A true crime podcast that recalls the brutal slaying of BETTY ANN SULLIVAN on a snowy night in January of 1988, a night that, more than 30 years later, the small town of Jefferson Township, New Jersey has yet to fully recover from. The violence of that evening shocked the nation for the perpetrator... was her own son, a boy of fourteen who would take his own life only hours later. What the investigation revealed left a community in tatters, unwilling to believe the evil that had befallen them.
The Devil Within is a meticulously researched and professionally produced podcast that delves into the intriguing story of a murder-suicide in West Milford. As someone who grew up in the area, I found this podcast to be a particularly well-told account of the events surrounding the crime. The deep dive into local history was a fascinating aspect of the podcast that added depth and context to the story. The host did an excellent job of presenting various theories, including paranormal explanations, in a relevant and thoughtful manner. Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed each episode and felt that it brought me closer to home.
One of the best aspects of The Devil Within is its ability to stick with you long after you finish listening. The tragic nature of the story and the lingering questions about the murder create a sense of intrigue that stays with you. The podcast also does a great job of incorporating the paranormal aspects of the case, adding an extra layer of mystery to the story. I particularly appreciated how well-researched and well-produced each episode was, making for a compelling listen.
While there were many positive aspects to this podcast, some reviewers have criticized it for its speculative nature and inclusion of paranormal explanations. However, I believe that these elements are entirely relevant given the circumstances surrounding the crime. It is important to remember that this is true crime storytelling, not just investigative reporting. With real-life occurrences like this, there are often unknown details that are open to interpretation. It is refreshing to hear alternative viewpoints and explore different perspectives on what happened.
In conclusion, The Devil Within is an engaging and thought-provoking podcast that offers a unique perspective on a true crime story. Despite some negative reviews criticizing its speculative nature, I believe that this podcast successfully presents multiple viewpoints while maintaining an intriguing narrative throughout each episode. From its meticulous research to its professional production quality, this podcast stands out as one of my favorites in the true crime genre. Whether or not you're a fan of paranormal aspects or speculative theories, I highly recommend giving The Devil Within a chance. It may just leave you captivated and wanting more.
Stopping By Woods On a Snowy Evening: REDUX (Part Two) The darkest night of the year. A chilling poem by Robert Frost. And a teenager walking into the woods of Jefferson Township, never to return the same. In this REDUX edition of The Devil Within, we return to Stopping By Woods On a Snowy Evening, exploring how Frost's poetry of solitude and dread became an eerie mirror for the life and death of Tommy Sullivan. With added commentary and deeper analysis, Branden Morgan traces how the winter solstice, ancient folklore, and occult historyconverged in the Pine Barrens—and how one boy's story still resonates nearly four decades later. This re-release comes in support of the MGM+ documentary series Let the Devil In, currently the #1 show on the platform, expanding the story of Season One into a chilling new visual dimension. Support & Connect • Stream Let the Devil In now, only on MGM+. • Visit http://www.quince.com/devilwithin for free shipping and 365-day returns. • Go to www.mood.com/devilwithin and use promo code DEVILWITHIN for 20% off your first order. • Follow us on Instagram: @thedevilwithinpod (https://instagram.com/thedevilwithinpod). • For press & inquiries: info@eviocreative.com. • Don't forget to rate, review, and follow The Devil Within wherever you get your podcasts.
Stopping By Woods On a Snowy Evening: REDUX (Part One) The darkest night of the year. A chilling poem by Robert Frost. And a teenager walking into the woods of Jefferson Township, never to return the same. In this REDUX edition of The Devil Within, we return to Stopping By Woods On a Snowy Evening, exploring how Frost's poetry of solitude and dread became an eerie mirror for the life and death of Tommy Sullivan. With added commentary and deeper analysis, Branden Morgan traces how the winter solstice, ancient folklore, and occult historyconverged in the Pine Barrens—and how one boy's story still resonates nearly four decades later. This re-release comes in support of the MGM+ documentary series Let the Devil In, currently the #1 show on the platform, expanding the story of Season One into a chilling new visual dimension. Support & Connect • Stream Let the Devil In now, only on MGM+. • Visit http://www.quince.com/devilwithin for free shipping and 365-day returns. • Go to www.mood.com/devilwithin and use promo code DEVILWITHIN for 20% off your first order. • Follow us on Instagram: @thedevilwithinpod (https://instagram.com/thedevilwithinpod). • For press & inquiries: info@eviocreative.com. • Don't forget to rate, review, and follow The Devil Within wherever you get your podcasts.
The Ides of April: The Assassination of Julius Caesar (Part II) In the conclusion of our two-part story on the fall of the Roman Republic, host Branden Morgan of The Devil Withincontinues the saga of Julius Caesar's last days and their aftermath. This episode covers the final three chapters: • The Fallout — Mark Antony seizes the moment, and Rome's streets erupt in chaos. • Judgment of History — Brutus and Cassius, hailed by some as liberators and condemned by others as traitors. • The Death of the Republic, Birth of the Empire — How Caesar's assassination closed one chapter of Rome and opened another that would last for centuries. The knives ended Caesar's life, but they could not stop the tide of empire. Support Our Sponsors • Take the online quiz and introduce Ollie to your pet. Visit https://www.ollie.com/ides for 60% off your first box of meals!#ToKnowThemIsToLoveThem • Use code IDES at www.monarchmoney.com (http://www.monarchmoney.com/) in your browser for 50% off your first year. Follow & Connect • Follow us on Instagram: @idesofaprilpod (https://instagram.com/idesofaprilpod). • For press & inquiries: info@eviocreative.com. • Don't forget to rate, review, and follow The Ides of April wherever you get your podcasts. • And check out more shows from Evio Creative, including The Devil Within.
Spring and Fall to a Young Child: REDUX We return to one of the most haunting chapters of The Devil Within—this time with new commentary and deeper insights. In this REDUX edition, we explore Gerard Manley Hopkins' poem Spring and Fall to a Young Child, a work whose meditation on loss and innocence casts a chilling light on the story of Tommy Sullivan. Alongside the poem, we examine Tommy's life as a young wrestler in Jefferson Township, New Jersey—a world of pressure, discipline, and hidden struggle. You'll also hear newly added clips from an interview with Jefferson Township resident and former wrestler Dave Esposito, who helps us understand the intensity of the sport, the culture it creates, and what that meant for a boy like Tommy Sullivan TDW_E4 . This re-release is part of our REDUX series, updated to support the MGM+ documentary Let the Devil In, which brings the story of Season One to television with gripping new detail and perspective. Support & Connect • Stream Let the Devil In now, only on MGM+. • Visit http://www.quince.com/devilwithin for free shipping and 365-day returns. • Follow us on Instagram: @thedevilwithinpod (https://instagram.com/thedevilwithinpod). • Questions or inquiries? Email: info@eviocreative.com. • Don't forget to rate, review, and follow The Devil Within wherever you get your podcasts.
Spring and Fall to a Young Child: REDUX We return to one of the most haunting chapters of The Devil Within—this time with new commentary and deeper insights. In this REDUX edition, we explore Gerard Manley Hopkins' poem Spring and Fall to a Young Child, a work whose meditation on loss and innocence casts a chilling light on the story of Tommy Sullivan. Alongside the poem, we examine Tommy's life as a young wrestler in Jefferson Township, New Jersey—a world of pressure, discipline, and hidden struggle. You'll also hear newly added clips from an interview with Jefferson Township resident and former wrestler Dave Esposito, who helps us understand the intensity of the sport, the culture it creates, and what that meant for a boy like Tommy Sullivan. This re-release is part of our REDUX series, updated to support the MGM+ documentary Let the Devil In, which brings the story of Season One to television with gripping new detail and perspective. Support & Connect • Stream Let the Devil In now, only on MGM+. • Visit http://www.quince.com/devilwithin for free shipping and 365-day returns. • Follow us on Instagram: @thedevilwithinpod (https://instagram.com/thedevilwithinpod). • Questions or inquiries? Email: info@eviocreative.com. • Don't forget to rate, review, and follow The Devil Within wherever you get your podcasts.
The Ides of April: The Assassination of Julius Caesar (Part I) The Ides of April is back—and now it's a weekly series of new stories from across history, narrated by Branden Morganof The Devil Within. In this two-part debut story, we return to the Roman Republic at its breaking point. Part I covers the first three chapters of Julius Caesar's dramatic rise and bloody fall: • The Rise of Caesar — From military genius to dictator-for-life, how Caesar unbalanced the Republic. • The Conspiracy Forms — Brutus, Cassius, and their allies wrestle with loyalty, power, and the fate of Rome. • The Ides of March — A day of omens fulfilled, as knives are drawn in Pompey's Theater. This is where the Republic gasped its last breath, and the Empire began to stir. Follow & Connect • Follow us on Instagram: @idesofaprilpod (https://instagram.com/idesofaprilpod). • For press & inquiries: info@eviocreative.com. • Don't forget to rate, review, and follow The Ides of April wherever you get your podcasts. • And check out more shows from Evio Creative, including The Devil Within. Take the online quiz and introduce Ollie to your pet. Visit https://www.ollie.com/ides for 60% off your first box of meals! #ToKnowThemIsToLoveThem Use code IDES at www.monarchmoney.com in your browser for half off your first year. That's 50% off your first year at www.monarchmoney.com with code IDES.
A Spellbound Palace: REDUX We're going back inside the ruins of Cross Castle. In this REDUX re-release of The Devil Within, Branden Morgan revisits A Spellbound Palace, a chilling tale of occult rituals, isolation, and the haunted ground that lured Tommy Sullivan to Clinton Road. Originally released in Season One, this episode has been updated with new commentary and insights—exploring how the story has evolved over the last four years and how it aligns with the new MGM+ documentary series Let the Devil In. From the legacy of Richard Cross's Bearfort estate to the whispered satanic rituals of the 1980s, the legend of the so-called “Most Haunted Road in America” takes on new meaning when paired with fresh testimony, cinematic retellings, and the investigative depth of the MGM+ series. Whether you've heard this story before or are stepping into the shadows for the first time, this Redux version pulls you even deeper into the darkness of Jefferson Township. Follow & Connect • Subscribe to MGM+ to watch Let the Devil In, the documentary series based on Season One of The Devil Within. • Follow us on Instagram: @thedevilwithinpod (https://instagram.com/thedevilwithinpod) & @eviocreative (https://instagram.com/eviocreative). • For press & inquiries: info@eviocreative.com. • Don't forget to rate, review, and follow The Devil Within wherever you get your podcasts.
Show Notes – A Spellbound Palace: REDUX We're going back inside the ruins of Cross Castle. In this REDUX re-release of The Devil Within, Branden Morgan revisits A Spellbound Palace, a chilling tale of occult rituals, isolation, and the haunted ground that lured Tommy Sullivan to Clinton Road. Originally released in Season One, this episode has been updated with new commentary and insights—exploring how the story has evolved over the last four years and how it aligns with the new MGM+ documentary series Let the Devil In. From the legacy of Richard Cross's Bearfort estate to the whispered satanic rituals of the 1980s, the legend of the so-called “Most Haunted Road in America” takes on new meaning when paired with fresh testimony, cinematic retellings, and the investigative depth of the MGM+ series. Whether you've heard this story before or are stepping into the shadows for the first time, this Redux version pulls you even deeper into the darkness of Jefferson Township. Follow & Connect • Subscribe to MGM+ to watch Let the Devil In, the documentary series based on Season One of The Devil Within. • Follow us on Instagram: @thedevilwithinpod (https://instagram.com/thedevilwithinpod) & @eviocreative (https://instagram.com/eviocreative). • For press & inquiries: info@eviocreative.com. • Don't forget to rate, review, and follow The Devil Within wherever you get your podcasts.
Interview with Trey Nelson (Director of Let the Devil In) This week on The Devil Within host Branden Morgan sits down with filmmaker Trey Nelson, director of the new MGM+ documentary series Let the Devil In. The series—based on Season One of The Devil Within—brings the haunting story of Jefferson Township to the screen with gripping visuals, never-before-seen interviews, and an intensity that lingers long after the credits roll. Trey shares what drew him to this dark chapter in American true crime, how he approached the balance between fact and myth, and the creative choices behind capturing fear, paranoia, and belief on screen. Together, we talk about trust, responsibility, and the challenges of translating a podcast into a cinematic documentary. Plus, Trey opens up about his own background, influences, and what he hopes Let the Devil In will mean for viewers. Follow & Connect • Subscribe to MGM+ to watch Let the Devil In — now streaming. • Follow us on Instagram: @thedevilwithinpod (https://instagram.com/thedevilwithinpod) & @eviocreative (https://instagram.com/eviocreative). • For press & inquiries: info@eviocreative.com. • Don't forget to rate, review, and follow The Devil Within wherever you get your podcasts.
The Devil Within: Paradise Lost: REDUX - Part Two In 1988, Jefferson Township, New Jersey, was thrust into the national spotlight. A teenage boy, Tommy Sullivan, murdered his mother before taking his own life in a crime so shocking it became a lightning rod for the Satanic Panic. Suddenly, everything—from heavy metal music to role-playing games to Catholic school curriculums—was scrutinized as potential gateways to darkness. This episode, Paradise Lost, explores how Tommy's seemingly ordinary suburban life unraveled in just a matter of weeks: his exposure to occult literature, his fascination with extreme music, whispers of rituals in the woods, and a town hall meeting where parents confronted the chilling possibility that their own traditions might have paved the way for horror. Now, four years after this story first aired on The Devil Within, I'm bringing it back as part of our REDUX season—with brand new commentary. Together, we'll re-examine what we thought we knew about the Sullivan case, how the story has evolved since we first told it, and how the MGM+ documentary series Let the Devil In aligns with and expands on each episode of Season One. And while I can't reveal everything just yet, know this: there are stunning new developments, and we'll be unpacking them in our upcoming bonus episode. Follow & Connect • Subscribe to MGM+ to watch Let the Devil In — now streaming. • Follow us on Instagram: @thedevilwithinpod (https://instagram.com/thedevilwithinpod) & @eviocreative (https://instagram.com/eviocreative). • For press & inquiries: info@eviocreative.com. • Don't forget to rate, review, and follow The Devil Within wherever you get your podcasts.
The Devil Within: Paradise Lost (REDUX) In 1988, Jefferson Township, New Jersey, was thrust into the national spotlight. A teenage boy, Tommy Sullivan, murdered his mother before taking his own life in a crime so shocking it became a lightning rod for the Satanic Panic. Suddenly, everything—from heavy metal music to role-playing games to Catholic school curriculums—was scrutinized as potential gateways to darkness TDW_E2 . This episode, Paradise Lost, explores how Tommy's seemingly ordinary suburban life unraveled in just a matter of weeks: his exposure to occult literature, his fascination with extreme music, whispers of rituals in the woods, and a town hall meeting where parents confronted the chilling possibility that their own traditions might have paved the way for horror. Now, four years after this story first aired on The Devil Within, I'm bringing it back as part of our REDUX season—with brand new commentary from me, Branden Morgan. Together, we'll reexamine what we thought we knew about the Sullivan case, how the story has evolved since we first told it, and how the MGM+ documentary series Let the Devil Inaligns with and expands on each episode of Season One. And while I can't reveal everything just yet, know this: there are stunning new developments, and we'll be unpacking them in our upcoming bonus episode. Follow & Connect • Subscribe to MGM+ to watch Let the Devil In — now streaming. • Follow us on Instagram: @thedevilwithinpod (https://instagram.com/thedevilwithinpod) & @eviocreative (https://instagram.com/eviocreative). • For press & inquiries: info@eviocreative.com. • Don't forget to rate, review, and follow The Devil Within wherever you get your podcasts.
Interview with Christopher Brian (Let the Devil In) In this special episode of The Devil Within, host Branden Morgan sits down with Christopher Brian, the actor who portrays Tommy Sullivan in the new MGM+ documentary series Let the Devil In. Together, they explore the art and intensity behind stepping into the shoes of a boy at the center of one of America's most disturbing true crime stories. Christopher shares how he prepared for the role, the acting techniques he relied on, and the weight of portraying a real person whose story still haunts a community decades later. He also opens up about the audition process, what drew him to the project, his experiences on set, and how the role has changed the way he thinks about his craft. For Christopher, Let the Devil In is more than just a credit — it's a chance to carve a path forward in his career while honoring the legacy of a story that should never be forgotten. In This Episode • How Christopher Brian landed the role of Tommy Sullivan. • The challenges of portraying real-life tragedy on screen. • Behind-the-scenes insights from the MGM+ set. Call to Action • Watch Let the Devil In now on MGM+. • Follow us on Instagram: @thedevilwithinpod (https://instagram.com/thedevilwithinpod?utm_source=chatgpt.com) & @eviocreative (https://instagram.com/eviocreative?utm_source=chatgpt.com). • For press & inquiries: info@eviocreative.com. • Don't forget to rate, review, and follow The Devil Within wherever you get your podcasts.
The Devil Within Season One: In the bleak midwinter of 1988, the quiet town of Jefferson Township, New Jersey, was shaken to its core. A mother was found brutally murdered. Her teenage son vanished into the night. What unfolded in the hours and days that followed would horrify even the most seasoned investigators — and feed directly into the fever dream of the Satanic Panicsweeping across America. This was the case that introduced listeners to The Devil Within. It wasn't just a true crime story — it was the beginning of a descent into fear, paranoia, and the darker corners of human belief. Now, we're re-releasing The Jersey Devil with a twist. Host and writer Branden Morgan returns to the story with new commentary, reflecting on what it meant to tell this tale the first time, what he's uncovered since, and why the Sullivan case still lingers in the American imagination. This re-release also marks a milestone: the launch of the new MGM+ documentary series Let the Devil In, based on season one of The Devil Within. The four-part series — premiering August 31st — expands on the original story with exclusive interviews, never-before-seen evidence, and firsthand accounts from detectives, first responders, and those who lived through the nightmare. In This Episode • The brutal 1988 murder that shocked Jefferson Township. • How the case became entwined with the national hysteria of the Satanic Panic. • New behind-the-scenes reflections from Branden Morgan. • How this story connects to the upcoming MGM+ series Let the Devil In. Why Revisit This Story Now? Because some stories never truly leave us. They echo, they evolve, and sometimes, they return in ways we never expect. The Jersey Devil is not only a cornerstone of this podcast — it's the origin of a much larger journey that's about to play out on screen. Follow & Connect • Instagram: @eviocreative (https://instagram.com/eviocreative?utm_source=chatgpt.com) • Email: info@eviocreative.com • Watch Let the Devil In on MGM+ – Premiering August 31st
The Devil Within - Season One In the bleak midwinter of 1988, the quiet town of Jefferson Township, New Jersey, was shaken to its core. A mother was found brutally murdered. Her teenage son vanished into the night. What unfolded in the hours and days that followed would horrify even the most seasoned investigators — and feed directly into the fever dream of the Satanic Panicsweeping across America. This was the case that introduced listeners to The Devil Within. It wasn't just a true crime story — it was the beginning of a descent into fear, paranoia, and the darker corners of human belief. Now, we're re-releasing The Jersey Devil with a twist. Host and writer Branden Morgan returns to the story with new commentary, reflecting on what it meant to tell this tale the first time, what he's uncovered since, and why the Sullivan case still lingers in the American imagination. This re-release also marks a milestone: the launch of the new MGM+ documentary series Let the Devil In, based on season one of The Devil Within. The four-part series — premiering August 31st — expands on the original story with exclusive interviews, never-before-seen evidence, and firsthand accounts from detectives, first responders, and those who lived through the nightmare. In This Episode • The brutal 1988 murder that shocked Jefferson Township. • How the case became entwined with the national hysteria of the Satanic Panic. • New behind-the-scenes reflections from Branden Morgan. • How this story connects to the upcoming MGM+ series Let the Devil In. Why Revisit This Story Now? Because some stories never truly leave us. They echo, they evolve, and sometimes, they return in ways we never expect. The Jersey Devil is not only a cornerstone of this podcast — it's the origin of a much larger journey that's about to play out on screen. Follow & Connect • Instagram: @eviocreative (https://instagram.com/eviocreative?utm_source=chatgpt.com) • Email: info@eviocreative.com • Watch Let the Devil In on MGM+ – Premiering August 31st
Danielle Franco, show runner and director of the MGM+ series Let the Devil In, joins Branden for an in-depth discussion on what it takes to go from a true crime podcast to a four part documentary series. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
The Devil Within – Denver Confidential Part Two The shadows of Denver stretch deeper than anyone dares to admit. In Part Two, we return to the Mile High City's darkest corners, where history, legend, and the supernatural collide. Chapter Four leads us into the halls of the old Fitzsimons Army Hospital, where soldiers once healed, and spirits still linger in corridors thick with memory. Chapter Five drags us down to the River North district, where the “Demon of RiNo” turned industrial decay into a breeding ground for nightmares. And Chapter Six pulls us beneath Colfax Avenue, where whispers tell of children who never made it home—and whose voices still echo below the streets. Part cautionary tale, part séance in the dark, Denver Confidential closes with stories that blur the line between myth and memory, forcing us to ask: how much of Denver's past is really past? Follow The Devil Within on Instagram @thedevilwithinpod (https://www.instagram.com/thedevilwithinpod) and @eviocreative (https://www.instagram.com/eviocreative). Got a theory, story, or haunting of your own? Email us at info@eviocreative.com Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
The Devil Within – Denver Confidential: Part One Denver is a city built on secrets, and some of them refuse to stay buried. In this episode, we pull back the curtain on the Mile High City's darkest legends, where whispered stories of séances, restless spirits, and long-forgotten curses converge. Chapter One takes us inside the Brown Palace Hotel, where high society once gathered for a séance that spiraled into something far more sinister. Chapter Two follows us to Cheesman Park, a lush expanse of green built over the bones of thousands—a playground for the living and a graveyard for the dead. And in Chapter Three, we climb the steps of Colorado's State Capitol, where the foundations themselves carry a curse and the echoes of a troubled past. Part history, part nightmare, Denver Confidential exposes the city's haunted underbelly and the spectral fingerprints left on its most iconic places. Follow The Devil Within on Instagram @thedevilwithinpod (https://www.instagram.com/thedevilwithinpod) and @eviocreative (https://www.instagram.com/eviocreative). Got a theory, story, or haunting of your own? Email us at info@eviocreative.com. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Stolen Voices of Dole Valley is a haunting investigative podcast series from Pie in the Sky Media, KSL Podcasts and Lemonada, hosted by Carolyn Ossorio. With immersive storytelling, archival tape, and survivor interviews, the show revisits one of the darkest, most under-reported serial predator cases in the Pacific Northwest. The series begins in the early 1970s, when 16-year-old Jamie Grissim vanishes from her foster home in Vancouver, Washington. She would become the first suspected victim in a string of disappearances and murders stretching across rural Clark County. But for years, the cases remained unconnected—dismissed as runaways, forgotten in filing cabinets, or ignored altogether. At the center of this story is Norma Jean Countryman, a 15-year-old girl who escaped her abductor by chewing through the ropes that bound her. Her account, dismissed by police at the time, holds the key to understanding the scale and method of a predator hiding in plain sight… Through meticulous reporting and the raw testimony of survivors and family members, Stolen Voices of Dole Valley brings long-buried stories to light. From a body in a silo mistaken for D.B. Cooper to a grieving sister who becomes a tireless advocate, each episode builds toward justice —and reckoning. Over 50 years after the first disappearance, this series uncovers systemic failures, cultural blind spots, and the fierce resilience of those left behind. In a community desperate for closure, these voices—once ignored—finally speak for themselves. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
The Devil Within — The Caracas Seminary Possession: Part Two In the shadow of the Andes, a shuttered seminary holds more than dust and memories. Whispers in the chapel. A vanished priest. A locked door that was never truly locked. In Part Two of The Caracas Seminary Possession, the line between ritual and reckoning blurs. From a midnight Mass that leaves nine witnesses changed forever, to the disturbing discovery beneath the chapel's foundation, this chapter pulls us deeper into a mystery the Church would rather forget. The question isn't what happened inside San Miguel Seminary— It's what might still be happening.
The Devil Within — The Caracas Seminary Possession: Part One A crumbling seminary in Caracas. Nine witnesses who swore they saw the impossible. And a Church desperate to bury the truth—along with the bodies. In Part One of The Caracas Seminary Possession, we open the locked doors of San Miguel for the first time in decades. Through survivor testimony, long-sealed diocesan files, and forgotten police reports, we follow the trail from a single unexplained incident to a full-scale exorcism that spiraled out of control. Some say the evil was cast out. Others believe it never left.
EPISODE 4: “...To the Ages” April 14, 1865. A shot rings out—and a nation holds its breath. The Ides of April chronicles the moments after Lincoln's assassination at Ford's Theatre. From Dr. Charles Leale's desperate efforts to save the President to Booth's narrow escape across the Navy Yard Bridge, this is the night history changed forever.
Let the Devil In — The Devil Within Comes to MGM+ Description: In 1989, Jefferson Township, New Jersey, was shaken to its core by the murder–suicide of Tommy Sullivan and his mother. The Devil Within first told that story in its debut season—peeling back the layers of mystery, fear, and unanswered questions. But now… the story goes deeper. On August 31, the case takes on new life in a four-part documentary series on MGM+ titled Let the Devil In, executive produced by horror legend Eli Roth. This isn't a simple retelling—it's an evolution. More than a dozen new voices have come forward, including the lead detective on the case, the first officers on the scene, and Tommy's high school principal—one of the last people to speak with him before that horrific night. In this episode, Branden Morgan shares the behind-the-scenes story of how The Devil Within became Let the Devil In, the revelations uncovered along the way, and why you'll want to sign up for MGM+ to watch it. Plus, to mark the occasion, The Devil Within is re-releasing Season One—with brand new commentary and perspective after nearly five years of living with this story. And one more thing… this is the first-ever video episode of the podcast, with every episode going forward available to watch as well as listen. The story isn't over. In fact, it's never been told quite like this. Watch Let the Devil In—premiering August 31 on MGM+.
THE IDES OF APRIL EPISODE 3: “Joy Cometh in the Morning”November 1864. A night at the theater becomes a night of terror. In this episode of The Ides of April, Alec Baldwin tells the story of the fateful performance of Julius Caesar that united the Booth brothers on stage—and foreshadowed the tragedy to come. From a Confederate plot to burn New York City to Booth's growing obsession with Lincoln's demise, we follow the night that turned the actor into a would-be assassin.
EPISODE 2: “Tragedy and Comedy” The stage is set. The war is over. But for John Wilkes Booth, the fight has just begun. In Episode Two of The Ides of April, we follow Booth's transformation from frustrated actor to radical conspirator. From failed kidnapping plots to brazen plans of coordinated assassinations, Booth and his band of loyal followers edge closer to infamy. We trace the roots of his hatred, his obsession with legacy, and the moment Lincoln's final speech pushed him over the edge.
Show Notes: It started as a story whispered at campfires and on playgrounds. But on Staten Island, the name Cropsey became something far more terrifying—a legend that seemed to step out of the shadows and into reality. In the first half of this two-part episode of The Devil Within, we trace the origins of the Cropsey myth, from abandoned asylums to forgotten tunnels. We explore how fear took root in a community, and how a monster of folklore became linked to real-life tragedy.
Show Notes: It started as a story whispered at campfires and on playgrounds. But on Staten Island, the name Cropsey became something far more terrifying—a legend that seemed to step out of the shadows and into reality. In the first half of this two-part episode of The Devil Within, we trace the origins of the Cropsey myth, from abandoned asylums to forgotten tunnels. We explore how fear took root in a community, and how a monster of folklore became linked to real-life tragedy.
EPISODE 1: Northern Aggression April 1865. The Civil War ends—but the peace is fragile, and the nation stands at the edge of chaos. In this first episode of The Ides of April, we explore the days leading to the assassination of Abraham Lincoln. We uncover the towering egos, the desperate plots, and the fractures in a nation struggling to heal. What drove John Wilkes Booth—a celebrity actor and son of a famous family—to transform into an agent of terror? And how did his personal insecurities and extremist beliefs ignite one of the most shocking acts in American history?
THE IDES OF APRIL Show Description: The Ides of April is a gripping historical podcast that takes you inside the final 17 days of John Wilkes Booth's life—from the surrender at Appomattox to the assassination of Abraham Lincoln and the largest manhunt in American history. Narrated by Alec Baldwin, this immersive series blends dramatic storytelling, historical detail, and expert insight to trace the deadly plot that changed the nation forever.
Show Notes: In 1984, a brutal murder in the woods of Northport, New York shocked the nation and ignited a moral panic that still echoes today. In this episode of The Devil Within, we dive into the dark and chaotic life of Ricky Kasso—the so-called “Acid King”—whose obsession with the occult, drugs, and Satanic symbolism spiraled into violence. From his troubled upbringing to the infamous killing of his friend Gary Lauwers during what some called a ritual sacrifice, we separate myth from fact and explore the real horror at the heart of the legend.
THE IDES OF APRIL Show Description: The Ides of April is a gripping historical podcast that takes you inside the final 17 days of John Wilkes Booth's life—from the surrender at Appomattox to the assassination of Abraham Lincoln and the largest manhunt in American history. Narrated by Alec Baldwin, this immersive series blends dramatic storytelling, historical detail, and expert insight to trace the deadly plot that changed the nation forever.
Show Notes: In the dark heart of Washington State, a predator stalked his prey. Jack Spillman earned the name “The Werewolf Butcher” for crimes so brutal, they seemed ripped from myth. In this chilling episode of The Devil Within, we explore Spillman's terrifying attacks, his obsession with wolves and the occult, and the twisted psychology that drove him to kill.
Show Notes: December 8th, 1980. New York City. John Lennon is gunned down outside The Dakota, and the world loses a Beatle. When police arrest his killer, Mark David Chapman, they find him carrying a copy of The Catcher in the Rye—a book that, for him, blurred the lines between fiction and murder. In this episode of Taboo Treasures, we explore the haunting artifact at the center of this infamous crime. From the history of The Beatles and J.D. Salinger's iconic novel to Chapman's obsession and New York's dark night, we unpack the symbolism of that paperback. We'll also follow the journey of this chilling collectible—right to the auction block.
Show Notes: Italy — land of empires, saints… and monsters. In this haunting series of The Devil Within, we uncover the chilling legends that lurk behind Italy's beauty. From the night battles of the Benandanti in Friuli to the wolf cults of Lucera, the possessed convent of Prato, and the submerged beasts of Venice — these are not just stories. These are warnings. Across 12 gripping episodes, we explore centuries of folklore, true crime, and the terrifying spaces where they overlap. Werewolves in noble courts. Skinwalkers among shepherds. Choirs that sang to the abyss. Some say these tales are myth. Others know better.
Show Notes: Italy — land of empires, saints… and monsters. In this haunting series of The Devil Within, we uncover the chilling legends that lurk behind Italy's beauty. From the night battles of the Benandanti in Friuli to the wolf cults of Lucera, the possessed convent of Prato, and the submerged beasts of Venice — these are not just stories. These are warnings. Across 12 gripping episodes, we explore centuries of folklore, true crime, and the terrifying spaces where they overlap. Werewolves in noble courts. Skinwalkers among shepherds. Choirs that sang to the abyss. Some say these tales are myth. Others know better. EPISODE 7: The Beast Beneath Venice Long before tourists filled St. Mark's Square, locals spoke of a creature beneath the canals — a wolf that fed not on flesh, but on sin. EPISODE 8: The Black Huntsman of Sicily A shadow on horseback terrorized the island's countryside. Was it a bandit? A ghost? Or the last of the ancient wolf-blooded clans? EPISODE 9: The Werewolf Trials of Tuscany Between the plague years, fear took root in the villages — and men stood trial not for witchcraft, but for turning wolf beneath the full moon.
Show Notes: In 1997, the world was stunned by the mass suicide of 39 members of the Heaven's Gate cult in San Diego. But one detail stood out in every photo of that tragic scene—the matching black Nike Decade sneakers on each body. In this episode of Taboo Treasures, we explore how these now-infamous shoes became a dark symbol of the cult's final ritual. We trace the origins of Heaven's Gate, led by Marshall Applewhite, the apocalyptic beliefs tied to the Hale-Bopp comet, and the eerie details of that last night—right down to the poisoned applesauce.
Show Notes: Italy — land of empires, saints… and monsters. In this haunting series of The Devil Within, we uncover the chilling legends that lurk behind Italy's beauty. From the night battles of the Benandanti in Friuli to the wolf cults of Lucera, the possessed convent of Prato, and the submerged beasts of Venice — these are not just stories. These are warnings. Across 12 gripping episodes, we explore centuries of folklore, true crime, and the terrifying spaces where they overlap. Werewolves in noble courts. Skinwalkers among shepherds. Choirs that sang to the abyss. Some say these tales are myth. Others know better. EPISODE 4: The Werewolf of Naples A noble family's darkest secret — a man who prowled the city's outskirts, not as a prince, but as a beast. EPISODE 5: The Possessed Convent of Prato In 1587, the nuns of Prato claimed they were stalked by a wolfish demon. Was it mass hysteria — or a predator cloaked in faith? EPISODE 6: The Wolf and the Pope A Vatican advisor accused of lycanthropy. A secret tribunal. And a question that shook the Church: can a soul turn feral?
Show Notes: Italy — land of empires, saints… and monsters. In this haunting series of The Devil Within, we uncover the chilling legends that lurk behind Italy's beauty. From the night battles of the Benandanti in Friuli to the wolf cults of Lucera, the possessed convent of Prato, and the submerged beasts of Venice — these are not just stories. These are warnings. Across 12 gripping episodes, we explore centuries of folklore, true crime, and the terrifying spaces where they overlap. Werewolves in noble courts. Skinwalkers among shepherds. Choirs that sang to the abyss. Some say these tales are myth. Others know better. EPISODE 1: The Curse of Lucera In the shadow of the ancient Roman colony of Lucera, a wolf cult thrived — and its echoes still haunt the Apulian hills. Explore how settlers, invaders, and wolves shared blood, soil, and secrets. EPISODE 2: The Benandanti of Friuli They called themselves “the good walkers” — but the Church called them witches. Discover the night battles fought between these dream warriors and the forces of evil. EPISODE 3: The Skinwalkers of Abruzzo Shepherds in the high pastures whispered of men who could wear wolf skins… and of the terrible price they paid for their hunger.
Taboo Treasures is a true crime–adjacent podcast that dives deep into the world's most shocking, macabre, and controversial artifacts—the objects that carry the weight of dark history, forbidden belief, and unspeakable acts. From the sneakers worn by the Heaven's Gate cult on their final night… to the copy of Catcher in the Rye found int he possession of the man who killed John Lennon… to relics, Barbie Dolls and memorabilia linked to murder, mystery, and mayhem—each episode unearths the twisted stories behind these rare and disturbing collectibles.
© 2020-2025 Ivy Podcast Discovery LLC
