Tiki and Tierney

BT & Sal dive into a heated discussion on the New York Jets, with BT's renewed faith in the team's "unkillable" foundation and coach Aaron Glenn leading to a debate on whether Tyrod Taylor is helping develop young talent like Mitchell (00:04:50) despite the losing season. Callers weigh in with fiery takes on the Mets' offseason, urging Steve Cohen to trade for Skubal and move on from Diaz (00:17:52). The main event is the NFL Power Rankings for Week 14, where both hosts exclude traditional powers like the Bills, Ravens, and Eagles (00:36:31). Number 1: Both agree on the dominant New England Patriots (00:42:50). Number 2: Both choose the Los Angeles Rams (00:42:19). Contention: Sal shocks with the Bears at #5 (00:37:24) and Seahawks at #3 (00:41:29), while BT defends the Packers at #5 (00:36:31), 49ers at #4 (00:38:12), and the Broncos at #3 (00:39:17). They also discuss the tenure clock ticking for the Jets' front office (00:30:32).

BT & Sal dive into the most chaotic power ranking week of the season, fueled by the NFL's "up and down" parity. They agree on one undisputed leader: the New England Patriots ($11-2$ with 10 straight wins) and their impressive quarterback, Drake Maye.The rest of their lists ignite a debate, particularly over the surging Denver Broncos (Sal begrudgingly puts them at #4, BT at #3) and the surprise Chicago Bears (Sal at #5), who BT dismisses as winning with "smoke and mirrors."The discussion covers the Seahawks, the Rams' inexplicable loss to the Panthers, and why perennial contenders like the Bills and Ravens have fallen off both hosts' radar. The consensus: the NFL is unpredictable, making the search for the five best teams harder than ever.

From 'Kickoff with Boomer & Valenti' (subscribe here): Kickoff with Boomer Esiason and Mike Valenti for week 14 in the NFL. The boys go over what happened in week 13. They pick every game against the spread and Boomer hands out his awards for the season. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

BT & Sal kick off a fiery segment by discussing the death of office etiquette after Sal left three boxes of vintage baseball cards (including an '88 Score Mattingly!) in a community area, only for them to vanish without a trace in under two hours. Tierney confesses he, too, swiped a few packs "just in case Santa forgets" but was shocked to find the entire haul—and even the boxes—gone on his return. The hosts rail against the "every man for himself" mentality that dominates the station's communal space. The discussion pivots to the MLB free-agent market, where Sal details Marc Feinsand's top starting pitcher rankings, including Ranger Suarez, Framber Valdez, and Michael King—all of whom the Mets and Yankees are pursuing. Sal expresses frustration over the Mets missing out on Max Fried last year, arguing that he was a better and more proven "true ace" than the high-priced, potential-based pitchers available now. Tierney highlights the defensive concerns, noting Valdez's extreme ground-ball rate and the Mets' shaky infield defense (especially at 3B/1B).

BT & Sal go off on the Detroit Tigers' hesitation to trade ace left-hander Tarik Skubal, arguing the team would be "idiots" to risk losing him for nothing when his value is at its absolute peak right now in the offseason. Tierney emphasizes that Detroit is in no position to pay the $400 million Skubal is expected to command in free agency, making a trade the only smart move. The hosts argue that Skubal is the "biggest difference maker" available and should be the Mets' absolute focus, even if it means giving up a massive package. Sal says Skubal is "ten times better" than Framber Valdez, urging the Mets not to get distracted by other lower-tier pitching targets.

BT & Sal dive into a deep-cut sports debate, first reacting to the Lions' dominant win over the Cowboys. The conversation quickly shifts to the New York baseball offseason, where Sal predicts the Mets will have a "better" and more active winter than the Yankees, particularly in "crushing the rotation." They discuss the "Giants Effect," arguing that the Mets' unexpected success in 2024 "complicated" David Stearns' job, forcing him to keep a core that should have been dismantled earlier. They analyze the Yankees' internal problems, noting the lack of improvement if Volpe can't put in work due to his shoulder injury and if the lineup relies on Stanton and Grisham. They challenge Mets fans' pessimism, demanding the team lands two top pitchers (Skubal/Suarez or Peralta/Valdes) and explore Tatis Jr. as a dynamic replacement option if Pete Alonso bolts. The segment closes with a note that Giannis will dominate Knicks coverage for the next two months.

BT & Sal ignite a debate over Mets President David Stearns' disciplined, non-budging stance on a three-year contract for Pete Alonso. Sal believes Alonso is "100% gone" for at least four years elsewhere, but Tierney respects Stearns' hard line—if he wins! The pressure is immense: if Stearns lets fan-favorite Alonso walk and the team loses, he's a "dead man." The discussion heats up over the possibility of the Mets pursuing Kyle Schwarber, with the hosts agreeing that if Stearns gives Schwarber (who is two years older) more years or money than Alonso, it would be a "dirty" move and a massive blunder. Callers chime in, suggesting front-loaded deals, while the hosts ultimately acknowledge that Stearns must be allowed to build the team his way, or else the model breaks. The excitement builds imagining a Lindor-Schwarber-Soto three-man tandem.

BT & Sal ignite a heated debate over the Mets' struggling outfield, dismissing Cody Bellinger as an unlikely option given his Yankee ties, but acknowledging his flexibility is appealing. The conversation quickly shifts to the current center field options, with Sal calling a potential Harrison Bader signing a waste of time and Byron Buxton an injury-prone gamble. The crux of the segment focuses on the future of Pete Alonso: if the Mets let him walk, they "must sign Kyle Schwarber." Sal passionately argues that Schwarber's superior plate discipline (despite the high strikeouts) and unhinged "caveman" energy make him a better power-bat acquisition than retaining Alonso. They compare the two sluggers' OPS and debate the risk of Schwarber's two-hundred-strikeout season in the postseason.

BT & Sal dive into the hot rumor connecting the Mets to free agent Kyle Schwarber, immediately questioning whether the power-hitting DH is a replacement for Pete Alonso or an addition. Sal loves the idea of adding Schwarber's prodigious power while weakening the Phillies, but BT argues it makes little sense for a team emphasizing defense and versatility under David Stearns, given Schwarber's lack of position and high strikeout rate. The conversation pivots to the "hardball" the Mets are playing with Alonso, with sources indicating the team is holding firm at a three-year offer, far below what Pete and Boras are seeking. They debate whether moving on from Alonso to pursue Schwarber—and finally breaking up the core—is a smart business decision, even if it sacrifices a fan favorite. They agree the Mets have options, including a Bellinger-Pete combo, and must prioritize pitching, but the Alonso-Schwarber ultimatum is the most fascinating offensive negotiation.

BT & Sal ignite a New York sports firestorm starting with the Giannis Antetokounmpo trade rumors, passionately arguing that Jalen Brunson is "untouchable" and debating which key player (OG Anunoby or Mikal Bridges) must be sacrificed for the Greek Freak. Sal insists the trade is pointless if the Knicks retain Karl-Anthony Towns' contract. The heat moves to the Giants, where the hosts slam the decision to keep Joe Schoen as GM, calling him a "lame duck" who will only worsen the upcoming head coach search. They then pivot to the Yankees' confusingly "lukewarm" offseason, questioning if the Bronze Bombers are serious about winning while pursuing Cody Bellinger and other Japanese stars like Kaz Okamoto and Tatsuya Imai. The segment also features NFL Week 14 "best bets" with Nick Kostos on the Chiefs' "DEFCON ONE" status, a spicy Hall of Fame debate over the eligibility of A-Rod and Manny Ramirez, and the shock of the Diddy documentary footage. The show closes with a desperate "Call from Down Under" lamenting the Mets' "slop" pitching.

BT & Sal dive into the Giannis Antetokounmpo trade rumors, which are heating up with reports that the superstar wants the Knicks. The fiery debate centers on the New York Knicks' strategy: Giannis In, Karl-Anthony Towns Out. Sal argues that keeping the overpaid and defensively exploitable KAT makes the trade pointless, even with Giannis. They discuss the likelihood of OG Anunoby and Mikal Bridges being the necessary price, and whether a Brunson-Giannis-Towns trio could ever work. Later, the conversation pivots to the New York Giants' front office turmoil, where Sal and BT react to a report from Ian O'Connor asserting that the organization made a "bad situation worse" by retaining General Manager Joe Schoen, who is now reportedly "leading the way" for the next head coach search. The hosts argue that Schoen must be removed to facilitate a clean break.

BT & Sal ignite on the Yankees' confusing "Hot Stove" reports, questioning why the Bronze Bombers aren't a threat to sign every top free agent like Edwin Diaz, though they agree with the team's pursuit of Cody Bellinger. They debate if the team is prioritizing winning and if the front office is playing possum. The conversation then pivots to the Knicks, where the hosts vehemently disagree with trading Jalen Brunson for Giannis Antetokounmpo, but analyze the difficult decision the Knicks face regarding which other key player—OG Anunoby or Mikal Bridges—would have to be moved for a blockbuster trade. Finally, Nick Kostos jumps on to share his "best bets" for NFL Week 14, calling the Lions/Cowboys game a must-win for Dallas and declaring the Chiefs are at "DEFCON ONE" ahead of their dangerous matchup against the surging Texans. They also touch on the Jaguars' trajectory and the surprising NFC North race between the Packers and Bears.

BT & Sal dive into the fallout of Giannis Antetokounmpo's calf strain, debating the conspiracy theories about whether the two-to-four-week injury is a power play to force a trade to the Knicks. Sal argues that Jalen Brunson is "untouchable" and that acquiring Giannis now is necessary to maximize the Knicks' championship window. The discussion pivots to the MLB Hot Stove as they examine the odds for several Japanese stars heading to New York. They break down the pursuit of infielder Kaz Okamoto (Yankees favored) and the intriguing pitcher Tatsuya Imai, who declared he wants to "beat the Dodgers." The hosts also weigh the cost of Japanese pitchers, discussing the impact of extra rest days on a team's rotation. The consensus: the Knicks must strike now for a championship, whether with Giannis or another star, as the window is wide open.

BT & Sal dive into the buzz surrounding the Diddy documentary, highlighting the "unreal" vintage footage and the early rise of the hip-hop mogul. The conversation shifts to a fiery debate over the 2026 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot, triggered by a voter who submitted a ballot with only David Wright's name. Sal and BT dissect their differing picks, agreeing on Carlos Beltran and Felix Hernandez, but clashing over Andy Pettitte and closers like K-Rod. They also tackle the elephant in the room: whether A-Rod and Manny Ramirez should be let in despite their PED use. In football, they debate whether the Giants should gamble on the past glory of Bill Belichick or the program stability of Mike McCarthy, acknowledging the "purgatory" status of the Yankees. The show concludes with a special "Call from Down Under" from a loyal Mets fan in Australia seeking solutions for the Mets' dire pitching situation, which Sal labels "slop."

BT and Sal dive headfirst into the controversial 2026 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot, which they deem "light." The discussion kicks off with a viral single-vote ballot for David Wright, prompting a fiery debate on the Mets Captain's true Hall credentials versus his "Hall of Fame person" status. The hosts break down their respective five- and four-man ballots, agreeing on Carlos Beltrán (despite the sign-stealing controversy) and "King" Félix Hernández (dominance over longevity). Sal makes a passionate case for Andruw Jones (ten Gold Gloves) and Andy Pettitte (postseason legacy), while BT argues for Francisco "K-Rod" Rodríguez based purely on his historic peak and questions why all the steroid-era greats like A-Rod and Manny Ramírez shouldn't just be inducted together.

BT & Sal dive into the breaking news that Giannis Antetokounmpo is officially out for two to four weeks with a right calf strain. Tierney expresses suspicion, questioning if the fall was "overly theatrical" and if Giannis might be "milking this" to force a trade, while Sal points out that reports confirming the injury won't stop the speculation. The conversation quickly pivots to the Knicks' championship window, with callers debating if the injury should deter the pursuit of the "mega-star." Sal emphasizes that Jalen Brunson is "untouchable," arguing that trading him defeats the purpose of acquiring Giannis and that the window for a title is "now." They also touch on the bizarre logistics of a "five-syllable superstar" name at Madison Square Garden.

BT & Sal bring in sports betting insider Nick Kostos to dissect the critical Week 14 NFL slate. Kostos issues a "Code Red" for the Chiefs, arguing they are a must-win team against the surging Houston Texans and declaring their season over if they lose. He reveals why the injury-depleted Lions are ripe for a Dallas Cowboys upset on Thursday night, a game he views as an "elimination game" for the NFC East race. Other hot takes include: The Colts' Collapse: Why the Jaguars will beat a team led by a quarterback playing on a broken leg. The NFC North: Why the Packers are better than the Bears, despite Chicago's recent wins. Giants' Future: A quick-fire prediction on who will be the G-Men's head coach in 2026.

BT and Sal dive into the red-hot debate surrounding the Knicks' dynamic wing duo, OG Anunoby and Mikal Bridges. With superstar trade rumors—like the ongoing Giannis Antetokounmpo chatter—heating up, the guys discuss the painful reality that to land an MVP, New York would likely have to break up their formidable wing combination. The hosts clash over which player is the more valuable long-term asset and who the Knicks would dare to include in a blockbuster trade package. The segment also touches on the debate around Karl-Anthony Towns (KAT) and his disappointing performance, and why trading Jalen Brunson for any player, including Giannis, is non-starter.

BT & Sal are fired up over the Yankees' hot stove buzz, particularly the stunning report that the Yankees are "not expected to be a threat" to sign top free-agent closer Edwin Diaz. Sal argues the Yankees should be a threat to sign every elite player, while Tierney is slightly less concerned, noting the team already has a cheap, controlled, and effective closer in Bednar. The conversation pivots to the Yankees' need for a massive offensive upgrade, with Sal expressing frustration that the Yankees are once again being "priced out" of the top tier of talent, unlike the Mets or Dodgers. The hosts agree that the Yankees must pivot aggressively to get better after losing Soto and not letting other rivals gain ground. The segment closes with breaking news that Cody Bellinger remains the Yankees' number one target, making a "big effort" to sign him, although the hosts debate if he'll give them a hometown discount or leave for the highest bidder.

BT and Sal explode over The Athletic's Ian O'Connor's report that the Giants are making a huge mistake by retaining Joe Schoen to lead the next head coaching search. With Brian Daboll gone and the losing continuing, Sal argues Schoen is the "poster boy" for the team's demise and that a clean break is needed now to prevent the situation from getting worse. The hosts worry that allowing the "lame duck" GM to pick the next coach will lead to organizational chaos, with one voice claiming the team's disastrous performance is due to the roster Schoen built versus the coaching that was just fired. The conversation then transitions to the Knicks, where a caller proposes a blockbuster trade: Jalen Brunson for Giannis Antetokounmpo.

BT & Sal dive into the Knicks' future, with Tierney dubbing them the "Bronze Bombers" for settling for less than gold. The main focus is the swirling trade rumors involving Giannis Antetokounmpo and the need to move Karl-Anthony Towns (KAT) to make a championship roster. Sal and a caller argue that keeping the Brunson-KAT tandem is a recipe for disaster due to their defensive liabilities, stating that KAT must be traded in any Giannis scenario. The hosts agree that the only viable path is Giannis in, Towns out, even if it means sacrificing Mikal Bridges and OG Anunoby. The debate turns to how the Knicks can build a supporting cast of "buyout guys" and veterans to surround a Brunson-Giannis core, especially against the "seemingly unbeatable OKC Thunder."

BT & Sal dive into the red-hot trade rumors surrounding Giannis Antetokounmpo and the Knicks, fueled by reports that the superstar only wants New York. Sal argues that Giannis's rumored preference gives the Knicks massive leverage, potentially allowing them to acquire him without giving up everything the Bucks demand. The hosts agree on one crucial point: for the Knicks to win a championship with Giannis, Karl-Anthony Towns must be traded. They debate the toxic fit of a Brunson-Giannis-Towns trio and the need to reroute Towns for the wing defenders (Mikal Bridges, OG Anunoby, and picks) they would have to surrender in the initial Giannis trade. The conversation heats up when a producer suggests Jalen Brunson should be traded for Giannis, a notion Tierney instantly shuts down as "zero chance." The segment also touches on the trade restriction on Mikal Bridges (who can't be traded until early February) and questions whether Leon Rose made a strategic error by going "all-in" for Towns a year ago, thereby depleting the trade capital needed for this now-looming blockbuster.

BT & Sal kick off by addressing the "elephant in the room"—the widely rumored return of Craig Carton—and how it impacts their future. The debate immediately shifts to a fiery attack on the Giants, with Sal declaring GM Joe Schoen's tenure a "fireable offense" for overseeing the team's regression, while Tierney argues the job is suddenly "incredibly appealing" due to QB Jaxson Dart. They debate the fit of a veteran GM like Thomas Dimitroff and whether Bill Belichick's baggage is too much for the New York spotlight. In a Yankees Hot Stove segment, they debate Kyle Tucker's price tag, Sal demands a hard stop at eight years, and they analyze the potential "Superpower Strategy" of trading for an ace like Max Fried or Tarik Skubal to create the league's best rotation. The Mets debate centers on Pete Alonso's free agency, with Tierney predicting a "robust" market (including the Red Sox) that forces the Mets to pay, while Sal dismisses the notion of a significantly better offer emerging. They also discuss the Jets' momentum trending up versus the Giants' organizational rot. Finally, they tackle the hilarious and controversial Three Random Questions: Would you date a porn star? (a nod to the viral fake Soto tweet), What's the worst part of being married? (losing your schedule/having to fake interest), and What's the best part of being married? (having a supportive teammate).

BT & Sal immediately address the "elephant in the room"—the widely reported, yet unofficial, inevitable return of Craig Carton—and the future implications for their show. With that out of the way, the focus shifts to the Giants' "unstable mess." Sal emphatically argues that Joe Shane's four-year tenure has resulted in regression, and his continued presence should be a "fireable offense" that owner John Mara must correct. Tierney argues that, despite the chaos, the Giants job is now "incredibly appealing" due to the presence of QB Jaxson Dart and the potential for a clean GM/Coach synergy, possibly featuring a proven veteran like Thomas Dimitroff. They debate whether a big name like Bill Belichick is the right fit, with Tierney questioning if Belichick's age and the "unnecessary noise" from his personal life could be a problem in the high-pressure New York market. Finally, they cover the Perfect Parlay standings, with BT on a heater (6-0 in the last two weeks!) surging past Sal, who declares he's playing "under protest" due to a half-point line discrepancy on his missed Turkey Day Teaser.

BT & Sal dive into a fiery Yankees Hot Stove debate, starting with the likelihood of Cody Bellinger returning, and then pivot to Kyle Tucker, with Sal arguing that giving him 10 years or $$400$ million is "untenable," calling for a hard stop at eight years. They discuss the Yankees' possible "Superpower Strategy" of trading for an ace like Max Fried or Tarik Skubal to create the best rotation in decades—a move that prioritizes pitching dominance over position player spending.The talk heats up as they preview the Winter Meetings chaos and touch on the persistent (but unlikely) trade rumor of Bryce Harper to the Yankees.Finally, they tackle Three Random Questions, going completely off the rails:Would you date a porn star? (Prompted by the fake Juan Soto/Mia Khalifa social media image)

BT & Sal dive into the hot stove debate surrounding Pete Alonso's free agency, with Tierney predicting a "robust" market—possibly including the Red Sox—that forces the Mets into a tough decision on a five- or six-year contract. Sal, however, remains skeptical, arguing he doesn't see a "significantly better offer" emerging despite the slugger's improved year and the absence of a qualifying offer. The discussion also veers into a larger question about New York sports: Do high taxes, traffic, and media pressure make the area less desirable for top free agents who no longer need "Madison Avenue" endorsements to maximize their off-field earnings? Plus, they briefly slam the Giants' worsening track record under GM Joe Shane.

BT & Sal dive into the state of New York football, declaring the Giants' season "over" and shifting focus to the Jets, whose "stock is trending up" due to better infrastructure, young talent development (like AD Mitchell), and winning three of their last five. They contrast this with the Giants' lack of cap space and the need to "fire everybody" from the front office down. The discussion pivots to baseball, debating the contentious question of Pete Alonso's next contract. Sal defends his $180M/6-year line in a fiery exchange with a caller who suggests the Mets should let Pete walk and rely on Mark Vientos—a prospect Sal vehemently dismisses. Finally, they cover the Saint John's Johnnies Report, noting the team's surprising four-and-three start and the need for Pitino to tighten the rotation and defense. The segment ends with the "Call of the Day," a shocking, dumped-out call that leads to a hilarious discussion about Juan Soto's patience and the viral Wes Steinberg fake news tweet that garnered 25 million views.

BT and Sal dive into the day's most outrageous call, where a listener named Chris compares Juan Soto's plate discipline to Mia Khalifa's... expertise, sparking a hilarious and awkward on-air moment. The discussion quickly pivots to the sheer absurdity of social media after they reveal a fake "Wes Steinberg" tweet about a football player received over 25 million views. Finally, the hosts tackle a Giants fan's wild suggestion to trade the team's top draft pick for star WR Justin Jefferson. Sal pushes back hard, arguing the Giants have more crucial holes to fill—like the trenches and the secondary—especially given their limited cap space. The conversation closes with a listener lamenting the state of media, demanding quality and debate over shocking absurdity.

BT & Sal dive into the hot stove debate surrounding Pete Alonso's free agency, with Tierney predicting a "robust" market—possibly including the Red Sox—that forces the Mets into a tough decision on a five- or six-year contract. Sal, however, remains skeptical, arguing he doesn't see a "significantly better offer" emerging despite the slugger's improved year and the absence of a qualifying offer. The discussion also veers into a larger question about New York sports: Do high taxes, traffic, and media pressure make the area less desirable for top free agents who no longer need "Madison Avenue" endorsements to maximize their off-field earnings? Plus, they briefly slam the Giants' worsening track record under GM Joe Schoen.

BT & Sal dive into a trio of combustible topics! First, a viral (and fake) image of Juan Soto and Mia Khalifa sparks the question: Would you ever date a porn star? The hosts explore the potential challenges, from confidence issues to differing lifestyles. Next, the segment plunges into a marital "minefield" by asking, "What's the worst part of being married?" BT admits he misses being on his own schedule, while Sal and Hoff lament the need to "pretend to care" about endless stories and unnecessary communication ("Just talk to me like you're sending a text!"). Finally, they pull back from the sarcasm to share the best part of marriage: having a "pit bull" teammate and an unshakeable home base. The conversation briefly touches on a Bryce Harper to the Yankees rumor that Cashman can't seem to kill.

BT and Sal are bracing for a chaotic MLB Winter Meetings, with Sal expecting a "blockbuster blitz" of trades and signings. The hosts recall the frenzy of Juan Soto's massive signing from a previous year that broke right at the start of the meetings. The conversation quickly pivots to the Yankees, where Sal argues against the conventional wisdom of needing an entire starting rotation overhaul. He strongly asserts the Yankees are "deficient" in position players, not pitching, and should instead strengthen their existing strength to create a "superpower" rotation with the returns of Gerrit Cole and Cam Schlittler. Tierney agrees, saying the Yankees must strengthen what they're already good at, since they can't match rivals like the Dodgers or Blue Jays in other areas. The segment sets the stage for a dramatic week of hot stove action.

BT & Sal dive into the Yankees' Free Agency strategy, debating whether the team will land a big fish like Cody Bellinger or Kyle Tucker. Sal is skeptical the Yankees will match the necessary seven-year deal for Bellinger, while both hosts agree that Tucker, despite being the better all-around player, is not worth the "Soto Money" (an astronomical $765M) that Juan Soto's dominant walk year commanded. Tierney presents a plausible "outside-the-box" scenario: trading for a star like Jazz Chisholm or beefing up the rotation with a trade for a top-tier pitcher like Max Fried or Tarik Skubal to create the "best rotation this century" and pairing it with Edwin Diaz in the bullpen. Sal argues that overinvesting in pitching and neglecting the lineup is a "dangerous plan" for postseason success. The discussion centers on the core tension in MLB contracts: paying veterans for past performance due to their age at free agency (like Tucker at 29), rather than their future prime years.

BT & Sal dive into a heated recap of their "Perfect Parlay Pick" segment, where the leaderboard has dramatically shifted! BT is riding a scorching 6-0 streak after hitting two straight three-team parlays, catapulting him to 210 points, just behind "Big Hoff" at 215. Sal, however, is protesting his score of 110, arguing that he was "murdered" by the Chiefs, Lions, and Eagles upsets over Thanksgiving weekend and demanding a review of the "Turkey Day Teaser" points. The segment exposes the fierce betting rivalry and the dubious math behind the on-air competition, making every pick a matter of pride and points!

BT and Sal tear into the pathetic state of the New York Giants, responding to a furious caller who threatens to cancel his 40-year season tickets if GM Joe Shane returns—a threat Sal quickly calls "BS." They pivot to what must be done next, focusing on bringing in an experienced GM like former Falcons executive Thomas Dimitroff, whose proven track record (building the Falcons to sustained success after the Vick era) contrasts sharply with Shane's failures. The hosts debate the correct order of hiring: GM first, then coach? They argue that only a Super Bowl winner like Bill Belichick should have the latitude to pick his GM. The episode kicks off with a heated battle over the Perfect Parlay standings, as Sal reveals he was "screwed" out of a win on his Turkey Day Teaser by a half-point line change, sparking a furious debate over NFL betting rules on a tie.

BT & Sal kick off the show addressing the elephant in the room—the breaking news about Craig Carton's inevitable return to the station—and commit to delivering the same "damn good show" regardless of the downstream effects. They then dive into a fiery post-mortem of Joe Shane's press conference, dismissing it as irrelevant compared to the bigger picture. Sal is definitive: the Giants' underperformance proves Shane must go, and he should not be allowed to pick the next head coach. Tierney argues that the Giants' job is actually highly appealing due to the lack of an Eli Manning transition roadblock, and the presence of a promising young QB in Jaxson Dart. Sal counters that the uncertainty and instability at the top of the organization make it an "unstable mess," and that the team's regression under Shane's roster influence is undeniable proof that a total clean sweep is necessary. The hosts and callers agree that there is "no support for Joe Shane" left among the fans.

The best reactions from the Giants' 33-15 loss to the Patriots from Boomer & Gio, Brandon Tierney & Sal Licata, and Evan & Tiki.

Hour 1: The Giants were embarrassed and exposed on a primetime stage, the guys say this will lead to the change necessary for the Giants to start moving in the right direction. BT loves Jaxson Dart. And, who is better dressed-- BT or Dart? Hour 2: The Mets signed Devin Williams, they still need a closer but he's a good contingency plan if Edwin Diaz walks. Sal's acting career may be taking off. Bald Faced Truth / Lie. Hour 3: Should the Giants hire Bill Belichick as their next Head Coach? The NFL Playoff picture is wide open, is that a good thing? Brian Baldinger on next Giants HC, and Calls Out Abdul Carter. Hour 4: Is Home Field Advantage Lost in the NFL? Who of the Mets Young Core Will Step Up in 2026? Jaxson Dart took another terrible hit, he needs to learn from it. Plus, Call of the Day.

Hour 1: The Giants were embarrassed and exposed on a primetime stage, the guys say this will lead to the change necessary for the Giants to start moving in the right direction. BT loves Jaxson Dart. And, who is better dressed-- BT or Dart?

Hour 2: The Mets signed Devin Williams, they still need a closer but he's a good contingency plan if Edwin Diaz walks. Sal's acting career may be taking off. Bald Faced Truth / Lie.

Hour 3: Should the Giants hire Bill Belichick as their next Head Coach? The NFL Playoff picture is wide open, is that a good thing? Brian Baldinger on next Giants HC, and Calls Out Abdul Carter.

Hour 4: Is Homefield Advantage Lost in the NFL? Who of the Mets Young Core Will Step Up in 2026? Jaxson Dart took another terrible hit, he needs to learn from it. Plus, Call of the Day.

Brian Baldinger on next Giants HC, and Calls Out Abdul Carter, plus the Jets O-line looks great!