Podcast appearances and mentions of Craig Carton

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate over the potential impact John Harbaugh will have on the Giants. Plus, reaction to Malik Nabers starting camp completely off the PUP list (23:55); Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash on if it's playoffs or bust for the Giants (32:30); Evan argues the Giants should sign Vita Vea (50:03)

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate over the potential impact John Harbaugh will have on the Giants. Plus, reaction to Malik Nabers starting camp completely off the PUP list (23:55); Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash on if it's playoffs or bust for the Giants (32:30); Evan argues the Giants should sign Vita Vea (50:03)

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate over the potential impact John Harbaugh will have on the Giants. Plus, reaction to Malik Nabers starting camp completely off the PUP list (23:55); Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash on if it's playoffs or bust for the Giants (32:30); Evan argues the Giants should sign Vita Vea (50:03)

The Tiki Time Machine goes back to the Jets drafting Geno Smith in 2013, and the old WFAN reactions are stunning in hindsight. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash revisit takes from Boomer Esiason, Craig Carton, Joe Benigno, Mike Francesa and a much younger Evan, then decide Francesa came closest to identifying the pick for what it really was: a second-round gamble on a quarterback the Jets did not truly love. The archives also uncover a young Tommy Lugauer receiving an on-air assignment from Boomer and Carton before delivering a polished sports minute on J.R. Smith. The nostalgia leads back to a familiar Jets problem, as Geno Smith's draft-day slide is compared to Cade Klubnik and the impossible criticism teams face when deciding how long to wait on a quarterback.

Craig Carton and Chris "C-Mac" McMonigle are back on WFAN with a wildly entertaining segment of The Carton Show!

Craig Carton and Chris "C-Mac" McMonigle dive into the wild world of college sports economics on this segment of WFAN's The Carton Show! The guys break down the staggering financial numbers from Penn State's athletic department. While the Penn State football team raked in a massive $58 million net operating profit, the athletic department as a whole only walked away with a net profit of $223,000!

Craig Carton and Chris "C-Mac" McMonigle are back breaking down a wild start to NFL Training Camp! The guys kick things off reacting to the massive relief of seeing Malik Nabers completely off the PUP list and looking electric at Giants camp. Then, things get crazy in Minnesota as reports surface of Kyler Murray and J.J. McCarthy throwing hands after a camp interception. Is competition boiling over, or is this a disaster for the Vikings? Finally, they take a call from Stevie on Long Island to debate the future of Big Blue. Is the John Harbaugh and Jaxson Dart era enough to wash the 15-year "stink" off the Giants organization, or is it going to take a lot more than coaching to get back to winning? Plus, a quick shoutout to Lil Wayne and French Montana killing it in Bangor, Maine!

Craig Carton and Chris "C-Mac" McMonigle jump right into the fire on this segment of WFAN's The Carton Show, defending Robert Saleh against critical callers while breaking down NFL Training Camp hype, hilarious history debates, and unique fan memorabilia!

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze Malik Nabers' health at training camp and debate the potential for the Jets to relocate to the Aqueduct Racetrack site in Queens. They test an intern's knowledge of Eagles history with a trivia question about 4,000-yard passing seasons. The discussion concludes with a deep dive into the Yankees' trade deadline needs and Aaron Boone's recent management success. 01:25 - Malik Nabers Impresses at Camp 06:01 - Potential Jets Move to Aqueduct 16:15 - Nashville Travel and App Issues 23:15 - Eagles QB Yardage Trivia Challenge 34:50 - Yankees Success Under Aaron Boone 45:15 - John Harbaugh and Giants' Future 51:00 - Yankees Trade Deadline Strategy

The John Harbaugh debate reaches another level. Craig Carton doubles down on his controversial take that Giants fans are overrating their new head coach, while Chris McMonigle passionately defends Harbaugh's winning résumé. The two go back and forth over playoff expectations, Lamar Jackson, Joe Flacco, Brian Daboll, and whether Giants fans are setting themselves up for disappointment.

Forty years later, Mookie Wilson takes Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle behind the scenes of one of the greatest moments in baseball history. From his unforgettable Game 6 at-bat against the Red Sox to his emotional friendship with Bill Buckner, Mookie shares stories Mets fans have never heard. He also reflects on the chemistry that made the 1986 Mets champions, why today's Mets are falling short, and what this year's 40th anniversary celebration means. Don't miss one of the best baseball interviews you'll hear all year.

After setting Giants fans on fire, Carton doubles down on his claim that John Harbaugh is the most overrated coach in the NFL. Chris McMonigle pushes back, callers defend Harbaugh's résumé, and the debate quickly turns into one of the hottest Giants conversations of training camp.

Craig Carton and Chris "C-Mac" McMonigle bring the heat to WFAN! In this segment, the guys talk New York Jets expectations, Yankees trade deadline moves, and a major shakeup for local sports streaming. Plus, Craig interrogates C-Mac about his parenting rules for an upcoming Disney cruise.

Craig Carton and Big Mac react to former wide receiver Plaxico Burris comparing his time with the New York Jets to serving a prison sentence. They also debate whether the New York Giants can replicate recent historic playoff turnarounds and revisit Carton's awkward run-in with movie critic Rex Reed. 01:20 - NFL Playoff Turnaround History 05:00 - Giants Postseason Expectations Debate 11:35 - Plaxico Burris Slams Jets 15:30 - Jets Loser Culture Discussion 19:45 - Jets Draft Selection Critique 23:35 - Long Island Roadway Rant 27:35 - Carton Syracuse Career Story 32:00 - Port Jefferson Ferry Controversy 37:30 - Movie Review Discussion 42:30 - Famous Critic Encounter Story

The Yankees escaped with a wild win, but Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle aren't letting them off easy. The guys break down Anthony Volpe's bizarre night, sloppy defense, the bullpen's heroics, and how the Yankees managed to stay in the playoff race despite plenty of mistakes. Meanwhile, the Mets continue to fall down the New York sports priority list as Craig jokes they could be “relegated to the tablet” while the Yankees, Red Sox, and even Rays take over the spotlight.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle revisit one of the wildest moments from the show — the legendary “meat draft” and Craig's beef with PETA after buying an entire cow. Would you trade a cow for 1,500 pounds of vegetarian alternatives? Craig explains why he said absolutely not. The guys also debate the greatest cuts of steak, including the legendary spinalis/deckle, ribeye, skirt steak, and whether a tomahawk steak is overrated. Plus, Craig and Big Mac dive into sports rivalries, biblical trivia, prayer, and more hilarious conversations from The Carton Show on WFAN.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into one of the strangest NFL stories of the offseason, questioning why news of Shanahan's serious car accident stayed quiet for weeks. The guys debate whether reporters should protect sources, the ethics of breaking news, and whether a bigger story is still waiting to come out.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle get into a heated debate over the Giants' future, with Carton making the shocking case that Harbaugh may be one of the NFL's most overrated coaches. The guys break down Baltimore's late-game collapses, Lamar Jackson's playoff shortcomings, Brian Daboll's tenure, and what Giants fans should realistically expect in 2026.

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the New York Giants' path to the playoffs and the evolution of Jaxson Dart. They also react to Plaxico Burress's viral comparison between his time with the New York Jets and his prison sentence. Additionally, the conversation turns to a heated debate over Jets rookie David Bailey and local geography. 01:00 - Giants Playoff Potential 09:48 - Plaxico Burress Viral Comments 18:10 - Jets David Bailey Debate 23:23 - Long Island Geography Banter

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the controversy surrounding Kyle Shanahan's reported car accident and question why the story wasn't immediately reported. The guys debate whether public figures deserve privacy or if major incidents involving NFL coaches and stars are automatically newsworthy.

Evan Roberts and TikI Barber discuss if John Harbaugh has restored Giants pride. Plus, Gregg Giannotti and Boomer Esiason discuss the hope around the G-Men this year; Gio and Jerry Recco on if the Giants are capable of winning 10 games this season; Evan and Shaun Morash discuss Malik Nabers avoiding the PUP list; Craig Carton and Willie Colon on Cam Skatteboo.

Evan Roberts and TikI Barber discuss if John Harbaugh has restored Giants pride. Plus, Gregg Giannotti and Boomer Esiason discuss the hope around the G-Men this year; Gio and Jerry Recco on if the Giants are capable of winning 10 games this season; Evan and Shaun Morash discuss Malik Nabers avoiding the PUP list; Craig Carton and Willie Colon on Cam Skatteboo.

Evan Roberts and TikI Barber discuss if John Harbaugh has restored Giants pride. Plus, Gregg Giannotti and Boomer Esiason discuss the hope around the G-Men this year; Gio and Jerry Recco on if the Giants are capable of winning 10 games this season; Evan and Shaun Morash discuss Malik Nabers avoiding the PUP list; Craig Carton and Willie Colon on Cam Skatteboo.

Boomer Esiason has doubled down on his stance that the Mets need to trade Francisco Lindor, and wonders if the shortstop still wants to be in Queens. Plus, the Evan and Tiki crew relate to the SNY announcers, who can't seem to help themselves when it comes to criticizing the putrid Mets. Bobby Valentine joined Craig Carton to discuss what this team needs to do to get things turned around, and Evan explains why he would cheer for Edwin Diaz when he returns to Queens this weekend.

Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash agree that it is time for the Yankees to call up George Lombard Jr., and it should be done ASAP. Plus, Jim Leyritz joined The Carton Show and went off on the use of analytics and AI in baseball today, and why the Yanks should go get Rafael Devers. Evan and Tiki debate if it would be worth it for the Yankees to take on a bad Padres contract if it meant getting Mason Miller, and Craig Carton believes Jazz Chisholm is a misunderstood player who will be vital to the team's title chances.

Boomer Esiason has doubled down on his stance that the Mets need to trade Francisco Lindor, and wonders if the shortstop still wants to be in Queens. Plus, the Evan and Tiki crew relate to the SNY announcers, who can't seem to help themselves when it comes to criticizing the putrid Mets. Bobby Valentine joined Craig Carton to discuss what this team needs to do to get things turned around, and Evan explains why he would cheer for Edwin Diaz when he returns to Queens this weekend.

Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash agree that it is time for the Yankees to call up George Lombard Jr., and it should be done ASAP. Plus, Jim Leyritz joined The Carton Show and went off on the use of analytics and AI in baseball today, and why the Yanks should go get Rafael Devers. Evan and Tiki debate if it would be worth it for the Yankees to take on a bad Padres contract if it meant getting Mason Miller, and Craig Carton believes Jazz Chisholm is a misunderstood player who will be vital to the team's title chances.

Boomer Esiason has doubled down on his stance that the Mets need to trade Francisco Lindor, and wonders if the shortstop still wants to be in Queens. Plus, the Evan and Tiki crew relate to the SNY announcers, who can't seem to help themselves when it comes to criticizing the putrid Mets. Bobby Valentine joined Craig Carton to discuss what this team needs to do to get things turned around, and Evan explains why he would cheer for Edwin Diaz when he returns to Queens this weekend.

Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash agree that it is time for the Yankees to call up George Lombard Jr., and it should be done ASAP. Plus, Jim Leyritz joined The Carton Show and went off on the use of analytics and AI in baseball today, and why the Yanks should go get Rafael Devers. Evan and Tiki debate if it would be worth it for the Yankees to take on a bad Padres contract if it meant getting Mason Miller, and Craig Carton believes Jazz Chisholm is a misunderstood player who will be vital to the team's title chances.

The Wheel is back on The Carton Show, and this time Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are tackling everything from Philadelphia and LeBron James to diner food debates, chicken dishes, and the most random conversations you'll hear on WFAN. Craig also tells an unbelievable behind-the-scenes story about the time he played for the Washington Generals against the Harlem Globetrotters at Barclays Center — including a halftime locker room speech where the coach treated the game like Game 7 of the NBA Finals.

On The Carton Show with Chris McMonigle, Craig unloads on LeBron's decision to join the 76ers, arguing the Knicks remain the undisputed kings of the Eastern Conference. Carton claims New York turned LeBron away, calls Philadelphia "MSG South," predicts Sixers fans will eventually turn on him, and debates whether the Sixers are even a legitimate threat to the defending NBA Champion Knicks. Will LeBron and the Sixers create the NBA's next great rivalry, or is Philadelphia destined for another playoff disappointment?

The Knicks are the best team in the Eastern Conference but who is their biggest rival? Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle get into a heated debate over whether the Philadelphia 76ers or Indiana Pacers are the true Knicks rival. The guys break down the Sixers' chances with LeBron James rumors, Joel Embiid, Jaylen Brown, and why Philly still may not be on New York's level. Plus, Craig and Big Mac revisit classic Knicks rivalries involving the Sixers, Celtics, Pacers, and Heat.

The Yankees are approaching a massive trade deadline, and Chris McMonigle is ready for a change at shortstop. Craig Carton and Big Mac debate whether Anthony Volpe and Jon Berti/Caballero have done enough, if top prospect George Lombard Jr. could get the call, and how the Red Sox becoming buyers changes the AL race.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the proclamation of "LeBron Day" in Philadelphia, debating whether the aging superstar can handle the intensity of Northeast sports fans. They evaluate the 76ers' roster and playoff potential while ranking the greatest rivals of the New York Knicks. They also discuss Tony Romo's broadcasting future and the New York Yankees' strategy ahead of the trade deadline. 01:50 - LeBron Day in Philadelphia 07:00 - Sixers' Playoff Outlook 11:35 - Aging Superstars' Declines 18:40 - Naked Beach Stories 25:20 - Yankees Trade Rumors 35:50 - Tony Romo's Future 48:20 - Knicks Rivalry Rankings

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the Mets' struggling fan experience and ask whether Steve Cohen needs to do more to bring fans back to Citi Field. With the Mets struggling on the field, Craig argues the organization should lower ticket prices, parking costs, and concessions to show fans they understand their frustration. Would cheaper games, affordable food, and family-friendly pricing help get fans back in the stands?

Craig Carton sounds off on LeBron James and the NBA after the league delays releasing the 2026-27 schedule while waiting for LeBron's decision. Carton argues the defending NBA Champion New York Knicks deserve to be the center of attention—not a 43-year-old superstar deciding his next team.

With the MLB Trade Deadline just days away, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down exactly what the Yankees need to do to become legitimate World Series contenders. Is pitching already good enough? Should Brian Cashman focus on bats instead? The guys debate the Yankees' biggest needs, including catcher, shortstop, bullpen help, and whether George Lombard deserves a shot in the Bronx. They also discuss Aaron Judge's return, Giancarlo Stanton's status, Cody Bellinger's struggles, and why the Yankees can't rely on their pitching staff to carry a lifeless offense all October.

The Mets' disastrous 2026 season has reached a new low, and Craig Carton isn't holding back. Craig and Chris McMonigle break down why the Mets' decision to hold back second-half tickets completely backfired, how cheap Citi Field tickets have become, and why fans are walking away from their season tickets.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down everything happening in New York sports on the Carton Show. The Yankees are struggling at the plate, Aaron Judge's return remains uncertain, and Craig says Brian Cashman has to make major moves before the MLB Trade Deadline. Can the Yankees fix their offense in time?

Craig Carton drops a massive, hilarious bombshell on Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle during this segment of The Carton Show!

Things get fiery on this segment of The Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle tackle a highly controversial sports column, and drop a massive New York Giants teaser!

Craig Carton returns to the studio only to find out that Big Mac completely lost his mind while hosting the show!

Craig Carton and C-Mac tear into the New York Mets' ticket pricing strategies and the organization's disconnect from its fan base. They analyze current StubHub prices for future games and discuss Pete Alonso's anticipated return to Citi Field with the Baltimore Orioles. Additionally, the conversation shifts to media industry egos and Craig's review of the film, The Odyssey. 01:50 - Summer Sun And Shaving 07:48 - Media Egos And Retirements 17:10 - Mets Ticket Price Analysis 23:46 - Pete Alonso Return To Queens 31:12 - Carton Reviews The Odyssey 44:09 - LeBron James NBA Hostage 50:05 - Rant Against Station Management 58:08 - Parking And Concession Issues 01:02:48 - Carton New Weed Strain

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle argue that the NBA is delaying its season schedule release solely to accommodate LeBron James, leaving the New York Knicks and their fans in limbo. They also analyze the Yankees' rotation stability and potential trade deadline acquisitions while debating a controversial column concerning Caitlin Clark. Additionally, they share personal stories including a family dispute involving Aaron Rodgers and a high-stakes shaving bet. 02:15 - Football Season Anticipation 06:50 - NBA Schedule Delay 11:45 - LeBron Holding Hostage 16:10 - Mets Fan Therapy 20:50 - Partnership Drama Explained 27:10 - Yankees Rotation Analysis 31:50 - Trade Deadline Strategy 38:10 - Rodgers Family Feud 45:20 - Home Security Incident 30:00 - Shaving Bet Discussion 34:40 - Media Industry Shakeups 42:15 - WNBA Racial Discourse 50:15 - Controversial Column Analysis 01:03:30 - Marijuana Brand Concepts 21:20 - Bon Jovi History 34:20 - Caitlin Clark Debate 39:45 - Malik Nabors Status

It's a wild hour on The Carton Show! Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle rip into the Yankees' lifeless offense, question Cody Bellinger's disappointing season, debate John Harbaugh's viral Giants speech, and Craig drops a surprising rumor about the New York Jets potentially moving their practice facility back to New York. Plus, the guys take hilarious calls, react to ESPN's Ryan Clark situation, and go completely off the rails with classic Carton storytelling.

The Yankees' offense has become painful to watch, and Craig Carton isn't holding back. Craig and Chris McMonigle break down another frustrating loss, rip Cody Bellinger's struggles, discuss Giancarlo Stanton's possible return, and debate whether Brian Cashman can save the lineup before the trade deadline. They also react to John Harbaugh's first speech to the New York Giants and Craig absolutely unloads, calling it one of the most embarrassing coach speeches he's ever heard. Do Giants fans have reason to worry already?

Hear why Craig Carton believes that the Jets will win the AFC East before the Giants win the NFC East. Plus, Gio wonders about the Jets expectations after Geno Smith's latest legal headlines; Shaun Moras and Tiki Barber take calls from Jets fans and whether or not their offense can surprise, and ask if the Jets being bad in 2026 is really the worst thing?

Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash find reasons to get excited for Giants football, starting with the NFC being wide open this year. Plus, Tiki and Shaun on the Giants having a quarterback they can believe in; concerns around Malik Nabers' health; Craig Carton cautions Giants fans that John Harbaugh alone won't save the team; Craig and Chris McMonigle on the hype around Jaxson Dart this season.

Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash find reasons to get excited for Giants football, starting with the NFC being wide open this year. Plus, Tiki and Shaun on the Giants having a quarterback they can believe in; concerns around Malik Nabers' health; Craig Carton cautions Giants fans that John Harbaugh alone won't save the team; Craig and Chris McMonigle on the hype around Jaxson Dart this season.

Hear why Craig Carton believes that the Jets will win the AFC East before the Giants win the NFC East. Plus, Gio wonders about the Jets expectations after Geno Smith's latest legal headlines; Shaun Moras and Tiki Barber take calls from Jets fans and whether or not their offense can surprise, and ask if the Jets being bad in 2026 is really the worst thing?