This podcast covers many different theological, historical and philosophical topics, with round table discussions, debates and theological commentary from different points of view. Emphasis is especially given to the Roman Catholic, Eastern Orthodox and Reformed perspectives. Visit ReasonAndTheolog…
The Reason and Theology Show is a highly informative and engaging podcast that provides in-depth discussions on Catholicism, Eastern Catholicism, Orthodox theology, and various theological topics. Hosted by Michael Lofton, the show offers a fair perspective on Pope Francis's magisterium and its critics, presenting teachings within a hermeneutic of continuity. Lofton's expertise on the Magisterium and Eastern Catholicism, as well as his balanced approach to Trad Catholicism, brings much-needed balance to the Church.
One of the best aspects of this podcast is its commitment to providing educated and brilliant discussions on theological issues. The guests are erudite and well-prepared, offering deep insights into Catholicism and other related topics. The episodes cover a wide range of subjects, including the teachings of Pope Francis, traditionalism, defending the Church for Union with Rome, and even debates between Catholics and Orthodox Christians. This makes it a valuable resource for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of Catholic theology.
Another positive aspect of this podcast is how it helps heal spiritual wounds caused by traditionalist influences or personal hurts experienced within the Church. Michael Lofton eloquently expresses thoughts and feelings that many listeners may have struggled to articulate themselves. By addressing these concerns head-on, the show contributes to strengthening faith and fostering unity within the Church.
However, one possible drawback of the Reason and Theology Show is that Lofton occasionally comes across as negative or attacking towards fellow Catholics or Protestants. While it may be argued that this adds an element of truth-telling to the discussions, some listeners may find his approach off-putting or divisive. It would be beneficial for Lofton to strike a better balance in his criticisms to promote dialogue rather than further division.
In conclusion, The Reason and Theology Show is a must-listen for anyone interested in delving deeper into Catholic theology. Despite its occasional negative tone or divisive approach towards certain groups, this podcast offers enlightening discussions on various theological topics and helps listeners navigate challenging issues within the Catholic Church. With its commitment to educating and providing a fair perspective, the Reason and Theology Show is a valuable resource for those seeking the truth of the Church.
St. Peter's Basilica has just installed a “Listening Kiosk” — a new station designed for spiritual dialogue, personal reflection, and pastoral outreach. But what exactly is this kiosk? Who is it for? And why is the Vatican introducing it now? In this video, I break down what the kiosk actually does, how it fits into […]
In 2009, Patriarch Bartholomew of Constantinople gifted a Quran to a Muslim leader — and many Christians are still asking: Why would an Orthodox patriarch do that? And it's not an isolated example. In recent decades we've seen a growing list of gestures and statements from major Christian leaders that seem totally at odds with […]
After the recent plenary assembly of the Catholic Bishops' Conference of England and Wales, the Vatican's nuncio in Britain confirmed that Pope Leo XIV does not intend to overturn Pope Francis' limits on the traditional Latin Mass. That means “Traditionis Custodes” remains in effect, but with one small caveat: bishops who request it can receive […]
In this episode, I cover the growing controversy after a priest — with the involvement of Fr. James Martin — confirmed an openly gay man living in a same-sex relationship, with his partner serving as his sponsor. Bishop Joseph Strickland raised this serious concern during the annual meeting of the U.S. bishops, but the conference […]
Openly Gay ABC Anchor Joins Catholic Church with Partner as Sponsor
Bishop Schneider Reacts to New Vatican Document: Catholics Must Accept Co-Redemptrix
Olympics Moves To Ban Transgender Women?
Pope Leo XIV has just announced plans to convene an extraordinary consistory of cardinals in early January — but no one knows why. According to a leaked Vatican communication obtained by the National Catholic Register, the meeting is set for January 7–8, 2026, and will bring together the world's cardinals to discuss matters of major […]
In this episode, we break down three major developments in the Catholic Church: Pope Leo's upcoming document on polygamy and what it could mean for the Church—especially in Africa; the Italian bishops' study on the female diaconate and whether it signals change ahead; and the Pope's latest remarks on immigration in America.
In this episode, we dive deep into the Vatican's brand-new doctrinal note Mater Populi Fidelis (2025) from the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith — the one addressing Marian titles like Co-Redemptrix and Mediatrix. I walk through the key parts of the document, explain what the Church actually says about Mary's role, and unpack […]
BREAKING: Vatican to Decide Is Mary ‘Co-Redemptrix'? New Magisterial Document November 4th!
Did the Vatican Host a Religious Snake Ritual? Interfaith Gathering Examined
Pope Leo XIV: Some Are Ready for Change, Others Aren't
Did Ancient Scribes Edit the Bible to Hide Contradictions?
BREAKING: Pope Leo Unites World Religions in Prayer for Peace — Assisi 3.0?
Cliffe Knechtle vs Eastern Orthodox Christian – Bible Authority Debate
Is the Vatican “Muslim Prayer Room” Story A Hoax?
BREAKING: The Anglican Church Just Split in Two — History Is Being Made!
Is the Trinity Logically Coherent? Jake Brancatella vs. Dale Glover
Bishop Mark Beckman of Knoxville, Tennessee, has directed that all celebrations of the Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) in the diocese end by November 23, 2025, following the Vatican's 2021 motu proprio Traditionis Custodes. This decision impacts communities including Holy Ghost Church in Knoxville, St. Henry Parish in Johnson City, and the Basilica of Saints Peter […]
Join Michael Lofton as he dives into the Vatican's recent message wishing Hindus a “Happy Deepavali,” exploring how this reflects a broader trend in the post-conciliar period where the Church's magisterium has shifted in emphasis. He also brings viewers the latest updates on the Rupnik trial and examines the German Bishops' Episcopal Conference's ongoing discussions […]
Vatican Approves PRAYER SPACE for Muslims?
Dr. Joshua Sijuwade Reflects on His Debate: Trinity vs. Tawhid
Trinity or Tawhid? Dr. Joshua Sijuwade vs. Jake Brancatella
Can Church Doctrine Change? Here's What the Church Really Says
Benedict XVI or Leo XIV — Which Pope Is Right on the Death Penalty?
Breaking: Vatican Congratulates First Ever Woman Archbishop of Canterbury
Ice Blessing Scandal? Pope Leo Accused of Pagan Worship!
Pope Leo XIV just made headlines with his explosive comments on what it truly means to be “pro-life.” In a bold statement, he declared that you cannot call yourself pro-life while supporting the death penalty or backing American immigration policies that harm human dignity. This shocking take is stirring global debate—tying together abortion, capital punishment, […]
Pope Leo XIV Calls Religions to Be Bridges of Unity
In this episode, we dig deep into the role of the Church Fathers and how Catholics should understand their authority. We start with the classic criteria—antiquity, orthodoxy, sanctity, and ecclesiastical approbation—and then explore what that means both individually and collectively. Individually, the Fathers are private theologians: brilliant, holy, and zealous for truth, but not infallible. […]
Did Jesus Claim To Be God in the Gospels? Deenresponds vs. TurretinFan
In a historic first, Pope Leo XIV quoted a hadith during one of his addresses, marking a groundbreaking moment in Catholic–Muslim dialogue. In this video, I cover what this means for interreligious relations, how it connects with the Pope's broader approach to other religions, and what Vatican II taught about Jews, Muslims, and the Church's […]
Most people know about the big heresies of the early Church—Arianism, Nestorianism, Monophysitism. But have you ever heard of the Agnoetae? This strange and almost forgotten heresy claimed that Jesus didn't know everything in His earthly life. In this video, we'll explore who the Agnoetae were, what they believed, why the Church condemned them, and […]
How to Respond to Threats: The Role Forgiveness Plays
Pope Leo XIV Calls on Catholics to Embrace Religious Diversity
Newly revealed text messages show the chilling confession of Tyler Robinson, the accused killer of Charlie Kirk. In this episode, we go through the messages and what they reveal about his motive and state of mind.
Some are pointing to official Vatican transcripts. Others are sharing a viral post online. And questions are swirling: Did Pope Leo XIV really use those words? Was something changed or covered up? Or is this just another case of fake news? In this episode, we dig into the sources, compare transcripts, and look directly at […]
First Rap Concert at the Vatican? Here's What Just Happened
First Rap Concert at the Vatican? Here's What Just Happened
Tyler Robinson, Kirk's Alleged Assassin, Linked to Transgender Partner
Charlie Kirk's Wife Speaks Out: Her Message to America
DEBATE: Is the Prophet Muhammad in the Bible? (The Orthodox Muslim vs. Dale Glover)
Pope Blesses LGBTQ Catholic Event, NYT Reports
Vatican Smokescreen: Latin Mass Used to Distract After LGBTQ Takeover?
LGBTQ+ Catholics processed a rainbow cross into St. Peter's Basilica during their Jubilee pilgrimage in Rome. Even more shocking, Pope Francis (through Cardinal Leo) personally sent a bishop to celebrate their LGBTQ Mass. The Vatican even listed the event on the official Holy Year calendar, sparking worldwide outrage. In this episode, I unpack what happened, […]
An LGBTQ group officially processed a rainbow pride cross into St. Peter's Basilica—wearing pride shirts, waving pride flags, and holding a special Mass endorsed by Pope Leo – who personally sent a bishop to celebrate it. In this episode, I break down what happened, why it matters, and what this means for the future of […]
Cardinal Cupich Says Traditionalists Are ‘Backwards’—Online Trads React
© 2020-2025 Ivy Podcast Discovery LLC
