Podcast appearances and mentions of anthony volpe

The Yankees' struggling offense has reached the point where Evan Roberts believes Brian Cashman must call up George Lombard Jr. immediately. Evan argues that Jose Caballero and Anthony Volpe have already shown what they are, while Lombard could provide the jolt the lineup desperately needs. Tiki Barber urges caution about throwing a young prospect into a pennant race, and Shaun Morash wonders whether the Yankees are saving Lombard for after the trade deadline. The conversation shifts to a lost Mets season, Keith Hernandez and Gary Cohen sounding increasingly fed up, and even Donald Trump taking a shot at the team. Evan, Tiki and Shaun also debate the excitement surrounding John Harbaugh and the Giants, why his résumé gives his message credibility, and whether universal optimism should make Giants fans nervous.

The Yankees' offense needs an immediate jolt, and Evan Roberts is demanding that Brian Cashman call up George Lombard Jr. now. Evan argues that Jose Caballero and Anthony Volpe have already shown they are not the long-term answer at shortstop, while Lombard's hot bat and major league-ready defense make him the most exciting option available. Tiki Barber agrees with the idea but warns that a rookie could struggle under postseason pressure, while Shaun Morash believes Lombard could also solve the Yankees' problems at third base. They debate whether Volpe should be sent down, whether Lombard is being protected as a trade chip, and why waiting until September could waste the prospect's chance to transform the season.

Boomer and Gio dive into their favorite things about Fire Island multiple callers that Al usually blocks get on the air. Is it better to work in the morning or the afternoon? Jerry's update starts with talking about Anthony Volpe finally coming through in a big spot. The guys debate whether or not rivalries in golf are good for the sport. Gio gives a review of Death of a Salesman on Broadway.

Jerry's update starts with Anthony Volpe finally coming through in a big spot. The Mets were being a mess. The guys debate whether or not rivalries in golf are good for the sport.

Boomer and Gio open with makeup fixes, a SiriusXM recap, Harbaugh's flat Giants speech, Jerry's dinner report, Caballero's pitch clock issue during the Yankees' split, the Mets' abysmal defense, Heyman's X fight, and defining "cuck." Then, they dive into Fire Island, rogue callers slipping past Al, morning vs. afternoon shifts, Anthony Volpe's big moment, golf rivalries, and a Death of a Salesman review. Hour three brings a CBS Sports graphic blunder, Max Fried's return, secret MLB rule changes, early football hype, Cleveland's LeBron pitch, and golf course drink etiquette. Finally, they close with Fire Island weekend plans, Jaxson Dart and Jets outlooks, Kendrick Perkins' LeBron conspiracy, Jerry's health and verbal stumbles, the show's post-Boomer future, LeBron chatter, and whether Juan Soto is irking his teammates.

Spencer Jones is called up as the Yankees' 27th man and immediately placed third in the lineup, leaving Evan Roberts with one glaring question: If the Yankees trust him in the heart of an offense that cannot score, why is he still in the minor leagues? Evan argues Jones deserves an extended opportunity and questions why Anthony Volpe continues to hold a roster spot, while Tiki Barber explains the matchup and playing-time complications.

Jose Caballero's pitch clock gamesmanship has opponents furious, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why his ability to get under their skin could make him even more valuable to the Yankees. They also debate whether Anthony Volpe deserves to lose playing time and why Dennis Santana's reaction missed the mark. The conversation turns to grim Jets predictions, the team's new white uniforms, a welcome gesture from the Mets and Brian Cashman's history of making midseason moves. Plus, the crew discusses Freddy Peralta's struggles, Malik Nabers' recovery and what the Yankees must accomplish at the trade deadline.

A caller is ready to drive Jazz Chisholm to the airport for Luis Arraez, but Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash strongly reject the idea of subtracting a dangerous bat during a playoff push. Even with his flaws, Jazz gives the Yankees power, athleticism and late-game upside that would be difficult to replace. The debate then shifts to shortstop, where Jose Caballero's energy and disciplined approach continue to separate him from Anthony Volpe. Caballero has already received most of the recent starts at short, but the hosts question whether Aaron Boone should make the change permanent and how Ryan McMahon factors into the best defensive alignment.

Jazz Chisholm's latest power surge has Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash convinced the Yankees cannot afford to move him before the trade deadline. His inconsistency remains maddening, but his production in high-leverage moments gives the lineup an October weapon it desperately needs. The debate turns to Luis Arraez, where he would play, and whether the Yankees should sacrifice defense by moving Jazz around the diamond. Uncertainty surrounding Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton makes the deadline even more complicated, while Jose Caballero continues to strengthen his case for more playing time over Anthony Volpe. Plus, Freddy Peralta's brutal return to Milwaukee leads to harsh criticism of David Stearns, and Evan delivers an early NFC East prediction that the Dallas Cowboys will win the division.

Jose Caballero's pitch-clock gamesmanship ignited a benches-clearing confrontation with Dennis Santana, but the real controversy came afterward. Santana's claim that Caballero's tactics were unnecessary in a three-run game gets ripped as ridiculous, while Caballero earns praise for embracing the villain role and giving the Yankees an edge they have lacked. The debate also strengthens the case for playing Caballero over Anthony Volpe. Plus, Freddy Peralta's Mets struggles raise fears that he will rediscover his form after a trade, and the Jets' defensive talent, new whiteout uniforms and far-fetched AFC Championship hopes come under the microscope.

Chris McMonigle dives into a frustrating series against the Dodgers, breaking down the atrocious state of the Yankees' offense, expressing major concerns over a disappointing injury update on Aaron Judge and the severe struggles of Cody Bellinger, Jazz Chisholm, and Anthony Volpe. Looking ahead to the trade deadline, Chris insists the front office must prioritize a new starting shortstop and outlines his ultimate wish list, including Rafael Devers and Mason Miller. EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS 00:40 - The Elephant in the Room: The Yankees' offense is absolutely awful right now. 3:00 - A deep dive into the offensive black hole at the bottom of the lineup. Chris highlights the struggles of Cody Bellinger and Jazz Chisholm, noting that a starting infield with only one above-average hitter is unacceptable. 10:40 - The Aaron Judge Update: Chris expresses his disappointment over the latest medical update on Aaron Judge, noting that going from "sharp pain" to "dull pain" in six weeks without resuming baseball activities is a massive concern. 15:45 - Game 1 Recap & Gerrit Cole: Despite the offense only scraping together one run on an error and a wild pitch, Gerrit Cole provided a major bright spot with swing-and-miss stuff after some rough outings of late. 23:45 - Defending Boone & Grisham: Chris pushes back against fans criticizing manager Aaron Boone for leaving Cole in too long. He also defends Trent Grisham getting thrown out at the plate, attributing it to a bad base-running read rather than a lack of hustle. 43:00 - Game 3 Bullpen Heroics: A breakdown of the much-needed series finale victory, but Chris had to vent about a frustrating fifth-inning bases-loaded jam. 59:00 - Trade Deadline Wishlist: Chris demands that Brian Cashman prioritize a new shortstop. He also tosses out bold trade targets to save the season, including Rafael Devers, Luis Arraez, and Mason Miller. 1:09:20 - Shill or Shame: Reliever David Bednar earns the "Shill" for his shutdown performance out of the bullpen, while the recently demoted Jake Bird gets handed the "Shame." 1:14:00 - Silver Linings in the Standings: Despite the offensive woes and losing the series, Chris notes that the Yankees actually gained a game and a half on the slumping Tampa Bay Rays, keeping their division title hopes very much alive.

The Yankees offense is drowning, Aaron Judge cannot be counted on to return soon, and Evan Roberts says Brian Cashman now has two weeks to save the season. Evan points to Cashman's aggressive 2017 trade deadline as the blueprint, arguing that New York needs impact bats instead of waiting for Anthony Volpe, Austin Wells and others to suddenly turn things around. Tiki Barber agrees the Yankees can no longer assume struggling players will figure it out, but warns there is no obvious answer on the trade market. With the lineup averaging just over three runs per game for a month, Evan and Tiki debate catcher and infield upgrades, a possible George Lombard Jr. call-up and why every mistake becomes devastating when the Yankees cannot score.

Gio breaks down Bryson DeChambeau's penalty, calling it an attempt to gain an advantage rather than blatant cheating. Next, Jerry's update highlights Ferran Torres' lone World Cup final goal, Zlatan Ibrahimovic's blunt farewell to TV, Peter Schwartz's indoor football call, and Rex Ryan being awestruck by Ella Langley. In baseball action, David Bednar escaped a jam to help the Yankees top the Dodgers despite Cam Schlittler's struggles, while Francisco Lindor powered the Mets past the Phillies, crediting Bo Bichette's preceding 11-pitch at-bat. Finally, Ryan Fox clinches the British Open amidst "Baba Booey" cheers, Jordan Clarkson de-escalates a nightclub situation to show why the Knicks wanted him back, and Boomer defends Anthony Volpe from a frustrated caller.

Chris McMonigle dives into a frustrating series against the Dodgers, breaking down the atrocious state of the Yankees' offense, expressing major concerns over a disappointing injury update on Aaron Judge and the severe struggles of Cody Bellinger, Jazz Chisholm, and Anthony Volpe. Looking ahead to the trade deadline, Chris insists the front office must prioritize a new starting shortstop and outlines his ultimate wish list, including Rafael Devers and Mason Miller. EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS 00:40 - The Elephant in the Room: The Yankees' offense is absolutely awful right now. 3:00 - A deep dive into the offensive black hole at the bottom of the lineup. Chris highlights the struggles of Cody Bellinger and Jazz Chisholm, noting that a starting infield with only one above-average hitter is unacceptable. 10:40 - The Aaron Judge Update: Chris expresses his disappointment over the latest medical update on Aaron Judge, noting that going from "sharp pain" to "dull pain" in six weeks without resuming baseball activities is a massive concern. 15:45 - Game 1 Recap & Gerrit Cole: Despite the offense only scraping together one run on an error and a wild pitch, Gerrit Cole provided a major bright spot with swing-and-miss stuff after some rough outings of late. 23:45 - Defending Boone & Grisham: Chris pushes back against fans criticizing manager Aaron Boone for leaving Cole in too long. He also defends Trent Grisham getting thrown out at the plate, attributing it to a bad base-running read rather than a lack of hustle. 43:00 - Game 3 Bullpen Heroics: A breakdown of the much-needed series finale victory, but Chris had to vent about a frustrating fifth-inning bases-loaded jam. 59:00 - Trade Deadline Wishlist: Chris demands that Brian Cashman prioritize a new shortstop. He also tosses out bold trade targets to save the season, including Rafael Devers, Luis Arraez, and Mason Miller. 1:09:20 - Shill or Shame: Reliever David Bednar earns the "Shill" for his shutdown performance out of the bullpen, while the recently demoted Jake Bird gets handed the "Shame." 1:14:00 - Silver Linings in the Standings: Despite the offensive woes and losing the series, Chris notes that the Yankees actually gained a game and a half on the slumping Tampa Bay Rays, keeping their division title hopes very much alive.

Covino & Rich have fun with 'OLD-SCHOOL WHEN 50 HITS'! In honor of "Black Sunday" at Disneyland 70 years ago, the crew & caller share crazy summer heat stories. Plus, Derek Jeter's admission about Anthony Volpe may be a red flag!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

C&R laugh about Rich's annual car wash! Last night at the ESPY Awards, Mike Tyson literally didn't know who Shohei Ohtani is. They talk bubbles & blind spots! Messi dropped dimes, Will Ferrell's Bday, & 'OLD-SCHOOL WHEN 50 HITS' launches! In honor of "Black Sunday" at Disneyland, the crew & caller share crazy summer heat stories. Plus, Derek Jeter's admission about Anthony Volpe may be a red flag!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

The NFC playoff race may be far more open than expected, giving the Giants a legitimate reason for hope. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they examine the uncertainty surrounding the Eagles, Packers, Lions, Seahawks and 49ers, and explain why simply exceeding expectations could put the Giants in the postseason conversation. Shaun and Tiki also refuse to fall for the annual Cowboys hype, debate whether the Mets must finally spend big on starting pitching and examine how trade deadline pressure could affect Anthony Volpe and other young Yankees. Plus, Shohei Ohtani's surprising lack of mainstream recognition raises a larger concern about baseball's place in American sports culture.

The NFC playoff race may be far more open than anyone realizes, and that gives the Giants a legitimate reason for hope. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and Shaun explains why only a few NFC teams feel like postseason locks. He is not predicting a Giants playoff berth yet, but uncertainty surrounding the Eagles, Packers, Lions, Vikings, Seahawks and 49ers has him talking himself into the possibility. Tiki also examines how the MLB trade deadline can affect young Yankees such as Anthony Volpe, while Geno Smith's future, the annual Cowboys hype cycle and the Mets' chances of rebuilding their rotation spark more debate. Plus, callers deliver bold predictions involving Dallas, Juan Soto and a potential Mets rebound.

Artificial intelligence is becoming an increasingly important topic for credit union leaders, but questions remain around governance, transparency, and practical implementation. Inthis episode of C.U. On The Show, Doug English speaks with Mitch Rutledge of Vertice AI, Fred Eisel of Vizo Financial, and Anthony Volpe about CUltivate AI, a newly launched credit union-focused CUSO designed to provide AI capabilities built around industry-specific knowledge sources. The discussionexplores how credit unions are evaluating AI adoption, the role of shared knowledge within the movement, and potential future applications for compliance, operations, strategic planning, and board-level decision-making.Watch the video version of this episode: https://youtu.be/CUC1KBUNrlURead the episode summary here: How Credit Unions Are Exploring a Cooperative Approach to AI | ACT AdvisorsEmail doug@act-advisors.com with any inquiries.The guests on today's show are not affiliated with or endorsed by ACT Advisors, LLC and their opinions are their own. ACT Advisors did not provide cash or non-cash compensation for their participation. ACT Advisors, LLC is an SEC-registered investment adviser. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. This content is provided for informational purposes only and is not investment, legal, or tax advice.

Brian Cashman gave a discouraging update on Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton, leading Chris McMonigle to wonder if Stanton will return at all this season. Plus, Evan Roberts wonders if it is far to worry that Judge won't be back this season either. Evan also says the Yankees need to trade for Tarik Skubal, while C-Mac declares that the Yanks need to cut ties with Anthony Volpe.

Brian Cashman gave a discouraging update on Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton, leading Chris McMonigle to wonder if Stanton will return at all this season. Plus, Evan Roberts wonders if it is far to worry that Judge won't be back this season either. Evan also says the Yankees need to trade for Tarik Skubal, while C-Mac declares that the Yanks need to cut ties with Anthony Volpe.

Brian Cashman gave a discouraging update on Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton, leading Chris McMonigle to wonder if Stanton will return at all this season. Plus, Evan Roberts wonders if it is far to worry that Judge won't be back this season either. Evan also says the Yankees need to trade for Tarik Skubal, while C-Mac declares that the Yanks need to cut ties with Anthony Volpe.

Episode 443: Dallas, Jay Hay, Jared, and Tyler react to a loaded week of news in the baseball world. Surefire Hall of Famer Justin Verlander has announced his retirement at the end of the 2026 season. Dallas reflects on one of the greatest pitchers he ever shared the diamond with, what Verlander's career means, and the end of a bygone era for starting pitchers. Jared Jones became the latest pitcher to be pulled in the midst of a perfect game. Jared and Jay Hay dive deep into why they believe it was the right decision for both the Pirates and the Marlins. Yankees announcer Michael Kay found himself in hot water after reporting that Anthony Volpe would not be moving positions. The wait is over, BID Family Feud is back with another special guest rounding out the four-person battle, and the platinum player, Atlanta Braves first baseman Matt Olson, joins the show to catch up with the crew and talk about the Home Run Derby. 00:00:00 - Sign Up For Our Patreon! Deserted Island Album Draft Coming Today! 00:02:24 - Justin Verlander Retiring at the End of the Season 00:18:00 - Jared Jones Pulled During Perfection 00:28:01 - Dylan Cease's AL Cy Young Chase 00:35:19 - Anthony Volpe Second Base Reports 00:46:52 - Matt Olson Joins BID 01:05:11 - Family Feud | Feat. KFC 01:31:10 - Same Ol' Mets 01:50:35 - Award-Winning Nugs 01:54:24 - Final Thoughts NEW BID MERCH IS HERE: https://www.baseballisdead.com Trade $20 get $20 on Kalshi - https://app.kalshi.com/1r91/BID Sign Up For Our Patreon for more Baseball Is Dead Content! https://www.patreon.com/cw/BaseballisDead Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Welcome back to the Sorry to Interrupt podcast! Sean is back for another Yankees Series Recap pod as he reacts to the Yanks splitting a 4-game set with the Rays at the Trop. He gives his biggest takeaways from the series including the offense going from historically bad to putting up 12 on Thursday as well as his thoughts on Jasson Dominguez in the OF and Ben Rice's monster series. Next, he gives some big picture observations including Brian Cashman's quotes, Judge and Stanton's injury updates, Jazz's future and more Anthony Volpe drama. Lastly, he gives a brief preview for this weekend's set against the Nats in D.C to close out the 1st half. Everyone enjoy the pod!

Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' shortstop situation, asserting that Jose Caballero is currently the team's best option over Anthony Volpe. He proposes a significant trade for Rafael Devers to bolster the lineup and replace Giancarlo Stanton's production. They also delve into the New York Giants' offseason concerns and debate which New York Mets players should be moved in a Would You, Wouldn't You? segment. 01:20 - Mets Face Delayed Red Sox 05:50 - Caballero Over Volpe At Shortstop 10:51 - Nabors Injury Impacts Giants Season 16:07 - Jaxson Dart Franchise Potential 21:18 - Proposal To Trade For Devers 27:04 - Scouting Trade Deadline Targets 34:13 - Extending Clarke Schmidt And Rice 43:21 - Would You Wouldn't You Mets 48:55 - Evaluating Mets Trade Candidates

C-Mac rants about slow drivers and people who decorate their car dashboards with tchotchkes like rubber ducks. They transition into a trivia game called The Wheel, where Gallo and Hoff struggle with Tom Hanks movies and Beatles facts. The segment concludes with a look at the Yankees lineup as Anthony Volpe sits once again for Jose Caballero. 01:20 - Driving Etiquette Rant 11:04 - Tom Hanks Trivia Game 18:21 - Beatles Clues Challenge 24:25 - Sox and Mets Trivia 31:40 - Anthony Volpe Benched

On this week’s edition of Inside the (Rob) Parker, Rob discusses Kansas City Royals' OF Tyler Tolbert's impressive streak of 12 straight plate appearances with a hit, the drama involving Anthony Volpe and the New York Yankees, and St Louis Cardinals OF Jordan Walker agreeing to participate in the Home Run Derby. Plus, San Diego Padres OF Samad Taylor swings by, as does NBC Los Angeles sports anchor Olivia Garvey. Finally, we drop Rob's latest appearance on MLB Network and the latest edition of Pocket Protector Central with analytics maven Anthony Masterson, and reveal the fourteenth installment of Rob’s Memory Lane series. Subscribe and download all of the latest Inside the Parker podcasts and follow Rob on Twitter!! #OddCoupleSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

The Yankees face a pivotal game against Tampa Bay with Cody Bellinger at first base, Paul Goldschmidt on the bench, and their division hopes beginning to tighten. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate the lineup, the bullpen plan, and whether Brian Cashman deserves more credit for keeping the franchise competitive without delivering another championship. The Anthony Volpe controversy takes center stage as Michael Kay walks back a report that Volpe resisted playing second base while Joel Sherman appears to support the original claim. The conversation also covers Francisco Lindor's lack of hustle, excitement around the young Nets, the Jets' definition of the promised land, and possible catcher moves before the trade deadline.

The Yankees offense has reached a historic low, but finding a solution is far more complicated than identifying the problem. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Cody Bellinger deserves the most blame, how much Aaron Judge's absence has damaged the lineup and whether Aaron Boone can do anything to create urgency before the season slips away. The guys pull a new Yankees lineup out of a hat, examine Paul Goldschmidt's decline and weigh the latest Anthony Volpe controversy. They also enter the Mets alternate universe, revisiting the decisions involving Zack Wheeler, Pete Alonso and Brandon Nimmo, while rejecting a wild proposal to send Francisco Lindor across town.

The Anthony Volpe controversy deepens as Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber compare Michael Kay's retracted claim with a similar report from Joel Sherman. They debate whether Volpe resisted playing second base, whether the story was twisted by semantics, and why versatility could determine his future with the Yankees. The conversation also covers Brett Baty's value as a multiposition player, the Jets' modest version of the promised land, and Evan's scorekeeping vindication after a Mets error was corrected. Plus, the hosts discuss a frustrating flat tire ordeal, possible catcher trades involving the Yankees, and Jordan Clarkson's return to the Knicks.

Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle breaks down the New York Yankees' 10-4 victory over the Tampa Bay Rays to salvage a crucial series split. He highlights Ryan McMahon's twelve-pitch at-bat as a season-defining moment and discusses Ben Rice's power performance while addressing injury updates for Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. 01:20 - Yankees Salvage Rays Series Split 04:42 - Ryan McMahon's Turning Point At-Bat 10:34 - Ben Rice and Offensive Outburst 13:40 - Bullpen Usage and Washington Series 17:02 - Caller Debate: Championship Expectations 21:34 - Trusting the Yankee Bullpen Arms 25:08 - Phil's Positive Outlook on Yankees 30:38 - Brian Cashman Injury Updates 38:04 - Striking Out and Analytics Talk 43:28 - Anthony Volpe vs Jose Caballero

Mac revisits a nostalgic 2008 radio segment featuring Johan Santana's shutout performance before engaging in a heated debate with callers about the Yankees. He argues that Anthony Volpe should be benched in favor of Jose Caballero due to prolonged offensive struggles. The discussion also critiques Brian Cashman's roster construction, specifically comparing the Giancarlo Stanton trade to missed opportunities with Christian Yelich and Bryce Harper. 01:00 - Reliving Santana's 2008 Gem 07:07 - Case for Benching Volpe 12:22 - Cashman and Boone Accountability 17:28 - Evaluating the Stanton Trade

C-Mac evaluates the New York Yankees' offensive struggles and the significant lack of production from the catching position. He analyzes the debate between starting Anthony Volpe or Oswaldo Cabrera at shortstop while addressing the team's high strikeout rate compared to recent World Series champions. 01:00 - Highlander Movie Discussion 02:43 - Yankees Catching Upgrade Needed 06:33 - Debating Yankee Strikeout Rates 13:53 - Volpe vs Cabrera Debate 16:48 - Bellinger And Mets Update

Levack and Goz on a Thursday July 9th, 2026 editionWho is the Albany Firebirds starting quarterback?Is there drama involving the franchise heading into Saturday's big game?Yankees done with Anthony Volpe?Injury status on Aaron JudgeIs Kawhi Leonoard really traded?Thoughts on Season 7 premiere of Dark Side of the Ring and Jeff JarrettYou can follow the guys on X@TheJeffLevack@TomGozzDownload/subscribe/rate/review on YouTube sidehttps://www.youtube.com/channel/UCjoBykuMcJ-Na_oGjs3fv-w

Once again, the Yankee bats were shut down by Tampa, falling further back in the AL East standings with a shutout loss. Chris breaks down the offensive showing, how Gerrit Cole looked on the mound as he looks to move past his post-Tommy John struggles, Aaron Boone's heated ejection, the continued listless at-bats from Paul Goldschmidt and Cody Bellinger, and Anthony Volpe's return to the starting shortstop role.

Jose Caballero takes one of the strangest called third strikes imaginable, leaving broadcasters and fans searching for an explanation. Was he fooled, expecting a walk, or simply caught guessing on the wrong pitch? The conversation also examines the Anthony Volpe position change rumor, Michael Kay's quick retraction, and why the allegation may follow Volpe regardless of the truth. Plus, the Yankees weigh bold pitching upgrades while the Mets face difficult decisions about their roster and future.

The Yankees are stumbling through another extended summer slide, but the numbers suggest this is not simply a normal part of a long baseball season. Evan examines why these prolonged downturns keep happening, how heavily the team depends on Aaron Judge, and whether the organization has built a roster that is too vulnerable when its biggest star is unavailable or struggling. The conversation also turns to an aggressive solution at the trade deadline, with Tarik Skubal presented as the kind of ace who could give the Yankees a dominant postseason rotation. Plus, a disastrous Mets debut raises questions about sympathy and clubhouse humor, Anthony Volpe's future comes under scrutiny, and the most memorable traditions in NFL fandom get ranked.

Michael Kay says there is no truth to the rumor that Anthony Volpe refused to play second base in the minor leagues, but the original claim may have already changed how Yankees fans view him. Evan Roberts examines the retraction and the questions that still remain. The conversation explores whether the Yankees pushed back on the story, why false or unverified claims can be impossible to erase, and how Volpe could rebuild his value by becoming a more versatile player. Even with the denial, the rumor may continue to follow him.

Jose Caballero produced one of the strangest at bats of the season when he appeared to give up on a full count pitch before it reached the plate. Evan Roberts breaks down the confused reactions from the Yankees television and radio broadcasts and searches for a reasonable explanation. The discussion also turns to the energy Caballero brings compared with Anthony Volpe, the limitations of defensive metrics, and whether the Mets should ever consider helping the Yankees through a trade. Evan also explains why most Major League Baseball draft picks cannot be traded and what could change under a future labor agreement.

A local pitcher's feel good Mets debut turns into a brutal night at Citi Field, raising an awkward question: when can his friends finally start giving him a hard time about it? Evan also debates how aggressively the Yankees should pursue Tarik Skubal, where the line should be drawn in a prospect package, why the organization cannot quit Anthony Volpe, and whether a viral World Cup controversy was real or satire.

C-Mac joins Evan for a blunt conversation about Anthony Volpe, the controversy over a possible move to second base, and why frustrated Yankees fans are now ready to believe almost any negative story about him. They also examine how prospect expectations can trap a player, whether Volpe can reinvent himself as a versatile role player, and why a fresh start elsewhere may be his best path forward. The discussion closes with some newsroom chaos, solo hosting talk, and the misery of watching a team that keeps testing its fans.

Chris McMonigle is flying solo on The Carton Show and says the Yankees are focusing on the wrong issues. While Anthony Volpe continues to dominate the headlines, Chris argues the bigger concerns are Cody Bellinger's struggles, Paul Goldschmidt's shocking slump, and a team that's unraveling at the worst possible time.

Chris McMonigle delivers a passionate rant on the Yankees' recent struggles, pushing back against fans demanding more "accountability" from Aaron Boone. Is benching Anthony Volpe really the answer? Should Paul Goldschmidt be punished during his brutal slump? Chris explains why the Yankees' issues run much deeper than simply holding players accountable.

Anthony Volpe is finally responding to the rumors that he refused to move to second base and Chris McMonigle isn't buying the narrative. After Michael Kay walks back his report and Volpe publicly denies ever refusing a position change, Chris breaks down why the damage may already be done. Plus, should the Yankees send Volpe back to Triple-A to rebuild his confidence and learn second base?

Did one missing welcome message create lasting tension between Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate the reported origin of their strained relationship, how Soto changed the Mets clubhouse hierarchy, and whether any realistic Lindor trade could actually improve the team. The conversation shifts to the Yankees and their continued faith in Anthony Volpe despite mounting frustration from fans. Evan and Tiki also discuss whether Jose Caballero deserves the shortstop job, why Jasson Dominguez still needs more time, what happened to Austin Wells, and whether the Yankees remain the best option in a flawed American League.

The Yankees are chasing Tampa Bay, but does a rivalry with the Rays generate any real emotion? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate why the matchup lacks the atmosphere, history and intensity of the Yankees battles with Boston, Baltimore and Toronto. The conversation also examines whether the Yankees should replace Austin Wells, how Anthony Volpe should be used and why one misleading statistic fails to tell the full story. Plus, the Mets face questions about Francisco Lindor, Pete Alonso and David Stearns, while the Knicks weigh the value of Mitchell Robinson and the future dominance of Victor Wembanyama.

Could tension between Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto be affecting the Mets, or is their relationship being overanalyzed? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber examine how the arrival of Soto may have changed the clubhouse dynamic, whether Lindor should remain part of the Mets' future, and why trading a star shortstop is easier to suggest than execute. The conversation also turns to the Yankees' flaws, Aaron Boone's continued faith in Anthony Volpe, and whether New York is still the best team in a weak American League. Plus, Evan and Tiki react to Sean Payton's remarkable idea involving Bill Belichick, debate the appeal of European soccer, and explore how a potential MLB lockout could reshape free agency.

The Yankees may already have their best shortstop on the roster, but are they willing to admit it? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Jose Caballero has surpassed Anthony Volpe and why the organization remains committed to a former top prospect after thousands of plate appearances. The conversation also turns to the Mets and the difficult decisions surrounding Bo Bichette, David Stearns and a disappointing season. Plus, the guys react to Jalen Brunson undergoing surgery on his right forearm and wrist, what his recovery means for the Knicks and why some early season rest could ultimately benefit their star guard.

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dive into the growing frustration around the Yankees, Aaron Boone's future, and whether his legacy in the Bronx will be defined more by regular season success or postseason disappointment. The conversation centers on sloppy defense, June swoons, lineup concerns, and the feeling that the Yankees may eventually need a very different voice in the dugout. They also debate the controversial red card decision involving Flo Balogun, VAR procedure, and why soccer's lack of transparency can drive American sports fans crazy. Plus, callers weigh in on World Cup officiating, stoppage time confusion, Giancarlo Stanton's absence, Anthony Volpe's struggles, Jazz Chisholm's disappointing season, and whether the Yankees are missing urgency as much as production.

Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to the idea that the Mets have to trade Francisco Lindor, questioning whether the team should even think that way unless the return clearly makes them better. They break down Lindor's contract, his leadership, his fit with Juan Soto, and why Steve Cohen's comments may have reopened an unnecessary conversation. The discussion also turns to the Yankees and their glaring issues up the middle, from catcher to shortstop to second base. Evan and Tiki examine what Brian Cashman may need to address at the trade deadline, why Anthony Volpe's standing has changed, and how injuries and roster holes have shaped the Yankees' current concerns.