Tiki and Tierney

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate over the potential impact John Harbaugh will have on the Giants. Plus, reaction to Malik Nabers starting camp completely off the PUP list (23:55); Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash on if it's playoffs or bust for the Giants (32:30); Evan argues the Giants should sign Vita Vea (50:03)

Tiki Barber is already putting Geno Smith on notice, declaring that Cade Klubnik should get the QB1 if he outplays the veteran in training camp and the preseason. Plus, Evan and Tiki can already see the Jets' use of AI going hilariously wrong. Boomer and Gio wonder if Aaron Glenn's job is tied to how Geno performs this season, and The Carton Show reacts to Plaxico Burress comparing playing for the Jets to being in prison.

Gregg Giannotti has had enough of the Aaron Boone criticism when it is never followed by any kind of praise. He says Boone's critics who also rip the Yankees' use of analytics need to be consistent in their arguments. Plus, Evan Roberts says vintage Gerrit Cole has returned, and the rest of the American League should be scared. Chris McMonigle calls for Brian Cashman to stack the deck with pitching if there isn't a significant bat available at the trade deadline, and Boomer and Gio wonder why Boone doesn't have better odds to win Manager of the Year.

Chris McMonigle is talking all things trade deadline, addressing the Yankees' biggest needs, where they can realistically upgrade the roster, C-Mac's most desired trade targets, and who the Yankees could ship out before the deadline. Plus, reactions to the final two games of the White Sox series, from Ali Sanchez's inexplicable gaffe to the Yankees' continued struggles in extra innings, and the team's offensive struggles that do not seem to be going away.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS3:00 - Defending Aaron Boone and why manager accountability won't fix major mental errors.12:00 - Breaking down the disastrous third game of this series, perhaps the worst loss of the season23:00 - Analyzing the inexplicable Ali Sanchez decision to throw to third with two outs and the terrible execution of spiking the ball.28:50 - Weathers pitches seven shutout innings, but the offense stays ice cold in game four.32:00 - Baserunning issues continue with Jasson Dominguez sliding past the bag and Jazz Chisholm getting picked off on an aggressive first move. 39:46 - Shill or Shame Segment: Handing out praise and blame for the series.43:50 - What the Yankees absolutely must acquire at the trade deadline to survive until their injured stars return.

The Yankees are halfway to a four-game sweep in Chicago, and Chris McMonigle is back to break down the first two games of the series, including Gerrit Cole's six scoreless innings on Tuesday night. C-Mac covers all the hot topics in Yankees Universe, from Anthony Volpe's dropped pop-up in game one to the continued optimism coming from the bullpen. Plus, all the latest trade deadline rumors and where the Yankees will have the best chance to upgrade the team.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS7:33 - Analyzing Max Fried's start, a rocky first inning plagued by sloppy defense, and the offense battling back from a 3-0 deficit.18:18 - An honest conversation about Volpe's dropped pop-up, his overall defensive abilities compared to Caballero, and his improved on-base percentage.25:26 - Cole throws six scoreless innings with seven strikeouts, successfully navigating a difficult 30-pitch fourth inning.37:36 - Giving much-needed credit to the back end of the bullpen, specifically highlighting the reliability of Headrick and Chivilli.40:35 - Why Bednar's workload is a concern and why Mason Miller is the ultimate prize for Brian Cashman.50:28 - Exploring alternative options if the Miller trade falls through, including Marlins catcher Liam Hicks and Mets outfielder Tyrone Taylor.

Craig and Big Mac sit down with Mets legend Mookie Wilson to celebrate the 40th anniversary of the 1986 World Series and his friendship with Bill Buckner. They also break down positive training camp footage of Malik Nabors and debate whether John Harbaugh is an upgrade over Brian Daboll for the Giants. Additionally, the discussion covers the Yankees' trade deadline needs and a potential new stadium location for the Jets. 01:54 - Romo and Shanahan Videos 06:45 - John Harbaugh Debate 16:12 - Robert Saleh Predictions 27:20 - Mookie Wilson Interview 30:41 - Malik Nabors Update 34:49 - Jets Stadium Rumors 45:24 - Gotham App DAZN Move 53:45 - Eagles History Trivia

Craig and Big Mac dive into a heated debate regarding whether John Harbaugh is truly an upgrade for the New York Giants or simply a coach who benefited from elite talent. They analyze his fourth-quarter track record and compare his recent struggles to Brian Daboll's tenure. The discussion also covers Robert Saleh's bold predictions for the Jets and the mysterious lack of body cam footage from Kyle Shanahan's car accident. 01:20 - Tony Romo DUI Video 05:05 - Radio Advice For Morash 09:45 - Harbaugh Blown Leads Debate 14:15 - Giants Franchise Embarrassment 17:25 - Robert Saleh Jets Prediction 20:30 - Caller Defends Harbaugh 26:00 - Coaching vs Player Talent 32:15 - LeBron James Bar Ban 38:40 - Giants Roster Breakdown 45:05 - Pass Rush Expectations

Mookie Wilson joins to discuss the legacy of the 1986 World Series and details his legendary Game 6 at-bat. He shares stories about his deep friendship with the late Bill Buckner and the unique chemistry of that championship squad. The conversation also covers Malik Nabors returning to practice for the Giants and the Jets' season expectations. 01:20 - Heidi Klum's Chip Brand 04:25 - Mookie Wilson Joins 08:10 - Game 6 Breakdown 18:00 - Friendship With Bill Buckner 26:30 - Mets Team Chemistry 30:15 - Malik Nabors Practice Update 40:40 - Jets Season Outlook 46:55 - Gotham App Joins DAZN

Craig and C-Mac analyze the hypothetical impact of Robert Saleh and Brian Daboll teaming up in Tennessee, debating if they could turn the Titans into a defensive juggernaut. They also delve into sports history, discussing infamous sign-stealing rumors from 1951 and the unfair legacies of Bill Buckner and Ralph Branca. 01:48 - Robert Saleh Coaching Future 06:42 - Gilligan's Island Debate 12:47 - Snow White Casting Controversy 15:47 - Branca and Buckner Legacies 25:24 - 1951 Sign-Stealing Rumors 34:30 - College Sports Profitability 46:16 - Saleh vs Gase Analysis 56:07 - Starting Lineup Figurines

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze Malik Nabers' health at training camp and debate the potential for the Jets to relocate to the Aqueduct Racetrack site in Queens. They test an intern's knowledge of Eagles history with a trivia question about 4,000-yard passing seasons. The discussion concludes with a deep dive into the Yankees' trade deadline needs and Aaron Boone's recent management success. 01:25 - Malik Nabers Impresses at Camp 06:01 - Potential Jets Move to Aqueduct 16:15 - Nashville Travel and App Issues 23:15 - Eagles QB Yardage Trivia Challenge 34:50 - Yankees Success Under Aaron Boone 45:15 - John Harbaugh and Giants' Future 51:00 - Yankees Trade Deadline Strategy

Craig Carton and Chris "C-Mac" McMonigle jump right into the fire on this segment of WFAN's The Carton Show, defending Robert Saleh against critical callers while breaking down NFL Training Camp hype, hilarious history debates, and unique fan memorabilia!

Craig Carton and Chris "C-Mac" McMonigle are back breaking down a wild start to NFL Training Camp! The guys kick things off reacting to the massive relief of seeing Malik Nabers completely off the PUP list and looking electric at Giants camp. Then, things get crazy in Minnesota as reports surface of Kyler Murray and J.J. McCarthy throwing hands after a camp interception. Is competition boiling over, or is this a disaster for the Vikings? Finally, they take a call from Stevie on Long Island to debate the future of Big Blue. Is the John Harbaugh and Jaxson Dart era enough to wash the 15-year "stink" off the Giants organization, or is it going to take a lot more than coaching to get back to winning? Plus, a quick shoutout to Lil Wayne and French Montana killing it in Bangor, Maine!

Craig Carton and Chris "C-Mac" McMonigle dive into the wild world of college sports economics on this segment of WFAN's The Carton Show! The guys break down the staggering financial numbers from Penn State's athletic department. While the Penn State football team raked in a massive $58 million net operating profit, the athletic department as a whole only walked away with a net profit of $223,000!

Craig Carton and Chris "C-Mac" McMonigle are back on WFAN with a wildly entertaining segment of The Carton Show!

Craig Carton and Chris "C-Mac" McMonigle bring the heat to WFAN! In this segment, the guys talk New York Jets expectations, Yankees trade deadline moves, and a major shakeup for local sports streaming. Plus, Craig interrogates C-Mac about his parenting rules for an upcoming Disney cruise.

Forty years later, Mookie Wilson takes Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle behind the scenes of one of the greatest moments in baseball history. From his unforgettable Game 6 at-bat against the Red Sox to his emotional friendship with Bill Buckner, Mookie shares stories Mets fans have never heard. He also reflects on the chemistry that made the 1986 Mets champions, why today's Mets are falling short, and what this year's 40th anniversary celebration means. Don't miss one of the best baseball interviews you'll hear all year.

The John Harbaugh debate reaches another level. Craig Carton doubles down on his controversial take that Giants fans are overrating their new head coach, while Chris McMonigle passionately defends Harbaugh's winning résumé. The two go back and forth over playoff expectations, Lamar Jackson, Joe Flacco, Brian Daboll, and whether Giants fans are setting themselves up for disappointment.

After setting Giants fans on fire, Carton doubles down on his claim that John Harbaugh is the most overrated coach in the NFL. Chris McMonigle pushes back, callers defend Harbaugh's résumé, and the debate quickly turns into one of the hottest Giants conversations of training camp.

They evaluate the Giants' chances of reaching the postseason and compare the leadership of Brian Daboll and John Harbaugh. The conversation also covers Plaxico Burris's viral comments comparing his time with the Jets to prison and the reporting surrounding Kyle Shanahan's recent car accident. 02:15 - Giants Playoff Expectations 10:35 - Plaxico Burris Slams Jets 18:20 - David Bailey Draft Critique 23:45 - Dice Clay Comedy Talk 30:25 - Harbaugh Leadership Debate 34:15 - Shanahan Accident Mystery 19:40 - Baywatch Casting Comparisons 27:15 - Pornography Movie Parody Titles 32:10 - Anthony Volpe Error Analysis 35:20 - Yankees Mets Trade Rumors

Craig Carton and Big Mac react to former wide receiver Plaxico Burris comparing his time with the New York Jets to serving a prison sentence. They also debate whether the New York Giants can replicate recent historic playoff turnarounds and revisit Carton's awkward run-in with movie critic Rex Reed. 01:20 - NFL Playoff Turnaround History 05:00 - Giants Postseason Expectations Debate 11:35 - Plaxico Burris Slams Jets 15:30 - Jets Loser Culture Discussion 19:45 - Jets Draft Selection Critique 23:35 - Long Island Roadway Rant 27:35 - Carton Syracuse Career Story 32:00 - Port Jefferson Ferry Controversy 37:30 - Movie Review Discussion 42:30 - Famous Critic Encounter Story

The hosts engage in a spirited debate over whether John Harbaugh is truly an upgrade over Brian Daboll for the Giants, citing Harbaugh's history of blown leads. They also investigate the reported media blackout and alleged cover-up surrounding Kyle Shanahan's recent serious car accident. 01:20 - Andrew Dice Clay Discussion 04:53 - Sebastian Maniscalco Comedy Repetition 06:18 - John Harbaugh Blown Leads 13:43 - Harbaugh vs Daboll Debate 19:32 - Ravens Playoff Underachievement 24:02 - Giants Playoff Expectations 30:20 - Hypothetical Play-By-Play Call 31:10 - Kyle Shanahan Accident Cover-Up 37:25 - Media Ethics and Insiders 43:40 - Shanahan Responsibility and Fault

On The Carton Show, Carton and C-Mac explore the disparity in media coverage regarding Kyle Shanahan's unreported car accident versus minor infractions by players like Geno Smith. They revisit a past confrontation with PETA over a show 'meat draft' involving a cow named Mookie before debating the proper etiquette for concert guests like Bruce Springsteen and Pat Monahan. The discussion also covers the Yankees' messy victory over the White Sox and rumors surrounding LeBron James and the Tyrese Maxey led 76ers. 01:22 - Livvy Dunne Vs Brooks Nader 06:45 - Evolution Of Adult Entertainment 11:50 - Kyle Shanahan Accident Reporting 18:08 - PETA Meat Draft Battle 27:15 - Psychology Of Personal Prayers 31:28 - Anthony Volpe Sloppy Error 36:15 - Springsteen Bon Jovi Duet 49:02 - LeBron James Sixers Rumors

The discussion kicks off with a lively debate about the vocal prowess and versatility of Pink compared to other legendary performers like Adele, Whitney Houston, and Taylor Swift. The conversation then shifts to the MLB trade deadline, exploring potential moves for the Yankees, including interests in Mason Miller and Tyrone Taylor. 01:00 - Pink Debate 09:51 - Yankees Trade Rumors 16:35 - Intern Joe Farewell

The Yankees escaped with a wild win, but Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle aren't letting them off easy. The guys break down Anthony Volpe's bizarre night, sloppy defense, the bullpen's heroics, and how the Yankees managed to stay in the playoff race despite plenty of mistakes. Meanwhile, the Mets continue to fall down the New York sports priority list as Craig jokes they could be “relegated to the tablet” while the Yankees, Red Sox, and even Rays take over the spotlight.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle revisit one of the wildest moments from the show — the legendary “meat draft” and Craig's beef with PETA after buying an entire cow. Would you trade a cow for 1,500 pounds of vegetarian alternatives? Craig explains why he said absolutely not. The guys also debate the greatest cuts of steak, including the legendary spinalis/deckle, ribeye, skirt steak, and whether a tomahawk steak is overrated. Plus, Craig and Big Mac dive into sports rivalries, biblical trivia, prayer, and more hilarious conversations from The Carton Show on WFAN.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the controversy surrounding Kyle Shanahan's reported car accident and question why the story wasn't immediately reported. The guys debate whether public figures deserve privacy or if major incidents involving NFL coaches and stars are automatically newsworthy.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into one of the strangest NFL stories of the offseason, questioning why news of Shanahan's serious car accident stayed quiet for weeks. The guys debate whether reporters should protect sources, the ethics of breaking news, and whether a bigger story is still waiting to come out.

The discussion focuses on the mysterious 11-day media silence following Kyle Shanahan's severe car accident and reports of a potential cover-up by police. They examine why journalists and insiders like Chris Simms withheld information out of personal friendship until the San Francisco 49ers officially disclosed the crash. Finally, they cover Shanahan's press conference where he took full responsibility for the distracted driving incident. 01:07 - Kyle Shanahan Accident Details 02:39 - Alleged Media Blackout Discussion 07:32 - Chris Simms Friendship Conflict 11:31 - Shanahan Admits Fault Publicly 15:12 - Pool Noodle Safety Hack

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle get into a heated debate over the Giants' future, with Carton making the shocking case that Harbaugh may be one of the NFL's most overrated coaches. The guys break down Baltimore's late-game collapses, Lamar Jackson's playoff shortcomings, Brian Daboll's tenure, and what Giants fans should realistically expect in 2026.

From crazy New York weather, the Long Island-to-Connecticut ferry debate, and movie nostalgia to Craig's unbelievable story about legendary film critic Rex Reed hitting on him after the Ghostbusters II premiere, this segment has it all. Plus, the guys rank classic movies, debate Ghostbusters, The Pacifier, Beverly Hills Cop, and preview the Giants' expectations heading into training camp.

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the New York Giants' path to the playoffs and the evolution of Jaxson Dart. They also react to Plaxico Burress's viral comparison between his time with the New York Jets and his prison sentence. Additionally, the conversation turns to a heated debate over Jets rookie David Bailey and local geography. 01:00 - Giants Playoff Potential 09:48 - Plaxico Burress Viral Comments 18:10 - Jets David Bailey Debate 23:23 - Long Island Geography Banter

WFAN hosts break down LeBron James' shocking decision to sign with the Philadelphia 76ers, debating whether this new Eastern Conference superteam actually poses a threat to the Knicks or is destined for an epic collapse. Plus, the crew reacts to wild reports that LeBron plans to live in New York City and commute to Philly home games by helicopter.

Will Warren and the Yankees were hammered by the Phillies on Sunday night, losing their chance of a three-game sweep. A fired-up Chris McMonigle reacts to the series finale, Warren's continued struggles, Jose Caballero's diminishing value, Cody Bellinger's hamstring injury, and the series as a whole, including Cam Schlittler's dominating outing in the series opener. Plus, more trade deadline talk and what moves will help the Yanks regain control of the AL East.EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS6:41 - Reacting to Bellinger heading to the 10-day IL and how devastating it is for a lineup already missing Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton.14:18 - Comparing Anthony Volpe's hot bat to Caballero's struggles, and why playing Amed Rosario isn't working right now.22:04 - Breaking down Cam Schlittler's masterpiece and his vastly improved curveball.27:10 - Praising the elite back-end of the bullpen, which Chris says has become one of the best in baseball.45:11 - Chris vents about the umpires targeting Caballero with pitch clock rules and a ridiculous "intentional drop" call.54:02 - Reacting to the series finale and Will Warren getting lit up again.1:05:03 - Debating if the Yankees should call up red-hot prospect George Lombard after the trade deadline passes.1:09:51 - Shill or Shame Segment1:13:11 - Discussing Matt Blake's impact, the steep asking price for Mason Miller, and whether the Yankees should trade for George Springer.1:29:04 - Looking ahead to the four-game series in Chicago and setting up Thursday's trade deadline deep-dive episode.

Hoff chats with Anthony DiComo about the Mets ahead of the trade deadline.

McMonigle breaks down the devastating injury news for the New York Yankees and explores how Cody Bellinger's absence shifts their trade deadline priorities. He weighs the benefits of adding stars like Mason Miller or Luis Arraez against the current lineup's offensive struggles. The segment also features insights on LeBron James joining the 76ers, the New York Giants' cultural overhaul, and the superstitious polo curse. 01:50 - McMonigle Solo Intro 06:45 - Yankees Pitching Dominance 11:50 - Brian Cashman Strategy 17:10 - Postseason Hitting Concerns 21:43 - Music Banter Segment 26:30 - Bills Uniform Outrage 31:42 - LeBron 76ers Move 36:15 - Knicks Rivalry Discussion 41:20 - Mets Fan Call 26:35 - Mets Movie Controversy 31:55 - Francisco Lindor Rumors 18:15 - Giants Coaching Hopes 25:55 - Berbari Joins Show 31:45 - The Polo Curse 41:15 - Final Injury Update

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' trade deadline needs, suggesting that elite arms like Tarik Skubal or Mason Miller might be more valuable than minor offensive tweaks. He debates with callers about the team's struggling lineup and upcoming stars while also finding time to joke about the Red Hot Chili Peppers. 01:20 - Yankees Series Recap 05:15 - Trade Deadline Strategy 21:06 - Red Hot Chili Peppers 24:45 - Elite Pitching Targets 31:30 - Fan Reaction Segment 43:00 - Sports News Update

McMonigle reacts to the Buffalo Bills' widely criticized new uniforms and Mike Vrabel's clever use of a puppy to disarm the media. They also break down the New York Yankees' trade deadline strategy, debating whether the team should prioritize a dominant rotation or offensive upgrades like Luis Arraez. 01:20 - Bills Uniform Criticism 05:15 - Vrabel's Puppy Presser 10:53 - Host Dog Allergy Stories 17:06 - Yankees Trade Deadline Strategy 31:14 - LeBron's 76ers New York Connection 41:00 - Craig's Bizarre Candy Preferences 46:49 - Machado And Yankees Trades

McMonigle argues that the Yankees should aggressively target Tyrone Taylor from the Mets and explore a deal for George Springer to bolster their outfield. He also evaluates the potential for a defensive turnaround for the Giants, specifically focusing on the development of Deonte Banks. Additionally, callers debate the roster value of contact hitters like Luis Arraez versus high-impact power threats. 01:20 - Tommy's Virtual Team 02:35 - Yankees Deadline Strategy 10:26 - Catching Offensive Value 15:14 - Arraez vs Devers 19:28 - Giants Defensive Changes 22:37 - Deonte Banks' Development 31:42 - Proposed Yankee Trades 40:03 - Evaluating Young Prospects

Chris McMonigle analyzes the Mets' disappointing season and the indifference of the fan base following Juan Soto's injury. He is later joined by Emmanuel Berbari to discuss Cody Bellinger's Grade 2 hamstring strain, which leaves the Yankees' offense in a vulnerable position. They also debate the future of the Giants and the potential for a George Lombard Jr. promotion. 01:20 - Mets Indifference Discussion 06:05 - Selling The Mets Core 13:47 - Giants Playoff Potential Debate 25:44 - Knicks vs Sixers Rivalry 29:44 - Yankees Offensive Lineup Crisis 42:46 - Bellinger's Hamstring Injury Update 49:39 - George Lombard Jr Promotion

C-Mac and Emmanuel Berbari evaluate the Yankees' outlook following news of Cody Bellinger's hamstring injury. They explore high-profile trade targets like Manny Machado and Mason Miller while debating Anthony Volpe's position in the long-term roster. The duo also addresses a caller's frustration and a bizarre superstition involving a lost polo at the stadium. 01:29 - Cody Bellinger Hamstring Injury 05:06 - Yankees Trade Deadline Scenarios 15:58 - Jose Caballero Umpire Controversy 24:54 - Championship Expectations vs. Mets 31:38 - Massive Manny Machado Proposal 37:11 - C-Mac's Lost Polo Superstition

On this segment of The Carton Show on WFAN, Chris McMonigle flies solo and is joined by Emmanuel Berbari to react to some devastating injury news for the New York Yankees: Cody Bellinger has suffered a Grade 2 hamstring strain and will be sidelined for 4 to 6 weeks. The guys discuss how this major blow alters Brian Cashman's strategy with the trade deadline exactly a week away. With Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, and now Bellinger all sidelined, Chris and Emmanuel dive into potential deadline pivots. They debate whether the Yankees should go all-in for Oakland's star reliever Mason Miller, the hesitation around calling up or trading top prospect George Lombard Jr., and what to expect from Max Fried as he takes the mound against the White Sox tonight.

Chris McMonigle evaluates the New York Giants' roster and the influence of the coaching staff on struggling players like Deonte Banks. He considers how specific scheme changes might revitalize the defense before pivoting to the New York Yankees' strategy. The discussion focuses on potential acquisitions such as Luis Arraez and Jazz Chisholm Jr. to provide a much-needed spark to the lineup. 01:01 - Giants Coaching Impact 05:25 - Deonte Banks' Potential Turnaround 11:49 - Yankees Trade Deadline Discussion 21:37 - Valuing Yankees Trade Pieces