Joe Benigno and Evan Roberts

The Dolphins make a GM decision that eases Giants fans worries, plus a Football Friday playoff edition with all the trimmings.

The Giants coaching search hits a fever pitch as the show debates why it suddenly feels like John Harbaugh is the one hire that changes everything, and why missing out could trigger a full fan meltdown. Evan and Tiki break down the Dolphins GM curveball, what it means for Harbaugh's options, and why Kevin Stefanski is still a real long-term alternative. Plus, Giants fans call in on ownership, Joe Schoen's role in the search, wild record predictions for next season, and the viral Jaxson Dart lip-reading moment that has everyone trying to decode the future.

Hour 2 starts with the mystery of Evan's pre-recorded question for MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred that never made air, and the behind-the-scenes explanation from Craig Carton on why it got spiked. The guys finally reveal the question, argue whether it was fair or “too much,” and debate Manfred's obsession with a salary cap and the financial gap between big and small markets. Then the conversation turns into full MLB confusion as Manfred talks realignment, geography, and keeping the Mets and Yankees separate, and nobody can quite agree on what he actually meant. Calls roll in to interpret it, while Evan vents about owners crying “unable” instead of “unwilling” to spend. Plus, the show pivots to Wild Card weekend storylines, including how often teams win rematches, and a fun deep dive into Tiki Barber's playoff games where he faced an opponent for the third time in the same season. The hour also touches on the Giants coaching search optics, Evan's choice between banishing Woody Johnson or Rob Manfred, and a Yankees offseason debate about Cody Bellinger's market and whether Brian Cashman should pivot to Bo Bichette.

It's Wild Card Weekend, so we're playing the most dangerous game: who are we selfishly rooting for and why. The guys go matchup by matchup with Jets and Giants agendas all over the place, from hoping Carolina creates Bryce Young doubt (hello, Jets QB options) to rooting for pure chaos in Bears-Packers if it means more coaching openings. They also hit Bills-Jaguars, Eagles-Niners (and the John Harbaugh fear factor), plus the Patriots as the ultimate “please lose” postseason villain. Then it turns into full New York sports radio perfection: Cinco de Luncho takes over, Evan's brain gets exposed, and the crew reacts to the Saquon Barkley billboard shot at Giants fans on I-95. Hour 3 also dips into Knicks/Wizards draft-pick drama, Giants coordinator continuity talk (Kafka, Dart development), and a college QB watch that turns tonight's game into a Jets scouting mission. Key moments: rooting-interest power rankings, Giants coaching search circus, Saquon billboard outrage, Cinco de Luncho, and the phones lighting up with callers.

Hour 4: Could Trinidad Chambliss be the Next Jets QB? WFAN Jeopardy Controversy

The Mets choose not to hold FanFest, and the optics could not be worse. The guys break down why skipping a fan event makes the organization look scared of its own fans, especially when there is nothing new to celebrate. Outside of modest moves, nothing about this roster feels better than it did months ago, and fans can feel it. The conversation then pivots to the New York football picture, including Antonio Pierce emerging as a legitimate sleeper candidate in the New York Giants head coaching search if it is not John Harbaugh or Kevin Stefanski. From there, the show spirals into classic chaos, Cinco de Lunch energy, Wild Card Weekend rankings, draft obsession, quarterback scouting madness, and the brutal reality that most fans watch sports through selfish rooting interests. It is part Mets frustration, part Giants coaching intrigue, and part unhinged Friday sports radio at its finest, with food debates, cheese takes, and playoff chaos layered on top.

The guys kick off Wild Card Weekend by laying out their “selfish rooting interest” list, where Jets bitterness, Giants coaching paranoia, and pure chaos all collide. It starts with Rams-Panthers and a very specific agenda: hope Carolina's Bryce Young doubt grows just enough to create more QB options for the Jets, while also keeping the Panthers from becoming a real future threat. Then it turns into Bears-Packers, where personal grudges (Ben Johnson), weather talk, and the dream of a coaching-search circus take center stage. If the Packers lose, does it crack open another job and send the league into full-blown coach chaos? That's the debate. They hit Bills-Jaguars with the “maximum pain” theory for Buffalo fans, plus the Harbaugh ripple effects in Eagles-Niners, before the segment swerves into the Saquon billboard drama that feels like a direct shot at Giants fans. The back half includes Knicks-Wizards draft-pick paranoia, Giants OC continuity talk (Kafka and the Dart development angle), and a mini debate on why you can't blindly trust AI without fact-checking.

Evan explains how he was promised a chance to ask Rob Manfred a question on the air, only to have it pulled at the last second for being “too disrespectful.” The show finally reveals the question about a salary cap, debates whether it crossed the line, and argues if it would have forced a real answer from the commissioner. Craig Carton explains why it never aired, while Tiki Barber compares his version of a Manfred question to how it was actually asked on the show. The segment then spirals into total confusion when Manfred discusses MLB realignment, geography, and keeping the New York Yankees and New York Mets out of the same division. Evan and Tiki try to decode what he actually meant, whether MLB is moving toward an East vs West conference model, and why the explanation left more questions than answers. The segment wraps with listener calls, World Baseball Classic timing debates, and breaking news that Ketel Marte is not being traded after weeks of rumors.

Evan takes the unpopular stance with Jets fans: you can't fire Aaron Glenn after one season just to take a blind swing at John Harbaugh, especially when Harbaugh isn't committing to anybody and might even consider taking a year off. That's why Schefter's reporting matters, and why the Dolphins were able to play it differently since they were already on the fence with Mike McDaniel. The conversation then flips back to the Giants, where the urgency is real, the fan base is locked onto one name, and the stakes feel enormous if ownership can't close the deal. Calls roll in on whether Mara and Tisch need to directly recruit Harbaugh, what Joe Schoen's role really is, and why being “Harbaugh or bust” might be unfair, but also totally inevitable.

The Giants coaching search has reached the point where it feels like one name is towering over everyone else: John Harbaugh. Evan explains why this has become a “massive disappointment” situation if the Giants don't land him, even if the replacement is a proven coach like Kevin Stefanski or Mike McCarthy. Tiki pushes back with a reality check: Harbaugh could want a break, he might not want a rebuild, and nothing is guaranteed. The big question becomes simple: are Giants fans being reasonable… or is this officially turning into Harbaugh or heartbreak?

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The offseason is extremely slow moving. Even with it dragging, it feels like the direction is not going the right way for Mets fans. Evan takes you through all the latest rumors and where the Mets stand. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Tiki is back and prefers Stefanski to Harbaugh. Mike McDaniel gets fired in show leading to more Harbaugh speculation.

Hour 1 kicks off with the Giants coaching search heating up fast. With names like Bill Belichick floating out there, Tiki Barber drops a stunner: he'd lean Kevin Stefanski over John Harbaugh. The guys debate QB development, offensive upside, and why building the right staff might matter even more than the head coach. Plus, the “sure thing vs bust factor” argument, Harbaugh's coordinator track record, and the one concern that could change everything: does Harbaugh still have the fire for a full rebuild in New York?

Hour 2 opens with some off the rails concert and weekend planning before the show snaps back to Giants business. The guys react to Joe Schoen basically bragging about how “cheap” the Giants' core is, and debate if that's smart roster building or a quote that could annoy his best players. Then it turns into full Harbaugh madness: why the Giants can't assume anything, what factors really drive a coach's decision, and the conflicting reports from the league's biggest insiders on what actually happened in Baltimore. Plus, the Joe Schoen question hangs over everything, fans fear it could cost the Giants Harbaugh, and the crew makes official date and time predictions for when the Giants finally hire their next head coach. They wrap with Belichick talk, skepticism about his “I'm happy at North Carolina” line, and a larger debate about age, perception, and whether one recent coaching flop changed the market for older legends.

Hour 3 spirals fast as the guys revisit their preseason Super Bowl predictions and realize just how wide open and chaotic this playoff field really is. Updated picks get bold and uncomfortable with Jacksonville, Seattle, and Buffalo all in the mix, while trust in the NFC completely collapses. The conversation shifts back to the Giants coaching search, fan fear over “settling” for Kevin Stefanski, and Rex Ryan questioning whether Stefanski belongs in the elite tier. Tiki pushes back with a strong case for crisis management and leadership in New York. The hour ends with a full Northeast parent meltdown when the crew learns school may start before Labor Day, triggering boycott talk, PTA outrage, and an all time relatable rant.

The 4th and final hour of the Evan & Tiki Show

The crew debates the one question every baseball fan would want to ask Rob Manfred. The conversation dives into the widening financial gap in Major League Baseball, whether teams like the Los Angeles Dodgers are exploiting the system, and why a true salary cap could blow up the sport all over again. From fears of another labor war to the idea that would hit New York fans hardest, the possibility of the New York Yankees and New York Mets eventually sharing a division, this segment breaks down what really matters, what Manfred will never say out loud, and why one honest answer could change baseball's future overnight.

Parents officially lose it after learning New York schools are starting before Labor Day. Evan, Tiki, and Shaun react in real time to the calendar shocker, threaten a full-scale parent boycott, and argue why the Northeast has one sacred rule you do not break. The conversation spirals into vacation chaos, NFL timing, snow days that never happen, and why this decision feels like a direct attack on families who plan their lives around that final summer week.

The crew revisits their preseason Super Bowl predictions and quickly realizes how wrong almost everyone was, highlighting just how wide open and chaotic this playoff field feels. Buffalo, Philly, Baltimore, Kansas City, and Green Bay all get put under the microscope as old picks get roasted and eliminated. From there, the discussion pivots to bold updated predictions, with Jacksonville, Seattle, the Rams, and Buffalo emerging as trendy and uncomfortable new favorites. The segment closes with a heated Giants coaching debate, as fans panic over the idea of Kevin Stefanski being the answer, Rex Ryan openly questions his résumé, and Tiki fires back with a strong defense centered on crisis management and surviving dysfunction in New York.

The guys put their reputations on the line by predicting the exact date and time the Giants' next head coach will be reported by Schefter or Rapoport, not the press conference, the real breaking news moment. From there, the conversation swerves into a brutal reality check on Bill Belichick. Is the greatest resume in NFL history suddenly irrelevant? They dissect why the phone might not be ringing anymore, how Pete Carroll's one and done stint changed league perception, and why age suddenly feels like a bigger factor than anyone wants to admit. Then it turns into a wide ranging debate on Harbaugh vs McCarthy, playoff failures, coaching “stench,” and whether history actually matters when hiring a Super Bowl caliber head coach.

What starts as a lighthearted detour into concert plans and feeling old quickly turns serious once Joe Schoen's latest comments hit the table. The guys debate whether Schoen basically admitted the Giants' best players are underpaid and if that kind of honesty helps roster building or risks irritating the locker room. From there, the conversation pivots back to John Harbaugh and why his decision may come down to far more than roster strength, including lifestyle, geography, and even old family ties to Cleveland. The segment heats up with conflicting reports from Ian Rapoport and Adam Schefter on whether Harbaugh truly lost the Ravens locker room, and Tiki explains why both sides can actually be true. The hour closes with mounting fan anxiety that retaining Joe Schoen could cost the Giants their dream coach and shape the narrative around this hire no matter how it ends.

The coaching carousel gets even crazier when Mike McDaniel suddenly becomes available, and the guys immediately frame him as a potential offensive coordinator jackpot, not the Giants head coach. They break down why his scheme is so “nerdy” and QB friendly, why Jaxson Dart could benefit from that kind of detail and precision, and why Stefanski and Harbaugh still sit in a different tier as head coach options. Plus, the conversation swings into the staff building obsession, the Dolphins emerging as a real Harbaugh threat, and the chaos theory: when an upgrade appears, teams start firing coaches just to get in the race.

Tiki Barber doubles down on his surprising stance in the Giants coaching debate, explaining why Kevin Stefanski edges out John Harbaugh for him. The discussion centers on QB development, staff building, and long term upside versus the comfort of a proven track record. The guys dig into Stefanski's “boost factor,” Harbaugh's elite résumé, concerns about burnout, and why the Giants may need hunger and fire as much as experience in their next head coach.

Hour 1 opens with a wild thought experiment: what if the Giants coaching market gets even crazier, with longshot names like Sean McVay or Matt LaFleur potentially entering the mix? With Shaun Morash filling in for Tiki, the show debates the core question every Giants fan is wrestling with: do you strike fast for John Harbaugh, or stay patient and let the full “historic” coaching class reveal itself? Evan argues the Giants cannot afford a waiting game where they lose Kevin Stefanski while hoping Harbaugh doesn't pick a more playoff-ready “mystery team.” The conversation turns into a full breakdown of urgency versus patience, Rooney Rule logistics, and whether the Giants should have been interviewing candidates weeks ago to get a true head start. Then it gets even messier: Jets fans start dreaming about firing Aaron Glenn for a tiny shot at landing Harbaugh, leading to a heated debate about realism, desperation, and whether a “secret backchannel” is the only way to even find out if a coach would consider the job. The hour wraps with a spirited caller segment, resume comparisons (Harbaugh vs McCarthy), and a preview of a deep dive into why some Ravens fans turned on Harbaugh in recent years.

John Harbaugh's playoff résumé compared to the Giants' last 20 years sparks a brutal reality check, then the guys break down why Ravens fans actually turned on him. From big-game failures and conservative decisions to staff loyalty and late-season fades, every criticism gets aired out. Plus, a surprise contender emerges as a real threat in the Harbaugh sweepstakes with Cleveland entering the picture, fueled by deep family ties and an all-time White Castle honeymoon story. Calls pour in on whether Harbaugh would even choose the Giants, how much money should matter, and whether Joe Schoen helps or hurts New York's case.

Hour 3 focuses on the latest reporting around John Harbaugh and whether Joe Schoen will actually factor into the Giants coaching decision. With early indications that Schoen is not a roadblock, the conversation centers on power dynamics, long term control, and why Harbaugh would immediately become the unquestioned voice in the room for the New York Giants. The hour then turns to intense debate and caller reaction on what happens if the Giants miss on Harbaugh, whether first time head coaches are even sellable to the fan base, and why this hire feels different than recent searches. It all builds to a heated on air showdown over Kevin Stefanski, complete with audio receipts, arguments over playoff wins, and a real time dispute about honesty, framing, and taking accountability on the air.

FULL SHOW: John Harbaugh is exactly what the Giants have been looking for, Evan gives the pros and cons of Harbaugh as an HC, Connor Hughes joins the show, Cinco De Lunch-O, and much more.

Hour 4: Connor Hughes Talks Harbaugh Sweepstakes, Shaun's Hat, and More on the Coaching Carousel.

Connor Hughes joins the show to deliver a deep dive into why momentum is building toward John Harbaugh becoming the next head coach of the New York Giants. Connor explains why the process will take time despite clear interest, how the Rooney Rule factors into the timeline, and why Harbaugh has quickly separated himself from the rest of the field. The conversation digs into the power dynamic between Harbaugh and Joe Schoen, whether ownership would reshape the front office to land a proven coach, and how Harbaugh's presence would immediately change decision making inside the building. Connor also addresses competition from other potential openings, why the Giants are viewed as the most desirable vacancy, and whether candidates like Kevin Stefanski remain realistic alternatives. The interview wraps with expectations if Harbaugh is hired, from short term win projections to long term culture change, and Connor ultimately makes his call that all signs point toward Harbaugh and the Giants coming together sooner rather than later.

Edward Cabrera is off the board, and not to the Yankees. With Ken Rosenthal reporting the Cubs land the hard-throwing righty, the conversation shifts to what this means for New York's offseason plan, why Cabrera made sense as a target (upside, velocity, control), and why the Cody Bellinger situation might be clogging up every other move. From there, it turns into a bigger picture Yankees debate: how badly do they really need another starter, what kind of trade is coming next, and what happens when the rotation logjam hits in May. Plus, the show veers into peak chaos with Harbaugh countdown talk, tanking jokes that can get you in trouble, and an all-time “take the L” moment as Sean gets called out on the Stefanski playoff win debate.

The Giants coaching search takes center stage as early reports suggest Joe Shane will not be a roadblock if John Harbaugh seriously considers the job. The discussion breaks down why Harbaugh would immediately hold the power in the room, how this hire could future proof the organization even if Shane is gone in a year, and why fans view Harbaugh as a rare no bust option. The conversation also spins into classic WFAN chaos with on air debates, caller reactions, awkward office stories, and plenty of laughs along the way.

Everyone assumes John Harbaugh choosing his next job is a straight Giants conversation, but there is one team that keeps popping up as a legitimate surprise contender. The Cleveland Browns. The guys break down why Cleveland should not be dismissed, digging into the Harbaugh family's deep personal ties to the city, including stories passed down through Jim Harbaugh that reveal just how strong that emotional connection really is.

The numbers are staggering. John Harbaugh has won at least one playoff game in nine different seasons with the Baltimore Ravens, while the New York Giants have managed playoff wins in just ten seasons across the entire Super Bowl era. The guys dig into what that gap really means, how often Harbaugh has hosted playoff games, and why Giants fans are still dreaming of a January home playoff tailgate. The conversation then shifts to why Ravens fans turned on Harbaugh, breaking down the biggest criticisms from playoff failures and late game decision making to staff loyalty and late season collapses. Are those flaws deal breakers, or just the normal baggage that comes with any long tenured successful coach? Plus, a candid debate on whether Harbaugh is truly the best possible answer for the Giants right now, and why even elite resumes always come with real concerns.

The coaching carousel turns into chaos as the conversation shifts from the Jets to the Giants and back again. Should the Jets really consider firing a first year head coach just to chase a slim chance at landing John Harbaugh? And if money is the only leverage, would Woody Johnson have to make him the highest paid coach in NFL history to even listen?

The Giants are caught between temptation and patience as the coaching market heats up. Evan and Shaun debate whether chasing John Harbaugh is worth the risk of losing Kevin Stefanski, and why this search could turn historic fast. Desire, panic, and power plays collide as the New York Giants try not to blow the biggest hire of the decade.

Evan opens a chilly Tuesday in NYC with Shaun Morash filling in for Tiki, and it immediately turns into a full-blown Giants coaching search argument. Is Kevin Stefanski the clear best option for Big Blue, or is he being overrated because the other candidates feel like bigger risks? Evan and Shaun go back and forth on Stefanski's résumé, the red flags, and why fans are split between “safe hire” and “dream hire” as names like Mike McCarthy, Brian Flores, and other coordinators get dragged into the debate. Then the conversation shifts to the New York Knicks after another ugly loss and a stretch of sloppy, low-effort basketball. Are the warning signs real, or is this just a January lull that good teams go through? Plus: a preview of what's coming later in the show, including reaction to James Dolan's appearance with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle, and hearing from Aaron Glenn and Darren Mougey.

Hour 2 starts loose and gets weird fast before settling back into serious Giants talk. Evan, Shaun, and Tiki explain why they were standing during the show, joke through an awkward cold weather discussion, and set the table for a packed hour. The focus quickly turns to James Dolan's in studio appearance, breaking down what stood out from his answers on the Knicks and Rangers. Dolan saying Leon Rose can overrule him sparks a real conversation about ownership, power, and trust, while his patience with Chris Drury frustrates Rangers fans and draws comparisons to the Giants sticking with Joe Schoen. From there, the Giants coaching search takes over again. Callers debate Kevin Stefanski versus Mike McCarthy, defensive minded hires versus offensive development for Jaxson Dart, and whether keeping Schoen could cost the Giants their top coaching choice. The Knicks slump, Trae Young trade rumors, and draft pick implications also get mixed in before the hour takes another sharp turn with an unforgettable Boomer Esiason massage story that completely hijacks the show.

Hour 3 centers on the question Giants fans actually want answered: why Joe Schoen is still the general manager. Evan and Shaun react to Schoen's press conference and replay his explanation for keeping the job, then rip apart the idea that the Giants have merely “stubbed their toe.” The discussion turns into a blunt breakdown of accountability, ownership patience, and whether Schoen is underselling just how bad things have gone. The hour also dives into whether Jaxson Dart should have any input in the next head coaching hire. Schoen's dismissive answer sparks frustration, with Evan arguing that listening to your young quarterback does not mean handing him the keys. The guys explain why ignoring Dart's perspective sends the wrong message about development, leadership, and the future of the franchise. From there, the Giants coaching search opens back up. Kevin Stefanski, Mike McCarthy, Rex Ryan, Bill Belichick, and surprise candidates all come up, with a focus on who the Giants are most likely to hire rather than who fans want. Callers weigh in on dynastic ownership, why bad owners only fix things by accidentally hiring the right person, and whether the Giants should slow the process in case a major name becomes available. The hour ends with classic show chaos, including Jets misery comparisons, Olympic hockey arguments, media access stories, and a reminder of the hard truth of fandom: you scream, you argue, and then you hope you are wrong.

FULL SHOW: Evan and Shaun debate if Kevin Stefanski is the right hire as the new Giants Head Coach. Plus, reacting to Mougey and Glenn's press conference, Yankees offseason talk, Bill Belichick is not a legitimate HC candidate for the Giants, the Knicks have looked lifeless since the NBA Cup, and much more.

Hour 4: Darren Mougey & Aaron Glenn Speak but Did They Say Anything?

Evan and Shaun listen to Aaron Glenn and Darren Mougey meet the media and react in real time, pausing after each answer to break down what was actually said… and what wasn't. The Jets leadership promises to “exhaust every option” at quarterback, but the follow-ups (or lack of them) leave a lot hanging in the air. They debate whether the Fields signing was a clear mistake, why Glenn keeps hijacking answers meant for Mougey, and how much confidence fans should have in this staff's ability to develop a young QB. Plus, the guys kick around potential defensive coordinator candidates (including a big name idea), question the bold “we can be competitive next year” claim, and point out why Jets talk always seems to turn into motivational slogans instead of real substance.

Time for Cinco de Lunch-o the show turns into a full-blown vent session for New York football fans. Evan and Shaun rank the five figureheads fans should be most furious with, starting with the Giants' defensive mess and ending with the most infuriating answer of all: how the Giants can justify bringing Joe Schoen back. Along the way, they debate whether Aaron Glenn's “tough guy” approach should matter, and why Jets ownership keeps making the job feel impossible. Then the show pivots into baseball with a hilarious MLB free agency bingo update where everybody whiffs on where Murakami would land. That leads into Evan's frustration with the Mets and Yankees seemingly passing on a perfect fit from Japan, and why the price tag makes it even more annoying. The segment closes with a surprisingly honest conversation about being a sports fan: you scream, you vent, and then you're forced to live with whatever your team does. Plus, a quick dive into early 2026 win totals and why Mets fans might have to accept an “86 wins is fine” mindset on January 6. Finally, the phones bring the chaos, including coaching takes, a Nets trade detour, and an all-time moment with a “17-year-old” caller who is definitely, absolutely, totally not cutting school.