Review that Review is a comedy podcast dedicated to reviewing... reviews! What 'Siskel & Ebert' did for cinematic masterpieces, we do for online reviews! Join hosts Chelsey Donn and Trey Gerrald as they review some of the wildest reviews to hit the internet.
Donate to Review That Review with Chelsey Donn & Trey Gerrald
The Review That Review with Chelsey Donn & Trey Gerrald podcast is an absolute gem that I stumbled upon before it even had any episodes released. From the moment I heard about the concept, I was hooked. This podcast is led by two incredibly talented individuals who know how to put on a show. The premise of the podcast is original and captivating, and the presentation is fun and engaging. I have no doubt that this show is going to go far!
One of the best aspects of this podcast is the chemistry between Chelsey and Trey. They are a hilarious duo who work seamlessly together to bring their unique insights to each episode. Their banter and comedic timing are top-notch, making every episode incredibly entertaining. I also appreciate their attention to detail and thoughtfulness when dissecting online reviews. Despite their humor, they manage to provide insightful analysis and put themselves in the shoes of the reviewers.
If there's one downside to this podcast, it's that there just isn't enough of it! I can't get enough of Chelsey and Trey's hilarious commentary on online reviews. They have completely changed my perspective on how I judge reviews, and now I always consider their criteria when reading them. It's a shame that they only release one episode a week because I eagerly await each new episode.
In conclusion, The Review That Review with Chelsey Donn & Trey Gerrald podcast is a true joy to listen to. It brings so much laughter and joy into my day, serving as a wonderful mid-week reprieve from darker podcasts. Chelsey and Trey are exceptional hosts who truly shine in their roles. If you love fun internet finds, positive comedy, cheeky jokes, wackadoos' opinions, and great chemistry between hosts, then this podcast is definitely worth checking out!
The Queens take a bite out of nostalgia and end up with a mouthful of disappointment. In this episode, Trey presents a scathing 1 Star Yelp Review of NYC's iconic Magnolia Bakery—specifically the once-revered banana pudding. Is it still worthy of the Sex and the City fame, or has it lost all its flavor?Before the pudding meltdown, Chelsey logs a customer service complaint we all can relate to—being trapped in the purgatory of endless department transfers. Then it's time for the Review Breakdown, where Chef Earth E. spills the (spoiled?) tea on cupcakes that taste like chemicals, banana pudding made of “whipped air,” and the death of culinary pride.⏰ Timestamps:(00:01:00) Lodge A Complaint – Endless Customer Service Loops(00:06:48) Review Breakdown – 1 Star Yelp Review of Magnolia Bakery(00:16:09) The Verdict(00:18:00) Magnolia's Reply Breakdown(00:18:46) My Royal Highness – Perfect Parking Moment(00:22:14) On This Week's After Show Pod – Penguin Overhead Mask ReviewEnjoyed the episode? Don't forget to rate and review us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen. Your support helps us grow!
Tensions run high as the Queens kvetch about bad drivers in left turn lanes, but the mood quickly softens thanks to a surprise birthday gift from Chelsey to Trey: an electric Shiatsu neck massager!
Welcome back, Queens! In Part 2 of this Versus Episode, Chelsey brings the glow-up with a 5 Star review of the same whitening powder, featuring a VIDEO review from a sweet but mysterious user named Sandra. The only problem? Sandra doesn't know the name of the product, is fully out of breath, and records her glowing recommendation… in the dark.
The Queens are back with another Versus Episode, and this time it's a battle of the smiles.
The Queens are getting their protein on... or are they? Chelsey brings in a TikTok review that single-handedly changed her purchase decision on a trending box of Prime Bites Protein Brownies. But it's not just any review—it's a dramatic, windy, zero-out-of-ten takedown by the now-iconic Mrs_Tink, complete with gagging, PR shoutouts, and beet juice comparisons.
“His Nuts Were HOWLING!” – Gay Erotica Goodreads Review Breakdown
The Queens take flight with a shockingly delightful 5 Star Amazon Review of the Mafiti Electrified Fly Swatter. Chelsey is buzzing with excitement (and just a little bit of moral conflict) over a product designed to literally zap flies into oblivion. Trey shares a deep-seated kvetch about people who face the wrong way in public spaces—elevators, theaters, treadmills... it's a directional disaster.But it's Linda, the reviewer, who steals the show. From a nursing home bed to viral-worthy video stardom, Linda's electrifying review (complete with skeeters, a long-haired chihuahua, and a pineapple box) stuns the Queens!PLUS: A video surprise, a cinema-worthy performance, and a Royal Highness moment that will make you believe in fate—and second chances.⏰ Timestamps:(00:00:00) Introduction(00:01:10) Lodge A Complaint(00:07:24) Review Breakdown(00:17:03) Surprise Video Reveal(00:18:50) The Verdict(00:24:01) My Royal Highness(00:30:44) On This Week's After Show PodEnjoyed the episode? Don't forget to rate and review us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen. Your support helps us grow!
The Queens are back for Part 2 of this Versus Episode, where things get spicy as they review a 1 Star Amazon Review of the Stanley Cup. Chelsey's reviewer might be mad at Target, delivery drivers, or Stanley itself—we're honestly not sure—but the drama is real and the emotional damage is done.
In this Versus Episode, the Queens are taking a sip from the viral tumbler that's flooded TikTok feeds everywhere: the Stanley Cup. Kicking off the Review Spectrum Comparison: a glowing 5 Star Amazon Review that includes a birthday gift, a dad on a mission, and a level of review detail that borders on forensic investigation.
Crocs… but make them fashion? The Queens are elevating their footwear game in Episode 201 with a jaw-dropping 5 Star Zappos Review of the infamous Siren Clogs by Crocs — a high-heeled Croc hybrid that defies fashion logic and maybe physics.
Can a $16 voodoo doll really change your fate—or is it just a cute piece of cloth? In this mystical and hilarious episode, Trey and Chelsey unpack a 1 Star Etsy review of a handmade voodoo doll from the shop LunaZingara. With mysterious intentions, spiritual consequences, and a seller reply that pulls no punches, this episode dives headfirst into the metaphysical (and the ridiculous).Chelsey battles earworm-induced nightmares while Trey literally crafts his own voodoo doll—yes, complete with a topknot and lashes. But when the actual review reveals a disgruntled buyer who bought four dolls and claims “nothing happened,” the Queens dig into what this Etsy review really says about intention, energy, and ethics.PLUS: Chelsey crowns a local muralist as her Royal Highness and the Queens debate the power of voodoo… and Yelp.Episode Highlights(00:01:08) Lodge A Complaint: Chelsey loses sleep thanks to earworms and anxiety dreams.(00:07:06) Review Breakdown: Trey reveals a 1 Star Etsy review for a voodoo doll from LunaZingara.(00:12:14) Review Reading: “Bought four dolls. Nothing happened.”
The Queens are tackling the ultimate moving dilemma in this Versus Episode, where they review both a 1 Star and 5 Star take on Royal Moving & Storage. Are they a reliable, professional moving company, or a red-flag-filled nightmare? Chelsey and Trey are here to break it all down!In Part 2, Trey presents a 1 Star Review from Samira A., whose experience with Royal Moving & Storage took a dark turn. After writing a glowing 5 Star Review at the insistence of a mover, Samira discovered she had been double-charged! Is this an isolated incident, or is there something shady going on?PLUS: The Queens take a spin on the Meryl-Go-Round, bringing their signature dramatic flair to some hilarious 1 Star zingers.Episode Highlights(00:00:35) Recap of Part 1 & the Royal Moving Controversy(00:01:00) The Meryl-Go-Round: Trey and Chelsey bring the drama to some epic 1 Star zingers.
The Queens are tackling the ultimate moving dilemma in this Versus Episode, where they review both a 1 Star and 5 Star take on Royal Moving & Storage. Are they a reliable, professional moving company, or a red-flag-filled nightmare? Chelsey and Trey are here to break it all down!In Part 1, Chelsey presents a 5 Star Review from TL, a stressed-out office tenant who needed to move a decade's worth of belongings in just one week! But was it too perfect? The Queens dissect every detail of this glowing review to see if it holds up under scrutiny.Plus: It's time for Move It or Lose It, a packing-themed trivia game where Trey must guess the correct moving techniques—or suffer hilarious consequences!Episode Highlights(00:01:00) Lodge A Complaint: Trey struggles with choosing the perfect e-signature—cursive? Comic Sans? Who decides?! ✍️
Palm trees, sunshine, and… LIES?! This week, the Queens head to Palm Springs for a 2 Star Review of Triada Palm Springs Autograph Collection that is long on mystery and short on details. Carrie C. has stayed here six times, but a shocking betrayal has her vowing never to return. What could it be? What is the truth? And most importantly—WHY WON'T SHE TELL US?!Trey and Chelsey break down this maddeningly vague review, try to decode the mystery, and debate whether this is a valid kvetch or just a dramatic exit. Episode Highlights(00:01:00) Lodge A Complaint: Trey has a bone to pick with people who park too close to the gym entrance.
Episode 195: Chiropractor - 1 Star Review
The Queens are putting love to the test in this Versus Episode, where they review both a 1 Star and 5 Star take on speed dating. Is NY Minute Dating a scam filled with actors pretending to be singles, or is it a real-life love connection waiting to happen?In Part 2, Trey presents a 5 Star Review from Elizabeth C., who swears she met her fiancé at one of these speed dating events.
The Queens are putting love to the test in this Versus Episode, where they review both a 1 Star and 5 Star take on speed dating. Is NY Minute Dating a scam filled with actors pretending to be singles, or is it a real-life love connection waiting to happen?In Part 1, Chelsey presents a 1 Star Review that exposes NY Minute Dating's alleged stand-in speed daters, fake matches, and secret staff participants. Is this reviewer onto something, or is this just the worst date night ever? Plus, Trey and Chelsey face off in a brand-new game: Crush or Crash!Episode Highlights:(00:01:09) Lodge A Complaint: Chelsey's label-maker order goes terribly wrong, leading to a bizarre delivery mix-up involving five pounds of hair weave.
In this terrifying episode, Trey and Chelsey dive into a 1 Star review of a Halloween Grandpa Mask from Temu. With misleading images, bizarre claims, and a final product that looks more like “roadkill than realism,” this review has the Queens howling. Complete with multimedia content, Trey even tests the mask live on camera—proving that sometimes, you get what you pay for.Episode Highlights:(00:01:02) Lodge A Complaint: Chelsey airs her frustration with Macy's disappointing plus-size department and the struggle of finding fashionable clothing in-store.(00:06:25) Review Breakdown: Trey presents Benjamin R's scathing 1 Star review of Temu's Halloween mask, complete with photos, a video, and a middle finger.(00:20:41) The Verdict: Trey and Chelsey crown Benjamin R as a Review Queen, applauding the detailed critique and entertaining content.(00:24:14) My Royal Highness: Chelsey celebrates the simple joy of feeling the wind through an open car window, likening it to freedom and connection.(00:27:01) On This Week's After Show Pod: The Queens tackle a 1 Star review of the Infinite Classroom app—because the horrors don't end with Halloween masks.Timestamps:(00:00:35) Introduction(00:01:02) Lodge A Complaint(00:06:25) Review Breakdown(00:20:41) The Verdict(00:24:14) My Royal Highness(00:27:01) On This Week's After Show PodEnjoyed the episode? Don't forget to rate and review us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen. Your support helps us grow!
Episode 192: Skims Micro Bikini - TikTok Review
Episode 187: Chocolate Shoppe - 2 Star Review
Episode 190 (Part 2): Versus Episode - YouTube App Reviews
Episode 190 (Part 1): Versus Episode - YouTube Reviews
This week, the Queens dive into a hilariously cheesy 2 Star Review of an 11-pound “wheel” of cheese from Amazon. When is a wheel not a wheel? When it's an oval! Trey and Chelsey dissect the outrageous claims of one disappointed cheese enthusiast.Episode Highlights:(00:07:00) Review: A cheese rolling competition disaster!(00:17:07) Crowning the Review(00:23:14) Royal Highness Induction: Trey crowns “Hiring a Professional” as his royal highness of the week, honoring the value of trusting experts!Timestamps:(00:00:33) Lodge A Complaint(00:07:00) Review(00:17:07) The Verdict(00:23:14) My Royal Highness (00:25:49) On This Week's After Show PodEnjoyed the episode? Don't forget to rate and review us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen. Your support helps us grow!
Episode 188: Premiere Video Episode: Clip-On Veneers - 1 Star Review
RE-VIEW: Planet Fitness (From Ep 30)
RE-VIEW ALERT: Revisiting Episode 26 of Review That Review – Hanukkah Special!
RE-VIEW ALERT: Holiday Showdown – Revisiting Episode 28 of Review That Review
RE-VIEW ALERT: Special Guest Episode with Mac Mart – Revisiting Episode 112 of Review That Review
RE-VIEW ALERT: Revisiting Episode 126 – Blue Mountain Family Restaurant Review
RE-VIEW ALERT: Revisiting Episode 07 – Ripley's Believe It or Not! & The Giving Tree Reviews
RE-VIEW ALERT: Revisiting Episode 10 – Mav Lash & Splash at the Boathouse Reviews
RE-VIEW ALERT: Special Guest Episode with Joe Kinosian – Revisiting Episode 128 of Review That Review
RE-VIEW ALERT: Revisiting Episode 50 – De Buena Planta & James P's Churros
RE-VIEW ALERT: Revisiting Episode 13 – Hex: Old World Witchery & The Haunted Stanley Hotel
RE-VIEW ALERT: Revisiting Episode 106 – Thruster's Lounge Yelp Drama
RE-VIEW ALERT: Special Guest Episode with Marc Tumminelli – Revisiting Episode 34 of Review That Review
RE-VIEW ALERT: Revisiting Episode 09 – Ross Dress For Less & Medieval Times Reviews
RE-VIEW ALERT: Revisiting Episode 31 – American Girl Doll & Aldi Reviews
RE-VIEW ALERT: Special Guest Episode with Natalie Weiss – Revisiting Episode 38 of Review That Review
RE-VIEW ALERT: First-Ever Versus Episode – Revisiting Episode 04 of Review That Review
RE-VIEW ALERT: Revisiting Episode 06 of Review That Review – Wish.com & Giant Inflatable Ball Madness
RE-VIEW ALERT: Revisiting Episode 14 of Review That Review – Nair for Men & Sesame Place
The Queens get digital as they delve into a 4.6 out of 9 TikTok review of Chocolate Frosted Donut KitKats. The Queens get mucky with JShock before they cut knowing eyes at one another. Plus, this episode includes a very major Announcement From The Queens.(01:11) Queendom Announcement!(03:49) Review(19:05) Exclusive Offer(25:49) My Royal Highness(29:31) On This Week's After Show PodReview The Pod at lovethepodcast.com/thereviewqueensDONATE to the Production of Review That Review by visiting ReviewThatReview.com/Donate Click Here to Join our Patreon for Bonus content and Member's Only After-Show Companion Podcast featuring additional reviews, deeper dives, salacious stories, and more.***** PROMO CODES *****REVIEWQUEEN at clean.emailREVIEW40 at vitable.com.auREVIEWQUEEN at shesbirdie.comREVIEWQUEEN40 at NatalieWeissVoice.comQUEEN15 at SmartPatches.comQUEEN at superchewer.com***Click Here to Join the Queendom Mailing List!Leave us a voicemail at 1-850-REVIEW-0WATCH CLIPS on YouTube!Visit our website for more: www.ReviewThatReview.com@TheReviewQueens | @ChelseyBD | @TreyGerrald ---Review That Review is an independent podcast. Executive Produced by Trey Gerrald and Chelsey Donn with editing and sound design by Trey Gerrald. Cover art designed by LogoVora, voiceover talents by Eva Kaminsky, and our theme song was written by Joe Kinosian and sung by Natalie Weiss.
The Queens go head-to-head in another VERSES Episode comparing both a 1 Star Review and a 5 Star Review for the same Plastic Surgery Center in California: BGMG Cosmetics. Chelsey quietly shares her loud issue and the Queens pull out their detective magnifying glasses to determine what's truly going on under the knife!(01:13) Lodge a Complaint!(05:11) BGMG Cosmetics in California(10:11) 1 Star Review(22:22) Plastic or Plastink?!(33:20) Exclusive Offer(36:15) There's A Reply!(41:25) SURPRISE!(45:49) On This Week's After Show PodReview The Pod at lovethepodcast.com/thereviewqueensDONATE to the Production of Review That Review by visiting ReviewThatReview.com/Donate Click Here to Join our Patreon for Bonus content and Member's Only After-Show Companion Podcast featuring additional reviews, deeper dives, salacious stories, and more.***** PROMO CODES *****REVIEWQUEEN at clean.emailREVIEW40 at vitable.com.auREVIEWQUEEN at shesbirdie.comREVIEWQUEEN40 at NatalieWeissVoice.comQUEEN15 at SmartPatches.comQUEEN at superchewer.com***Click Here to Join the Queendom Mailing List!Leave us a voicemail at 1-850-REVIEW-0WATCH CLIPS on YouTube!Visit our website for more: www.ReviewThatReview.com@TheReviewQueens | @ChelseyBD | @TreyGerrald ---Review That Review is an independent podcast. Executive Produced by Trey Gerrald and Chelsey Donn with editing and sound design by Trey Gerrald. Cover art designed by LogoVora, voiceover talents by Eva Kaminsky, and our theme song was written by Joe Kinosian and sung by Natalie Weiss.
The Queens rate and review a 5 Star Amazon Review for Furtalk Women's Beach Sun Straw Hat UV UPF50 Travel Foldable Brim Summer UV Hat. Chelsey questions the appropriateness of doctors soliciting reviews, the Queens feel pretty and witty and gay, and Chelsey does NOT know her boyfriend's name.(01:18) Lodge a Complaint!(04:58) Review(19:05) Exclusive Offer(22:18) My Royal Highness(25:17) On This Week's After Show PodReview The Pod at lovethepodcast.com/thereviewqueensDONATE to the Production of Review That Review by visiting ReviewThatReview.com/Donate Click Here to Join our Patreon for Bonus content and Member's Only After-Show Companion Podcast featuring additional reviews, deeper dives, salacious stories, and more.***** PROMO CODES *****REVIEWQUEEN at clean.emailREVIEW40 at vitable.com.auREVIEWQUEEN at shesbirdie.comREVIEWQUEEN40 at NatalieWeissVoice.comQUEEN15 at SmartPatches.comQUEEN at superchewer.com***Click Here to Join the Queendom Mailing List!Leave us a voicemail at 1-850-REVIEW-0WATCH CLIPS on YouTube!Visit our website for more: www.ReviewThatReview.com@TheReviewQueens | @ChelseyBD | @TreyGerrald ---Review That Review is an independent podcast. Executive Produced by Trey Gerrald and Chelsey Donn with editing and sound design by Trey Gerrald. Cover art designed by LogoVora, voiceover talents by Eva Kaminsky, and our theme song was written by Joe Kinosian and sung by Natalie Weiss.
The Queens give birth to a brand new episode this week as they rate and review a 5 Star Amazon Review for SafeRest 100% Waterproof Full Size Mattress Protector, Fitted with Stretchable Pockets, Machine Washable Cotton Mattress Cover for Bed, Perfect for Bedding AirBnb Essentials for Hosts. Trey wants the insides to not come to the outsides, Chelsey solves the issue, and suffice to say, things get royal!(01:02) Lodge a Complaint!(04:02) Review(15:49) Exclusive Offer(20:19) My Royal Highness(24:05) On This Week's After Show PodReview The Pod at lovethepodcast.com/thereviewqueensDONATE to the Production of Review That Review by visiting ReviewThatReview.com/Donate Click Here to Join our Patreon for Bonus content and Member's Only After-Show Companion Podcast featuring additional reviews, deeper dives, salacious stories, and more.***** PROMO CODES *****REVIEWQUEEN at clean.emailREVIEW40 at vitable.com.auREVIEWQUEEN at shesbirdie.comREVIEWQUEEN40 at NatalieWeissVoice.comQUEEN15 at SmartPatches.comQUEEN at superchewer.com***Click Here to Join the Queendom Mailing List!Leave us a voicemail at 1-850-REVIEW-0WATCH CLIPS on YouTube!Visit our website for more: www.ReviewThatReview.com@TheReviewQueens | @ChelseyBD | @TreyGerrald ---Review That Review is an independent podcast. Executive Produced by Trey Gerrald and Chelsey Donn with editing and sound design by Trey Gerrald. Cover art designed by LogoVora, voiceover talents by Eva Kaminsky, and our theme song was written by Joe Kinosian and sung by Natalie Weiss.
© 2020-2025 Ivy Podcast Discovery LLC
