Joe Benigno and Evan Roberts

Follow Joe Benigno and Evan Roberts
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

Benigno & Roberts

Radio.com


    • Feb 5, 2026 LATEST EPISODE
    • daily NEW EPISODES
    • 37m AVG DURATION
    • 12,092 EPISODES

    4.3 from 896 ratings Listeners of Joe Benigno and Evan Roberts that love the show mention: wfan, joe and evan, cmb, craig carton, boomer and carton, ny sports, loving the show, listening to joe, mets, sports radio, posting, afternoon, welcome back, best show, unbelievable, sports talk, saturday, station, new york, breakdown.


    Ivy Insights

    The Joe Benigno and Evan Roberts podcast is a must-listen for sports fans looking for engaging and entertaining sports talk. With the dynamic duo of Joe Benigno and Evan Roberts, this podcast offers a unique blend of passion, insight, and humor that keeps listeners hooked from start to finish.

    One of the best aspects of this podcast is the chemistry between Joe and Evan. They have a natural rapport that shines through in their discussions and banter. Whether they are talking about the New York Mets or breaking down the latest NFL game, their back-and-forth adds an enjoyable dynamic to the show. Additionally, their passion for sports is infectious, making it easy for listeners to get caught up in the excitement.

    Another highlight of this podcast is its versatility. While it primarily focuses on sports, Joe and Evan aren't afraid to venture into other topics when there isn't much happening in the sports world. This allows for a more well-rounded listening experience that appeals to a wider range of interests.

    However, one potential downside of this podcast is that it may not appeal to those looking for strictly sports-focused content. Some listeners prefer podcasts that solely focus on analyzing games and teams without any extraneous discussions. While Joe and Evan do provide insightful analysis, they also incorporate humor and personal anecdotes into their conversations.

    In conclusion, The Joe Benigno and Evan Roberts podcast is a standout in the world of sports talk podcasts. With their chemistry, passion, and versatility, Joe and Evan create an enjoyable listening experience that keeps fans coming back for more. Despite some deviation from strict sports analysis at times, this podcast provides a refreshing take on sports talk that sets it apart from others in the genre.



    More podcasts from Radio.com

    Search for episodes from Joe Benigno and Evan Roberts with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from Joe Benigno and Evan Roberts

    Thursday Full Show: Knicks Win and Add At The Deadline, Super Bowl Gets Closer

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2026 170:50


    The Knicks win a thriller, they add defense while losing Deuce. Plus the Super Bowl storylines continue to be discussed.

    Hour 1: Knicks Survive Double-OT, Mitch Robinson's Clinic + Deadline Talk

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2026 46:14


    Evan and Tiki try to “breathe” after an insane double-overtime Knicks win at MSG that almost turned into an all-day referee meltdown. They break down Mikal Bridges' brutal night (and the massive corner three), why Knicks fans are suddenly saying “we don't need Giannis,” and the real takeaway: Mitchell Robinson looking like a one-man defensive cheat code against Jokic and Jamal Murray. Plus, trade deadline talk with the latest buzz, the Knicks' minor money move, what the buyout market could look like, and calls on Brunson's clutch DNA and a wild Draymond-to-NY idea. Then the hour takes a hard turn to hockey as the Rangers ship Artemi “Breadman” Panarin to the Kings, sending Sean into full Fan Focus fury about Drury, the direction of the franchise, and why this “retool” feels like a wrecking ball. Also: an unexpected debate on the worst U.S. president of all time.

    Hour 2: Brady's "No Dog" Comment Angers Boston, Tigers Sign Framber Valdez & NBA Trade Deadline Buzz

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2026 40:34


    iki and Evan dive into the controversy surrounding Tom Brady's recent comments about the Patriots in the Super Bowl. Despite his former teammate Mike Vrabel coaching New England, Brady claims he has "no dog in the fight," sparking outrage among Boston fans and former players. The guys debate whether Brady is being corporate, disconnected, or just trying to protect his new ownership interests. Later, the show shifts to Major League Baseball as the Detroit Tigers make a splash by signing Framber Valdez, leading to a debate on whether the Tigers are now legitimate threats to the New York Yankees in the American League.

    Hour 3: Giannis Stays, Knicks Add Alvarado and the Jets Still Can't Escape Themselves

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2026 40:39


    Hour 3 opens with Giannis dominating the NBA deadline conversation, plus the fallout from Tom Brady's “no dog in the fight” comments as even active players pile on. Then the real deadline bomb drops: Shams reports the Bucks are keeping Giannis, which the show calls the best possible news for Knicks fans and a major setup for a wild summer. Minutes later, the Knicks strike anyway, landing Jose Alvarado in a low-risk move built for playoff minutes. The guys break down why he's a perfect pest defender, why it helps if Deuce McBride's injury lingers, and how “Jose Jose” might return at the Garden. It also sparks a classic New York argument: Knicks title odds vs Islanders “sport nature” logic, complete with soapbox energy and lap talk. The hour wraps with Jets frustration returning fast as the conversation shifts to roster building, reputation, and why the Knicks are the blueprint for fixing a broken franchise. Leon Rose gets his flowers for deadline hits, while the Jets still feel stuck in the cycle.

    Hour 4: Knicks Trade for Jose Alvarado, Deuce McBride Surgery Fallout & Least Sexy Super Bowls Ever

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2026 43:07


    The final hour of Evan & Tiki opens with breaking Knicks news as New York trades for Jose Alvarado just moments before reports surface that Deuce McBride will undergo core muscle surgery and could miss the rest of the regular season. Evan and Tiki break down what the injury really means, playoff timelines, and why the move reflects how well-run the Knicks have become. The conversation shifts to NBA trade deadline fallout, Giannis' future in Milwaukee, James Harden analogies that hit a little too close to home, and Hall of Fame debates involving Eli Manning, Luke Kuechly, and Jason Witten. Plus, the guys dive deep into Super Bowl Week, ranking the least appealing Super Bowl matchups of the last 20 years, debating Patriots vs Seahawks fatigue, Tom Brady's competitiveness, and whether this game has any real juice. All that, Cinco de Lunch, calls, laughs, and peak WFAN energy to close out the show.

    Cinco de Luncho: The Least "Sexy" Super Bowl of the Last 20 Years

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2026 10:19


    Cinco sets the tone for Super Bowl week and admits it out loud. The excitement just is not there yet. As the booth spirals into controlled chaos, the crew debates whether this year's matchup belongs in the conversation as the least appealing Super Bowl in recent memory. That leads to a full countdown of the five least exciting Super Bowl matchups going in over the past 20 years, based on hype, star power, and buzz at the time, not how the games eventually played out. From Steelers Seahawks to Panthers Broncos, the guys argue legacy quarterbacks, franchise fatigue, and whether dominant regular seasons always translate to must-watch Sundays. The discussion circles back to this year's game, the perception of quarterbacks like Sam Darnold, and whether coaching intrigue and future legacy can overcome a lack of pregame juice. Plus, a quick temperature check on why we always end up watching anyway, even when the matchup does nothing for us.

    Deuce McBride Surgery Bombshell

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2026 12:15


    Everything snaps into focus once The Athletic report drops: Deuce McBride is getting surgery for a core muscle injury and might be out until the playoffs. Five minutes ago, the Alvarado trade felt like smart “just in case” depth. Now the “just in case” has a name and it's a scalpel. The guys immediately pounce on what feels “off” about the situation. McBride had been listed as left ankle injury management, then it morphed into an ankle issue, and now it's suddenly a core muscle surgery that never showed up on the injury report in any obvious way. That whiplash becomes the story, not just the injury itself. They compare it to how different leagues handle transparency, with the NFL forcing specifics while other sports can play games with wording, competitive advantage, and vague reporting.

    BREAKING: Knicks Trade for Jose Alvarado

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2026 21:04


    Breaking news hits mid-show and the Knicks make a classic contender move, grabbing Jose Alvarado from the Pelicans. The guys immediately lean into the New York angle, Alvarado is a local kid, and the “homecoming” vibe matters because this is a player built for Madison Square Garden energy. They run through the scouting report fast: high motor, pest defender, full-court pressure, and the nickname says it all. “Grand Theft Alvarado” is about taking the ball, not the video game jokes, even if they still squeeze those in. Then the return drops and everyone starts laughing because it's one of those deals where you almost assume there has to be more. The Knicks give up newly acquired Dalen Terry and two second round picks. That's it. It also sets up a mini victory lap at the reporters who said the Knicks were nowhere close to Alvarado. From there, the basketball case gets loud. This is a playoff-rotation pickup, not a headline grab. They frame Alvarado as a weapon for a series where you need someone to harass a primary ball handler, with Cade Cunningham being the example that keeps coming up. He also becomes insurance for Deuce McBride with the injury situation still weird and vague. The point is simple: you just added a guy who will actually play when it matters, without touching the core.

    Giannis Stays & A Warning on Kyler Murray

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2026 19:33


    Hour 3 kicks off with the NBA deadline chaos and the biggest headline hanging over everything: Giannis. The show then pivots to the Tom Brady controversy after he says he has “no dog in the fight” for the Super Bowl. Patriots fans are annoyed, former teammates are chirping, and an active player goes as far as saying he's “disgusted,” turning Brady into a weird New England villain story. The guys debate whether Brady is detached, protecting broadcast credibility, or just wired to compete at whatever he's doing next. Then the real breaking news hits. Shams reports the Bucks have told teams they are keeping Giannis through the deadline. Evan frames it as the best possible outcome for Knicks fans because it keeps a rival from getting stronger now, while leaving the door open for summer chaos. They also talk through the strange ripple effects: Milwaukee possibly shutting him down, Shams' careful wording, and how Giannis could still weaponize his leverage later by scaring off teams with the “I'm not re-signing there” card. The segment ends with the bigger theme: the East feels wide open, the Celtics are compromised without a fully healthy Tatum, and this is exactly the kind of season where the Knicks get a real shot to “finish the story” before the summer superstar carousel starts again.

    Tigers Sign Framber Valdez, Tiki Wins "Bingo" & A Wild "Trade Brunson" Theory

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2026 23:27


    The hot stove finally cools down as the Detroit Tigers sign ace pitcher Framber Valdez to a massive 3-year, $111 million deal. Tiki and Evan debate whether this move makes Detroit a legitimate World Series contender or if they are simply capitalizing on a weak AL Central—and how they stack up against the New York Yankees in a potential playoff series. Then, the results are in for the show's MLB Free Agency Bingo. After months of tracking, a winner is crowned (spoiler: it's Tiki), while Tommy finishes dead last. The guys also pivot to a bizarre history lesson, discussing Robert Todd Lincoln's uncanny proximity to three presidential assassinations and the irony of the man who saved his life.

    Tom Brady's “No Dog in the Fight” Line Has Boston FUMING

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2026 17:06


    Tom Brady set off a full-blown Patriots fan meltdown after saying he has “no dog in the fight” when asked who he's rooting for in the Super Bowl. Boston fans and former Patriots are ripping him for sounding cold, scripted, and weirdly detached from the franchise that made him. The guys break down the full context of the clip, why the “resume speech” made it worse, and whether Brady is trying to please everyone as a broadcaster and part-owner of the Raiders. Plus, the show compares it to the old “Tiki rooted against the Giants” stereotype, talks loyalty in sports, and takes calls from fans with theories on what Brady is really doing.

    Karl-Anthony Towns and Draymond Green Would Never Work

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2026 17:22


    The idea sounds wild, but once you dig in, it completely falls apart. The guys explain why Karl-Anthony Towns and Draymond Green could never coexist on the same team, starting with a total lack of respect and ending with impossible chemistry and salary math. From Draymond's history with teammates to the uncomfortable comparison to the Jordan Poole situation, this debate breaks down why a theoretical New York Knicks move makes no sense. Would you really trade Josh Hart or Mikal Bridges for Draymond? And even if you could, should you? The answer here is pretty clear.

    Panarin Out, Knicks Deal Minor, Giannis Staying Put?

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2026 9:44


    The inevitable finally happens as the Rangers move on from Artemi Panarin, and emotions run hot in the studio. Then the focus shifts to the Knicks, who make a quiet but calculated deadline move, dumping salary and adding Delon Terry with limited short term expectations. What does it really mean for the playoff rotation? From there, the conversation widens to the NBA trade deadline chaos. The Knicks stay disciplined, the Milwaukee Bucks listen but likely hold Giannis Antetokounmpo until the offseason, and contenders like the Golden State Warriors pivot after swinging and missing. Plus, reaction to James Harden landing in Cleveland and why it does not change the Knicks' postseason outlook. Calls from Knicks fans wrap it up, including buy-in debates, playoff trust issues with Karl-Anthony Towns, and why this deadline may be remembered more for what did not happen than what did.

    Knicks Fans Are Starting to Believe

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2026 16:34


    A wild double overtime night at Madison Square Garden had everything. Late whistles. Missed shots. Big nerves. And a Knicks team that refused to fold. Evan and Tiki break down the double overtime win over the Denver Nuggets and why this one felt different from past seasons. The conversation starts with the controversial loose ball foul that nearly flipped the night and why the Knicks overcame a moment that usually ends in disaster. From there, the focus shifts to the trade deadline chatter and why a game like this makes you wonder if the Knicks even need Giannis Antetokounmpo to compete with the league's best. At the center of it all is Mitchell Robinson. His ability to guard Nikola Jokic in the paint and switch out onto Jamal Murray on the perimeter is dissected in detail, along with why his defensive impact might be the real difference between a good team and a Finals team. Jalen Brunson gets his due for late game poise, Karl-Anthony Towns' bloody toughness moment is discussed, and the roller coaster night from Mikal Bridges is put into full context. Plus, legendary calls from Walt Clyde Frazier add another layer to an already unforgettable night. A reminder to stay calm during an 82 game season, but also a clear message. This Knicks team can beat anyone when it defends like this.

    Carlos Enters Hall As A Met | 'Rico Brogna'

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2026 62:35


    From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): It's another version of the "Rico 10". So let's catch you up with all things Mets related you may have missed. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    Mario Bautista Previews UFC Fight Night 266 | 'WFAN Daily with Pete Hoffman'

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026 20:55


    From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): Bantamweights Mario Bautista & Vinicious Oliveira clash at UFC Fight Night 266 for a chance to try and crack the top 5 in the division. Pete Hoffman gets a chance to speak with Mario Bautista during fight week to talk about the huge matchup! Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram, TikTok To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    Wednesday Full Show: Jets Hire Frank Reich, Sam Darnold Mania

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026 171:12


    Jets mess enters another day, they hired Frank Reich in a sign of good news, and Super Bowl week pushes on.

    Hour 1: Frank Reich In, Jets Chaos Still Here + Shaun Morash Defends His Report

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026 43:08


    The Jets finally make it official: Frank Reich is the new offensive coordinator, and Evan and Tiki debate whether it's a stabilizing move or just another “single to center field” for a franchise that always finds a way to spiral. Evan breaks down why Reich's résumé works, why the Carolina stint shouldn't be the whole story, and why none of it matters until the Jets find an actual quarterback. Then the show turns into a full-on Jets credibility cage match. Shaun Morash joins the hour and answers the backlash from his reporting, clears up what he said about Darren Muji, and explains why people around the league keep calling the Jets a toxic environment. Plus, Evan puts the ultimate poll to the audience: who do you trust more, Morash or Craig Carton, and the early results might surprise you.

    Hour 2: Giannis Speaks, Trade Deadline Tension, and What It Means for the Knicks with Ian Begley

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026 46:32


    With the NBA trade deadline just hours away, the league is holding its breath after a revealing quote from Giannis Antetokounmpo: “I want to be here, but I want to win.” Evan and Tiki react to what that really signals about Giannis' future in Milwaukee and whether the Knicks were ever truly in the mix. The guys are joined by Ian Begley to break down why Giannis may ultimately stay put, how his situation slowed the entire trade market, and what realistic moves the New York Knicks could still make before the buzzer. They also examine how recent moves by Cleveland and Boston reshape the Eastern Conference, why asset limitations matter for New York, and whether the real Giannis sweepstakes are more likely to spill into the offseason. It is a deadline-eve deep dive into superstar leverage, front office patience, and what Knicks fans should actually be rooting for when the clock hits 3:00 PM.

    Hour 3: “Seeing Ghosts” Lives Forever, Vrabel Audio Chaos, and Super Bowl Food

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026 40:06


    Sam Darnold is finally rewriting his story, but the Jets chapter still has one moment that refuses to die: “seeing ghosts.” We dive back into the WFAN archives for the original Joe & Evan reaction, how Adam Gase took the early heat, and why the soundbite became a national punchline that followed Darnold for years. Plus, the show goes fully behind the scenes as a Mike Vrabel clip turns into a studio fire drill, and we check in on the ongoing “who do you trust more” poll chaos. Finally, Cinco de Luncho shifts gears with the five must-haves for your Super Bowl table, including a dip-first philosophy and a pigs-in-a-blanket debate that gets personal.

    Hour 4: NFL Coaching Bingo Results, First Coach Fired Predictions & Beltran Hall of Fame Debate

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026 42:25


    The final hour of Evan & Tiki is packed with laughs, debates, and classic WFAN chaos. The guys revisit their NFL head coaching predictions and score themselves in “NFL Coaching Bingo,” reacting to hires like Todd Monken, Mike McCarthy, Klint Kubiak, and more. They debate which new head coach will be the first one fired and whether dysfunctional franchises like the Browns or Raiders are doomed to repeat history.

    Maddux Autograph Prank: “Jeffrey Dahmer” Balls and a Fan Confirms It

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026 9:38


    A hilarious Jeff Francoeur story turns into an all-time sports prank: Greg Maddux allegedly signed autograph balls as “Jeffrey Dahmer” to mess with suspected resellers, while making sure kids still got the real signature. The crew debates how anyone could miss it, then a caller from the Upper East Side drops a perfect firsthand twist from a 2014 autograph event where Maddux allegedly joked about not writing a serial killer name on his jersey. From there the segment spins into a convo about all-time greats struggling as owners and coaches.

    NFL Coaching Bingo Results and Who's Fired First?

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026 16:27


    The guys go back to the prediction desk and grade their NFL head coaching “bingo” cards now that the jobs are filled. Sean comes out on top, Evan salvages a couple, and Tiki somehow goes 0-for-10. Then the conversation shifts to the real fun question: which of these new hires is the first one fired? The Browns and Raiders dysfunction debate gets heated, Tom Brady's Raiders influence comes up, and the segment detours into a Michael Jordan ownership discussion before taking a caller who jumps into Yankees lineup controversy with Trent Grisham vs Jasson Domínguez.

    Vrabel Clip Disaster and Cinco De Luncho

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026 18:04


    The show tries to do the responsible thing and hold takes accountable, but it turns into total chaos when a classic Mike Vrabel “how far would you go to win a Super Bowl” clip hits the system without the proper edits. The crew scrambles to dump, bleep, and re-cut the audio on the fly while Evan loses patience and Sean spirals. Then the “Who do you trust more” poll update drops, and it is suddenly uncomfortably close between Shaun Morash and Craig Carton, with Craig firing back at the whole idea.

    Sam Darnold, “Seeing Ghosts,” and the Moment That Defined the Jets

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026 22:02


    Sam Darnold may be writing a new chapter in his career, but one Jets moment still lingers. The guys revisit the infamous “seeing ghosts” game against the Patriots, how it defined Darnold's New York tenure, and why Adam Gase initially took most of the blame. A deep dive into WFAN archive audio, how one mic'd-up moment became a national punchline, and why Jets fans still can't shake it, even as Darnold moves on.

    Jets QB Talk Goes Off the Rails in a Hurry

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026 25:04


    With two first-round picks in hand, the New York Jets may have the flexibility to make a bold quarterback move in the upcoming draft. Evan and Tiki dive into the idea of using a high pick on Ty Simpson, a prospect whose stock has swung wildly over the last college season. They revisit how quickly quarterback evaluations can change, why waiting can be risky if you truly believe in a player, and how past debates like the Daniel Jones draft still shape how fans view early QB selections today. The conversation also expands to broader draft philosophy, media hype cycles, and why it may be too early for anyone to feel confident about next year's quarterback class. A thoughtful look at patience, projection, and pressure when it comes to finding the next franchise quarterback.

    Ian Begley Explains the Truth About Giannis and the Knicks' Deadline Reality

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026 21:25


    Trade deadline eve gets spicy fast after a new report out of The Athletic delivers the money quote from Giannis: “I want to be here, but I want to win.” Evan and Tiki translate what that really means for Milwaukee, why the Giannis uncertainty froze the market, and why so many teams made their moves early. Then Ian Begley joins the show to lay out the hard truth for Knicks fans: New York is on the outside looking in on Giannis right now, not because they “love their roster,” but because they simply do not have the assets to win that bidding war. Begley explains what the Knicks could still do before 3:00 PM, including potential targets like Jose Alvarado and a backup big, plus how Deuce McBride's status factors in. Finally, the conversation widens to the East shifting under everyone's feet, from Cleveland's aggressive swing to Boston's moves, and why the real Giannis sweepstakes might be headed for the offseason.

    Shaun vs Craig: Evan Drops the Trust Poll and Jets Fans Explode

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026 23:27


    Evan tries to calm the Carton vs Morash noise by admitting he respects both, then throws gasoline on it anyway by posting the ultimate Twitter poll: who do you trust more, Craig Carton or Shaun Morash? The guys break down the voting blocs, Mets fans still angry about the Kyle Tucker saga, Jets fans furious at Morash, and the “swing states” that decide the whole thing. Early returns come in and Shaun is actually winning, which turns into a hilarious reality check on what it even means to be in a trust poll with a Radio Hall of Famer. The calls keep it moving, the Jets credibility debate keeps boiling, and then the show pivots to the night in New York sports: the Knicks crush the Wizards and keep their win streak alive, the Nets get run off the floor by the Lakers, and the Islanders finally grab a win in a wild one. Plus, a quick laugh at Big Mac refusing to run the poll, some family fandom warfare, and then the focus shifts to what's next for the Knicks with the NBA trade deadline looming and Ian Begley joining to break it all down.

    Frank Reich Hired + Morash vs Carton Gets Personal

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026 19:40


    The Jets finally make it official: Frank Reich is the new offensive coordinator. Tiki calls it a smart, stabilizing hire for Aaron Glenn, but Evan keeps it real, a “single to center field” that doesn't fix the one thing that matters most: quarterback. They dig into Reich's résumé (Philly success, Indy chaos, Carolina disaster), why some fans can talk themselves into it, and why the vibe around the franchise still feels inevitable. Then it turns into a full-on Jets credibility brawl. Shaun Morash is in the crosshairs of Jets fans and Craig Carton after yesterday's reporting, and Evan lays out why the public treats them like extremes. Morash pushes back, defends his sourcing, clarifies the Darren Muji comments, and explains why the Jets always seem to be playing defense. Plus, the show tackles the bigger point behind all of it: Woody Johnson's involvement, the “toxic” perception around the league, and why Jets fans can't get inspired until the organization proves it can simply win.

    Best of the Giants on WFAN: Reaction to the Matt Nagy Hire

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2026 22:58


    WFAN dives deep into the shockwaves following the New York Giants' decision to hire former Chiefs OC and Bears Head Coach Matt Nagy as their next offensive coordinator. As the "John Harbaugh era" officially takes shape in East Rutherford, the station debates whether Nagy's experience under Andy Reid is the secret sauce needed to unlock Jaxson Dart's superstar potential—or if this is a repeat of past offensive frustrations

    Tuesday Full Show: Nagy Hired, Woody Johnson Halts Wink Hire

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 3, 2026 163:40


    Super Bowl Week continued with breaking Giants and Jets news, plus Evan proves Aaron Boone may be wrong.

    Hour 1: Matt Nagy to Giants, While Jets Spiral: The Woody Johnson Bombshell

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 3, 2026 40:28


    The New York Giants finally lock in their offensive coordinator as Matt Nagy comes over from the Kansas City Chiefs to join John Harbaugh. The crew breaks down what Nagy's offense could mean for Jaxson Dart, why Theo Johnson might be a sneaky winner, and how much credit should go to Andy Reid after Nagy's mixed run with the Chicago Bears. Then the mood flips to the New York Jets, as exclusive reporting paints a franchise with no real head coach autonomy, with Woody Johnson stepping in and Aaron Glenn getting undercut, including a wild twist involving Wink Martindale. Giants competence, Jets chaos, and a fan base bracing for impact.

    Hour 2: Giants Gain Stability With Matt Nagy as Jets Spiral, Boone Fires Back, and Posted & Toasted

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 3, 2026 47:28


    Hour 2 keeps the spotlight on the growing divide between New York football franchises. The New York Giants officially bring in Matt Nagy, and the discussion centers on competence, development, and why this staff feels trustworthy under John Harbaugh, even if the hire is not flashy. On the other side, the New York Jets remain mired in dysfunction. Woody Johnson is painted as increasingly hands on, confidence in Aaron Glenn continues to erode, and fans openly wonder if there is any path to credibility without a complete reset or a powerful buffer between ownership and football operations. The hour also features a classic Posted & Toasted segment that dredges up old takes, cold tweets, and station personalities getting exposed, followed by a full blown showdown involving Aaron Boone. Boone fires back at criticism over how the New York Yankees handled Jasson Domínguez, prompting a deep dive into the actual numbers that turns anecdotal frustration into hard evidence. Add in raw Jets fan calls, season ticket soul searching at MetLife Stadium, and the growing sense that one franchise is moving forward while the other is stuck arguing with itself.

    Hour 3: Goodell on Steve Tisch, Super Bowl XLII Heroes, & The Matt Nagy Debate

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 3, 2026 33:25


    Evan and Tiki turn a messy headline into a game: how many times would the media actually press Roger Goodell about Steve Tisch and the newly released Jeffrey Epstein email exchanges. The league drops a brief statement, then the room goes right at it, including questions from Judy Battista and Albert Breer. The guys react to Goodell's careful wording, debate what an actual NFL “fact-finding” process even looks like, and whether “not illegal” can still be “bad enough” under the personal conduct policy. Plus: quick hits on the Rooney Rule, Goodell going out of his way to praise officiating, and the league's thoughts on Bad Bunny and the halftime spotlight.

    Hour 4: Giants OC Drama, Jets Coordinator Rankings, Evan's Prank Call & Knicks Trade Buzz

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 3, 2026 43:10


    The final hour of Evan & Tiki dives deep into the reaction around the New York Giants hiring Matt Nagy as offensive coordinator and why fans are split between trust and skepticism under John Harbaugh. The guys also rank the top Jets offensive coordinator candidates, debate Greg Roman vs Frank Reich, and break down uninspired vs experienced hires. Plus, Evan reveals his prank call on Tommy Lugauer, Knicks trade deadline talk heats up with Giannis rumors, James Harden trade speculation, and plenty of classic Evan & Tiki banter to close the show.

    Matt Nagy to the Giants: Smart Hire or Just Settling

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 3, 2026 17:02


    The New York Giants officially land on Matt Nagy as their next offensive coordinator, and the reaction is exactly what you would expect. After Todd Monken heads to Cleveland, John Harbaugh pivots to Plan B, bypassing names like Kliff Kingsbury and Charlie Weis Jr. and choosing experience over mystery. The crew breaks down why Giants fans are already uneasy, where the criticism of Nagy actually comes from, and why the surface-level stats do not tell the full story of his time in Kansas City or Chicago. Is this really a boring hire, or just a familiar one for a fanbase conditioned to expect disappointment? The conversation then swings to Florham Park, where the New York Jets continue their own coordinator search. Frank Reich, Greg Roman, and Darrell Bevell are on the board, and the guys rank the candidates while unpacking what Aaron Glenn actually needs right now. Giants optimism, Jets uncertainty, and a reminder that sometimes the loudest reactions come from the least informed places.

    Cinco de Luncho: The Five Real MVPs of Super Bowl 42

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 3, 2026 20:37


    Super Bowl 42 officially turns 18, and that means the Helmet Catch is now an adult. With Giants fans already feeling old, the crew takes a nostalgic turn on Cinco de Luncho by ranking the five MVPs of the historic upset over the Patriots who were just as vital as Eli Manning. From clutch catches and relentless pass rush to an unforgettable halftime moment that steadied an entire fan base, they break down the plays, performances, and forgotten heroes that made one of the greatest Super Bowls ever. A pure Giants throwback that still feels as good as it did in 2008.

    Roger Goodell's Most Awkward Press Conference Moments

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 3, 2026 12:48


    After a quiet Friday news dump, the focus turns to the Steve Tisch connection to the Epstein emails and how the NFL chose to handle it. The crew plays a game predicting how many times Roger Goodell would actually be asked about the situation, then listens back as the commissioner faces three pointed questions at the podium. From the league's vague preemptive statement to Goodell's careful non answers, they break down what was said, what wasn't, and what an NFL “investigation” even means in this context. The conversation expands to personal conduct standards, how far the league should go with owners, and whether this opens a much bigger can of worms. Along the way, they also react to other Goodell topics from the podium, including the Rooney Rule, officiating, tanking, and the Super Bowl halftime show.

    Aaron Boone Calls Out Morash, Evan Brings the Receipts, and the Matt Nagy Debate Deepens

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 3, 2026 18:51


    Things get personal when Aaron Boone unexpectedly fires back at on-air criticism, directly calling out comments made by Shaun about how the New York Yankees handled Jasson Domínguez. What follows is a full blown fact check, as Evan digs into every two-hit game Domínguez had last season and proves Boone sat him eight times immediately after, including against multiple right-handed pitchers. Anecdotes turn into data, and the numbers spark a heated debate about development, matchups, and trusting young players when they are hot. From there, the conversation shifts back to the New York Giants and the hiring of Matt Nagy. Callers weigh in on what Nagy really brings after his time with the Kansas City Chiefs and Chicago Bears, debating how much credit he deserves, what he learned from Andy Reid, and why his role alongside Jaxson Dart matters more than his head coaching record. The segment wraps with classic sports-radio chaos, including a live season ticket negotiation at MetLife Stadium, fan frustration boiling over, and a quick pivot toward the next headline involving Roger Goodell and league level scrutiny.

    Posted & Toasted Torches Old Takes on Matt Nagy

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 3, 2026 8:05


    The show takes a sharp and hilarious turn with Posted & Toasted, as the crew digs up old tweets from WFAN coworkers and lets Tiki Barber guess who posted them before deciding who deserves to be toasted. It starts with an all time 2020 cold take shredding Doug Pederson and Matt Nagy while propping up Eric Bieniemy and questioning the greatness of Andy Reid. Tiki immediately sniffs it out as a vintage Shaun Morash take. Then comes a dark 2017 train ride tweet that shocks everyone when it turns out to belong to Chris McMonigle, followed by a 2023 confession from Evan Roberts admitting he roots against the New York Yankees just to hear Big Mac battle callers over Aaron Boone.

    Giants Build Real Coaching, Jets Still Search for a Savior

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 3, 2026 20:32


    his segment opens with a full takedown of what the Pro Bowl has become and why it no longer means what it used to. Justin Fields turning down the Pro Bowl earns respect, while seeing Shedeur Sanders labeled a “Pro Bowler” highlights how hollow the honor has become. The crew argues the solution is simple: keep Pro Bowl selection as a standalone honor, then separate it from the exhibition event entirely, possibly reimagined as a fan focused showcase tied to flag football and the future Olympic push. From there, the conversation swings back to New York football. The New York Giants are praised for leaning into real coaching and teaching under John Harbaugh, with callers emphasizing fundamentals like catching, tackling, and development, especially with young players such as Theo Johnson. The takeaway is that this staff feels deliberate and built to improve players, not just manage games. Meanwhile, the New York Jets spiral continues. Calls center on ownership dysfunction, whether Woody Johnson is driving the franchise into a dead end, and the bleak reality that even big name saviors like Mike Tomlin feel unrealistic. The hour circles the same haunting question Jets fans cannot escape: who, if anyone, can actually save this franchise.

    Is This Woody Johnson's “James Dolan Moment”

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 3, 2026 22:05


    After painting the bleakest picture yet of the New York Jets, the crew tries to find the one possible silver lining: if this thing fully detonates, does Woody Johnson finally have his “James Dolan moment” where he spends big on a true franchise savior and then actually steps back? They debate what the Jets are missing most, not just a quarterback or an OC, but a real football “filter” between ownership and the people trying to do the job. The frustration boils over when money enters the chat: rumors of Aaron Glenn earning massive dollars, fans getting crushed by rising costs at MetLife Stadium, and the core question that drives every call: if you are charging people a fortune, how do you not do everything possible to win? Plus, calls pour in as Jets fans hit their breaking point, from “denouncing” fandom to wondering if the league would ever step in, while the show circles back to the reality that competence is the rarest commodity in this building right now.

    Claim Joe Benigno and Evan Roberts

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel