Deconstructing Comics

FLASHBACK! Eileen Gray: A House Under the Sun is a slim graphic novel by Charlotte Malterre-Barthes and Zosia Dzierzawska, about the titular famous Irish architect that most people have never heard of. Kumar and Emmet found it beautiful and intriguing; here's their review. (Originally published August 28, 2019.) This episode includes a new intro from … Continue reading #633 “Eileen Gray: A House Under the Sun”

Ken Krimstein‘s Einstein in Kafkaland: How Albert Fell Down the Rabbit Hole and Came up with the Universe builds on the fact that these two stars of the early 20th century were part of the same friend group at one point and builds it up into what NPR described as “Alice in Wonderland meets The … Continue reading #841 Ken Krimstein on Einstein, Kafka, and comics in general

Joe Sacco has been covering the Israel-Palestine conflict in varying forms since 1991: first in Palestine, then in Footnotes in Gaza, and most recently in War on Gaza. It's too much for Kumar and Dana to contain in their heads all at once, both in terms of information and emotion, especially for poor Kumar, who … Continue reading #840 Joe Sacco's books on the Middle East

FLASHBACK! The 1990s DC series Starman is one of comicdom's most fondly remembered series. Interestingly, says series author James Robinson, it seems to be more popular now than it was when it was actually in production! James joins Tim and Ryan Haupt this week to look back on various aspects of this iconic series, including … Continue reading #385 The Legacy of “Starman”

Fables of Fear is an anthology horror title by Karl Brandt and David Parsons. Tim and Adam discuss; there are some good short stories here, but maybe they're a bit … TOO short? Black Plastic, by Josh Tierney and Nicci Busse is, as its writer says, a “karaoke cyber-thriller” graphic novel. That's his description; Tim … Continue reading Critiquing Comics #243: “Fables of Fear” and “Black Plastic”

FLASHBACK! This week a wide-ranging discussion between two Canadians, Koom and Ian, about comics in Canada. The talk centers on Montreal-based publisher Drawn & Quarterly, and two books from their catalog: Michel Rabagliati's 2005 book Paul Moves Out, and the latest from Jillian Tamaki, Boundless. Also, some deep background on the history and people behind … Continue reading #559 Drawn & Quarterly and Canadian comics

FLASHBACK! Skim is a coming-of-age graphic novel written by Mariko Tamaki, and drawn by her cousin Jillian Tamaki. Jillian works primarily in the field of illustration; how does she find that different from drawing a comic? Is it wrong to say that a comic is “illustrated”? She also discusses her perhaps unorthodox collaboration with Mariko … Continue reading #210 Jillian Tamaki interview(s)

This week we look at the movie that was based on the “Galactus Trilogy” of Fantastic Four #48-50, Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer. How does it stand up against the comics, and against the 2005 film? How do we feel about Galactus being a cloud of smoke? Does Doom finally have a real plan … Continue reading #839 The Fantastic Four on Film: “Rise of the Silver Surfer” (2007)

One of the most famous Fantastic Four stories is the “Galactus Trilogy” from Fantastic Four 48-50 in 1966. This story has been adopted more than once, including in the 1990s FF cartoon, and in 2007's Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer. Leading into our discussion of that movie next week, this week Tim, Kumar, … Continue reading #838 The Fantastic Four on Film: The Galactus Trilogy

When Steve and Sam foil an attempt by police from south of the border to arrest their friendly waiter, the cops decide to arrest Steve instead! Hey, beats heading home empty handed! What looks like it's going to be a story about Cap (and maybe Falcon?) locked up in a Central American prison takes several … Continue reading #837 Jack Kirby's Captain America 206-208: The Tiger, the Swine…and the Fish

In Clyde Fans by Seth, two brothers run a fan company for fifty years. One might expect it to be prosaic, but instead it's an immersive and epic exploration of the sense and meaning of life, every life, even when it's not apparent on the surface. Kumar and Dana ask the big questions. Brought to … Continue reading #836 “Clyde Fans” reviewed by two fans

Briana Loewinsohn, who got a lot of praise two years back for her graphic memoir Ephemera, is back with a new book, Raised by Ghosts. It's a slightly fictionalized look at Briana's teen years, acting as both a time capsule of late-20th-century teenager culture, and the struggles of being comfortable with oneself that ‘s almost … Continue reading #835 “Raised by Ghosts”: A time capsule, but relevant to anyone who's been a teen

What's that Kirby Crackle octopus chasing Cap and Falcon? And didn't it used to be an oddly muscular, bald (naturally) corpse? It's Agron, who gives our heroes some headaches in Captain America and the Falcon issues 204 and 205. Not the best Jack Kirby Cap adventure ever, but it produces at least one wildly T-shirt-worthy … Continue reading #834 Jack Kirby's “Cap and Falcon” vs a bodybuilding corpse

The Night People are looking for a superhero. But who are the Night People? Where do they come from? And what does one have to sacrifice to become their superhero? Tim and Emmet discuss Captain America and the Falcon issues 201-203! Brought to you by: Worst Collection Ever podcast Our supporters on Patreon

Michael Cohen has created comics such as Strange Attractors and Tangled River, and is credited with helping to create the first known comic book price guide. He's also co-host of the Unpacking Peanuts podcast, and his talk with Tim includes discussion of Charles Schultz's strip, including about the reason why Michael has no interest in … Continue reading #832 Michael Cohen: Comics price guides, “Peanuts”, and more

While the 2005 film Fantastic Four gives us, debatably, a well-casted group of heroes, with plenty of comics-accurate details, the script does no favors to Dr. Doom. What are his goals, other than “taking everything back” from Reed? Why is he a CEO instead of a despot? Who the heck gives a frightening metal mask … Continue reading #831 The Fantastic Four on Film: “Fantastic Four” (2005) pt 2: What does Doom want?!

The Star Tide Shores is an action space adventure comic that isn't afraid to get a little deeper emotionally than, say, Star Wars. Tim and Adam enjoyed reading the first volume, by Henry Goeldner and Illuminated, and are here to give you the scoop.

After the fiasco of the 1994 unreleased Fantastic Four movie, development proceeded on a big-budget FF film, which finally hit theaters in 2005 — a better film than the '94 attempt in some ways, but frustratingly as bad or worse in others. This week, in another crossover with the Comic Book Movie Oblivion podcast, Tim … Continue reading #830 The Fantastic Four on Film: “Fantastic Four” (2005) pt 1: “I am hot, and I'm not afraid to cry”

Captain America was the obvious choice of a character to help Marvel celebrate the USA's bicentennial in 1976. The job of doing that went to Jack Kirby, co-creator of the character. Naturally, that meant a story full of hard-hitting moments, and one that gets a bit treacly at the end, but also doesn't back away … Continue reading #829 Jack Kirby's “Captain America's Bicentennial Battles”

Oni are mythical monsters similar to the ogres of Western tradition. Like many of the legendary Japanese creatures, their characteristics are often adopted for manga characters, including series such as Lum, The Promised Neverland, and Demon Slayer. Our own Patrick has compiled a lot of data on them, and he's here this time to fill … Continue reading #828 Japan's mythical “oni” in manga

The second omnibus volume of Mitsuru Adachi's Cross Game focuses largely on a scrimmage between the varsity team and the “portables”, which doesn't go how anyone expects it to. Things are shifting subtly under the surface; we're pretty sure what the series is leading up to (it's a baseball manga, after all), but it's fun … Continue reading #827 “Cross Game” Omnibus 2: Subtle Shifts

When Hugh D'Andrade was ten years old, his next door neighbor was mysteriously murdered, and he saw the body. In his forthcoming graphic memoir The Murder Next Door, he explores the trauma this caused him as the experience stuck with him over decades, and he explores the question: If someone else has had a worse … Continue reading #826 Hugh D'Andrade's “The Murder Next Door”: Your trauma is your trauma

Brad Guigar, creator of Evil Inc., has been putting his comics on the Web for over 20 years, and this week he's here to talk about how he made that his day job, the challenges of promoting your work in a changing media environment, how making an erotic comic (his Patreon-only spinoff Evil Inc. After Dark) … Continue reading #825 Brad Guigar talks promoting your webcomic, even (especially?) if it's NSFW!

Tim is now completely caught up with the MCU! Mulele joins him to discuss the most recently released (as of this episode's recording) Marvel Cinematic Universe film, last summer's Spider-Man: Far From Home! (Originally published on Patreon March 28, 2020) Brought to you by: The Law of Equivalent Exchange: A Fullmetal Alchemist manga podcast Our … Continue reading “Spider-Man: Far from Home” (2019)

Now that we've become familiar with Jack Kirby‘s original Eternals comics, repeatedly referring to the 2021 MCU film along the way, it's time to sit through all two hours and 37 minutes of it again and evaluate it anew. Unfortunately, as a movie, it still has just as many problems, but at least now Tim … Continue reading #824 “Eternals” (2021): Where it went wrong (and right!)

Samuel Edme's comic The Shapes is… a bit hard to pin down. It looks like notebook scribblings, it has its faults, but it seems to have found an audience, which is all a comics creator can ask for. Bad? No. Not for us? Probably. Tim and Adam attempt to describe it anyway.

We've reached the end of Jack Kirby‘s Eternals series. Sure, it was a weird series, but introducing a Hulk robot apparently did little for the sales numbers. How did Kirby wrap things up? For a series that featured so many characters (though not as many as the freakin' movie, which we'll get to soon!), he … Continue reading #823 Jack Kirby's “Eternals,” #17-19: Lots o' Ikaris (or Ikarus?)

The 1994 film The Fantastic Four seems to have been made with the expectation, at least from producer Roger Corman on down, that it would be released. While some interested parties have claimed that it was only made to help Constantin Film's Bernd Eichinger keep his option to make an FF film from expiring, others … Continue reading #822 The Fantastic Four on Film: “The Fantastic Four” (1994) (part two) Why wasn't the film released?

By the early '90s, Superman and Batman were blockbuster movie franchises, but Marvel had yet to find a way to get a big-budget film made based on their characters, let alone succeed at the box office. Bernd Eichinger of Constantin Film owned the film rights to the Fantastic Four, but those rights were soon to … Continue reading #821 The Fantastic Four on Film: “The Fantastic Four” (1994), a Roger Corman production (part one)

Jack Kirby‘s The Eternals was not a conventional superhero book. It didn't even seem to take place in the Marvel Universe. By issue 14, it appears that Marvel editorial must have been pressuring him to make it more Marvel Universe-y, which would account for the appearance of the Hulk in issues 14-16… except it's not … Continue reading #820 Jack Kirby's “Eternals,” #14-16: The Coming of…. The Editor!

This week we catch up with the work of two DCP favorites, Chad Bilyeu and David Dye! Chad's series The Re-up, about his time as a pot dealer 20 years ago, continues and has overcome the skepticism Tim had of the series at the start. David has released three more issues of Amazing Tales and … Continue reading #819 We catch up with “The Re-up” and “Amazing Tales”

If you've ever felt like your city left you before you left your city, Jason McNamara's Ghost Band is for you. Tim and Emmet discuss this post-apocalyptic look at San Francisco. Jason then taps in to explain the inspiration for the book and what happened to artist Vincent Gladnick 2/3 of the way through. Meanwhile, … Continue reading #818 Requiems: “Ghost Band” and “Grimm's Assistant”

Tim gets ever closer to catching up with the MCU! Tim and Mulele discuss Avengers: Endgame‘s time-travel explanation (and problems), Captain Marvel's relative irrelevance to the film, how this movie set the stage for the upcoming TV shows, and much more. (Originally published on Patreon March 14, 2020) Brought to you by: Bat Bits podcast … Continue reading “Avengers: Endgame” (2019)

FLASHBACK! Sports have rarely been subject matter for comics in the US; perhaps comics' inherent static-ness has seemed antithetical to an activity with so much movement. But Japan has seen comics about various sports, and some of them have been quite popular, even iconic. Takehiko Inoue's Real is not only about basketball, but about physical … Continue reading #437 “Real” is a slam dunk

Most Americans know little about the Crimean War (1853-1856). Adam McGovern and Bruno Letizia's The Night Brigade may go some way toward filling us in on that conflict, and it does give us several historical figures, including Florence Nightingale – but it also features a werewolf. Tim and Adam critique. Asante Amani‘s Joe Mallard gives … Continue reading Critiquing Comics #240: “The Night Brigade” and “Joe Mallard”

We left the Eternals joined together in the Unimind. The 1977 Annual doesn't clearly fit into continuity, but features only one Eternal, Thena, together with Deviants Karkas and the Reject against a time-traveling threat! Back in the regular series, issue 13 gives us exactly two Eternals, trying to stop a Deviant attack on the Celestials. … Continue reading #817 Jack Kirby's “Eternals”, 1977 Annual + #13: Fun “Eternals” stories with few Eternals

Chester Brown's work has come up on this show a number of times over the years. We've discussed Ed the Happy Clown, Louis Riel, and Paying for It. He's actually published 10 graphic novels since 1989, some of which are collections of his comics series. In connection with the recent premiere of the movie version … Continue reading #816 Chester Brown interview: “Paying for It,” the movie

FLASHBACK! A comic strip gag can be a deceptively simple thing. Once you take it apart — “deconstruct” it, one might say — you find that it actually has many moving parts. Paul Karasik and Mark Newgarden‘s How to Read “Nancy” takes a close look at each of those parts — as well as arguing … Continue reading #593 “Reading ‘Nancy'”, plus “Cat and Mouse”!

What does an 11-year-old do when her “only friend” moves away? In Coco Fox's “sorta” memoir Let's Go, Coco, she joins the basketball team. But when you're a pre-teen, everything's fraught with challenges. Tim and Adam discuss this book – aimed at middle schoolers, but recommended for all ages. As far from that world as … Continue reading Critiquing Comics #239: “Let's Go, Coco” and “Digital Bardos”

FLASHBACK! It's been more than 70 years now since the debut of Archie comics, featuring (though not quite from the beginning) America's favorite love triangle of Archie, Veronica, and Betty. Along with Jughead, Reggie, and the rest of the gang, these characters keep us coming back for more, changing with the times while still presenting … Continue reading #338 Everything's Archie!

Eternals are only human, I guess! In Eternals issues 9-12, many of the Eternals exhibit a segregationist attitude toward the Deviants, and just about everybody assumes Karkas is going to kick the Reject‘s butt in a fight based solely on how they look. Meanwhile, are the Celestials kind, or sadistic? Tim and Emmet discuss Jack … Continue reading #815 Jack Kirby's “Eternals”, #9-12: Judging books by their covers

FLASHBACK! A then-recent R. Crumb compilation is reviewed by a Crumb connoisseur (Kumar) and a Crumb newbie (Tim). The book features Crumb at his sweetest and his most shocking. But can this (or any book) claim to be the perfect Crumb compilation? (Originally published June 30, 2008.) Brought to you by: To the Batpoles! podcast … Continue reading #134 “The R. Crumb Handbook”

Once again we take a look at some comics submitted by their creators; we talk about what we liked about them and what could have been better. Jane Jet book 1: Nuclear Shadows, by writer Amal Desai and artist Paul Essenson, recalls Dave Stevens' Rocketeer — the art, the jet-pack concept, the time period — … Continue reading Critiquing Comics #238: “Jane Jet” and “The Fog Within”

FLASHBACK! While Alan Moore and J.H. Williams' Promethea, published from 1999 to 2005, is not one of Moore's most remembered works, it's not because the author wasn't at the top of his game. Kumar and Emmet find it to be entrancing, even if you don't buy into the various magical and spiritual elements that Moore … Continue reading #591 “Promethea”: A mind-bending, life-changing comic

FLASHBACK! Harold Gray's Little Orphan Annie debuted in 1924 and was a big success. FDR having not yet turned him against organized labor, Gray shows hardworking Annie going on strike in one of her many jobs. Tim and Kumar discuss the '20s strips, their strengths and idiosyncrasies (one strip=one day?!), and how Gray's outlook changed … Continue reading #296 “Little Orphan Annie”

Back in Critiquing Comics 154, Tim and Mulele discussed 2019's Captain Marvel; Tim enjoyed it, Mulele did not. Now that we've arrived at the time to give it a full review as part of “Tim Catches Up with the MCU,” another viewing has helped us both to clarify our positions and see things we didn't … Continue reading “Captain Marvel” (2019)

FLASHBACK! Twenty years after the first collection of Hicksville was released, creator Dylan Horrocks talks to Emmet about how the comic looks to him now. Some of the work's commentary on the comics industry turned out to presage subsequent developments, and in some cases he ended up not going far enough! Also, his source for … Continue reading #598 Dylan Horrocks looks back at “Hicksville”

Reading the original Jack Kirby iteration of The Eternals shows that the MCU movie based on the title was rather dour, where Kirby's version veers into wackiness! Sersi shows quite the sense of humor. SHIELD agents appear who just can't seem to accept that they can't get the upper hand on giant space gods! People … Continue reading #814 Jack Kirby's “Eternals” 5-8: As wacky as they wanna be

Mitsuru Adachi's Cross Game is a baseball manga for people who don't care about baseball. A tragedy early in the story helps to shape the narrative, but there's also a good dose of unexpected comedy, and sequences that really make us want to cheer for Ko and his friends as they work toward the goal … Continue reading #813 “Cross Game”: Baseball manga that's not about baseball (much)

Jonah Lobe, after many years designing characters for video games, has recently turned his attention to comics. He's the illustrator of Marvel Anatomy: A Scientific Study of the Superhuman, in which we can finally learn just what's going on inside characters like Wolverine, Venom, and Modok. He's also on the verge of his first Kickstarter … Continue reading #812 Jonah Lobe on character anatomy and “Quiet: Level One”

On the surface, Sammy Harkham's Blood of the Virgin is about an editor of b-movies in 1970s L.A. who has greater artistic aspirations, but it's also rich with unexpected explorations of character and narrative approaches, themes about the creative process, responsibility, and being an immigrant, and Harkham's best art and writing to date. Over a … Continue reading #811 “Blood of the Virgin”: About much more than filmmaking