You've Lost Me: A Lost Rewatch Podcast

Follow You've Lost Me: A Lost Rewatch Podcast
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

Join America's sweethearts, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, as they hearken back to a simpler time, 2004, to answer the age old question: "What happened on LOST?" 50% TV recap/review and 50% nostalgia podcast. Every Monday and Friday, we delve into another episode of the Emmy Award winning show Lost as well as the context of the week it premiered (including important events, #1 in the box office, top song, and really whatever piques our interest).

Chicken & Friend


    • Sep 27, 2022 LATEST EPISODE
    • monthly NEW EPISODES
    • 48m AVG DURATION
    • 53 EPISODES


    Search for episodes from You've Lost Me: A Lost Rewatch Podcast with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from You've Lost Me: A Lost Rewatch Podcast

    "Dear goo goo gaga?" S3E4--Every Man for Himself

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 27, 2022 39:48


    Two miner forty-niners, Caroline Kidwell and Anna Seibert, are glad to know that the bunny is alive, even while we mourn the loss of another minor character, and read some advice on marriage. Then we touch on Snagglepuss, that infernal beeping, James Brown v. Ludacris, and beauty men. "Ruby lips above the water Blowing bubbles soft and fine..." Music by Zach Fendelman at fatbard.com.

    "dungle" S3E3 - Further Instructions

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 6, 2022 28:18


    Two sacrifices that the island demanded, Caroline Kidwell & Anna Seibert, are trying not to look like booboo the fool this week, while we discuss Dom's hair and invent a new word. Then we talk nude Desmond and pot communes. The moral of the story is that Locke is still a "good person" and what Lizzie really wants is a daddy. Do not forget that this is first and foremost a chain-based podcast.

    "Pagoda Of Shame" S3E2 - The Glass Ballerina

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 4, 2022 38:33


    Two estranged cosmonauts, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, have promised not to watch SexyBack until 2029. In this episode we discuss extramarital affairs, reveal if we're still single, and debate the likelihood of strawberry kisses. Throw on a teen's dress and just TRY to break the chain while we spill some tips on how to live past one hundred.

    "Kilby" S3E1--A Tale of Two Cities (w/Natalie Santoro)

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 3, 2022 60:44


    Three burnt muffins, Caroline Kidwell, Natalie Santoro, and Anna Seibert, discuss calling all of your ex's contacts. Plus, we learn which box office hit is neither good nor fun.

    "Locke Bottom" S2E23 -- Live Together, Die Alone

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 22, 2022 47:40


    Two silent baristas, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, close out season two (!!!) by discovering what Lost might have to do with Watchmen, and which popular movie is too long/too boring/too pretentious. It was g'nice to see you!

    "Even Wolves Have Honor" S2E22 -- Three Minutes

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 15, 2022 50:07


    Two tactless real estate agents, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, argue about whether this one is good, worry about our small ashtrays, prattle on about Michael's motivations, compare Phi Beta Kappa keys, and then decide who we think is out for revenge. Email us at youvelostmepod@gmail.com if you've ever been caught in a net. #memycarandmyplane

    "Suspicious peasants" S2E21--?

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 29, 2021 37:25


    Two bassists for Foghat, Caroline Kidwell & Anna Seibert, count how many hatches we've accumulated, reflect on John Locke's useless pathetic life, & decide for sure that Rihanna stans Bernard & Rose. Email us if you've ever been "between places". Why don't you come on over, Valerie? [DON'T LISTEN TO THEIR LIES. THIS IS PERSEPHONE. I DON'T HAVE MUCH TIME--NONE OF US DO. IF YOU WANNA KNOW THE TRUTH ABOUT "YOU'VE LOST ME POD", THE REAL STORY BEHIND THEM, A LIE PULLED TIGHT ENOUGH WILL ALWAYS SNAP UNDER THE BREAKING STRAIN.............................THEY'RE COMING!]

    "Too many men. Not funny." S2E20 -- Two for the Road (w/Andre Colin)

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 10, 2021 60:45


    Three nonplussed rock gods, Anna Seibert, Caroline Kidwell, and Andre Colin, discuss book-burning, and our one-year anniversary. The moral of the story is: If you're going to take someone out on a date, do it fucking right.

    "WWMBD?" S2E19--S.O.S.

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 28, 2021 42:49


    Two restaurant violinists, Caroline Kidwell and Anna Seibert, talk groping (cuddling?) your way out of a situation, healing energy, Ian Somerhalder, sleepy Locke, and what song you probably shouldn't sing on The Voice.

    "Lord Haw-Haw of House Hee Hee" S2E18--Dave

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 28, 2021 47:37


    Two silly geese, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, take a dip into Descartes, and check in with some heated movie reviewers. Later, we discover what an absolute gem Ron Bottitta is. Which do you think is the horniest treatise?

    "DHARMA blacklight party" S2E17 - Lockdown

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 19, 2021 46:38


    Two struggling Etsy artists, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, find out who's dumb and strong, talk out John Locke's timeline, and kick ourselves for not recognising Nadia. Then we discuss the white version of The Wiz, and catch some wry little quips in our Actor spotlight! Who is and is not mad at Sawyer!?

    "Thigh gap cancer" S2E16--The Whole Truth

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 12, 2021 36:46


    Two ESL teachers, Anna Seibert & Caroline Kidwell, discuss a devastating banana scarcity, the likelihood that Jennifer exists, & Jae Lee's function on the show. Plus, we raise our eyebrows at Daniel Dae Kim & Yunjin Kim/try to think of anyone Sun would sleep with, all the while wondering if Henry Gale is evil. Could this entire show be a dream? Does anyone remember where we've heard the name Widmore Labs before?

    "Chloroform Claire" S2E15--Maternity Leave

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 16, 2021 45:32


    Two blue-eyed teens, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, identify the BRAND NEW island shit-starter!! Then we discuss child indoctrination and try to forget about all the screaming.

    "The coconut internet" S2E14 - One of Them

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 8, 2021 36:55


    Two purveyors of fine wine, Caroline Kidwell & Anna Seibert, discuss Babar, Sayid's box of yuckies, & which wars we've heard of. Plus we get into which museum you absolutely must visit in Grand Rapids, Minnesota, Sayid's short hair, and shooting frogs with guns. Tune in to find out how many dogs it takes to make a Disney movie. #ItsPonytailTime

    "New sheriff in town" S2E13 - The Long Con

    Play Episode Listen Later May 23, 2021 42:45


    Two experienced pumpkin-eaters, Anna Seibert & Caroline Kidwell, talk fake abduction attempts, a celebrity dad lookalike, & that persistent coconut business. Then we really break down who was conning who, & chat about deceptive Hollywood people. Come for Ana Lucia's army, stay for Charlie's blocking in that last scene.

    "You wanna see my what?" S2E12 - Fire + Water

    Play Episode Listen Later May 10, 2021 37:52


    Two headless dolls, Caroline Kidwell & Anna Seibert, discuss apartments in London, & sacrificing your dignity.

    "Scary Boat Man" S2E11--The Hunting Party

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 22, 2021 43:07


    Two hardboiled eggs, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, discuss Going to Trinidad, jungle meetings, and why Kate needs to stay behind. Then we tell people what they can't do.

    "The biggest child" S2E10 -- The 23rd Psalm

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 27, 2021 40:19


    Two timid dimwits, Caroline Kidwell and Anna Seibert, are back to debate Goldie's motivations, and what Charlie remembers. Then we try to poke holes in these instant message conversations (Where's Walt-o?). And we get fired up again about Locke randomly knowing things. Tune in next episode when I hopefully remember what I know about Yoruba.

    "Bible Study" S2E9 - What Kate Did

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 21, 2021 57:50


    Two friendly horses, Caroline Kidwell & Anna Seibert, discuss who's mad at Ana Lucia & who should keep an eye on Sawyer. Then we declaim which choices we "didn't like" & scour the internet for Black Pearl! Email us at youvelostmepod@gmail.com if you've ever hooked up with your wife.

    "Choice Bad Daddy" S2E8 - Collision

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 4, 2021 33:00


    Two Will Shortz wannabes, Anna Seibert & Caroline Kidwell, try to pinpoint who's dead on the inside. Then we discuss the significance of Gilgamesh, but not before being astounded by Jack having to ask twice. Last but not least, we really keep our fingers on the pulse, with more Teen Choice winners & losers from over a decade ago.

    "Fishing Hero" S2E7 - The Other 48 Days

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 1, 2021 49:29


    Two shy telemarketers, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, discuss Eko and Ana, getting a sunburn for attention, and the skewered man. Plus we try to guess where Nathan was for two hours.

    "You thirsty, Dog?" S2E6--Abandoned

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 25, 2021 47:54


    Two teacher's pets, Anna Seibert & Caroline Kidwell, are absolutely giddy with anticipation for the NEXT episode of Lost while we discuss Ana Lucia's leadership style. Before that, we serve up some personal fun "facts" about this week's movie, reminisce about liturgical dance, dream about what setups will soon pay off, ponder what Ethan's mission might have been, & lament accidental murder.

    "Baby Post Box" S2E5 - ...And Found

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 22, 2021 55:08


    Two unlicensed physicians, Caroline Kidwell and Anna Seibert, discuss festering wounds, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, and Marie Antoinette. Then we ponder whether rabbits cause rockfalls, and babble over each other about Ian Somerhalder.

    "#PunishFran" S2E4 - Everybody Hates Hugo

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 18, 2021 52:39


    Two island babies, Caroline Kidwell & Anna Seibert, break down the real John Locke's take on child labor. Plus we celebrate the first recipient of the Lurleen B. Wallace award, & then try to figure out the logistics of the messages in a bottle.

    "Little Ditch Prison" S2E3--Orientation

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 15, 2021 48:06


    Two shark tank rejects, Caroline Kidwell and Anna Seibert, talk crazy inflections and the hottest chick in group therapy. Plus we add another Cato to the ever-growing list, and everyone's favourite little rascal FINALLY makes it through the bedroom door!

    "The Boxman Cometh" S2E2 - Adrift

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 11, 2021 38:26


    Two boiling hot cauldrons of rage, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, discuss Austin Leslie, the Godfather of Fried Chicken! Then we have a heated custody debate, and share some shocking news about the Tampa job.

    "Ray Romano's Macaroni Grill" S2E1-Man of Science, Man of Faith (w/Jack Wright)

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 8, 2021 69:22


    Three caricatures of their former selves, Anna Seibert, Caroline Kidwell, and Jack Wright, talk Cheesecake Factory, canned smoothies, and sopping wet children.

    "Deep Holes" S1E25 - Exodus: Part 2 (Part II)

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 28, 2021 47:51


    Two frightened co-pilots, Anna Seibert & Caroline Kidwell, discuss culty island bullshit, Flintstones push-ups, & Moses's hot older brother.

    "I Think It's Groovy" S1E24 - Exodus Part 2 (Part I)

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 25, 2021 59:44


    Two incorrigible vacuum salesmen, Caroline Kidwell and Anna Seibert (née Hamburger), discuss the Teen Choice Awards in our latest Actor Spotlight, then malign the PTC (Parents Television Council), and marvel at Cool Guy Moves.

    "Mean Bush" S1E23--Exodus Part 1 (w/Maggie Sorensen)

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 21, 2021 68:20


    Three amateur dolphin wranglers, Anna Seibert, Caroline Kidwell and Maggie Sorensen, talk staccato running noises and bootcut jeans...Plus we play two THRILLING new games!

    "MonSusan" S1E22--Born to Run

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 18, 2021 54:41


    Two bioluminescent sea slugs, Caroline Kidwell & Anna Seibert, discuss protecting your penis, & The SVU Twist. Plus we dish out a helping of Mommentary, & a fresh Actor Spotlight.

    "Boone Style" S1E21-The Greater Good

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 14, 2021 59:11


    Two unsightly piccolo players, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk Mom-mentary, gamer boys, and more of the 129 Ways to Get a Husband.

    "Clap for the Sinners" S1E20--Do No Harm

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 11, 2021 67:48


    Two hotel skanks discuss high-stakes telephone, leg guillotines, and saviours' blood. Plus we learn how to birth a baby (It's simple!).

    "Kidney Brain" S1E19-Deus Ex Machina

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 7, 2021 56:37


    Two notable economists, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk bad news orchestras, diamond teeth, and nanny abuse.

    "Beans" S1E18-Numbers

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 4, 2021 49:47


    Two tacky harbingers of death, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk jungle cradles, bashful beauties, and 129 ways to get a husband.

    "Rich Clique" S1E17-...In Translation

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 31, 2020 56:14


    Two pushy cheesemongers, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk komodo dragons, stolen puppies, and Life With Derek.

    "Happy New Year, Rascal Flatts" S1E16-Outlaws

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 28, 2020 48:13


    Two ingrown doll hairs, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk sweet shrimp guys, best frenemies, and how The Lonely Island saved the internet.

    "Cool Guy Gun Club" S1E15-Homecoming

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 24, 2020 44:23


    Two lonely goatherds, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk saucy sirens, polar bear costumes, and global circumnavigation.

    "The Rose Mary Stretch" S1E14-Special

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 21, 2020 59:44


    Two unfortunate kitten-wranglers, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk stealing dogs, summoning birds, and WALT! Plus, Anna does her second Actor Spotlight!

    "An Episode of Porn" S1E13-Hearts and Minds

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 17, 2020 54:44


    Two rare cuts of hot beef, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk camellia sinensis, vision quests, and too much fruit.

    "Bikinis of the Dead" S1E12-Whatever the Case May Be

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 14, 2020 51:56


    Two professional lollygaggers, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk Team Yahoo vs. Team Shlimshlam, mid-robbery coitus, and the absurdity of trying to pick a lock on a Halliburton.

    "Mt. Baldy" S1E11-All the Best Cowboys Have Daddy Issues

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 10, 2020 47:40


    Two Martha Stewarts of matrimony, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk other dads, anagrams, and jumprope challenges. Anna does the first Actor Spotlight!

    "Island Father of the Island Baby" S1E10-Raised by Another

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 7, 2020 51:48


    Two VH1 hasbeens, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk Princess Diaries, middle of the night phone calls, and what constitutes "tea."

    "Science Team" S1E9-Solitary

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 3, 2020 34:01


    Two incredulous cheese mongers, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk the Xerox Murders, negligent fathers, and celebratory blazers.

    "Island Shit-Starter" S1E8-Confidence Man

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 30, 2020 47:02


    Two ungrateful choir leaders, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk imaginary peanut butter, ASMR, and Alicia Keys's Masterclass.

    "Scott and Steve" S1E7-The Moth

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 28, 2020 52:55


    Two disgraced bird watchers, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk forced laughter, overt metaphors, and the movie that Adrien Brody got skinny for.

    "Island Boyf" S1E6-House of the Rising Sun

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 23, 2020 47:08


    Two uninspired cobblers, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk bees, crying, and the movie that Christian Bale got skinny for. *MILD MAD MEN SPOILER WARNING*

    "Ass Over Tea Kettle" S1E5- White Rabbit

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 19, 2020 57:19


    Two industrious leech farmers, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk homosexual sharks, Indian bandit Veerappan, and Jefferson Airplane. They also take their first LOST personality quiz-- and you won't BELIEVE the results!!! Music by Zach Fendelman at fatbard.com.

    "Tygert" S1E4-Walkabout

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 13, 2020 57:32


    Two washed up truffle hogs, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk Outback Steakhouse, cursing on TV, and a 250-pound rat with scimitar-like tusks and a surly disposition who would love nothing more than to eviscerate anything that comes near. Music by Zach Fendelman at fatbard.com.

    "Denims" S1E3-Tabula Rasa

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 9, 2020 64:50


    Two freelance ghost whisperers, Anna Seibert and Caroline Kidwell, talk Nobel Prize winners, cartoon fish, epistemology, and ponder whether any movies are certified 100% fresh. Music by Zach Fendelman at fatbard.com.

    "It's the Pilot" (part two!!) S1E2

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 6, 2020 53:31


    Two former pageant queens talk skateboarding dogs, burning flesh, giant squids, and Caroline thinks about explaining an episode of Seinfeld, but don't worry-- she doesn't. It's the Pilot! (part 2) Music by Zach Fendelman at fatbard.com. SyXZmcpnvJpkjWiBXm5j

    Claim You've Lost Me: A Lost Rewatch Podcast

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel