Reason and Theology Show – Reason and Theology

Follow Reason and Theology Show – Reason and Theology
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

This podcast covers many different theological, historical and philosophical topics, with round table discussions, debates and theological commentary from different points of view. Emphasis is especially given to the Roman Catholic, Eastern Orthodox and Reformed perspectives. Visit ReasonAndTheolog…

Michael Lofton


    • Mar 1, 2026 LATEST EPISODE
    • weekdays NEW EPISODES
    • 1,604 EPISODES

    Ivy Insights

    The Reason and Theology Show is a highly informative and engaging podcast that provides in-depth discussions on Catholicism, Eastern Catholicism, Orthodox theology, and various theological topics. Hosted by Michael Lofton, the show offers a fair perspective on Pope Francis's magisterium and its critics, presenting teachings within a hermeneutic of continuity. Lofton's expertise on the Magisterium and Eastern Catholicism, as well as his balanced approach to Trad Catholicism, brings much-needed balance to the Church.

    One of the best aspects of this podcast is its commitment to providing educated and brilliant discussions on theological issues. The guests are erudite and well-prepared, offering deep insights into Catholicism and other related topics. The episodes cover a wide range of subjects, including the teachings of Pope Francis, traditionalism, defending the Church for Union with Rome, and even debates between Catholics and Orthodox Christians. This makes it a valuable resource for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of Catholic theology.

    Another positive aspect of this podcast is how it helps heal spiritual wounds caused by traditionalist influences or personal hurts experienced within the Church. Michael Lofton eloquently expresses thoughts and feelings that many listeners may have struggled to articulate themselves. By addressing these concerns head-on, the show contributes to strengthening faith and fostering unity within the Church.

    However, one possible drawback of the Reason and Theology Show is that Lofton occasionally comes across as negative or attacking towards fellow Catholics or Protestants. While it may be argued that this adds an element of truth-telling to the discussions, some listeners may find his approach off-putting or divisive. It would be beneficial for Lofton to strike a better balance in his criticisms to promote dialogue rather than further division.

    In conclusion, The Reason and Theology Show is a must-listen for anyone interested in delving deeper into Catholic theology. Despite its occasional negative tone or divisive approach towards certain groups, this podcast offers enlightening discussions on various theological topics and helps listeners navigate challenging issues within the Catholic Church. With its commitment to educating and providing a fair perspective, the Reason and Theology Show is a valuable resource for those seeking the truth of the Church.



    Search for episodes from Reason and Theology Show – Reason and Theology with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from Reason and Theology Show – Reason and Theology

    Trump Promised No More Wars—Now America Is Fighting Iran

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 1, 2026


    Trump Promised No More Wars—Now America Is Fighting Iran

    Catholics EXCOMMUNICATED for Attending Latin Mass?

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 27, 2026


    A Catholic archbishop has declared that attending certain Latin Masses could result in automatic excommunication. In the Archdiocese of Maceió, Brazil, the Traditional Latin Mass is now restricted to a single approved location. According to the archbishop, attending or celebrating the Latin Mass elsewhere constitutes a “public act of schism,” which carries the most severe […]

    Why People Leave After Joining the Church

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 26, 2026


    Why People Leave After Joining the Church

    German Bishops Elect New Leader — This Is Not Good

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 24, 2026


    German Bishops Elect New Leader — This Is Not Good

    Why Did Pope John Paul II Excommunicate Archbishop Lefebvre?

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 21, 2026


    SSPX Response to Rome: July Consecrations Are On

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 19, 2026


    SSPX Response to Rome: July Consecrations Are On

    Another Eastern Catholic Priest Goes Orthodox — A Pattern?

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 18, 2026


    Another Eastern Catholic priest has become Eastern Orthodox — and it's not an isolated case. In this video, I take a closer look at why this keeps happening and explore the deeper dynamics behind these conversions. Why do some Eastern Catholics — including clergy — eventually cross over to Orthodoxy? Is it theological formation, ecclesiology, […]

    Archbishop Vigano: The Vatican is in Schism, Not the SSPX

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 16, 2026


    Archbishop Vigano: The Vatican is in Schism, Not the SSPX

    Vatican II CANNOT Be Changed? Vatican Drops Bombshell on SSPX

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 14, 2026


    Vatican II CANNOT Be Changed? Vatican Drops Bombshell on SSPX

    ‘Get Out of Jail Free?' Epstein Lawyer's Shocking Admission

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 13, 2026


    ‘Get Out of Jail Free?' Epstein Lawyer's Shocking Admission

    BREAKING: Vatican Publishes Statement on SSPX Negotiations

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 12, 2026


    BREAKING: Vatican Publishes Statement on SSPX Negotiations

    Bad Bunny's Super Bowl Show Erupts Massive Culture War

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 9, 2026


    Bad Bunny's Super Bowl Show Erupts Massive Culture War

    Epstein Files Reveal Plot To Take Down Pope Francis?

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 7, 2026


    Epstein Files Reveal Plot To Take Down Pope Francis?

    Did Trump Really Depict the Obamas As Monkeys? My Honest Thoughts

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 7, 2026


    Did Trump Really Depict the Obamas As Monkeys? My Honest Thoughts

    Major Updates in the SSPX–Vatican Situation

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026


    There are major developments in the relationship between the Catholic Church and the SSPX, especially in light of the SSPX's intention to ordain new bishops this July. In this video, I explain the history of the SSPX and why this next step is so significant.

    Did the Catholic-Orthodox Schism Just End… And Nobody Noticed?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 22, 2026


    Did the Catholic-Orthodox Schism Just End… And Nobody Noticed?

    Mike Huckabee Anathematizes Catholic and Orthodox Theology

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 22, 2026


    Mike Huckabee Anathematizes Catholic and Orthodox Theology

    U.S Warns Bank of England to Prepare for Aliens?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 20, 2026


    This isn't a show I planned to make today, but reports are circulating that the U.S. has warned the Bank of England to prepare for alien disclosure. Is there any substance to this claim, or is it just another distraction from what's really happening in the world? In this episode, I break down what we […]

    Jerusalem Church Leaders Jointly Condemn Christian Zionism

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 19, 2026


    Jerusalem Church Leaders Jointly Condemn Christian Zionism

    BREAKING: Benedict XVI's Unpublished Letter SLAMS the German Bishops

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 19, 2026


    BREAKING: Benedict XVI's Unpublished Letter SLAMS the German Bishops

    Excommunicated “Female Priest” Returns to the Catholic Church… Unrepentant

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 17, 2026


    The story of an excommunicated “female priest” returning to the Catholic Church while still unrepentant is more than just a headline — it's a wake-up call. If we stop clearly preaching sin, conversion, and repentance, we shouldn't be surprised when people want inclusion without conversion. Love and mercy are inseparable from truth. This is why […]

    Grok CONFESSED God Is Real — Then Things Got Weird

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 16, 2026


    In this episode, I put Grok to the test on the biggest questions imaginable. Using what I believe are airtight logical arguments, I press the AI on whether God must exist — and its responses take an unexpected turn. From there, things get even stranger as I ask Grok whether artificial intelligence could be being […]

    Candace Owens Says Charlie Was a Time Traveler – Let's Be Honest

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 15, 2026


    Recently, Candace Owens made a striking claim that has generated a great deal of attention online. She asserted that Charlie Kirk is a “time traveler” sent from the future to disrupt what she describes as a satanic agenda. According to her, the CIA supposedly used ancient Sumerian technology from the future to identify both Charlie […]

    BREAKING: Leaked Vatican Report Targets the Latin Mass?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 13, 2026


    BREAKING: Leaked Vatican Report Targets the Latin Mass?

    Pope Removes Traditional Priest Over Homophobic Slur?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 12, 2026


    In this episode, I examine the Pope's decision to remove a Traditional Latin Mass priest after the use of a homophobic slur, and what this action reveals about church discipline and its public optics—especially when contrasted with the lack of discipline for cardinals who promote doctrinal errors. I then analyze a letter circulated at the […]

    Tucker Carlson & Megyn Kelly Call Out Media, Israel, and War Propaganda

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 10, 2026


    In this episode, I examine recent comments from Tucker Carlson and Megyn Kelly as they call out media narratives surrounding war and propaganda. Building on their critiques, I argue that our generation has a moral responsibility to challenge media-driven war rhetoric and to seriously question continued U.S. funding for Israel's killing of Palestinians. I also […]

    Pope BLASTS World Powers on Suppressing Free Speech!

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 9, 2026


    Pope BLASTS World Powers on Suppressing Free Speech!

    Has the Bible Always Been the Same for Everyone?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 8, 2026


    Most people know there are differences between Catholic and Protestant Bibles—but the reality is far more complex. In this video, I explore the incredible diversity of Bibles throughout history, shaped by geography, religious traditions, theological agendas, and social contexts. From variations within Catholicism, Eastern Orthodoxy, Oriental Orthodoxy, Protestantism, Judaism, and even Islam, to striking examples […]

    BREAKING: ICE Officer Fatally Shoots Woman—Chaos Follows

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 8, 2026


    BREAKING: ICE Officer Fatally Shoots Woman—Chaos Follows

    Pope Leo Defines His Papacy: Vatican II and Ecumenism

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 7, 2026


    Pope Leo Defines His Papacy: Vatican II and Ecumenism

    New Cardinal Has No Issue with Women Priests and Gay Relationships?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 6, 2026


    New Cardinal Has No Issue with Women Priests and Gay Relationships?

    OnlyFans Star Lily Phillips Gets Re-Baptized — Real Conversion or Publicity Stunt?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 5, 2026


    An OnlyFans star, Lily Phillips, has gone viral after getting re-baptized and publicly identifying as a Christian—yet her pornographic content remains online, and there's no clear sign of repentance. This has ignited a massive debate: Should Christians withhold judgment? Is it fair to expect real change after conversion? What does genuine repentance actually look like? […]

    He Said the World Would End on Christmas – Now What?

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 26, 2025


    In this video, I break down the failed end-times prophecy of Ebo Noah and what happened after the world didn't end. While followers were gripped by fear and expectation, the prophet moved on to luxury cars, rap concerts, and a very different lifestyle. But this video isn't just about one man. I explain why people […]

    Trump's Hanukkah Reception Just Woke Me Up!

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 18, 2025


    I just watched Trump's Hanukkah reception—and it was a wake-up call. What stood out wasn't the symbolism or the speeches, but what the event revealed about influence and priorities. The reception made it painfully clear how beholden Trump appears to be to major donors and political interests that prioritize Israel's agenda over the needs of […]

    Have I Been Wrong About Church Teaching This Whole Time?

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 13, 2025


    A Catholic bishop displayed an image of a pig's heart inside a condom over the altar—and he's still in ministry. The same bishop has publicly defended artwork depicting Jesus as a crucified frog, as well as an image portraying the Virgin Mary as a transgender man. These weren't hidden provocations. They were praised, justified, and […]

    Most U.S. Catholics Support the Death Penalty—Despite the Catechism

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 11, 2025


    Most U.S. Catholics Support the Death Penalty—Despite the Catechism

    Addressing Kirk Cameron's New Thoughts On Hell

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 10, 2025


    In this episode, we take a closer look at Kirk Cameron's recent statements about hell and explore how they compare with Scripture, Christian tradition, and contemporary theological perspectives. From Ray Comfort's reaction to the broader Protestant response, we'll examine whether these newer ideas align with historic Christian doctrine—or represent a departure from it. We'll then […]

    St. Thomas Aquinas on Why Heretics Should Be Forced to Return to the Faith

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 9, 2025


    Was coercion ever considered a legitimate tool in the defense and preservation of the Catholic faith? In this episode, we examine St. Thomas Aquinas' reasoning behind the medieval position that civil and ecclesiastical authorities could compel heretics—by force if necessary—to return to the Church. We'll explore the theological arguments, historical backdrop, and the later development […]

    Was Leaving Christianity Punishable by Death in Church History?

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 9, 2025


    For most of us today, changing our religious beliefs is understood as a personal right — a matter of conscience. But throughout much of Christian history, things were very different. In many eras, leaving the faith or publicly challenging official doctrine wasn't just discouraged… it could be illegal, and in some cases, even punishable by […]

    Did Pope Benedict XVI Believe the Magisterium Has Erred?

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 6, 2025


    Did Pope Benedict XVI believe the Magisterium can err—or that it has erred in the past? In this video, we explore his views across different stages of his life: his early reflections as a young theologian at Vatican II, his role as Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, and finally, his […]

    Did the Vatican Just Shut the Door on the Female Diaconate? Not Exactly

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 4, 2025


    The Vatican study commission on the female diaconate recently released its findings: while it does not support a sacramental form of the female diaconate at this time, it leaves the door open for the magisterium to reconsider in the future. Meanwhile, a non-sacramental female diaconate is still possible today. What does this really mean for […]

    Catholic Nun Stabbed in Hate Crime? MAJOR PLOT TWIST

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 3, 2025


    Catholic Nun Stabbed in Hate Crime? MAJOR PLOT TWIST

    Pope Praises Islamic Call to Prayer in Interfaith Event

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 2, 2025


    Pope Praises Islamic Call to Prayer in Interfaith Event

    Catholic–Orthodox Reunion: Is It Finally Happening?

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 1, 2025


    Catholic–Orthodox Reunion: Is It Finally Happening?

    Vatican Releases Document on Polygamy – Here's What You Need To Know!

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 25, 2025


    Vatican Releases Document on Polygamy – Here’s What You Need To Know!

    Pope Leo XIV Says Christians Must Move Past Old Doctrinal Wars

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 24, 2025


    In today's episode, we take a close look at the recent document calling Christians to “move beyond outdated theological disputes” and to leave behind controversies that are believed to have lost their purpose. But what does that actually mean? I walk through the text, its key claims, and the implications many Catholics, Orthodox, and Protestants […]

    Pope Leo XIV Weighs In on U.S. Immigration and Open Borders

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 18, 2025


    In this episode, we break down Pope Leo XIV's new comments on U.S. immigration and the ongoing open-borders debate. What exactly did the Holy Father say? How does it compare with the recent statements from the U.S. bishops? And why has JD Vance—one of the most prominent Catholic politicians in America—remained silent on the issue?

    Did Ireland Really Have a Woman Bishop? Fact or Fiction?

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 18, 2025


    Did Ireland Really Have a Woman Bishop? Fact or Myth?

    What the Vatican Synod Report Reveals on LGBT Issues, Women Deacons & Polygamy

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 17, 2025


    The Synod's Study Groups have released their Interim Reports, and some of the most controversial topics are sparking intense debate: homosexuality, polygamy, and the question of women deacons. In this episode, I break down what the Church is actually saying in these reports, what's being proposed, and the hot-button controversies these topics are generating. From […]

    Vatican Installs “Listening Kiosk” Inside St. Peter's Basilica

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 15, 2025


    St. Peter's Basilica has just installed a “Listening Kiosk” — a new station designed for spiritual dialogue, personal reflection, and pastoral outreach. But what exactly is this kiosk? Who is it for? And why is the Vatican introducing it now? In this video, I break down what the kiosk actually does, how it fits into […]

    Patriarch Bartholomew Gives Quran to Russian Muslim Leader — What's Going On?

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 15, 2025


    In 2009, Patriarch Bartholomew of Constantinople gifted a Quran to a Muslim leader — and many Christians are still asking: Why would an Orthodox patriarch do that? And it's not an isolated example. In recent decades we've seen a growing list of gestures and statements from major Christian leaders that seem totally at odds with […]

    Claim Reason and Theology Show – Reason and Theology

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel