Tiki and Tierney

Aaron Glenn admits that he has super powers and wants to use them to help the Jets in 2026. This, of course, makes sense. After all of what happened during the John Harbaugh coaching search and hire, Joe Schoen says his role with the Giants has NOT changed in anyway. For this fan focus, Carton surprises Big Mac with a story about a deer that he was not expecting. A touching check-in with legendary Yankees announcer John Sterling after his recent heart scare, and nostalgia-packed stories about New York's iconic broadcasters. Plus, the first handheld football video game makes a comeback?

Aaron Glenn admits that he has super powers and wants to use them to help the Jets in 2026. This, of course, makes sense.

After all of what happened during the John Harbaugh coaching search and hire, Joe Schoen says his role with the Giants has NOT changed in anyway.

For this fan focus, Carton surprises Big Mac with a story about a deer that he was not expecting.

A touching check-in with legendary Yankees announcer John Sterling after his recent heart scare, and nostalgia-packed stories about New York's iconic broadcasters. Plus, the first handheld football video game makes a comeback?

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the latest NY sports drama! From Aaron Glenn taking control of the Jets' defense to Breece Hall's future, potential Kirk Cousins rumors, and an inside look at the Jets' QB dilemma. Plus, a touching check-in with legendary Yankees announcer John Sterling after his recent heart scare, and nostalgia-packed stories about New York's iconic broadcasters. Don't miss the laughs, insights, and behind-the-scenes commentary from WFAN's Carton Show!

This segment of The Carton Show starts nostalgic and ends completely unhinged.

Did the most powerful man in hockey just disappear?! On this wild segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle demand answers: Where was Gary Bettman during the Olympic gold medal moment for hockey? If this was such a massive event for the sport, why wasn't the commissioner front and center? The debate spirals into whether Olympic success actually grows hockey in America and how other commissioners like Adam Silver and Roger Goodell would've handled it.

This might be one of the wildest segments you'll ever hear on sports radio and that's saying something. On WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to an absolutely shocking news story out of Kentucky that leaves the studio speechless and spirals into one of the most chaotic discussions you'll ever hear on air.

Did a full-blown power struggle just get exposed inside the New York Giants front office?!

The hockey debate just EXPLODED on The Carton Show. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle take on furious hockey fans after their controversial claim that America's latest international win won't grow the sport at all. Using hard numbers, ratings, and draft data, Carton argues even the legendary 1980 Winter Olympics didn't spark a lasting hockey boom so why would this? Plus things heat up in New York football as Joe Schoen responds to the noise and lays out his mission for the New York Giants.

Things got heated FAST on this episode of The Carton Show. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle respond to the backlash over their controversial claim that a gold medal hockey moment won't boost ratings or grow the sport in the U.S. and they are NOT backing down.

The drama is heating up at the NFL Combine and the takes are getting WILD. On this explosive segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to shocking comments from Aaron Glenn, who says his “superpower” is calling defensive plays for the New York Jets. But does that actually translate to WINS or more chaos?

If the Gold Medal game was so good, then why do we still not care for the NHL. Plus, Guess which sports have the least amount of action in them. Karl Anthony Towns has put up incredible numbers this season, yet he's still getting asked for more from fans! Carton brings out the wheel to play "Spin That Wheel", A new game that tests the knowledge between Big Mac, Hoff and Gallo. Unfortunately they all buckle under pressure. Plus, help McMonigle to pick a name for his new Yankee podcast. USA shocked the world and beat Canada in Mens Hockey. Unfortunately, hockey will continue to be 4th biggest sport in America and it doesn't seem the Olympics will change that. Plus, the crazy similarity between 1980 and 2026 Olympic teams.

If the Gold Medal game was so good, then why do we still not care for the NHL. Plus, Guess which sports have the least amount of action in them.

Karl Anthony Towns has put up incredible numbers this season, yet he's still getting asked for more from fans!

Carton brings out the wheel to play "Spin That Wheel", A new game that tests the knowledge between Big Mac, Hoff and Gallo. Unfortunately they all buckle under pressure. Plus, help McMonigle to pick a name for his new Yankee podcast.

USA shocked the world and beat Canada in Mens Hockey. Unfortunately, hockey will continue to be 4th biggest sport in America and it doesn't seem the Olympics will change that. Plus, the crazy similarity between 1980 and 2026 Olympic teams.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive deep into the iconic 1980 “Miracle on Ice” hockey game, sharing behind-the-scenes stories you've never heard reporters, ABC's broadcast choices, and the unforgettable peanut M&Ms ritual! From Lake Placid memories to family traditions, this segment is a wild ride through sports history and personal anecdotes. Don't miss these hilarious and jaw-dropping stories!

This podcast naming session went completely off the rails! On WFAN, Craig Carton pushes Chris McMonigle to the edge while trying to name a new show about the New York Yankees and his idea is WILD.

Absolute chaos on the air

This was supposed to show off their sports knowledge, instead it turned into TOTAL chaos. On WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle host a wild round of Name That Number and things go off the rails FAST.

The guys break down the emotional fallout after Team USA's massive gold medal win but not everyone is celebrating the same way! Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle clash over how much it really matters, debate international tournaments, and react to wild fan stories.

This stat will blow your mind. On WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down one of the craziest facts in sports: the average NFL game has just 11 minutes of real action. Meanwhile… NBA, NHL, and Major League Baseball all give fans MORE actual gameplay yet football dominates ratings. How does that make sense?!

The Olympic gold medal hockey game between Team USA and Canada had EVERYONE buzzing but on WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down why this epic moment might NOT change anything long-term. From emotional tributes and overtime drama to the reality of hockey's place in American sports the guys ask the big question: was this just a one-day sports high?

WFAN presents a selection of conversations from during the past week about the Giants from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Craig Carton Show with Chris McMonigle. Star wide receivers Mike Evans and Jaylen Waddle have surfaced as potentially being available this offseason -- should Big Blue be in on them? Plus, reacting to the Giants' over/under win total for 2026, and yet another sign that John Harbaugh has taken charge.

WFAN presents a selection of conversations about the Jets during the past week from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Craig Carton Show with Chris McMonigle. Breece Hall's free agency and the possibility of the Jets tagging him remains a top talking point. Evan's Jets quarterback big board raises some eyebrows. Boomer & Gio are surprised by the salary projections for an underwhelming crop of free-agent QBs.

The Knicks just got bullied by the Pistons, and the vibes in New York are shifting fast. Is it just a mid-season slump, or is it officially time to hit the panic button? The WFAN team breaks down the ugly Thursday night loss and asks the question every fan is dreading: What happened? Plus, we dive into Jalen Brunson's future as he begins looking ahead to his next massive contract. Can the Knicks afford to keep the core together while paying their superstar?

Carlos Mendoza joined The Carton Show and laughed off the idea that politics had anything to do with the Mets' clubhouse issues last season. Plus, reaction to early injuries in camp, and Gio wonders who will be the casualty if the team gets off to a rough start.

Aaron Judge opened some eyes with his comments on the Yankees offseason, leading to reactions from Craig Carton, Chris McMonigle, and Tommy Lugauer. Plus, did Brian Cashman slip up with some spring training comments of his own? And Shaun Morash ignited baseball fans with his Derek Jeter vs. Omar Vizquel take.

The Knicks take another loss to the Pistons on Thursday night. Does this mean the Knicks have no chance at getting to the Finals? Pete Alonso hits the first home run of spring training. Carton dives into how much Pete Alonso is going is going to be on the minds of all New Yorkers? Punch the Monkey is getting all the support from Craig and C-Mac. Plus, Marlon Jackson stops by to dish out the life and times of the Jackson 5. USA moves on to take on Canada in the Men's Hockey Gold Medal Game, but why is it scheduled for 8am? Plus, what to do on a snowy day with your new fiancée and why are Mets fans scared of the 2026 season?

The Knicks take another loss to the Pistons on Thursday night. Does this mean the Knicks have no chance at getting to the Finals?

Pete Alonso hits the first home run of spring training. Carton dives into how much Pete Alonso is going is going to be on the minds of all New Yorkers?

Punch the Monkey is getting all the support from Craig and C-Mac. Plus, Marlon Jackson stops by to dish out the life and times of the Jackson 5.

USA moves on to take on Canada in the Mens Hockey Gold Medal Game, but why is it scheduled for 8am? Plus, what to do on a snowy day with your new fiancée and why are Mets fans scared of the 2026 season?

Are New York Mets fans already giving up on the season?! On WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a shocking fan mindset skipping Citi Field and buying tickets to Yankee Stadium instead just to see Pete Alonso early in the season

It's ON at WFAN! After getting called out online, Craig Carton fires back with a WILD challenge come into the studio and prove you know more sports than him and Chris McMonigle LIVE on air! Win the trivia battle? You get to HOST the show. Lose? Well that's another story.

Things got WILD on WFAN when Craig Carton revealed that Chris McMonigle might be singing LIVE with Marlon Jackson! It all started with talk of surprise celebrity karaoke appearances at Baby Grand and spiraled into a full-on on-air challenge. Would YOU sing in front of a music legend?!

New York sports fans are LOSING IT and Craig Carton is not holding back. In this explosive segment of WFAN's The Carton Show, Carton and Chris McMonigle break down everything driving fans crazy right now…

Imagine walking into a tiny karaoke bar and suddenly you're watching SUPERSTARS perform live. That's exactly what happened at Baby Grand in NYC when Kelly Clarkson and John Legend reportedly jumped on stage… and the stories only get crazier from there.

Chaos in New York baseball… and Craig Carton can't stop laughing.

Who REALLY knows the New York Knicks best at WFAN?! On this hilarious segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton puts the station's biggest Knicks fans to the test in a wild game inspired by Name That Tune… but with playoff opponents instead. Can Big Mac outlast Anthony Gallo in Knicks playoff history trivia? Who folds under pressure? And who ends up paying the tip from Prince Street Pizza?!