P.S. I Love This Podcast

Follow P.S. I Love This Podcast
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

Sarah and Dana are lifelong followers and fans of romance in any medium: Books, movies, TV and the occasional fanfiction. Join them for a hilarious deep-dive into what makes the genre so addicting including the unattainable heartthrobs, the inevitable fallouts and everyone’s favorite happy endings.

Sarah and Dana


    • Oct 23, 2024 LATEST EPISODE
    • infrequent NEW EPISODES
    • 44m AVG DURATION
    • 49 EPISODES

    5 from 22 ratings Listeners of P.S. I Love This Podcast that love the show mention: love love, best, good, like.


    Ivy Insights

    The P.S. I Love This Podcast is a must-listen for anyone who has a deep appreciation for love and the romantic comedy genre. Hosted by Sarah and Dana, this podcast takes you on a journey through all your favorite rom coms, allowing you to relive those moments that made you laugh, cry, and dream about being the main character. With each episode, they bring their own unique perspective and hilarious commentary to the table, making it feel like you're hanging out with your best friends.

    One of the best aspects of this podcast is how easy it is to listen to. Sarah and Dana have such great chemistry together that it feels like you're eavesdropping on a fun conversation between friends. Their genuine enthusiasm for romantic comedies shines through in every episode, making it impossible not to get caught up in their excitement. Additionally, they offer insightful analysis and discussions about various themes and tropes within the genre, giving listeners a deeper understanding and appreciation for these films.

    Another standout feature of this podcast is the routine game of Marry, Cuddle, Kill that Sarah and Dana play. This game adds an entertaining twist to their discussions as they debate which characters from rom coms they would marry, cuddle with, or kill. It's a lighthearted segment that brings humor to each episode and allows listeners to engage with the hosts' choices and share their own opinions.

    However, one potential downside of this podcast is its narrow focus on romantic comedies. While it's understandable considering the title and concept of the show, some listeners who aren't die-hard fans of rom coms might find themselves alienated or lacking interest in certain episodes. It could be beneficial for Sarah and Dana to occasionally expand their discussions to include other related genres or even branch out into different forms of media like TV shows or books.

    In conclusion, The P.S. I Love This Podcast is a delightful escape into the world of romantic comedies. Sarah and Dana's infectious energy, witty banter, and insightful discussions make each episode a joy to listen to. Whether you're a die-hard rom com fan or simply looking for a feel-good show to brighten up your day, this podcast is sure to bring a smile to your face. So grab your favorite snack, cozy up with some nostalgia, and let Sarah and Dana transport you into the magical world of love and laughter.



    Search for episodes from P.S. I Love This Podcast with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from P.S. I Love This Podcast

    Hot Stuff: Nobody Wants This, Emily in Paris and More!

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 23, 2024 67:18


    After a 2-year hiatus, Sarah and Dana are BACK for the Season 4 premiere of P.S. I Love This Podcast. A lot has changed... Dana had another baby, Sarah took up a new hobby and Emily Cooper is moving to Rome! In this episode, they're talking about allllll the things the internet is gushing over lately including Adam Brody in Nobody Wants This and Marcello in Emily in Paris. Plus, they're diving into Tell Me Lies, The Idea of You, The Perfect Couple, Bridgerton and the Secret Lives of Mormon Wives.

    The Dead Romantics

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 6, 2022 54:22


    Just in time for Spookay Season...Sarah and Dana dive into one of their new favorite books, The Dead Romantics. And they rant over a new Glen Powell development.

    Purple Hearts

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 14, 2022 49:15


    This week, Sarah and Dana are talking about Netflix's latest hit with Sofia Carson, Purple Hearts. 

    Never Have I Ever

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 7, 2022 54:52


    After giving each other the gift of time, Sarah and Dana are back to discuss Netflix's hit series from Mindy Kaling, Never Have I Ever. They're breaking down the couples and comparing our own high school "never have I evers."

    Matching Characters to Enneagrams

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 24, 2022 48:17


    In this episode, Sarah and Dana are exploring the enneagram and matching their favorite romance characters to each number. From Pride and Prejudice to Outlander and everything in between, do you agree with their assessments?

    The Definitive Ranking of Sandra Bullock RomComs

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 19, 2022 52:12


    In this belated episode, Sarah and Dana got to record together! They're talking about meeting each other's moms and breaking down six of Sandra Bullock's most memorable romantic comedies. 

    Emily Henry: Beach Read, People We Meet on Vacation, Book Lovers

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 10, 2022 56:14


    This week, Sarah and Dana are tackling the Emily Henry universe: "Beach Read," "People We Meet on Vacation," and "Book Lovers." Fans of happy endings won't want to miss this deep dive.

    Love is Blind + The Ultimatum

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 3, 2022 60:21


    Sarah and Dana are talking the Nick and Vanessa Lachey reality universe of Love is Blind and The Ultimatum on Netflix. 

    Netflix Takes on Jane Austen's Persuasion

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 27, 2022 51:41


    In this episode, Sarah and Dana are talking about the much-debated, generally hated "Persuasion" adaptation from Netflix. We also cover two of Dana's very detailed IRL beefs.

    Emily in Paris: Season 2

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 20, 2022 62:00


    Sarah and Dana are back with a very important discussion around the second season of Emily in Paris. Because... better late than never. Tune in for serious rhetoric around Lily Collins' eyebrows, how to pronounce Gabriel and who is getting offed in this week's MCK.

    The Summer I Turned Pretty

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 13, 2022 48:39


    Sarah and Dana are back from their two-year COVID hiatus and ready to talk Jenny Han x Amazon's, "The Summer I Turned Pretty." If you don't care what the hosts have been up to, skip to 19:33 to get romancing.

    Emily in Paris aka Giving the People What They Want

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 4, 2020 65:52


    In this episode, Dana and Sarah take a deep look at Netflix's latest millennial escapism smash - Emily in Paris. From the men to the outfits, their conversation leaves no champagne glass unturned.

    From Binge to Cringe: Quarantine Recap

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 21, 2020 52:29


    In their first episode back, Sarah and Dana catch up on life during the pandemic. Spoiler alert: it includes wine hangovers from nights at home. They spill all of their favorite TV shows and movies including Upload, Palm Springs, Hollywood and the cult classic, The Hills. They also address their once favorite actor, Glen Powell, and his less than stellar sense of humor. 

    The Bold Type: Season Four

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2020 38:08


    In this episode, Dana and Sarah work through the technical issues of recording across state lines and dig into the season four premiere of The Bold Type. They talk season predictions, early disappointment and more!

    Binge Alert: You, Season 2

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 22, 2020 66:49


    You've been wanting to meet the guy of your dreams in the produce section... you probably linger by the peaches for a little too long... but you don't know any better... because you haven't seen Season 2 of You... but that's OK... we can fix that... we can fix... you. In this episode, Sarah and Dana do a deep dive into the creepy hit Netflix show You and play a new game, Creepy Joe or Regular Joe, where they deem popular rom-com scenes creepy or not.  

    The One About Christmas

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 24, 2019 42:13


    In this episode, Sarah and Dana are back to talk to you about all of the year's holiday hits and misses, plus they share some real Christmas hot takes, AND MCK your favorite holiday classics.

    The Thanksgivingful Episode

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 26, 2019 60:31


    In this episode of P.S. I Love This Podcast, Sarah and Dana share all the things they're thankful for in 2019. We're talking about Disney+ (praise him), Christmas bops (looking at you John Paul Jones), the Bridget Jones universe, Glen Powell and so much more. Tune in and turn up the thankful.

    Talking American Royals with Katharine McGee

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 12, 2019 59:15


    In this episode of P.S. I Love This Podcast, Sarah and Dana talk to Katharine McGee, New York Times bestselling author of American Royals. They go deep on a shared love of Shonda Rhimes, crafting an alternate reality timeline and the potential fate of all your favorite couples.

    Binge Alert: Grey's Anatomy, Season 1

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 29, 2019 55:16


    In this episode, Sarah and Dana are deep diving on season one of Grey's Anatomy, including a nightmare game of would you rather. Join them for all the love triangles, unrequited love and medical drama that makes up one of TV's longest-running scripted dramas.

    Spookay Season

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 15, 2019 46:45


    In this episode of P.S. I Love This Podcast, Sarah and Dana are talking about all their favorite Halloween romances including Teen Witch, Hocus Pocus, Casper and the new season of Charmed. They also get one degree closer to Glen Powell with a special caller on the #SixDegreesofGlenPowell hotline. 

    Talking Mean Girls with Jonathan Bennett

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 1, 2019 47:07


    In the season three premiere, Sarah and Dana talk to Aaron Samuels himself (Jonathan Bennett) about Mean Girls, the Burn Cookbook and his hosting gig on Food Network's Halloween Wars. They also introduce three exciting new segments including #SixDegreesOfGlenPowell. Welcome back, fam!

    Talking "The Wedding Party" with Jasmine Guillory

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 30, 2019 22:49


    In the season finale of P.S. I Love This Podcast, Sarah and Dana chat with Jasmine Guillory, the New York Times bestselling author of "The Wedding Date" and Reese Witherspoon x Hello Sunshine Book Club pick "The Proposal," about her latest novel, "The Wedding Party." Find out who would play Theo in a Netflix adaptation, what's next for her universe of characters, and which of her leading men would get voted off the island in a cutthroat game of marry, cuddle, kill.

    The Mary-Kate and Ashley Collection

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 16, 2019 49:04


    In this episode, Sarah and Dana are throwing it back to teen queen dreams of the 90s: Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen. From their first big screen hit (It Takes Two) to their last appearance together (New York Minute) and all the twin action in between, no Olsen moment was forgotten. Take a stroll down memory lane and see how your favorite MK&A movie stacks up.

    Crafting the Perfect Summer Rom-com

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 2, 2019 37:22


    In this episode of P.S. I Love This Podcast, Sarah and Dana are creating their ideal rom-coms by drafting a leading man, leading lady, supporting characters and the perfect location from a list of classics. Listeners are in for a sneak preview of their summer love story screenplay, "Dirty Laundry," and an inside scoop on their romance recs "Outlander" (yes, again) and "Dynasty" (the remake).

    The Bold Type: Season 3 Reflections

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 18, 2019 40:21


    In this episode of P.S. I Love This Podcast, Sarah and Dana are taking a look back at their predictions for season three of Freeform's "The Bold Type" to see which were right, which were wrong and all the curveballs they didn't see coming. Plus, stay tuned for a bosses edition of marry, cuddle, kill featuring Jacquelyn, Patrick and Oliver. 

    Guess whose bach, bach again...

    Play Episode Listen Later May 21, 2019 37:30


    In this episode of P.S. I Love This Podcast, Sarah and Dana are joined by Rockbox coach and recent Bachelorette lover, Johnny, to discuss Alabama Hannah's new season of The Bachelorette. From first impressions roses to Luke P.'s female doppelgänger, they're spilling all the tea around the most dramatic season yet.

    That's awkward...

    Play Episode Listen Later May 6, 2019 37:22


    In this episode of P.S. I Love This Podcast, Sarah and Dana explore those moments that make us cringe IRL and along with our favorite characters. From Game of Thrones (GOT) and Hannah Montana to Bridget Jones and Josie Grossy, they refuse to leave well enough alone. PLUS a Chris-studded Marvel MCK.

    After: One Direction Fanfic

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 23, 2019 36:23


    This week Sarah and Dana dive into the One Direction fanfic world of "After," a book-turned-movie based on former 1D heartthrob, Harry Styles. The duo examines his tumultuous relationship with a fellow classmate, Tessa Young, and the major differences between Anna Todd's book and the screen adaptation. Sarah also reveals her love for the boy band, her hatred for Zayn breaking up said boy band and chooses the 1D song that perfectly describes this fanfic.

    The Bold Type

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 9, 2019 29:45


    In this episode of P.S. I Love This Podcast, Sarah and Dana preview the upcoming season of Freeform's "The Bold Type." Join them for season three predictions, a quick recap of season two and a marry, cuddle, kill featuring your favorite BT guys.

    High School (Movie) Superlatives

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 19, 2019 53:35


    In this episode, Sarah and Dana are joined by long-time listener, first time podcaster, Beth Booker. The trio award senior year-style superlatives to the teen flicks of the late 90s/early 2000s. Awards include: MVP, Prom King and Queen, Class Clown and Most Likely to be Problematic in the Year 2019.

    All Up in Our Feelings

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 26, 2019 45:33


    Grab a blanket and a box of tissues, you're going to want to cuddle up for this one. Dana and Sarah are talking all about the movies that wrecked them growing up. That's right - Jack, My Girl, The Man in the Moon - they go all up in their feelings with their favorite sad movies from the 90s and 00s.

    Galentine's Day Anniversary Episode

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 13, 2019 39:45


    Sarah and Dana welcome New York Times Bestselling Author Jill Santopolo to answer rapid fire romance questions. They also chat about her books —"More Than Words" and "The Light We Lost" — and dive into the love, turmoil and life-altering tough decisions that brought them to tears. Dun dun dun. Speaking of tough decisions, Sarah and Dana play another challenging round of Marry, Cuddle, Kill and celebrate P.S. I Love This Podcast's 1-year anniversary by reminiscing on some of their favorite memories.  

    Binge Alert: Sex and the City

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 29, 2019 29:30


    Sex and the City has been on the air for more than 20 years. In 1998, Carrie was screening calls, not analyzing Mr. Big's Instagram Story viewing habits. But Sarah and Dana couldn't help but wonder if some of the scenarios from Season 1 were still relevant today. Tune in to hear them call up their single friends in NYC to get the scoop on dating in the Big Apple. 

    Love Triangle Extravaganza

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 15, 2019 35:08


    In this episode, Sarah and Dana dive into their favorite love triangles including "Dawson's Creek," "True Blood," "Scandal" and "The Parent Trap." They freak out about a recent celeb romance development, and Sarah establishes herself as Glen Powell's #1 fan. Stick around for everyone's favorite game — Marry, Cuddle, Kill — where someone chooses to not share the door with Jack.

    Minisode: The Bachelor Season Premiere

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 8, 2019 30:40


    In the most dramatic minisode ever, Sarah and Dana recap the first episode of the newest Bachelor season. They talk about Colton's reputation, contestant superlatives and award their own first impression roses.

    Binge Alert: Vampire Diaries

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 31, 2018 43:14


    In this episode, Sarah and Dana deep dive into The Vampire Diaries. That's right, they spent the holiday season hiding from their families in favor of watching a show that's been out for a decade. Characters are ripped to shreds and the Salvatore brothers are just plain ripped. Stick around for vampire bingo to determine whether or not you're undead and didn't know it.

    Netflix Christmas Movies

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 18, 2018 50:11


    In this episode of P.S. I Love this Podcast, Sarah and Dana are taking you through the 2018 Netflix Christmas line-up and letting you know how they stacked up against Hallmark fare in People Magazine's "Hallmark Christmas Movie Drinking Game." There are also multiple very special shoutouts to some loyal listeners.

    Minisode: An ode to Peter Kavinsky

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 11, 2018 8:32


    In a very special minisode of P.S. I Love This Podcast, Sarah and Dana wax poetic about your boyfriend, my boyfriend, the internet's boyfriend - Peter Kavinsky.

    Hallmark Christmas Movie Rundown

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 4, 2018 42:44


    In the season premiere of P.S. I Love this Podcast, Sarah and Dana are giving you the inside scoop on the latest Hallmark Christmas movies featuring the Hallmark Christmas Queens: Lacey Chabert and Candace Cameron Bure. They also sacrificed themselves to see which movie will get you most toasted based on People Magazine's "Hallmark Christmas Movie Drinking Game."

    Episode 10: Country Strong

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 26, 2018 36:59


    In this episode, Sarah and Dana talk about how to get a gig as a seat filler at major award shows and their favorite country music movies... which spirals into movies in general. You know how it goes.

    Episode 9: Jingle Jangle

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 12, 2018 32:55


    In this episode of P.S. I Love this Podcast, Sarah and Dana... wing it. If you're looking for an episode featuring everything from the drug of choice on "Riverdale" to why Bill is a sub-par lover on "True Blood," you're in the right place.

    Episode 8: #FindJoeyFromOhio

    Play Episode Listen Later May 22, 2018 44:43


    In this week's episode of P.S. I Love This Podcast, we explore classic stories of long lost loves... including one from Sarah's past. Fans of the Notebook, Casablanca and Sarah's childhood, this one's for you.

    Episode 7: A Prom Episode to Remember

    Play Episode Listen Later May 8, 2018 32:17


    In this episode, Sarah and Dana reminisce about their proms that greatly lacked in the romance department, discuss their favorite prom movie moments and welcome a very special guest for Marry, Cuddle, Kill.

    Episode 6: It's Getting Haute in Here

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 24, 2018 46:28


    In this episode, Sarah and Dana welcome the brains behind the Haute Dish podcast to talk about the intersection of food and romance. Find out which rom-coms know the way to their stomachs and why eggs are the sexiest food. 

    Episode 5: Lost in Austen

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 10, 2018 33:09


    In this week's episode of P.S. I Love This Podcast, Sarah and Dana explore a Jane Austen-themed choose your own adventure novel and leave feeling a little battered by the author. They also engage in one of the hardest Marry, Cuddle, Kill segments yet: Darcy on Darcy on Darcy. 

    Episode 4: You Are the Music in Me

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 27, 2018 42:07


    In this episode, Sarah and Dana reminisce about their favorite Disney Channel Original Movies (DCOMs), play a round of DCOM-themed Speed Dating and make life-altering decisions in Marry, Cuddle, Kill. Will they say "I do" to Erik von Detten or Joe Jonas? Plus, Dana recounts the time she had breakfast with Kevin Jonas in SoHo and the fateful day she met Zac Efron.

    Episode 3: Love and Basketball

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 13, 2018 35:53


    In this week’s March Madness themed episode of P.S. I Love This Podcast, Dana and Sarah go head-to-head with their romance starting lineups, play a very special round of Marry, Cuddle, Kill featuring a teen heartthrob and attempt to say Sara Bareilles’ name.

    Episode 2: You've Got Power Couples

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 27, 2018 30:43


    In this week's P.S. I Love This Podcast, Dana and Sarah debate the genre's top power couples, talk with Kimmery Martin about her new novel "The Queen of Hearts" and play a bongo-filled version of Marry, Cuddle, Kill.

    Episode 1: When Dana met Sarah

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 13, 2018 36:28


    In the first ever episode of P.S. I Love This Podcast, Sarah and Dana play a round of speed dating to share some of their favorite romance genre staples, highlight their top leading ladies and play a TGIT version of Marry, Cuddle, Kill.

    Claim P.S. I Love This Podcast

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel