Since 2010 we've been a club that meets up once a month to sample a new Scotch; Because drinking scotch is better than not drinking scotch. Only one of of knows what were drinking. The rest of us are blind tasting. We'll talk about color, smell, and taste. We make predictions about age, region, and if we're feeling lucky even distillery. Then we rate it on a scale of one to ten. Remember to always drink responsibly.
Donate to Mystery Scotch Tasting with Gentlemen of the World
MST Rating: 9.2 Ever been to a Harvard party attended by PhDs with a ruggedly dressed guest from Boston College? Oh, the suspense! That's what we encountered in our latest mystery scotch tasting. The unexpected guest, we all agreed was perfectly balanced, with an intriguing blend of sweet and smoky hints. In this episode we explore the depths of this deliciously complicated scotch, tantalized by flavors from sweet fruits and nutty undertones to smoky peat and salty accents. Now that's a party!The plot thickens as we continue our spirited discussion, speculating about the origin of our mystery guest. It was an uninvited guest, but oh boy, it was loved by everyone. The scotch was like a ruggedly dressed guest at a highbrow party, initially misjudged, but later turning out to be the most charismatic attendee. The flavors were elegant and edgy, dark fruity notes wonderfully mingling with the richness of flan custard. This scotch tasting was not just a casual sip; it was an immersive experience we would love to relive.Toasting to this nearly perfect 10, we concluded our wild journey into this unpredictable yet delightful scotch. Listen in, savor the journey with us, and who knows, you might just discover your new favorite scotch! Support the show
MST Rating: 7.4Congratulations to us on our 50th episode!!!You're in for a sensory roller coaster as we unravel the layers of a unique Scotch. We've got a potpourri of flavors and scents from the sweet perfume of honey and orange to the spicy twist of furniture polish and hot tamales. Each sip is a revelation, tickling our taste buds with sugar plums, chocolate covered orange sticks, and a cayenne hot and spicy finish. Be prepared to take your palate on an adventure!You'll get an insight into our personal reviews and ratings. Was the nose promising but the palate disappointing? How does it fare as a guest at a party? Is it a good mixer? Our opinions may differ, but one thing we all agree on is that this Scotch intrigues us. Also on the menu are some unique tasting notes, a little Gaelic language trivia, and our final thoughts on this very divisive Scotch. So pour yourself a dram and join us on this flavorful journey! Support the show
Walking you through this Mossburn No. 21, we'll delve into its light color, elusive legs, and an array of intriguing aromas. Imagine smelling vanilla, marshmallow, and a tire shop's rubber, all swirling together in a complex bouquet. But wait, there's more - a fruity cocktail of pineapple and pear, with a nutty whiff of almonds. All of this beneath the surface of a Scotch that isn't trying too hard - subtle, yet beguilingly complex.You'll learn about the immersive dance between the Scotch's high ABV and its peaty palate. We'll discuss the meadow-like aroma becoming a floral symphony when water is added. We'll reveal how this change intensifies the peat and salt on the palate - and we'll consider the distiller's reputation and whether this particular Scotch lived up to our expectations. We'll also uncover the intriguing evolution of Scotch flavor over time - always improving, always surprising. We'll also compare this to some "interesting" animals.As we share our collective rating and mull over whether we'd buy this Scotch again, we hope to ignite your own curiosity about this captivating spirit. An unforgettable adventure in alcohol and aroma awaits you. Grab a glass, sit back, and let us guide your journey into the heart of Scotch.MST Rating: 7.76 Support the show
Ever wonder how a glass of Scotch can transport you to a camping trip under a starlit desert night? Join us, the Gentlemen of the World, as we navigate through a thrilling mystery Scotch tasting. Our first stop is a deep dive into the visual appeal of our drink. We draw parallels between its coloration and various beverages such as an Irish whiskey, a Chardonnay, or a Pinot Grigio. Behold, as we appreciate the 'legs' of the Scotch and their potential impact on mouthfeel, while also detecting various scent notes from smoke to moss to "a gushers ball".Our journey doesn't end there. We set off to revel in the Scotch's flavor profiles, comparing it to a wide spectrum of things, even the notorious Malort.In the final leg of our adventure, we lay bare our honest ratings of this intricate Scotch. After contemplating its complexity and individual components, we declare it an ideal drink for a camping trip or a desert night escapade. So, come along and raise a glass with us, as we toast to the health of the Scotch and its enchanted drinkers. Here's to an episode brimming with spirit and cheer!MST Rating 8.4 Support the show
Ever had one of those hangovers that just won't quit, despite your best efforts? One where that throbbing headache or the constant retching makes you swear off alcohol for good? Well, we've all been there! In our recent conversation, we took a trip down memory lane to some of our most infamous hangovers - the kind that unfold after a night of too much of a good thing or a themed party gone wild.Our chat wasn't just tales of woe, though. We also revisited the reckless freedom of our twenties and contrasted it with the responsibilities of fatherhood. From a memorable first year at Coachella, fueled by breakfast burritos and shots, to the dangerous game of "Beer Life" that had us downing pints like there was no tomorrow, we laid it all bare. But we also acknowledged the darker side of these antics, highlighting the risks of binge drinking and the importance of knowing when to say no. And then there were those drinking stories that are more cautionary tales than badge-of-honor-worthy exploits. Remember that time with the cement mixer shots or the one that led to a hospital trip? Or the fun trip to Costco that ended with an unbearable hangover? We discussed these and more, sharing the lessons we've learned along the way. So, buckle up for a hearty chat filled with laughter, cautionary tales, and a few unforgettable anecdotes. Support the show
The Gentlemen try this bottle from the Arran distillery. There was a new guest who asked a lot of great questions.MST Rating: 8.6 Support the show
The Gentlemen enjoy this lightly peated Scotch Whisky from the Wolfburn Distillery. MST Rating: 8.2 Support the show
This Gentlemen sample this funky Scotch Whisky from the Isle of Raasay Distillery.MST Rating: 7.5 Support the show
This episode the Gentlemen enjoy a dram of Talisker Port Ruighe. Some say the perfict party guest doesn't exist... we just met them.MST Rating: 8.9 Support the show
In this special episode the gentleman finally drink some bottles that they have been sitting on. Valkyrie, Valknut, and Valfather, the three bottles in the Viking Legends Series. Listen to find out if it was worth the wait.MST Rating: Valkyrie - 8.3Valkunt - 8.9Valfather - 7.4 Support the show
Once again the Gentlemen blow all their funds and buy some higher priced bottles. The boys sample four bottles in this extra long episode. They like some, and loath some.Talisker 11yr 2022 Special Release MST Rating 8.5, Highland Park 11yr bottled by Scotch Malt Whisky Society MST Rating 6.6, Lagavulin 12yr 2022 Special Release MST Rating 8.6, Bunnahabhain 12yr bottled by AD Rattray MST Rating 3.9 Support the show
Join the Gentlemen as they revisit three of their highest rated bottles of the year and choose their SCOTCH OF THE YEAR!!! In the running this year are: Tobermory 12, Cask Islay, and Glenmorangie Signet. Support the show
AKA: the worst idea ever! Its happening! Distilled sadness. Join The Gentlemen as they punish themselves for your entertainment. They try to stomach both Malort and Buckfast in this episode. Two of the worst alcoholic beverages ever created. MST Rating: Don't do it! Support the show
The gentlemen enjoy this mystery distillery bottled by our friends at AD Rattray. It was really good!! MST Rating: 8.9 Support the show
Aka: Marzipan or Mascarpone? The Gentlemen enjoy this small Batch bottle of Ardnamurchen. Includes a discussion on "Block Chain" that my or may not be true. I don't know, I'm ignorant. MST Rating: 8.1 Support the show
What a delicious mouthful!! the Gentlemen sample the excellent 7yr Bunnahabhain bottled by Signatory. A great time had by all. MST Rating: 9.6 Support the show
The Gentlemen try this Old Particular Linkwood 12yr. Words were said, jokes were made, good times were had. MST Rating: 8.05 Support the show
The Gentlemen talk about their memories of a first fight or physical altercation. Support the show
The Gentlemen talk of luxury after enjoying this fine scotch from Tobermory. MST Rating 8.9 Support the show
In this non tasting episode the gentlemen discuss their childhood career aspirations. Support the show
AKA: Reliant K, or floor Scotch. The boys try this Johnnie Walker Green label and most are unimpressed. includes a deep dive tangent on their favorite cuts of steak. MST Rating: 5.5 Support the show
Aka: Beach bonfires and barbecue.... The Gentlemen taste this bottle of Torfa by Glenglassaugh. They are reminded of campfires of the past and 80's action moviestars. MST Rating: 7.975 Support the show
This time the guys are gifted with a special Scotch from Evan's boss. This bottle of Glenmorangie Signet was a surprise for all of them. They even take back some of the bad things they said in the past! MST Rating: 8.02 Support the show
AKA: Alex's most favorite scotch ever!! The boys try a bottle of Macallan 12 Double Cask. Discoveries are made, hopes are crushed, the world may never be the same for some of us. MST Rating: 6.8 Support the show
AKA Distant Biscuit.... The Gentlemen sample a spirit that started at Glen Moray and finished with Duncan Taylor. MST Rating: 8.02 Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
Car, truck, or van, the gentlemen get nostalgic about their first vehicle. Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
AKA: Rompers and Cadillacs. The Gentlemen discuss fine clothing and fine automobiles to complement this fine scotch. MST Rating: 7.9 Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
In this Side Bar, the Gentlemen discuss things the want do do before they die. Travel, Retirement, Second Career, Festival in a bubble car... they talk about it all. Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
The boys sample a bottle of apples with this Dalwhinnie 15. MST Rating: 7.2 Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
In this episode the gentlemen discuss the alcoholic beverages they no longer enjoy. Tales of bad decisions and poor life choices to entertain you. Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
The Gentlemen blow all their funds and sample 4 bottles of scotch for the holidays (on a boat). - Highland Park 15 Viking Heart MST Rating: 8.5- Port Charlotte Heavily Peated MST Rating: 7.9- Caol Ila 13 cask strength (Signatory Vintage independent bottling) MST Rating: 9.01- Ardnamurchen cask strength AD/09:15 CK.632 MST Rating: 9.2 Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
In this very special episode the gentlemen have a showdown between their two highest rated samplings of the year. Who will take home the title of SCOTCH OF THE YEAR? Highland Park Cask Strength, or Torabhaig 2017? listen and find out. Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
The gentlemen try another excellent bottle from Kilchoman. MST Rating: 8.25 Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
In this non tasting episode the gentlemen talk about their individual favorite bottle of scotch. Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
The Gentlemen explore the blended side of Scotch Whisky with The Double Peat. This bottle is an interesting mix of Isley and Speyside single malt whiskys. MST Rating: 7.9 Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
The Gentlemen get literally every tasting note imaginable from this bottle of Talisker 10. Definitely not what they remembered! MST Rating: 7.2 Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
The Gentlemen sample this excellent young Scotch from Kilchoman. The youngest distillery on Islay really make an impression. MST Rating: 8.02 Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
In the second episode of their two episode series on Scotch under $20 that you can get at Trader Joe's, The Gentlemen of the world sample this bottle of Lismore. MST Rating: 7 Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
The boys dive into this mystery bottle from Finlaggan! A road less traveled, but still a perfectly acceptable Scotch. MST Rating: 7 Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
After trying one of the more terrible scotches known to man, the club returns and receives a gift from the Scotch Gods... or at least the Isle of Skye. The Torabhaig 2017 comes in and dazzles the fellas with its mystery, wonder, and essence of Pears in a Pan! (What does that even mean?) Coined the "mid-summer scotch" by some and the "Willy Wonka scotch" by others. The boys also compare this scotch to their favorite rides at Disneyland. MST Rating: 8.87 Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
Listen as the Gentlemen drag this bottle of Glen Kirk 8yr through the mud! Do not drink this Scotch. MST Rating: 2.1 Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
The Gentlemen sample a bottle of Bowmore 15. The dessert Scotch you might like, but it was a little too sweet the them. Its still scotch though! MST Rating: 5.8 Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
The Gentlemen dive into Benriach 10 yr, The Smokey Ten. They have opinions, make some guesses (most of them wrong), and come up with some brand new words. MST rating: 7.28 Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
No tasting this time. The Gentlemen discuss the best way to blow $500 on Scotch. The consensus.... spent more! Always drink responsibly. Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/mysteryscotchtasting)
The Gentlemen of the World delve into the mystery that is this this un-peated Islay Scotch.
The Gentlemen of the World try to solve the mystery of what they are drinking.... It was a bottle of AD Rattray (distilled by Glen Moray Distillery). Listen in and hear their thoughts on color, smell, and flavor. They think that they're funny too! Enjoy and always drink responsibly.
An extra long episode where the gentlemen sample a bottle of Aberfeldy 12, and have a lot to say about it. Find out what they think!Always drink responsibly.
The Gentlemen try a bottle of Highland Park Cask Strength. Find out what they think about it.Always drink responsibly.
This time Ardbeg Wee Beastie is the bottle, but no body knows.Remember to drink responsibly
The Gentlemen of the World try a bottle of Glenkinchie 12 (without knowing what they are drinking). They talk about it and give it a rating. Always drink responsibly.
The Gentlemen of the World sample a bottle of Scotch, but they don't know what kind. Turns out its Aberlour 16yr. Join them as they look at the color, smell the scent, and taste the flavors. Listen and see if they can decipher the mystery. Always drink responsively!
© 2020-2025 Ivy Podcast Discovery LLC
