Case of The Creeps: A Truly Creepy Podcast

Follow Case of The Creeps: A Truly Creepy Podcast
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

It’s a CREEPY good time over here! Join Katie and Nate your head creepy crawlers each week as they dive into all things creepy and unexplained. From murder and paranormal cases to conspiracy theories. If its creepy, they're is on the CASE. See what we did

Case of the Creeps


    • Dec 15, 2023 LATEST EPISODE
    • every other week NEW EPISODES
    • 1h 1m AVG DURATION
    • 65 EPISODES


    Search for episodes from Case of The Creeps: A Truly Creepy Podcast with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from Case of The Creeps: A Truly Creepy Podcast

    Episode 49: Frolic Away in Elephant Bootay | Toy Box Killer pt 1

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 15, 2023 66:16


    Grab your buckles and comfort pillows Creeps! We have finally come to the debut of our heaviest case we've covered in our podcast history. David Parker Ray was born and bred in the environment of evil and became a product of it. He is responsible for the murder of anywhere from 40-60 women during his 40 years of active killing. But if that wasn't enough, he also made history with his...Toy Box and House of Horrors where he would kidnap women and keep them as his personal torture slaves. On this episode and part one, the girls crack this wide open - examine his childhood and leave us cringing, with a whole new unease of Creeps.

    Episode 48: The Math Ain't Mathin' | Harold Shipman pt. 2

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 1, 2023 66:23


    Its the conclusion of Dr Death Creeps! Harold Shipman was one of the most prolific serial killers, who was active for over 20 years, and made sure he was covering his tracks in his most professional manner. That was, until he got cocky and was the product of his own demise. The ladies buttoned this up with the details of his empire crumbling and pay tribute to just some* of the 200+ victims of this Dr and his deadly diagnosis, leaving us all with a clean bill of health, and creeps.

    Episode 47: Someone Call OSHA | Wizard of Oz *UNEDIT BONUS*

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 11, 2023 45:33


    Oh boy! Y'all better watch out, because the Chaos train is coming in hot with a whole load of tangents and cackles. Welcome to the Bonus episode! The girls got together and decided to step out of the wheel house on this one and did a light coverage on The Wizard of Oz and the maddening events that took place during filming. To make it even better....its unedited. Grab your makeup brushes and fire extinguishers....maybe even some febreze; Because this one painted on the fire that stunk....you'll get it we promise.

    Episode 46 : Here Comes Primmy | Harold Shipman pt. 1

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 29, 2023 57:02


    The girls are BACK, and starting off the new way of things with a deadly DOSE of creeps for you listeners. On this episode Katie and Jerri dug deep into the life of Harold Shipman. On the outside, he was the well know and loved family practitioner - while on the inside had an unhealthy goal to make his patients perish by his hands. On part one, the girls broke down his childhood and a lot of the red flags that led to our Dr Death being born, leaving us all with a replenishing dose, of the creeps.

    Here's What's Happening - Friday the 13th

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 13, 2023 23:40


    Well hey Creepy Crawlers. We've been quiet for a few and it's time you know why. There have been some major updates happening over here for the platform both behind the scenes and for you listeners. On this episode, we're bringing everything up for you all and then closing out the episode with some fun facts for our spooky holiday, Friday the 13th, that may even have you counting how many letters you have in your name. When one case closes, another opens and with that - we all have a new case, of the creeps.

    Episode 46: I Like It Cold and Dry | Ed Kemper part 1

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 20, 2023 40:28


    We're taking it back to the cracker box mic days and comin at you creeps with a remake episode part one!!! Ed Kemper is one of the biggest hitters in the serial killer world, let alone the mammoth of a man he is himself. And while this tree of a man may look like a gentle giant that just wants to talk - don't be fooled. This man's childhood molded him into the Co-Ed Killer that'll soon be known around the world. On this episode, our hosts are picking apart the events that took place in the early years of Big Ed's life and the start of his killing spree. Be warned creeps, while the adolescent life of this man was dark - Papa Bear and Katie waste no time unhinging the entire episode and creating the ambience of the sh*t show ride we are all about to take. Leaving us all with a nurtured case, of the creeps.

    Episode 45: Mothman Is A Gentle Lover | Mothman

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 23, 2023 51:15


    BEWARE OF THE BRIDGE!!!! And 9/11, but mostly the bridge. Strap in Creeps! Katie and Nate are diving into the cryptozoological marvel of West Virginia, the Mothman. With glowing red eyes, giant wings and a DUMP TRUCK of an ass, this fluffy winged man left absolutely no crumbs on his terror in the 1960s. So get ready creeps as our hosts get into the nitty gritty of it with the usual witch cackles from Katie and absurdity spewing from Nate; this episode is sure to leave us all with a lurking case, of the creeps.

    Episode 44: Please Don't Cancel Us | Aleister Crowley FINAL PART

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 15, 2023 58:46


    Can we all give a collective scream in Sherpa that ITS FINALLY HERE?!?! AAHAAHAHHHAAHAH! The Final part and wrap up of the elusive and magically abusive Crowley is finally here for your listening pleasure, Creeps. On this one, our hosts are just absolutely DONE with this man and the tales of woe his life beheld. We got the details on the closing and final act of Cooky Crowley and the shenanigans this man got into before inevitably passing away from his bad habits catching up with him. PLUS as usual, the unhinged cackles that comes completely free from our mouths, to your ear holes. So grab those robes and wizard hats and buckle up for this closing, because this case is sure to leave us all with an addictive case, of the creeps.

    Reddit Reads: Dinner Plate Nipples

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 1, 2023 56:44


    When in doubt, pull a reddit reads out! After the plague infected our team to the highest extent - we needed a good laugh. And as always, Reddit NEVER disappoints us. Starting right off the bat with a succubus demon and then ending with a harrowing shadow man story. We got laughs, chills and all sorts of thrills. Sure to leave us all with a stomach aching case, of the creeps.

    Episode 43: Ride This Bull Aileeny Weeny | Aileen Wuornos

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 26, 2023 66:57


    Sorry for the delay on this one Creeps! But alas, tis time! LETS GET READY FOR MURDER!!!! Finally creeps the episode you've all been waiting for, the dry handy giving, Marlboro red smoking, Milwaukees best drinking hooker of death, Aileen Wuronos! So strap in and get ready for dirty talk, because Katie and poppa bear are joined by a special guest on this one. While she hitchhiked her way through the eastern United States and left her mark on the Sunshine State - its also apparent Aileeny Weeny Hitchhiked her way into our hearts too. Get ready for all the emotions on this one creeps, as this episode is sure to leave us all with a dangerous case, of the creeps.

    Episode 42: Money Talks, Babies Walk | Aleister Crowley pt. 2

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 11, 2023 58:59


    Aahahhhahaahha! Do you guys hear that? It's the cries of sherpas. It's time for part two of Crazy Crowley Creeps. Join Katie and Nate for this part 2 of the wild and extravagantly embellished life of Aleister Crowley. From wizard battles to mountain climbing there's sure to be something for you in this episode. Plus, we have our first installment of our new mini segment with Creepy Miki and her Creepy Corner. There's unhinged laughter, bad name pronunciation and a whole butt load of Magickal moments in this one. Sure to give us all a mystifying case, of the creeps.

    Episode 41: Power Bottom | Aleister Crowley pt. 1

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 30, 2023 51:22


    We're Back Creeps! After a small hiatus, we have RETURNED and with a whole new side of the creepy case. In this episode, we dive into a brief overview of "The Beast" himself Aleister Crowley. Going through his wild lifestyle while also diving into fits of absolute unhinged laughter. Prepare yourselves creeps. On this one there's a few facts, and a lot of side tracks. From the creation of his own religion, becoming a published poet, a mountaineer and hosting wizarding wars - Aleister was nothing short of a boring person. And this is just the overview episode. With the insane history, to the insane laughter; this episode is sure to give us all a magickal case, of the creeps.

    Episode 40: Gimme Me The Creamy Oysters | St Augustine Recap ONE YEAR ANNIVERSARY

    Play Episode Listen Later May 30, 2023 50:42


    Its been a whole YEAR of shenanigans creepy crawlers! We couldn't have done it without all you weirdos joining us as we continue to grow and learn with this podcast. So, as a THANK YOU we headed over to St Augustine and took over for the weekend. There was food, there was booze, a live that was beyond chaos AND A GHOST TOUR complete with boos and interviews! Thank you guys again for sticking with us and all our creepiness, we have the best followers that even give US a case, of the creeps.

    Episode 39: Give Me The Poopy Walls | Katies Recap From W.V

    Play Episode Listen Later May 17, 2023 62:09


    Thank the Gods, Katie is back from WV! On this episode, Katie is taking us on a wild ride of retelling her accounts from visiting the very much haunted Tran Allegheny Lunatic Asylum in Weston, West Virginia. And if you weren't a believer of ghosts and paranormal before, we garuntee you will be by the end of this road trip. As Katie goes through the daytime paranormal tour she attended, we get to hear some of the very stories and claims of what happened behind the walls of the hospital taken over by the patients, and the absolute absurdity that we all know and love our Smut Queen for. From Katies unhinged story telling and excitement, to Papa Bears reluctancy to ever even wanting to go there, this episode is sure to leave us all with a haunting case, of the creeps.

    Episode 38: Shark Whack A Mole | Florida Mayhem

    Play Episode Listen Later May 9, 2023 42:20


    Ah, Florida. The state where all bets are off and the news articles never disappoint. Papa Bear and Katie are pulling some of those whacky articles for your listening pleasure on this episode! We got shark whack a mole, space force base invasion and.....kid fight club? Like we said, Florida never disappoints. But we'll let you be the judge on this episode that sure to give you an unhinged case, of the creeps.

    Episode 37: Ham and Eggs | Albert Fish

    Play Episode Listen Later May 2, 2023 54:05


    He's not beauty, definitely not grace...but he loves poopy in the face. He's The Floppy Fish himself, Albert Fish. On this episode our creepy hosts summarize the utterly horrifying deeds this man committed along with his very questionable pleasure outlets. *TRIGGER WARNING* this man is very vile creeps, and we want our audience to be fully prepared prior to listening to this episode - this man willingly shoved things into his own orifices, he consumed human feces, but he also raped, tortured, murdered and dabbled in cannibalization - of CHILDREN. This will be one of the most gruesome people our hosts have covered so please air on the side of caution prior to hitting the play button creeps. This is also a very much summarized episode of this man, thanks to Smut Queen Katie not having the stomach for this guy. All in all, the man was born from Satan himself and this episode is sure to leave us all with a stomach churning case, of the creeps.

    Reddit Reads: What Not To Do With A Skinwalker

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 18, 2023 32:41


    Creeps and creepettes we promise we're gonna be back to our regularly scheduled unhinged true crime episodes..... Right after the Reddit reads that poppa bear and Katie have for you. From a haunting church to a crawler account about their own skin walker encounter this episode is sure to leave us all with a freaked case, of the creeps.

    Last of Us Breakdown: Episode 6

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 11, 2023 55:53


    Cue the Johnny Cash music cuz we're going to Jackson, Creeps! Papa Bear snatched the reins from Katie and theyre riding off into the sunset towards Colorado in this episode breakdown of The Last of Us. But be warned, there are a few foes along the way, in the form of Katie becoming their own soundboard, the cupboard lady ghost making a pant sh*tting appearance and lets not forget the constant roller coaster of heartache and sheltered life coming forward in the form of Katies lack of movie watching. You could call this episode "everything but the kitchen sink" to be quite honest. Bottom line though, this episode is sure to give us all a humorous case, of the creeps.

    Last of Us Breakdown: Episode 5

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 4, 2023 64:23


    We got one word for this episode - unhinged. It's a breakdown episode! And right off the bat, Katie and Papa Bear are already holding onto their sh*t as Katie's ghost goes bananas with the lights and completely scares the life out of them. From that point on, its all downhill as they dissect Episode 5 of The Last of Us. As Joel and Ellie are making their way through Kansas City, they're greeted with some unwanted guests that turn into allies and we finally meet the man behind the name....Henry. Unfortunately for our cross-trekking saviors though, that's not the only people that they meet during their time in the City of Fountains. From guns in the face to GIANT infected creatures, this episode is sure to leave us all with a heart pounding case, of the creeps.

    Episode 36: The Supah Fly Snookah | The Unsolved Case of Molly Bish

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 28, 2023 68:30


    Its a Crawler requested episode this week creeps! And on this one, Katie & Papa bear waste no time jumping right in to the tragic unsolved case of Molly Bish. Molly was only 16 years old and on her 8th day of her summer job as a lifeguard when she was abducted minutes after her mother dropped her off for the day. To this day,. suspects have been identified, but no arrests have been made. With little to no evidence and the largest search ever conducted in Massachusetts state history, Mollys case is one that we will never forget. Molly's family to this day still search for her killer with the help of the detailed sketch of the possible suspect from 22 years ago, and the suspects under investigation. From the wild rants of Papa Bear to the extreme possibilities of these disgusting men, this case is definitely going to leave us all with a questioning case, of the creeps. If you or anyone you know have any information on the Bish case, please call Mass. State Police Hot line at 508-453-7575 To donate to Bush foundation please go to https://www.mollybishfoundation.com/

    Last of Us Breakdown: Episode 4

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 21, 2023 44:29


    Cue the boogie music because it's time for a breakdown episode. Joel and Ellie seem to have already come so far on their journey in the hit new show The Last of Us, and things are just getting started. After losing Tess, the only companion Joel had left, and Ellie losing…well, everyone; they're left with no one else but each other. Which in essence starts to make/force the pair to create a bond within each other. After restocking up at Bill & Franks home and heading back out our duo hits the road continuing West. But what's a journey of self-growth and relationship building without a couple road bumps along the way, eh? And in this case, our duo may have quite literally wrecked themselves into a big bump, with the burning ongoing question of who the f*** is Henry!? On this episode, Katie & Mama Jerri take on Kansas City, a mysterious man named Henry and…a breathing floor? All of which are sure to leave you with a questionable case, of the creeps. 

    Episode 35: Pimp Hands Smackin' & Chains a Draggin' | The Bell Witch Haunting

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 14, 2023 58:26


    O.M.G it's a GIRLS NIIIIGHT over here at the creepy cave. With Katie & Mama Jerri at the mic and the listener requested episode with our main girl the Bell Witch, this episode is FULL of Witch Mafia shenanigans and spooky moments galore. John Bell Sr was your average Joe (or John) famer during the 1800s, until he and his family became the center of the towns attention with their uninvited guest - The Bell Witch. This witch had a vendetta out against the entire Bell Family and would cause insane havoc on the lives of all who dared enter the Bell Property or surrounding areas. To this day, this haunting is considered Americas most Famous; and is recorded as being the only haunting to ever be the cause of death of someone too. From the insane laughing fits to the crazy bananas facts of this tale - this case is sure to leave us all with a baffled & spooky case, of the creeps.

    Last of Us Breakdown: Episode 3

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 7, 2023 51:10


    Ouu everyone buckle up, it's time for us to crack open the breakdown of the super talked about episode 3 of The Last of Us. In this breakdown, Papa Bear and Katie first go off the rails about…. book porn? Which let's be honest, just sets the tone for you weirdos to listen to the breakdown of episode 3. This is THE episode that caused a huge uproar within the shows fan community that Nick Offerman starred in; and set a huge fire under Papa Bears ass who just wants everyone to realize one thing – love is love. From the off the wall intro, to the discussions this one sparks between our two hosts – this episode is bound to give us all an awkward case, of the creeps.

    Episode 34: Rick Flair This Bitch | Ted Bundy pt. 3

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 3, 2023 65:47


    As the title says, lets Rick Flair this Bitch because we are FINALLY to the conclusion of Ted Bundy. Not only that, but its very apparent that our hosts are absolutely slap happy in this re-record of the episode. With Bundy in custody, then out, then back in custody....and then out again.....only to end up in Florida, reeking more havoc in the Florida State University area with the Chi omega murders; and then BACK in custody for the final time, we reach the electric ending of Bundy in more ways than one. And Katie.....is saying words that she swore she never would?! This episode is one for the books creeps and sure to leave us all with a buzzing case, of the creeps.  

    Last of Us Breakdown: Episode 2

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 27, 2023 39:02


    It's a Katie filled episode! With Katie riding solo on this one, she's diving into Episode 2 of the hit new HBO Series, "The Last of Us." **Spoiler Alerts Ahead** We're talking about the trek to meet the Rebel Fireflies, and the shit fest show it took to get there. Plus, we get an intro to the second type of "infected" running around town now too - The Clicker. The name alone is enough for for this episode to give us all a case, of the creeps.

    Episode 33: Check The Chin | Ted Bundy pt 2.

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 21, 2023 87:41


    Crusin down the street in my V dub, crowbarin the bitches, Killin these girls! That's right creeps the long awaited part 2 on Ted Bundy in our heavy hitters series is finally here! Pappa bear Nate and Katie finally get into what you've all been waiting for, the twisted disgusting nitty griddy details of Bundy's murders that are sure to make you grind your teeth. And guess what you guys get this one fully unedited! So strap in and prepare those holes on the side of your heads. This man was so extra it's enough alone to give you an eye rolling case, of the creeps.

    Last of Us Breakdown: Episode 1

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 20, 2023 47:53


    Its a fungal infected nightmare over here Creeps! As Katie & Papa Bear get back to normal life after the chaos of moving, our Head Creeps decided to do just one more pallet cleanser before the mayhem of upcoming cases is unleashed. How you may ask? By starting a new series breaking down the new hit series "The Last of Us" taking the cinematic world by storm currently....or should we say infecting. In this episode we are breaking down the very first episode of this season, and lets just say - its chaos. Based off of a video game and taken to the very realistic side of TV, this show alone is enough to leave us all with an infecting case, of the creeps. 

    Reddit Reads: The Spook Skoots

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 6, 2023 56:33


    Who's ready for some slappy happy tangent filled nonsense!?! Katie and Pappa bear decided to scrape your tongues and cleanse that pallette this week with some good ol reddit reads in preparation for part 2 of the murders and trial of Ted Bundy. So sit back and relax while Pappa bear and Katie give you some of the best (and worst) stories the people of reddit have to offer up.

    Episode 32: Selfish C*ck Smooch | Ted Bundy pt. 1

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 31, 2023 55:58


    It's time for Bundy and Katie won't stop screaming (weirdo). The girls are back at it with the introduction to Bundy, and the facts of the somewhat normal raising of lil Ted. Usually there's a point in someone's upbringing that can pinpoint when things go wrong, however there are also cases where that person was just born hollow - like Bundy. On this episode the girls dig into the weird upbringing of Bundy, his school years and the events that led to his first two known* attacks. If one thing is certain, it's that this guy knew how to be a charming liar and wasn't afraid to use his powers for evil. This episode lays out all of the ground work of what led to Ted being one of the most profound killers out there with just a taste at the senseless brutality he was capable of. Giving us all a questionably trusting case, of the creeps.

    Episode 31: I'll Bring the Chicken | John Wayne Gacy part 2

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 23, 2023 112:34


    You Creeps better strap in for this one! Its part 2 and the conclusion of our first heavy hitter John Wayne Gacy from the new mini series New Years Fears.  **If you are not into sexual violence, or a super long episodes -this isn't the one for you Creeps** With Mama Jerri subbing in for Papa Bear, the girls open and shut the Killer Clown known as John Wayne Gacy. With a quick recap, they're off to the races (or should we say Jaycee Club) to dissect what would be the booming bustiness of PDM contractors and the slimy owner behind it. From the crazy business schedule, to the 33 murders that happened at that infamous house in Chicago, the girls have covered it all. And if that wasn't enough, Katie has learned the hard way that these episodes should maybe be three parts after also closing this episode with the wild ride that would be Gacy's investigation, and finally - the death sentence. This epiosde is not for the faint of heart in more than one way, but one thing is for sure...this excuse of skin and his murderous life will be sure to leave us all with a PUTRID case, of the creeps.

    Episode 30: 11 Herbs & Spices | John Wayne Gacy part 1

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 20, 2023 73:36


    Did you miss us and have withdrawals!? Trust when we say, us too. But here we are, and most importantly here is part one of John Wayne Gacy. In this episode Katie & Papa Bear go into the specific mold that would later produce the man who raped and murdered 33 young boys and buried them under his house. If it wasn't the constant abuse from his father, then maybe it was being sodomized for two years before the age of 12. Either way, this episode is stocked with the terrors that young Gacy was subjected too, and the first of his own endeavors as he starts to become....the Killer Clown. Gacy was an absolute horror of a man and is someone who will truly leave you with a terrifying case, of the creeps. This episode is a hot mess in the beginning and if you're not interested in hearing about the recap of our time off, go ahead and skip to 17:00. Cook County Sherriffs Office website for helping ID the unknown victims. https://www.cookcountysheriff.org/departments/c-c-s-p-d/unidentified-victims-john-wayne-gacy/ National Center for Missing and Exploited Children https://www.missingkids.org/poster/ncmu/1184583

    Poor Farterroy | Krampus & Christmas Monsters

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 20, 2022 49:33


    It's a Yule Tide Christmas horror over here! Ole Saint Nick isn't the only tradition celebrated around Christmas time, Creeps. On this episode Katie & Papa Bear look into the not so holly jolly side of Advent Season and unwrap Krampus, The Scary Saint Nick that drags bad kids back to hell, but that's not all! They also look into other traditions known around the globe. One consisting of nine mischievous Yule Lads that are the epitome of their names and Katie also talks about being introduced to the Elf on the Shelf world too. Trust when we say this episode is chalk full of creepy Christmas traditions that will definitely leave you with a horrifyingly cheerful case of the creeps.

    Episode 28: I'm Sizing Up Your Mist | Sleep Paralysis

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 15, 2022 71:46


    It's here! Finally! Get ready creeps! This episode is absolutely bonkers as Katie & Nate dove headfirst into the horrifying world of sleep paralysis. As they went deeper and deeper into the phases of sleep and the odd lore behind sleep demons, Papa Bear got the bright idea to get some first hand accounts, and some phone calls were made. Get your sh*t together for this creeps. From the absolutely unhinged hosting, to the "The Hat Man" coming to visit - this episode is sure to leave you paralyzed with the creeps.

    Episode 27: Let Me Suck Your Toes | Chupacabra

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 5, 2022 59:08


    Papa Bear is back!!! And the creeps are bringing all the weirdness on this one! With time way over due for a cryptid episode, Katie & Nate cracked open the oddity that is, The Chupacabra. With a dash of light hearted catching up on the weird things happening on the road to work and in Katie's home, and a dollop of El Chuppy Reddit Reads - this episode left us all with a chill filled case, of the creeps.

    I Can't Tea Kettle Anymore | Reddit Reads

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 28, 2022 31:54


    Welcome to the new mini series "Reddit Reads" where the head creeps pick a topic and then search through reddit and creepypasta for some of the best of the best (or at least good lookin) stories out there. On the episode its Katie & Mama Jerri as they take on ghost stories. Definitely hold onto your shi*t for this one creeps, because the girls obviously cant keep it together.

    Episode 26: The Polerse Search | Matthew Hoffman "The Leaf Killer" pt. 2

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 28, 2022 103:16


    Well, looky who's back on schedule! Hey Creeps! Katie is at it again, and with a special sub in co-host Mama Jerri, as they dig into part two of Matthew Hoffman a.k.a. The Leaf Killer. In this conclusion episode, Katie & Mama Jerri talk about the abduction of 13 year old Sarah Maynard and the horrors she endured while held captive by Hoffman. They also look into the discovery of Hoffman as the suspect and the spectacle that was his entire home. But don't worry creeps, this tale has a happy ending, with some twist and turns along the way. PLUS, Katie cant seem to get her speech together and we got some wild side stories for you. Tis the Season to Be Creepy! And this episode is sure to leave you with a case full of season greeting creeps.

    Episode 25: Scum Bag Demon D*ck Monster | Matthew Hoffman "The Leaf Killer" part 1

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 14, 2022 68:53


    Matthew Hoffman was the epitome of a Grade A Creep. He seemed like the normal stubborn kid during childhood, with an added dash of Dendrophilia or "love of trees" added to the mix. But when he was bored, bad things happened. In part one, Katie & Papa Bear look into the background of the soon to be dubbed "Leaf Killer" and the crimes that built up to his 3 person murder and kidnapping of a 13 year old girl. And we're just getting started. Hold onto your sh*t creeps! This one is a doozy, sure to leave us all wandering the woods with a Case of the Creeps.

    Episode 24: Geins Goods | Ed Gein

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 7, 2022 62:27


    The tech battle is over and Katie prevailed! With a new computer and all the giddyness to get back into it, the Head Creeps are back at it again with this skin peeling* episode on none other than the Butcher himself, Ed Gein. Ed was an interesting case, but what made it even more interesting - Papa Bear led and Katie had no idea what she signed up for. With the undying need and want to please his psychotic mom, Ed truly knew no bounds of life itself after her passing and would later exhibit no shits to give with the respect of those who had recently passed. Creating a plethora of oddities from human remains in his home. Hold your sh*t creeps! This one left us all with the heebie jeebies and a skin crawling Case of the Creeps.

    Episode 23: Not on My Porch | Black Eyed Children

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 24, 2022 79:52


    Turn off the lights and definitely lock your doors creeps! You never know when you may just get the unsuspecting knock of a child with pits of darkness for eyes needing to come inside your home or your car. On this episode, Katie and Nate are at it again, but with a different vibe for the episode - reading claims from Reddit of those who have encountered Black Eyes Kids. And let me tell ya....Katie scares the soul out of herself with just the thought of these little demon kids. So grab your flashlights and your brown pants, because this episode is definitely going to leave you with a hauntingly terrifying case, of the creeps.

    Episode 22: Headbutt a Hooker | The Abduction of Colleen Stan

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 17, 2022 79:42


    Can we all agree that Colleen Stan is one of the baddest b*tches to walk this earth!? This epsiode is dedicated to her, and the intense true story of the kidnapping and enslavement of Colleen. Not only that, but her captor, Cameron Hooker, took to a whole new dark side even Darth Vader would be proud of and kept Colleen in a box under his bed during her enslavment too. The elaborate schemes he pulled off to brainwash Colleen, and the intense torture she went through would make any sane person truly lose their mind. Buckle up creeps and hold your shit as Katie, Papa Bear and a special guest tell this heartbreaking tale sure to leave you with a gruesome churning case, of the creeps.

    Clap Them Demon Cheeks | Halloween History

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 13, 2022 51:53


    Its time for a lighthearted episode Creeps! And boy did Katie & Nate deliver on this one. After the last few episodes being such heavy ones it was time for a break and what better topic than the origin of Halloween. We got - Gaelic origin, Christian origin, Spanish origin.....candy corn origin? Plus, Nate finally admits Katie is a wildcard and his secret desire of....ghost cheeks. Get your sh*t together Creeps, this one was off the rails and sure to have you searching in the dark for the reason behind your case of the creeps.

    Chili Crawlers Ep. 3 - Sins of Our Mother Review

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 10, 2022 46:05


    The leaves are changing, and the season is spooky. Making it the perfect time for Katie & Nate to do a new Chili Crawler episode. After the heavy episodes, its easy to agree, a lighter episode was needed. So Katie made HER OWN Chili Recipe and the voids were filled in Nates belly for a good ole fashioned recipe. With all the new series being released on Netflix, it was just to easy for our Head Creeps to choose The Sins of Our Mother to watch and immediately feel compelled to do a review on the series the covered Lorrie Vallow and Chad Daybell as they use the excuse of Religion to end the lives of Lorries children. Strap In creeps, while this may be a lighter episode, its still one sure to leave pissed off with parentings views, religion, and a crawling case, of the creeps.

    Episode 20: Rock Tooth Fonzie | Richard Ramirez "The Night Stalker" pt.2

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 10, 2022 91:19


    Its finally her Creeps! The closing part of Richard Ramirez, "The Night Stalker." Prepare yourselves too crawlers, this one is little on the longer side to make sure all victims are given the time deserved. **Trigger Warning** for this one too guys, as Katie & Nate go into detail of the crimes committed by this monster and the 50 Shades of Violence he showered California in. If you haven't felt it yet, this episode is sure to leave you with a chilling case, of the creeps.

    Episode 19: One Man Wolfpack | Richard Ramirez "The Night Stalker" pt. 1

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 26, 2022 60:08


    Strap in Creeps! We're going deep into the night with this two-parter. Into the home, of Richard Ramirez....The Night Stalker. When it comes to bad guys, this one most definitely takes the cake. Ramirez was responsible for a multitude of assaults, murders, theft and so much more. The true blue charcuterie board of serial killers. On this one, Katie & Nate set your scene with the troubled childhood, to the early 20s and the mix of crimes that would later mold the terrifying rampage of The Night Stalker. Plus Katie gets super hyped on the survivor story cliff hanger, leaving us all with an invested Case...of the creeps.

    Episode 18: The Witches Cake | Salem Part 2.

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 19, 2022 78:36


    It's a whole family affair over here creeps! On this one Katie & Nate are joined with the Boo herself, Jenna AND the mother in law to Katie (Jenna's mom) Ms Jerri is here too! With the full group we jumped into Salem part two! We got witch exams, we got trials, we got afflicted b*itches and.....a cake you most definitely don't want. It's no wonder our schools didn't go into detail on these trials, as this episode is sure to leave you hungry... for a case of the creeps.

    Episode 17: Mean Girls of Salem | Salem Witch Trails pt. 1

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 12, 2022 59:30


    It's the Witching hour over here creeps, and we're Bob Ross painting the scene of Salem, Massachusetts during the year of 1692 for the beginning of the soon to be famous witch trials. In this episode Katie and Nate start to stir the pot of events that lead up to the trials and who was involved. Truly expressing the weird times of the 16th century and the survival mode people were living. While this episode may seem short, it's just the start to the witch hunt and new case of creeps that's about to be cracked open.

    Episode 16: The Booger of Westfield | John List

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 5, 2022 79:37


    Hold onto your hats creeps! Papa Bear took the reins on this one. Nate & Katie switched roles this week, and Katie sat back while Nate got to do all the research and lead the episode. On this one, they covered the family annihilator - John List. The man who loved God, but apparently feared debt way more. This lead to the unfortunate demise of his entire immediate family that lived in his 3 story, 19 room mansion solely because he was to good for welfare and felt his family deserved death, vs assistance. After taking out his entire family, he then disappeared for 18 years before finally being exposed thanks to good ole American TV. Strap in creeps, this episode is completely UNHINGED and will leave your face hurting from laughing so much and a new found feeling of looking at those closest to you for inner battles you know nothing about. Developing a mental* case of the creeps.

    Episode 15: Bigfoot is a Selfish Lover | Bigfoot

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 29, 2022 71:58


    Cryptozoological hide and seek champion, or just a guy in a monkey suit? You Creeps decide as Katie & Nate dive into the world of Sasquatch! From first hand accounts, to the many hoaxes surrounding the legend of Bigfoot and the... fan fiction erotic's sprinkled in the mix as well. So strap in Creeps as they take you on the hunt around the globe for the elusive ape-man all while Pappa Bear tries out his best mating calls on this poo and hair covered episode, and Katie just tries to hold on after unlocking a new side of Case of the Creeps.  

    Episode 14: Greg & Katrina vs. Katie & Nate | Hurricane Disasters

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 22, 2022 72:19


    The title says it all for this one folks. Katie & Nate cover the natural disasters of the Galveston Hurricane of 1900 and Hurricane Katrina from 2005, and have a few disaster of their own throughout the recording. Diving into the technology or lack there of, the short notice prep and the repercussions of a pissed off mother nature. These storms are some of the worst ones in our history to have created the earth shattering damage and robbing families of loved one. Plus, Papa Bear came extra prepared in the accent department for this one too. After this one, its safe to say that hurricanes are not only dangerous, but a new category of creeps you'll definitely feel after hearing the destruction they have caused. 

    Episode 13: Stone Cold Stunner | Katherine Knight

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 15, 2022 92:32


    Ah, Australia. The land down under. Known for their kangaroos, koala bears, Steve Irwin and the absolute insane woman by the name of Katherine Knight. Katherine had big dreams creeps, she just wanted a big family and to have her unhealthy violent outbursts with her butcher knife set. But with the dysfunctional childhood that unleashed more trauma than any child should go through, her dream would become everyone else's living nightmare. Papa Bear and Katie sliced into this one and picked apart each of her 4 relationships that lead to the unfortunate demise of her common law husband quite literally getting turned into a curtain. Strap in creeps - this one is definitely going to leave you feeling some type of creepy way and maybe even turn you into a vegetarian....

    Chili Crawlers Ep. 2 - Movie Review

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 8, 2022 62:18


    The Summer Flu tried really hard to take Katie & Papa Bear Nate down, but it didn't succeed! While still trying to recover, Katie snagged the opportunity to do a new Chili Recipe that was emailed and Papa Bear filled the nostalgic hearts with some good ole classic Horror Movies. So what better to do than a Chili Crawler Movie Review. On this one they watched The Shining and the original black and white Frankenstein. Both for Katie's first time too, and let the review commence. Be warned creeps there are some failed accents, major brain farts and a whole mess of coughing fits on this one, sure to leave you wondering if the summer flu is coming to give you the creeps too. 

    Claim Case of The Creeps: A Truly Creepy Podcast

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel