Reason and Theology Show – Reason and Theology

Follow Reason and Theology Show – Reason and Theology
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

This podcast covers many different theological, historical and philosophical topics, with round table discussions, debates and theological commentary from different points of view. Emphasis is especially given to the Roman Catholic, Eastern Orthodox and Reformed perspectives. Visit ReasonAndTheolog…

Michael Lofton


    • Jul 24, 2025 LATEST EPISODE
    • weekdays NEW EPISODES
    • 1,478 EPISODES

    Ivy Insights

    The Reason and Theology Show is a highly informative and engaging podcast that provides in-depth discussions on Catholicism, Eastern Catholicism, Orthodox theology, and various theological topics. Hosted by Michael Lofton, the show offers a fair perspective on Pope Francis's magisterium and its critics, presenting teachings within a hermeneutic of continuity. Lofton's expertise on the Magisterium and Eastern Catholicism, as well as his balanced approach to Trad Catholicism, brings much-needed balance to the Church.

    One of the best aspects of this podcast is its commitment to providing educated and brilliant discussions on theological issues. The guests are erudite and well-prepared, offering deep insights into Catholicism and other related topics. The episodes cover a wide range of subjects, including the teachings of Pope Francis, traditionalism, defending the Church for Union with Rome, and even debates between Catholics and Orthodox Christians. This makes it a valuable resource for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of Catholic theology.

    Another positive aspect of this podcast is how it helps heal spiritual wounds caused by traditionalist influences or personal hurts experienced within the Church. Michael Lofton eloquently expresses thoughts and feelings that many listeners may have struggled to articulate themselves. By addressing these concerns head-on, the show contributes to strengthening faith and fostering unity within the Church.

    However, one possible drawback of the Reason and Theology Show is that Lofton occasionally comes across as negative or attacking towards fellow Catholics or Protestants. While it may be argued that this adds an element of truth-telling to the discussions, some listeners may find his approach off-putting or divisive. It would be beneficial for Lofton to strike a better balance in his criticisms to promote dialogue rather than further division.

    In conclusion, The Reason and Theology Show is a must-listen for anyone interested in delving deeper into Catholic theology. Despite its occasional negative tone or divisive approach towards certain groups, this podcast offers enlightening discussions on various theological topics and helps listeners navigate challenging issues within the Catholic Church. With its commitment to educating and providing a fair perspective, the Reason and Theology Show is a valuable resource for those seeking the truth of the Church.



    Search for episodes from Reason and Theology Show – Reason and Theology with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from Reason and Theology Show – Reason and Theology

    Did Pope Leo XIV Just Deny Papal Supremacy?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 24, 2025


    Did Pope Leo XIV just deny papal supremacy? Here’s what he said—and what it could mean for the Church.

    Archbishop Fires 2 Top Professors from Sacred Heart Seminary?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 24, 2025


    Archbishop Edward Weisenburger of Detroit has dismissed two highly respected professors from Sacred Heart Major Seminary. The professors are Dr. Eduardo Echeverria and Dr. Ralph Martin. No official explanation has been given for their sudden termination. In this episode, we break down what we know and explore the possible implications. Stay tuned for updates as […]

    Israeli Minister Claims Trump Supported Gaza “Cleansing”; U.S. Denies

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 23, 2025


    Israeli Minister Claims Trump Supported Gaza “Cleansing”; U.S. Denies In a shocking statement, Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich claimed that former President Donald Trump gave a “green light” to clear Gaza of Palestinians. The White House has pushed back, calling the claim a “conspiracy theory.” In this episode, we break down Smotrich's explosive remarks, examine […]

    Church Scandals, the Pope, and Israel: A Priest Speaks Out w/ Fr. John Brown

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 22, 2025


    Church Scandals, the Pope, and Israel: A Priest Speaks Out w/ Fr. John Brown In this episode, I sit down with a Catholic priest to ask some of the most pressing and controversial questions facing the Church today. We cover everything from Pope Francis’ call for a ceasefire in the Holy Land, to attacks on […]

    Catholic and Orthodox Leaders Denounce Israeli Settler Violence

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 21, 2025


    In this episode, I cover the alarming statements made by top Church leaders in the Holy Land regarding escalating settler violence against the only entirely Christian Palestinian village left in the occupied West Bank—Taybeh. Greek Orthodox Patriarch Theophilos III and Latin Patriarch Pierbattista Pizzaballa visited the village in a rare show of solidarity, denouncing recent […]

    My Honest Thoughts on the Alleged Strickland–Westen Audio Leak

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 18, 2025


    My Honest Thoughts on the Alleged Strickland–Westen Audio Leak

    Online ‘Orthobros' Rebuked by Orthodox Priest

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 18, 2025


    An Orthodox priest speaks out against the rise of online “Orthobros”—a growing subculture marked by zeal without nuance, tribalism, and performative piety. In this episode, we take a close look at his critique: what exactly is he calling out, why does it matter, and how should Orthodox Christians (and others) respond? Whether you’re Orthodox, Catholic, […]

    Catholic Bishop Celebrates LGBTQ+ Pride Mass — What We Know So Far

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 18, 2025


    Catholic Bishop Celebrates LGBTQ+ Pride Mass — What We Know So Far

    Disturbing Moment: Zionist Defends Outrageous Position on Palestinians

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 17, 2025


    Disturbing Moment: Zionist Defends Outrageous Position on Palestinians

    Israel Destroys Church of the Holy Family in Gaza

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 17, 2025


    Israel Destroys Church of the Holy Family in Gaza

    Dead Sea Scrolls Scholar Tells All w/ Dr. Kipp Davis

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 16, 2025


    Join me for a fascinating deep-dive into the Dead Sea Scrolls with scholar Dr. Kipp Davis. We explore his personal work on the scrolls and uncover how their discovery has shaped modern biblical scholarship. We'll walk through the story of how the Dead Sea Scrolls were found, what they say—and what they don't say. Do […]

    Why This Popular Apologetics Argument Doesn't Work for Me Anymore

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 15, 2025


    In this episode, I dive into a common response I hear when raising concerns about problematic Vatican or papal documents: “But it's not magisterial.” For many, that phrase is meant to shut down the conversation—as if non-magisterial means non-consequential. But over time, I've come to see why that response no longer satisfies, and why it […]

    Pope Says Muslims Can Be Saved Through Islam

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 13, 2025


    In this video, I show that Pope John Paul II taught that non-Christians—including Muslims—can be saved through their own religions, even without knowing Jesus. This is no longer something that can be ignored—it deserves honest and open discussion.

    Why Are Traditionalists Upset with Pope Leo XIV?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 12, 2025


    Why Are Traditionalists Upset with Pope Leo XIV? In today's episode, we cover several major developments shaking the Catholic world. John-Henry Westen is no longer with LifeSite News—his co-founder reveals what led to his departure. Meanwhile, Pope Leo XIV is making waves with a series of controversial episcopal appointments that have traditionalists sounding the alarm. […]

    How the Trinity Was Understood Before Nicaea – Dr. Jim Papandrea Explains

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 7, 2025


    Did Christians believe in the Trinity before the Council of Nicaea in 325 AD? Was the doctrine developed over time—or was it already present in the early Church? In this episode, Dr. Jim Papandrea, expert in early Christianity and historical theology, joins me to explore how the Trinity was understood before and after Nicaea. We […]

    Dr. Craig Keener Interview on the Reliability of the New Testament

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 3, 2025


    Join Michael Lofton and Luis Dizon as they sit down with renowned New Testament scholar Dr. Craig Keener to discuss the reliability of the New Testament. In this in-depth interview, Dr. Keener addresses key questions about the historical trustworthiness of the Gospel accounts, the role of eyewitness testimony, manuscript evidence, and how ancient sources help […]

    Pope Creates Mass for Creation | Jay Dyer Loses Debate | Fr. Martin Compares LGBT to Trinity

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 1, 2025


    Pope Francis has introduced a new Mass for the Care of Creation — what does it mean for the liturgy and the direction of the Church? We also break down: There's a lot to unpack — theological implications, public reactions, and what it means for Catholics today.

    Does Catholicism Teach Muslims Can Be Saved? Here's the Answer

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 30, 2025


    Everyone's debating “Do Muslims and Christians worship the same God?”—but they're missing the bigger picture. In this video, we dive into what Vatican II’s Lumen Gentium actually says—and what most people completely overlook. Yes, the document famously states that “the Muslims… along with us adore the one and merciful God,” but did you catch the […]

    Responding to Jay Dyer: Did Popes Contradict Themselves on Islam?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 29, 2025


    Eastern Orthodox apologist Jay Dyer claims that the Catholic magisterium has contradicted itself—specifically when it comes to Islam. He argues that medieval and modern popes taught conflicting things: some affirmed that Muslims worship the same God as Christians, while others (like Pope Urban II) allegedly said Muslims worship demons. But is that actually a contradiction […]

    BREAKING: Sam Shamoun Admits He's NOT CATHOLIC – Why Has He Been Saying He Is?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 28, 2025


    BREAKING: Sam Shamoun Admits He's NOT CATHOLIC – Why Has He Been Saying He Is? For months, Sam Shamoun has publicly claimed to be a Catholic and even appeared on Catholic shows sharing his “conversion” story. But in response to questions raised in my previous video, Sam finally admitted he has not formally entered the […]

    BREAKING: Sam Shamoun Has NOT Converted to Catholicism? – The Evidence Considered

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 27, 2025


    Did Sam Shamoun really convert to Catholicism? In this in-depth episode, I carefully walk through the evidence, claims, and public statements surrounding Sam's religious identity and whether he has actually entered full communion with the Catholic Church. This isn't about accusations—it's about clarity. We look at Sam’s own words, Church law, the process for reception […]

    Sam Shamoun, the Qur'an, and the Trinity—Did I Misstate His Views?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 27, 2025


    Did I misrepresent Sam Shamoun on the nature of the God of the Qur'an and the Trinity? In this in-depth response, I carefully walk through Sam's claims, public behavior, and theology—while addressing whether my portrayal of his views was fair and accurate. Along the way, I explore the Catholic magisterium's teaching on Islam, clarify the […]

    Sam Shamoun, Please Watch — My Response to You

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 27, 2025


    In this video, I respond directly to Sam Shamoun's latest hit piece and clarify key points about Catholic teaching and apologetics. I address misunderstandings and invite Sam to engage with humility and charity. This isn't just about a disagreement — it's about truth, respect, and growth in faith. Whether you follow Sam, me, or are […]

    Divine Deception? Exploring God's Role in Misleading Others

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 26, 2025


    The Bible contains some challenging passages that seem to suggest God can mislead or send a “lying spirit” — so what's going on? In this video, we dive into those difficult texts and explore whether God ever truly deceives people, what Scripture says about His character, and how to make sense of these mysteries. Join […]

    Do the Popes Say the God of the Quran Is Satan? The Surprising Truth

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 25, 2025


    In this video, we take a close, careful look at what the popes have actually said about Islam's understanding of God. Some people claim that the God of the Quran is Satan — but is that really what the popes and the Catholic Church teach? We'll explore key statements from Church teaching, highlight what makes […]

    Was the Promised Land Given to Israel on Condition of Obedience?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 24, 2025


    Was the Promised Land Given to Israel on Condition of Obedience? In this video, we dive into one of the most important questions in biblical theology: Were God's promises about the land of Canaan unconditional, or did Israel have to obey the Law of Moses to keep it? We'll look at the key biblical texts […]

    Ceasefire Violated – Trump Goes Off On Israel!

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 24, 2025


    Ceasefire Violated – Trump Goes Off On Israel!

    Trump Declares Ceasefire Deal Between Iran and Israel

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 24, 2025


    Trump Declares Ceasefire Deal Between Iran and Israel

    BREAKING: Iran is Bombing Qatar; Iran Uranium Missing After US Attack

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 23, 2025


    BREAKING: Iran is Bombing Qatar; Iran Uranium Missing After US Attack

    Trump Just Bombed Iran — Here's What We Know So Far

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 22, 2025


    Trump Just Bombed Iran — Here's What We Know So Far

    Nobody's Talking About This in the Cruz & Tucker Israel Debate

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 21, 2025


    Ted Cruz says supporting Israel is a biblical obligation — but what does that really mean? In this episode, we go beyond the talking points and ask the uncomfortable questions: What are the implications of basing U.S. foreign policy on biblical prophecy? How does this theological stance shape Cruz's unwavering support for Israel? And what […]

    Why This Vatican Appointment by Pope Leo XIV Is Making Headlines

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 19, 2025


    Pope Leo XIV has just made a surprising new appointment that’s turning heads across the Catholic world—and beyond. In this episode, we break down who was appointed, why it’s so controversial (or groundbreaking), and what this could mean for the future direction of the Vatican. Is this a sign of reform, a political move, or […]

    Tucker Was Right: Ted Cruz Took the Bible Out of Context on Israel

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 18, 2025


    In a recent appearance on Tucker Carlson's show, Senator Ted Cruz quoted Genesis 12:3 — “I will bless those who bless you, and curse those who curse you” — as justification for unwavering U.S. support for the modern state of Israel. But is that what the Bible actually teaches? In this video, we break down […]

    Catholic Pride Masses and Episcopal Silence: Complicit or Cowardly?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 18, 2025


    Pride-themed liturgies are being held in Catholic parishes across the country — often with full knowledge of the local bishops. But while the faithful raise concerns, most bishops remain silent. Why? Is it fear of backlash, a strategy of appeasement, or something deeper? In this episode, we examine the rise of so-called “Pride Masses” in […]

    51 Killed in Gaza While Waiting for Food | Eyewitness Accounts

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 17, 2025


    Israeli forces opened fire near an aid distribution site in Gaza, killing at least 51 Palestinians who were reportedly waiting in line for flour and other basic supplies. In this episode, we cover the reports of eyewitnesses who were on the ground when the tragedy unfolded.

    Temple Mount Just SHUT DOWN by Israel – Tensions Rising?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 16, 2025


    In a major development, Israeli authorities have shut down access to the Temple Mount for worshippers, sparking concerns and speculation across the region and beyond. In this video, we break down what led to the closure, and what this could mean for the ongoing tensions in Israel.

    Can Non-Orthodox Be Saved? What Eastern Orthodoxy Actually Teaches

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 16, 2025


    Can someone outside the Orthodox Church be saved? It’s a question many ask — and the answer might surprise you. In this episode, we explore what Eastern Orthodoxy actually teaches about salvation beyond its visible boundaries. Drawing from the Church Fathers, councils, and contemporary Orthodox theologians, we dive into the nuanced and often misunderstood doctrine […]

    Cardinal Burke: The Papacy is Persecuting Faithful Catholics | My Thoughts

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 14, 2025


    Cardinal Raymond Burke has raised alarm over recent restrictions on the Traditional Latin Mass, claiming they amount to a form of persecution by the very heart of the Church—the papacy itself. What does this mean theologically? In this video, I explore the deep implications of Cardinal Burke's statement. If the papacy can be perceived as […]

    The Middle East on Fire 🔥 Israel and Iran at WAR

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 14, 2025


    The world is watching as a full-scale conflict erupts in the Middle East. In this episode, we break down how the war between Israel and Iran began, the key events leading up to Israel's first strike, and what's happening on the ground right now. From missile launches to international reactions, we cover the timeline, political […]

    Was Cardinal Fernández Reconfirmed by Pope Leo XIV?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 13, 2025


    Join us as we explore the recent rumors, reports, and theological implications surrounding Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández and his role as head of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith. Has there been a reconfirmation? Is the Vatican doubling down on his doctrinal direction? And what would it mean if this move came from […]

    Catholic Charismatic Renewal: Will Pope Leo XIV Say Yes?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 12, 2025


    In this episode, we dive deep into the growing conversation around the Catholic Charismatic Renewal and the Vatican’s response under the leadership of Pope Leo XIV. With millions of Catholics around the world embracing charismatic worship, many are asking: Will the Holy Father officially recognize and support this dynamic movement?

    God vs. the Gods: The Canaanite Origins of Psalm 82

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 12, 2025


    Psalm 82 presents a striking scene: God presiding over a council of other divine beings. But what does this really mean? In this episode, we explore the ancient Near Eastern backdrop of this mysterious psalm—drawing from Canaanite and Ugaritic texts that may shed new light on its origins.

    BREAKING: Bishop QUITS German Church – Disillusioned by Synodal Direction

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 11, 2025


    A German Catholic bishop has just resigned in a stunning move, citing deep disillusionment with the Synodal Way and the ongoing chaos within the German Church. After years of scandals, unresolved conflicts, and what he calls spiritual exhaustion, he says he can no longer stay silent or pretend the Church is on the right path. […]

    Is This the End of Sola Scriptura and Protestantism?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 10, 2025


    In this episode, I examine a critical issue at the heart of Protestant theology: the preservation of Scripture. Drawing on the scholarship of Dr. Daniel Wallace and Dr. Emanuel Tov—two of the most respected textual critics—I explore whether the Old Testament has truly been preserved in the way Sola Scriptura requires. Both Wallace and Tov […]

    Vatican Removes Fr. Rupnik's Art… But That's Not the Whole Story

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 9, 2025


    The Vatican has quietly removed the artwork of Fr. Marko Rupnik from its official website — a move many see as long overdue. But what they haven't done is even more shocking. In this episode, we dive into the full story: the abuse allegations, the Vatican's selective response, and what this reveals about the Church's […]

    What Nobody Told You About the Dead Sea Scrolls

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 9, 2025


    The Dead Sea Scrolls are often mentioned in passing—but rarely explained. In this episode, we uncover what you were never told about these ancient manuscripts and why they matter more than you think.

    The Original Old Testament: Lost or Preserved?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 8, 2025


    The Old Testament is at the heart of the Christian faith — but how close is your Bible to what was originally written? In this episode, we dive deep into the complex history of the Old Testament text. We explore the major manuscript traditions — the Masoretic Text, the Dead Sea Scrolls, and the Septuagint […]

    The German Bishops Need to Go! | Reason & Reactions

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 6, 2025


    A petition has been launched calling on Pope Leo XIV to remove Cardinal Rainer Maria Woelki, a prominent figure in the German Catholic Church. In this episode, I break down the reasons behind this growing demand—from his handling of abuse cases to broader concerns about leadership and accountability. But this issue goes far beyond one […]

    Elon vs Trump Just Got Nasty—Epstein Name Dropped!

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 6, 2025


    The Origins of Yahweh Worship: History, Archaeology & Theology w/ Dr. Justin Sledge

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 5, 2025


    The Origins of Yahweh Worship: History, Archaeology & Theology w/ Dr. Justin Sledge

    Fr. James Martin Says Catholics Should Celebrate Pride Month — Here's My Response

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 4, 2025


    In this episode, I take a deep dive into Fr. James Martin’s recent article advocating that Catholics should celebrate Pride Month. Join me as I respectfully examine his claims, highlight key theological concerns, and discuss what authentic compassion and truth look like when it comes to this complex issue. Whether you agree or disagree, this […]

    Claim Reason and Theology Show – Reason and Theology

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel