Should I Play That?

Follow Should I Play That?
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

A weekly podcast about video games and the industry/culture surrounding them.

Should I Play That?


    • Sep 11, 2023 LATEST EPISODE
    • infrequent NEW EPISODES
    • 1h 50m AVG DURATION
    • 131 EPISODES


    Search for episodes from Should I Play That? with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from Should I Play That?

    Episode 132: Slow Burn

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 11, 2023 73:45


    Chris and Rod are back with a quick catch up episode. Mostly a Whatcha Been Playing segment we talk about Starfield, Street Fighter 6, and Bomb Rush Cyberfunk.

    Episode 131: Vitamins for Drama

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 7, 2023 83:03


    This week, the crew tackle a pair of betas with surprising reception, discuss Multiversus suddenly being taken down, witness another E3 cancellation, and become intrigued by the new Zelda trailer!

    Episode 130: Jinxed Internally

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 17, 2023 104:44


    Join us on this episode of Should I Play That as we discuss the latest games we've been playing. Rod shares his thoughts on the Resident Evil 4 demo and Yakuza Ishin. Alana talks about her experience with Overwatch. Chris discusses the shutdown of AltspaceVR. Plus, don't miss our review of the HBO show The Last of Us.”

    Game of the Year 2022 Part 2

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 10, 2023 80:31


    The exciting deliberations continue as the crew reach a consensus on the Top 10 and ultimately the best game of 2022!

    Game of the Year 2022 Part 1

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 6, 2023 163:23


    Finally, Game of the Year 2022 has arrived for SIPT! The full squad huddle together to whittle down their list of nominated games and compile a Top 10 list.

    Episode 127 “Just Like Old Times”

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 20, 2023 58:46


    SIPT returns! The crew catches up with each other on what we've all been playing (like Hi-Fi Rush) and…watching (The Last of Us on HBO)!?

    Episode 126: Dogmatic: Rebirth

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 2, 2022 78:52


    Not-E3 2022 continues and it's a bit of a surprising week as Xbox + Bethesda kick off their showcase, Overwatch 2's PvP is formally revealed, and even Square Enix manages to sneak in a few surprises. https://mlp.onuniverse.com/

    Episode 125: Hot_Ryu.png

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 11, 2022 107:57


    This week, we have our mod Alana on to tell us about her Overwatch League experience. It's that time of year for gaming news, so we dive into last week's State of Play and we go over the start of the Summer Game Fest. Tune in live on our YouTube channel https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCUE0hTggL3j-rCtDtcGrWOQ Follow our Socials https://www.tiktok.com/@shouldiplaythat https://www.instagram.com/shouldiplaythat/

    Episode 124 : Another SA 2 Reference...

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 3, 2022 89:52


    This week Rod finishes Horizon and gives his thoughts on it and James takes Rods recommendation last week and played through Life is Strange True colors.

    Episode 123: Muckluck strikes again

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 1, 2022 77:06


    This week the guys catch up on gaming news from over the past couple of months. James replays Mass Effect and Rod and Chris weigh in on Horizon Forbidden West.

    Episode 122: We're Back

    Play Episode Listen Later May 3, 2022 102:13


    Time to catch up with Chris, James, and Rod as they talk about what they've been playing since the beginning of the year.

    Ep. 121: GOTY 21 PT3

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 13, 2022 108:45


    The GOTY 2021 finale is here! The Top 10 is finalized and the SIPT team ranks them.

    goty sipt
    Ep. 120: GOTY 21 PT2

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 13, 2022 133:22


    The nomination culling continues as Chris, James, and Rod deliberate further in an effort to form the Top 10!

    Episode 119: Game of the Year 2021 Part 1

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 27, 2022 141:33


    The SIPT crew rings in a new year of episodes with their Game of the Year 2021 discussion!

    Episode 116: That's Meta

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 13, 2021 131:10


    As the end of the year approaches, the SIPT crew spend plenty of time catching up on the various releases that have occupied their time in a jam-packed Whatcha Been Playin' segment. Forza Horizon 5! Guardians of the Galaxy! Unpacking! Lost Judgment! Far Cry 6! For news, Oculus dominated headlines with a couple of new initiatives, Halo Infinite and Elden Ring finally unveiled a glimpse of their campaigns, and Sony showed off a new trailer for a live-action adaptation of the Uncharted series.

    Episode 115: Heart of the Cards

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 22, 2021 100:28


    Chris is back in the driver's seat this week as he gathers James and Rod to discuss everything going on while he's been away. During Whatcha Been Playing, the crew discuss Kena: Bridge of Spirits, Back 4 Blood, Flynn: Son of Crimson, and Dandy Ace! In news, Game Pass misses its' target, Sony brings more first-party titles to PC, and Nintendo unveils an extension of their online service.

    Episode 114: Butt Rock

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 9, 2021 112:25


    Alana fills in as a guest this week as James and Rod join her in a deep dive over the past week's games like Outer Wilds: Echoes of the Eye, Tales of Arise, and the Halo Infinite flight! The gang also manage to catch up on the biggest news from the console makers like Nintendo's Direct plus highlights from Sony's State of Play!

    Episode 111: What a Name

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 18, 2021 197:49


    In this episode of Should I Play That, Gamemaster Herb(twitch.tv/3bearsgayming) shares his thoughts on E3 2021 and talks about some of his favorite games from the show. Watch us live on Wednesday nights on twitch.tv/ssjblackarrot

    Episode 110: Into the Thick of It

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 15, 2021 119:47


    As E3 2021 rounds the corner, the SIPT crew begin to speculate about what may or may not make an appearance and what they're anticipating overall. Also, with the Summer Games Festival kick-off show complete, they review what was shown. Listen live on Wednesday nights on twitch.tv/ssjblackarrot

    Episode 109: Slimes With Guns

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 4, 2021 177:43


    Episode 109: Slimes With Guns by Should I Play That?

    Episode 108

    Play Episode Listen Later May 28, 2021 172:57


    The guys are joined by Gamemaster Herb (Twitch.tv/3bearsgayming)on this episode, and they discuss Herbs favorite games that cost less than $5.They also chat about what a "Games as a service" means for the future of gaming. Listen live on Wednesday nights on twitch.tv/ssjblackarrot

    Episode 107

    Play Episode Listen Later May 21, 2021 131:41


    We're back live on Twitch every Wednesday night at 9:30est! Join us as we talk about Mass Effect: Legendary Edition, Persona 5 strikers, and Yupitergrad. Sony dominates the news cycle and we discuss how cryptocurrency can have positive or negative effects on gaming in general.

    Episode 106: & Park

    Play Episode Listen Later May 9, 2021 110:14


    This week, the SIPT crew travel the stars in Mass Effect: Andromeda, learn about the trials of love in It Takes Two, and perpetually re-live the same experience in the new PS5 blockbuster Returnal!

    Episode 105: Mr. HotKeys

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 30, 2021 93:07


    Cedrick joins the crew this week to help discuss Apex Legends, the latest Warzone changes, It Takes Two, and Resident Evil: Village! For news, Jeff Kaplan leaves Blizzard, Sony isn’t shutting down their store after all, Discord won’t be purchased, and rumors of a Square-Enix acquisition aren’t true.

    Episode 104: The Demon’s Souls of The Frontier

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 19, 2021 123:18


    April is halfway over and there may be GOTY contenders already…!? See what all the fuss is about during this week’s Whatcha Been Playin’ as the crew dive into It Takes Two, Oregon Trail, and Swarm. In News, each of the big 3 have a segment: Nintendo unveils more indies during a showcase, rumors abound that MS is publishing Hideo Kojima’s next project, and a story about one of Sony’s support studios causes quite the stir.

    Episode 103: Statement of Statements

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 11, 2021 118:01


    Chris is absent this week but never fear: Alana is here! And she brings a little something different to Whatcha Been Playin’ this week while James gives first impressions on Outriders and Rod briefly chats about Knockout City and League of Legends: Wild Rift. For news, Bioware has updates on the Mass Effect remaster and E3 2021 is officially on!

    Episode 102: Year of Toad

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 2, 2021 81:14


    The crew continue to move forward in the Halo franchise and Janes still can’t put Avengers down. News refuses to slow down as we have updates on sales figures for the Quest and Monster Hunter Rise, more concrete details on the new Switch, and new indie titles recently unveiled at ID@Xbox.

    Episode 101: Good Hair

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 27, 2021 109:37


    This week, James has impressions on the next-gen Avengers and Chris begins his journey through the Halo franchise. Meanwhile, the news is busy as Microsoft begins rebranding Xbox Live, Square Enix holds a showcase, and Sony announces the closing of their old storefronts, reveals the PSVR2 controller, and purchases EVO.

    Episode 100: It’s A Start

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 19, 2021 133:53


    Finally! The 100th episode has arrived. Celebrate with Chris, James, and Rod as they revisit Halo campaigns and explore the capability of the Backbone peripheral, become amazed at the sheer audacity (and implications) of the recent Game Pass offerings, and reflect on the memories and lessons accrued from the past 99 episodes. If you’re a new listener, welcome. If you’re a regular, thank you. Here’s to 100 more!

    Episode 99: Super Switch

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 13, 2021 128:08


    James rediscovers an old flame in Final Fantasy XIV and Chris has his heaviest Whatcha Been Playin’ segment in a long time with titles including Ghost of Tsushima and Valheim! Meanwhile, Nintendo seemingly preps a new version of Switch, Microsoft’s acquisition of Zenimax is fully complete, and Mario Day (MAR10) is upon us!

    Episode 98: No Star

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 5, 2021 92:03


    This week, Rod’s been digging into new releases like Persona 5 Strikers and Bowser’s Fury while the entire crew checks out the Outriders demo. News covers the Japan Studio re-organization, Sony’s recent State of Play, and a pair of big Pokémon announcements for the franchise’s 25th anniversary. Speaking of anniversaries, the Topic covers significant gaming anniversaries and how meaningful they actually are.

    Episode 97: Striving to Feel Guilty About Switching Gears

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 26, 2021 130:37


    Black History Month comes to a conclusion, and with it, a dedicated Topic about the significance of that in the game space! Plus, James tries Shadow of War, Rod jumps into Galaxy, and Chris digs in to Borderlands 3. In a jam-packed News section, Microsoft provides a FPS boost to certain older titles, Sony talks about PSVR2, a bunch of Overwatch 2 information is released, and the ultimate fate of Anthem is finally revealed.

    Episode 96: New Software, Same Us

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 19, 2021 111:26


    This week, James finishes Hades, Rod jumps into Super Mario Sunshine, and Chris dives further into Control! In the news, the NPD January 2021 sales are in, G4 is preparing to return, Google throws in the towel, and the crew tackles the first Nintendo Direct in quite some time.

    Episode 95: The Return

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 17, 2021 131:25


    The SIPT returns for the new year and eases back into things by recalling what they’ve been playing over the break. Superhot: Mind Control Delete, Destruction All-stars, 13 Sentinels: Aegis Rim, Control: Ultimate Edition, Risk of Rain 2, and much more!

    risk rain control ultimate edition superhot mind control delete sipt
    Episode 94: Game of the Year 2020 Part 3

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 8, 2021 65:28


    The top 10 games have finally been selected. It’s now time for the crew to put them in ranking order and ultimately crown SIPT’s Game of the Year 2020!

    Episode 93: Game of the Year 2020 Part 2

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 1, 2021 97:12


    The Game of the Year debate continues as the nominees dwindle until only the top 10 games of 2020 remain!

    Episode 92: Game of the Year 2020 Part 1

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 25, 2020 112:43


    Game of the Year 2020 has finally arrived! The full SIPT ensemble is here as they sift through nearly 40 nominated games in order to craft their collective top 10 list.

    SIPT Ep 91: Fell Through the World

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 18, 2020 91:28


    As 2020 draws to a close and the time to pick SIPT’s Game of the Year approaches, the crew conduct the year’s final, normal episode by discussing more CD Projekt Red follies, the latest incoming Nintendo indie titles, and the highs and lows of The Game Awards 2020.

    SIPT Ep 90: If The Bug Fits

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 11, 2020 99:34


    Just because the show’s runtime is shorter this week doesn’t mean that the SIPT crew is bringing less heat! And there’s plenty to go around as Subject and Rod dive into Ghost of Tsushima: Legends while James explores Immortals: Fenyx Rising and romantic indie title Haven. Afterward, everyone finally sits down to have a serious discussion of the major controversy surrounding CD Projekt Red and their newest game, Cyberpunk 2077.

    SIPT Ep 89: Please Season Your Turkey

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 4, 2020 129:43


    The SIPT gang recover from the holiday by gathering to discuss fall titles like Assassin’s Creed Valhalla, Hyrule Warriors, and Yakuza: Like a Dragon (and Subject floats the suggestion that all Pokémon titles may contain a Groundhog Day-influenced narrative…!? ). News is fresh with next-gen sales figures and player experimentation with the PS5’s Activities feature. The show closes with a discussion of moments in games that left the crew truly and thoroughly shook.

    Episode 88: Del Train, Baby!

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 27, 2020 151:13


    New generation launch excitement continues as the crew shifts their attention toward exploring the PlayStation 5! Before that, they discuss Assassin’s Creed: Valhalla, Gears of War 4, Yakuza: Like a Dragon, and The Game Awards 2020 nominees!

    Episode 87: SIPT-ers

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 20, 2020 87:11


    It’s finally arrived: next-gen has begun! With the release of the Xbox Series X/S, we embark on the journey of a new console cycle and discuss the highs and lows of Microsoft’s latest machine. Before that, the crew talk about Forza Horizon 4 and Assassin’s Creed: Valhalla, ponder the likelihood of a MS-acquired Japanese studio, and reminisce about Mass Effect due to the upcoming remaster.

    Episode 85: John Cena

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 30, 2020 131:19


    SIPT returns with the latest on the new Hyrule Warriors, an expanded look on Hades, and a fresh pair of VR goodies. For news, Cyberpunk suffers yet another delay, PS5 and Xbox Series X/S have unboxings, and Nintendo has its’ last Partner Showcase of the year. To wrap up, the Topic this week covers the recent, major delays in gaming and what industry standards may change moving forward into the next generation.

    Episode 82: HaloXDoom?

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 25, 2020 124:32


    Microsoft bought Bethesda. That’s not a sentence anyone thought they would read when this week started yet here we are. The crew discuss the impact of this industry-shattering event along with the future ramifications right after they trade next-gen console pre-order tales, James/Rod travel to the Underworld in Hades, and Chris finishes Marvel’s Avengers and dives into the new Samurai Jack game!

    Episode 81: Zuck’s Watching

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 18, 2020 112:18


    Now that Microsoft revealed its’ hand, it’s time for Sony’s response — and they certainly respond! The week brings another PS5 showcase filled with upcoming games, the console release date, and price! Before that, James and Rod continue digging into Marvel’s Avengers while Chris gets into the rhythm with Bullets Per Minute.

    Episode 80: Bailed

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 11, 2020 146:39


    Huge news abound for a short week! Chris re-discovers Monster Hunter: World while James and Rod indulge in superheroics and extreme sports with the week’s brand new releases of Marvel’s Avengers and Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 1 + 2. In the meantime, Sony’s gaining further interest in putting first-party titles on PC, Oculus may have a Quest 2 ready sooner than anticipated, and at long last...Microsoft has finally revealed their full launch details!

    Episode 79: We Are Back

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 4, 2020 154:28


    James traverses the post-apocalypse in Wasteland 3, Rod is astounded by The Friends of Ringo Ishikawa, and Chris faces his fears in Dread X Collection 2! Meanwhile, Nvidia drops their new, shocking GPU line, a brand new Switch is rumored to be arriving early next year, and the crew discuss the next path for VR upon the impending arrival of next-gen.

    Episode 78: Sick-Rank

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 21, 2020 132:06


    James finds new joy in Transistor while Rod is elated with Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 1 + 2. News is decidedly less happy with Epic and Apple in a massive, public fight, Rocksteady is the latest studio in the spotlight for harassment claims, and E3 tweets a truly baffling article.

    Episode 77: Delay Party

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 14, 2020 141:22


    Chris has humorous escapades in Onward, James continues saving Japan in Ghost of Tsushima, and Rod has a multitude of games from the week including Doom Eternal and Cris Tales! News is particularly busy as Microsoft announces a delay for Halo Infinite, Sony hosts a third-party State of Play, Warner Brothers may still be on the chopping block, and the crew wraps up with a discussion on the current state of marketplace competition. Thanks for checking us out! Please be sure to leave a “Like”, comment, and subscribe to our show feed; we really appreciate it! You can always email us at shouldiplaythatfanmail@gmail.com. Also, be sure to drop us some feedback and follow us on our other social media platforms like Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, and Instagram! Stay Beastly!

    Episode 76:...And You Doubled Down On It

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 7, 2020 129:40


    The crew talk about the latest releases in Fall Guys and Paper Mario, become baffled at the latest exclusivity deal, get frustrated with ongoing wage disparity in the industry, and debate every possible facet of chicken wings. Thanks for checking us out! Please be sure to leave a “Like”, comment, and subscribe to our show feed; we really appreciate it! You can always email us at shouldiplaythatfanmail@gmail.com. Also, be sure to drop us some feedback and follow us on our other social media platforms like Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, and Instagram! Stay Beastly!

    Episode 75: Another Hot Take

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 31, 2020 144:46


    James and Rod make a return trip through destroyed beauty in Ghost of Tsushima while Chris continues the adventure in Cross Code. Meanwhile, the crew discusses the Xbox July 2020 showcase, the US military using streaming platforms for recruitment, and Marvel’s The Avengers new video with fresh details. Rounding out the show, the Topic poses the question of whether or not video games are becoming too long and how that affects the current value proposition. Thanks for checking us out! Please be sure to leave a “Like”, comment, and subscribe to our show feed; we really appreciate it! You can always email us at shouldiplaythatfanmail@gmail.com. Also, be sure to drop us some feedback and follow us on our other social media platforms like Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, and Instagram! Stay Beastly!

    Claim Should I Play That?

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel