.



    Search for episodes from Try Trial Again with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from Try Trial Again

    100. Busload of Firemen

    Play Episode Listen Later May 24, 2022 73:05


    WE HAVE A BIG ANNOUNCEMENT! And a big case! In 1922, Edward Hall, a New Jersey minister, was murdered along with his girlfriend Eleanor Mills, a singer in the church choir. Both were married to other people at the time. Was Edward's jealous wife responsible for the killings? We argue the Hall-Mills murder case with Christine Woodward and Michele Lee!  

    99. Hobby First

    Play Episode Listen Later May 17, 2022 73:12


    Did Dr. Sam Sheppard kills his wife Marilyn to be with another woman, or was he accused of a murder he didn't commit? We argue the case that (might have) inspired The Fugative with Jessica Barth. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram for episode pics and more!

    Re-Release: Drag Queen and a Drug Problem

    Play Episode Listen Later May 10, 2022 70:19


    We're rereleasing a TTA classic this week! In 1974, auto executive Liz Carmichael claimed she'd invented a three-wheeled car called The Dale, which would get 70 miles per gallon. After raising over $3 million in investments and pre-orders though, she never built it. Was she a dreamer or fraudster? We argue the case with Sean Roschman.

    Re-Release: Zero Growth Mindset

    Play Episode Listen Later May 3, 2022 61:49


    We're re-releasing one of our wildest cases this week about the murder of Missouri fraudster Dee Dee Blanchard. 

    98. It's Gorgeous

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 26, 2022 75:40


    We're back with a brand-new case! Was 2-year-old Caylee Anthony's death an accident or a murder? We cover the Casey Anthony trial with Julia Harrah. Follow @TryTrialAgain on instagram for eispode pictures and more!

    Re-release: Woke Date Night

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 19, 2022 80:16


    We'll be back with a new case next week! In the meantime, we're re-releasing one of our favorite episodes - Woke Date Night, about the case that inspired Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil.

    Re-release: Reasonable Dithering

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 12, 2022 78:41


    We're re-relesing one of our favorite episodes this week - a case helped turn Dorian on to true crime! Here's episode 39 on Audrey Marie Hilley!

    Re-release: You Had Me at Collar Bomb

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 5, 2022 77:37


    We're re-releasing one of our favorite episodes this week: You Had Me at Collar Bomb about the Margorie Diehl-Armstrong case! 

    CPR Looks - with Updates!

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 29, 2022 70:32


    We have news about the Robert Neulander case! Check out our re-release of episode 38 and stick around after the show for updates!

    Celebration of Pettiness - with Updates!

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 22, 2022 66:51


    We've got updates on the Martin Shkreli case! Check out the re-release of our episode on his first trial, and stick around after the show to hear about his latest brush with the law!

    Vegas is Out There - with Updates!

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 15, 2022 70:33


    We're off this week, so we're re-releasing our episode on the Jussie Smollett case. Stick around after the show for updates! 

    97. Her Own Gravity

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 8, 2022 65:03


    Faylene Grant survived a 60-foot fall in September 2001 and drowned in her bathtub less than a week later. Was her death an accident, a suicide, or a murder? We argue the case with Rosalyn Luna.  Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram for episode pictures and more!

    96. Paralysis of Morality

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 1, 2022 67:59


    Was Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes a fraudster or an entrepreneur? We argue the case with Aimee Morris and John O'Donnell. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram for episode pictures and more!

    95. Lotta Nuance

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 22, 2022 62:46


    THIS ONE HAS A BOMBSHELL ENDING Y'ALL. Did Crystal Mangum stab and kill her boyfriend Reggie Daye in self-defense, or was it murder? We argue the case with Kit So. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, or Facebook for episode pictures and more!

    94. It Takes All Kinds

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 15, 2022 67:27


    South African sprinter Oscar Pistorius shot and killed his girlfiend Reeva Steenkamp on Valentine's Day, 2013. Was it an accident or a murder? We argue the case. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram for episode pictures and more!

    93. Angry Neighbors Everywhere

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 8, 2022 61:49


    Did Robert Durst shoot and kill his neighbor Morris Black in self-defense, or murder him to keep a secret? We argue the case with Carrie Faverty. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram for episode pictures and more!

    92. Disgruntled Crow

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 1, 2022 65:45


    Happy Black History Month, everybody! We're kicking it off with a case involving one of the most famous social justice activists in American history. Did Angela Davis help plan a 1970 prison-break scheme that resulted in the deaths of four people? We argue the case Kimberly Anderson. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram for episode pictures and more!

    91. Heinous Fashions

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 25, 2022 53:54


    Did Dolores Vasquez kill Rocio Wanninkhof, the daughter of her former lover, as revenge for their breakup? We argue one of Spain's most famous cases with Kyla Evans. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram for episode pictures and more!

    90. Vegas is Out There

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 18, 2022 66:01


    Did actor Jussie Smollett fake an attack on himself for publicity, or was he the victim of a real hate crime? We argue the case with Robyn Tretter. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for episode pictures and more!

    89. Never Go Toward Psoriasis

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 11, 2022 69:11


    We're back with a case ripped from the headlines! Anthony Broadwater was convicted of raping college student Alice Sebold in 1982. Was he really guilty though? We argue the case with Jason Meyers. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook!

    HAPPY NEW YEAR! Q&A Special

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 4, 2022 21:39


    Happy New Year, everybody! We'll be back with regular episodes next week, but we thought we'd start off the year by answering some of your questions about the show! It's our TTA Q&A Special!

    Re-release: DIY Murder

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 28, 2021 75:37


    We're wrapping up the year with a TTA classic! Did Betty Wilson and her twin sister hire a hitman to kill her husband Jack? We argue Alabama's "twin murder" with Jenny Starkey. 

    The Terror was Real - with Updates!

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 21, 2021 71:47


    Did Oklahoma zookeeper Joe Exotic hire a hitman to kill animal rights activist Carole Baskin? We're back with updates on the Tiger King case! 

    Get This Woman a Hobby - with Updates!

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 14, 2021 57:05


    We have updates on another TTA classic this week - episode 12 on Russ Faria's trial for the murder of his wife Betsy. Stick around after the show for some news about Pam Hupp!

    What a Happy Ending- with Updates!

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 7, 2021 63:03


    Hey everybody! Thank you so much for making November our biggest month yet! We're off this month, but we're not leaving you without your true crime fix! We're re-releasing four episodes with updates, starting with this one on the Brandi Levy case. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook for episode pictures and more. We'll see ya with brand-new shows in January!

    88. Well of Eternal Crime

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 30, 2021 56:34


    Texas businessman Bill Mowbray died from a gunshot wound while he was in bed with his wife Susie. Did she kill him or did he kill himself? We argue the case with Tina Kit. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for episode pictures and more!

    87. Football Curious

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 23, 2021 70:15


    Did Shane Ragland, a student at the University of Kentucky, shoot and kill his classmate Trent DiGiuro for getting him blacklisted from a college fraternity? We argue the case with Jenny Brown. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook for episode pictures and more. 

    86. Ruh-Roh Moments

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 16, 2021 65:40


    Did Exondia Salado kill her husband for cheating on her? Or did he leave to start a new life with a new identity? We argue a "no body" case with Jen Zellers. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for episode pictures and more. 

    85. Zero Growth Mindset

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 9, 2021 61:13


    Dee Dee Blanchard forced her daughter Gypsy to pretend she was quadriplegic as part of a scheme to cheat charities out of money. And that's only the backstory! We argue one of Missouri's wildest cases with Selma Avdagic. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for episode pictures and more. 

    84. Ambient Noise

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 2, 2021 52:44


    Did TV talk show host Oprah Winfrey tank the Texas cattle market with fake news about American beef, or was a Mad Cow outbreak to blame? We argue the case with Kerri Rawson. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook for episode pictures and more! 

    83. Oh, It's a Last Name

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 26, 2021 70:50


    15-year-old Martha Moxley was murdered outside her home in Greenwich, Connecticut on October 30, 1975. Was her neighbor Michael Skakel the killer? We argue the case with Liz Gonzales. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for episode pictures and more. 

    82. Nature's Medicine

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 19, 2021 66:07


    In 1611, Countess Elizabeth Bathory was accused of kidnapping and killing hundreds of girls from all over Hungary. Were her servants accomplices in the murders or victims of the countess themselves? We argue the case with Karisa Gilman Hernandez. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram for episode pictures and more!

    81. Gonna End Up Being Shade

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 12, 2021 62:25


    Did Cassandra Peterson rip off Maila Nurmi's Vampira character to create Elvira, Mistress of the Dark? We argue the case with Rosenellie Bayron! Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook for episode pictures are more!

    80. Three Beasts and a Waterbed

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 5, 2021 71:45


    Arne Johnson stabbed his landlord Alan Bono to death in 1981. What prompted the murder - a fight over Arne's girlfriend or...demonic possession? We argue the "Devil Made Me Do It" case with Michele and Barb Dumoulin on the first of four Halloween shows! Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook!

    79. The Toolbox Theory

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 28, 2021 65:24


    Did Leigh Stubbs and a friend assault Kim Williams during a Mississippi road trip? We argue the case with Kaitlin Petersen. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for episode pictures and more. 

    78. A Guy and His Aunt

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 21, 2021 74:08


    Misha Defonseca wrote a best-selling memoir about her Holocaust survival story. Did her publisher Jane Daniel cheat her out of the profits? Or did Misha con Jane? We argue the case with Catherine Hoyt. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for episode pictures and more.

    77. Emperor's New Clothes Situation

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 14, 2021 68:20


    Gucci CEO Domenico De Sole paid $8 million for a painting he thought was the work of a famous abstract impressionist. When it was exposed as a forgery, he sued art dealer Ann Freedman for fraud. Did she know it was fake when she sold it to him? We argue the case with Hyo Jeung. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for episode pictures and more!

    76. A Thing Called Tapes

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 7, 2021 69:17


    In February 1974, a group of San Francisco radicals kidnapped newspaper heiress Patty Hearst. Two months later, she helped them rob a bank. Was she victim of brainwashing, or a willing participant? We argue the case with Natalia Harasymowicz. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook. 

    Re-release: Madam Mirrorball

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 31, 2021 51:52


    We're off this week, so we're re-upping a TTA classic - episode 4: Madam Mirrorball with Carrie Faverty! 

    75. Always Better on Time

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 24, 2021 77:58


    Curtis Flowers was tried six times for murders at a Mississippi furniture store. Was he the killer though? We argue the case with David May. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook. 

    74. The Terror Was Real

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 17, 2021 67:39


    Did Oklahoma zookeeper Joe Exotic hire a hitman to kill animal rights activist Carole Baskin? We argue the Tiger King case with Felipe Figueroa. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook.

    73. Rug Sales

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 10, 2021 66:50


    Did Larry Griffin shoot Quintin Moss on a St. Louis street corner to avenge his brother's death? We argue the case with Brenda Becker. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for episode pictures and more.

    72. Let Your Freak Straw Fly

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 3, 2021 69:44


    When Samantha Davis crashed her truck into the side of an overpass near Cincinnati, Ohio, it careened over the edge and into a car below, killing two other people. Was it a freak accident or reckless driving? We argue the case with Olaya Fernandez Gayol. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook for episode pictures and more.

    71. Sus AF

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 27, 2021 68:23


    Deana Wild fell to her death from a cliff in Big Sur, California in 1987. Was it an accident or a murder? We cover the Virginia McGinnis trial with Katrina Linker. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook!

    70. Bane Ate His Dog House

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 20, 2021 74:29


    A neighbor's dog killed Diane Whipple outside her San Francisco apartment. Who was responsible - the dog or his owner? We argue the case with Cristy Miller. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for episode pictures and more. 

    69. And Also Communism

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 13, 2021 64:42


    Kiera Newsome said she was at school in downtown Los Angeles when Christian Henton was shot 10 miles away. But police thought she was lying. Did she ditch school to commit the murder? We argue the case with Carissa Dege. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for episode pics and more!

    68. Keep on Detecting

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 6, 2021 65:15


    In 1992, Stella Liebeck got third-degree burns after spilling a hot McDonalds coffee on her lap. Was she responsible for her injuries or was McDonalds? We argue the case with Barb Weigel. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for episode pictures and more!

    67. Zero to Murder

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 29, 2021 77:40


    Did Amanda Knox kill her roommate in a sex game gone wrong, or was she the victim of bad police work? We cover one of Italy's most famous cases with Shreena Chopra! Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for episode pictures and more! 

    66. A Little More Jazz Hands

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 22, 2021 63:56


    Happy Pride, everybody! Did The National Enquirer defame fitness guru Richard Simmons when it claimed he was transitioning from male to female? We argue the case with Susan-Kate Heaney. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for episode pictures and more!

    65. Normal Range of Emotions

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 15, 2021 71:26


    Did actor Robert Blake shoot his wife outside Vitello's Italian restaurant in Los Angeles? We argue the case with Michele Leigh. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook for episode pictures and more!

    64. What a Happy Ending

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 8, 2021 60:18


    Did a Pennsylvania high school break the law when it kicked Brandi Levy off the cheerleading squad for cursing on Snapchat? We argue the case. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook for episode pictures and more! 

    Claim Try Trial Again

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel