Joe Benigno and Evan Roberts

The hosts of WFAN react to the biggest storyline of the Giants' preseason game against the Vikings: second-year QB Jaxson Dart making yet another visit to the medical blue tent for a concussion evaluation. Evan and Tiki say perception is not necessarily reality when it comes to Dart's concussion history, while Craig GOES OFF on John Harbaugh.

The Mets destroy the Nationals in a three game series. Another sweep in the Month of August! Everything is clicking for the New York Mets. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Paul Rosenberg debate Jaxson Dart's tendency to wind up in the NFL's infamous "blue tents," the Yankees' survival, why Evan isn't buying the Mets hype, and whether or not Cade Klubnik looked like a real NFL quarterback in the preseason.

Jaxson Dart has already been sent to the blue medical tent six times, putting him just one trip behind Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen for their entire careers. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Dart's playing style is the real problem or whether NFL spotters are treating the Giants quarterback with extra caution. They break down the hit against Minnesota, Tyrone Tracy's missed block, Dart's belief that he is being targeted, and why these interruptions could become a serious problem once the regular season begins. The conversation also turns to the Jets after Cade Klubnik's brief preseason opportunity. Evan comes away intrigued and frustrated that Aaron Glenn gave the rookie only two drives, while Tiki explains why the Jets may not want to create an unnecessary quarterback controversy with Geno Smith.

Jaxson Dart's repeated trips to the blue tent are becoming impossible to ignore, with Evan Roberts arguing the Giants need clarity on their young quarterback by Thanksgiving. Tiki Barber explains why Dart still needs live reps and how the new coaching staff can help determine whether he becomes New York's long-term answer.

Jaxson Dart's second season could define the Giants' future at quarterback. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how much progress Dart must show, why year-two improvement is so important for franchise quarterbacks, and whether comparisons to Josh Allen and Eli Manning strengthen the case that New York should know exactly what it has by season's end. The Giants also bring in Najee Harris for a visit, raising questions about Tyrone Tracy and the running back room. Plus, Kodai Senga's surprising bullpen success creates a new Mets debate, Joe Burrow's future in Cincinnati comes under scrutiny, Cade Klubnik flashes for the Jets in the preseason, and Tommy John's remarkable legacy sparks a Hall of Fame conversation.

Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Paul Rosenberg close out Monday's show by debating Jaxson Dart's future, talking about scoring baseball and why Evan threw up at a Mets game,

The Mets are red hot, but Evan Roberts still refuses to call them a playoff contender. Tiki Barber sees reasons for optimism heading into a huge series against the Padres, while Evan insists the Mets remain a bad team on a hot streak until they get within seven games of a playoff spot. The debate also turns to whether Andy Green could earn the Mets' permanent managerial job with a strong finish. Plus, Evan defends his stance on Jaxson Dart, arguing that by the end of Year 2 the Giants should know whether they truly have their franchise quarterback.

Jaxson Dart's second season remains the defining question for the Giants. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Dart can prove he is a true franchise quarterback, how much a new coaching staff should matter, and why clear improvement is essential after watching quarterbacks like Josh Allen and Drake Maye make major Year 2 jumps. Joe Burrow's long-term future in Cincinnati also comes under scrutiny, while the Jets' young quarterbacks create preseason intrigue. Tiki reveals he'll run the New York City Marathon, Evan makes a bold prediction about Fernando Mendoza's first NFL start, and the conversation closes with Tommy John's extraordinary impact on baseball and whether his unique legacy belongs in the Hall of Fame.

Najee Harris is visiting the Giants, and the timing immediately raises questions about Tyrone Tracy and New York's confidence in its running back room. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the Giants are sending Tracy a message or simply protecting themselves with another proven option. The conversation then shifts back to Jaxson Dart and the pressure surrounding his second season. Evan argues that franchise quarterbacks usually reveal themselves by Year 2, while Tiki points to the development and playmaking ability Dart still needs to show. Plus, Josh Allen and Eli Manning comparisons fuel the debate, and Kodai Senga's surprising success in the Mets bullpen starts to create a legitimate closer conversation.

Jaxson Dart's second season could define his future with the Giants. Evan Roberts argues that history gives young quarterbacks very little time to prove they are true franchise players and says New York should know the answer on Dart by November. Tiki Barber stresses how much coaching and scheme will matter, especially as the Giants build an offense around what Dart does best. The conversation also turns to Odell Beckham Jr.'s push to make the Giants roster. Tiki liked what he saw in Beckham's preseason return, but with a crowded receiver room and special teams value working against him, OBJ still has plenty to prove before securing a spot.

Jaxson Dart's repeated trips to the blue tent are becoming a real concern for the Giants. Evan Roberts points to six evaluations in 13 games and argues that the pattern cannot continue once the regular season begins, while Tiki Barber pushes back on the idea that Dart should have been pulled from the preseason game after taking a hard hit. Tiki also agrees with Shaun O'Hara's criticism of Tyrone Tracy for blowing a protection assignment and failing to pick up his quarterback afterward. Plus, the debate turns to Dart's long-term future, with Evan arguing the Giants should know by November whether their young quarterback is truly the franchise answer.

Jaxson Dart's repeated trips to the blue medical tent have Giants fans wondering whether every big hit is about to become a problem. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the NFL is being overly cautious with Dart, whether he needs to get up faster after contact, and why comparisons to Tua Tagovailoa still go too far when Dart has only been diagnosed with one concussion. The calls turn into a broader argument about how physical football is supposed to be. Tiki explains why tough training camps matter, breaks down Tyrone Tracy's missed protection that led to Dart getting drilled, and pushes back on the idea that every violent-looking hit should automatically trigger panic. Evan also admits football is the one sport he has absolutely no desire to pretend he could play.

Cade Klubnik got only two preseason drives, but it was enough to leave Evan Roberts intrigued and wondering why Aaron Glenn pulled him so quickly. With Geno Smith sitting out because of an ankle issue, Klubnik showed enough against Tampa Bay to separate himself from Bailey Zappe and Brady Cook, even if Evan is not ready to call for a change at starter. Tiki Barber explains why giving Klubnik too much preseason runway could create an unwanted quarterback controversy if the rookie starts building momentum. Evan still believes Geno is the better option to open the season, but if the Jets spiral later in the year, Klubnik could quickly become the quarterback everyone wants to see.

Jaxson Dart has already been sent to the blue medical tent six times, just one fewer than Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen over their entire careers. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber agree the frequency is impossible to ignore, but they push back on comparisons to Tua Tagovailoa because Dart has only been diagnosed with one concussion.

Boomer Esiason and Gregg Giannotti discuss the earl portion of the Giants schedule and if they can have a strong start to the season. Plus: -Shaun Morash dishes on how badly he needs the Giants to beat the Cowboys Week 1 -Tiki Barber and Shaun on what Jaxson Dart must show in Year 2. -Craig Carton shares his concerns about the Giants depth to Chris McMonigle -Craig and C-Mac on why Giants fans are expressing concern over Matt Nagy -Boomer & Gio on if John Harbaugh can continue his preseason success with the Giants

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle were live from Jets training camp this week, speaking at length with Aaron Glenn, Darren Mougey, Breece Hall, and others about the upcoming season and what changes have been made to turn the franchise around. Plus, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate if the Jets should pick up the phone and see if J.J. McCarthy is available.

Boomer and Gio believe Yankee fans take their team's success for granted, especially given where the team stands right now amid several injuries to key players. Plus, Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber debate if Jazz Chisholm Jr. should be benched so Luis Garcia Jr. can play second base when the team is at full strength, while Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss how Giancarlo Stanton will be handled when he returns, as he takes a next step toward being cleared to play.

The trade deadline is over, the season is pretty much over, so what do we do as Mets fans? Hit the mailbag! In the lates episode Evan answers YOUR emails. P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Jaxson Dart should play against Minnesota, but only if the Giants protect him with their starting tackles. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they break down what Dart must show in Matt Nagy's offense and why this preseason opportunity matters. The Jets need David Bailey to flash immediately, especially with Giants rookie Orville Reese creating an unavoidable comparison across town. Plus, Odell Beckham Jr. enters a fascinating fight to keep his NFL career alive, the Giants' wide receiver and cornerback rooms face major questions, and Cade Klubnik gets a chance to prove the Jets have something behind Geno Smith.

The Titans already have New York's attention after an ugly preseason showing from Cam Ward and former Giants corner Cor'Dale Flott. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and they explain why Tennessee's struggles only crank up the pressure on the Jets to win Week 1. With Flott getting beaten repeatedly and Garrett Wilson waiting in the opener, the Jets could have a matchup they need to exploit. Shaun and Tiki also debate Geno Smith's leash, what Cade Klubnik must prove in the preseason, and why Aaron Glenn's defense could determine whether the Jets finally show real progress. Plus, Shaun argues Yankee Stadium is getting shafted by MLB's All-Star Game rotation, and the guys question why Giants legend and Hall of Famer Harry Carson still hasn't had his number retired.

Darius Slayton's drops have Shaun Morash worried that the Giants will once again learn the hard way they cannot trust him in the biggest moments. Tiki Barber sees another possibility, explaining how Tom Coughlin forced him to fix his fumbling issues and why John Harbaugh could have a similar impact on Slayton's technique and focus. Shaun also unloads on Jerry Jones and declares the Cowboys are going nowhere near the Super Bowl, while the Yankees' lineup creates another major debate over Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Luis Garcia Jr. Plus, Tiki and Shaun revisit unforgettable New York preseason moments involving Victor Cruz, Lawrence Taylor, Jason Sehorn, Mark Sanchez and Aaron Rodgers.

Aaron Glenn could be trapped by the Jets' biggest weakness. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and they debate whether an elite defense can save Glenn if Geno Smith and the offense fail to score enough points. With the Jets potentially forced to win on the margins, every game could become part of the evaluation of Glenn's future. The Yankees also face a looming October lineup problem. Jazz Chisholm's struggles against lefties spark a debate over Luis Garcia Jr., Giancarlo Stanton, Trent Grisham and how Aaron Boone can keep his best bats in the lineup. Plus, the Giants' running back situation, Cade Klubnik's opportunity, J.J. McCarthy speculation, Tiki's rookie encounter with Christian Peter, and the return of football tailgates at MetLife.

The first fooooootbaaallllll friiiiidaayyy of the year! Shaun and Tiki break down the first preseason games for the Jets and Giants, David Bailey's debut against the Buccs, the Giants biggest concerns and a whole lot more.

The Jets may be better off resisting the urge to chase another quarterback and simply letting this season play out. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber debate whether J.J. McCarthy would really solve anything, why Aaron Glenn's future complicates the quarterback picture, and how the Jets' three first-round picks could make next year's draft the cleanest path to finding their future at the position. Cade Klubnik also gets a chance to create some optimism with a big preseason performance. Plus, the return of football at MetLife brings a heated tailgate food debate, Geno Smith and Odell Beckham Jr. jerseys make a comeback, and the crew celebrates another edition of Idiots with Idioms.

Jazz Chisholm's struggles are creating a major Yankees lineup problem, especially against left-handed pitching. The debate turns to whether Luis Garcia Jr. needs to take over at second base and whether Aaron Boone must start experimenting now instead of waiting for October. That could mean Giancarlo Stanton returning to the outfield, Trent Grisham sitting, or Jazz losing playing time to keep the Yankees' best bats in the lineup. Plus, Spencer Jones' future gets debated, the Giants' running back situation comes into focus, and Aaron Glenn's ability to survive another losing Jets season may depend on just how dominant his defense becomes.

Luis Garcia Jr. is forcing the Yankees into a difficult lineup decision, and Shaun Morash believes Aaron Boone cannot let Jazz Chisholm Jr.'s feelings stand in the way. If the Yankees get healthy, Garcia's bat has to remain in the lineup, which could mean preparing him for second base before the postseason instead of waiting until it is too late. Tiki Barber and Shaun also revisit some of the wildest preseason moments in Giants and Jets history, from Victor Cruz's breakout and Lawrence Taylor's legendary mic'd-up performance to devastating injuries involving Jason Sehorn and Mark Sanchez. Plus, the Giants' cornerback depth becomes an urgent concern after missing out on Terry and Arnold.

Darius Slayton's costly drops remain impossible for Shaun Morash to ignore, even with a new Giants coaching staff in place. Tiki Barber explains why John Harbaugh could be exactly what Slayton needs, drawing on how Tom Coughlin forced Tiki to completely change his ball-security habits and become a better player. Shaun makes it clear that Slayton's reputation and contract cannot protect him if the mistakes continue, while Tiki argues that focused coaching and relentless technique work can still change a veteran's game. Plus, Shaun takes aim at Jerry Jones and dismisses the Cowboys' latest Super Bowl expectations before the show dives into memorable New York preseason moments.

Yankee Stadium keeps getting passed over for the MLB All-Star Game, and Shaun Morash has had enough. With future host cities lining up and the current stadium getting older, Shaun argues it is ridiculous that baseball still has not brought the Midsummer Classic to the Bronx. Tiki Barber agrees the continued wait is becoming harder to explain. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as the conversation also turns to another New York sports oversight. A caller asks why Giants legend and Hall of Famer Harry Carson has never had his number retired, leading Tiki and Shaun to question how one of the franchise's greatest players has remained overlooked.

The Titans looked so bad in preseason that Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber are already raising the stakes for the Jets' Week 1 opener. Cam Ward struggled badly, Cor'Dale Flott was getting beaten in coverage, and Tennessee suddenly looks like a team the Jets simply cannot afford to lose to. Garrett Wilson could have a major opportunity if Flott's issues carry into the regular season. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they also debate Geno Smith's leash and what Cade Klubnik needs to show in the preseason. If the Jets stumble early, could Klubnik become a real option, or would turning away from Geno only create more chaos?

Cade Klubnik has a real opportunity to make the Jets rethink their quarterback plans, but Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber agree he has to earn it. Geno Smith remains the safer choice for Aaron Glenn, especially with so many young offensive pieces whose development could suffer if the rookie quarterback isn't ready. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they also dive into the Giants' biggest preseason questions. Orville Reese has fans dreaming about a return to the franchise's physical linebacker identity, while Colton Hood gets an important early test in a cornerback room filled with uncertainty. Plus, the Jets' tight ends could give their offense a major matchup advantage.

Jaxson Dart should play in the Giants' preseason opener, but Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber agree it needs to be a real dress rehearsal with his starting tackles protecting him. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki as they lay out what they need to see from Dart and why simple quarterback competency matters more than flashy highlights. For the Jets, David Bailey enters the spotlight with enormous expectations and an inevitable comparison to Giants rookie Orville Reese. Cade Klubnik also gets a major opportunity behind Geno Smith. Plus, Odell Beckham Jr. fights for a roster spot in what could be his final NFL chance, while questions surround the Giants' wide receiver depth and Malik Nabers' health.

Mets can't win their third series in a row, but do find a way to take the season series against the Braves. High Five! P.S. T-Shirts are back on sale if you want to buy one.... or two! https://breakingt.com/products/the-rico Please like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: ⁠⁠https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrogna⁠⁠ Email TheRicoB@gmail.com

Shaun Morash hosts solo and is suddenly buying back into the Yankees. After another stirring comeback, he argues this team feels different, with George Lombard Jr. and Spencer Jones injecting life into the lineup while Trent Grisham and Ryan McMahon heat up around them. The frustration with Brian Cashman's deadline remains, and Morash warns that Spencer Jones could still become the odd man out when Cody Bellinger returns. The Giants create an entirely different debate as John Harbaugh addresses the possibility of adding Terrion Arnold. Morash says that if the Giants' background work and the NFL's plans leave a realistic path for Arnold to play, the secondary is too vulnerable for New York to simply walk away. Malik Nabers' Week 1 outlook also gets a boost, while Jayden Daniels gets blasted for the terrible optics of fighting LSU over another quarterback wearing No. 5.

The Yankees suddenly look alive, and Shaun Morash is buying back in. After another dramatic comeback and a surge fueled by George Lombard Jr. and Spencer Jones, Shaun argues this team feels different from the stale Yankees of recent Octobers. The pitching remains dominant, struggling bats are waking up, and the Bronx has rediscovered its energy. Shaun hosts while Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber are away and explains why a healthy return for Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton and Cody Bellinger could make the Yankees a legitimate World Series threat. He also tackles the looming Spencer Jones roster crunch, whether New York can still chase down Tampa Bay, concerns about the bullpen, and Major League Baseball's maddening TV maze. The next big test is whether this momentum survives once the Yankees' stars return.

The Giants should sign Terrion Arnold if their background work clears a path for him to play. Shaun Morash argues New York cannot afford to take the moral high ground while winning organizations routinely gamble on talented players with serious off-field concerns, especially with the secondary looking like the Giants' biggest weakness. Talkin' Giants co-host Justin Penick joins Shaun and agrees the NFL is not a morality league, though he stops short of viewing Arnold as an automatic starter. Shaun also looks ahead to the preseason opener, from Malik Nabers trending toward Week 1 to Odell Beckham Jr.'s anticipated return to the field, Deonte Banks' critical test and Arvell Reese's growing hype. Plus, Jayden Daniels gets ripped over his LSU No. 5 dispute, and the Yankees' young surge gets another look.

Craig Carton gets confronted over the studio mystery nobody wanted solved: who was clipping their nails at work. After the evidence points directly at Craig, he jumps in to defend himself while Shaun Morash unloads on what he calls one of the grossest possible workplace habits. The confrontation quickly spirals into a hilarious debate over whether clipping nails in the studio is actually worse than Shaun's preferred method of doing it on the toilet. From movie theater food to secret drive-thru eating habits, Craig and Shaun turn an ugly discovery into a wildly entertaining argument about personal boundaries, food, and disgusting routines.

Craig Carton gets called out after Shaun Morash discovers nail clippers and nail remnants in the studio, leading to a hilarious confrontation over Craig's workplace grooming habits. Craig admits there may have been some trimming during a commercial break, but he refuses to accept Shaun's outrage without firing back.

Spencer Jones and George Lombard Jr. have injected life into the Yankees, and Shaun Morash believes the young stars may be helping revive a season that had become increasingly frustrating. Lombard's rise up the order and Jones' production have created a playoff-like energy at Yankee Stadium, even as Shaun remains furious with Brian Cashman and skeptical about how the roster will be handled.

Talkin Giants co-host Justin Penik joins Shaun Morash to break down the biggest questions facing the Giants before their preseason opener. The conversation starts with Terrion Arnold, as Justin explains why NFL teams remain fascinated by former first-round talent and why Arnold would still have to earn a starting role if the Giants sign him. Justin also lays out what he needs to see from Odell Beckham Jr. to justify a roster spot, whether Deonte Banks can finally turn camp buzz into real production and why Arvell Reese has him so excited. Plus, Shaun and Justin dig into the kicker competition and the under-the-radar offensive and defensive linemen worth watching.

The Giants should sign Terrion Arnold if their background work gives them a legitimate path to put him on the field. Shaun Morash argues New York cannot afford to take the moral high ground when other NFL contenders routinely gamble on talented players with serious off-field concerns. With the secondary looking vulnerable, Shaun says there should be virtually no excuse for the Giants to pass if Arnold can help them win. Shaun also reacts to John Harbaugh's revealing comments about the Giants doing extensive homework on Arnold and explains why another team will sign him if New York does not. Plus, Malik Nabers continues trending toward Week 1, and the Yankees' youth movement with George Lombard Jr. and Spencer Jones sparks a bigger reflection on Aaron Judge's championship-less decade.

The Yankees' biggest problem may soon be figuring out who actually plays. Shaun Morash explains why the returns of Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton and Cody Bellinger could create a brutal lineup crunch, especially with Spencer Jones and George Lombard Jr. forcing their way into the conversation. Shaun believes Jones has shown enough to deserve a major role and argues the Yankees may even need to consider unconventional October lineups to keep their best bats on the field. Shaun also refuses to give up on the AL East despite Tampa Bay's surge, pointing to the Yankees' remaining head-to-head opportunities. With the Bronx energized by its young players and the pitching staff built for a short series, he sees a legitimate path to a deep postseason run.