Room for Nuance

Join us for a conversation on EFS with Kyle Claunch, Associate Professor of Christian Theology at the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary.   Detailed Analytical Outline: "Everything You Need to Know About EFS and The Trinity | Kyle Claunch | #100" This outline structures the podcast episode chronologically by timestamp, providing a summary of content, key theological arguments, analytical insights (e.g., strengths of positions, biblical/theological connections, and implications for Trinitarian doctrine), and notable quotes. The discussion centers on Eternal Functional Submission (EFS, also termed Eternal Submission of the Son [ESS] or Eternal Relations of Authority and Submission [ERAS]), its biblical basis, critiques, and broader Trinitarian implications. Host Sean Demars interviews Kyle Claunch, a theologian offering a non-EFS perspective rooted in classical Trinitarianism (e.g., Augustine, Athanasius). The tone is conversational, humble, and worship-oriented, emphasizing the doctrine's gravity (per Augustine: "Nowhere else is a mistake more dangerous"). Introduction and Setup (00:10–01:48) Content Summary: Episode opens with music and host introduction. Sean Demars welcomes first-time guest Kyle Claunch (noting a prior unreleased recording). Light banter references mutual acquaintance Jim Hamilton (a repeat guest) and a breakfast discussion on Song of Solomon. Transition to topic: the Trinity, with humorous acknowledgment of its complexity. Key Points: Shoutout to Hamilton as the "three-timer" on the show; playful goal of featuring Kenwood elders repeatedly. Tease of future episodes on Song of Solomon, Ecclesiastes, Psalms. Analytical Insights: Establishes relational warmth and insider Reformed/Baptist context (e.g., Kenwood Baptist Church ties). Frames Trinity discussion as high-stakes yet accessible, aligning with podcast's "Room for Nuance" ethos—nuanced, non-polemical engagement. Implications: Builds trust for dense theology, reminding listeners of communal discipleship. Notable Quote: "Nothing better to talk about... Nowhere else is a mistake more dangerous, Augustine says about the doctrine of the trinity." (01:33) Opening Prayer (01:48–02:29) Content Summary: Claunch prays for accurate representation of God, protection from error, and edification of listeners (believers to worship, unbelievers to Christ). Key Points: Gratitude for knowing God as Father through Son by Spirit; plea for words and meditations to be acceptable (Psalm 19:14 echo). Analytical Insights: Models Trinitarian piety—prayer invokes all persons, underscoring episode's theme of relational unity over hierarchical submission. Strengthens devotional framing, countering potential abstraction in doctrine. Notable Quote: "May the saints who hear this be drawn to worship. May those that don't know you be drawn to want to know you through your son Jesus." (02:07–02:29) Interview Origin and Personal Context (02:29–04:18) Content Summary: Demars recounts how Hamilton recommended Claunch as a counterpoint to Owen Strawn's EFS views (from a prior episode on theological retrieval). Demars shares his wavering stance on EFS (initial acceptance, rejection, ambivalence—like amillennialism) and seeks Claunch's help to "land" biblically. Key Points: EFS as a debated topic in evangelical circles; Claunch's approach ties to retrieval. Demars' vulnerability: Desire for settled conviction on God's self-revelation. Analytical Insights: Highlights EFS debate's live-wire status in Reformed theology (post-2016 surge via Ware, Grudem). Demars' "help me land" plea humanizes the host, inviting listeners into personal theological pilgrimage. Implication: Doctrine as transformative, not merely academic—echoes Augustine's "discovery more advantageous" (later referenced). Notable Quote: "Part of this is really just being like dear brother Kyle help me like land where I need to land on this." (03:53) Defining EFS/ESS/ERAS (04:18–07:01) Content Summary: Claunch defines terms: EFS (eternal functional submission of Son/Spirit to Father per divine nature); ESS (eternal submission of Son); ERAS (eternal relations of authority/submission, per Ware). Contrasts with incarnational obedience (uncontroversial for creatures). Key Points: Eternal (contra-temporal, constitutive of God's life); not limited to human nature. Biblical focus on Son, but extends to Spirit; relations as "godness of God" (Father-Son-Spirit distinctions). Analytical Insights: Clarifies nomenclature's evolution (avoiding "subordinationism" heresy). Strength: Steel-mans EFS as biblically motivated, not cultural. Weakness: Risks blurring persons' equality if submission is essential. Connects to classical taxonomy (one essence, three persons via relations). Notable Quote: "This relation of authority and submission then is internal to the very life of God and as such is constitutive of what it means for God to be God." (06:36) Biblical Texts for EFS: Steel-Manning Arguments (07:01–14:34) Content Summary: Claunch lists key texts EFS advocates use, steel-manning sympathetically. John 6:38 (07:35): Son came "not to do my own will, but the will of him who sent me"—roots in pre-incarnate motive. Sending Language (09:04): Father sends Son (never reverse); implies authority-obedience. Father-Son Names (09:43): Eternal sonship entails biblical patriarchal authority. 1 Cor 11:3 (10:04): "God [Father] is the head of Christ"—parallels man-woman headship (authority symbol). 1 Cor 15:24–28 (13:13): Future subjection of Son to Father ("eternity future" implies past). Key Points: EFS holders (e.g., Ware, Grudem—Claunch's friends/mentor) prioritize Scripture; not anti-Trinitarian. Analytical Insights: Effective charity—affirms motives (biblicism) while previewing critiques. Texts highlight economic Trinity (missions reveal immanent relations). Implication: If valid, EFS grounds complementarity in creation (e.g., gender roles via 1 Cor 11). But risks Arianism echoes if submission essentializes inequality. Notable Quote: "They believe this because they are convinced that this is what the Bible teaches... It's a genuine desire to believe what the Bible says." (14:15) Critiquing EFS Texts: Governing Principles (14:52–19:02) Content Summary: Claunch introduces "form of God/form of servant" rule (Augustine, Phil 2:6–8) and unity of God (one essence, attributes, acts). Applies to texts, emphasizing incarnation. John 6:38 (15:11): Incarnational (Son assumes human will to obey as Last Adam); "not my own will" implies distinct (human-divine) wills, not eternal submission. Compares to Gethsemane (Lk 22:42), Phil 2 (obedience as "became," not eternal), Heb 5:8 (learns obedience via suffering). Key Points: Obedience creaturely (Adam failed, Christ succeeds); EFS demands discrete divine wills, contradicting one will/power (inseparable operations). Analytical Insights: Augustinian rule shines—resolves tensions without modalism/Arianism. Strength: Harmonizes canon (analogy of Scripture). Implication: Protects active obedience's soteriological role (imputed righteousness). Weakness in EFS: Overlooks hypostatic union's permanence. Notable Quote: "Obedience is something he became, not something he was." (35:15) Inseparable Operations and Unity (19:02–28:18) Content Summary: One God = one almighty/omniscient/will (Athanasian Creed); external acts (ad extra) undivided (e.g., creation, resurrection appropriated to persons but shared). EFS's "distinct enactment" incoherent—submission requires discrete wills, implying polytheism. Submission entails disagreement possibility, undermining unity. Key Points: Appropriation (e.g., Father elects, but all persons do); one will upstream from texts. Analytical Insights: Core classical rebuttal—echoes Cappadocians vs. Arius (one ousia, three hypostases). Strength: Biblical (e.g., Jn 1 creation triad). Implication: Safeguards monotheism; critiques social Trinitarianism/EFS as quasi-polytheistic. Ties to procession (relations without hierarchy). Notable Quote: "If God's knowledge and mind understanding will is all one then the very idea... that you could have one divine person... have authority and the other... not have the same authority... Seems to be a category mistake." (24:41–25:14) Further Critiques: Sending, Headship, Future Submission (28:18–50:07) Content Summary: Sending (42:30): Not command (Aquinas/Augustine); missions reveal processions (eternal generation), not authority (analogical, e.g., adult "sending" without hierarchy). 1 Cor 11:3 (46:34): Incarnational (Christ as mediator); underdetermined text, informed by whole Scripture. 1 Cor 15 (48:10): Post-resurrection = ongoing hypostatic union (God-man forever submits as creature). Spirit's "Obedience" (49:26): No biblical texts; EFS extension illogical (Spirit unincarnate). Jn 16:13 ("not... on his own authority") mistranslates—Greek "from himself" denotes procession, not submission (parallels Jn 5:19–26 on Son's generation). Key Points: Obedience emphasis on Son's humanity for redemption; Spirit's mission unified (takes Father's/Son's). Analytical Insights: Devastating on Spirit—exposes EFS asymmetry. Strength: Exegetical precision (Greek apo heautou). Implication: EFS risks divinizing hierarchy over equality; retrieval favors Nicene grammar. Notable Quote: "There's not one single biblical text that uses the language of authority, submission, obedience in relation to the spirit." (50:07) Processions, Personhood, and Retrieval Tease (50:07–1:10:04) Content Summary: Persons = rational subsistences (Boethius); distinction via relations/processions (Father unbegotten, Son generated, Spirit spirated—not three wills/agents). Demars probes: Processions define persons (Son from Father, Spirit from both?). Claunch: Analogical, not creaturely autonomy. Teases retrieval discussion for future episode. Key Points: Creator-creature distinction; via eminentia/negativa for terms like "person." God unlike us—worship response to mystery. Analytical Insights: Clarifies hypostases vs. prosopa; counters social Trinitarianism. Strength: Humility amid density ("take your sandals off"). Implication: EFS confuses economic/immanent Trinity; retrieval recovers Nicene subtlety vs. modern individualism. Notable Quote: "The distinction is in the relation only... The ground of personhood is the divine nature." (1:03:07–1:03:32) Eschatological Reflection and Heaven (1:10:04–1:13:39) Content Summary: Demars: Perpetual learning in heaven? Claunch: Infinite expansion (Edwards' analogy—expanding vessel in God's love); Augustine: Laborious but advantageous pursuit. Key Points: Glorified knowledge joyful, finite yet ever-growing; press on (Hos 4:6). Analytical Insights: Pastoral pivot—doctrine doxological, not despairing. Ties to episode's awe: Trinity as eternal discovery. Notable Quote: "Nowhere else is a mistake more dangerous or the task more laborious or the discovery more advantageous." (1:13:11) Rapid-Fire Q&A (1:13:55–1:20:14) Content Summary: Fun segment: Favorites (24, Spurgeon/Piper sermons, Tolkien, It's a Wonderful Life, mountains, wine, licorice hate, fly, morning person, etc.). Ends with straw holes trick (one). Key Points: Reveals Claunch's tastes (e.g., Owen's works as "systematic theology," "Immortal, Invisible" hymn for funeral—mortality vs. God's eternity). Analytical Insights: Humanizes expert; hymn choice reinforces theme (Psalm 90 echo). Lightens load post-depth. Closing Prayer (1:20:14–1:21:04) Content Summary: Demars thanks God for Claunch's clarity; prays for his influence in church/academy. Key Points: Blessing for edification, glory. Analytical Insights: Bookends with prayer—Trinitarian focus implicit. Overall Analytical Themes: Claunch's non-EFS view upholds Nicene equality via processions/operations, critiquing EFS as well-intentioned but incoherent (risks subordinationism). Episode excels in balance: exegetical rigor, historical retrieval (Augustine/Aquinas/Owen), pastoral warmth. Implications: Bolsters complementarianism without Trinitarian cost; urges humility in mystery. Ideal for theology students/pastors navigating debates.  

Join us for a conversation with Owen Strachan, founder of One Gospel and author of several books, including 'Christianity and Wokeness,' 'The War on Men,' and 'Designed for Joy.' One Gospel: https://onegospel.net/2026conference

Join us for a conversation with Andrew Davis, the senior Pastor of First Baptist Church of Durham in North Carolina, founder of Two Journeys Ministry, and author of many books, including 'How to Memorize Scripture for Life'. His book on heaven: https://www.amazon.com/Glory-Now-Revealed-Discover-Heaven/dp/1540901041 Two Journeys Ministry: https://twojourneys.org/

Join us for a conversation with Steve Wellum, Editor of The Southern Baptist Journal of Theology and Professor of Christian Theology. Wellum is the author of many books, including Systematic Theology, Volume 1: From Canon to Concept (B&H Academic, 2024), The Person of Christ: An Introduction (Crossway, 2021), and God's Kingdom through God's Covenants: A Concise Biblical Theology, Co-authored by Peter J. Gentry (Crossway, 2015). His Systematic Theology: https://bhacademic.bhpublishinggroup.com/product/systematic-theology-2/#flipbook-sampler/

Join us for a conversation with Tom Hicks, the senior pastor of First Baptist Church of Clinton, Louisiana. Hicks received his MDiv and PhD degrees from The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, and is the author of 'What is a Reformed Baptist?'.  'What is a Reformed Baptist?' Book: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0F2FNH85F?ref_=cm_sw_r_ffobk_cp_ud_dp_EDZA3FSXW29SK90SCVPT&bestFormat=true

Join us for a conversation discussing the best books of 2025 with Walter Shaw, creator of WTSreads. WTSreads Website: https://www.wtsreads.com WTSreads Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/wtsreads?utm_source=ig_web_button_share_sheet&igsh=ZDNlZDc0MzIxNw==

Join us for a conversation about whether or not Christians should celebrate Christmas.

Join us for a conversation with Dr. Jim Newheiser, the Director of the Christian Counseling Program and Professor of Christian Counseling and Pastoral Theology at Reformed Theological Seminary in Charlotte. Dr. Newheiser is also the Director of the Institute for Biblical Counseling and Discipleship, and has written many books including 'The Abuse Pendulum', and 'Marriage, Divorce, and Remarriage: Critical Questions and Answers.' Website: https://jimnewheiser.com Marriage, Divorce, and Remarriage Book: https://us.10ofthose.com/product/9781629953168/marriage-divorce-and-remarriage-paperback

Join us for a conversation with Neil Shenvi, author of 'Why Believe?: A Reasoned Approach to Christianity' and coauthor of 'Critical Dilemma: The Rise of Critical Theories and Social Justice Ideology-Implications for the Church and Society'.   Critical Dilemma Book: https://a.co/d/5MrGwtB  Shenvi Apologetics: https://shenviapologetics.com Post Woke Book: https://a.co/d/av3YL49

Join us for a conversation with Jim Hamilton, Professor at The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary and Harry Potter literary expert. Should Christians avoid Harry Potter? Is It Evil? Satanic?

Share your favorite episode on facebook and tag us!

Join us for a conversation with Jonathan Leeman, the new President of 9Marks.

Join us for a conversation with TJ Freeman, Executive Director of the Brainerd Institute and Pastor of Christ Church Wellsboro. 

This interview was recorded on May 13th. Join us for a conversation with Trevin Wax, the Vice President of resources and marketing at the North American Mission Board, former missionary to Romania, writer for TGC, and founding editor of The Gospel Project. Trevin Wax has also written numerous books, such as 'The Thrill of Orthodoxy', 'Gospel Centered Teaching', and 'The Gospel Way Catechism', and is the host of the podcast 'Reconstructing Faith'.

This talk was recorded at the 2025 Feed My Sheep Conference.

This is a talk given by Jonathan Leeman at the 2025 Feed My Sheep Conference. 

This is a talk given by Paul Lamey at the 2025 Feed My Sheep Conference. 

This is a talk given by Jonathan Leeman at the 2025 Feed My Sheep Conference. 

Join us for a conversation with Jonny Ardavanis, Lead Pastor of Stonebridge Bible Church, President and Founder of Dial In Ministries, and author of 'Consider the Lilies: Finding Perfect Peace in the Character of God.' Consider the Lilies Book: https://us.10ofthose.com/product/9780310368243/consider-the-lilies-paperback Dial In Ministries: https://dialinministries.org

Join us for a conversation with Luke Hill.    Link to Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/artist/21q5OSg8JT1ICg0jO4j8wT Link to Apple Music: https://music.apple.com/us/album/the-voyage-of-life-ep/1839739666    

Join us for a conversation with Amos Luka, a Christian from Northern Nigeria.

Join us for a conversation with Barry Peterson, executive director of Clearly Reformed. 

Join us for a conversation with Dr. Daniel Akin, President of Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary and author of a number of books, including Discovering the Biblical Jesus. 

Join us for a conversation with Zane Pratt, a former missionary who now works for the International Mission Board as the Vice President for Global Training, and at Southern Seminary as the Associate Professor of Christian Missions.

Join us for a conversation with Erin Wheeler, author of The Good Portion – The Church: Delighting in the Doctrine of the Church. She is also a nurse, a Bible teacher, and one of the co-hosts of the 9Marks Priscilla Talk podcast.

Join us for a conversation with Donald Whitney, professor of Biblical Spirituality at Midwestern Theological Seminary. He is the author of nine books, including 'Spiritual Disciplines for the Christian Life' and 'Praying the Bible', and formerly served as a pastor in the suburbs of Chicago for nearly 15 years. Feed My Sheep Conference: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/feed-my-sheep-conference-2025-tickets-1366384646259  

Join us for a conversation with Nathan White, the pastor of Good Shepherd Presbyterian Church in Madison, Alabama. Feed My Sheep Conference: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/feed-my-sheep-conference-2025-tickets-1366384646259  

Join us for a conversation with Thomas Kidd, Research Professor of Church History at Midwestern Seminary. Kidd holds a Ph.D. in history and is the author of several books, including 'Who Is an Evangelical? The History of a Movement in Crisis',  'American Colonial History: Clashing Cultures and Faiths', and 'Thomas Jefferson: A Biography of Spirit and Flesh'. Feed My Sheep Conference: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/feed-my-sheep-conference-2025-tickets-1366384646259  

Join us for a conversation with Dr. Rob Plummer, professor and author. He has served as a missionary to multiple countries, and is the founder and host of 'The Daily Dose of Greek'. Daily Dose of Greek: https://dailydoseofgreek.com/ Feed My Sheep Conference: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/feed-my-sheep-conference-2025-tickets-1366384646259

Join us for a conversation with Tim Challies, a Canadian blogger, speaker, pastor, and author. His books include "From the Rising of the Sun," "A Visual Theology guide to the Bible," and "Seasons of Sorrow: The Pain of Loss and the Comfort of God." Blog: https://www.challies.com/ Song: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bY1ph_PYMtg  

Join us for a conversation with Sam Allberry, a pastor, speaker, author, and apologist. Book: https://us.10ofthose.com/product/9781433589157/one-with-my-lord-paperback

Join us for a conversation with Ross Ferguson, a student from Scotland with ten years of ministry experience, who is now studying at the Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. https://www.mbts.edu  

Join us for a conversation with Mack Stiles, author of multiple Christian books, and the director of Messenger Ministries Inc. He has been involved with missions for many years, and served as a pastor in the UAE and in IraqBooks: https://us.10ofthose.com/product/9781433544651/evangelism-hardback https://us.10ofthose.com/product/9781914966576/the-truth-about-lies-paperback https://us.10ofthose.com/product/9781433591723/how-do-i-get-started-in-evangelism-paperback  

Join us for a conversation with Brooks Buser, the President of Radius International and former missionary to Papua New Guinea. Articles: https://www.9marks.org/article/a-better-way-to-look-at-missions/ https://www.missionary.com/articles/dont-overlook-the-unreached  

Join us for a conversation with Bobby Jamieson, senior pastor of Trinity Baptist Church in Chapel Hill, North Carolina and the co-author of Biblical Reasoning: Christological and Trinitarian Rules for Exegesis. You can buy the book here: https://www.amazon.com/Biblical-Reaso...

Join us for a conversation with Sean DeMars, Pastor of 6th Avenue Community church and author of Redemption Song.

Join us for a conversation with Jim Hamilton, professor of biblical theology at The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary and Senior Pastor of Kenwood Baptist Church in Louisville, Kentucky. He has written numerous books, including God's Glory in Salvation through Judgment: A Biblical Theology and In the Beginning Was the Word: Finding Meaning in the Literary Structure of the Gospel of John You can buy the book here: https://bakerpublishinggroup.com/books/in-the-beginning-was-the-word/424461

Join us for a conversation with Dane Ortlund, senior pastor of Naperville Presbyterian Church in Naperville, Illinois. He is the author of Gentle and Lowly: The Heart of Christ for Sinners and Sufferers and Deeper: Real Change for Real Sinners. Worship Conference link: https://SEworship.eventbrite.com 9Marks Giveaway: 9marks.org/nuance If you are new to this channel, don't forget to subscribe! https://bit.ly/48UFgAt  

Join us for a conversation with Luke Hill, Pastoral Assistant at 6th Avenue Community church. 

Join us for a conversation with Tilly Dillehay, wife to Justin and mom to Norah, Agnes, and Henry. She is the author of Seeing Green: Don't Let Envy Color Your Joy, Broken Bread: How to Stop Using Food and Fear to Fill Spiritual Hunger, and My Dear Hemlock. Link to 9Marks giveaway: https://www.9marks.org/nuance/ Link to Worship Conference: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/southeast-worship-conference-tickets-1259612909119  

Join us for a conversation with Bob Kauflin, the Director of Sovereign Grace Music. Check out the Southeast Worship conference in Nashville: https://SEworship.eventbrite.com

Join us for a conversation with Michael Waugh, church member at 6th Avenue Community Church. 

Join us for a conversation with Jim Hamilton, professor of biblical theology at The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary and Senior Pastor of Kenwood Baptist Church in Louisville, Kentucky. He has written numerous books, including God's Glory in Salvation through Judgment: A Biblical Theology and What Is Biblical Theology? A Guide to the Bible's Story, Symbolism, and Patterns.   Link to the Southeast Worship Conference in Nashville, TN: https://SEworship.eventbrite.com

Join us for another conversation with Garrett Kell, lead pastor of Del Ray Baptist Church in Alexandria, Virginia, author, husband to his wife, Carrie, and father to their seven children.  Helpful resources for grieving: - Facing Grief by John Flavel: https://banneroftruth.org/us/store/christian-living/facing-grief/ - Songs of Suffering by Joni Eareckson Tada: https://us.10ofthose.com/product/9781433576409/songs-of-suffering-hardback - Dark Clouds, Deep Mercy by Mark Vroegop: https://us.10ofthose.com/product/9781433561481/dark-clouds-deep-mercy-paperback - Lord From Sorrows Deep I call: https://youtu.be/nATJFlTjJF0?si=iHhv3Qw0bls5du9_ - I Asked the Lord: https://youtu.be/YFsENAGs3gQ?si=Lnr92LuWWZTFsb1c

Join us for a conversation with Gavin Ortlund, the president of Truth Unites, visiting professor of historical theology at Phoenix Seminary, and theologian-in-residence at Immanuel Nashville. He is the author of several books, including The Art of Disagreeing, Why God Makes Sense in a World That Doesn't.

You asked, we answered... This is supposed to be fun! Enjoy!

Join us for a conversation with Mez McConnell, the director of 20Schemes and the author of numerous books, including The Creaking on the Stairs: Finding Faith in God Through Childhood Abuse and Is There Anybody Out There?: A Journey from Despair to Hope.

Join us for a conversation with Matthew McCullough, pastor of Edgefield Church in Nashville, Tennessee, and the author of Remember Heaven: Meditations on the World to Come for Life in the Meantime.   To sign up for the Southeast Worship Conference Click this link: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/southeast-worship-conference-tickets-1259612909119   If you are new to this channel, don't forget to subscribe!