POPULARITY
There is a comfort between Sidney Crosby and Mike Sullivan and Sullivan has been loyal to the Penguins. Jay thinks the Penguins need to find a top-six forward and find guys who can gel together in the bottom six. Jay thinks the Penguins need to see someone different in net and goaltending let them down this year.
Hour 2 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: Jay thinks the Penguins need to find a top-six forward and find guys who can gel together in the bottom six. Jay thinks the Penguins need to see someone different in net. Longtime Steelers insider Gerry Dulac is adamant the Steelers won't take Shedeur Sanders. Gerry's sources said there was a 0% chance the Steelers pick Kenny Pickett... could this be similar?
Jay Caufield calls in to talk about the pens and their season ahead of tonight's Fan appreciation season closer.
Jay thinks the No. 1 priority for the Penguins needs to be figuring out their goaltending. Solid goaltending can allow the Penguins to take a step up and overcome shortcomings on other parts of the team. If the Penguins want to compete, they MUST hit on the decisions they make.
Hour 2 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: Stanley Cup Champion Jay Caufield joined the show. Kris Letang has surgery to replace a small hole in his heart. Jay thinks the No. 1 priority for the Penguins needs to be figuring out their goaltending. The Steelers have concluded their top 30 visits with 10 defensive lineman and nine running backs. The Pirates are offering fans replica Bucco Bricks that fans can have for free that previously had a brick years ago, in addition to their new display.
Alex Ovechkin scored 895 and Jay thinks what Sidney Crosby and Alex Ovechkin have done has helped keep hockey relevant for a long time. No one thought this could be done. Bob and Jay both think Mario Lemieux would be the all-time goal scorer if he didn't get hurt. Sidney Crosby could end up being a top 5 goal scorer ever.
Hour 2 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: Alex Ovechkin scored 895 and Jay thinks what Sidney Crosby and Alex Ovechkin have done has helped keep hockey relevant for a long time. Bob and Jay both think Mario Lemieux would be the all-time goal scorer if he didn't get hurt. Six of the nine hitters in the lineup last night were hitting under .200. Ian Rapoport thinks the draft could be a realistic deadline for Aaron Rodgers to sign, or the Steelers will draft a quarterback.
The Penguins have promoted a few young players, including Rutger McGroarty, and Jay thinks they played at a good tempo with Sidney Crosby and trying to adapt to the speed of the game. Jay thinks Crosby still has a lot left in the tank but won't be someone that goes to another line if he isn't ELITE.
Hour 2 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: The Penguins have promoted a few young players, including Rutger McGroarty. Jay thinks Crosby still has a lot left in the tank but won't be someone that goes to a second or third line and still play if he can't be at a great, elite level. NFL rule changes. Half the NFL wants to ban the tush push, including the Steelers.
Jay Caufield made a huge upset against Colby Armstrong as a 16 seed in the media madness bracket! The Penguins had a really bad night against Tampa Bay and Jay said there was not enough help in front of Tristan Jarry. With 10 games left and playing a good team, the game got away from them with four goals in just under four minutes.
Hour 2 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: Jay Caufield made a huge upset against Colby Armstrong as a 16 seed in the media madness bracket! The Penguins had a really bad night against Tampa Bay and Jay said there was not enough help in front of Tristan Jarry. Gerry Dulac reported that Russell Wilson wanted to come back to the Steelers, right up until the end. What happened? The Steelers said they wanted Wilson to be back, but clearly didn't want to bring him back.
Hour 3 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: Jay said the Penguins had a little bad luck to start the third period against the Islanders but they had multiple breakdowns. It could be the dagger for a playoff spot. Mark doesn't think Aaron Rodgers news will take a month, but also won't be a few days too. Does Mason Rudolph deserve another chance to start?
Many teams in the East are falling apart and the Penguins started to climb the ladder with a four-game winning streak. Jay said the Penguins had a little bad luck to start the third period against the Islanders but they had multiple breakdowns. This could be the dagger to their hopes.
Jay wants the Penguins to ride it out right now with Tristan Jarry, who has played well the last two games. Joe doesn't trust Kyle Dubas to turn the Penguins around to win with Sidney Crosby. Jay thinks the decisions Dubas makes with draft picks, or trading picks to receive good players, will define this era.
Hour 2 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: Jay wants the Penguins to ride it out right now with Tristan Jarry, who has played well the last two games. Joe doesn't trust Kyle Dubas to turn the Penguins around to win with Sidney Crosby. Pat McAfee retweeted a tweet from 2021 where Aaron Rodgers spoke of his love for Pittsburgh. Will Rodgers announce his decision??
Jay gives the argument why the Penguins wouldn't trade Rickard Rakell because he has three years remaining at $5 million per season. If the Penguins are still trying to build around Sidney Crosby, why would you take that away from Sid? At the same time, Jay admits Rakell's value has never been higher and could get a good return for him too.
Hour 2 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: Jay makes the case why the Penguins wouldn't trade Rickard Rakell because he has three years remaining at $5 million per season. At the same time, Rakell's value has never been higher. One mock draft has Tyler Warren 18th and Ashton Jeanty in the same range. Would you trade up for one of those players? Would you sign Adams?
Goaltending has been a significant concern for the Penguins, but defensive breakdowns have not helped them whatsoever. Other teams are taking advantage against the Pens and the Penguins do not punch back. Trading Erik Karlsson will be very difficult with a no-trade and $10 million contract.
Hour 2 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: Goaltending has been a significant concern for the Penguins, but defensive breakdowns have not helped them whatsoever. Other teams are taking advantage against the Pens and the Penguins do not punch back. NFLPA grades are here! What do we make of the grades?
Lange was a huge draw to the Penguins early in their existence to grow the PGH audience. Mike Lange taught the game to so many fans and people would call in to offer suggestions for goal calls. Jay mentioned how people would repeat his calls throughout the country at events too. We think Lange would have loved to call USA-Canada and be a part of this game.
Hour 3 with Bob Pompeani: Mike Lange was a huge draw to the Penguins early in their existence to grow the PGH audience. Jay Caufield mentioned how people would repeat his calls throughout the country at events too. Pirates broadcaster Greg Brown's career was significantly enhanced by Lange.
Four Nations has created so much buzz. We react to Jay Caufield's take on the first USA/Canada matchup. Will other sports adopt this?
RIP Mike Lange. Dorin shares his memories of Mike Lange and his youth following the Pens. He was synonymous with the Pens for decades, but also inspired countless broadcasters. Four Nations has created so much buzz. We react to Jay Caufield's take on the first USA/Canada matchup. Will other sports adopt this? O'Neil Cruz will be crucial for the Pirates if they have success. He was part of bringing in Tommy Pham. Is he turning the corner in his career? Dorin's favorite Fan 15 clip - Ron Cook calling Eric as Ron Jeremy.
Jay thought Team USA played the game to perfection and fed off the booing of the national anthem and energy associated with the game. Bryan Rust and Evgeni Malkin are practicing for the Penguins and Jay thinks with other teams losing, the Penguins still have a chance to make a run.
Hour 2 with Joe Starkey: Jay thought Team USA played the game to perfection and fed off the booing of the national anthem and energy associated with the game. Bryan Rust and Evgeni Malkin are practicing for the Penguins and Jay thinks with other teams losing, the Penguins still have a chance to make a run. MLB is testing robot umps in spring training.
Tyler Kennedy thinks Sid can play for four more years. Mario Lemieux made a surprise appearance at the 4 Nations Face-Off and Jay Caufield thinks it's a shame Mario is not around anymore. Mario's feelings are very clear on the current ownership. Jeff tells us how Pitt Athletics needs to continue to raise money and schools are going to have to hand out $20 million total for athletes.
Hour 4 with Bob Pompeani Joe Starkey, and Jeff Hathhorn: Jeff Hathhorn joins for the full four. Jay Caufield thinks it's a shame Mario is not around anymore. Mario's feelings are very clear on the current ownership. Jeff tells us how Pitt Athletics needs to continue to raise money and schools are going to have to hand out $20 million total for athletes. Mark Kaboly reported the Steelers don't have interest in Trevor Lawrence.
Bob and Jay both think Team USA has a deep roster and has a great chance to win with their goaltending. Jay thinks Leon Draisaitl is the NHL MVP right now. The Capitals and Rangers have been the biggest surprises of the season for good and bad reasons.
Hour 2 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: Bob and Jay both think Team USA has a deep roster and has a great chance to win with their goaltending. The Capitals and Rangers have been the biggest surprises of the season for good and bad reasons. Ben Cherington pointed to Darick Hall and DJ Stewart as options at first base.
Hour 2 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: Jay believes the Penguins did a good job getting a 1st round pick and Danton Heinen for Marcus Pettersson and Drew O'Conner. Starkey is in disbelief the Steelers wouldn't let Russell Wilson make changes at the line of scrimmage. It's strange because they wouldn't let Kenny Pickett or Justin Fields audible and going to Wilson for his veteran presence.
Jay thinks it's critical to see how the Penguins do in these upcoming Metro games to make a decision on fully selling. If they don't win a ton of games, Jay thinks Kyle Dubas will make the changes he's been discussing before the trade deadline in March.
Join Josh and Louie as they sit down and talk with Penguins' legend, Jay Caufield! Follow us: YouTube - @PensCollective X - @PensCollective Instagram - @PensCollective Facebook - @PensCollective Join our Discord:Discord/ThePenguinsCollective ROGUE ENERGY⚡️rogueenergy.com/penscollective Use Code TPC10 for 10% Off all orders! See you in the next episode, and as always, LET'S. GO. PENS.
We knew this stretch would define the Penguins season and it has brought them to the bottom of the standings. Mario has been very hands off with the Penguins and his relationship with Fenway Sports Group isn't great. Jay thinks if Mario feels he is in the right, he's not going to change and cater to someone.
Hour 2 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: We knew this stretch would define the Penguins season and it has brought them to the bottom of the standings. Jay doesn't think this is all on Mike Sullivan and the players need to step up. Mario Lemiuex has been very hands off with the Penguins and his relationship with Fenway Sports Group isn't very good. Erik Karlsson called Sharks rookie Macklin Celebrini a great kid and said maybe he'll see Celebrini soon, "who knows."
Dr. Jay Calvert chats with NHL Legend Jay Caufield! The two Jay's discuss the up-and-down start to the 2024-25 season for the Pens, how Monday night's win over the Kings represents the blueprint the Pens need for the rest of the year, how the West Coast road trip could unite the team, the looming trade deadline, Matt Grzelcyk, PO Joseph, needing more out of Erik Karlsson, In Rust We Trust, tonight's game vs the Ducks, and the incredible work from the Mario Lemieux Foundation!
Show recap including Jay Caufield's memories of traveling to different parts of the country with the Penguins and the Paul Skenes $1 million dollar autograph patch signed card.
Hour 2 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: Jay went to college in North Dakota and was as cold as it is today with -4 degree weather! Jay tells us about pregame meals, travel, his favorite cities, flying commercial, team building events, and stories from playing. The Limitless Express: Today's top football stories!
Jay went to college in North Dakota and was as cold as it is today with -4 degree weather! Jay tells us about pregame meals, travel, his favorite cities, flying commercial, team building events, and stories from playing.
Hour 4 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: Steelers owner Jim Rooney said the Steelers have outperformed the NFL average over the last 25 years and perform in a harder circumstance than most, but understand they haven't won playoff games the last eight years. Jay Caufield's memories of traveling to different parts of the country with the Penguins and the Paul Skenes $1 million dollar autograph patch signed card.
Tristan Jarry once again gave up a bad goal and there have been breakdowns defensively. The Penguins need to evaluate their options at goalie and consider Joel Blomqvist. Jay thinks the upcoming road trip will tell what the Penguins ultimately will do at goalie, especially Jarry.
Hour 2 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: Tristan Jarry once again gave up a bad goal and there have been breakdowns defensively. The Penguins need to evaluate their options at goalie and consider Joel Blomqvist. Joe thinks Lamar-Allen is one of the best quarterback matchups in playoff history. Which NFL head coach is under the most pressure in the playoffs?
Jay Caufield joins to discuss the lack of juice in the game last night, Jarry continues to give up goals on the first shot of the game, Croby's greatness, Joe's interesting proposal for 4 on 4 in the third period, the bad slashing call, his thoughts on new golf technology. What is at stake this Saturday? Would a loss be the low point of Tomlin's career? What this game means for Wilson's future? Do parrots have nipples? It's huge for Pickens, either to sign an extension or increase his trade value. Arthur Smith needs a good game to become a head coach. When should you take a Christmas tree down?
Jay Caufield joins to discuss the lack of juice in the game last night, Jarry continues to give up goals on the first shot of the game, Croby's greatness, Joe's interesting proposal for 4 on 4 in the third period, the bad slashing call, his thoughts on new golf technology.
Joe is starting to lean towards picking the Steelers. Bob isn't as optimistic. There's demons on both sides of this matchup. Deshon Elliott and Donte Jackson being available should make a big difference this time, and Watt should have a bigger impact. The Steelers are truly desperate this time. Things could go either way with Pickens. Joe thinks Boz will be crucial in this game. The Steelers should force feed Pickens, and Jaylen Warren needs 25 touches. Fields should get a few touches too. Pomp wants to see them air it out early. The Steelers need to show something different. The defense may try to punish Lamar if he runs. The Steelers will try to make it ugly and hope the Ravens will blow it. A comparison to the Miracle on Ice. Do we believe in miracles?? How many points do the Steelers need to score to win? George Michalowski joins to discuss Pitt's loss at Duke, Cooper Flagg. How good are the Panthers? Can Pitt still build a great resume? The General is giving a Joe Burrow card this week. Nobody has found the Skenes card!? Meet the Parents talk. Jay Caufield joins to discuss the lack of juice in the game last night, Jarry continues to give up goals on the first shot of the game, Croby's greatness, Joe's interesting proposal for 4 on 4 in the third period, the bad slashing call, his thoughts on new golf technology. What is at stake this Saturday? Would a loss be the low point of Tomlin's career? What this game means for Wilson's future? Do parrots have nipples? It's huge for Pickens, either to sign an extension or increase his trade value. Arthur Smith needs a good game to become a head coach. When should you take a Christmas tree down? Dan Campbell gives great speeches. Bob and Joe give their SB picks as of right now. It's a big game for Najee, but Warren should be the guy anyway. Justin Fields, the Steelers tackles allow a ton of sacks. Mark Kaboly reacts to his new nickname, he is picking the Steelers, what they'll need to do to pull off the upset, the predictability of the Steelers offense, did the Ravens really insult Pickens or was that a fake video, how will Pickens respond, the Steelers defense and stopping the run, free association - final score, game ball, Najee/Warren, Fields touches, Watt sacks, Pickens TDs, Henry yards, Highsmith sacks. We miss Ron Cook, Peter King thinks Aaron Rodgers could come to Pittsburgh. What will the team do at QB? Mullsy the Snowman returns, Joe is very proud. The Pens game was boring.
The Penguins have a different energy around them now and Jay feels they are on the up. Losing two points to Detroit when the schedule becomes difficult is not ideal but he thinks the Penguins are on the right track in the Metro.
Hour 2 with Bob Pompeani: The Penguins have a different energy around them now and Jay feels they are on the up. Losing two points to Detroit when the schedule becomes difficult is not ideal but he thinks the Penguins are on the right track in the Metro. Questions remain on what the Steelers long-term answer is at quarterback with Fields and Wilson.
Hour 2 with Bob Pompeani and Joe Starkey: The Penguins are on a roll and other teams are not playing well, allowing the Penguins to move up in the standings. He thinks Lamar will have a big game and there is voter fatigue with Lamar to win MVP and Josh Allen will win. Rob would rather win playoff games than the division being valued as a great prize to mount a successful season.
The Penguins are on a roll and other teams are not playing well, allowing the Penguins to move up in the standings. Depth scoring and timely goal scoring has been big for the Penguins especially with Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin aren't scoring. Jay discussed how Ned and Tristan Jarry have shared time in goal.
The game against Colorado got away from the Penguins and couldn't contain the Avs in the third period. Ryan Graves was -2 in +/- last night but Jay thinks he is starting to, and needs to be more physical. The power play has gained momentum with Evgeni Malkin being split on the second power play.
Hour 2 with Joe Starkey: The game against Colorado got away from the Penguins and couldn't contain the Avalanche in the third period. Ryan Graves was -2 in +/- last night but Jay thinks he is starting to, and needs to be more physical. Big Ben revealed that Mike Tomlin is second behind Dan Campbell in his Coach of the Year rankings. Who is your NFL Coach of the Year?