Tiki and Tierney

This week's Jets highlights include Craig Carton calling Dante Moore's decision to stay in college a blessing for Gang Green, while Evan Roberts rips that opinion. Plus, Craig is dreaming for Mike Tomlin to be the coach in 2027, and Tommy Lugauer says these playoffs should be a wake-up call for the organization.

This week's Mets highlights include all the reactions to Kyle Tucker signing with the Dodgers, and what it could mean for the future of baseball. Plus, instant reactions to New York's pivot of signing Bo Bichette to a three-year deal.

The Giants and John Harbaugh are close to finalizing a deal to make him their new head coach and Boomer & Gio are ecstatic for the franchise. Plus, Boomer & Gio on the behind-the-scenes action on how the Giants wined and dined Harbaugh (17:51); Evan & Tiki on why Harbaugh is a franchise-altering moment (25:49); Craig Carton and C-Mac have differing reactions to Harbaugh (43:38); C-Mac and Craig on why this hire feels different (1:09:03); Evan and Tiki on what it says about the Giants that Harbaugh chose them (1:24:44).

The Mets quickly move on from missing out on Kyle Tucker to signing Bo Bichette. Was this the plan all along? No. Plus, what are the Yankees doing watching the perfect piece go to Queens? Craig shares newly discovered information regarding how the Mets handled their negotiations with Kyle Tucker. At the end of the day, Steve Cohen didn't drop the ball. Plus, Shohei Ohtani's cheat code of a contract is impossible to match. Craig add's more details to the Kyle Tucker signing with the Los Angeles Dodgers. Steve Cohen and the Mets did all they could. Speaking of New York Baseball teams, what have the Yankees been up to? It's 6pm on Friday night. The John Harbaugh news broke more than 36 hours ago that he was going to be the next head coach of the New York Giants. Why has a contract not been signed? Plus, C-Mac goes off on Yankees Hotstove.

The Mets quickly move on from missing out on Kyle Tucker to signing Bo Bichette. Was this the plan all along? No. Plus, what are the Yankees doing watching the perfect piece go to Queens?

Craig shares newly discovered information regarding how the Mets handled their negotiations with Kyle Tucker. At the end of the day, Steve Cohen didn't drop the ball. Plus, Shohei Ohtani's cheat code of a contract is impossible to match.

Craig add's more details to the Kyle Tucker signing with the Los Angeles Dodgers. Steve Cohen and the Mets did all they could. Speaking of New York Baseball teams, what have the Yankees been up to?

It's 6pm on Friday night. The John Harbaugh news broke more than 36 hours ago that he was going to be the next head coach of the New York Giants. Why has a contract not been signed? Plus, C-Mac goes off on Yankees Hotstove.

Craig Carton and Chris “C-Mac” McMonigle kick things off with food talk before diving into a spirited debate about the Dodgers' spending, whether buying championships still counts, and what truly defines a sports dynasty. The guys discuss why villains are good for sports, compare past MLB dynasties, and explain why everyone loves to hate dominant teams. As only the Carton Show can, the segment takes hilarious detours into Seattle fans, tridents, Lord of the Rings, Star Wars, Game of Thrones, and why Carton proudly avoids all of it.

Craig Carton and Chris “C-Mac” McMonigle break down a massive weekend of NFL playoff football, starting with the Giants officially landing John Harbaugh as head coach and what it means for Big Blue fans. The guys debate Sam Darnold's oblique injury and whether it's a real concern or a built-in excuse, analyze Seahawks vs 49ers, Rams vs Bears in brutal Chicago weather, Bills vs Broncos and the pressure on Josh Allen, plus Texans vs Patriots.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dig into the Beef Bar incident sparking a #BanBeefBar movement, calling out the restaurant's pretentious behavior and fallout with fans. They then break down the Mets' Kyle Tucker offer compared to the Dodgers, revealing the Mets actually offered more upfront cash despite losing the bid. The guys debate the Yankees' stubborn loyalty to Anthony Volpe at shortstop, discussing whether it's time for a change and the challenge of balancing conviction with results. Plus, fan calls and a humorous history detour round out the lively show.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle tackle the growing controversy over the Dodgers' massive spending spree and its impact on baseball's competitive balance. They discuss the push for a hard salary cap and spending floor, the Dodgers' advantage using deferred money, and why more fans than ever support salary caps in MLB.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the UFC on Paramount debut featuring Sean O'Malley vs. Song Yadong, with plenty of laughs along the way. They break down Shohei Ohtani's unique deferred contract and how the Dodgers are profiting from the investment.

Craig Carton and Chris “C-Mac” McMonigle dive deep into the real details behind the Mets' pursuit of Kyle Tucker and explain why Steve Cohen didn't actually get outbid by the Dodgers. The guys reveal the contract structure, opt-outs, signing bonuses, and deferred money that shaped Tucker's decision.

Craig Carton and Chris “C-Mac” McMonigle break down the stunning news of Kyle Tucker choosing the Dodgers over the Mets and what it means for Steve Cohen and the Mets' offseason strategy. The guys debate whether the Mets should have matched the Dodgers' massive offer, discuss payroll philosophy, luxury tax penalties, and why Bo Bichette's signing helps soften the blow—while also hurting the Phillies.

A wild opening segment on The Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the most chaotic 24 hours of the MLB offseason. The Mets thought they had Kyle Tucker locked up before the Dodgers swooped in during the dead of night, sparking outrage across New York. Craig unloads on Mets and Yankees fans for whining about money, calls the Dodgers the new Evil Empire, and debates whether the Mets truly “panicked” or smartly pivoted to Bo Bichette. Plus, why Bichette was a better fit for the Yankees, why Yankee fans should actually be angrier than Mets fans, and a fiery argument over whether the Dodgers have an unfair advantage or are just smarter than everyone else.

Giants fans are excited that they have their head coach, but who else do they have? One person who hasn't gotten much credit for securing John Harbaugh is GM Joe Schoen, but he sure as heck deserves it! In what was now more than 4 years ago, C-Mac is still a little salty over Craigs Meat Draft which left C-Mac meatless. Plus, more on John Harbaugh and the waiting game on Kyle Tucker. The Giants still have a lot of moves to make to get to a serious championship level contender. Plus, can this be all she wrote for Mike Tomlin as a coaching career? Giants fans are excited that they have their head coach, but who else do they have? One person who hasn't gotten much credit for securing John Harbaugh is GM Joe Schoen, but he sure as heck deserves it!

Giants fans are excited that they have their head coach, but who else do they have? One person who hasn't gotten much credit for securing John Harbaugh is GM Joe Schoen, but he sure as heck deserves it!

The Giants still have a lot of moves to make to get to a serious championship level contender. Plus, can this be all she wrote for Mike Tomlin as a coaching career?

In what was now more than 4 years ago, C-Mac is still a little salty over Craigs Meat Draft which left C-Mac meatless. Plus, more on John Harbaugh and the waiting game on Kyle Tucker.

The Longer it goes on, the less likely that Kyle Tucker comes to Queens. Craig does give us some more info that could lead you to believe Flushing could still happen.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into a wild stretch of caller-driven chaos on The Carton Show, starting with the return of a legendary Jets fan — now a “hot grandma” — and an unforgettable conversation about family nicknames that quickly spirals into classic Carton absurdity. The guys then pivot to Mets talk as callers debate whether keeping Carlos Mendoza while reshaping the roster makes sense, and whether Kyle Tucker would truly move the needle for the Mets. As the clock ticks toward Carton's self-imposed signing deadline, the show keeps one eye on breaking news while also touching on Yankees pivot options and reminding Jets fans they once had their own moment of hope with Aaron Rodgers.

In this lively segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle reminisce about legendary broadcasters Jack Buck and Hank Stram, share behind-the-scenes stories about Howard Cosell and the announcement of John Lennon's death, then dive deep into the ongoing Mets-Kyle Tucker contract saga. Plus, listener calls covering the Giants draft pick, Knicks trade rumors, and more.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle continue reacting to the Giants landing John Harbaugh, addressing lingering paranoia over the contract not being signed yet and why Giants fans finally feel stability again. The conversation shifts into a spirited NFC East quarterback debate, with Dak Prescott's legacy taking center stage — is he a Hall of Famer, a stat padder, or somewhere in between? The guys compare Dak to Eli Manning, break down what really matters for Canton, and debate whether winning trumps elite numbers. Things go fully off the rails with a fiery Mets fan caller blasting David Stearns, skepticism over Harbaugh's résumé, and a legendary Carton rabbit hole involving a supposed NFL stadium named after a frozen dumpling company.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open the segment with peak Carton Show chaos, breaking down Craig's beef jerky obsession and uncovering a shocking revelation from the infamous WFAN meat draft — Big Mac may have been robbed of his tomahawk steaks. Accusations fly, Evan Roberts becomes a prime suspect, and justice for the stolen meat is finally addressed. From there, the show pivots to serious Giants talk as callers weigh in on the John Harbaugh hire, expectations for next season, and whether Big Blue truly belongs on the field with playoff teams.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle deliver a classic, all-over-the-map Carton Show segment as Giants fans continue celebrating the hiring of John Harbaugh. The guys debate what the hire really means for the fan base versus ownership, break down why this doesn't erase a decade of Giants misery, and take fired-up calls from Giants and Jets fans alike. Plus, a hilarious and heated argument erupts over Tom Brady vs Aaron Rodgers, greatest players in sports history, fork fisting etiquette, sausage rankings, and some wildly relatable stories from listeners. The segment also takes a serious turn with breaking news on the largest college basketball gambling scandal in U.S. history, including alleged point-shaving tied to Fordham and a St. John's game.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle continue the Giants celebration following the hiring of John Harbaugh, with Giants fans calling it the best feeling since the Super Bowl. The guys break down why this hire feels different than past regimes, compare it to the Brian Daboll era, and debate whether Jaxson Dart inspires more confidence than any Giants quarterback in recent memory.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Giants officially landing John Harbaugh, a move that instantly energizes Big Blue and saves a bleak New York sports winter. Craig celebrates the hire but pumps the brakes on over-the-top optimism, while Big Mac takes a victory lap and gives major credit to Joe Schoen for orchestrating the deal after months of criticism. The guys debate whether Giants fans almost got this wrong by wanting Shane fired, argue about John Mara's legacy as an owner, and take calls from fired-up listeners. Plus, a hilarious and revealing “game of honesty” breaks out as Big Mac is asked if he'd trade Jaxson Dart for just about every quarterback in the NFL with some shocking answers.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open the show reacting to the Giants officially landing John Harbaugh as head coach, calling it the biggest and best move the franchise has made in over a decade. Craig gives credit where it's due — the Giants got their dream coach and instantly stabilized the organization — but quickly pumps the brakes, arguing Big Blue still has the worst quarterback and wide receiver group in the NFC East. Big Mac fires back with optimism, playoff dreams, and belief in Jaxson Dart, while Craig plays the role of honest reality check.

John Harbaugh can't leave Metlife; Breaking News: Ranger Suarez signs with the Red Sox and Dante Moore stays in school. With Dante Moore sticking in Oregon, what does that mean for the New York Jets number two draft pick. Does Ty Simpson make a leap? Plus, Carton breaks down the ridiculous award shows, and a caller gives the Carton Show a new name. SNY's Connor Hughes joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle to give the latest on the John Harbaugh meeting. Plus, Connor breaks the news that Jaxson Dart has met with John Harbaugh. It's Wednesday... which means it's time for another episode of "What the F*** Wednesday". Also word breaks that the Giants are wrapping up their interview with John Harbaugh and that he is indeed.... leaving the building.

John Harbaugh can't leave Metlife; Breaking News: Ranger Suarez signs with the Red Sox and Dante Moore stays in school.

With Dante Moore sticking in Oregon, what does that mean for the New York Jets number two draft pick. Does Ty Simpson make a leap? Plus, Carton breaks down the ridiculous award shows, and a caller gives the Carton Show a new name.

SNY's Connor Hughes joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle to give the latest on the John Harbaugh meeting. Plus, Connor breaks the news that Jaxson Dart has met with John Harbaugh.

It's Wednesday... which means it's time for another episode of "What the F*** Wednesday". Also word breaks that the Giants are wrapping up their interview with John Harbaugh and that he is indeed.... leaving the building.

On today's Carton Show, Big Mac and Craig Carton break down exclusive details from insider Connor Hughes about the Giants' head coaching search. Hear why Jaxson Dart's involvement in meeting John Harbaugh and other candidates is a smart move for the franchise's future. Plus, get the latest on Harbaugh's interview timeline, his upcoming visit with the Titans, and what it means for the Giants. They also dive into Aaron Rodgers' Jets tenure, the Mets' pitching rotation, and caller takes on Harbaugh's decision-making

On this WTF Wednesday edition of the Carton Show with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle, the hosts dive into hot New York sports topics. They break down the ongoing Kyle Tucker contract saga with the Mets and what his passion (or lack thereof) for baseball means for a potential deal. Plus, insider calls reveal the latest on John Harbaugh and the New York Giants coaching search. The show also confirms Aaron Glenn's return as Jets head coach and tackles the controversial Rooney Rule debates and media dynamics in the NFL.

On this segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle sit down with NFL insider Connor Hughes to discuss the New York Giants' intense pursuit of John Harbaugh as their next head coach. Connor shares exclusive updates on Harbaugh's potential visit to the Falcons, the Giants' impressive coaching offer, and how the franchise legends like Steve Tisch, Chris Mara, and Eli Manning are involved in the push. Plus, a deep dive into the Jets' quarterback situation following Dante Moore's return to Oregon and what it means for the Jets' draft strategy

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle bring classic Carton Show chaos as Giants coaching buzz heats up and the guys debate how fans should celebrate a potential John Harbaugh hire — including a ridiculous barbecue sauce bath bet. The conversation rolls into what the Giants really need to become relevant again, why simply “normal” winning football would be a victory, and how New York sports expectations have shifted. Plus, hilarious tangents on audiobooks vs. reading, fork etiquette, getting weighed at the doctor, burrito loyalty, Jets quarterback ideas, and a surprise call from Willie Colon.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down a jam-packed segment that starts with a major correction and a big college football storyline as Ty Simpson officially declares for the NFL Draft, reshaping the Jets' options with the No. 2 overall pick. The guys debate whether the Jets must leave the draft with a quarterback at all costs, trade scenarios, and how NIL money is changing the decision-making process for top prospects. The conversation shifts into a deeper look at New York sports as a whole, sparked by a powerful caller and the question of whether New York has become a “toxic” destination for athletes. Craig and C-Mac push back hard, arguing it's not toxicity — it's years of bad management, missed drafts, and brutal football failures by the Jets and Giants. Plus, Yankees heartbreak, Mets frustration, and why this might be the worst multi-sport stretch in NYC history. A thoughtful, emotional, and classic WFAN back-and-forth.

Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle are interrupted by breaking news that Oregon QB Dante Moore has decided to stay in school another year. Craig Carton discusses why this may be a great thing for the Jets & their fans.

As the fellas discuss the Yankees big trade for Ryan Weathers, news breaks that Ranger Suarez is headed to Boston and why it puts pressure on the Mets & David Stearns.

The Carton Show kicks off with Craig and Big Mac diving deep into the Giants fans psyche and figuring out if they are starting to get anxious as the John Harbaugh saga continues.