Joe Benigno and Evan Roberts

This week's Jets highlights include Craig Carton calling Dante Moore's decision to stay in college a blessing for Gang Green, while Evan Roberts rips that opinion. Plus, Craig is dreaming for Mike Tomlin to be the coach in 2027, and Tommy Lugauer says these playoffs should be a wake-up call for the organization.

This week's Mets highlights include all the reactions to Kyle Tucker signing with the Dodgers, and what it could mean for the future of baseball. Plus, instant reactions to New York's pivot of signing Bo Bichette to a three-year deal.

The Giants and John Harbaugh are close to finalizing a deal to make him their new head coach and Boomer & Gio are ecstatic for the franchise. Plus, Boomer & Gio on the behind-the-scenes action on how the Giants wined and dined Harbaugh (17:51); Evan & Tiki on why Harbaugh is a franchise-altering moment (25:49); Craig Carton and C-Mac have differing reactions to Harbaugh (43:38); C-Mac and Craig on why this hire feels different (1:09:03); Evan and Tiki on what it says about the Giants that Harbaugh chose them (1:24:44).

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): 4 years and $240 million dollars. The Los Angeles Dodgers have done it again. Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram, TikTok To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

A Football Friday is filled with a Mets roller coaster that starts sad, got happy with Bichette signing in show. Plus the Rangers warnt heir fans again.

Tiki tries to keep it calm, Evan absolutely does not. Kyle Tucker is officially a Dodger, and the anger is not just about losing the player, it's about how the Mets ended up stuck with no clear direction again. Evan breaks down why the Mets' offer was real, why being “close” never matters against L.A., and how the Dodgers treat the luxury tax like pocket change. The conversation quickly turns into a full Mets identity crisis. No Pete Alonso, no obvious pivot, and spring training right around the corner. Calls pour in debating whether Tucker could survive New York, why stars keep choosing the Dodgers, and how the Mets are supposed to compete with Philly and Atlanta. Plus Evan drops a full conspiracy theory on Rob Manfred, MLB, and why the Dodgers dominating the sport might be exactly what the league wants.

With Kyle Tucker off the board, the Mets are staring into the void and Evan lays out why Cody Bellinger is not a realistic “panic buy,” even with rumors of the Yankees sitting around five years and $160M. If the Mets wouldn't go long for Tucker or Alonso, why would they suddenly cave to Scott Boras? Then the debate turns into the uncomfortable part: what's the actual pivot? Evan pitches a wild, short-term, mega-AAV idea for Bo Bichette that's basically a Tucker-style offer to blow him away, get an opt-out, and take another swing at free agency before 30. The problem: where does he play, and how much run prevention are you willing to sacrifice to get a real bat? Tiki pushes back on the defensive domino effect, the “versatility” trap, and the weekly second-guessing Mets fans would live through. The guys kick around the alternatives (including a one-year Eugenio Suárez power play), plus why pitching still has to be the priority no matter what. And of course, the segment ends with the same challenge: if you hate the plan, tell us a better one.

The show comes to a screeching halt with legitimate breaking news as the Mets land Bo Bichette on a three-year, $126 million deal, and Evan immediately reminds everyone he called the pivot before it happened. Evan and Tiki react in real time to the signing, the massive AAV, the opt-out structure, and what this move says about how David Stearns is operating in the market. They break down where Bichette fits defensively, why third base appears to be the early plan, and how much offensive ground this actually recovers after losing Pete Alonso and Kyle Tucker. The guys debate the risk of one-year and two-year opt outs, the surprising draft pick cost, and whether this is a necessary concession in today's marketplace. Plus, what this move means for Philadelphia after reportedly agreeing to a long-term deal, how Toronto now pivots, why Cody Bellinger still does not make sense for the Mets, and whether this finally changes the tone of a chaotic Mets offseason. Live calls, instant reactions, and a full breakdown of how the roster and expectations shift after the biggest move yet.

The final hour of Evan & Tiki is packed with New York sports chaos. Evan, Tiki, and Sean react to the Mets' stunning pivot to Bo Bichette after missing on Kyle Tucker and officially closing the door on Pete Alonso. Giants fans remain on John Harbaugh watch as contract details drag on, while the guys debate what his leadership would mean for Big Blue. The hour takes a sharp emotional turn with the Rangers' brutal Friday letter signaling a reset, sparking an all-time rant from Sean. Plus, Yankees offseason questions, AL East power rankings, NFL Divisional Round picks, and plenty of passionate fan calls to close out a wild Friday on WFAN.

The discussion opens with the moment Mets fans still argue about. Pete Alonso's defensive mistake that altered an entire season and still hangs over his departure. Now the reality is unavoidable. Pete Alonso is gone, and the New York Mets are moving in a completely new direction. That direction comes into focus with the addition of Bo Bichette, a bold pivot after missing out on Kyle Tucker. The guys break down why the Mets moved fast, how Bichette reshapes the lineup, and why this roster feels unfamiliar from top to bottom. The bullpen is just as different, with Edwin Díaz out and Devin Williams stepping into a high pressure closer role. From the lineup to the ninth inning, this is a new Mets identity, and everyone is about to find out if that change actually works.

The Mets sign Bo Bichette, and immediately the word panic starts flying. Evan explains why the money is not the panic at all. The Mets were ready to spend even more on Kyle Tucker, and short-term premium contracts are clearly part of the plan. The real concern is the opt-out. Giving up draft pick compensation for a player who could walk after one season feels less like free agency and more like a deadline rental, something David Stearns has historically avoided. The conversation turns into a deep debate on whether one year of elite talent is worth the risk, how past Mets contracts like Carlos Beltrán shape fan perspective, and why even a move everyone likes can still carry a subtle sense of urgency. The guys also dive into roster ripple effects, including what this means for Brett Baty, the Mets' trade flexibility, and how the upcoming CBA could impact Bichette's opt-out decision. Mets fans and Yankees fans both weigh in as New York's baseball balance of power continues to shift.

The show spirals immediately. A little Giants contract paranoia. A little Mets panic even while liking the move. Absolute chaos in the booth as the phones light up, voices overlap, and Cinco energy takes over. Then it turns into a full rooting guide for the NFL playoffs. From old grudges to fresh annoyances, the guys count down the five easiest teams to root against this weekend. Rams, Broncos, Bills, Patriots, Seahawks, nobody is safe. Along the way there's Giants coaching intrigue, Sam Darnold discourse, backup quarterback nightmares, and a reminder that New York fans never forget. Plus, the Mets land Bo Bichette while Kyle Tucker bolts for the Dodgers, setting up a massive day for both New York baseball teams. Loud, unhinged, and extremely opinionated.

Evan and Tiki react in real time to the breaking news that the Mets have signed Bo Bichette, finally answering the biggest question of the offseason. After weeks of debating pivots, desperation, and whether the Mets would actually pull the trigger on a major bat, the move is real. They break down why the Mets chose Bichette, what it says about David Stearns and Steve Cohen, and how this signing fits into the bigger picture after missing out on Kyle Tucker. The guys debate where Bichette plays, how much the bat changes the lineup, and whether this move actually closes the gap with the league's elite. Plus, immediate fan reaction, instant expectations, and the real pressure this puts on the rest of the offseason.

It turns into an all-Rico day as Evan's Kyle Tucker meltdown spills into the newsroom, the breaks, and basically the entire show. From there, the guys pivot to a throwback clip of Steve Cohen admitting he wants the Mets to model themselves after the Dodgers, and why that gap still feels massive beyond the farm system. Then the conversation swings to how Tucker's decision can ripple to the Yankees with Cody Bellinger, including why Toronto suddenly looms as a real threat if they are willing to throw big years and money around. And because it's New York sports radio, the segment closes with a true courtroom drama: Evan's infamous “Edwin Díaz re-signed” line versus Craig Carton's “I believe” Kyle Tucker guarantee. Who committed the bigger sports talk felony, and can “I believe” really save you when you were ready to take credit if you were right?

Evan lays out why Cody Bellinger is simply not a realistic option for the Mets, even with the Yankees reportedly sitting around five years and $160 million. If the Mets refused to go long-term for Kyle Tucker or Pete Alonso, why would they suddenly cave to Scott Boras now? The discussion turns to what desperation would actually look like, why David Stearns and Steve Cohen are unlikely to abandon their principles, and why relying on the kids may be the real outcome if no clean pivot exists. The guys also agree that pitching should be the priority regardless, and explain why even missing on Tucker does not mean the Mets are about to hand out contracts they do not believe in.

Evan unloads a full conspiracy theory: Rob Manfred is not mad about the Dodgers dominating baseball, he's thrilled. The idea is simple and terrifying. Let the Dodgers keep stacking stars, let fans scream “baseball is broken,” and then use that outrage to win the PR war for a salary cap the players will hate. Tiki buys it immediately, even as they admit it still might never work. From there, the focus snaps back to the Mets problem that keeps getting louder: they can “try” for Tucker, but where's the backup plan? A caller compares Cashman's quick Soto pivot to the Mets dragging their feet, and the guys dig into the bigger issue: Stearns will spend huge AAV, but refuses to go long term, which kills half the market. Then it turns into pure show chaos: Free Agent Bingo standings, Knicks misery, and Mets fans roasting the offseason, including a fake “Mets fan” troll call and the return of the “chomping at the bit” debate right before Evan teases a pivot plan that does not include Cody Bellinger.

Kyle Tucker's $240 million deal with the Dodgers sparks a loaded fan debate. Calls flood in on whether Yoshinobu Yamamoto or Garrett Crochet is the better arm, and why the Mets came up short on both. Evan and Tiki break down what it really takes to beat the Dodgers in negotiations, why “being close” never works, and how absurd offers are now the baseline. The conversation turns emotional as Mets fans wrestle with a brutal question: did they dodge a bullet with Tucker, or was this another missed opportunity that only hurts because it feels familiar? There's a deep dive into New York pressure, why stars thrive in L.A., and whether elite free agents truly want the Mets or just cannot say no to the Dodgers. By the end, one thing is clear: there are only a few teams at the top of the market, and right now, everyone else is playing catch up.

The news Mets fans feared becomes reality as Kyle Tucker chooses the Los Angeles Dodgers over the New York Mets. Evan reacts with raw frustration, breaking down why this one hurts even though the Mets made a massive and legitimate offer. Tiki Barber explains why the Dodgers always win these battles, how their financial edge changes everything, and why no one should be surprised. The conversation turns from Tucker to the bigger picture as Evan questions the Mets' offseason direction, the failure to replace Pete Alonso, and what the real pivot is with spring training approaching. Is this anger really about Tucker, or about the position the Mets have put themselves in? Plus a Winston Churchill inspired rally cry, and a brewing conspiracy involving MLB and Rob Manfred. A must listen for Mets fans trying to figure out where this team goes next and whether there is still a path to contention.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The Mets up their offer to 4 years on Kyle Tucker. The only good news about Ranger Suarez not signing with the Mets is he's out of the NL East! Plus more news. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

We have full reaction to the news of John Harbaugh taking the Giants job as Head Coach. Plus, The Kyle Tucker rumors continue to swirl.

John Harbaugh to the Giants feels like the rare “everyone wanted him and you actually got him” moment, and the guys dive into why this hire is different from the team's recent coaching cycles. They also give Joe Schoen credit for building a roster and drafting Jaxson Dart in a way that made the job appealing enough for Harbaugh to skip other interviews entirely. Plus, the phones light up with fans debating Harbaugh vs. McCarthy, the “can a coach win a Super Bowl with two teams” question, and whether anyone owes an apology to ownership. Then the show pivots to a brutal Knicks loss, a Brunson ankle scare, and why the effort level (especially from KAT) had everyone boiling.

The guys go down a fascinating New York sports rabbit hole: how often does a coach or manager arrive here already owning a championship, and how rarely it actually turns into a title in New York. They land on Weeb Ewbank as the lone example of someone who won before coming to a New York team and then won again here, framing just how unique the John Harbaugh moment is for the Giants. Then the phones roll with Harbaugh hype, expectations for Year 1, and early buzz about what his staff could look like, including chatter around Todd Monken. The segment also takes a detour into classic New York fan trauma, comparing “can't miss” celebrations (Nets Big 3, Rodgers to the Jets) to why the Giants situation feels different. And of course, the Jets can't stay out of it: Dante Moore going back to school sparks a full blown debate about options, draft pressure, and what the organization should do at quarterback next.

From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): Hoff explains his issues with David Stearns and how he's playing too many games during this off-season. Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram & TikTok To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

With a real head coach now in place, the entire Giants conversation shifts from “hope” to “expectation.” The guys debate what the floor actually is in 2026: simply a winning season, meaningful football in December, or a flat-out playoff mandate. They also dig into the reality of the NFC landscape, the pressure on Joe Schoen now that the “big hire” is done, and why some fans are setting the bar high while others are preaching patience. Plus, callers weigh in on whether this feels like a true turning point, and why Harbaugh should inspire more confidence than past “winning coaches” like Dan Reeves.

It's a wild day in New York sports. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to the Giants hiring John Harbaugh as their next head coach and break down what it means for Big Blue moving forward. Plus, the guys dive deep into the Kyle Tucker sweepstakes, debating the Mets' reported short-term mega offer versus Toronto's long-term deal, whether Tucker is worth $50 million per year, and what decision makes the most sense for both the player and the Mets. Giants history, Mets roster construction, Yankees crossover fallout, and plenty of classic Evan & Tiki banter all in one jam-packed segment on WFAN.

The Mets are reportedly in with a massive short-term offer for Kyle Tucker, while Toronto looms with long-term security and the Dodgers lurk as a wildcard. The guys debate the core question every star free agent faces: take the absurd annual payday and bet on yourself, or lock in a decade of guaranteed money and never look back. They dig into whether Tucker is truly worth Juan Soto-level money, the risks of overpaying on a short deal, and why a ten-year commitment feels dangerous for the Mets. From roster construction to championship ceilings to quality-of-life considerations, this turns into a full breakdown of what Tucker should do, and what the Mets should be willing to live with if they miss out.

Cinco De Luncho takes center stage as Evan, Tiki, and Shaun rank the five greatest games ever played at the old Giants Stadium. From iconic playoff blowouts to unforgettable regular season moments, each list sparks debate, nostalgia, and plenty of arguing over what truly belongs in the top five. The conversation weaves through legendary wins, painful losses that shaped championships, and personal memories from the field and the stands. A full-on Giants history lesson with strong opinions, laughs, and classic sports radio chaos.

The Giants finally have a real head coach, and everything feels different. Evan, Tiki, and Sean debate how much the John Harbaugh hire should immediately raise expectations in Year 1. Is a winning season the floor, or is it fair to expect playoff contention right away? The guys dive into what this move means for Joe Shane, how tough the NFC really is, why meaningful football in December matters, and whether Giants fans should aim high or stay patient. One thing is clear: the bar has officially been raised in New York with John Harbaugh now leading the franchise.

A passionate debate erupts over tanking, fandom, and what fans are actually supposed to root for in September and October. The guys argue whether it's ever acceptable to cheer for losses, how draft position really changes franchises, and why fans should never be told to embrace losing. The conversation spills into Giants optimism under John Harbaugh, Jets misery, long term expectations, and whether New York sports fans are finally allowed to believe again or if that's just asking to get burned.

A full blown Jets meltdown after Dante Moore decides to return to college. The guys debate why Moore staying in school actually hurts the Jets by taking options off the board, killing trade down possibilities, and increasing pressure on the front office to get quarterback right. What starts as a simple prediction check quickly turns into a heated argument about draft philosophy, organizational competence, and whether Jets fans are actually celebrating being saved from themselves.

The guys break down a wild stat that makes the John Harbaugh moment feel even bigger: the Giants almost never bring in a head coach who already has a Super Bowl on his resume, and across New York sports it's surprisingly rare to land a proven champion and have it translate into titles here. That leads to the Weeb Ewbank deep dive as the lone example of a coach who won elsewhere and then won again with a New York team, plus a rapid fire debate over which sports even “count” in the conversation. Then the callers take over, mixing Harbaugh euphoria with classic New York superstition, including one fan reaching for “Giants were first to do this” trivia and the show pushing back with a simpler point: Harbaugh means consistent competence, yearly playoff contention, and eventually a real shot at a title. The segment also hits on 2026 expectations with Jaxson Dart entering Year 2, and why this feels different than other “can't miss” New York celebrations like Aaron Rodgers to the Jets or the Nets superteam. The message is basically this: even if it doesn't immediately end in a parade, Harbaugh can still be the turning point that drags the Giants out of the mud for the long haul.

John Harbaugh did not just take the Giants job. He chose it. The guys explain why Harbaugh skipping other interviews is such a powerful signal about where the New York Giants are headed, and why this hire stands apart from past coaching cycles. They also dig into how Joe Schoen's roster build and the drafting of Jaxson Dart helped make the Giants the most appealing destination on the board. From past misses to present momentum, this is the clearest case yet that the Giants finally got it right.

The New York Giants finally land the coach everyone wanted. The guys break down why John Harbaugh choosing the Giants over every other opening is such a massive statement for the franchise, and why this cycle feels different from the last decade of misses. They also explain how Joe Schoen deserves real credit for building a roster and drafting Jaxson Dart in a way that made the job irresistible for a Super Bowl winning head coach. From coaching failures of the past to why this move feels like a true turning point, this is why Giants fans have every reason to believe again.

Kyle Tucker watch is underway while John Harbaugh finally leaves Maryland for Blue Sky's.

The Mets offseason is at a tipping point, and Kyle Tucker is the one move that could change the entire mood. Evan and Tiki debate why Tucker would “save” the winter, why the Mets' only real edge is money, and how David Stearns' short-term, high-AAV philosophy is shaping everything after losing Pete Alonso. Then it turns into a wild New York sports morning: John Harbaugh meets with the Giants, fans call in on Tucker vs pitching help (Suarez, Valdez, Giolito), and the guys hit the Yankees' under-the-radar Ryan Weathers trade before circling back to the big question: who's the Mets ace right now? Chapters 00:00 Kyle Tucker “saves” the Mets offseason 03:20 Mets vs Dodgers vs Blue Jays and what actually matters 06:25 Trusting Stearns, roster “maybes,” and the first base frustration 14:00 Giants news: John Harbaugh meeting and the Tisch plane buzz 18:30 Calls: Tucker vs Suarez/Valdez, plus the rotation anxiety 35:15 Yankees add Ryan Weathers, then Giolito and the Mets “ace” debate

The Giants finally get their face-to-face with John Harbaugh, and the debate turns into a full blown strategy session: is it better to go first and try to close immediately, or go last and land the final pitch? The guys size up the competition from Tennessee and Atlanta, including why both spots are way more appealing than fans want to admit. Plus, Ravens owner Steve Bisciotti's brutally honest press conference becomes must-listen audio, from Harbaugh's next move to Lamar's role in the coaching search. Then the show hits a whirlwind of calls on everything from Brian Daboll's next stop, the Jets' draft options and quarterback chaos, to what a “successful” Mets offseason even means and why Kyle Tucker suddenly feels like a must.

The Athletic's Ian O'Connor joins Evan and Tiki with the latest on the John Harbaugh meeting and why the Giants appear to be leading the race. Ian explains what today's sit-down really means, why the face-to-face time with Joe Schoen matters most, and what Harbaugh is looking for when it comes to roster power and the quarterback plan. Then the conversation widens to the other suitors, including why Atlanta and Tennessee might come to Harbaugh instead of the other way around, plus the one “looming” team that could still complicate things. Ian also gives his current odds on Harbaugh landing with the Giants, and why money will not be the issue. Finally, it turns to Aaron Rodgers and what comes next, including the possibility of Minnesota, a fascinating GM “word salad,” and what it all signals about the Vikings' quarterback direction. Oh, and yes, the show also finds time for an all-time Cinco de Lunch moment: the “salmonella vs semolina” bread confusion goes fully off the rails.

In this 4th and final hour of the show, Evan accuses Chris McMonigle of a crime against his fanhood and all hell breaks loose. Also more on the John Harbaugh front.

A full on courtroom breaks out on the show when allegations surface that coworker Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle coached his kid's flag football team… as the Eagles… while wearing Kelly green. Sean serves as prosecutor and lays out the case for why a real Giants fan should refuse the Eagles assignment, rename the team, and never chant “Go Eagles” under any circumstances. Big Mac storms in to defend himself, arguing it was a league issued NFL Play 60 shirt, not real fandom, and that being a good dad matters more than jersey politics. The debate escalates into fantasy football hypocrisy, coaching fashion solutions, and Tiki delivering the final verdict: guilty. Evan agrees, says he would never wear the rival gear himself, and Big Mac leaves branded with the scarlet letter of a convicted sports fan manatee whenever he steps into their territory.

A casual idea for tomorrow's Cinco turns into a full blown argument when Evan and Tiki start debating the best games ever played at old Giants Stadium. Evan plants his flag on the Jets beating the Bengals in the final game at the building, Tiki roasts him for treating a glorified preseason as history, and the whole thing spirals into condescension, yelling, and an all time “I hope Harbaugh leaves” line. Then the Cinco de Lunch-o aftermath keeps rolling: Sean gets publicly assigned the show's “L” on YouTube for the semolina vs salmonella disaster, the chat piles on, and a caller solves Evan's late night PB&J problem in two seconds by diagnosing the real culprit: refrigerated peanut butter.

Cinco de Lunch officially pivots away from football for the first time as Evan unveils his Top 5 Sandwiches of All Time and the studio immediately turns it into a food debate. The guys rank an Italian hero, grilled cheese, grilled chicken with roasted peppers and mozzarella, PB&J, and a turkey club, plus they argue the eternal question: does adding bacon change the name of the sandwich? It all peaks with an all time slip when “semolina” bread becomes “salmonella” bread live on air, leading to a full on correction, laughter, and a reminder of what you definitely do not want on your lunch.

Veteran New York reporter Ian O'Connor joins Tiki and Evan to break down the most pivotal day in the New York Giants coaching search. O'Connor explains why the Giants are firmly out in front in the pursuit of John Harbaugh, why New York's quarterback situation gives them an edge over Atlanta and Tennessee, and how today's meeting could determine whether this saga ends quickly or drags on. Plus, why there is effectively no true Plan B, what could cause hesitation, and why this hire would be the biggest the Giants have made in decades.