POPULARITY
On this January 23, 2026 segment of The Carton Show on WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss the massive snowstorm heading to New York City, including snowfall predictions and travel woes. They dive into the challenges of commuting during snow, school closures, and nostalgic memories of snow days. Later, they talk MLB's potential expansion and divisional realignment, debating how it could affect Yankees-Mets rivalries.
What's going on with Cody Bellinger? Are the Yankees out on him? What about the Mets? Plus, would you draft Dante Moore at No. 2 if you ran the Jets? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
From 'WFAN Daily' (subscribe here): Hoff talks about the end of the BT & Sal Show and then somehow goes on a rant about the Yankees and Mets awful offseasons. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
BT unleashes his frustration over the disappointing 2025 MLB offseason for both the Yankees and Mets, comparing the lack of major moves to a "snowball fight" that never materialized. He dissects the confusing state of both New York cores, noting the scarcity of solidified positions for either club. Tierney lays out the Yankees' dilemma: relying on a "phenomenal" rotation (Cole, Freed, Schlittler, McClain) while simultaneously "praying" that the price doesn't go up on Cody Bellinger. He argues that acquiring only a pitcher like Michael King is not an acceptable plan. For the Mets, the chaos is clearer: a dismantled core with "a million questions" at every turn, including the ongoing possibility of a Francisco Lindor trade and the debate over the future of prospects like Ben Rice at first base. BT concludes that the clock is running out, and a "very dark and very empty offseason" is becoming a frightening reality for New York baseball.
¡Bienvenidos a Baseball News! ⚾
BT & Sal ignite a fierce debate on how the Yankees and Mets can realistically compete with the Dodgers' powerhouse, star-stockpiling strategy. They argue that both New York teams must stop being "afraid to make mistakes" and aggressively "eat" bad contracts to maintain a competitive edge, just like the Yankees of old. The conversation centers on the Dodgers' financial model, specifically the Ohtani deferral deal, which Sal calls a "perfect storm" built on a willing star, and question why the Mets and Yankees haven't been as innovative. For the Yankees, they explore bold moves like trading Rodón to make room for an elite arm like Skubal and question the value of trading a top prospect like Lombard for a rental. The bottom line: The Dodgers have raised the bar, and New York must match the intensity and financial bravado.
Evan Roberts discusses the possibility of Cody Bellinger to the Mets and what he would want that to look like. Plus, Pete Hoffman gives his take on the Pete Alonso opt out with BT & Sal and argue if it is a distraction; Evan is bothered two Mets coaches have joined the Braves' staff; Evan, Tiki, Shaun and Tommy give their plans to fix the Yankees (34:31); Evan is intrigued by the A-Rod documentary; BT, Sal and Pete Hoffman on if Alonso will earn MVP votes next season and if Aaron Boone has the safest job of all New York sports teams.
Evan Roberts discusses the possibility of Cody Bellinger to the Mets and what he would want that to look like. Plus, Pete Hoffman gives his take on the Pete Alonso opt out with BT & Sal and argue if it is a distraction; Evan is bothered two Mets coaches have joined the Braves' staff; Evan, Tiki, Shaun and Tommy give their plans to fix the Yankees (34:31); Evan is intrigued by the A-Rod documentary; BT, Sal and Pete Hoffman on if Alonso will earn MVP votes next season and if Aaron Boone has the safest job of all New York sports teams.
Evan Roberts discusses the possibility of Cody Bellinger to the Mets and what he would want that to look like. Plus, Pete Hoffman gives his take on the Pete Alonso opt out with BT & Sal and argue if it is a distraction; Evan is bothered two Mets coaches have joined the Braves' staff; Evan, Tiki, Shaun and Tommy give their plans to fix the Yankees (34:31); Evan is intrigued by the A-Rod documentary; BT, Sal and Pete Hoffman on if Alonso will earn MVP votes next season and if Aaron Boone has the safest job of all New York sports teams.
BT & Sal torch the Yankees and Mets for their reluctance to spend and acquire talent like the Los Angeles Dodgers, who relentlessly add superstars like Ohtani and Yamamoto. They demand both New York teams "go all in" this offseason, aggressively pursuing trade targets like Tarik Skubal and Kyle Tucker to compete with LA's "better, smarter, and wealthier" brand. The hosts debate the logistical and brand reasons why Japanese stars now favor the Dodgers over the Yankees. Sal and BT rave about baseball's immense drama, reflecting on the previous night's 18-inning marathon, before wrapping up with a fun discussion about their viral interview with actress Sydney Sweeney—and the unimpressed reactions of their spouses!
BT & Sal launch a blistering critique of the Yankees and Mets, arguing they are light years behind the Dodgers' aggressive, 'win-now' blueprint. They torch New York's ownership for their "financial fear," demanding both teams stop settling and "go Dodgers-Deep" by trading for stars like Tarik Skubal and Kyle Tucker. The show then erupts over Giants legend Carl Banks' scorching public criticism of Dexter Lawrence, questioning if the $90M All-Pro is hurt, "lazy" after getting paid, or if opponents truly "don't respect" him anymore. They debate the impact of Banks' verbal fire on the Big Cat's effort. The hosts also discuss the Mets' puzzling loss of first base coach Antoan Richardson, rumors of a Kayvon Thibodeaux trade, and end the hour with a fiery round of "Bald-Faced Lie, Bald-Faced Truth" covering the Knicks' minutes, the Phillies' stars, and a potential Rangers' rebuild via trading Panarin/Zibanejad.
BT & Sal launch a fiery critique on the Mets and Yankees, arguing they are light years behind the Dodgers who combine aggressive spending (Ohtani, Yamamoto, Snell) with smart trading. They challenge New York to be "great, not just good" by flexing their financial muscle in multiple ways. The debate centers on the Mets' J.T. Ginn McLain dilemma: is he an untouchable asset, or should they trade him for an immediate ace like Skubal? Plus, NFL insider Jordan Schultz's report on the Giants potentially trading Kayvon Thibodeaux sparks a discussion on helping Jackson Dart's development. Fan legend John Minko joins the show to share his bittersweet retirement story and a wild tale about being eyed as a "corporate spy" when WFAN began. Then, NFL analyst Brian Baldinger breaks down Dexter Lawrence's underwhelming performance and why the Giants must get a receiver to help Dart.
New Pod Alert!!! John McCormick makes his Free Oakley debut, and we recap the insane Giants/Broncos finish...dive into Ohtani's unparalleled greatness...and tie a bow on the 2025 NY baseball season. Yes - we actually talk Giants/Yanks tonight. Mac absolutely COOKS in the Yankees section...a must listen.
Hour 4: Keith talks about if the Mets and Yankees need to make big changes to improve their results.
Yankees/Mets Playoff Push Fantasy vs Reality TNF Football
Sal Rants about the maddening inconsistency of both the Yankees and Mets, expressing his frustration with their inability to play solid, consistent baseball. He highlights the Yankees' near-collapse after a 10-1 lead and the Mets' win streak after an embarrassing losing streak, arguing that these wild swings make it impossible to know how to feel about either team. Sal explains that while both teams have the potential to make a deep playoff run, their unpredictable nature and unreliability make it difficult to be confident in their success. He concludes that despite the emotional toll, the only thing that matters now is for both teams to make the postseason, where their regular season performance becomes irrelevant.
Sal dissects the emotional rollercoaster of being a fan of both the New York Yankees and New York Mets this season. He highlights the maddening inconsistency of both teams—the Yankees nearly blowing a 10-1 lead and the Mets' constant ups and downs. Despite all the frustrations, Sal insists that both teams have the potential to make a legitimate run at the World Series, especially given the current MLB playoff format. He praises the Mets for finally "piggybacking" pitchers to overcome their starting rotation's weaknesses and notes that Anthony Volpe's past playoff experience could make him a valuable asset for the Yankees in October. Ultimately, Sal argues that the regular season's flaws will be forgotten if either team can "just get there" and catch fire in the playoffs.
Host Bill Donohue welcomes former New York Mets and Yankees pitcher Ray Burris, followed by a discussion about the greatest sports speeches with author Robert Begley.
On the somber 24th anniversary of 9/11, BT and Sal opened their show with a powerful reflection on the tragedy, the heroism of first responders, and the sense of unity that once defined New York. But they quickly pivoted to a fiery critique of the Yankees and Mets, arguing that both teams have failed to provide the very escape and sense of normalcy that sports offered in the aftermath of the attacks. They lamented that instead of being a welcome distraction from the weight of the day, the teams' inconsistent, sloppy, and frustrating play has become just another source of stress and disappointment, a true failure on their part.
In a somber tribute to 9/11, BT and Sal discuss how sports are meant to be an escape but the current state of both the Mets and Yankees has become a new source of frustration. They dissect the Mets' shocking inconsistency, pondering whether they're better off with quirky personalities like Jesse Winker and Grimace than with a numbers-obsessed star like Juan Soto. Meanwhile, Sal expresses concern over the Yankees' bullpen and Volpe's injury, while the hosts disagree on whether the Yankees can still win their division. The conversation shifts to the Jets, with Wayne Chrebet discussing his 9/11 memories and the team's new culture under Aaron Glenn, before diving into NFL power rankings and venting from fans.
Yankees Mets Stink AI Time Travel Knicks Say to Ben Simmons
Devin Williams and Ryan Helsley were both problems yesterday as the Yankees & Mets both lost. Plus, football is back tonight! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
In a fiery segment, BT and Sal tore into the New York sports scene after a night of frustrating losses. They dissected the Yankees' painful defeat, pointing fingers at a historically bad umpire and the bullpen's ongoing implosion, led by a struggling Devin Williams. The frustration didn't stop there, as they also hammered the Mets for their own bullpen woes, specifically Ryan Helsley's dreadful performance, and questioned the team's questionable roster decisions. The duo's passionate monologue covered everything from the teams' lack of accountability to the impact of the trade deadline, concluding that both the Yankees and Mets have significant, unresolved issues that could derail their playoff hopes.
What's the ceiling for the Yankees and Mets this season? And Gary Myers joins us! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Covino & Rich wrap up the calls & debate on Shadeur Sanders! They talk MLB divisional races & discuss Aaron Rodgers & his no bluetooth stance. Covino got "Covid Eye?" 'IRON MIKE TRIVIA' churns out another champ & Rich has an NL West question. Plus, their Yankees/Mets bet, & Mr. Wonderful buys a one of a kind 12+ million dollar card! See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Buster Olney drops by to discuss the struggles of Anthony Volpe & when Mets fans could potentially see Jonah Tong in the big leagues. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
The final hour discusses the Mets' win, Willie's concerns about Mendoza's team, and the Jets possibly claiming Tommy DeVito. Jerry and Willie debate why some college players fail in the NFL and agree not to rush Jaxson Dart. Bogusch's update covers DeVito's cut, the Jets' receiver search, and Yankees/Mets blowout wins. The show also questions Ohio State banning Dave Portnoy, features Willie the Yogi, and concludes with a dessert debate: key lime pie vs. chocolate, and cone vs. cup.
Hour 1 Jerry and Willie Colon fill in for Boomer and Gio. The Mets bounced back, despite another poor Kodai Senga start (the new human rain delay), scoring many runs with two outs. Mark Vientos is red hot, and Willie says it's time for the Mets to stack wins; Sean Manaea needs to step up tonight. The game was delayed for 10 minutes because the Phillies complained about parabolic mics. Jerry was impressed with the Mets' response. The Yankees did what they needed to do in a lose-lose series. Andrew Bogusch's first update covers the Yankees' win, Jazz Chisholm's 25th homer, Luis Torrens' 5 RBIs, and Francisco Alvarez's potential rehab assignment. Kodai Senga struggled again. With McLaurin and Hendrickson signed, Micah Parsons is the lone hold-in; Dak Prescott is unbothered, and Jerry Recco believes Jerry Jones will get a deal done. Jerry and Willie discuss paying Parsons with a Cowboys fan and Jerry updates his bat situation (the exterminator was jacked). Hour 2 Jerry and Willie discussed Aaron Rodgers' interview, agreeing he tried with the Jets and expect him to excel in Pittsburgh. Terry McLaurin and Trey Hendrickson secured new contracts. The guys believe the Giants, with Russell Wilson, will surprise people and beat the Commanders. Bogusch provided an update, and Jerry mentioned Willie and Eddie Scozzare considering yoga. The Mets won big, and Cam Schlittler had a good start for the Yankees. Willson Contreras had a dugout meltdown. The hour concluded with a yoga call and a discussion about The Biggest Loser documentary. Hour 3 Willie believes Eddie and Fliegs have untapped athletic potential, but they and Jerry disagree. Jerry wonders what activities people spend a lot on but never master, like golf, with top X responses including sex, marriage, gambling, and skiing. Willie was a bad bowler early in his NFL career. The guys discuss the Jets and Giants' offensive and defensive lines. Bogusch updates on Tommy DeVito being waived by the Giants (Willie and Jerry expect him to be picked up) and plays Rodgers' message to Jets fans. The Yankees and Mets both crushed their opponents. Jerry is concerned about the bullpen tonight if Sean Manaea doesn't pitch deep. LIU is getting paid to play Florida, which helps financially, but Jerry and Willie worry about injuries. Finally, Jerry looks at examples of athletes with one standout season and surprising attendance numbers. Jerry thinks Raleigh, not Aaron Judge, should be MVP. Hour 4 The final hour discusses the Mets' win, Willie's concerns about Mendoza's team, and the Jets possibly claiming Tommy DeVito. Jerry and Willie debate why some college players fail in the NFL and agree not to rush Jaxson Dart. Bogusch's update covers DeVito's cut, the Jets' receiver search, and Yankees/Mets blowout wins. The show also questions Ohio State banning Dave Portnoy, features Willie the Yogi, and concludes with a dessert debate: key lime pie vs. chocolate, and cone vs. cup.
Football season is back- ATH finally dives into football season. Quick monologue- why to watch/monitor EuroBasket, some Yankees/Mets thoughts (still bleak) and a quick thought on the NY Giants (1:40). Then a recurring guest is back to talk more about NY Giants optimism and preview the NFC with standings predictions, Over/Unders and more (8:30).
MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred raised eyebrows by mentioning geographic realignment as part of future expansion. Chuck Garfien and MLB Network Radio's Mike Ferrin dig into what that could mean for baseball — from the Cubs and White Sox sharing a division, to Yankees–Mets and Dodgers–Angels rivalries heating up. Chuck even unveils his own realignment plan, while Mike explains how it could boost rivalries, cut travel, and reshape the postseason.
When we hit the air on Monday morning, will the Yankees still be a playoff team? What about the Mets? Plus, Plays of the Week from Ray! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Is this really the season the Yankees make a change at manager? And what happens if the Mets miss the playoffs? Buster Olney dropped by to discuss it all. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Another day, and another loss for the Yankees. Same for the Mets. Plus, we're at Giants training camp & chat with LB Bobby Okereke! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Joe is solo for this episode and he starts the show going over all of the trades the Yankees made at the trade deadline, what that means for the rest of the season, his optimism, & the lens that you need to look through for the rest of the season (1:03). Then, he switches to the moves the Mets made, why they are the best team in the National League now, & why David Sterns won the trade deadline (20:07). Finally, he talks about NFL training camp notes for the Jets and Giants (30:10), & SO much more!
Both the Yankees and Mets made significant moves at the trade deadline, earning high praise for their aggressive approach. The two teams addressed critical weaknesses, with a particular focus on bolstering their bullpens. The Yankees acquired players like McMahon, an elite-fielding third baseman with power, while the Mets brought in Cedric Mullins, a veteran center fielder with a well-rounded game. Despite some debate over whether either team landed the "knockout punch" trade that would make them a World Series favorite, the consensus is that both clubs are now better positioned to compete for a championship. The Mets, in particular, are seen as finally having a deep and talented roster that can sustain success, a far cry from the lean years of the past.
Case is coming to us from Bristol Motor Speedway where he's hanging with MLB Network for the Speedway Classic this weekend. We dig in to who won and lost the Trade Deadline. Brian Cashman, David Stearns and the 2 NYC teams wen't on a bullpen shopping spree while the M's finally got a super slugger bat to compliment the Big Dumper. Plus, did the Padres outduel the Dodgers enough to take the NL West down the stretch? Full Youtube Broadcast here: https://youtu.be/7o7oHDVVXog
Joe is solo for this episode as he begins talking about the Yankees season on the brink of being over, no accountability for the problems on the ball club, and the breaking trade news surrounding the newest Bronx Bomber (1:07). Then, he talks about the Mets also making a move, their chances of owning the trade deadline, & why he believes the Mets will have another great summer (26:40). Finally, he talks about some of the notes from the beginning of the Jets Training Camp (36:20), & SO much more!
Evan proposes a couple of trades the Mets and Yankees could make together and debates if there is one to be made.
What's the one move that the Yankees need to make before the deadline? And what about the Mets? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Mike Francesa discusses MLB's return after the break, focusing on trade deadline expectations, highlighting key players like Vientos for the Mets and McMahon for the Yankees. He also touches on David Wright's legacy, NFL players union drama, and the British Open.
Are the Yankees true title contenders? What about the Mets? And if not, what needs to be added at the deadline to change that? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Do the Yankees or Mets have a better chance to win their respective division? Also, ranking the best TEs in the NFL & The Morning Roast! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Today on "Hot Mic", Kirk Herbstreit calls out Elle Duncan for being a fan on TV, US Soccer makes it hard to love them and is Hugh Freeze golfing too much? Plus, USA Today MLB Columnist, Bob Nightengale with thoughts on the Nationals firing their GM Mike Rizzo and head coach Davey Martinez 1 week before the MLB draft where the Nationals hold the #1 overall pick and the July 4th Yankees-Mets games was the 2nd most watched game in history for MLB.TV. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
The Knicks aren't interested in Kevin Durant. Plus, we chat with Buster Olney about the the struggles of the Yankee offense & whether the Mets would target Jacob deGrom at the deadline. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Is there anything Evan or Shaun will agree the Mets or Yankees is better than the other at?
A Yankees-Mets summer debate is set to begin, Giancarlo Stanton still needs another rehab game, the Knicks turn their attention in the coaching search, and much more
What's going to happen when Giancarlo Stanton returns to the Yankees? And will Pete Alonso end up with a long-term deal with the Mets after all? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
The Ringer's John Jastremski joins the show to break down his favorite bets for the Knicks/Pacers & Wolves/Thunder. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Eric Hosmer and Buster discuss Hos returning to Kansas City to celebrate the 2015 World Series, what advice he'd give to Craig Breslow about tough conversations with players, Juan Soto's return to the Bronx and Ronald Acuña Jr. making amends. Then, Darryl Strawberry shares what his reception was like after returning to Shea Stadium as a Dodger. Next, David Schoenfield talks about the Yankees-Mets rivalry returning to 2000-levels of animosity, the Dodgers fixing their issues, and their musings as to why pitchers are getting injured at a higher rate in the modern game. Later, Sarah Langs shares her essay on Aaron Judge. CALL THE SHOW: 406-404-8460 EMAIL THE SHOW: BleacherTweets@gmail.com REACH OUT ON X: #BLEACHERTWEETS 5:07 Eric Hosmer 26:06 Darryl Strawberry 26:56 David Schoenfield 41:29 Sarah Langs 42:56 Bleacher Tweets Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Eric Hosmer and Buster discuss Hos returning to Kansas City to celebrate the 2015 World Series, what advice he'd give to Craig Breslow about tough conversations with players, Juan Soto's return to the Bronx and Ronald Acuña Jr. making amends. Then, Darryl Strawberry shares what his reception was like after returning to Shea Stadium as a Dodger. Next, David Schoenfield talks about the Yankees-Mets rivalry returning to 2000-levels of animosity, the Dodgers fixing their issues, and their musings as to why pitchers are getting injured at a higher rate in the modern game. Later, Sarah Langs shares her essay on Aaron Judge. CALL THE SHOW: 406-404-8460 EMAIL THE SHOW: BleacherTweets@gmail.com REACH OUT ON X: #BLEACHERTWEETS 5:07 Eric Hosmer 26:06 Darryl Strawberry 26:56 David Schoenfield 41:29 Sarah Langs 42:56 Bleacher Tweets Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices