Reason and Theology Show – Reason and Theology

Follow Reason and Theology Show – Reason and Theology
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

This podcast covers many different theological, historical and philosophical topics, with round table discussions, debates and theological commentary from different points of view. Emphasis is especially given to the Roman Catholic, Eastern Orthodox and Reformed perspectives. Visit ReasonAndTheolog…

Michael Lofton


    • Oct 7, 2025 LATEST EPISODE
    • weekdays NEW EPISODES
    • 1,530 EPISODES

    Ivy Insights

    The Reason and Theology Show is a highly informative and engaging podcast that provides in-depth discussions on Catholicism, Eastern Catholicism, Orthodox theology, and various theological topics. Hosted by Michael Lofton, the show offers a fair perspective on Pope Francis's magisterium and its critics, presenting teachings within a hermeneutic of continuity. Lofton's expertise on the Magisterium and Eastern Catholicism, as well as his balanced approach to Trad Catholicism, brings much-needed balance to the Church.

    One of the best aspects of this podcast is its commitment to providing educated and brilliant discussions on theological issues. The guests are erudite and well-prepared, offering deep insights into Catholicism and other related topics. The episodes cover a wide range of subjects, including the teachings of Pope Francis, traditionalism, defending the Church for Union with Rome, and even debates between Catholics and Orthodox Christians. This makes it a valuable resource for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of Catholic theology.

    Another positive aspect of this podcast is how it helps heal spiritual wounds caused by traditionalist influences or personal hurts experienced within the Church. Michael Lofton eloquently expresses thoughts and feelings that many listeners may have struggled to articulate themselves. By addressing these concerns head-on, the show contributes to strengthening faith and fostering unity within the Church.

    However, one possible drawback of the Reason and Theology Show is that Lofton occasionally comes across as negative or attacking towards fellow Catholics or Protestants. While it may be argued that this adds an element of truth-telling to the discussions, some listeners may find his approach off-putting or divisive. It would be beneficial for Lofton to strike a better balance in his criticisms to promote dialogue rather than further division.

    In conclusion, The Reason and Theology Show is a must-listen for anyone interested in delving deeper into Catholic theology. Despite its occasional negative tone or divisive approach towards certain groups, this podcast offers enlightening discussions on various theological topics and helps listeners navigate challenging issues within the Catholic Church. With its commitment to educating and providing a fair perspective, the Reason and Theology Show is a valuable resource for those seeking the truth of the Church.



    Search for episodes from Reason and Theology Show – Reason and Theology with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from Reason and Theology Show – Reason and Theology

    Trinity or Tawhid? Dr. Joshua Sijuwade vs. Jake Brancatella

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 7, 2025


    Trinity or Tawhid? Dr. Joshua Sijuwade vs. Jake Brancatella

    Can Church Doctrine Change? Here's What the Church Really Says

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 6, 2025


    Can Church Doctrine Change? Here's What the Church Really Says

    Benedict XVI or Leo XIV — Which Pope Is Right on the Death Penalty?

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 5, 2025


    Benedict XVI or Leo XIV — Which Pope Is Right on the Death Penalty?

    Breaking: Vatican Congratulates First Ever Woman Archbishop of Canterbury

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 3, 2025


    Breaking: Vatican Congratulates First Ever Woman Archbishop of Canterbury

    Ice Blessing Scandal? Pope Leo Accused of Pagan Worship!

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 2, 2025


    Ice Blessing Scandal? Pope Leo Accused of Pagan Worship!

    BREAKING: Pope Leo Drops Bombshell on Abortion, Death Penalty and Immigration

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 1, 2025


    Pope Leo XIV just made headlines with his explosive comments on what it truly means to be “pro-life.” In a bold statement, he declared that you cannot call yourself pro-life while supporting the death penalty or backing American immigration policies that harm human dignity. This shocking take is stirring global debate—tying together abortion, capital punishment, […]

    Pope Leo XIV Calls Religions to Be Bridges of Unity

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 30, 2025


    Pope Leo XIV Calls Religions to Be Bridges of Unity

    How Much Authority Do the Church Fathers Really Have? | The Michael Lofton Show

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 29, 2025


    In this episode, we dig deep into the role of the Church Fathers and how Catholics should understand their authority. We start with the classic criteria—antiquity, orthodoxy, sanctity, and ecclesiastical approbation—and then explore what that means both individually and collectively. Individually, the Fathers are private theologians: brilliant, holy, and zealous for truth, but not infallible. […]

    Did Jesus Claim To Be God in the Gospels? Deenresponds vs. TurretinFan

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 29, 2025


    Did Jesus Claim To Be God in the Gospels? Deenresponds vs. TurretinFan

    Pope Leo XIV Makes History With Hadith Quotation

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 26, 2025


    In a historic first, Pope Leo XIV quoted a hadith during one of his addresses, marking a groundbreaking moment in Catholic–Muslim dialogue. In this video, I cover what this means for interreligious relations, how it connects with the Pope's broader approach to other religions, and what Vatican II taught about Jews, Muslims, and the Church's […]

    The Early Christian Heresy You've Never Heard Of

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 23, 2025


    Most people know about the big heresies of the early Church—Arianism, Nestorianism, Monophysitism. But have you ever heard of the Agnoetae? This strange and almost forgotten heresy claimed that Jesus didn't know everything in His earthly life. In this video, we'll explore who the Agnoetae were, what they believed, why the Church condemned them, and […]

    A Message to My Critics – Let's Talk

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 20, 2025


    A Message to My Critics – Let’s Talk

    How to Respond to Threats: The Role Forgiveness Plays

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 19, 2025


    How to Respond to Threats: The Role Forgiveness Plays

    Pope Leo XIV Calls on Catholics to Embrace Religious Diversity

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 17, 2025


    Pope Leo XIV Calls on Catholics to Embrace Religious Diversity

    The Confession Texts of Charlie Kirk's Killer (Tyler Robinson) | The Michael Lofton Show

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 16, 2025


    Newly revealed text messages show the chilling confession of Tyler Robinson, the accused killer of Charlie Kirk. In this episode, we go through the messages and what they reveal about his motive and state of mind.

    There's NO WAY Pope Leo XIV Just Said THIS About Islam

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 15, 2025


    Some are pointing to official Vatican transcripts. Others are sharing a viral post online. And questions are swirling: Did Pope Leo XIV really use those words? Was something changed or covered up? Or is this just another case of fake news? In this episode, we dig into the sources, compare transcripts, and look directly at […]

    First Rap Concert at the Vatican? Here's What Just Happened

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 14, 2025


    First Rap Concert at the Vatican? Here's What Just Happened

    First Rap Concert at the Vatican? Here's What Just Happened

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 14, 2025


    First Rap Concert at the Vatican? Here's What Just Happened

    Tyler Robinson, Kirk's Alleged Assassin, Linked to Transgender Partner

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 13, 2025


    Tyler Robinson, Kirk's Alleged Assassin, Linked to Transgender Partner

    Charlie Kirk's Wife Speaks Out: Her Message to America

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 13, 2025


    Charlie Kirk's Wife Speaks Out: Her Message to America

    DEBATE: Is the Prophet Muhammad in the Bible? (The Orthodox Muslim vs. Dale Glover)

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 10, 2025


    DEBATE: Is the Prophet Muhammad in the Bible? (The Orthodox Muslim vs. Dale Glover)

    Pope Blesses LGBTQ Catholic Event, NYT Reports

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 9, 2025


    Pope Blesses LGBTQ Catholic Event, NYT Reports

    Vatican Smokescreen: Latin Mass Used to Distract After LGBTQ Takeover?

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 8, 2025


    Vatican Smokescreen: Latin Mass Used to Distract After LGBTQ Takeover?

    Vatican Embraces LGBTQ Pilgrims—Controversy Follows

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 7, 2025


    LGBTQ+ Catholics processed a rainbow cross into St. Peter's Basilica during their Jubilee pilgrimage in Rome. Even more shocking, Pope Francis (through Cardinal Leo) personally sent a bishop to celebrate their LGBTQ Mass. The Vatican even listed the event on the official Holy Year calendar, sparking worldwide outrage. In this episode, I unpack what happened, […]

    LGBTQ Cross Carried into St. Peter's Basilica—Unbelievable!

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 6, 2025


    An LGBTQ group officially processed a rainbow pride cross into St. Peter's Basilica—wearing pride shirts, waving pride flags, and holding a special Mass endorsed by Pope Leo – who personally sent a bishop to celebrate it. In this episode, I break down what happened, why it matters, and what this means for the future of […]

    Cardinal Cupich Says Traditionalists Are ‘Backwards'—Online Trads React

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 5, 2025


    Cardinal Cupich Says Traditionalists Are ‘Backwards’—Online Trads React

    Calvinist Says Child Deserves Torment! The Absurd View of R.C. Sproul Jr.

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 4, 2025


    In this video, we unpack a shocking statement from R.C. Sproul Jr., who claimed that a child could deserve torment. We break down the reasoning behind this view and expose how absurd and troubling it is when applied to real people. If you've ever wondered how far theological reasoning can go, this episode will leave […]

    The Toughest Passage in the Bible Unpacked (Numbers 31:13-19)

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 3, 2025


    Skeptics often point to some of the most difficult passages in the Bible, especially those involving moral issues that are hard to reconcile. In this episode, we take a closer look at one of the toughest texts in Scripture—unpacking its historical context, wrestling with the ethical questions it raises, and examining how some people have […]

    Rainbow Crucifix To Be Displayed at Vatican LGBTQ Event

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 2, 2025


    The Vatican will soon host a pro-LGBTQ Catholic group in Rome, featuring a transgender speaker and Fr. James Martin, SJ. A church has even been given to them to display their rainbow crucifix. In this episode, Michael unpacks what this means for the Church, why it's stirring controversy, and how Catholics should think about these […]

    Catholic Bishop Celebrates Mass with Married Lesbian Priest

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 2, 2025


    A Catholic bishop recently celebrated Mass alongside an Anglican priest who is both openly gay and married to a woman. What does this mean for Catholic teaching, ecumenical relations, and the integrity of the liturgy? In this episode, we break down the details, the controversy, and why this moment has Catholics asking serious questions about […]

    Pope Leo XIV Meets with Fr. James Martin – A Big Signal?

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 1, 2025


    Fr. James Martin, S.J., recently met with Pope Leo XIV, raising big questions about what this encounter could mean for the Church. Is it a sign of a new direction under the papacy of Leo XIV? Does it indicate a shift in how the Vatican will engage with Fr. Martin and his views? In this […]

    Another Pro-LGBT Catholic Group Appears on the Vatican Jubilee Calendar

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 30, 2025


    Another Pro-LGBT Catholic Group Appears on the Vatican Jubilee Calendar

    The Heretic Friar Who Escaped the Roman Inquisition

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 29, 2025


    Sentenced by St. Charles Borromeo for heresy, a Franciscan friar escapes the Roman Inquisition. With his life spared only in effigy, this daring escape shocked the Church. Discover the story of The Heretic Friar Who Escaped the Roman Inquisition.

    Catholic Priest Busted in Undercover Sting – Arrested on Child Sex Charges

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 28, 2025


    A Catholic priest has been arrested for child sex solicitation — a shocking betrayal that has left many outraged. This case raises urgent questions about accountability, the protection of children, and the ongoing scandal of abuse within the Church. In this video, we break down what happened, why it matters, and how the faithful should […]

    Archaeologists Find Ancient Christian Site in the Arabian Gulf

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 28, 2025


    Archaeologists in Abu Dhabi have uncovered a 1,400-year-old cross at an ancient Christian monastery on Sir Bani Yas Island—reshaping what we thought we knew about the spread of Christianity in the Arabian Gulf. Far from being in decline, the evidence shows that believers here were thriving during the rise of Islam, blending local culture with […]

    Did Pope Leo Say You Can't be Catholic and Pro-Abortion?

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 28, 2025


    Did Pope Leo really declare that you can't be Catholic and support abortion—or is this just a modern twist on his words? In this episode, we dive into Pope Leo's actual teaching, examine the context of his statements, and ask whether today's headlines are faithfully representing his message or sensationalizing it.

    Priest Claims Self-Pleasure Can Be Prayerful ⚠️ Viewer Discretion Advised

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 27, 2025


    At a recent Catholic annual meeting attended by multiple bishops, a priest made waves by claiming that masturbation can be a “moment of prayer” — a way to thank God for the gift of sexuality. In this episode, I break down exactly what he said, examine the reactions from clergy and attendees, and discuss how […]

    BREAKING: Shooting at Minneapolis Catholic School

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 27, 2025


    BREAKING: Shooting at Minneapolis Catholic School

    The Worst Pope in History? Pope John XII and the Council that Removed Him

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 26, 2025


    Pope John XII is often remembered as one of the most scandalous figures to ever sit on the papal throne. Rising to power as a teenager, he became infamous for corruption, violence, and immorality. In 963, a council deposed him—but his downfall didn't end there. John XII would ultimately be killed by the enraged husband […]

    Pope Leo XIV BANS 12 Ancient Catholic Rituals?

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 25, 2025


    Several outlets are claiming that Pope Leo XIV has just banned 12 ancient Catholic rituals, and some are even circulating an alleged audio homily of the Pope announcing the ban. But is it real? In this video, I take a closer look at the recording, examine the claims, and break down what's actually going on.

    Scripture & Tradition: Private Opinion vs. Magisterium

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 24, 2025


    Some Catholics claim that each individual believer can decide what the Bible and Tradition mean. But that's exactly the Protestant principle of private judgment. The Catholic Church has always taught that it is the Magisterium — the Pope and bishops in union with him — who authentically interpret the Word of God. If you've ever […]

    Wait… Christians Kept Sacrificing Animals After Jesus?

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 22, 2025


    Did animal sacrifices really continue after the crucifixion of Jesus? Many Christians assume the cross ended sacrifices once and for all—but Scripture and history tell a more complex story. The apostles went to the Temple during the daily sacrifices (Acts 3), Paul himself participated in offerings (Acts 21, 24), and traditions like the Armenian matagh […]

    DEBATE: Is the Trinity Coherent? (Jake Brancatella vs. Samuel Green)

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 19, 2025


    DEBATE: Is the Trinity Coherent? (Jake Brancatella vs. Samuel Green)

    Israel Freezes Greek Orthodox Church's Bank Accounts in Tax Showdown

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 15, 2025


    Jerusalem has frozen all bank accounts of the Greek Orthodox Patriarchate over an ongoing property tax dispute — leaving clergy, teachers, and staff without pay. The city claims the Church owes millions in back taxes for properties not used as houses of worship, while the Patriarchate says this move breaks centuries of precedent and ongoing […]

    Pope Leo to Host Pro-LGBTQ+ Catholic Group at the Vatican?

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 15, 2025


    Reporters are claiming that for the first time in history, Pope Leo will meet with a pro-LGBTQ+ Catholic group at the Vatican. What does this mean for the Church, the LGBTQ+ community, and the future of Catholic dialogue? In this episode, we break down the significance of this historic meeting, what it could signal about […]

    Catholic Bishops Allow Woman “Priestess” to Concelebrate Mass in Italy

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 14, 2025


    An incident at the Basilica of Loreto, where the Holy House of Mary is enshrined, is drawing widespread attention. Footage shows Catholic bishops concelebrating Mass alongside a woman dressed in a cassock and clerical collar, possibly a Protestant “priestess.”

    Bishop Reinstates Priest After Same-Sex Relationship: A Biblical Response

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 12, 2025


    A priest who entered a same-sex civil union was recently reinstated to active ministry—promoted to parish leadership, school oversight, and even the diocesan marriage tribunal. All this, despite a public record of LGBT advocacy and no clear public repentance. In this video, I explore the deeper issue: What happened to the biblical standards for ministry? […]

    Leaked Benedict XVI Letter Ends the Resignation Debate

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 11, 2025


    Leaked Benedict XVI Letter Ends the Resignation Debate A previously unpublished letter from Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI — dated August 21, 2014 — has just been made public, and it delivers a decisive blow to one of the most persistent Catholic conspiracy theories of the last decade. For years, some claimed that Benedict resigned only […]

    Bishop Reinstates Priest After Same-Sex Relationship: A Biblical Response

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 11, 2025


    A priest who entered a same-sex civil union was recently reinstated to active ministry—promoted to parish leadership, school oversight, and even the diocesan marriage tribunal. All this, despite a public record of LGBT advocacy and no clear public repentance. In this video, I explore the deeper issue: What happened to the biblical standards for ministry? […]

    Israel's Total Occupation of Gaza: A Theological Perspective

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 8, 2025


    Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says Israel is moving forward with the full occupation of Gaza. Former President Donald Trump refuses to oppose it, and some far-right Israeli politicians are even quoting Hitler in defense of wiping Gaza off the map. In the U.S., Christian Zionists like Speaker Mike Johnson are citing the Bible—especially Genesis […]

    Claim Reason and Theology Show – Reason and Theology

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel