Tiki and Tierney

Big Mac breaks down the New York Knicks' incredible 22-point comeback against the Cleveland Cavaliers in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals. They praise Jalen Brunson's legendary fourth-quarter performance and Mike Brown's bold coaching decisions, specifically the insertion of Landry Shamet for Josh Hart. The discussion also covers the New York Mets' jersey controversy involving Gary Carter and Boomer Esiason's induction into the National Radio Hall of Fame.

Big Mac celebrates the New York Knicks' improbable 22-point comeback against the Cleveland Cavaliers, spotlighting Jalen Brunson's heroics at Madison Square Garden. He also addresses the controversy surrounding the New York Mets and Gary Carter's jersey number, followed by a unique segment featuring an Aztec death whistle. 01:20 - Miraculous Knicks Playoff Comeback 05:30 - Mike Brown Outcoaches Atkinson 10:12 - Fans Leaving MSG Early 13:30 - Mets Gary Carter Controversy 18:00 - Hack-a-Mitch Strategy Debate 23:48 - Jalen Brunson's Dominant Performance 35:50 - Aztec Death Whistle Blown 43:40 - Morbid Office Death Theories

They analyze the Knicks' postseason success and debate where Mike Brown ranks among New York's current head coaches. The conversation shifts to a memorable story about the 1994 NBA Finals and OJ Simpson's attempt to contact Bob Costas during the famous police chase. Additionally, they poke fun at Evan Roberts for bringing a night light to Madison Square Garden to ensure he could keep scoring the game during the player introductions. 01:26 - Landry Shamet Impact 05:54 - Mike Brown Success 10:45 - New York Top Coaches 17:08 - Jalen Brunson Performance 22:11 - OJ Simpson Chase 24:46 - OJ Calls Bob Costas 30:13 - Garden Food and Entertainment 37:26 - Evan Roberts' Night Light

Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the New York Knicks' incredible 22-point comeback and discuss Jalen Brunson's surging legacy. They also rip into the New York Mets for the Gary Carter jersey blunder and react to Aaron Rodgers' retirement news. Additionally, they debate movie sequels and the conflict of rooting for family versus a favorite team. 01:20 - Knicks Comeback and Mets Grand Slam 05:08 - Mets Disrespect Gary Carter's Legacy 13:53 - Aaron Rodgers Announces Final Season 17:35 - Leon Rose's Impact on the Knicks 21:58 - Tom Thibodeau's Legacy and Success 29:15 - Big Mac's Custom Board Game Business 34:30 - Watching Knicks with a Bat Infestation 38:59 - Debating the Greatest Movie Sequels 51:30 - Rooting for Family vs. Favorite Team

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle celebrate Boomer Esiason's induction into the National Radio Hall of Fame while reflecting on their history together. They also break down Jalen Brunson's historic performance in the Knicks' comeback win and discuss the impact of ALS following a moving call from a listener. 01:20 - Zach Thornton's Mets Debut 04:40 - Aaron Rodgers Retirement Tour 08:08 - Ayahuasca and Sports Discussion 13:40 - WFAN History and Grievances 18:52 - Tommy's ALS Diagnosis Call 25:38 - Knicks' Historic Comeback Win 32:24 - Roasting Station Employee Attire 36:30 - Boomer's Hall of Fame Honor 45:01 - Afternoon Sports Roundup

Craig and Chris give a heart felt tribute to Boomer Esiason after it was announced he would be inducted into the Radio Hall of Fame

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle spiral into an all-time movie debate on The Carton Show after talking Knicks, bats flying around houses during playoff games, and kids bringing Yankees hats to school. Craig unloads on legendary sequels like Ghostbusters 2, Jaws 2, Ace Ventura 2, Back to the Future 2, and even Die Hard With a Vengeance while the rest of the studio calls his movie opinions completely insane.

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to one of the strangest Mets controversies in years after the team accidentally gave away Gary Carter's iconic No. 8 jersey.

After the Knicks' unbelievable playoff comeback at Madison Square Garden, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go completely off the rails in this hilarious Carton Show segment.

The Knicks pulled off another unbelievable playoff comeback at Madison Square Garden, and Craig Carton is ready to give Mike Brown ALL the credit. Craig and Chris McMonigle debate Brown's coaching adjustments, Landry Shamet's huge impact, Tom Thibodeau comparisons, and whether the Knicks are officially headed to the NBA Finals. Plus: Craig stirs the pot ranking the best coaches and executives in New York sports right now.

A caller shares wit Carton & Big Mac how he refused to leave the toilet for 25 minutes to ensure a Knicks victory, leading to a debate over bathroom-related health risks. They jokingly discuss which colleague is most likely to meet an end like Elvis and delve into the intricacies of newspaper obituaries and leper colony legends. 01:00 - Laughing At Evan Roberts 04:51 - Ben's Bathroom Superstition 05:56 - Bathroom Hazards And Obituaries

The New York Knicks completed a 22-point comeback to defeat the Cleveland Cavaliers in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals. Discussions cover Jalen Brunson's heroics, Karl-Anthony Towns' mistakes, the Mets' jersey controversy, and a ritual involving an Aztec death whistle. 01:01 - Knicks Comeback Victory 04:51 - NBA Performance Comparisons 09:09 - Mets and Death Whistle

Big Mac breaks down the New York Knicks' improbable 22-point comeback victory over the Cleveland Cavaliers at Madison Square Garden. He praises Jalen Brunson's superstar performance and the crucial coaching adjustments made down the stretch. They also criticize fans who left the game early and address the New York Mets' blunder regarding Gary Carter's jersey number. 01:08 - Knicks Historic Comeback 08:01 - Early Exit Fan Critique 11:51 - Mets Gary Carter Blunder 17:25 - Brunson Performance Analysis 21:31 - Madison Square Garden Chaos

Craig returns from his son's graduation to debate Big Mac on the Knicks' upcoming playoff series against the Cavaliers, boldly predicting a dominant New York victory. They also break down the Yankees' recent win over Toronto and the Mets' extra-innings triumph, focusing on the impact of young stars like Anthony Volpe. Additionally, they discuss Rashee Rice's legal troubles and a plagiarism scandal involving the latest issue of Sports Illustrated.

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the Knicks' upcoming series against the Cavaliers, with Craig confidently predicting a sweep. They also react to news of Rashee Rice serving jail time for a probation violation while debating the consistency of NFL disciplinary measures. Craig shares personal insights on the legal system to provide context for the challenges of probation. 01:19 - New York Baseball Update 05:57 - Yankees and Volpe Performance 14:00 - Handicapping Knicks-Cavs Series 19:45 - Debating Knicks Dominance 24:10 - MSG Game Day Rules 27:42 - Rashee Rice Probation Violation 34:15 - NFL Discipline Debate 44:01 - Final Playoff Series Breakdown

Craig and Chris debate whether the Mets perform better without Francisco Lindor and analyze the current state of the Yankees' lineup. They also dive into the decline of Sports Illustrated following a plagiarism scandal and the history of the legendary Sid Finch hoax. Finally, Chris's sons call in to earn exclusive Looney Tunes team hats by answering team trivia. 01:50 - Mets Performance Without Lindor 04:50 - Viral Mariners Foul Ball Incident 14:38 - Knicks and Cavaliers Series Debate 30:14 - Yankees Catcher and Infield Struggles 36:52 - Sports Illustrated Plagiarism Scandal 46:40 - Portuguese Dining in the Ironbound 01:02:54 - Yankee Trivia With C-Mac's Kids 01:09:19 - Evan Roberts' Performative Scorekeeping

Craig and Big Mac celebrate the news of Gerrit Cole's return to the Yankees rotation as he prepares to face Tampa Bay this Friday. They engage in a heated debate regarding the origin of the baseball term "five and fly" following a clip from a Michael Kay broadcast. The discussion also features an announcement for an upcoming live show at the Salt Shack in August. 01:20 - Wemby Generational Performance 04:40 - Forgotten Sports History 10:35 - Cars For Kids Jingle 15:37 - Rotisserie Chicken Debate 19:39 - SNY Camera Angles 23:46 - Evan Roberts Ticket Pricing 36:36 - Salt Shack Show Announcement 40:14 - Five and Fly Controversy

McMonigle previews the Knicks' Eastern Conference Finals matchup against the Cavaliers and debates the team's chances to reach the NBA Finals. He also analyzes the Yankees' recent hitting woes and explains the situation surrounding Mets prospect Nick Morabito wearing Gary Carter's unretired number eight. 01:01 - Knicks ECF Game 1 Preview 02:23 - Yankees Offensive Struggles 05:13 - Knicks Series Predictions 08:20 - Morabito Wearing No. 8 11:38 - Mets Season Outlook

Did Chris McMonigle invent the baseball phrase “five and fly” or is Craig Carton right that Michael Kay STOLE it from the Carton Show? Craig & Big Mac spiral into an all-time WFAN debate after Michael Kay uses the phrase “five and fly” during a Yankees broadcast, leading to accusations, conspiracy theories, listener calls, Knicks ticket drama, Evan Roberts getting roasted, and complete sports radio chaos.

Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle break down Victor Wembanyama's insane “legacy game,” debate whether the Spurs or Thunder would be a better Finals matchup for the Knicks, and absolutely DESTROY Evan Roberts for planning to score the Mets game during Knicks Eastern Conference Finals action at Madison Square Garden.

Craig Carton surprises Chris McMonigle's sons with exclusive New York Yankees x Looney Tunes hats from Fanatics & New Era… but there's a catch. Before they can take the hats home, the boys have to answer Yankees trivia LIVE on WFAN! From Ben Rice and Anthony Volpe questions to “Uncle Craig” moments and hilarious Knicks/Evan Roberts banter, this turned into one of the funniest and most wholesome Carton Show segments yet.

Craig unloads on Sports Illustrated after the shocking AI plagiarism scandal involving a fake reporter and stolen articles, while C-Mac reacts to the downfall of one of sports media's biggest names. The guys also dive into the legendary Sidd Finch Mets hoax, old-school SI memories, swimsuit issue debates, and somehow end up talking Portuguese steakhouses, Frostys, and Newark food spots.

Craig Carton is DONE with scared Knicks fans ahead of Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals. On this episode of the Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether Knicks fans should actually fear the Cavaliers, argue over Jarrett Allen being “soft,” and clash over whether Mike Brown has already surpassed Tom Thibodeau.

A viral moment at the Mariners game has Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle absolutely DYING on the Carton Show

Craig and Big Mac react to Kansas City Chiefs wide receiver Rashee Rice receiving a 30-day jail sentence for a probation violation. The conversation shifts to the NBA playoffs as Craig expresses total confidence that the Knicks will easily handle the Cleveland Cavaliers. They also recap a record-breaking performance by the Mets. 01:22 - Rashee Rice Jail Sentence 11:32 - Knicks Cavaliers Series Analysis 20:18 - Respecting Dennis Schröder Game 23:01 - New York Baseball Update

Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the Yankees' critical win over Toronto and Anthony Volpe's improved plate discipline. They pivot to a detailed preview of the Knicks-Cavaliers series, with Craig predicting a dominant New York victory. The conversation also covers the Mets' recent surge and Craig's chaotic travel experience returning from Iowa. 01:03 - MLB Recap and Highlights 06:04 - Yankees Defeat Blue Jays 12:30 - Knicks vs Cavaliers Preview 17:42 - NBA Playoff Coaching Analysis 24:08 - Garden Baseball Scorekeeping Debate

The guys break down the highly anticipated Knicks vs. Cavaliers Eastern Conference Finals, debating whether an 11-day layoff or a historic Game 1 hex will derail New York's championship dreams. Plus, they preview the tactical matchups against Donovan Mitchell and map out Evan and Big Mac's upcoming trip to Madison Square Garden.

Following a shocking 9th-inning comeback, we break down the fallout of a dramatic Subway Series, from Tyrone Taylor's miracle home run for the Mets to the Yankees' crushing bullpen collapse. Discover what this massive momentum shift means for both New York franchises moving forward.

Chris McMonigle is NOT happy as he breaks down a nightmare Subway Series finale in which David Bednar blows a ninth-inning save before the Mets take it in extra innings. C-Mac gives the verdict on whether the Yanks are officially in one of their trademark "swoons" (2:50) while sounding off on what he calls the worst loss of the Yankees season so far (8:45). Plus, why the Max Fried update was good news (10:10), a plea to Aaron Boone to stop batting Trent Grisham leadoff (22:00), why Austin Wells has become a MAJOR problem (26:00), and how big of a concern the bullpen has become (35:50).

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Mets' resilient performance in the Subway Series following a major injury to the pitching staff. They evaluate the New York Yankees' bullpen collapse and the offensive struggles of the bottom of the lineup on The Carton Show. Additional topics include the New York Knicks' playoff matchup against the Cleveland Cavaliers and the return of Aaron Rodgers to professional football.

Big Mac analyzes the New York Mets' impressive series win over the New York Yankees, noting how they overcame a significant injury to Clay Holmes. He details the deep-seated issues within the Yankees' bullpen and bottom of the lineup, specifically criticizing Austin Wells and Ryan McMahon. The discussion also touches on potential roster moves involving Anthony Volpe and Jose Caballero as the New York Knicks prepare for the playoffs. 01:33 - Impactful Subway Series Recap 05:30 - Mets Resilience After Injury 11:00 - Yankees Bullpen And Lineup 14:49 - Volpe And Roster Logic 20:25 - Listener Reactions To Victory 25:35 - Journey And Sopranos Finale 30:00 - Yankees Internal Roster Fixes 38:26 - Debating Yankees Bullpen Urgency 45:48 - Clay Holmes Injury Impact

Big Mac critiques broadcaster Joe Davis for what he perceives as a mocking tone during a Mets defensive error. He also shares his vindication regarding the baseball term five and fly before analyzing the Knicks playoff path and Anthony Gallo's engagement. 01:20 - Mets Broadcast Critique 04:40 - Joe Davis Troll Job 11:35 - Five and Fly Vindication 14:45 - Knicks Playoff Route 17:35 - Yankees Bullpen Changes 21:10 - Anthony Gallo Engagement 29:40 - Gerrit Cole Update 32:20 - Subway Series Rivalry 39:00 - Austin Wells Struggles 43:10 - Knicks Cavaliers Preview

Chris McMonigle discusses the news of Aaron Rodgers returning for another season and expresses envy toward Howie Rose for getting to meet Paul McCartney after a Mets game. They also dive into the Knicks' playoff path and the bizarre career pivot of Ben Simmons into professional saltwater fishing. 01:20 - Aaron Rodgers Return 04:34 - Howie Rose Meets McCartney 10:23 - Career Dreams Discussion 15:10 - Knicks Playoff Path 23:03 - Gerrit Cole Update 26:23 - Ben Simmons Fishing 32:23 - Marcus Semien Analysis 37:12 - Yankees Bullpen Worries

Big Mac analyzes the Mets' surprising success in the Subway Series while highlighting the Yankees' recent pitching and roster concerns. They also explore Eli Manning's candid explanation for avoiding the Chargers and discuss Jalen Brunson's legacy as the Knicks prepare for the Eastern Conference Finals. 01:20 - Subway Series Breakdown 06:15 - Aaron Boone Critique 10:35 - Movies And Personal Stories 25:20 - Manning's Chargers Draft Truth 30:43 - Brunson's Knick Legacy 34:21 - Eastern Conference Finals Preview 40:27 - Knicks vs Nets Rivalry

C-Mac analyzes the Mets' recent success over the Yankees and how the series highlighted major issues within the Bronx Bombers' bullpen. He offers a strong defense of Aaron Boone's managerial choices before the conversation shifts into humorous territory with stories of childhood antics and cable bill mishaps. 01:00 - MLB Roster Updates 02:41 - Subway Series Recap 06:08 - Defending Aaron Boone 09:35 - Movie Comparison Debate 15:05 - Cable Bill Stories

While Craig is away Chris & the Crew explore Ben Simmons' transition into professional competitive fishing and his ownership in the South Florida Sails. A caller recounts a chance dinner meeting with Paul McCartney, describing the rock legend's surprising humility and kindness. The discussion also highlights the high-stakes world of elite sport fishing, including Michael Jordan's involvement. 01:00 - Knicks Banners and Fishing 05:51 - Ben Simmons Pro Fishing 10:40 - Meeting Paul McCartney 13:16 - Pro Fishing Tournament Scene

Big Mac is flying solo and discusses the potential return of Yankees ace Gerrit Cole and NBA player Ben Simmons' victory in a professional saltwater fishing league. The segment also covers the Mets' roster adjustments following key injuries and includes listener calls regarding recent performances from both New York teams. 01:00 - Gerrit Cole's Potential Return 05:01 - Mets Roster Moves 12:01 - Bullpen Strategy and Calls

Chris McMonigle and Pete Hoffman analyze Aaron Rodgers' return to the Steelers and the viral story of Howie Rose leaving a Mets game to meet Paul McCartney. They compare the legacy of the 1986 Mets to the current Knicks squad while debating the team's chances in the upcoming series against the Cavaliers. 01:32 - Aaron Rodgers Steelers Return 04:07 - Howie Rose Meets McCartney 13:05 - Knicks Playoff Analysis 19:10 - Caller Accent Banter

Big Mac opens by congratulating Anthony Gallo on his recent engagement and sharing lighthearted wedding planning advice on The Carton Show. They transition to New York Yankees news, discussing roster moves and the anticipated return of Gerrit Cole to the rotation. The segment concludes with an in-depth preview of the New York Knicks' upcoming playoff series against the Cleveland Cavaliers. 01:00 - Anthony Gallo Engagement 07:33 - Yankees Roster Moves 13:40 - Subway Series Analysis 17:38 - Yankees Lineup Changes 21:48 - Knicks Playoff Preview

Chris McMonigle reacts to broadcaster Joe Davis's viral "Oh, the Mets" call, debating whether national announcers are biased against New York teams. They also celebrate Michael Kay's use of the term "five and fly" and evaluate the Yankees' decision to sign Yovanny Cruz to bolster the bullpen. 01:00 - Joe Davis Mocking Mets 08:01 - Subway Series Recap 09:47 - Five and Fly Vindication 13:22 - Knicks Playoff Path 16:34 - Yankees Sign Yovanny Cruz

Chris McMonigle examines the fallout from the Subway Series, noting how the Mets' performance crystallized the systemic issues facing the Yankees. He evaluates the struggles of Austin Wells and the bullpen while discussing potential roster adjustments and the impact of recent injuries. 01:00 - Journey and The Sopranos 03:08 - Mets Sweep Subway Series 09:34 - Yankees Roster and Bullpen 13:07 - The Crystallized Word Debate 19:25 - Mets Injuries and Vibes

Chris McMonigle is riding solo today, discussing the Mets' resilient performance in the Subway Series following a rotation injury. He evaluates the Yankees' bullpen struggles and roster gaps while looking ahead to the Knicks' playoff series against the Cavaliers. 01:03 - Big Mac Flying Solo 01:53 - Mets Subway Series Mojo 10:29 - Yankees Bullpen Meltdown 18:01 - Yankees Offensive Struggles 20:06 - Knicks Vs Cavs Preview