Welcome to Highly Unlikely with Josh and Jenaye. We're so glad you're joining us, and we're excited to take you into conversations about highly unlikely people, many from highly unlikely places, and now doing some highly unlikely things. We will also dig
The Highly Unlikely with Josh & Jenaye podcast is a must-listen for anyone seeking authentic and inspiring conversations. As a listener from rural North Dakota, I was initially drawn to this podcast because of my love for Evangel and the connection I felt to Josh and Jenaye. From the moment I started listening, I knew I had found something special. The open and honest nature of these episodes is truly refreshing, and the encouragement they provide is invaluable. This podcast has quickly become a favorite of mine, and I eagerly look forward to each new episode.
One of the best aspects of The Highly Unlikely with Josh & Jenaye podcast is the authenticity that shines through in every episode. Josh and Jenaye's willingness to be vulnerable and share their own experiences creates a relatable atmosphere that makes listeners feel understood and supported. Their discussions are not sugar-coated or filtered, but instead delve into real-life struggles and triumphs. It is evident that they genuinely care about their audience, as they tackle topics that challenge listeners spiritually, mentally, and emotionally.
Another great aspect of this podcast is the excellent sound quality and the natural flow between Josh and Jenaye. The back-and-forth banter between them feels like a beautiful dance, with each complementing the other perfectly. This dynamic makes it incredibly easy to listen to their conversations, which in turn creates a calmness for the listener. Additionally, it's refreshing to hear their willingness to address uncomfortable truths and dive deeper into difficult topics. This commitment to sharing honest truth is commendable and greatly appreciated.
It's difficult to find any negative aspects of The Highly Unlikely with Josh & Jenaye podcast as they consistently deliver meaningful content. However, one potential downside could be that some listeners might find certain episodes challenging or uncomfortable due to the raw nature of the discussions. While this can be seen as a positive for those seeking genuine conversations, it may not appeal to everyone who prefers lighter or more surface-level content. However, for those who are open to growth and self-reflection, these episodes provide a unique opportunity for personal development.
In conclusion, The Highly Unlikely with Josh & Jenaye podcast is a gem among podcasts. Its authenticity, vulnerability, and encouraging nature make it a standout in the crowded podcast landscape. The chemistry between Josh and Jenaye combined with the excellent sound quality creates an enjoyable listening experience that leaves a lasting impact. I highly recommend this podcast to anyone seeking deep and meaningful conversations that challenge them to become more like Jesus.
Pastor Josh led a powerful conversation with NFL players Carson Wentz and Drue Tranquill, highlighting the importance of authentic friendship and intentional community. The two athletes shared their personal faith journeys, reflecting on how deep relationships—with each other and their teammates—have shaped them, especially as husbands and fathers.https://arenamen.org
What does it really look like to grieve—and keep going? Diane Haan, Ruby Paul and Pastor Diane Freitag join Pastors Josh and Jenaye to share personal stories of loss and healing. They talk openly about what it means to grieve well and move forward. You'll hear how healing often begins in unexpected ways—through Grief Share, Connect Groups, and simply showing up for one another. This episode offers hope, insight, and a powerful reminder that God is near, even in the hardest seasons.
Pastors Josh and Jenaye sit down with Bryce and Eden Meyer for a real, meaningful conversation about parenting. Together, they explore what it looks like to go beyond behavior management and truly connect with our kids' hearts. They share practical insights on building strong relationships through open communication, intentional time, and discipline that helps kids grow from the inside out. Tune in for honest encouragement and useful tools to help make your parenting journey more connected and intentional.
In this episode, Pastor Jenaye is joined by Jasmine, co-director of Bismarck Global Neighbors, for a heartfelt conversation about how we can support immigrants and refugees in meaningful, lasting ways. Grounded in the biblical call to love our neighbor, this conversation serves as both an invitation to welcome others into what you're already doing and a challenge to consider: Do we truly see and love our neighbor?
What does it really mean to grow into the man you're meant to be? In this episode of Highly Unlikely, Pastor Josh unpacks the stages of identity, purpose, and legacy—from childhood roots to midlife revelations. With real talk and biblical wisdom, it's a call to grow deeper, love better, and leave a lasting impact.https://www.arenamen.org/
In this episode, Pastors Josh and Jenaye sit down once again with Steve Pavek, who shares powerful updates about the Hub 1 Initiative in Alaska. Through the Alaska Student Partnership, teachers are being equipped to serve in remote villages—communities facing deep challenges like domestic violence, substance abuse, and isolation. They explore how building trust and forming relationships through education is opening doors for church planting and long-term gospel impact. https://www.whatihave.org
Jake and Megan Thomas join Pastor Jenaye in today's episode to share their journey through infertility, foster care, and adoption. They discuss how they learned to surrender their plans to God's timing and encourage believers to step into uncomfortable, vulnerable spaces while trusting His plan. The couple also shares how The Lily Initiative has been instrumental in supporting them through the challenges of foster care.thelilyinitiative.orgnexusfamilyhealing.org
Join Pastors Josh and Jenaye as they talk with Mark Testroet, the Chaplain at both the North Dakota State Penitentiary and Missouri River Correctional Center. Hear about the transformative work happening in the lives of residents as they encounter hope and purpose through faith in Jesus. Mark emphasizes how they are seeking something real and authentic and that the most requested item is a Bible!
Join Pastors Josh and Jenaye as they sit down with Noah VanVoorhis to discuss his journey of stepping out of his comfort zone to serve on Dream Teams at Evangel. Noah shares how serving in Production has provided community for him, given him opportunity to serve with his son, and opened doors to helping in Middle School Services and NextGen Summer Camps. He also talks about his role as a public school ESL teacher and how it allows him to serve students in the community learning English as a second language. Tune in for an inspiring conversation on how saying “yes” to God can transform your life and make a big church feel like family!
In this episode, we talk about a Highly Unlikely way to take the gospel to all nations. Tune in for a powerful conversation with Pastors Josh and Jenaye as Travis Gatzke shares his journey—from his time at Midwest Leadership College to his current role as Prison Outreach Coordinator. Hear stories about Alpha groups, water baptisms, and Evangel's upcoming in-person services in 2025 at the North Dakota State Penitentiary!
In this episode, Pastors Josh and Jenaye are joined by three licensed counselors to discuss the role biblical counseling can play in supporting mental, emotional and spiritual health. They explore counseling not just as a reaction to crises, but as a proactive step for everyone—similar to regular car maintenance. The conversation highlights how faith can be integrated into the healing process, showing how the tools from counseling can be taken to the Lord. They also tackle common stigmas around counseling, encouraging listeners to overcome these misconceptions and embrace it as a valuable resource.https://www.goevangel.org/care
Pastor Josh hosts a discussion with Bill and Karen Schneider, retirees who challenge the conventional view of retirement as only a time of enjoyment and leisure. They emphasize that while they may have stepped away from their jobs, they continue to serve God by establishing a clear purpose in retirement and redefining the retired lives around service and legacy. Ultimately, they encourage people to see their later years as an encore, using one's time, talents, and resources to make a meaningful Kingdom impact.
Pastor Josh welcomes Pastor Noah, who leads Way Church in Nashville. Noah discusses his book "Holy Habits," emphasizing that while encounters with Jesus can lead to freedom, developing spiritual habits is essential for maintaining that freedom. Noah also highlights the importance of creating safe spaces for vulnerability, particularly among the younger generation. This conversation serves as a heartfelt reminder of the power of genuine relationships, the significance of community, and the ongoing need for spiritual growth in one's life.
In this final episode of 2024, Pastors Josh and Jenaye share practical plans and rhythms to start your new year strong! They encourage listeners to reflect on the past year, not just focusing on successes, but also acknowledging and processing the challenges faced. And to ultimately ask for God's wisdom and guidance as we step into 2025 to fulfill what He has called us to do.
Pastors Josh and Jenaye continue to discuss navigating family dynamics during the holidays in Part 2 of Tension at the Table. In this episode they address the tensions that can arise when new relationships are added, such as marriages or children. Listeners are encouraged to establish boundaries and find win-win solutions for family gatherings.Tension at the Table Message:https://www.youtube.com/live/bibhJS4Sm-g
In Part 1 of Tension at the Table, Pastors Josh and Jenaye explore the challenges that often arise during family gatherings, particularly around the holidays. The conversation centers on the importance of spiritual maturity when navigating complex family dynamics, including the shifting roles between parents and adult children. Key principles and resources are shared for fostering healthy interactions within families. Book: Doing Life with Your Adult Children by Jim BurnsBook: A Matter of Time by Galen WoodwardTension at the Table Message:https://www.youtube.com/live/bibhJS4Sm-g
In Part 2 of "Highly Unlikely Holidays," Pastors Josh and Jenaye encourage listeners to create meaningful family traditions that foster gratitude and generosity, rather than getting caught up in consumerism. They highlight how to get into the Christmas spirit specificially at Evangel with special events like "Christmas at the Movies" series and Christmas Eve services. In closing they touch on the importance of rest and intentionality, and why Evangel will have a Sabbath Sunday to end the year.
In this episode of "Highly Unlikely Holidays," Pastors Josh and Jenaye emphasize the importance of prioritizing peace and generosity during the busy holiday season. They share personal experiences of balancing family commitments, financial planning, and the challenge of maintaining a Christ-centered focus amidst cultural pressures. Listeners are encouraged to evaluate their holiday practices to ensure they align with the values of love and community, rather than commercialization and stress.
In this episode Pastors Josh and Jenaye engage in a fun conversation about asking meaningful questions to deepen connections with loved ones. They share insights into their communication styles, particularly how they support each other during overwhelming times, and the importance of understanding what each partner needs. They conclude by encouraging listeners to foster intentionality in relationships through thought-provoking questions.
Pastor Josh interviews Ricardo, a teacher and soccer coach in Bismarck, who shares his remarkable journey from Haiti to the United States. Ricardo shares his inspiring journey from using makeshift soccer balls in Haiti to playing on the national team, ultimately leading to establishing the organization Lespwa Lavi, which means "Hope for Life." The organization provides food, education, and soccer opportunities for children in Haiti, significantly impacting their lives and communities. Together, they discuss how prayer has played a crucial role in overcoming challenges in their mission, demonstrating the transformative power of faith and community support.
In this episode, Pastors Josh and Jenaye engage in light-hearted conversation starters to share more about themselves while discussing relevant topics. They emphasize the importance of curiosity in relationships, highlighting how asking good questions can deepen connections. Both share their personal insights on household management, parenting, and navigating daily challenges within their marriage. They encouraging listeners to use similar conversation starters to enhance their own relationships.
Pastor Josh and Cory Phillips, Evangel's Garrison Campus Pastor, reflect on the journey of planting the Garrison campus and the significant changes ahead as Pastor Cory and his family prepare to transition into RV Missions. They discuss the challenges and blessings of their time in Garrison, emphasizing the importance of open hands and trusting God's direction. Pastor Cory shares how divine appointments at a summer camp illuminated their calling to assist rural churches while traveling as missionaries. Both Pastors Josh and Cory highlight the excitement and peace that comes with following God's leading.
Listen in as Pastors Josh and Jenaye talk with Holly and Dillon Wilson. Holly (also known as Hollyn) and Dillon share stories about playing college football, competing on "American Idol", leading a young adult ministry, walking away from a successful music career, meeting and getting married in only three months, and allowing God to use their creative talents and honest art to share Jesus with the world.
After 24 years touring as an award-winning, platinum-selling, country music singer-songwriter, Granger Smith left the music business to pursue a future in ministry. Listen in as Granger shares about the events that led to that decision and how God has shown His goodness and faithfulness through deep suffering and loss. Learn more about Granger's story in his book, "Like a River" or listen to the "Granger Smith Podcast" here: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLFiiulATGt9ZdXv6a8uz7cP1UHf5YC2sl
Join Pastors Josh and Jenaye in a special episode about prayer and fasting as Evangel prepares for 21 Days of Prayer and Fasting starting on August 1. Listen in as they talk about the practical and spiritual principles and benefits of incorporating regular prayer and fasting as part of following Jesus. Visit goevangel.org/media to find Pastor Josh's message about prayer and fasting.Visit ultimatedanielfast.com to find Daniel Fast information and resources.
Jordy Nuñez grew up in Miami before moving to the midwest, meeting his wife, and joining staff at Trinity Bible College in Ellendale, ND. Join Pastors Josh and Jenaye and listen in as Jordy shares the story of how he and his family felt God calling them to share the love and hope of Jesus in Estonia by starting a coffee shop.For more information or to contact Jordy, visit https://linktr.ee/nuneznomads.
This episode of Highly Unlikely is a follow-up to Evangel's MDWK event which featured an extended and in-depth teaching of the Old Testament. Listen in as Pastors Josh, Nate Chapman and Dylan Werner address and discuss some of the questions that were submitted live during MDWK event.This video from BibleProject was used to open MDWK: https://youtu.be/ALsluAKBZ-c?si=B5ECrwhzqNtW3zG5 Use this link to view the MDWK handout: https://i.pinimg.com/originals/5f/cb/c0/5fcbc02a8b3694c6fb9637055055ea30.png
This episode of Highly Unlikely is the second part of a live recording from Evangel's MDWK event and features an extended and in-depth teaching of the Old Testament. Pastors Josh and Jenaye, Nate Chapman, Dylan Werner, and Davion Logan-Brown talk through how the Old Testament tells the story of our wandering and God's redemption plan through Jesus. This video from BibleProject was used to open MDWK: https://youtu.be/ALsluAKBZ-c?si=B5ECrwhzqNtW3zG5 Use this link to view the MDWK handout: https://i.pinimg.com/originals/5f/cb/c0/5fcbc02a8b3694c6fb9637055055ea30.png
This episode of Highly Unlikely was recorded live at Evangel's MDWK event and features an extended and in-depth teaching of the Old Testament. Pastors Josh and Jenaye, Nate Chapman, Dylan Werner, and Davion Logan-Brown talk through how the Old Testament tells the story of our wandering and God's redemption plan through Jesus. This video from BibleProject was used to open MDWK: https://youtu.be/ALsluAKBZ-c?si=B5ECrwhzqNtW3zG5 Use this link to view the MDWK handout: https://i.pinimg.com/originals/5f/cb/c0/5fcbc02a8b3694c6fb9637055055ea30.png
Tabi Deraas joins Pastors Josh and Jenaye in today's episode. Tabi is a nurse who started Parking Lot Prayer Warriors during the height of the COVID pandemic. Listen in as Tabi shares more about that experience, her own personal faith journey of seeking physical healing, and how she experienced beauty through the waiting.
Listen in as Pastors Josh and Jenaye share some of the joys and challenges of working together! In this episode, they also talk more in depth about the difference between their two roles (Lead Pastor and Co-Lead Pastor) and the role of women in ministry.* *For more information about Evangel's beliefs on this subject, check out this message from Pastor Josh: https://www.youtube.com/live/PUZS3_CCMoQ?si=e_GZIbiBw80viHbD
In this very special episode, Pastors Josh and Jenaye are interviewed by guest host (and good friend!), Jordan Pope. Listen in as Jordan asks questions about how the Skjoldals ended up leading Evangel, life experiences that helped prepare them for these roles, who is speaking into their lives, and more.
This episode of Highly Unlikely was recorded live at Unique Conference 2023 and features a panel discussion with Pastors Josh and Jenaye, Pastor Alisha Weston, Susie Larson, Hollyn, and Liz Turner. This lively group shares honest wisdom, insight, and expereience in response to a wide variety of questions submitted by conference attenders. ADULT CONTENT: Please note that some material may not be suitable for children.
Join Pastors Josh and Jenaye for an open conversation and listen in as they share some of their personal convictions in areas that don't necessarily have "right" or "wrong" answers that apply the same to everyone. This episode covers topics like physical boundaries in dating, friendships with the opposite sex, and alcohol.
Dr. Jeff Rundio joins Pastors Josh and Jenaye in today's episode. Jeff is an ER doctor and serves on the board of Evangel. Listen in as Jeff talks about how his personal experience with Jesus changed how he views his patients, his family, and his purpose in life.
In this episode, Pastors Josh and Jenaye talk about why the people we surround ourselves with really matter and how our communities can influence our thinking, our decisions, and our faith. Listen in as they discuss the importance of developing authentic relationships with people who will encourage and challenge us as we follow Jesus.
Pastors Josh and Jenaye are kicking off a new rhythm for the Highly Unlikely podcast! Today's episode is a continuation and a deeper dive of the Q&A from the last episode. Pastors Josh and Jenaye respond to questions from listeners about boundaries and relationships with things like social media, finances, building healthy community, food and body image, and unhealthy family members.
With the holidays (and family time!) coming up, Pastors Josh and Jenaye welcome Pastor Alisha Weston to talk through some questions from listeners about boundaries. Pastor Alisha has a Master's in Professional Counseling and talks through how to have healthy boundaries with loved ones who have different values and beliefs, enmeshment in relationships with family members and friends, and triangulation.
Ryne Jungling is the Area Director for Fellowship of Christian Athletes (FCA). In this episode, he and his wife, Rachel, share about their seven-year journey with infertility, eventually having twins, and then dealing with the death of one of them. Ryne and Rachel share deep insight about guarding your heart against bitterness, the reality of God's tangible peace, and keeping an outward focus in the midst of immense suffering. For more information about how to contact or support the Junglings, visit www.fcand.org.
Galen Woodward is a husband, father, grandfather, and pastor who authored the book "A Matter of Time: Positioning Your Children to Change Their World One Moment at a Time" and has over 40 years of ministry experience. Listen in as Pastors Josh and Jenaye talk with him about the various stages of parenting, the importance of being intentional, how to have healthy relationships with your adult children, and how to navigate family tensions that can come up during the holidays.
After being married for 38 years, Mark and Kitty Burke faced a brokeneness in their marriage that they were afraid could never mend. In this episode, Pastors Josh and Jenaye visit with Mark and Kitty about how they worked through the shame and condemnation of sexual addiction, found true freedom, learned to trust again, and experienced forgiveness and restoration in their individual lives and in their family.
Paul Hurckman joins a conversation with Pastors Josh and Jenaye about the journey of foster care to adoption. Paul lives in north Minneapolis, is the father of a multi-racial family with two biological children and three adopted children, and is the Executive Director of Venture. Listen in as Paul talks about the importance of gaining a biblical understanding of justice, displaying grace and compassion towards one another, and being willing to enter into uncomfortable emotional spaces. For more information about Venture visit www.venture.org.
Join Pastor Jenaye for a beautiful and honest conversation with three other moms who have all made different choices about how to educate their children. Carmen Banta (private school mom), Eden Meyer (homeschool mom), and Dorie Brendel (public school mom) share how they made specific education decisions for their children, some of the stigmas that come with their decisions, and what they are learning from it all.
In this episode, Pastors Josh and Jenaye talk with Bob and Lorie Pope and their son, Jordan Pope. Bob and Lorie started Nexus Innovations, a high level strategic consulting company, and Jordan joined the famiy business a few year later. Listen in as the Popes talk through what it takes to build a healthy team culture and keep family relationships healthy while working together.
Listen in as Pastors Josh and Jenaye talk with Kitty Burke about her journey to develop a deeper longing and a more intentional time with the Lord. Kitty is a wife, mother, and grandmother who has walked with the Lord for many years and through many trials. In this episode, Kitty shares about how she is learning to slow down, abide with the Lord, and keep her eyes and heart fixed on Jesus.
When Lance and Anna Anderson's son was born, they were unaware of the challenges that were ahead. As they began raising a child with severe disabilities, God gave them deep peace about who He had made Ben to be. Listen in as Lance and Anna share openly and honestly about the joys and difficulties of this journey. If you have a heart for or a personal issue regarding special needs, feel free to email Anna at annamikal83@gmail.com.
Micah and Stephanie MacDonald have a deep passion to reach people for Jesus. Five years ago, they gave up their full-time jobs to start Mac Ministries and have given their lives to sharing the love of Jesus with young people all over the world. Micah is also the author of "Death To Life". To order the book or find more info, visit mac-ministries.com.
Andrew and Carmen Banta are seasoned leaders of "Financial Peace University" and have an incredible personal story regarding finances and debt. In this episode, Pastors Josh and Jenaye talk with Andrew and Carmen about how to have a heathy relationship with money and finances.
Listen in as Pastors Josh and Jenaye go in-depth about the complexities of dating and how to navigate the dating process in a way that honors Jesus. This episode is a deep-dive continuation from "The Family Handbook (That You Never Received)" series.
© 2020-2025 Ivy Podcast Discovery LLC
