Couple of Critics Podcast

Follow Couple of Critics Podcast
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

Sam and Michelle Eisert have similar, yet radically different tastes. In this podcast they submit their favorite media from the past and present to each other to discuss and review.

Sam and Michelle Eisert


    • May 14, 2025 LATEST EPISODE
    • monthly NEW EPISODES
    • 1h 48m AVG DURATION
    • 318 EPISODES


    Search for episodes from Couple of Critics Podcast with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from Couple of Critics Podcast

    318. PAXTOWEEN 2025

    Play Episode Listen Later May 14, 2025 124:30


    Curiosity won't kill the Jonesy, but will it make Michelle regret choosing Aliens for this year's annual Paxtoween? Join the critics for the 4th annual Paxtoween hullabaloo where celebrating the superior Bill P. and his love of fried food is the name of the game, Man.

    317. 13 Songs by Fugazi

    Play Episode Listen Later May 7, 2025 106:32


    This week is a new one for both the critics, kind of. Sam finally decides to give Fugazi a chance again after 30 something years. This episode features a mini-episode of The Abraham Lincoln Crack Emporium Show.

    316. Bridge Over Troubled Water by Simon and Garfunkel

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 30, 2025 115:10


    Well, hey there. I guess it's a good time to tell you that we're back, and we're ready to be a source of love and light for you again, if love and light are boogers and farts. This week, we're picking up where we unexpectedly left off with Bridge Over Troubled Water by Simon and Garfunkel. This episode features some health advice, and Stacy's not happy about it.

    315. Burn After Reading

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 20, 2024 101:10


    This week the discussion is about the 2008 Coen Brothers movie Burn After Reading. With the ridiculous ravings of John Malkovich, the self-induced paranoia from George Clooney, and the rest of the insane cast line-up there is a good amount of stupidity to talk about.

    314. Made Of Bricks by Kate Nash

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 15, 2024 96:23


    With their best Cockney accents and flair for attitude, the critics review Made Of Bricks by Kate Nash. Will any of this break through Sam's hard candy shell to reveal his soft creamy center?

    313. The Number of the Beast by Iron Maiden

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 5, 2024 89:23


    In somewhat typical fashion Sam chooses metal that talks about Satan! This week the critics finally do their due diligence and listen to The Number of the Beast by Iron Maiden.

    312. The Monster Mash

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 29, 2024 69:25


    Happy Halloween! This week's spooky episode is dedicated to the most popular Halloween song of all time. Michelle got her favorite grave robbing shovel out dug through the catacombs to find 10 versions of The Monster Mash to listen to and dissect. Will they make it to the end or will they go completely, stark- raving mad before they can escape the clutches of Bobby "Boris" Picket!? This episode features a very scary message about the most horrifying season of all.

    311. The Kids and Me by Billy Preston

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 23, 2024 87:23


    The critics travel back to 1974 to review some classic tunes by Billy Preston. While discussing the album The Kids and Me, Billy's past dramas unfurl. Can the art be separated from the artist, or must they merge forever? This episode features a plea from J.D. Vance.

    310. Mother's Finest

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 16, 2024 78:23


    This week the critics listen to and discuss a group neither had heard of known as Mother's Finest. Will it be their new favorite thing or will it be the last time they listen to it ever again? This episode features a grumpy Abe Lincoln.

    309. In the Court of the Crimson King by King Crimson

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 9, 2024 105:44


    Since the critics can't seem to get enough progressive rock, they are reviewing In the Court of the Crimson King by King Crimson. Nerds unite! This episode features a ravenous parody of a rock'n'roll classic.

    308. The First Four Years by Black Flag

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 2, 2024 90:19


    This podcast works it's way through major punk bands through out musical history and this week is a necessary stop. This episode is dedicated to listening to and reviewing Black Flag's The First Four Years This episode features a musical classic.

    307. Survivor by Destiny's Child

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 25, 2024 129:45


    Is Samuel ready for this jelly? Is Michelle ready for this jelly? Critics are you ready for this jelly? Is Destiny's Child's Survivor too Bootylicious for you, baby? This episode includes a commercial for Slick @ Sight.

    306. A Night At The Opera by Queen

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 18, 2024 102:21


    This week is Sam's choice and he went for one of the biggest bands in Rock N' Roll history! This episode is dedicated to listening to and reviewing A Night At The Opera by Queen. Featuring a psychiatrist visit.

    305. Pink Flamingos

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 11, 2024 111:43


    Ah, yes. It's the episode that no one asked for. The critics review the 1972 NC-17 cult classic, Pink Flamingos. Strap in for a real sausage fest. This episode features a ditty from a man who was a bit of a horse fanatic.

    304. Haunted by Six Feet Under

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 3, 2024 102:04


    This week it's time to not brush your hair, smoke bongs, and listen to Six Feet Under. That's right, the critics are talking about the master of "EEEEEEEEEE" himself, Chris Barnes and the Six Feet Under debut album Haunted. This episode features an ad for a guitar player.

    303. Cosmic Thing by The B-52's

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 28, 2024 112:04


    Put on your beehive wigs and kitschy clothes because this week the Critics are talking about Cosmic Thing by The B-52's! This week features a Couple of Critics Classic.

    couple critics cosmic thing
    302. Jumanji

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 21, 2024 105:23


    This week the critics review.... Jumanji. That's right. Jumanji. Robin Williams. Kirsten Dunst. Jumanji. This episode features an announcement from a musician.

    301. The Spaghetti Incident? by Guns N' Roses

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 14, 2024 101:57


    With 300 episodes out of the way, it's time for podcast all-star Travis Harpster to come back and torture the critics. Knowing Michelle's distaste for Axl Rose he naturally chose the fifth studio release from Guns N Roses. This week is a dive into The Spaghetti Incident? Featuring Disgust Discussed!

    300. The 300th Episode Special w/ Zach and Chris!

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 7, 2024 106:08


    It's the Couple of Critics podcast 300th episode, and we brought in a couple of guests to celebrate! Chris and Zach join the critics in discussing songs they like but never need to hear again, all while competing for extravagant prizes and a high fiber diet.

    299. Rumours by Fleetwood Mac

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 31, 2024 98:14


    Drug addictions, band tensions, and lovers quarrels are the theme for this episode's album. This week the critics listen to and review Rumours by Fleetwood Mac. This episode features a warning from your soon to be robot overlord.

    299. Live Through This by Hole

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 24, 2024 83:37


    In a true act of heroism, Sam decided to bring some much needed female energy to the podcast. Since Sam definitely doesn't hate women and women's voices, this week's album is Live Through This by Hole. This episode features an ad from Connie Fupashank.

    297. Audioslave

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 17, 2024 140:31


    When one band reaches it's end, a new band is born. This week, ye ol' critics review the debut, self-titled album by the band Audioslave. This episode features a segment from the hit TV show Doin' It Dawny Style.

    296. House of Pain (Fine Malt Lyrics)

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 10, 2024 111:13


    Out of an Irish left field comes this week's album choice! Sam has decided to take another dive into the unknown with House of Pain (Fine Malt Lyrics) by House of Pain. This episode is brought to you by Angus McFist's Anal Fisting Salve

    295. Songs For The Deaf by Queens of the Stone Age

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 3, 2024 101:01


    Do you like the rock music? Are you content hearing two dumb dumbs tell you their opinions about it? Sam and Michelle decided to review Songs For The Deaf by Queens of the Stone Age, so you're in luck. Listen now, or bad luck and extreme misfortune will infest your pathetic soul for all eternity. This episode features a Night Crüe anthem.

    294. Desolation Boulevard by Sweet

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 26, 2024 96:12


    Taking a dive into the unknown seems to be the habit for Sam as of late and this week is no different. It's time for the the critics to listen to and discuss Desolation Boulevard by English glam rock band Sweet. Are you ready, Steve? This episode features an emergency episode of The Abraham Lincoln Crack Emporium Show.

    291. Bad by Michael Jackson

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 19, 2024 105:40


    Michael Jackson was a hit-making dancing machine, so Michelle wanted to review the album Bad by the almighty, sequined-gloved one. What was the Moonwalker movie really about? Was the Bad album better than Thriller? Does pool ball dust hurt eyeballs? This episode features a little writer's block

    290. Ramones

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 12, 2024 115:42


    Sometimes classic albums slip through the cracks. This episode rectifies one of those situations. What kind of punk does Sam think he is? This week he finally chose to give the debut album by The Ramones it's due. This episode features another episode of Hell Corner with Herschel J. Pinhead!

    289. The 1 to 10 Playlist

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 5, 2024 96:48


    Michelle decided to make another compilation playlist, this time with numbers 1-10 in the song titles. Does Sam wish Michelle would stop making playlists and just choose full albums like an adult? Is Michelle projecting? Listen now! This episode includes the new hit single, "34 4 45."

    289. Insecurity Notoriety by Arson Anthem

    Play Episode Listen Later May 29, 2024 132:38


    This week Sam gets back to his angry music with another Phil Anselmo project. This episode is all about Arson Anthem's Insecurity Notoriety and the love that Michelle will undoubtedly have for it! This episode features a mini-sode of Hell Corner with Herschel J. Pinhead.

    287. There's Something About Mary

    Play Episode Listen Later May 22, 2024 129:35


    While looking back at comedy movies, opinions are likely to vary. This week, we decided to do a re-watch of There's Something About Mary. It's time to get to the bottom of how the beans got above the frank.

    286. PAXTOWEEN 2024

    Play Episode Listen Later May 15, 2024 119:56


    It's the annual Paxtoween celebration where the critics review something from the late great Bill Paxton. This year, the critics are reviewing the album Holy Cow by Bill Paxton's 80s new wave band Martini Ranch. The critics also decide which style potato chip they fancy.

    285. Doggystyle By Snoop Doggy Dogg

    Play Episode Listen Later May 8, 2024 111:24


    It's time to make another stop on Sam's rap journey. When one is traversing such a vast genre, it is impossible not to familiarize yourself with the one and only Snoop Dogg. This week the critics listen to and discuss his debut studio album Doggystyle. This episode is sponsored by Barry Bonkers Bodega of Breakables!

    284. Cosmo's Factory by Creedence Clearwater Revival

    Play Episode Listen Later May 1, 2024 112:50


    Sometimes, we have a change of Heart, and instead of trying bland castle food, we gravitate towards good old-fashioned American comfort food. It's time to gobble up Cosmo's Factory by Creedence Clearwater Revival. This episode features a rousing round of Guess That Melody!

    283. Rubberneck by Toadies

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 24, 2024 99:12


    In a desperate search for material, did Sam stumble on a shining gem by choosing Rubberneck by Toadies OR will he hate it and just keep listening to Cannibal Corpse? Either way, this episode is about the previously mentioned album by the previously mentioned band. I don't mean Cannibal Corpse.

    282. Fat Boys

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 17, 2024 100:45


    Grab some pizzas and some tenderloins while you stuff your face and listen to Fat Boys. This episode is brought to you by DDDDoDG

    281. John Carpenter's The Thing

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 10, 2024 153:20


    If you hate dogs and love KY Jelly, then this week's episode is for you. Listen as the critics get into their favorite slimy puppet scenes and of course discuss who they think was the final assimilation! This episode is features a brave performance as The Jugg Hutt.

    282. Blood, Sweat & Tears

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 3, 2024 127:13


    What do the Cold War, Little Stevie Winwood, and Sam's mom all have in common? If you guessed baking banana booger bread, well then baby, you're incorrect. This week, the critics review the self-titled album from the band Blood, Sweat & Tears. This episode features a special birthday shout-out.

    281. The Stooges

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 27, 2024 77:28


    Sam calls himself some sort of punker and he hasn't even listened to an album by The Stooges!?This week he tries to fix being such a poser by choosing the self-titled album by The Stooges featuring that wiggling man made of sun-dried leather called Iggy Pop. This episode features a few minutes of ASMR from Outregis Philbin.

    280. The Godfather

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 20, 2024 170:24


    The critics have watched and reviewed one of the most beloved movies of all time, The Godfather. Did this movie offer entertainment they couldn't refuse, or is this movie swimming with the fishes? This episode includes an inspired montage.

    279. Chicago Transit Authority by Chicago

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 13, 2024 107:51


    With blind spots in classic rock comes the need to explore what you don't know. This week is exactly that. It's time for the critics to listen to and talk about Chicago Transit Authority by Chicago.

    278. Gangsta's Paradise by Coolio

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 6, 2024 130:12


    If you can't take the heat, get yo' ass out the kitchen, we on a mission to get to the bottom of Gangsta's Paradise by Coolio. "This episode of Couple of Critics Podcast is not wack", said Coolio. This episode is brought to you by ice cream.

    276. Heaven and Hell by Black Sabbath

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 28, 2024 107:15


    There comes a time when every Black Sabbath fan must at least dip a toe into the waters of the Dio years. That special time has finally come for Sam and Michelle. This episode the critics listen to and review Heaven and Hell by Black Sabbath. Featuring an episode of Rock n' Roll History!

    275. Whatever and Ever Amen by Ben Folds Five

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 21, 2024 111:39


    Find the nearest brick and drown it slowly because it's time to review Whatever and Ever Amen by Ben Folds Five. That's what that song said, right? This episode features a tune from a godless sodomite.

    274. Dog Police

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 14, 2024 115:16


    Are you ready to get weird? This week, the critics review the self-titled album by the short-lived 80s jazzy new wave band Dog Police. Nobody knows who they are! This episode is brought you by Side of the Road Mattresses.

    273. Drop Dead Fred

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 7, 2024 134:25


    The break that lasted twice as long as planned is over, and the critics are back! It only seems appropriate to return by reviewing the beloved millennial classic, Drop Dead Fred. This episode includes a tribute to a fallen American hero.

    272. Ernest Scared Stupid

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 31, 2023 127:22


    Happy Halloween! This holiday the critics are on their second foray into the world of Ernest P. Worrel with 1992's Ernest Scared Stupid. What is Trantor's underground diet? How old is Old Lady Hackmore? How sexy is Ernest? This episode asks the important questions.

    271. Infant Sorrow - Get Him To The Greek w/ Travis Harpster

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 25, 2023 123:01


    Podcast guest all-star Travis Harpster has once again made the drive to the podcast studio. This time he brought Infant Sorrow - Get Him To The Greek which means it's time to dive into the world of Russel Brand. Let the scandals begin. This episode features a special round of Guess That Melody.

    270. 2001 by Dr. Dre

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 18, 2023 120:08


    For the first time in five years, the critics have chosen an album from the same artist, two weeks in a row. Dr. Dre is back with the album 2001 for the critics to review. Will Sam stay on board the Dre train, or will he flush this down the Dre drain? This episode features a spooky story!

    269. The Chronic by Dr. Dre

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 11, 2023 109:44


    Sam is strapped and ready to continue his rap journey. This week the critics are listening to and discussing Dr. Dre's The Chronic! This episode features a Halloween Hip Hop Hit.

    268. 5th Anniversary Episode

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 4, 2023 96:25


    It's a celebration episode! Why? Because it's the 5th anniversary of The Couple of Critics Podcast! Michelle and Sam have separately created playlists made up of five songs from each other's album selections throughout every single year of the podcast. Plus, there are some extra song selections in there just for an extra good time. This episode features October 4th Birthday Shoutouts!

    267. Consolers of the Lonely by The Raconteurs w/ Zach Broering

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 27, 2023 112:50


    Long time guest guy Zach Broering is back on the podcast. This time he chose Consolers of the Lonely by The Raconteurs to listen to and talk about. Why in the world would he do something like this? I don't know. I just don't know. This episode features a message from our sponsor.

    Claim Couple of Critics Podcast

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel