Stab in the Back

Follow Stab in the Back
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

Dive into the dark world of true crime with us! Every week Benton & Anna review a case introduced to us by the campy world of true crime television documentaries. Watch with us as we have as much to say about the crime as we do about the production values.

Stab In The Back


    • Jun 3, 2025 LATEST EPISODE
    • monthly NEW EPISODES
    • 1h 35m AVG DURATION
    • 111 EPISODES

    5 from 34 ratings Listeners of Stab in the Back that love the show mention: stories, favorite, new, love, good, anna and benton.


    Ivy Insights

    The Stab in the Back podcast is an absolute gem for true crime enthusiasts. Not only does it offer gripping and well-researched stories, but it also brings a unique and entertaining twist to the genre. With themed cocktails, punny jokes, updates on Bubbles the chimp, and even grotesque presents for host Anna, this podcast goes above and beyond to keep its listeners engaged. The audio quality is top-notch, allowing for a seamless listening experience. From the very beginning, it is evident that hosts Anna and Benton are deeply passionate about true crime while maintaining a genuine respect for the darker aspects of these stories. They provide insightful discussions on broader ideas within the criminal justice system and criminal psychology, elevating the podcast beyond simply retelling murder tales.

    The best aspect of The Stab in the Back podcast lies in its delightful hosts, Anna and Benton. Their chemistry is palpable, creating an engaging dynamic that makes listeners feel like they are part of a lively conversation between friends. Their humor shines through as they inject witty banter into their storytelling. The games they play at the end of each episode add an extra layer of entertainment, showcasing their creativity and keeping the audience entertained until the very end. Furthermore, their storytelling skills are exceptional; they provide solid background information with attention to detail while ensuring their explanations never come across as exploitative or insensitive.

    While it's difficult to find any major flaws in this podcast, one minor drawback could be that some listeners may not resonate with the particular brand of humor employed by Anna and Benton. Humor can be subjective, and while many find their witty banter amusing, others may not share the same sentiment. However, given that humor plays a supporting role rather than being central to this true crime podcast's appeal, this drawback is likely negligible for most listeners.

    In conclusion, The Stab in the Back podcast stands out among its peers as a thoroughly enjoyable true crime experience. Anna and Benton's energy, knowledge, and chemistry make for delightful listening sessions. The unique elements they bring to the podcast, such as themed cocktails and punny jokes, add an extra layer of entertainment that sets it apart from other shows in the genre. With well-researched stories that delve into broader ideas within criminal justice and psychology, this podcast is a true gem for true crime enthusiasts. Whether you're multitasking at home or walking your dog, The Stab in the Back podcast is sure to become your new favorite companion.



    Search for episodes from Stab in the Back with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from Stab in the Back

    The Zodiass Killer

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 3, 2025 101:38


    Strap in, we're discussing copycat killers of all kinds! They say there are no original ideas, anymore. First, Benton tells the tragic tale of the murder of Cassie Jo Stoddart. Then, Anna recounts the chilling case of the Yorkshire Ripper, Peter Sutcliffe. Finally, the two watch an episode of Forensic Files, profiling the murders of Eddie Seda.Our TV doc this week is Season 8: Episode 25 of Forensic Files, "Sign of the Zodiac".

    Mommy and Clyde

    Play Episode Listen Later May 13, 2025 117:27


    Get ready for another creepy and disturbing Mother's Day episode of Stab in the Back! First, Benton shares thee infamous story of Susan Smith and the murders of her two children, Michael and Alex. Then, Anna tells the horrible tale of Debra Jeter's deadly. attack on her two daughters. Finally, the two settle in for an episode of Dateline, profiling the con artist Sante Kimes.Our TV doc this week is Season 33: Episode 13 of Dateline, "The Devil Wore White".

    Girl, You'll Be a Woman Soon-Yi

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 15, 2025 109:40


    How many celebrities have done some horrible things in the past that we've all forgotten about? That is the theme of this week's episode, and you'd be surprised how many that question applies to.First, Benton tells the tale of Woody Allen's questionable relationship with his former daughter, Soon-Yi Previn. Then, Anna relays the tragic tale of Matthew Broderick and Jennifer Grey's deadly car accident inn Ireland. Finally, the two discuss an episode of Cursed Films, profiling the fatal on set accident during the filming of The Twilight Zone: The Movie. Our TV doc this week is Season 1: Episode 5 of Cursed Films, "The Twilight Zone: The Movie"

    Cancer Ahead, Chemo-Sabe!

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 1, 2025 113:32


    Sometimes you know someone who is always sick, always getting tests done, needing you to acknowledge their struggle. It could be plain ol' Munchausen Syndrome! First, Anna gives a rundown of the type of behaviors exhibited by this type of personality, and Benton tells o the mysterious skin disorder, Morgellon's Disease. Then, Anna relays the life story of disgraced wellness influencer Belle Gibson, who faked her cancer diagnoses for financial gain. Finally the two watch an episode of Something's Killing Me, profiling the Munchausen syndrome case of Hope Ybarra.Our TV doc this week is Season 1: Episode 1 of Something's Killing Me, "Hope". 

    Folie à Deux...Quatre!

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 11, 2025 112:37


    Hey, Backstabbers!  Welcome to our 4th annual Folie à Deux episode. As it is our 4th time around, please indulge us as we play fast and loose with the topic.First, Benton tells of the infamous torture and murder of Sylvia Likens. Then, Anna gives us a look at the shared psychosis of the Tromp family in southeastern Australia. Finally, the two get comfortable and watch a classic case of Cold Case Files, profiling the murder of Jack Irwin.Our TV doc this week is Season 5: Episode 18 of Cold Case Files, "The Girls".

    Cedar Point of No Return

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 25, 2025 113:26


    Have you ever wondered if the roller coaster your'e on is safe? That is the theme of this week's episode, and you'd be surprised how often the answer is no!.First, Anna shares some information about theme park accidents and the various injuries that can occur any day, and Benton tells the tale of the tragic death of Deborah Stone. Then, Anna relays the tragic tale of the Battersea Park Funfair disaster. Finally, the two discuss a Youtube Disasterthon video, profiling the death of James Young.

    Dennis the Menace

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 4, 2025 119:19


    Are you a psychopath? Its possible! But you're probably not as bad as these lovely characters on this week's episode, the psychopath episode!First, Anna gives some general info on psychopathy and how it manifests, and Benton relays the story of Joanna Dennehy's unhinged murder spree in Great Britain. Then, Anna tells the tragic tale of blood countess and possible mass murderer Elizabeth Báthory. Finally, the two watch a classic episode of Cold Case Files, profiling the infamous serial killler Dennis Rader.Our TV doc this week is Season 5: Episode 8 of Cold Case Files, "Finding BTK".

    Holding Space for Amnesia

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 10, 2024 128:26


    How do you do, fellow Backstabbers?! We are your hosts, Benton and Anna, in case you've lost your memory. And memory loss is just what this episode is about!First, Anna gives a rundown on the generalities of amnesia, and Benton goes over the details of Agatha Christie's 11 day disappearance I 1926. Then, Anna tells the tale of the notorious Anna Anderson, who impersonated Anastasia Romanov. Finally, the two watch a documentary about the life of Richard Minnich, amnesiac.Our TV doc this week is "Forgetting Dad".

    Suffocate Middleton

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 26, 2024 111:19


    Some methods of murder are much more disturbing than others, and Episode 101 takes a look at the specific act of strangulation. First, Anna gives us a glimpse into the reasons why one may kill in such a way, and Benton tells the horrible tale of thee Foundling Wheel Killer, Luisa de Jesus. Then, Anna relays the story of Albert DeSalvo, who confessed to being the Boston Strangler. Finally, the two watch a classic episode of Forensic Files, profiling the murders of the South Side Strangler in Richmond, Virginia.Our TV doc this week is Season 1: Episode 6 of Forensic Files, “South Side Strangler".

    SITB Episode 100 Film Festival Spooktacular!

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 4, 2024 126:01


    Welcome to the second Stab in the Back Film Watch-along! To celebrate Episode 100, we watch the vampire classic, Interview with the Vampire. Watch along with us as we provide unparalleled commentary!

    Lice Krispy Treats

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 9, 2024 113:04


    Who's ready for some of the grossest pieces of evidence we've ever seen?! Sometimes it's not just blood ad guts! First, Benton tells the tale of Mark Redwine and a very special set of photographs. Then, Anna shares the story of Meredith Kercher's murder, and why you should always flush the toilet. Finally, the two watch the nastiest episode of Forensic Files ever made, profiling the murders of the Newman family in Achorage.Our TV doc this week is Season 5: Episode 7 of Forensic Files, “Trail of Truth”.

    R.I.P.?! More like BRB!

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 24, 2024 119:09


    They say you only die once, but some people seem to do it for sport! This episode is all about people who fake their own death, and have to explain why they're making such a stunning career move. First, Anna share a few bits of information on why a person may fake their own death, and Benton tells the tale of poisoner and murderer, Audrey Marie Hilley. Then, Anna shares the antics of evangelist Aimee McPherson. Finally the two watch a favorite episode of Cold Case Files, profiling the faked death of Clay Daniels.Our TV doc this week is Season 11: Episode 16 of Forensic Files, “Grave Danger".

    Butt I Thought We Were Friends?

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 4, 2024 97:33


    Have you ever seen a doctor and wondered if they were a quack? Maybe they are! Medical fraud is the focus of Episode 98!First, Benton tells of the many products containing radioactive material at the turn of the 20th century that probably did more harm than good. Then, Anna relays the case of Jacques Roy, one of the biggest Medicare fraudsters in history. Finally, the two watch a truly iconic episode of American Greed, profiling the illegal practice of back ally silicone butt injections.Our TV doc this week is the first half of Season 10: Episode 4 of American Greed, “Vanity and Greed: Deadly Beauty”.

    Stuck in the Middle with You

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 19, 2024 114:18


    Did a dingo eat that baby? You'll find out soon! This week's episode is all about strange and unusual deaths that you wouldn't see coming.First, Benton relays two stories of death resulting from being trapped, first in a laundry closet and then in a gap behind a supermarket freezer. Then, Anna tells the well publicized story of Azaria Chamberlain, who was carried off by a dingo in the Australian outback. Finally, the two watch an episode of Curious and Unusual Deaths, profiling 3 deaths caused by pressure.Our TV doc this week is Season 2: Episode 13 of Curious and Unusual Deaths, “Death Under Pressure”.

    Paint the Town Dead

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 17, 2024 115:07


    Do artists kill people? Some do, and Episode 96 profiles a few creative people who definitely shouldn't get top prize.First, Benton tells the tale of children's book artist Harry Horse and his murder-suicide, and Anna gives us the details of artist Richard Dadd's troubled life. Then, the two watch a classic episode of City Confidential, profiling the death of SoHo artist Ana Mendieta.Our TV doc this week is City Confidential Season 1: Episode 17, "SoHo: The Art of Murder".

    Women, Am I Right Fellas?

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 2, 2024 123:22


    Have you ever wondered if the vehicle you're on could be hijacked? Episode 95 is for you! First, Anna goes over the history of hijackings specific to the aviation industry, and Benton tells of the mundane but internet famous hijacking off EgyptAir Flight 181. Then, Anna relays everything we know about the mysterious hijacker, B.D. Cooper. Finally, the two watch a documentary profiling the infamous school bus hijacking of Chowchilla, California.Our TV doc this week is Chowchilla on Max.

    Tattoo-ine, The Desert Planet

    Play Episode Listen Later May 31, 2024 109:43


    For Episode 94 of Stab in the Back, we look into the phenomenon of murdered and missing Indigenous women, referred to as MMIW.First, Anna provides some information on why this group might be more susceptible to crime, and Benton gives a rundown on Canada's dangerous Trail of Tears. Then, Anna relays the tragic and mysterious death of Olivia Lone Bear. Finally, the two watch an episode of Cold Case Files, profiling the murder of Shirley Soosay.Our TV doc this week is Season 2: Episode 26 of Cold Case Files(Reboot), "Missing and Murdered".

    UFO No She Didn't!

    Play Episode Listen Later May 14, 2024 113:04


    Are you ready for more cult action? Episode 93 is all about the more benign cults that may fly under the radar, but still pose a threat to vulnerable people.First, the two discuss what makes a person more susceptible to getting sucked into a cult, and Benton shares the beliefs of UFO religious leader Raël and his group of Raëlians. Then, Anna tells of the current communal group of off-grid survivalists known as The Garden. Finally, Benton and Anna settle in to watch the documentary "Holy Hell", profiling the spiritualist cult known as Buddhafield.Our TV doc this week is "Holy Hell: 22 Years Inside a Modern Cult".

    Crony Bennett's Greatest Hits

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 17, 2024 99:47


    Episode 92 is all about cover ups! Sometimes it's before an investigation can even take place. First, Anna gives a small rundown on how justice can be thwarted early on, and Benton gives the details on the tragic death of Kendrick Johnson. Then, Anna tells the sordid tales of Warren G. Harding.Finally, the two settle in for a classic episode of Cold Case Files, profiling the death of Kimberly White.Our TV doc this week is the second half of Season 3: Episode 11, "The Bad Cop".

    Babes in Sex Toyland (3rd Anniversary Episode)

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 27, 2024 117:44


    Happy 3rd anniversary to Stab in the Back! Join Benton and Anna as they reminisce and discuss another year gone by, and invite a few special guests to share their favorite true crime stories. First, we welcome back one of Anna's best friends, Casey, who relays the murder of Austin jewelry store owner Ted Shaughnessy. Then, we welcome back Benton's partner, Matt, who tells the tale of Italian politician Aldo Moro's kidnapping and assassination. Also, play along to Anna's game, "Medieval torture device or new Target sex toy?", and stay for the 3rd annual Stabby Awards!

    Chef Buoyant Dee

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 12, 2024 111:40


    Was it an accident, a suicide, or a murder? That is the theme of this week's episode, and you'd be surprised how often that question is asked.First, Anna shares some information about accidents and why they might fly under the radar as unexplained deaths, and Benton tells the tale of the mysterious death of Gareth Williams. Then, Anna relays the tragic tale of the puzzling death of Laura Letts-Beckett. Finally, the two discuss a classic episode of Forensic Files, profiling the death of Janice Johnson. Our TV doc this week is Season 4: Episode 9 of Forensic Files, "Accident or Murder?"

    Folie à Deux: Trois!

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 20, 2024 89:18


    Strap in, it's the annual Valentine's Day episode! Crimes involving folie à deux are the gifts that keep on giving, and this episode focuses on more than 2 people being in on the delusion. First, Anna goes down the list of how people can develop such shared delusions, and Benton tells the tragic tale of the mass suicide of the Chundawat family. Then, Anna recounts the case of three sisters who fed into each other's religious fanaticism. Finally, the two watch an episode of Forensic Files, profiling the notorious BJ and Erika Sifrit.Our TV doc this week is Season 13: Episode 47 of Forensic Files, "Dirty Little Secret".

    Anne of the Thousand Slays

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 6, 2024 99:16


    Have you ever wondered how safe it is to work as a news anchor? Then episode 88 is for you, because they get murdered, too! First, Anna and Benton discuss why news anchors might have an elevated level of danger, and Benton tells of the senseless murder of Anne Pressly. Then, Anna relays the story of thee stalking/murder of Katherine Dettman. Finally, the two watch a classic episode of Forensic Files, profiling the murder of anchorwoman Diane King.Our TV doc this week is Season 9: Episode 5 of Forensic Files, "News at 11".

    Alice in Murderland

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 17, 2024 97:59


    Have you ever had a bad neighbor? For our first show of the new year, we dive into murders in the community between people who live in close proximity with each other. First, Benton tells the tale of Melanie Smith, who burned 5 members of her neighbor's family to death, and Anna relays the tragic story of the Pike County murders. Lastly, the two enjoy a classic episode of American Justice, profiling the murder of Bobby Kent.Our TV doc this week is Season 8: Episode 33 of American Justice, "Payback for a Bully".

    Raspberry Benét (Live at Brother Friend)

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 5, 2023 82:28


    Our first live show! For Episode 86, Benton and Anna attempt to condense the story of Jonbenét Ramsey into a tight hour and a half. Please enjoy our thoughts on this whopper of a crime, as well as our opinions on who might have done it.A very special thank you to Tim and Evan at Brother Friend for hosting us and supporting our podcast, we love you!

    Too Dracul For School

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 30, 2023 113:14


    How do you do, fellow Halloween kids?! Welcome to a very special episode of Stab in the Back, where Benton and Anna take a look at torture methods in medieval times, as well as some of its practitioners.First, Anna gives a rundown on thee generalities of torture in the middle ages, and Benton Benton presents a list of especially horrible forms of torture. Then, Anna tells the tale of the notorious Vlad the Impaler, inspiration for Count Dracula. Finally, the two watch a documentary about the Tower of London's most famous executioner, Bloody Bonner.Our TV doc this week is "The Psychopathis Executioner of the Tower of London | Tales from the Tower" from Chronicle.

    Two Wrongs Don't Make A Write

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 28, 2023 107:54


    Do you have any authors in your life? They may be hiding a dark secret in some of their work, and it just might mean murder! Episode 84 is all about writers involved in the deaths of themselves or others. First, Benton tells the tale of Syndrome author Blake Leibel's murder of Iana Kasian. Then, Anna relays the tragic story of Kenneth Halliwell and Joe Orton's murder-suicide. Lastly, the two watch an episode of World's Most Evil Killers, profiling the serial killer Jack Unterweger.Our TV doc this week is Season 2: Episode 9 of World's Most Evil Killers, "Jack Unterweger".

    The Parent Trap

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 12, 2023 118:04


    Hey, Backstabbers!  Have you ever had your identity stolen? You'll be glad that it wasn't by one of these hustlers in Episode 83. First, Anna gives a rundown on how identity theft has always been with us, but much easier it is in the digital world of today, and Benton tells of the infamous Chameleon Killer, Elaine Parent. Then, Anna gives us a look at credit card fraud gone wild with David Matthew Read. Finally, the two get comfortable and watch a classic case of Forensic Files, profiling the murder of Paul Gruber.Our TV doc this week is Season 11: Episode 28 of Forensic Files, "If I Were You".

    1947 (Taylor's Version)

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 29, 2023 117:32


    Attention all armchair detective Backstabbers, this episode is all about the coldest of cold cases! First, Anna gives some numbers on how many crimes go unsolved, and Benton tells the tale of San Francisco's unknown serial killer, the Doodler. Then, Anna relays the story of Edgar Allen Poe's mysterious death in 1849. Finally, the two watch a classic episode of Cold Case Files, profiling the murder of Elizabeth Short, otherwise known as the Black Dahlia.Our TV doc this week is Season 6: Episode 6 of Cold Case Files, "The Black Dahlia".

    Backstabbers' Film Festival #1...Silence of the Lambs!

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 31, 2023 122:33


    Hey Backstabbers! This really isn't an episode, but we thought it'd be fun if we recorded a viewing of the absolutely classic piece of cinema known as...The Silence of the Lambs!We have a pretty sizable gap between episodes around now due to vacation time, so we thought this would tickle your fancy. Watch along with us! Have a laugh! Wee streamed on Max and a prompt will be given at the proper time to press play if you'd like to watch along with us.

    Total Eclipse of the Hart

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 18, 2023 110:22


    Some crimes are much worse than others, and Episode 81 takes a look at the specific methods of murder known as familicide and family annihilation. First, Anna gives us a glimpse into the reasons why one may commit such a crime, and Benton tells the horrible tale of Jennifer and Sarah Hart's murder suicide. Then, Anna relays the story of Xavier Dupont, who disappeared after murdering his entire family. Finally, the two watch a classic episode of City Confidential, profiling the murders of the Defeo family in Amityville, New York.Our TV doc this week is Season 6: Episode 8 of City Confidential, "Horror in Amityville".

    Teacher From the Black Lagoon

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 4, 2023 105:20


    See that school? Keep your eyes peeled, those teachers may not have the best intentions, they may be killers! First, Benton relays the story of Carolyn Warmus, a woman who earned the nickname 'Fatal Attraction Killer'. Then, Anna recounts the murder of Kathy Essery at the hands of Nathaniel Mellerson. Finally, the two settle in for a classic episode of Forensic Files, profiling the murder of Avis Banks.Our TV doc this week is Season 14: Episode 9 of Forensic Files, "Textbook Murder".

    A Matter of Wife and Death

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 20, 2023 112:50


    They say it's usually the husband. Sometimes that's true many times over! This episode is all about so called Blue Beards, men who kill more than one wife. First, Anna share a few bits of information on how so-called Blue Beards operate, and Benton tells the tale of double wife murderer Earl Taylor. Then, Anna shares the sinister story of Johann Otto Hoch, a bigamist who may have killed up to 50 women. Finally the two watch a favorite episode of Cold Case Files, profiling the murders of John Smith.Our TV doc this week is Season 2: Episode 9 of Cold Case Files, "Lady in the Box".

    15 Seconds of Frame

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 6, 2023 102:24


    Have you ever been blamed for something you didn't do? It sucks! But that pales in comparison to truly being framed, which is the focus of Episode 78!First, Anna goes over some of the ways a person can be put away for a crime they didn't commit, and Benton tells the strange tale of Barry Ardolf and his reign of terror via a hacked wifi network. Then, Anna relays the frame up of Floyd Bledsoe by his brother Tom. Finally, the two watch a truly iconic episode of Dateline, profiling the three alleged murders by Pamela Hupp.Our TV doc this week is Season 30: Episode 22 of Dateline, "The Real Thing About Pam".

    The Talented Mr. Tickles

    Play Episode Listen Later May 23, 2023 94:38


    Happy Mother's Day, Backstabbers! Welcome to Episode 77, where mothers will do any manner of unspeakable things for their children. First, Benton tells the sordid tale of the murder for hire plot to kill Emilia Raras' own daughter-in-law, Sara. Then, Anna relays the story of Wanda Holloway, who chose murder to help advance her daughter's chances of making the cheerleading squad. Finally, the two settle in for a classic episode of Cold Case Files, profiling Esther Kahut, notorious member of a Portland crime family.Our TV doc this week is the first half of Season 4: Episode 18 of Cold Case Files, "The Family".

    Alvin and the Ridleys, Ft. Virginia

    Play Episode Listen Later May 2, 2023 107:26


    Get ready for a doozy! This episode is all about people who were kept captive and locked away by their family members, only to be discovered decades later. First up. is Benton, with the terrible story of Elisabeth Fritzl, who was imprisoned by her father Josef for 25 years, and Anna tells the tale of Blanche Monnier, who was imprisoned by her mother and brother before being discovered a few decades later emaciated and filthy in a locked room in their mansion. Then, the two watch a classic episode of Forensic Files, profiling the mysterious death of recluse Virginia Ridley. Our TV doc this week is Season 5: Episode 9 of Forensic Files, "Kill-igraphy".

    Break a Leg!

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 18, 2023 81:05


    Have you ever wondered what the weirdest murder weapon might have been? Then episode 75 is for you! First, Anna and Benton discuss why weapons can be, and often are completely random nearby objects, and Benton tells of a homemade suicide helmet and the murder of a man using a prosthetic leg. Then, Anna relays the story of a man murdered with a loaf of bread, and a seemingly innocent conch shell that held the key to a case. Finally, the two watch a classic episode of Forensic Files, profiling the murder of Denise O'neill.Our TV doc this week is Season 13: Episode 49 of Forensic Files, "Pet Rock".*Production Note: Please excuse the first 20 minutes of audio, Benton's feed was inadvertently recorded through the Mac's microphone.

    Hell Hath No Curry

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 4, 2023 101:10


    Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned! This episode is all about women who attempt to get back at the men in their lives, to varying degrees of success. First, Anna makes a few points about why a scorned woman may plot to kill, and Benton tells the tale of Brian Sugrim and his eventual arrest.  Then, Anna shares the poisonous plot of Lakhvir Singh. Finally, the two settle in for a classic episode of Cold Case Files, profiling the murder of sailor Jerry McClendon by Roxanna Latham and David Deshazo.Our TV doc this week is Season 1: Episode 26 of Cold Case Files, "The Baiting Game".

    Over My Dead Bodyguard

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 15, 2023 113:07


    Do you like music? We like music, too! But sometimes. the musicians we know and love murder people, and that's what Episode 73 is all about. First, Benton tells the tale of Big Lurch's murder of Tynisha Ysais due to drug induced psychosis, and then Anna relays the tragic tale of the death of Keith Moon's bodyguard, Neil Boland. Finally, the two watch a documentary about Sid Vicious and the mysterious death of Nancy Spungen. Did Sid do it?Our documentary this week is Sad Vacation: The Last Days of Sid and Nancy.

    So Quiet, You Can Hear a Twin Drop

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 28, 2023 97:32


    Do you ever see someone following you out of the corner of your eye, and they look exactly like you? They're your twin, and they want to murder you. Just kidding! But this episode IS all about twins and the special bond they can share. First, Anna shares a few details about how twins differ from the rest of us on a DNA level, and Benton tells the unbelievable story of June and Jennifer Gibbons. Then, Anna relays the bizarre tale of Sabina and Ursula Eriksson. Finally, the 2 settle in for a classic episode of Forensic Files, profiling the conspiratorial murder of Dr. Jack Wilson.Our TV doc this week is Season 1: Episode 8 of Forensic Files, "The Wilson Murder".Also, a special happy birthday to Matt! Love ya!

    Folie à Deux: Deux

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 14, 2023 111:02


    Hey backstabbers, get ready for a rough one! We're back with another Valentine's Day episode all about the shared psychosis known as folie à deux. First, Anna gives a rundown on the actual definition and diagnosis of the disorder, and Benton tells the horrible tale of the Sunset Strip Killers in Los Angeles. Then, Anna relays the story of the infamous Papin sisters. Finally, the two settle in for a documentary on the legendary Bonnie & Clyde.Our TV doc this week is Season 28: Episode 1 of American Experience, "Bonnie & Clyde".

    Not Just a Phrogment of Your Imagination

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 30, 2023 110:35


    Want to be creeped out? In this episode, Benton and Anna discuss the phenomenon of phrogging, or the act of living in a dwelling amongst us unknowingly. First, Anna gives a rundown on the differences between phroggers and squatters, and Benton shares the incredibly frightening crimes of Daniel Laplante. Then, Anna tells the tale of how a phrogger lived in the home of Stacy Ferrance, who couldn't understand why Christmas presents and food kept disappearing. Finally, the two watch a show all about phrogging, detailing the harrowing home invasion of James and Brittany Campbell.Our TV doc this week is Season 1: Episode 1 of Phrogging: Hider in My House, "Bump in the Night".

    Soap-rise! It's People (2nd Anniversary Episode)

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 17, 2023 126:39


    Happy 2nd anniversary to Stab in the Back! Join Benton and Anna as they reminisce and discuss Lizzie Borden's meatloaf recipe, and invite a few special guests to share their favorite true crime stories. First up, we welcome back Benton's partner Matt to tell the horrifying tale of the Soap Maker of Correggio. Then, we welcome one of Anna's best friends, Casey, who relays her hometown's most infamous crime, the axe murder of Betty Gore in Wylie, Texas. Also, play along to Anna's game, "Paula Deen or Charles Manson?", and stay for the 2nd annual Stabby Awards!

    Rebel Without a Claus

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 7, 2022 109:22


    Strap in, it's the annual Christmas episode! Santa can sometimes be a little naughty, himself, and this episode's stories prove it. First, Anna goes down the list of the crimes that occur more often around the holidays, and Benton tells the tragic tale of the Covina Massacre in Covina, California. Then, Anna recounts the case of the bank robbing Santa Claus, Marshall Ratliff. Finally, the two watch an episode of the rebooted Cold Case Files, profiling the murders of Ed and Minnie Maurin.Our TV doc this week is Season 6: Episode 2 of Cold Case Files(Reboot Season), "Killings on Christmas Eve".

    Ain't Mutton Like the Real Thing, Baby

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 22, 2022 91:14


    Gobble Gobble! Welcome to our Thanksgiving episode, Backstabbers! Have you heard of parricide? It defines the murder of a parent by a child, and we've got some stories for you! First, Anna gives a few important details on kids who kill their parents, and Benton tells of the murders of Blake and Mary Jo Hadley by their son Tyler right before throwing a high school party. Then,  Anna revisits the classic tale of alleged axe murderer Lizzie Borden. Finally, the two watch a very special Forensic Files, profiling the murder of socialite Bette Lucas in Tyler, Texas.Our TV doc this week is Season 11: Episode 37, "Step by Step".

    Bernie Goetz What Bernie Wants

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 7, 2022 95:15


    Have you ever wanted to take the law into your own hands? These people did! This week's episode is all about vigilante justice and how we rationalize it based on who the victims are. First, Anna gives a rundown on some of the reasons we may go into Robin Hood mode, and Benton tells of the "unsolved" murder of town bully Ken McElroy. Then, Anna shares the tragic story of Miriam Rodríguez Martínez, who tracked down 10 of her murdered daughter's kidnappers. Finally, the two watch a classic episode of American Justice, detailing some of America's most famous examples of vigilante justice.Our TV doc this week is Season 2: Episode 25 of American Justice, "Vigilante Justice".

    Eat, Drink and Be Buried

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 25, 2022 98:43


    Boo! It's the annual Halloween episode! In this hodge podge of an episode,  Benton and Anna pick a medley of spooktacular topics to creep you you out. First, Benton tells of the fear and hysteria that almost every society had about being possibly buried alive, and Anna takes us on a journey to Marfa, Texas to learn about the mysterious Marfa Lights. Then, the two watch an episode of Forensic Files, profiling the murders of Leslie Mazzara and Adriane Insogna on Halloween night.Our TV doc this week is Season 12: Episode 4 of Forensic Files, "Good as Gold".

    So I Married an Anthrax Murderer

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 11, 2022 101:23


    You want a scoop?! This week's episode is all about journalists who find themselves in the path of murder! First,  Anna shares some info on the risks a reporter might be taking when pursuing a story, and Benton tells of the on air murder of correspondent Alison Parker and cameraman Adam Ward. Then, Anna relays the story of the death of Robert Stevens by Anthrax in the wake of 9/11. Finally, the two watch a riveting documentary profiling the murder of Kim Wall by Danish entrepreneur Peter Madsen.Our doc this week is Into the Deep (on Netflix as of this writing)

    I Got 99 Problems but a Blitz Ain't One

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 26, 2022 97:20


    Get ready for another creepy and disturbing episode of Stab in the Back! This time we're traveling around the world to shed some light on foreign serial killers, and you won't be disappointed! First, Anna shares some stats on which countries have the most serial killers and why, and Benton endeavors to destroy all of us with the horrible crimes of Anatoly Slivko. Then, Anna tells the creepy tale of thee Black Magic Killer, Ahmad Suradji. Finally, the two settle in for an episode of Murder Maps, profiling the Blackout Ripper, Gordon Cummins.Our TV doc this week is Season 2: Episode 2 of Murder Maps, "The Blackout Ripper".

    Diaper? I've Never Even Met Her!

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 14, 2022 95:30


    Lock that door, someone might have you on the brain! Get ready for a gloriously unhinged episode about crimes of passion! First, Anna goes over the particulars of how a person may "snap", and do harm when they otherwise wouldn't, and Benton tells of Astronaut Lisa Nowak's assault on Colleen Shipman at Orlando International Airport. Then, Anna relays the event surrounding Marvin Gaye's death at the hands of his own father. Finally, the two settle in for a classic episode of American Justice, featuring the saga of Joey Buttafuoco and Amy Fisher, the "Long Island Lolita".Our TV doc this week is Season 7: Episode 5 of American Justice, "Killing in the Name of Love".

    KGB and the Sunshine Band

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 29, 2022 107:34


    Are we secret agents? If we told you, we'd have to kill you. But this episode is all about them, so get ready! First, Anna gives a rundown of the type of espionage a government may take part in, and Benton tells the mysterious tale of Georgi Markov's assassination in London in 1978. Then, Anna relays the career of disgraced FBI agent Robert Hanssen, who worked as a double agent for the Soviet Union and Russia. Finally the two watch a classic episode of American Justice, profiling the thallium poisoning of Peggy Carr.Our TV doc this week is Season 9: Episode 16 of American Justice, "Kill Thy Neighbor". While unavailable to stream, it can be found at the link below:https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x3eik9c

    Claim Stab in the Back

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel