Joe Benigno and Evan Roberts

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Jett Williams and Brandon Sproat, we hardly knew you. But to get a top of the line starting pitcher in Freddy Peralta it's worth it. The Mets also get back Tobias Myers. Is this the final stamp Mets fans have been waiting for this offseason? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Evan isn't in love with the Mets big trade for Peralta, callers react, a look ahead to Championship Sunday, plus a Giant reshaping.

Evan isn't screaming, he's just being honest: he did not celebrate the Freddy Peralta trade. Yes, the Mets are better right now and the rotation finally looks legit, but Evan's main fear is simple: this feels like a one-year rental, and they paid two top-100 prospects (Jett Williams and Brandon Sproat) to do it. That sparks the real debate for Mets fans: what result makes a rental worth it, World Series or bust? Plus, Mets fans flood the phones to defend the move, rip the move, and argue whether Stearns and Cohen are building a sustainable plan or living year to year. And Evan delivers a classic story from MSG, including the rough night as a Nets dad and the even tougher conversation explaining to his son why “Jet” is suddenly no longer a Mets prospect.

Hour 2 starts with the crew wrapping up their MLB Free Agency Bingo board, with only one final name left on the list and plenty of laughs at who nailed predictions like Cody Bellinger and who completely whiffed. Then the conversation shifts into the big-picture question: what do Vegas win totals say about the Yankees and Mets right now, and do those numbers match reality? Evan explains why he would have been far more comfortable paying a premium for an elite like Tarik Skubal than a “really good” Freddy Peralta, and why the “five-inning pitcher” label matters when you are giving up top prospects. Calls pour in debating whether the Mets should push Peralta deeper into games, whether an extension is actually possible, and whether this whole plan is a smart year-to-year build or just living on rentals. Plus: a wild Jets caller tries to “grease the wheels” for a Josh Allen fantasy, the guys roast the sad state of Jets fandom, and a fan checks in with life updates that send the show down an unexpectedly funny path. And to close the hour, the crew dives into pronunciation chaos, including a pitcher clarifying how to actually say his name, and a Drury joke that deserved better timing.

Hour 3 opens with Evan owning his “Nets shocked the world” slip, plus a full recap of the quickest 6–4 hope in sports history as he takes his five-year-old to MSG and watches the Knicks turn it into a crime scene. Then the guys debate whether Tommy is officially a group chat squatter and if the crew should quietly boot him at the perfect time. From there, it's real Giants business: the organization starts clearing out long-time staffers as John Harbaugh puts his stamp on the building, with Tiki explaining how those behind-the-scenes changes actually work and why some “family” staples may not survive this new era. Then the moment of the hour: Andrew Caplan's audio package that proves John Harbaugh and Joe Biden are voice doppelgangers. Once you hear it back-to-back, you cannot unhear it. Plus: Mets fans call in with the perfect word for this offseason, confusion, as the “hope mode” roster debate rages on. And the hour closes with pure Cinco de Lunch chaos as the crew fires off their top five New York starting pitchers lists and immediately starts a civil war over where Peralta, McClain, Rodon, Cole, and the new Yankees arms belong.

The final hour of Evan & Tiki is packed with baseball, football, and classic New York sports banter. Evan and Tiki react to a whirlwind MLB offseason, including the Mets' aggressive moves for Freddy Peralta, Luis Robert Jr., and Bo Bichette, and debate whether Peralta is a risky rental or a long-term building block. The Yankees' decision to retain Cody Bellinger sparks further discussion about roster construction and championship expectations in a Dodgers-dominated league.

The crew opens with a big-picture baseball thought experiment: MLB should invent “Fugazi deadlines” to turn the offseason into a fast, chaotic sprint, because the last week has felt like an NFL-style frenzy. The Mets' entire winter gets compressed into a handful of headlines, from missing on Kyle Tucker to landing Luis Robert Jr. and adding Freddy Peralta, plus the value of getting a controllable arm like Tobias Myers as part of the bigger move. Then the conversation shifts into the real Mets fan experience right now: confusion, nerves, and a growing divide. One side sees the Peralta trade as an obvious upgrade. The other sees a potential rental that cost two top prospects, and says if you do that, you better be serious about keeping him. From there, it becomes a full debate about how “rentals” actually work, with a Mike Piazza comparison, plus the bigger question hanging over everything: can anyone realistically beat the Dodgers. The answer is complicated. The Dodgers might be the best team, but baseball still gives you a shot if you catch the right breaks and play clean, because you cannot afford a single slip against a team that deep.

Championship Sunday can't get here fast enough, and this segment sets the table with a wild, history-flavored nugget: the Broncos are massive home underdogs in a conference title game, a point spread that almost never happens. The crew digs into recent championship games where the home team still got points, including the Nick Foles Eagles and the Peyton Manning Broncos, then lands on the rare example where the home dog actually lost in a tight one. From there, it turns into full sports-radio paranoia: is this a Patriots coronation, or can Denver's altitude, coaching, and a competent Jarrett Stidham performance flip the script. The conversation spirals into what a Stidham win would do to the QB market and whether quarterback-desperate teams would start talking themselves into it by Monday morning. Then the segment swerves into pure show chaos with Cinco de Luncho, featuring a rapid-fire Top 5 starting pitchers in New York and an immediate counter-list that turns into a debate about respect, projection, and whose “ace” is really built for the moment. It wraps with a quick tease that a weird streak ended during Knicks-Nets that's supposedly going to blow your mind.

Listeners noticed it first. Social media confirmed it. And once you hear it, you can never unhear it. The show takes a deep dive into one of the strangest and funniest discoveries of the week: New York Giants head coach John Harbaugh sounds eerily similar to former President Joe Biden. This segment features a carefully produced audio package putting their voices back to back, proving beyond any doubt that they are true voice doppelgängers. No politics, no agendas, just an uncanny comparison that leaves everyone confused, laughing, and questioning who they are actually listening to. The crew reacts in real time, explains how the comparison came together, and breaks down why this might be the most undeniable audio similarity you will hear all year. Once it clicks, it is ingrained forever.

Just days after his introductory press conference, John Harbaugh is already making meaningful organizational changes behind the scenes. Longtime Giants executive Kevin Abrams is out after decades with the team, signaling that familiar names and long standing roles are no longer untouchable. The conversation also highlights the continued presence of Ronnie Barnes, whose role may evolve but whose influence inside the building remains strong. The discussion centers on why these moves matter, how they connect to broader power structure questions involving Joe Shane, and why this level of internal change shows Harbaugh is fully in charge and committed to building a Giants organization that reflects his vision from top to bottom.

The conversation shifts from vibes to numbers as Vegas steps in. Using FanDuel win totals, the guys break down how the Mets and Yankees are actually being viewed heading into the season and the results are eye-opening. The Yankees are still favorites in the American League despite a quiet offseason, while the Mets are suddenly sitting right behind the Dodgers as one of the top teams in the National League. That leads to a deeper debate about roster construction and expectations. Why the Mets trading for Freddy Peralta was a necessity, not a luxury. Why the Yankees passing on him made sense given their rotation depth. And why David Stearns may be closer to finishing his “painting” than fans want to admit. Calls pour in arguing whether a 90-win projection is fair, whether Peralta should be pushed deeper into games, and whether an extension changes everything. Plus, the crew reacts to how tightly bunched the NL really is behind the Dodgers and asks the question Mets fans cannot avoid anymore: if Vegas believes this team is real, do you?

It's late January, almost every MLB domino has fallen, and the crew pulls out the Free Agency Bingo board to see who actually knew what they were talking about. They relive the Cody Bellinger call, admit who got played, and set the stage for the final remaining free agent while arguing about whether trades should even count in the game. Then Evan doubles down on the biggest Mets debate: why paying a premium for “really good” Freddy Peralta is not the same as paying up for a true monster like Tarik Skubal. The “five-inning pitcher” label gets thrown on the table, the Peralta vs Skubal comparison heats up, and the Mets' long-term plan gets questioned again. Plus, the phones go sideways. A Jets caller tries to “grease the wheels” for a Josh Allen trade fantasy, the guys roast how dark it has gotten for Jets fans, and a caller checks in with a life update, a joke, and a Mets reality check that turns into a full-blown offseason therapy session.

The guys boil the Freddy Peralta trade down to one core issue: the Mets improved immediately, but it still feels like a short-term roster with short-term bets. If Peralta is a one-year rental and anything goes sideways, the whole thing can feel like a “temporary Picasso” that gets ruined the second it gets wet. Then the phones light up. One caller thinks the Mets changed philosophy because of media pressure, but Evan pushes back hard and says the front office has actually been consistent all along. That leads into the bigger theme: the Mets' approach to short-term deals, what Bo Bichette's press conference really told you about the plan, and why fans keep asking what “good enough” is when you cash in top prospects. Plus: a debate over the “roadblock” narrative with Jett Williams, what happens if Luis Robert Jr struggles early, and how quickly the Mets would pivot if performance is not there. And it ends with a hard pivot to hoops: the Knicks annihilate the Nets, the “players-only meeting” story gets dissected through Josh Hart's comments, and the real question becomes what the Knicks do next, not what they did to Brooklyn.

Evan makes one thing clear right away: he does not hate the move, but he is not celebrating either. The Mets are undeniably better after adding Freddy Peralta, and the rotation finally looks respectable. The problem is the price. Two top-100 prospects for a pitcher Evan believes is a one-year rental based on the track record of David Stearns. That sparks a deeper conversation about what the Mets are actually building under Stearns and Steve Cohen. Is this a smart year-to-year strategy, or a risky way to live as a fan? Evan lays out why a rental only works if it leads to a World Series run, compares the move to past Mets rentals, and asks fans the real question: what result makes this trade worth it? Plus, a hilarious and painfully real dad moment from Madison Square Garden, where Evan has to explain to his kids both Nets misery and why Jet Williams is suddenly no longer a Mets prospect.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): It finally has happened. The New York Mets have made a trade with the White Sox for center fielder Luis Robert Jr. The Cost? Luisangel Acuna & Truman Pauly. The question at hand now, what took so long? To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

A day full of baseball news including a Mets trade and a breaking Yankee re signing we have been waiting for

The hour centers on what comes next for the Giants now that John Harbaugh is in place, with the spotlight firmly on coordinator hires and staff building. The guys react to Harbaugh's comments about Rex Ryan, debate how realistic a return to the sideline would be after a decade away, and whether Harbaugh's presence changes that equation. From there, it turns into a full breakdown of ideal coordinator fits, including why Harbaugh's credibility gives the Giants access to top tier candidates. Names like Todd Monken, Anthony Weaver, Jim Leonhard, and Antonio Pierce come up as the discussion shifts to scheme, quarterback development, and long term vision. Jets fans also get pulled into the conversation, especially around potential crossover candidates and rivalry tension, as callers weigh in on what a successful Giants staff could look like and why these decisions may define the entire era.

Big Mac storms in with a brutal comp, calling the Mets' Luis Robert Jr. trade the “Anthony Volpi” of moves, and the debate takes off from there. Why are Mets fans still fighting over the offseason, while Yankees fans are somehow… calm? The crew breaks down what the Robert Jr. deal signals about Cody Bellinger, why the Yankees' quiet winter has fans stuck in limbo, and why one announcement could flip the entire New York baseball mood overnight. Then it pivots hard to the Knicks, and the questions get louder: effort, energy, body language, and whether this looks like a team drifting from its coach. From Josh Hart's late-night TV appearance to the bigger issue of urgency, chemistry, and buy-in, the conversation turns into a real temperature check with CP “The Franchise” on what's actually happening and what (if anything) can fix it fast before things get ugly.

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down a wild day in New York sports. The Yankees finally re-sign Cody Bellinger to a five-year deal, bringing relief to Bronx fans after a quiet offseason. The Mets pivot with a Luis Robert Jr. trade, signaling that Cody was never headed to Queens and raising questions about David Stearns' long-term philosophy. Plus, Giants fans continue to buzz after John Harbaugh's official introduction as head coach, Knicks fans grow uneasy amid a slump, and Evan explains why the Yankees could actually be better in 2026 despite the lack of splashy moves. All that and more on WFAN's Evan & Tiki.

As Cody Bellinger edges closer to re-signing with the New York Yankees, we unpack why this move feels more like relief than celebration for Yankee fans. After months of leaked contract numbers, missed backup plans, and a quiet offseason, the expectations in the Bronx have clearly shifted. We discuss how the market dried up, why the Yankees backed themselves into needing Bellinger's bat, and how the bar slowly got lowered from blockbuster dreams to simply “being set.” Plus, an honest look at how the Yankees could still improve without a flashy offseason, relying on internal growth, healthier pitching, and year-two impact from deadline additions. It's a reality check on the Yankees' winter, the psychology of fan expectations, and why January optimism looks very different than it did in November.

Breaking news out of the Bronx as Cody Bellinger is officially re-signing with the New York Yankees. We react in real time to what this move means for the Yankees lineup, the balance of the roster, and how it impacts their plans heading into the season. Is this the stabilizing bat the Yankees needed, or just the first domino in a bigger offseason picture? We break down the contract implications, lineup fit, and how Bellinger's return reshapes expectations in the AL.

CP the Franchise joins the show for a real Knicks therapy session as the losses pile up and the panic meter rises. Is this just the dog days, or is something broken between Mike Brown, Karl-Anthony Towns, and the locker room? CP breaks down what he's seeing on the floor, what he's hearing around the team, and why tonight vs the Nets feels way bigger than it should.

It starts with the absurdity of modern sports news: reporters at an intro press conference, waiting for their phones to light up with the real headline. While fans are tracking every Yankees move (and Mets fans are locked into the latest Mets storyline), the crew questions why teams even stage the big production when one notification can steal the entire spotlight. Then the tone shifts to the Knicks, who suddenly look like a mess: bad effort, bad vibes, and the kind of body language that makes fans wonder if the locker room is fractured or if the team has checked out on the coach. The Josh Hart on Jimmy Fallon debate becomes the lightning rod, with one simple question at the center: should players keep living their lives when the team looks like it's collapsing? From there it opens up to calls, including a Jets fan dealing with furious Buffalo relatives over Sean McDermott being fired, and a bigger Jets dilemma: do you really want to draft a quarterback who's literally suing for another year because he isn't ready? The segment wraps with real worry, real laughs, and the kind of New York chaos that never takes a day off.

The NFL coaching carousel takes another unexpected turn as Mike McDaniel lands with Jim Harbaugh and the Chargers, choosing Justin Herbert over other potential landing spots. Evan, Tiki, and Shaun break down why quarterback fit matters more than anything for offensive minds and why certain franchises remain coaching dead ends. From there, the focus shifts to the Bills' underwhelming head coaching search, Brian Daboll's growing appeal, and whether Buffalo moved too quickly at the wrong moment. The conversation then explodes into draft season chaos, with a deep debate on how far teams should go to trade up for a franchise quarterback, why offensive line concerns should not stop you from taking the guy, and how recent playoff performances change evaluations overnight. The segment wraps with spirited calls, Jets and Giants tension, and a bigger question facing every front office right now: when you believe in the quarterback, is any price really too high?

After sitting down with John Harbaugh for an extended interview, the focus turns to what comes next for the Giants: building the right coaching staff. Evan, Tiki, and Shaun explain why Harbaugh's credibility and coaching tree give the Giants an immediate advantage when it comes to attracting top tier coordinators. The discussion includes Harbaugh's comments on Rex Ryan, how realistic a reunion actually is, and whether time away from the sideline matters. From there, the guys map out ideal coordinator fits, debate innovation on offense and stability on defense, and explain why this phase of the process may ultimately define the success of the Giants more than any single player move.

The conversation takes a sharp turn from today's Mets news into a bigger baseball legacy debate. Evan makes the case that Carlos Beltran has been unfairly defined by one moment, even though he was clutch and deserves Cooperstown. From there, the discussion spills into Andruw Jones and whether his defense alone should make him a Hall of Famer, with Evan calling him the best defensive center fielder he's ever seen and the phones lighting up immediately. Then it gets heated with the cheating and Hall of Fame standards argument. Beltran's Astros ties spark a broader debate about what counts, what doesn't, and why certain players get judged differently than others. The segment ends with a funny detour into real life chaos, then pivots back to the NFL with major coordinator chatter. Dianna Russini's report on Brian Daboll's possible landing spots leads to a bigger question for New York: what would a Daboll move mean for the Giants moving forward, and why Giants fans might actually view this as a sneaky win.

The Mets finally make the move everyone assumed would never happen, acquiring Luis Robert Jr. and forcing a hard look at what this roster is really becoming. Evan, Tiki, and Shaun debate why the trade makes sense defensively, why the upside is real despite two rough seasons, and why the only true risk might be financial. The conversation turns into a deeper breakdown of David Stearns' long term vision, the famous “painting” analogy, and whether this lineup is better, worse, or just wildly different after losing Pete Alonso and reshaping the middle of the field. They dive into Robert's change of scenery potential, the Mets' desperate need for a real center fielder, and how bad last year's production truly was at that spot. Plus, the ripple effect on the Cody Bellinger sweepstakes, why the Mets likely have a short term offer out, and why Yankees fans may feel more confident as the staredown with Scott Boras continues. The big question remains: when you squint at this roster, is the picture starting to come together or does it still feel unfinished?

The Mets finally pull the trigger on the move they've been circling for what feels like forever, landing Luis Robert Jr. and immediately reshaping the conversation around their lineup. Evan, Tiki, and Shaun break down why the deal makes sense even with the obvious red flags: recent struggles, durability concerns, and the price tag. They debate the upside of a true change of scenery in New York, what Robert's defense means for a team that badly needed real center field stability, and why this is a low risk swing with potentially massive reward. Plus, the ripple effect: where does this leave the Mets in the Cody Bellinger chase, and why Yankees fans might be feeling more confident today than they did yesterday as the staredown with Scott Boras continues. The hour also touches on growing buzz around the Giants, adding another major New York storyline to a packed opening segment.

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): The Jets are in a rare spot, there are plenty of head coaching jobs available and they aren't one of them. However, maybe they should be. Follow @HoffWFAN on Instagram, TikTok & X To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Evan and Tiki broadcast live from the Quest Diagnostics Training Center on a landmark day for the New York Giants as John Harbaugh is officially introduced as the franchise's next head coach. The show begins with live reaction from inside the building as the Giants stage the press conference, ownership speaks, and Harbaugh lays out his vision for toughness, culture, and winning football in New York. Across all four hours, the guys react in real time to what Harbaugh said, how he said it, and why it immediately resonated with players, media, and fans. They break down the themes that defined the day, loving football, earning success, winning in the margins, and why Harbaugh felt like a natural fit for the Giants from the start. The show also examines what this hire means for the roster, the quarterback position with Jaxson Dart, the offensive line and run game, and the overall direction of the franchise. The centerpiece of the show is an extended sit down interview with John Harbaugh, where he talks openly about leaving Baltimore, his relationship with Lamar Jackson, how he evaluates modern quarterbacks, what excites him about the Giants' roster, and where things stand with his coordinator search. He also delivers a clear message to Giants fans about pride, identity, and building a team they can believe in again. Joe Schoen also joins the show to explain the coaching search process, why Harbaugh became the clear choice, and how the organization positioned itself to land one of the most respected head coaches in football. The show wraps with full analysis, fan reaction, and perspective on why this day signals a turning point for the Giants, not just in expectations, but in professionalism, preparation, and belief moving forward.

The Giants kick off a new era as John Harbaugh arrives and the guys say the quiet part out loud: this might be the closest thing to a “sure thing” coaching hire New York sports has seen in decades. Live from the Quest Diagnostics Training Center ahead of Harbaugh's introductory press conference, they debate how fast he can flip the culture, what realistic expectations should be for next season, and whether Giants fans should already be thinking playoffs. Then it turns ugly in the Garden. The Knicks get embarrassed again, the boos rain down, and the conversation gets uncomfortable fast: is the Mike Brown and Karl-Anthony Towns relationship already beyond repair? The guys lay out the three options, ride it out, dump KAT, or fire the coach, and explain why none of them feel clean. Plus, fan calls on what Harbaugh means for the Giants and what's actually wrong with the Knicks right now.

Hour 2 opens with a bold prediction: if the Knicks lose to the Nets at MSG, Mike Brown might be gone immediately. The guys debate how quick the trigger could be, what a replacement could look like, and whether the Knicks are at the point where you do something drastic or just pray it magically fixes itself. Then the show pivots back to Giants Day with an early Cinco de Luncho: Shaun ranks the five most exciting Giants moments since Super Bowl XLVI, with Jaxson Dart's arrival, draft night hope, and today's John Harbaugh introduction sitting at the top of the list. The building buzz is real at the Quest Diagnostics Training Center as the press conference gets closer. The calls bring heat on both sides: Knicks fans go in on Karl-Anthony Towns and the locker room chemistry, plus a fascinating Carmelo Anthony clip about KAT's “rabbit ears” and how outside noise can wreck a player mid game. The guys also talk about where the Knicks spiral actually began, what's changed in their style and urgency, and why the vibe feels broken. Finally, the Harbaugh optimism gets its first speed bump when a caller brings up late game coaching decisions and blown leads in Baltimore. The guys discuss coaching shelf life, evolution, and why a fresh start can actually sharpen a coach who's already proven he can win big.

It's John Harbaugh's introductory press conference and the guys react to the biggest themes, the tone, and the energy inside the fieldhouse as the Giants officially turn the page. Harbaugh hits on what matters most, toughness, physical football, “the team” above everything, and a clear message that he wanted this job and believes the Giants can win. Then Giants GM Joe Schoen joins the show and walks through how the hire came together so fast, why the Giants were prepared for unexpected coaching movement, and what made Harbaugh the perfect fit. Schoen breaks down the collaboration he expects with the new head coach, how Jaxson Dart factored into the appeal of the job, and why he believes the roster has enough pieces to keep building quickly. The conversation also gets real about Schoen's tenure, how he grades himself, the pressure that came with the Daniel Jones decision, and why he refused to chase short term fixes at the expense of sustainability. Plus, they touch on roster priorities heading into free agency and the draft, and why the Giants believe they are set up for a legit turnaround under Harbaugh.

Hour 4 is the full reaction to a historic Giants day. The guys break down what John Harbaugh's press conference and interview revealed about who he is, why he wanted this job, and why the “love football” message landed so hard. They focus on the tone, the family element, and how naturally Harbaugh fits with the Giants identity, plus the way he spoke directly to the players in the room. They also debate expectations. Is the goal immediately playoffs, or is the real win simply eliminating the “miserable football” feeling and becoming a consistent, prepared, physical team every week? The conversation turns to what the Giants have lacked in recent years, situational mastery, discipline, and the details that decide close games, and why Harbaugh's track record suggests those issues finally get fixed. There are also quick temperature checks on a few storylines, including why Jaxson Dart was not in the building for the introduction and whether that matters at all, and how Joe Schoen's visibility shifts now that the franchise becomes “the Harbaugh show.” Fan calls pour in with the excitement level through the roof, and the show closes with more reflections on what winning culture actually looks like and what Giants fans should realistically demand next season.

New Giants head coach John Harbaugh sits down with Evan and Tiki right after his introduction and gets into what made this job feel inevitable, why the Giants are an iconic fit, and what he believes the team can become. Harbaugh talks about leaving Baltimore, his relationship with ownership, and the role his family and faith play in how he approaches the grind of coaching. On the football side, he dives into what he saw on tape, why the run game starts up front, and what excites him about the Giants' backfield and offensive line. He discusses Abdul Carter's rookie finish, the importance of physicality, and how he wants the Giants to win in the margins. Harbaugh also explains how he views Jaxson Dart as a modern quarterback who gives an offense options, from RPOs to quarterback driven concepts that stress defenses. Harbaugh updates where he is in the coordinator search, confirms he is meeting with the current staff, and even entertains the idea of reaching out to familiar names from his past. He also shares what he wants Giants fans to feel watching this team, pride, identity, and effort that shows up on tape every week. The interview closes with a few lighter moments, including the early morning workout routine and the competitive edge that comes with a fresh start in New York.

Live from the Giants fieldhouse, the scene is set with hundreds in attendance, current players in the building, and the room going silent as the organization prepares to introduce its next head coach. The guys play a quick prediction game on what Harbaugh will cite first for taking the job, then the moment arrives as Joe Schoen steps to the podium and officially introduces John Harbaugh as the new head coach of the New York Football Giants. Harbaugh's opening remarks hit hard. He makes it clear he wanted the job, embraces the expectations of New York, and lays out a foundation built on toughness, physical football, discipline, and finishing. He emphasizes “team” repeatedly, thanks ownership, and brings the room into his mindset with a message about attacking every day with “enthusiasm unknown to mankind.” In the Q&A, Harbaugh addresses why he didn't take time off, what he likes about the roster, and why he's excited to work with Jaxson Dart. He talks staff building starting immediately, explains what “culture” means in football terms, and even nods to Andy Reid's advice that “change can be good.” The press conference closes with Harbaugh reinforcing that success starts with how the Giants work every day and how they choose to play on tape.

Giants general manager Joe Schoen joins the show fresh off the hiring of John Harbaugh and walks through how the process came together so quickly. Schoen details why the Giants were prepared for unexpected coaching movement, how early research mattered, and why they moved decisively once Harbaugh became available. Schoen also opens up about roster construction, the importance of Jaxson Dart's development, and why the Giants believe their young core made the job attractive. He addresses his own performance as GM, the Daniel Jones decision, resisting short term fixes, and the plan to keep building through free agency and the draft. The conversation closes with roster priorities, staff building, and why Schoen believes the Giants are positioned for a real turnaround under Harbaugh.

Shaun unveils his full Cinco de Lunch countdown, ranking the five most exciting Giants days since Super Bowl XLVI and explaining why today stands above them all. The list revisits moments Giants fans almost forget, like clinching a playoff spot on New Year's Day 2023 and the unexpected thrill of beating the Vikings in the 2022 playoffs, even knowing how quickly things unraveled afterward. The conversation then jumps to recent hope. Draft night optimism with Abdul Carter and Jaxson Dart, followed by Dart's prime time statement game against the Eagles, is framed as a turning point fans will look back on as the night he truly arrived. At the top of the list is today. John Harbaugh becoming the head coach of the New York Giants is declared the most exciting Giants day since 2012, regardless of what he says at the podium. The segment also addresses fair concerns about Harbaugh's late game decisions in Baltimore, with comparisons to Andy Reid and why elite coaches can evolve after a long run in one place. As dignitaries arrive and the building buzz grows, Shaun makes it clear why this moment feels different. For Giants fans, the shelf life starts now, and the optimism is real.

The discussion starts with the surprise firing of Sean McDermott and why, despite his résumé, there has been almost zero immediate interest around the league. The guys explain how teams were already deep into their interview processes, why McDermott's exit from the Buffalo Bills caught the industry off guard, and how playoff consistency does not always translate to hot coaching demand. From there, the focus shifts back to the Knicks and what feels like a deeper problem than wins and losses. Callers and hosts break down the lack of urgency, respect, and cohesion surrounding Karl-Anthony Towns, including frustration with his on court habits and body language. A revealing clip from Carmelo Anthony adds context to the idea that outside noise and “rabbit ears” can derail a player mid game. The segment also digs into where the Knicks slide really began, why New Year's Eve in San Antonio feels like the turning point, and how unresolved locker room tension can quietly snowball. All of it unfolds with a major contrast in the background as anticipation builds at the Quest Diagnostics Training Center, where Giants fans await the arrival of John Harbaugh and a moment that feels stable and hopeful in a New York sports landscape full of chaos.

The segment opens with a bold declaration that if the Brooklyn Nets beat the New York Knicks at Madison Square Garden, Mike Brown could be fired almost immediately. The guys debate how real that scenario is, why this moment feels different from past Knicks slides, and whether ownership is nearing a breaking point with a team that entered the season with championship expectations. The conversation quickly turns into a deep dive on Karl-Anthony Towns, his trade value, his on court frustrations, and the growing belief that he is not respected around the league or even fully protected internally. Callers weigh in on whether dumping KAT actually improves the roster or simply removes a problem from the locker room. From there, the show widens to New York sports big picture talk, comparing this Knicks chaos to past transformational hires like Pat Riley and Bill Parcells, and why those moments mattered. The segment also detours into Jets talk, including why elite coaches gravitate toward stability and quarterbacks, and why the Giants job clearly beat the Jets in this cycle. All of it plays out with one major backdrop looming over the hour: the anticipation building at the Quest Diagnostics Training Center as Giants fans wait to hear from John Harbaugh, with the optimism around the Giants standing in stark contrast to the dysfunction unfolding at MSG.

The Knicks conversation gets grim. After another ugly loss and boos at MSG, the guys lay out the three options facing New York: ride it out, dump Karl-Anthony Towns, or fire Mike Brown. They discuss whether the locker room has quit, why the KAT relationship feels beyond repair, and how stunning it is that this is even the conversation in January.

The Giants officially usher in a new era with John Harbaugh, and for once the conversation is simple. There is nothing to nitpick. Live from the Quest Diagnostics Training Center, the guys explain why this feels like a rare sure thing in New York sports, from Harbaugh's résumé as a Super Bowl winner to his reputation as a culture builder and program stabilizer for the New York Giants.