The Cook & Joe Show

We take a deep dive into the DK Metcalf situation. What's the precedent for this situation? Lamar Jackson's situation was different. Joe cites a situation in Philadelphia a few years ago. There's another ordeal in 1999 in Denver. We take calls on the topic. Why didn't security intervene? It seems like Goddell will have the power to make the final ruling on Metcalf. Joe calls this an incorrect ruling. More calls on DK. Why isn't the national media referencing the Shaq Lawson ordeal as precedent? Nick Farabaugh thinks the Steelers can win a playoff game. There's no team in the AFC that the Steelers wouldn't have a chance against. Joe makes a bold playoff prediction. The Steelers are using the middle of the field suddenly, and Joe and Nick give possible explanations. The guys give their top 3 AFC teams as of right now. Nick would like the Steelers matchup against the Broncos. how many starters should sit for the Steelers if the Ravens lose? Joe would sit a ton of guys. Could Will Howard get some run? Joe's daughter had a slight driving mishap and it's very expensive. The Pro Bowl selections include Watt, Ramsey, and Skowronek. Tomlin press conference - Joe gives his highlights about Tomlin's comments on Metcalf. The Batkonian Mongoose joins to react to Tomlin's Metcalf comments, would this be as big of a deal if it wasn't part of the TV broadcast? Are Chad Johnson and James Harrison under the microscope now for their relaying of comments? Brian gives the latest on TJ Watt. Revisiting Tomlin's comments on Metcalf. Callers continue to weigh in on the topic. How was there not a bigger security presence? DK Metcalf's situation will void a lot of money in his contract. Tomlin had interesting comments about Myles Garrett and Derrick Harmon.

We take a deep dive into the DK Metcalf situation. What's the precedent for this situation? Lamar Jackson's situation was different. Joe cites a situation in Philadelphia a few years ago. There's another ordeal in 1999 in Denver. We take calls on the topic. Why didn't security intervene? It seems like Goddell will have the power to make the final ruling on Metcalf. Joe calls this an incorrect ruling. More calls on DK.

Revisiting Tomlin's comments on Metcalf. Callers continue to weigh in on the topic. How was there not a bigger security presence? DK Metcalf's situation will void a lot of money in his contract. Tomlin had interesting comments about Myles Garrett and Derrick Harmon

Why isn't the national media referencing the Shaq Lawson ordeal as precedent? Nick Farabaugh thinks the Steelers can win a playoff game. There's no team in the AFC that the Steelers wouldn't have a chance against. Joe makes a bold playoff prediction. The Steelers are using the middle of the field suddenly, and Joe and Nick give possible explanations. The guys give their top 3 AFC teams as of right now. Nick would like the Steelers matchup against the Broncos. how many starters should sit for the Steelers if the Ravens lose? Joe would sit a ton of guys. Could Will Howard get some run? Joe's daughter had a slight driving mishap and it's very expensive. The Pro Bowl selections include Watt, Ramsey, and Skowronek. 

Tomlin press conference - Joe gives his highlights about Tomlin's comments on Metcalf. The Batkonian Mongoose joins to react to Tomlin's Metcalf comments, would this be as big of a deal if it wasn't part of the TV broadcast? Are Chad Johnson and James Harrison under the microscope now for their relaying of comments? Brian gives the latest on TJ Watt.

DK Metcalf's situation will void a lot of money in his contract. Tomlin had interesting comments about Myles Garrett and Derrick Harmon.

Revisiting Tomlin's comments on Metcalf. Callers continue to weigh in on the topic. How was there not a bigger security presence?

The Batkonian Mongoose joins to react to Tomlin's Metcalf comments, would this be as big of a deal if it wasn't part of the TV broadcast? Are Chad Johnson and James Harrison under the microscope now for their relaying of comments? Brian gives the latest on TJ Watt.

Tomlin press conference - Joe gives his highlights about Tomlin's comments on Metcalf.

Joe's daughter had a slight driving mishap and it's very expensive. The Pro Bowl selections include Watt, Ramsey, and Skowronek.

Why isn't the national media referencing the Shaq Lawson ordeal as precedent? Nick Farabaugh thinks the Steelers can win a playoff game. There's no team in the AFC that the Steelers wouldn't have a chance against. Joe makes a bold playoff prediction. The Steelers are using the middle of the field suddenly, and Joe and Nick give possible explanations. The guys give their top 3 AFC teams as of right now. Nick would like the Steelers matchup against the Broncos. how many starters should sit for the Steelers if the Ravens lose? Joe would sit a ton of guys. Could Will Howard get some run? 

It seems like Goddell will have the power to make the final ruling on Metcalf. Joe calls this an incorrect ruling. More calls on DK.

We take a deep dive into the DK Metcalf situation. What's the precedent for this situation? Lamar Jackson's situation was different. Joe cites a situation in Philadelphia a few years ago. There's another ordeal in 1999 in Denver. We take calls on the topic. Why didn't security intervene?

Hour 1 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: The Pittsburgh Steelers are making us BELIEVERS. The Steelers held on to beat the Lions 29-24 on the final play. This is the first time in a long time that Joe thinks the Steelers have an actual chance to go to the Super Bowl. Bob thinks the main reason why is Aaron Rodgers. Sidney Crosby has passed Mario Lemieux for first all time in Penguins history. Joe gives us some gifts!

Hour 2 with Joe Starkey: If the season ended today, the Chargers would come to Pittsburgh. The Steelers offensive line has taken a leap and the running game is coming together. More information on the interaction between DK Metcalf and a fan. Tom Pelissero reported that Metcalf had previously reported the fan to the league when he was playing in Seattle.

Hour 3 with Joe Starkey: The Lions decided to go for it on 4th and goal from the three-yard line. Dan Campbell should have just put points on the board. The New England Patriots decision to trade Kyle Dugger to the Steelers was puzzling but great for the Steelers. In the short term, the Steelers have a chance to go into the playoffs and win a couple playoff games. It's ok to change your mind that the Steelers can succeed in the playoffs.

Hour 4 with Joe Starkey: Dan Orlovsky said on ESPN that he thinks the Steelers victory over the Lions was one of the most impressive games of the year. Around the NFL. Sidney Crosby passed Mario Lemieux for the most points in Penguins history with 1,724. Sidney Crosby is a top 5 player of all time and has an incredible resume.

Sidney Crosby passed Mario Lemieux for the most points in Penguins history with 1,724. Sidney Crosby is a top 5 player of all time and has an incredible resume. Mario might be the best player of all time, but Crosby's record of accomplishments are better. We are so lucky in Pittsburgh to have Sidney Crosby and Mario Lemieux.

Dan Orlovsky said on ESPN that he thinks the Steelers victory over the Lions was one of the most impressive games of the year. It starts with Aaron Rodgers. The AFC is wide open and Aaron Rodgers is playing very well. There is a chance the Steelers could play Denver in the playoffs. Would you sit starters against the Browns if the Ravens lose to Green Bay? The Patriots are 7-0 on the road.

The Steelers dominated the Lions rushing attack and didn't let them get any momentum. In the short term, the Steelers have a chance to go into the playoffs and win a couple playoff games. It's ok to change your mind that the Steelers can succeed in the playoffs.

The Lions decided to go for it on 4th and goal from the three-yard line. Dan Campbell should have just put points on the board. The New England Patriots decision to trade Kyle Dugger to the Steelers was puzzling but great for the Steelers. We were stunned that St. Brown didn't have his forward progress stopped.

Dennis in Shaler predicted the Steelers would win three games in a row to Austin and calls in! It was stunning to see Chris Boswell miss a field goal. We hear from Steelers fans about their optimism.

If the season ended today, the Chargers would come to Pittsburgh. The Steelers offensive line has taken a leap and the running game is coming together. Chad Johnson said that DK Metcalf told him the Lions fan he went after called him a racial slur and called his mom a slur when he was conversing with the Lions fan. Tom Pelissero reported that Metcalf had previously reported the fan to the league.

Lighting Ozzy calls in and wants to play and beat the Bills. Five pressing Steelers questions: What did you make of the DK Metcalf altercation with a fan. Bob thinks Metcalf will receive a one-game suspension. Adam Schefter reported on Saturday that Watt's return to play is murky and uncertain. Sidney Crosby has passed Mario Lemieux for first all time in Penguins history.

The Pittsburgh Steelers are making us BELIEVERS. The Steelers held on to beat the Lions 29-24 on the final play. This is the first time in a long time that Joe thinks the Steelers have an actual chance to go to the Super Bowl. Bob thinks the main reason why is Aaron Rodgers. Rodgers has been elite the last few weeks.

Steelers go for season-defining win in Detroit without Watt, FSG sells the Penguins and the Pirates trade for a big bat in the lineup.

The full Pomp and Joe Show, with Joe Starkey, Donny Football, and Austin Bechtold (behind the glass), from Friday, December 19th, 2025

Hour 1 with Joe Starkey and Donny Football: If the Steelers win and the Ravens lose, the Steelers could have the division clinched next week. If the Steelers lose and the Ravens win, the division will come down to Week 18. Donny thinks it will be a 38-30 game! Joe thinks that this is going to be a close game and have a score well into the 30s.

Hour 2 with Joe Starkey and Donny Football: Steelers reporter Ray Fittipaldo of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette joined the show. Ray doesn't think T.J. Watt will play in Detroit. Nick Herbig hasn't practiced with a hamstring. Derrick Harmon is good to go and is going back home to play since his time at Michigan State. Ray has 41-38 Lions with Jared Goff MVP. The Numbers Game in Steelers-Lions.

Hour 3 with Joe Starkey and Donny Football: Nick takes Patriots +3 with us picking the Ravens to beat New England The line is down to 6.5 in Steelers-Lions and Nick doesn't really want to bet the game, but likes the over. The Pirates have acquired 2B Brandon Lowe and two players for Mike Burrows. We think it's a really good deal for the Pirates. Lowe hit 31 home runs last year and on an expiring contract.

Hour 4 with Joe Starkey and Donny Football: The Quiz Show. Can Donny win it again??

Joe Starkey, Donny Football, and Austin Bechtold's College football and NFL Week 16 picks!

The Quiz Show - Pirates vs. Lions. Can Donny win AGAIN?!

The Pirates have acquired 2B Brandon Lowe and two players for Mike Burrows. We think it's a really good deal for the Pirates. Lowe hit 31 home runs last year and on an expiring contract. Donny is ok with the Pirates trading Mike Burrows. Pitt volleyball lost in the Final Four for the fifth consecutive year. Pitt linebacker Kyle Louis has declared for the draft and will likely be a safety.

Nick takes Patriots +3 with us picking the Ravens to beat New England. The line is down to 6.5 in Steelers-Lions and Nick doesn't really want to bet the game, but likes the over. Matthew Stafford remains the favorite for NFL MVP.

The numbers that matter in Steelers-Lions in Detroit!

Ray doesn't think T.J. Watt will play in Detroit. Nick Herbig hasn't practiced with a hamstring. Derrick Harmon is good to go and is going back home to play since his time at Michigan State. Ray thinks Kenneth Gainwell needs to be a priority for the Steelers in the offseason. Ray has 41-38 Lions with Jared Goff MVP.

Donny has the Lions winning 38-30 and thinks the Lions offense is so dynamic to stop. Dan Campbell is calling plays and the Lions are No. 1 in the NFL in scoring. Joe picks a VERY close game.

If the Steelers win and the Ravens lose, the Steelers could have the division clinched next week. If the Steelers lose and the Ravens win, the division will come down to Week 18. We are going to see Jack Sawyer have an opportunity to start. Zach Frazier has popped up on the injury report. Donny is 100% ruling out T.J. Watt and Joe would also be stunned if Watt plays.

The full Pomp and Joe Show, with Joe Starkey and Austin Bechtold, from Thursday, December 18th, 2025

Hour 1 with Joe Starkey and Tyler Kennedy: The Penguins typically start the season well, but TK thinks they are playing way too safe in the third period. How can the Penguins bounce back from this? TK thinks trading Tristan Jarry was selling high, but Stuart Skinner is similar to Jarry. The Penguins are being sold to the Hoffmann family of companies. Pittsburgh likes a family feel more than a corporate feel.

Hour 2 with Joe Starkey and Chris Hoke: The Steelers maintained momentum and applied pressure on the Dolphins in the second half. Derrick Harmon has been impactful as a rookie despite not a lot of splash plays. Detroit needs to win this game and likely to win out. Chris Hoke thinks that Queen plays better when the defensive line is keeping him clean and Queen can fly to the football.