POPULARITY
Categories
That's right, Carton thinks that Tom Brady has something up his sleeve again that's going to set the Jets back another decade or more!
That's right, Carton thinks that Tom Brady has something up his sleeve again that's going to set the Jets back another decade or more! Emmanuel Berbari gets a blessing from Big Mac on his home run call, plus NBA records are made to be broken. That's right, the Atlanta Hawks are promoting the best place to get wings. Plus, the Mount Rushmore of Cartoons; This will shock you! How does Handicap parking at the World Cup turn into returning your shopping cart? Tune in and you'll find out!
Kat was 5-5 from the floor and no other Knicks scored more than six baskets in the game. How could such a great team play so bad? Carton cracks the code.
KAT goes five for five from the field; Why did he only shoot five shots? Maybe ask Jalen Brunson. Or maybe ask Mike Brown! Troy Vincent opens up about some calls in games that would have changed the outcome of the playoffs. Thanks for telling us after the fact Troy! Kat was 5-5 from the floor and no other Knicks scored more than six baskets in the game. How could such a great team play so bad? Carton cracks the code. As we dive into more of who made it and who missed the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, we learn that Hoff dropped the ball with Ralph Macchio!
The debate is ON in this explosive opening segment of The Carton Show! With the Yankees honoring CC Sabathia, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle ask the question fans can't ignore…
The panic is REAL on The Carton Show! After Giancarlo Stanton revealed he struggles to open a bag of chips because of his elbows, Craig Carton is sounding the alarm! Will Stanton even make it through the season? Is 100 games realistic… or total fantasy? Are the New York Yankees headed for another injury nightmare?
Major drama surrounding the New York Giants and the guys on the Carton Show are calling it out. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle rip the latest NFL Draft buzz, saying there's ZERO chance the Giants take Jeremiah Love at No. 5 calling it nothing more than a SMOKESCREEN.
Aaron Glenn admits that he has super powers and wants to use them to help the Jets in 2026. This, of course, makes sense. After all of what happened during the John Harbaugh coaching search and hire, Joe Schoen says his role with the Giants has NOT changed in anyway. For this fan focus, Carton surprises Big Mac with a story about a deer that he was not expecting. A touching check-in with legendary Yankees announcer John Sterling after his recent heart scare, and nostalgia-packed stories about New York's iconic broadcasters. Plus, the first handheld football video game makes a comeback?
For this fan focus, Carton surprises Big Mac with a story about a deer that he was not expecting.
Did the most powerful man in hockey just disappear?! On this wild segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle demand answers: Where was Gary Bettman during the Olympic gold medal moment for hockey? If this was such a massive event for the sport, why wasn't the commissioner front and center? The debate spirals into whether Olympic success actually grows hockey in America and how other commissioners like Adam Silver and Roger Goodell would've handled it.
This segment of The Carton Show starts nostalgic and ends completely unhinged.
This might be one of the wildest segments you'll ever hear on sports radio and that's saying something. On WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to an absolutely shocking news story out of Kentucky that leaves the studio speechless and spirals into one of the most chaotic discussions you'll ever hear on air.
The hockey debate just EXPLODED on The Carton Show. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle take on furious hockey fans after their controversial claim that America's latest international win won't grow the sport at all. Using hard numbers, ratings, and draft data, Carton argues even the legendary 1980 Winter Olympics didn't spark a lasting hockey boom so why would this? Plus things heat up in New York football as Joe Schoen responds to the noise and lays out his mission for the New York Giants.
Things got heated FAST on this episode of The Carton Show. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle respond to the backlash over their controversial claim that a gold medal hockey moment won't boost ratings or grow the sport in the U.S. and they are NOT backing down.
The drama is heating up at the NFL Combine and the takes are getting WILD. On this explosive segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to shocking comments from Aaron Glenn, who says his “superpower” is calling defensive plays for the New York Jets. But does that actually translate to WINS or more chaos?
If the Gold Medal game was so good, then why do we still not care for the NHL. Plus, Guess which sports have the least amount of action in them. Karl Anthony Towns has put up incredible numbers this season, yet he's still getting asked for more from fans! Carton brings out the wheel to play "Spin That Wheel", A new game that tests the knowledge between Big Mac, Hoff and Gallo. Unfortunately they all buckle under pressure. Plus, help McMonigle to pick a name for his new Yankee podcast. USA shocked the world and beat Canada in Mens Hockey. Unfortunately, hockey will continue to be 4th biggest sport in America and it doesn't seem the Olympics will change that. Plus, the crazy similarity between 1980 and 2026 Olympic teams.
Carton brings out the wheel to play "Spin That Wheel", A new game that tests the knowledge between Big Mac, Hoff and Gallo. Unfortunately they all buckle under pressure. Plus, help McMonigle to pick a name for his new Yankee podcast.
Pete Alonso hits the first home run of spring training. Carton dives into how much Pete Alonso is going is going to be on the minds of all New Yorkers?
The Knicks take another loss to the Pistons on Thursday night. Does this mean the Knicks have no chance at getting to the Finals? Pete Alonso hits the first home run of spring training. Carton dives into how much Pete Alonso is going is going to be on the minds of all New Yorkers? Punch the Monkey is getting all the support from Craig and C-Mac. Plus, Marlon Jackson stops by to dish out the life and times of the Jackson 5. USA moves on to take on Canada in the Men's Hockey Gold Medal Game, but why is it scheduled for 8am? Plus, what to do on a snowy day with your new fiancée and why are Mets fans scared of the 2026 season?
New York sports fans are LOSING IT and Craig Carton is not holding back. In this explosive segment of WFAN's The Carton Show, Carton and Chris McMonigle break down everything driving fans crazy right now…
On this heated segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the stunning stadium drama that could move the Bears out of Chicago and into Indiana. Carton doesn't hold back calling it an “embarrassment” for the city and questioning how a major NFL franchise could leave after decades of history.
On The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go head-to-head in a surprisingly heated debate over the most controversial movies of the last decade.
This segment of The Carton Show has EVERYTHING a dramatic Team USA gold medal win, a massive March Madness TV shakeup… and one of the funniest pronunciation debates you'll ever hear.
This segment of The Carton Show goes completely off the rails and somehow turns into a sports debate, business breakdown, AND live math class all at once.
C-Lo is here with reporters asking Giancarlo Stanton about Clark resigning & the lack of moves in the offseason. Carlos Mendoza was on the Carton Show and was asked right away about the clubhouse not getting along. UConn's Dan Hurley wants support from the students.
BIG interview on the Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle welcome Carlos Mendoza to talk EVERYTHING about the New York Mets heading into the season. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Are the New York Mets already on the brink… before the season even starts?! On this intense segment of the Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down what might REALLY be going on behind the scenes in Queens — and why manager Carlos Mendoza could already be on the hot seat.
Did Aaron Judge just call out the New York Yankees front office?! On this heated segment of the Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go head-to-head over Judge's explosive comments about the Yankees offseason.
Evan & Tiki discuss the possibility of Derek Carr as the Jets' next quarterback. Plus, ranking the top five veteran QB choices (14:09); Carton trolls Patriots fans saying the Jets are better run (33:09); Boomer asks ChatGPT about the Jets QB situation (49:44) and discusses with Gio who the Jets best QB options are (59:04); Carton on his plan for the Jets (1:05:36).
Evan & Tiki discuss the possibility of Derek Carr as the Jets' next quarterback. Plus, ranking the top five veteran QB choices (14:09); Carton trolls Patriots fans saying the Jets are better run (33:09); Boomer asks ChatGPT about the Jets QB situation (49:44) and discusses with Gio who the Jets best QB options are (59:04); Carton on his plan for the Jets (1:05:36).
Evan & Tiki discuss the possibility of Derek Carr as the Jets' next quarterback. Plus, ranking the top five veteran QB choices (14:09); Carton trolls Patriots fans saying the Jets are better run (33:09); Boomer asks ChatGPT about the Jets QB situation (49:44) and discusses with Gio who the Jets best QB options are (59:04); Carton on his plan for the Jets (1:05:36).
What started as a mystery caller turned into an AWESOME surprise on The Carton Show! Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle take a random call from Chicago… only to realize it's ACTUALLY former Mets All-Star catcher Todd Hundley calling in LIVE! Todd breaks down Francisco Lindor's hamate bone surgery, what recovery REALLY looks like, and whether Mets fans should expect him ready for Opening Day. Plus, incredible insight into hitting, the steroid era, rule changes, and life after baseball. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
The Yankees get injury news and Craig Carton immediately EXPLODES. After hearing young pitcher Cam Schlittler has back inflammation, Carton goes OFF calling baseball players “soft” and saying football and hockey guys would NEVER miss time for this.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open the show with a MASSIVE controversy surrounding Giants owner Steve Tisch and Craig says there's only ONE solution he's gotta go. As more emails surface, Carton explains why this is a full-blown crisis for the franchise and why the Giants can't stay silent any longer. Then the mood shifts and the Knicks absolutely EMBARRASS the 76ers in Philadelphia, with Knicks fans taking over the arena in a blowout statement win heading into the All-Star break. Are they becoming a championship team?
Carton lays out the perfect plan to bring the Jets to the playoffs next season.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle kick off the show with MASSIVE sports drama Francisco Lindor heads into surgery just weeks before Opening Day, Mets fans are already sweating… and Craig absolutely GOES OFF on LeBron James for skipping another showdown with the Spurs.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go OFF after seeing FanGraphs' 2026 MLB predictions including the Yankees finishing FOURTH in the AL East?! Craig calls the projections “garbage,” adds multiple people to his official REVENGE LIST (including IKF and the Dodgers), and promises receipts when the season ends.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to disturbing news involving former Jets first-round pick Darron Lee and why some stories go far beyond sports. Then the conversation takes a sharp turn into the exploding world of prediction markets and unregulated wagering. Is it basically LEGAL insider trading? Can people bet using information they already know and cash in? Carton explains why the government may step in FAST and why this could all be outlawed sooner than you think.
A WFAN caller backs Craig Carton in the Spring Training debate proving he WASN'T crazy after all but that's just the beginning. What starts as sports talk spirals into a wild conversation about Ozempic taking over the world, Tom Brady's endorsements, AI replacing actors (and maybe athletes), Megan Fox robot movies, and whether baseball could someday be COMPLETELY fake.
As Craig and C-Mac are diving into some stories about the late Ray Hanley when breaking news hits about Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto! Craig sets up Pete Hoffman and the rest is brilliant! Plus, the Jets best asset going into next season is to dream! Carton lays out the perfect plan to bring the Jets to the playoffs next season. The Mets are completely off the hook after finding out more information on the Bad Bunny Insurance offer to team Puerto Rico. Plus, note to self, after winning an Olympic Medal, try not to tell the world you cheated on your girlfriend.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle start with brutal New England Patriots postseason stats and a full-on Jets “dream scenario” involving Frank Reich, Kirk Cousins or Mac Jones — then everything explodes. Carton unloads on a WFAN Jets promo, revisits the infamous Shea Stadium flying lawnmower tragedy with an eyewitness caller, and somehow turns the conversation into chainsaws, log splitters, barbershops, haircuts, and one of the wildest tangents in Carton Show history. You truly won't believe how far this segment spirals.
What starts as a serious breakdown of Francisco Lindor's hand injury timeline quickly spirals into absolute chaos. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate Mets injury recoveries, compare Lindor to Alvarez, and then everything goes off the rails — migraines, lights turned off in the studio, fake Todd Hundley fallout, and nonstop Carton Show comedy. Sports talk meets pure radio madness on WFAN.
One of the funniest moments of the Carton Show. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle completely set up WFAN producer Pete with a fake call from “former Met Todd Hundley” complete with Abu Dhabi stories, family trivia, and a flawless sell. The reveal sends the studio into chaos as Pete realizes he's been had, live on air.
The New York Mets offseason takes a brutal turn. On the Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to shocking news that Francisco Lindor may need hamate surgery and could miss Opening Day plus the Mets announcing Juan Soto will be their starting LEFT FIELDER. Was this even the plan? Carton unloads on the Mets' front office, questions the timing, and wonders if the season is already spiraling before spring training even starts. Mets fans are NOT going to like this.
The Jets have done the unthinkable, they have drafted a more recent Starting Super Bowl Winning QB before the Patriots, Bills, Dolphins, Giants, Cowboys, Steelers, Ravens so on and so forth! While we are not making light of the Guthrie kidnapping, Craig does feel this is perfect timing as the "other" half time show was not very good, while Bad Bunny wasn't that bad. Carton and Big Mac discuss the half time show and how it wasn't that bad. Not to mention there were some cool guests on site. Plus, Carton has a new book he wants to come out with. Why did the two decide to end their fantastic relationship? Because Stefon Diggs reportedly was being thrown a post Super Bowl party by Cardi B and he tried inviting an ex. We guess that's a no no. Plus, how much money did the Super Bowl streaker make and is the MLB screwing over their fans once again?
Jerry's back! He's got all the noises from the Knicks big win, that Carton and C-Lo feud that's now brewing, and college basketball fans getting real ugly.
The Knicks toppled Denver in what seemed like a Finals preview that saw a bloodied KAT return from the locker room to finish the job. Jerry's got all that sound plus ugly scenes at the Oklahoma State/BYU game. Also, Carton's taking shots at C-Lo and apparently Gio. We wrap up with the latest on the search for Savannah Guthrie's missing mother.
Evan tries to calm the Carton vs Morash noise by admitting he respects both, then throws gasoline on it anyway by posting the ultimate Twitter poll: who do you trust more, Craig Carton or Shaun Morash? The guys break down the voting blocs, Mets fans still angry about the Kyle Tucker saga, Jets fans furious at Morash, and the “swing states” that decide the whole thing. Early returns come in and Shaun is actually winning, which turns into a hilarious reality check on what it even means to be in a trust poll with a Radio Hall of Famer. The calls keep it moving, the Jets credibility debate keeps boiling, and then the show pivots to the night in New York sports: the Knicks crush the Wizards and keep their win streak alive, the Nets get run off the floor by the Lakers, and the Islanders finally grab a win in a wild one. Plus, a quick laugh at Big Mac refusing to run the poll, some family fandom warfare, and then the focus shifts to what's next for the Knicks with the NBA trade deadline looming and Ian Begley joining to break it all down.
The Jets finally make it official: Frank Reich is the new offensive coordinator. Tiki calls it a smart, stabilizing hire for Aaron Glenn, but Evan keeps it real, a “single to center field” that doesn't fix the one thing that matters most: quarterback. They dig into Reich's résumé (Philly success, Indy chaos, Carolina disaster), why some fans can talk themselves into it, and why the vibe around the franchise still feels inevitable. Then it turns into a full-on Jets credibility brawl. Shaun Morash is in the crosshairs of Jets fans and Craig Carton after yesterday's reporting, and Evan lays out why the public treats them like extremes. Morash pushes back, defends his sourcing, clarifies the Darren Muji comments, and explains why the Jets always seem to be playing defense. Plus, the show tackles the bigger point behind all of it: Woody Johnson's involvement, the “toxic” perception around the league, and why Jets fans can't get inspired until the organization proves it can simply win.
We heard Craig Carton shooting down Morash's report on the Jets. Plus, Todd Monken said he took the Browns job because of the players.