This weekly podcast finds two friends who are constantly at odds coming together to talk all things pop culture. With a quirky sense of humor (and a complete lack of humility), Shelby and Matt put their fingers on the pulse of social media’s zeitgeist as they discuss, dissect, and dismantle current…
Shelby and Matt do a deep dive into SJW -- I mean, Captain -- Brie Larson as they talk all the child actor no one remembers to the Oscar winner MCU bros everywhere wish we'd forget. She is the quirky nerd to her peer's cool girl, but is it all an act? Does she have a dream? Is she desperate for fame? IS SHE ANY GOOD?! They break down the hate around her as they try to parse out what works and what doesn't before breaking down her entire filmography. Love her, hate her, but you're probably wrong about her.
Shelby and Matt talk about Nic f**********cking Cage as they break down the splashy meta comedy Unbearable Weight of Massive Talent. From Hollywood jokes, to Nic Cage references, it’s not a question of if it worked but more was it worth it?
It's finally time to talk about Turning Red! Shelby and Matt might be late to the party but that just means they have more to say about this coming-of-age, pro-period Pixar flick that had conservatives feeling all sorts of way.
It’s a slow news week but they talk about Coachella (0:55) and the future of Fantastic Beasts (15:05) plus Barbie gets a shoutout (25:25). For love it or hate it (27:55) Shelby sees Flesh and Matt saw All the Old Knives.
Will Smith gets banned (0:31). Shelby tries to name a Shrek fan (9:55). Kylie Jenner has rules about red carpet (17:50). Jojo Siwa was nominated but not invited (22:55). Bennifer and Britney are reliving the 2000s (26:20). And Brie Larson finally made it (29:00). For love it or hate it (31:50), Shelby sort of recommends The Great and Matt is all in on Sonic 2.
Shelby and Matt talk about The Lost City and the return of the adventure romance genre. With a surprising cast and familiar beats, it's a lot of wondering what works — and what would have worked better.
There’s an update on The Slap (:40). Then an easy transition to The Grammys (11:45). They talk about Legally Blonde 3 (24:45) and then the sad news about Bruce Willis (27:30). For love it or hate it (33:40), Shelby watched Moonshot on HBO and Matt touts Killing It on peacock.
Shelby and Matt come back to talk about the Oscars — the good, the bad, and the Amy Schumer of it all. They start with the red carpet (:45) then dive into the show (8:12) and then finish off with the wins (42:15). Even without the Will Smith discourse, was this a night to remember or one the academy should be desperate to forget?
Shelby and Matt talk about the only thing that anyone’s talking about with this special roundup dedicated to Will Smith vs Chris Rock and the slap heard round the world. For love it or hate it (46:25), Matt saw Everything Everywhere All at Once and Shelby binged Bridgerton Season 2.
It's that time of year again! With the Oscars just a few days away, Matt and Shelby are ranking every movie they saw from 2021. Yes....every. single. one. What will top the list? What will send Shelby into a tailspin? What will make Matt scream in disgust? Listen to find out.
Matt got Gaga tickets but that’s not even close to the important news. Because Love is Blind had a reunion (6:25), Disney doesn’t want to talk about how they’re meddling in politics (14:27), and TikTok dancers might be in a cult (23:20)? For Love It or Hate It (31:20) Shelby finally watched The Woman in the House Across the Street from the Girl in the Window and Matt tried listening to LÉON.
Shelby and Matt are talking about Euphoria, the teen show people love to hate? Hate to love? Watch obsessively but question who hurt Sam Levinson? They break down the season's twists and turns and plot holes, plays and penises, digressing a bit to talk about why their tastes never align and just what they’re looking for in a teenage soap.
Colton Underwood got his final rose (:35). The Oscars are snubbing their own industry (4:15) and SAG awards picked their favorites (19:50). For Love It or Hate It (26:10), Shelby recommends the new sitcom Abbott Elementary and Matt says to avoid Four Good Days
Who will get murdered? Who is doing the murdering? Do they actually have enough champagne to fill the Nile? Matt and Shelby answer these questions and plenty more as they break down the latest adaptation of Agatha Christie's famous whodunit Death on the Nile.
Wordle is making people angry. The Oscars might have a secret (7:43). Euphoria has a nudity problem (13:20). Stranger Things gets another season (22:50). Kelly might not be Clarkson soon (28:25). For Love It or Hate It (32:53), Matt is catching up on RHONY and Shelby is watching Love Is Blind 2.
Shelby and Matt finally get to talk about Oscar nominations breaking down the news of new hosts, hosts and justifying the lack of Spider-Man love. Then it’s on to the surprises and snubs in the major categories as they try to decide what winners would make them happiest—-and who deserved better.
The Super Bowl happened (2:50). Julia Fox has her moment and Kanye won’t move on from his (13:10). For Love it or hate it (20:15), Shelby watched Marry Me and Matt liked I Want You Back.
Moonfall was a terrible movie, but we watched it, so you gotta hear about it. Sorry.
The Queen is maybe still alive (0:35). Joe Rogan will not be sipping tequila with The Rock (4:10). Kylie Jenner had her baby (16:00). And the Super Bowl has a lot lined up (20:25). For Love It or Hate It (26:55), Shelby swipes left on Tinder Swindler and Matt is curious about Suspicion.
Rihanna is pregnant (0:35). Taylor Swift is writing tweets (7:05). Spotify is losing subscribers (16:20). And Dakota Johnson might be a bit weird? (25:40) For love it or hate it (29:30), Shelby recommends Coda and Matt finally watched Second Act.
Shelby (and the general public) pressured Matt into watching Yellowjackets, so now we get to talk about cannibalism and hormones. It turns into a love it or hate it, but they nosedive into likeable girls, realistic gore, and all the possible ghosts in this Showtime original.
West Elm Caleb has the internet’s ire (1:05). Colin Jost and Pete Davidson have a ferry (11:55). Ana de Aromas’ fans have a problem (17:50). Adele has no show (23:40) and the Green M&M has no boots (27:35). For love it or hate it (34:30) Shelby talks Cheer and Matt officially falls for Euphoria.
There's a new Scream movie out (not called Scream 5 even though it is). Matt dragged Shelby to the theater despite her fear of horror movies and now they're talking about it.
Megan Fox and Machine Gun Kelly got engaged for the first time in this life (4:40). Jamie Lynn Spears is trying to sell books (11:00). Joss Whedon is angling for a comeback (15:25). And the Oscars are hoping for a host (). For love it or hate it (25:25), Matt is watching Euphoria and Shelby is trying to make Yellowjackets happen.
Shelby and Matt are on their fourth annual film preview where they make predictions on all the major releases coming out. They may not be good at it but, hey, someone’s gotta do it. From sequels to standalone, high brow to low brow, see what they’re anticipating loving — and hating.
The Golden Globes went live…on twitter (5:25). Tristan Thompson sewed some wild oats (11:03). And we said goodbye to too many legends (18:25). For love it or hate it (25:00) Matt sat through the new Matrix and Shelby is watching Station Eleven.
Shelby and Matt are back to talk about the happy holiday film, Don’t Look Up. From climate change to covid and the deniers in between, they break down what works and what doesn’t in this celebrity fueled satire
Shelby and Matt coming swinging in with their hot takes on Marvel's latest blockbuster, Spider-Man: No Way Home. Spoilers abound as they argue about surprises, revelations, and what-comes-nexts.
Shelby and Matt talk about this new season of Covid but eventually get to the point with what Ben Affleck’s been doing (10:55), who cares about the Golden Globes (16:20), and when John Mulaney actually broke things off (18:21). For Love It or Hate It (23:01), Shelby talks about the nasty new Showtime hit Yellowjackets and Matt gets sucked into RHOSLC.
The Golden Globes are trying to make the golden globes happen (2:42). Sex and the City has it out for Peloton (8:28). The Jeremy Strong profile leaves friends reeling (15:50). And Zendaya and Tom come out publicly (23:01). For love it or hate it (28:18), Shelby talks Selling Sunset and Matt discusses Succession.
Adele’s got a new album (:45). Britney Spears is calling people out (5:35). Tayshia and Zac broke up (8:30). But so did Camila Cabello and Shawn Mendes (11:55). Taylor got a number one (18:00). And Kim K got a new boyfriend (19:20). For Love It or Hate It (23:35), Matt saw King Richard and Shelby appreciated a recommendation for What the Constitution Means to Me.
Shelby gets Matt to listen to Red (Taylor’s Version). It’s a happy, free, confused and verbose time talking about the re-recordings and their general feelings before getting into the bonus tracks and their thoughts on the new All Too Well.
Britney Spears is free (5:00). Adele is coming (7:25). Paris Hilton got married. Taylor Lautner found another Taylor. For love it or hate it (14:20) Matt saw Belfast and Shelby revisits The Baby-Sitter’s Club.
Shelby and Matt talk about Marvel’s Eternals — the good, the bad and…well, none of them are ugly. Hard spoilers at # but expect a general discussion on what works, what didn’t, and what Matt missed when he walks out before the credits are over.
Wicked got a cast (:31). Chris Pratt stepped in it (10:20). Will Smith thinks he could get away with murder (19:55). And Tragedy struck at Astroworld (23:35). For love it or hate it (30:55), Matt watched Last Night in SoHo and Shelby recommends Hulu’s Dopesick.
Celebrities are celebrating Halloween (1:10). Kim Kardashian is holding Pete Davidson’s hand (15:05). Zayn Malik has an anger issue (21:35). And fast food chains are finding new ways to sell combos (24:30). For love it or hate it (31:25), Shelby recommends reading Tokyo Ever After and Matt discovers The Nightmare on Elm Street.
Shelby and Matt are just a couple of sandworms in need of wrangling as they talk about Dune — both the plot, the acting, and the Duncan Idaho of it all. From how it compares to the book, to how many minutes Zendaya actually features, it’s the first big movie of the season and they have thoughts.
We discuss the tragic accident on the set of Alec Baldwin’s film Rust (1:26). Then Matt gives the rundown on Golden Globes (8:15) and Oscar front runners (14:10) with enough time to spare on Olivia Munn (19:30) and Dave Chapelle (22:00). For love it or hate it (27:35) Shelby rates this season of You and Matt gives his thoughts on The French Dispatch. For bonus episodes, join our Patreon at Patreon.com/psyourewrong Check out our merch at psyourewrong.square.site!
Shelby and Matt are here to break down the BIGGEST FRANCHISE IN HISTORY. It’s been a long time coming but No Time to Die is finally out and Shelby and Matt are ready, super ready. They talk about the movie, and spoilers, and the future and then rapid fire questions (42:30).
Matt is back and we are answering the important questions like — who is the bad art friend (5:10)? How did Kim Kardashian do SNL (14:55)? What did Andrew Lloyd Webber think of Cats (19:30)? And when is Adele’s new album coming out (22:12)? For love it or hate it (27:01), Shelby sings praises to Squid Game and Matt made time for The Many Saints of Newark.
Shelby and Matt break down the return to normalcy at the Emmys -- from being in person, to being so white. But it wasn't all bad as they talk about their favorite looks, bits, and wins. For more PS content, including bonus episodes, support our Patreon at www.patreon.com/psyourewrong
The Met Gala happened (2:25). Not that Nicki Minaj was attending (10:15). Then the Rolling Stone’s chose violence with their ranking of the 500 Greatest Songs of All Time (18:14). For Love it or Hate It (26:23), Shelby talks about FX’s Y:The Last Man and Matt sings praises to the new Lil Nas X album Montero. For more content + bonus episodes, support our patreon at www.patreon.com/psyourewrong
Shelby gives a rundown on Bachelor in Paradise (2:30). Matt watched part of the VMAs (16:20). They both cringe about The Activist (20:25). And then TS rapid fire news stories about Britney Spears, Bennifer, and more (25:03). For love it or hate it (28:25), Shelby watched the LuLaRoe documentary and Matt liked Candyman.
Shelby gives a rundown on Bachelor in Paradise (2:30). Matt watched part of the VMAs (16:20). They both cringe about The Activist (20:25). And then TS rapid fire news stories about Britney Spears, Bennifer, and more (25:03). For love it or hate it (28:25), Shelby watched the LuLaRoe documentary and Matt liked Candyman.