Tiki and Tierney

That's right, Sam Darnold and Drake Maye are proof that you can have a bad quarterback and still win a Super Bowl. Jets and Giants fans, you should have plenty of hope next year! Chipper Jones knows how to troll back on social media. Plus, how does Craig know what bad oysters smell like at Hooters? Guess what doesn't make sense, Shedeur Sanders playing in a pro-bowl in his rookie year. Justin Fields had better numbers than Sanders as well as Trevor Lawrence among pretty much most of the QB's in the NFL. Plus, Mike McCarthy breaks down about taking a job with the Steelers. That's right, out of nowhere word comes down that Bill Belichick is not a good enough head coach to make the hall of fame on his first ballet.

That's right, Sam Darnold and Drake Maye are proof that you can have a bad quarterback and still win a Super Bowl. Jets and Giants fans, you should have plenty of hope next year!

Chipper Jones knows how to troll back on social media. Plus, how does Craig know what bad oysters smell like at Hooters?

Guess what doesn't make sense, Shedeur Sanders playing in a pro-bowl in his rookie year. Justin Fields had better numbers than Sanders as well as Trevor Lawrence among pretty much most of the QB's in the NFL. Plus, Mike McCarthy breaks down about taking a job with the Steelers.

That's right, out of nowhere word comes down that Bill Belichick is not a good enough head coach to make the hall of fame on his first ballet.

Pure Carton Show chaos on WFAN as Craig Carton takes on fiery callers, debates whether this is the Knicks' “no excuses” year, dives back into Jets coaching turmoil with Aaron Glenn, and delivers a wildly off-the-rails discussion that only Carton could pull off. From Giannis trade talk and NBA pressure comparisons to Josh Allen, to NIL insanity, college football chaos, golf legends, and laugh-out-loud analogies, this segment has everything—sports, controversy, and classic Carton unfiltered humor.

Craig Carton and Big Mac dive deep into the New York Knicks trade deadline drama, debating whether the Knicks should move Karl-Anthony Towns in a blockbuster deal for Giannis Antetokounmpo. Carton lays out realistic trade scenarios, discusses why KAT's contract is hard to move, analyzes roster chemistry, playoff identity, draft pick limitations, and explains why Giannis could instantly change everything in New York.

Another unpredictable Carton Show segment on WFAN as Craig Carton and Big Mac bounce from NFL chaos to New York sports frustration with classic Carton energy. From league decisions that make no sense, to Jets dysfunction, coaching talk, caller debates, and laugh-out-loud radio moments, this segment is pure WFAN madness.

Craig Carton goes off on the Pro Bowl process after a shocking quarterback selection, calling it a total embarrassment to the NFL. Carton and Big Mac break down eye-opening stats, debate reputation vs reality, question league credibility, dive into Browns coaching chaos, Kevin Stefanski criticism, Baker Mayfield grudges, and somehow end up arguing about how many beers are in a case.

Craig Carton stuns Big Mac by admitting he once turned down the chance to hang out with rock legend Robert Plant after a Led Zeppelin concert in Atlantic City and now deeply regrets it. The segment spirals into classic Carton Show chaos with outrageous World Cup ticket prices, flipping Super Bowl–level seats for massive profit, NASCAR pit dreams, a humiliating dirt track racing story, Mets vs Jets coaching debates, and nonstop WFAN laughs.

Craig Carton reacts to what he calls the “Tweet of the Year” after Hall of Famer Chipper Jones absolutely annihilates a troll on Twitter with a savage, unforgettable response. From Mets fans admitting reluctant respect, to ridiculous hypotheticals, legendary Jim McMahon stories, Ric Flair chaos, and a heated debate on John Harbaugh vs Aaron Boone, this Carton Show segment spirals into peak WFAN madness.

A wild Carton Show segment on WFAN starts with Craig Carton reacting to shocking Super Bowl ticket prices and quickly spirals into a fiery, must-hear debate about the New York Jets. Craig and Big Mac clash over Aaron Glenn firing his coaching staff, offensive and defensive coordinator drama, leadership, dysfunction, and whether the Jets finally taking accountability is a step forward or just more chaos.

Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle kick off this edition of "The Carton Show" with a heated debate over the future of New York Football. Giants & Jets could be the next Patriots? Who actually has a bright future if either? Also the guys get into it when discussing John Harbaugh's motivations for coming to Big Blue.

WFAN hosts are erupting over former Jets quarterback Sam Darnold reaching the Super Bowl, sparking a heated debate on whether his success serves as the ultimate proof of the Jets' organizational failure

Football is made for snow. If you don't believe that, than you're not a true football fan. Plus, everyone says the Jets screwed up with Sam Darnold, well guess what? The Giants screwed up as much as the Jets! If you didn't watch Alex Honnold climb a building live you can't watch now, plus, the coaching was extremely poor this weekend in the NFC and AFC championship games. That's right, the Giants want to hear from you! Plus, Drake Maye isn't really that good and it's time that we all get that through our thick skulls. We're about to do something no one has ever done before; Walk on the moon. Plus, Knicks show off this weekend against Philly!

Football is made for snow. If you don't believe that, than you're not a true football fan. Plus, everyone says the Jets screwed up with Sam Darnold, well guess what? The Giants screwed up as much as the Jets!

If you didn't watch Alex Honnold climb a building live you can't watch now, plus, the coaching was extremely poor this weekend in the NFC and AFC championship games.

That's right, the Giants want to hear from you! Plus, Drake Maye isn't really that good and it's time that we all get that through our thick skulls.

We're about to do something no one has ever done before; Walk on the moon. Plus, Knicks show off this weekend against Philly!

Jets fans are living in sports hell. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the absolute nightmare Super Bowl matchup nobody in New York wanted: Sam Darnold back on the biggest stage AND the Patriots sniffing another title.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down what went wrong for Sean McVay and the Rams in a brutal playoff loss. From clock mismanagement and refusing to go for two, to defensive breakdowns, taunting penalties, and confusing replay decisions, Carton questions whether McVay keeps coming up small in the postseason.

Craig Carton completely unloads on the Empire State Building lighting up in New England Patriots colors calling it UNACCEPTABLE for New York City. The rant spirals into Eagles hate, NFL hypocrisy, Jets tanking dreams, Giants coaching news, and an all-time Carton story about Frank Reich's unbelievable quarterback evaluation method.

Absolute chaos on The Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a bizarre New York Giants fan survey that turns into a sponsorship “scam.” From roasting the idea of winning a Jaxson Dart autograph to debating John Harbaugh's coaching tree, the segment spirals into wild WFAN callers, bowling shoe theft advice, tanking ideas gone wrong, and Carton calling out uninspired Giants hires.

Craig Carton delivers an all-time Carton Show rant as he declares Geno Smith the most powerful player in the NFL and somehow proves it. From Super Bowl appearances to the No. 1 overall pick, Carton breaks down Geno's “power” while Chris McMonigle pushes back. The debate spirals into snow football, domes, George Washington getting absolutely cooked, Netflix stunt climbers, and one of the wildest segments you'll hear on WFAN.

The Carton Show turns into absolute mayhem as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate snow football, Jets failures, Giants draft disasters, and the Sam Darnold controversy. Callers light up the phone lines arguing Lambeau weather, Jets incompetence, the Rooney Rule, and whether the Jets or Giants should be MORE embarrassed by Sam Darnold playing in the Super Bowl.

Craig Carton puts Chris McMonigle on trial and SLAMS the case shut using Giants history. From the 2008 NFC Championship Game in frozen Lambeau to today's snow-filled playoff chaos, Carton argues football is MEANT for the elements. Big Mac pushes back, calling the game unwatchable and Craig isn't having it.

Craig Carton comes out FIRING on The Carton Show as he unloads on the New England Patriots' “gift-wrapped” road to the Super Bowl. From Sam Darnold debates to Sean Payton's coaching blunders, Carton and Chris McMonigle clash over bad football, bad offenses, and fans crying about snow games. Plus, Craig says there's BLOOM OFF the Bill Belichick rose and predicts a shocking coaching return.

Evan & Tiki talk about rooting for Sam Darnold and how things could have panned out differently in New York for him. Plus, Evan wonders what would have happened if the Jets drafted Josh Allen instead (18:41); Craig on the possibility of Lamar Jackson on the Jets (39:53), and a caller asks Craig if he has inside info on defensive coordinators who refused to interview with the Jets (46:54).

This week's Yankees highlights are all about Cody Bellinger, as the Yanks finally signed their top offseason target. Evan and Tiki give their instant reactions, while Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the contract and debate if Bellinger was worth the price.

The Mets have completely turned their offseason around with a busy week. Boomer and Gio react to the blockbuster Freddy Peralta trade and how fans have changed their tone on David Stearns, while Craig Carton rips any fans who still don't like the offseason. Plus, Evan Roberts reveals his concerns about the deal, and reacts to the Luis Robert Jr. trade.

Boomer & Gio give their first impressions of John Harbaugh following his introductory press conference. Plus, Craig Carton and C-Mac debate if the Harbaugh excitement is overblown (14:50); Evan & Tiki interview Harbaugh (36:47), and ponder if Rex Ryan could join his staff (54:41); Boomer & Gio also discuss potential coordinators and coaching staff (1:19:09).

Phillip Rivers the next head coach of the Bills? And is getting an interview? What is going on in Buffalo? Also, with the biggest snowstorm of all time coming, what activities can we do during the snow storm? John Harbaugh puts a nice touch on his first week on the job. A special email was sent to all Giants season ticket holders. Also, would a surcharge prevent you from gambling? Mark Schlereth has a thing or two on Jarrett Stidham and the Denver Broncos this weekend. Plus, A 4 year old girl is getting death threats for making innocent NFL picks. That's right, if you live in New York City the Mayor has already said be prepared for school one way or another. Plus, C-Mac gives his Championship NFL Weekend picks.

Phillip Rivers the next head coach of the Bills? And is getting an interview? What is going on in Buffalo? Also, with the biggest snowstorm of all time coming, what activities can we do during the snow storm?

John Harbaugh puts a nice touch on his first week on the job. A special email was sent to all Giants season ticket holders. Also, would a surcharge prevent you from gambling?

Mark Schlereth has a thing or two on Jarrett Stidham and the Denver Broncos this weekend. Plus, A 4 year old girl is getting death threats for making innocent NFL picks.

That's right, if you live in New York City the Mayor has already said be prepared for school one way or another. Plus, C-Mac gives his Championship NFL Weekend picks.

On this January 23, 2026 segment of The Carton Show on WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss the massive snowstorm heading to New York City, including snowfall predictions and travel woes. They dive into the challenges of commuting during snow, school closures, and nostalgic memories of snow days. Later, they talk MLB's potential expansion and divisional realignment, debating how it could affect Yankees-Mets rivalries.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a disturbing story of a 4-year-old girl receiving death threats over her NFL playoff picks, sparking a larger discussion on what's wrong with sports fandom today. The conversation rolls into Mets “all-in” trade talk, MLB owner spending issues, Giants offseason frustrations, Jets misery, NFL MVP debate, and classic Carton Show humor.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the shocking news that Philip Rivers interviewed to become the Buffalo Bills head coach — and Carton loves the idea. The guys tear into AFC East ownership, explain why Terry Pegula is a problem in Buffalo, why Jets fans shouldn't fear the Dolphins or Bills, and why the Patriots' run is being massively overrated. Plus, Carton debates whether quarterbacks make the best head coaches, calls the Patriots “paper tigers,” previews Patriots vs Broncos with Jarrett Stidham, and welcomes Mark Schlereth for an all-time interview filled with football insight and classic WFAN insanity.

Only Craig Carton can turn a discussion about gambling taxes into a full-blown WFAN rollercoaster. From Israel qualifying for bobsledding, UFC bets, and why a 50-cent gambling surcharge cost Illinois millions, to snow blowers, plow guys, neighborhood privilege, viral Sydney Sweeney jokes, and an insane childhood soccer brawl straight out of West Side Story. This segment is pure Carton chaos you won't hear anywhere else.

From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for Championship weekend in the NFL. Should Ben Johnson have went for 2? Boomer feels bad for Bo Nix and Josh Allen. Mcdermott's exit from Buffalo. Catch or interception in Broncos Bills game? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Only on WFAN: Craig Carton goes full conspiracy mode questioning the moon landing and Helen Keller, then immediately pivots to praising John Harbaugh's emotional letter to Giants season ticket holders. From wild theories to genuine Giants optimism, Carton and Big Mac break down why this letter might actually win fans back—and why the Jets could never pull it off.