But You're Wrong Podcast

Follow But You're Wrong Podcast
Share on
Copy link to clipboard

Keith and Greg ditch structure to talk about whatever interests them while trying to amuse each other and you. Bizarre news, pop culture, flights of fancy -- it's always fun and always entertaining! Every episode is a great time to start listening!

Keith Bodayla & Greg DiNicola


    • Jul 6, 2018 LATEST EPISODE
    • infrequent NEW EPISODES
    • 1h AVG DURATION
    • 346 EPISODES


    Search for episodes from But You're Wrong Podcast with a specific topic:

    Latest episodes from But You're Wrong Podcast

    Episode 337: Flat Earth in a Fortnite

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 6, 2018 68:25


    Keith and Greg are back for a brief discussion on video games and what they've been up to. There's a little LL Cool J vs Biggie convo and then they do a little dive into the idea of Flat Earth and the world of Flat Earthers. Plus, Keith has one huge question.

    Episode 336: Status Update: The Pivot Begins

    Play Episode Listen Later May 27, 2018 11:22


    Keith is back with an update on what's been going on, reflecting on how Greg and Keith's lives have changed since the start and how the podcast will have to evolve too.

    Episode 335: Driving Lyft and Not Being Offended with John Oldfield

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 29, 2018 75:04


    Keith hangs out with Documentary Show co-host, John Oldfield. John's been driving Lyft and shares some stories. They talk about accents and people being offended. Plus, some talk about robots.

    Episode 334: When Idiots Fix Things and Invest in Cryptocurrency

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 15, 2018 13:53


    Brief discussion of video games, Greg fixes a sink, Keith takes apart a mattress, The Duo's close relationship and how much they've made from cryptocurrency.

    Episode 333: Memoriam for Pebbles and The Oscars

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 8, 2018 103:00


    Greg tells the story of what happens when you can't get a hamster on a plane. It does not end how Keith expects. The Duo talk about The Oscars and The MeToo Movement.

    Episode 332: Jabba's Palace Part 69

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 26, 2018 32:04


    The Duo respond to the longest comment on their Jabba's Palace YouTube video. They learn a lot about what this guy thinks happened in Star Wars.

    Episode 331: #Damerey, #Relo, #Renperor

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 19, 2018 58:48


    The Duo finally talk about Star Wars: The Last Jedi. Yea, it's one of those episodes. Did they love it? Did they hate it? And did one of them change their minds? They also mock some fan theories.

    Episode 330: The Academy of Feet

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 5, 2018 31:35


    Friend of the show, Myers, stops in. Then, The Duo talk about the craziness that is WikiFeet.com and the best feet of 2017. They're hope for sponsorship.

    Episode 329: Scamming the Scammers

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 30, 2018 83:26


    The Duo talk about urban explorers and old department stores. Greg reads some tweets. They fall down some rabbit holes. And Keith starts answering those scam calls and delivering something that's almost like justice.

    Episode 328: Dead Pool 2018

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 14, 2018 54:06


    The Duo are joined by fellow Wronger, John Oldfield of the Documentary Show for this years Dead Pool. After sorting out the holidays and edible jellyfish, they make their picks for the 2018 But You're Wrong Deadpool.

    Episode 327: Too Blessed To Be Stressed

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 7, 2018 87:34


    The Duo are back in 2018 with an episode recorded in 2017. They talk about what they've been up. Keith has house problems and is fired up. Greg is surprisingly mellow.

    Episode 326: Ball Shrapnel

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 2, 2017 74:39


    The Duo mourn the passing of AOL Instant Messenger which played a large part of their teenage years. Greg continues to win the Dead Pool. And a guy taints flutes across the world with himself.

    Episode 325: Greg Went on a Date Alone?

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 12, 2017 65:46


    Episode 324: Did The World End?

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 30, 2017 61:59


    Keith reveals that the world might end, it hasn’t yet. Greg shares celebrity crimes. And The Duo discuss Walmart and Marv Albert.

    Episode 323: Keith Might Have A Ghost

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 12, 2017 33:59


    Keith might have a ghost in his house after a strange carving shows up. Or Keith was drunk. The Duo investigate the paranormal with Rob Lowe and find nothing.

    Episode 322: John Stockton's Shorts

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 19, 2017 59:17


    Ok, so the episode isn't all about John Stockton's shorts, but it might as well be. Greg shares more secrets and what he has been up to on all these Wednesday afternoons when Keith can't get a hold of him. Keith gets old.

    Episode 321: 2001: A Tagline Odyssey

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 15, 2017 41:08


    The Duo consider a Family Friendly episode. They then endure of a battle of wits to determine who will edit the episode. Will Keith stump Greg with taglines from the films of 2001? Listen to find out.

    Episode 320: He’s Been Manscaping

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 31, 2017 45:45


    The Duo have a follow up to Jerry’s Records in Pittsburgh. Then Keith considers some beauty advice and Greg takes some time to pamper himself. PLUS: Keith’s cat makes an appearance.

    Episode 319: A Not So Quick recap

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 23, 2017 67:53


    The duo discusses a few things including Greg's trip out to Pittsburgh, their favorite record store, and the lost art of covering textbooks with brown paper bags.

    Episode 318: Weird Things That Turn You On

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 18, 2017 40:02


    The Duo discusses how much their moms still listen to the show. They consider a special episode. And Keith brought a game about some philias to turn you on. Or turn you off. Depends on what you’re into.

    Episode 317: Did You See It? Don’t Bother.

    Play Episode Listen Later Jul 12, 2017 44:24


    Keith punishes himself by playing video games. Greg doesn’t. Then Keith let’s Greg know the movies that he doesn’t need to bother seeing. Greg didn’t know any of them came out. Plus, Cosmo snores.

    Episode 316: Fear of Naming Games

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 25, 2017 21:23


    This one's a quick one, so don't get too worked up for it. Keith and Greg play a little game that Greg never came up with a name for. It is revealed that Keith does not know the name of phobia's, and neither of them can come up with a decent joke at the end to save themselves. Ed McMahon still had a ball, though.

    Episode 315: Around The Globe in 48 Minutes

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 18, 2017 48:14


    The Duo are recording in person this week. They went to the Giant Eagle and are looking at the strange world of The Globe. Plus Greg shows Keith Billy Joel’s daughter.

    Episode 314: They Just Don’t Do Sex Stuff

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 11, 2017 60:51


    The Duo ponder a new iTunes category. Keith is stressed, Greg less so. Keith is spending too much money on his house. Greg isn’t. Greg is winning the Dead Pool. Keith isn’t. And a man in Colorado is attacked.

    Episode 313: We Got Beef

    Play Episode Listen Later Jun 6, 2017 64:49


    Down the rabbit hole we go on Amazon reviews. This time with a wonderful woman from Virginia who likes soup and guns. The Duo then decide to look into a recent string of meat thefts in the Pittsburgh metro area, and Keith is a prime suspect.

    Episode 312: The Grossest Thing Keith Ever Saw

    Play Episode Listen Later May 28, 2017 48:56


    The Duo compare countries to superheroes. And Keith shares the story of the grossest thing he’s ever seen in real life.

    Episode 311: Not Funny

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 30, 2017 60:58


    The Duo discuss comedy, their tastes, and how they've changed in the last few years. They get a little snooty and discuss the logistics of intercourse with apple pies.

    Episode 310: Health Teaching

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 26, 2017 46:58


    Keith cleans out the garage. And that leads to The Duo going on a few tangents including health teachers that talked about sex ed. Also, Greg may have almost killed a teacher.

    Episode 309: The Goat Chronicles

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 19, 2017 36:59


    Greg is sporting a new look. Keith considers exercise. And The Duo share some stories of the place where they met, Goat.

    Episode 308: Buzz Aldrin Was In Transformers

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 9, 2017 42:04


    Greg follows Buzz Aldrin on Twitter. Keith listens to conservative talk radio. And The Duo hope Greg won’t get in trouble for ex-girlfriend stories Keith tells.

    Episode 307: Clarifying Star Wars

    Play Episode Listen Later Apr 4, 2017 36:52


    Keith has some questions about Star Wars. Greg clears things up. And The Duo know that this episode will piss off a number of people because they talk about things they don’t like in Star Wars. But at least they’re being honest.

    Episode 306: The 90’s Revival Episode

    Play Episode Listen Later Mar 26, 2017 62:39


    It’s like The Duo took a time machine back to the 90s. Keith and Greg talk about the trend of white guys in bands with dreadlocks, break-up songs, and Greg finds out what Party of Five was really about. Plus, automotive anti-theft devices.

    Episode 305: It's Not Lupus

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 26, 2017 62:48


    Keith and Greg thought that they were going to talk about something that Keith prepped, but that all gets cast aside when they start talking about House MD and bald eagles. It'll all make sense when you listen.

    Episode 304: Drama in the Checkout Aisle

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 19, 2017 68:16


    Keith forgets a major event and is late due to shopping issues. Greg has similar issues with a cashier and a waitress. A police blotter is read and the local bars are reviewed.

    Episode 303: The Illuminati Doesn't Do Shit

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 12, 2017 72:49


    Amazingly enough, it took 303 episodes before the duo started talking about Magic: The Gathering. They don't stay on the topic long since since there are lawsuits, illuminati, and Donald Trump to talk about.

    Episode 302: Apologies and a Podfession

    Play Episode Listen Later Feb 1, 2017 68:49


    The Duo make some edits to the world’s Pasta options and learn how to Au Gratin. They get an apology. And Keith makes a Podfession.

    Episode 301: A Game and A Dumpectomy

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 22, 2017 52:59


    Keith has some stories from the deli counter, and how he is becoming involved in his community. The duo then play a game about which celebrities have slept togehter, which provides for some interesting discussion.

    Episode 300: Johnathan Lee Riches Sued Lost

    Play Episode Listen Later Jan 18, 2017 79:50


    We’re back in 2017 to celebrate 300 episodes of non-sense! Keith reveals something embarrassing, another Dead Pool is submitted, and The Duo examine a lawsuit by their number one guy, Johnathan Lee Riches who sued the show Lost even before the series finale.

    Episode 299: Trigger Warnings and Dead Pool 2017

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 18, 2016 61:02


    Trigger Warning: This episode contains a lot of the same stuff The Duo normally talk about including things that bother them on Facebook and washed-up actors. Extra Trigger Warning: They also say something nice. PLUS: They announce their picks for the 2017 Dead Pool. Will Keith come back from his 2016 loss? Find out in 2018!

    Episode 298: My Mother the Dry Cleaner

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 18, 2016 94:24


    In what is likely the last episode of 2016, the duo jump around on a number of topics. They discuss a wedding they attended, a show that Keith attended, and how Keith's mother is very good at ironing.

    Episode 297: Steak Parms and Raw Turkey

    Play Episode Listen Later Dec 5, 2016 69:11


    The Duo get sidetracked with show production and a familiar topic. They explain their absence, make some food, have Thanksgiving and update the blow out that is the Dead Pool.

    Episode 296: Bumpin Uglies

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 14, 2016 57:54


    The Duo gets together to discuss their old job and their current legal issues. They also share awkward stories from their recent past. Keith goes to Dunkin Donuts, Greg goes to some strip clubs.

    Episode 295: The Trump House

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 6, 2016 57:54


    Keith visits The Trump House before the election. Greg doesn’t close a browser window. Peter Falk is mentioned. And The Duo field a complaint from the audience.

    Episode 294: Grab Your Cat By The P*ssy

    Play Episode Listen Later Nov 1, 2016 71:14


    The duo touch on a couple topics that they normally avoid, cats and politics. Keith finally gets his cat back from his parents in New Jersey and regains some clothing. The duo then get into the election modd with some political discussion...even though they mostly just hate it.

    Episode 293: Alderaanian Lives Matter

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 18, 2016 79:35


    Keith has issues with body counts in movies, but not how you might think. Greg brings us back into the world of Furries. Plus, the importance of Shaq’s autograph.

    Episode 292: Continental Drift

    Play Episode Listen Later Oct 2, 2016 47:15


    Greg and Keith give the listeners an update on the Dead Pool, and Keith's uphill odds of winning. Greg the recounts his trip to Iceland in excruciating detail. Prepare to be enlightened.

    Episode 291: Keith Buys A National Examiner

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 21, 2016 50:15


    To fit in better with the times, Keith buys a National Examiner at Wal-Mart. Only problem is he told Greg it was a National Enquirer. The Duo explore the rag regardless and learn of many plots against the Queen of England.

    Episode 290: Remember My Face

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 13, 2016 43:18


    Greg prepares for a trip to Iceland to see a lot of animal dongs. Keith asks a hypothetical not about dongs. And no one says the word “dong.”

    Episode 289: A Couple of Losers

    Play Episode Listen Later Sep 7, 2016 83:11


    Keith and Greg Explore Keith's clumsiness and his inability to leave his house without getting injured. They also play a game that Greg thinks he'll be great at...he's painfully wrong.

    Episode 288: Podfessions: Bugs and Poo Edition

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 29, 2016 65:47


    The Duo share stories of shady characters before launching a new segment, Podfessions. Keith and Greg each share some level of embarrassing story from their past. Keith has ones about a girlfriend and bugs that isn’t that good. And Greg has one about Poo that is great.

    Episode 287: I Guess This is Growing Up

    Play Episode Listen Later Aug 15, 2016 87:35


    The Duo are back, we'd say better than ever, but we haven't really set the bar that high. Keith has joined the ranks of the home ownership and is realizing how much fun it can be. Greg sympathizes, but only with the purchasing part, since he took the easy route and got a condo.

    Claim But You're Wrong Podcast

    In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

    Claim Cancel