Search for episodes from The Buck Stops Here with a specific topic:

Latest episodes from The Buck Stops Here

Hall of Fame Show: Coaching Scandals, World Cup Pricing, & Baseball Hall of Fame Snubs!

Play Episode Listen Later Dec 14, 2025 88:18


Welcome to Season 6, Episode 16 of The Hall of Fame Show with Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan!In this packed episode, the guys kick off the show with stories from the recent U.S. Athletics Hall of Fame announcement, featuring incredible insight from special guest Upton Bell, who was described as "an oracle from the early days".Then, Kirk shares a powerful PSA (rant) on powerful coaches and cheating scandals like Sherrone Moore and Ime Udoka. The conversation moves to the controversy surrounding the Seattle World Cup's decision to designate the Iran vs. Egypt match as a 'Pride Game' , and the "insane" dynamic ticket pricing from FIFA.The second half covers major Baseball Hall of Fame news, including the recent votes for Jeff Kent, Don Mattingly, and Dale Murphy , as well as the ongoing debate about PED-associated players like Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens. The show wraps up with the announcement of the Ford Frick Award winner, Joe Buck , and a look back at the lives and careers of the great playwright Tom Stoppard and former NFL Pro Bowl linebacker Chad Brown in Memoriam.0:00:34 Welcome to Season 6, Episode 16 of The Hall of Fame Show! 0:02:22 Upton Bell: An oracle with incredible stories about the early days of pro football.0:04:04 Kirk's PSA/Rant: Powerful Coaches and Cheating Scandals (Sherrone Moore).0:06:29 Cheating in the NBA: Ime Udoka and Nia Long.0:12:00 World Cup in Seattle: The irony of the designated "Pride Game" (Iran vs. Egypt).0:16:15 The "Insane" dynamic pricing and AI use for World Cup tickets.0:19:30 Baseball Hall of Fame: Reaction to the latest ballot results and Jeff Kent's chances.0:24:08 The Hall's clear strategy to eliminate PED candidates like Bonds and Clemens.0:36:07 Listener Hall of Fame Draft: Roger Federer (Tennis) and Jeff Kent (Baseball).0:41:49 Ford Frick Award Winner: Discussing Joe Buck's selection.0:45:46 Rene Cardenas's long wait for Hall of Fame induction.0:53:54 In Memoriam: Celebrating the life and work of playwright Tom Stoppard.1:16:37 In Memoriam: Remembering former NFL All-Pro linebacker Chad Brown and his passing at age 41.1:27:05 Shout out to Aaron James Freeman about the Not In Hall of Fame revisions for the Country Music list.1:28:14 Final thoughts and condolences for listener Richie Leitner.If you enjoyed this episode, please hit the like button, subscribe to the channel, and ring the notification bell so you never miss another Hall of Fame discussion! Let us know your thoughts on the cheating scandals, the World Cup pricing, and the latest Hall of Fame votes in the comments below!#HallOfFameShow #HOF #Podcast #SportsNews #MLBHOF #JoeBuck #WorldCup #FIFA #SherroneMoore #ImeUdoka #GoBlue #MichiganFootball #Celtics #JeffKent #BarryBonds #RogerClemens #ChadBrown #NFL #TomStoppard

Bill Belichick & Robert Kraft vs. The Seniors: Analyzing the ProFootball Hall of Fame Class Nominees

Play Episode Listen Later Dec 12, 2025 55:46


The Pro Football Hall of Fame voting process is more complicated than ever! Kirk Buchner and Paul Lawrence break down the final five non-Modern Era candidates for the Hall of Fame class: Coach Bill Belichick, Contributor Robert Kraft, and Senior Players Ken Anderson, Roger Craig, and L.C. Greenwood.Will the "Group of Five" voting math freeze out deserving Seniors like it did last year? The guys debate Belichick's "lock" status despite the scandals, Kraft's case as the ultimate contributor, and what the Hall needs to do to stop ignoring pre-1980 players.In this Episode:• The complex "Group of Five" HOF voting process• The argument for Coach Bill Belichick• Analyzing the candidacy of Contributor Robert Kraft• The tough road for Senior Finalists Ken Anderson, Roger Craig, and L.C. Greenwood• Paul Lawrence's proposal to fix the Senior backlogListen to more episodes and check out the rankings at NotInHallOfFame.com0:01:00 Breaking down the complex Hall of Fame voting process and the "group of five" finalists0:03:37 The difficult voting math that limits how many can be elected from the final five0:06:49 The case for Bill Belichick: Why he's an instant lock and the rule change that made it possible0:13:30 Addressing the Spygate and Deflategate controversies and if they matter to voters0:18:21 Robert Kraft's case: Six Super Bowls, saving the Patriots franchise, and his league influence0:24:52 Introducing the three Senior Finalists: Ken Anderson, Roger Craig, and L.C. Greenwood0:31:46 The tough math problem: Why Belichick and Kraft's votes shrink the total votes available for the Seniors0:38:35 The need for a "Super Senior" or Historian's Committee to get deserving pre-1980 players into the Hall0:46:06 Debating the Hall's preference for smaller classes and how it hurts fan engagement0:53:40 Why the Pro Football Hall of Fame needs more rotation in its 50-member voting committeeIf you enjoyed this debate, please like this video, subscribe to The Buck Stops Here for more Hall of Fame analysis, and share your own predictions for the class in the comments below!

2025 United States Athletics Hall of Fame Inductees Revealed! | Full Announcement Show

Play Episode Listen Later Dec 9, 2025 112:42


The wait is over! Join the NotInHallOfFame.com crew—Kirk Buchner, Evan Nolan, and special guests Upton Bell, Jack Silverstein, Chris Mouradian, Gil Florentino, Jack Moore, Ron Kaatz, Dave Whitlock, and Greg Oliver —as they unveil the third class of the United States Athletics Hall of Fame (theUSAHoF.com) for 2025!This highly anticipated class features legendary coaches, influential contributors, and 25 of the greatest athletes in American sports history, voted on by the public.In this video, we announce the inductees for three categories:Coaches: Featuring trailblazers like the first female coach inductee, an architect of modern NFL defense, and a college football giant.Contributors: From the "father of the NFL draft" and a key figure in the Negro Leagues, to the founder of the Elias Sports Bureau.Athletes: A diverse group including boxing legends, UFC pioneers, Olympic gold medalists, MLB icons, and the highest vote-getter—a tennis icon whose influence transcended the sport.Find out which of your favorites made the cut!Visit the Official Site: Check out the full list of inductees and learn more about the USA Hall of Fame selection process at theusahof.com!00:00:34 Welcome & Introduction: The NotInHallOfFame.com crew and guests introduce the announcement show.00:13:02 Hall of Fame Rules: Discussing the 50-year-old age requirement (and future eligibility for Tiger Woods). 00:14:11 COACHES ANNOUNCEMENT BEGINS00:14:11 Coach #5: Pat Summitt (First female coach inductee). 00:15:32 Coach #4: Eddie Robinson (All-time NCAA wins leader at retirement). 00:17:10 Coach #1 (Highest Vote-Getter): Tony Dungy (First Black head coach to win a Super Bowl). 00:18:13 Recap of the Top 5 Coaches. 00:21:29 CONTRIBUTORS ANNOUNCEMENT BEGINS00:21:50 Contributor #5: Bert Bell (NFL Commissioner, inventor of the NFL Draft). 00:32:04 Contributor #1 (Highest Vote-Getter): Seymour Siwoff (Elias Sports Bureau). 00:33:33 ATHLETES ANNOUNCEMENT BEGINS00:39:30 Athlete #25: Jack Johnson (Boxing, first Black heavyweight champion). 00:41:12 Athlete #21: Randy Couture (UFC pioneer). 00:43:21 Athlete #17: Mike Schmidt (Greatest third baseman, MVP). 00:47:01 Athlete #15: Pete Rose (Baseball's all-time hits leader). 00:57:01 Athlete #11: Kristi Yamaguchi (Figure Skating, first Asian American to win Winter Olympic gold). 00:58:49 Athlete #10: Dale Earnhardt (7-time NASCAR Champion). 01:06:22 Athlete #7: Jackie Joyner-Kersee (Track & Field, "America's first lady of track and field"). 01:25:28 Athlete #1 (Highest Vote-Getter): Arthur Ashe (Tennis icon). 01:28:14 Full List of the Top 25 Athletes Revealed.01:29:44 Discussion about past inductees and nominees.01:41:16 Planning for the future: Potential new nomination categories.

Who Gets In? Debating All 8 Candidates on the HOF Contemporary Era Ballot | Roundtable Discussion

Play Episode Listen Later Dec 4, 2025 109:17


Join Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan from NotInHallOfFame.com for a special roundtable debate focusing on all eight candidates on the Baseball Hall of Fame's Contemporary Era Ballot.The hosts are joined by an elite panel: Chris Mouradian, Blogger Tubbs, Longhorn Dave Whitlock, Jack Moore, and former professional baseball player Gill Florentino.The team dives deep into the cases for Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Jeff Kent, Carlos Delgado, Don Mattingly, and the others, discussing the controversial new rule that could permanently eliminate candidates, the hypocrisy of letting in Bud Selig and other managers from the steroid era, and whether the Hall is a "museum of history or an exclusive club".In a special segment, the panel holds two votes: one for who they would induct, and one for who they think the actual HOF committee will select!.00:00:34 The Core Topic: Analyzing all 8 Candidates on the HOF Contemporary Era Ballot 00:06:41 The New Elimination Rule for candidates who fail to get at least five votes00:07:48 Barry Bonds' HOF Case: Career stats (7 MVPs, 762 HR, 162.8 bWAR) and the controversy00:13:31 Bonds & Clemens: The argument that they are undeniable Hall of Famers based on talent00:17:58 The Hypocrisy of inducting Bud Selig & Steroid Era managers into the Hall00:25:17 Is the HOF a museum of history or an exclusive club?00:34:45 The case for Carlos Delgado's HOF induction00:46:28 Jeff Kent's Consistency: The best power-hitting Second Baseman?00:56:16 Don Mattingly: An "Elite" Player with an Epic but Short Peak01:28:53 The Panel's Two Votes: Who they would select and who they predict gets in 01:38:10 The Results: Panel's "Secret Ballot" revealed (Mattingly, Kent, Bonds, Clemens lead the votes)Subscribe for more Hall of Fame debates and join the conversation in the comments!Visit NotInHallOfFame.com to see all their lists and check out the new United States Athletics Hall of Fame!#BarryBonds #RogerClemens #BaseballHallOfFame #HOF #ContemporaryEra #VeteransCommittee #PEDs #JeffKent #CarlosDelgado #DonMattingly #MLB #Podcast #NotInHallOfFame #TheBuckStopsHere

November 2025 Sports Elevator | Philip Rivers' HoF Case, The Big Dumper, & The NBA's Problems

Play Episode Listen Later Dec 3, 2025 61:55


Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian are back on the Sports Elevator to look at who, in the last 30 days, made their Hall of Fame case go up in the elevator or pressed the button going down!This month, they dissect the Pro Football Hall of Fame semifinalists, debating whether a first-ballot semifinalist nod is Philip Rivers' biggest victory. In hockey, two stars cement their cases by hitting the 1,000-point milestone. On the baseball side, they analyze the MVP vote results, including "The Big Dumper" Cal Raleigh's record-setting season at catcherPlus, the hosts break down everything wrong with today's NBA, from flopping and the lack of physicality to the utterly forgettable NBA Cup.0:04:21 The biggest winner among Pro Football Hall of Fame semifinalists (Philip Rivers) 0:08:53 Brad Marchand's 1,000th career point cements his Hockey Hall of Fame legacy 0:14:29 Cal Raleigh's historic season and the controversy of "The Big Dumper" nickname 0:37:33 NBA Twitter drama (PJ Washington/Brittney Renner) and the useless NBA Cup 0:40:40 The decline of the NBA: Too many threes and the death of physicality 0:49:39 Ricky Watters' Hall of Fame case falls off the ballot after 20 years 0:55:03 The quarterback logjam: How the upcoming QB classes hurt Philip Rivers and Eli Manning 1:00:51 Barry Bonds and other players with "suspicious backgrounds" on the Veterans Committee ballot If you want to know who is Not In Hall of Fame, hit the like button, subscribe to the channel, and share this with a fellow sports fan!Don't miss our upcoming episodes, including the Baseball Roundtable and the announcement of the latest inductees for the United States Athletics Hall of Fame. #SportsHallofFame #ProFootballHallofFame #HOF #PhilipRivers #EliManning #BradMarchand #NikitaKucherov #CalRaleigh #JoseRamirez #MLB #NHL #NFL #NBA #NBACup #RickyWatters #BarryBonds #SportsPodcast #NotInHallofFame

MLB's PED Era Stars NOT in the Mitchell Report

Play Episode Listen Later Dec 3, 2025 35:06


Kirk Buchner (NotInHallOfFame.com) and Robert Dobek dive into the dark shadow the MLB's PED Era cast over some of the game's cleanest and best players. They analyze the careers of superstars who were not implicated in the Mitchell Report or any other scandal, arguing their Hall of Fame cases were wrongfully overshadowed by the inflated numbers of their juiced-up peers.From a fiery Yankees legend to a small-market OBP machine, you'll never look at the late 90s/early 2000s the same way!In this episode, we discuss:-How players like Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens created an unfair standard for greatness.-The surprising Hall of Fame-level statistics of players who never got the credit they deserved.-The argument that a player's OPS+ should outweigh their career hit totals.00:02:22 Why Paul O'Neill's Hall of Fame Case Was Lost in the Steroid Era00:04:14 Comparing O'Neill's WAR to Hall of Famers Kirby Puckett and Ryne Sandberg00:08:42 Brian Giles: A Career OPS+ Better Than Duke Snider and Andre Dawson00:11:45 How the Sosa/McGwire Chase Overshadowed Giles' MVP-Caliber Peak00:14:48 The Case for Shawn Green: One of the Era's Most Productive Right Fielders00:20:45 The Small-Market OBP King: Tim Salmon's Statistics vs. Tony Gwynn and Rod Carew00:26:00 Bernie Williams: Is the Yankees Center Fielder a Hall of Very Good Player?00:28:44 Todd Helton and the "Coors Field Effect" Bias00:31:30 Paul O'Neill's Impact: The Trade that Sparked the Yankees Dynasty00:34:26 Final Thoughts: Why We Need to Revisit the Overshadowed Stars

Hall of Fame News - PFHOF Surprise Debuts | Federer's HOF Slam Dunk

Play Episode Listen Later Nov 29, 2025 75:31


Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan return for Season 6, Episode 15 of The Buck Stops Here to break down the latest news from around the Hall of Fame world!Evan is back in action after a big exam and dives right into the controversial Pro Football Hall of Fame semi-finalists list, discussing first-ballot shoo-ins like Drew Brees and Larry Fitzgerald, the surprising inclusion of Kevin Williams, and the offensive line clog. They also update the Hall of Fame Draft with Roger Federer's unsurprising entry into the Tennis Hall of Fame and recap the latest inductees into the International Toy Hall of Fame.Later, they break down the ongoing vote for the United States Athletic Hall of Fame and talk about a Baseball Hall of Fame candidate who survived the writers' ballot. The show finishes with a look at the tragic story of NBA star Michael Ray Richardson and a retrospective on the NFL career of Seahawks legend Kenny Easley.00:00:34 | Intro: Season 6, Episode 15 with Kirk Buchner and the return of Evan Nolan.00:01:18 | Update on the United States Athletic Hall of Fame voting, noting the highly competitive contributor and coach categories.00:04:27 | Diving deep into the Pro Football Hall of Fame semifinalists.00:06:19 | Discussing first-ballot expectations for Drew Brees and Larry Fitzgerald.00:07:49 | Kevin Williams makes the list for the first time.00:11:32 | Critiquing the flawed PFHOF voting system and the wide receiver backlog.00:16:19 | A discussion on the pettiness that could keep Bill Belichick out of the Hall of Fame.00:17:33 | Hall of Fame Draft Update: Roger Federer's "slam dunk" induction into the Tennis HOF.00:21:52 | Guessing the newest inductees into the International Toy Hall of Fame.00:30:52 | Baseball HOF: The case for Carlos Beltran and Dustin Pedroia.00:45:52 | Hall of Fame of Shame: Analyzing the tragic, drug-destroyed career of NBA All-Star Michael Ray Richardson.01:02:18 | Paul Tagliabue's forgotten political impact, including saving the Saints after Hurricane Katrina.01:04:22 | A look back at the vicious hitting and surprise Hall of Fame induction of Seattle Seahawks safety Kenny Easley.01:12:21 | Kirk mentions recruiting an actual Pro Football Hall of Fame elector for their committee.Don't forget to cast your vote for the United States Athletic Hall of Fame at https://www.theUSAHOF.com ! Want to help us induct more deserving people? We are currently recruiting more members for our blue ribbon committee, including a Pro Football Hall of Fame elector, so visit theusahof.com to learn how you can join.#HOF #HallOfFameShow #ProFootballHallOfFame #PFHOF #DrewBrees #LarryFitzgerald #KevinWilliams #RogerFederer #TennisHOF #ToyHallOfFame #BaseballHOF #NFL #Podcast #NotInHallOfFame #BuckStopsHere

Pro Football Hall of Fame Class of 2026: Full Semifinalist Breakdown

Play Episode Listen Later Nov 28, 2025 62:54


Kirk Buchner and Paul Lawrence sit down to break down the newly announced 26 semifinalists for the Pro Football Hall of Fame Class of 2026.In this episode, the guys go position-by-position to analyze who made the cut, who got snubbed, and who is facing a "logjam" at their position. They discuss the difficult path for Philip Rivers compared to Eli Manning, the surprising omission of Ricky Waters, and why Kevin Williams is finally getting his due.Plus, they take a deep dive into the Senior, Coach, and Contributor pools—predicting how the committee might handle heavy hitters like Bill Belichick and Robert Kraft against deserving seniors like Roger Craig and Joe Jacoby.In this episode:Quarterbacks: Is Drew Brees the only lock?Running Backs: The "Compiler" argument against Frank Gore.Wide Receivers: How Larry Fitzgerald impacts Torry Holt and Reggie Wayne.The Trenches: The rise of Willie Anderson and the return of the "Williams Wall."Seniors: Will the committee use "sacrificial lambs" to get a specific candidate in?00:00:00 – Intro & The "Fictitious" Athlete Hall of Fame update.00:01:00 – Shedeur Sanders, the Browns, and the "Legendary" hype.00:03:00 – Quarterbacks: Drew Brees is a lock, but does Philip Rivers have a chance against Eli Manning?.00:08:00 – Running Backs: The shocking snub of Ricky Waters and the Frank Gore "compiler" debate.00:16:00 – Wide Receivers: Larry Fitzgerald enters the chat; the Hines Ward "20 for 20" prediction.00:20:00 – Tight Ends: Jason Witten's first-ballot chances vs. the Antonio Gates precedent.00:24:00 – Offensive Line: Steve Wisniewski's final year of eligibility and the rise of Willie Anderson.00:31:00 – Defensive Line: Kevin Williams (The Williams Wall) finally gets respect.00:35:00 – Linebackers: Luke Kuechly: Is he a lock for the final 7?.00:38:00 – Defensive Backs: Earl Thomas's character concerns & the safety logjam.00:41:00 – Special Teams: Adam Vinatieri's waiting game.00:45:00 – The Senior Committee Strategy: Using "pawns" to ensure specific candidates get elected?.00:50:00 – Coach & Contributor: The likelihood of Bill Belichick and Robert Kraft dominating the ballot.00:53:00 – Senior Candidates: Breaking down Roger Craig, Joe Jacoby, and the 49ers/Steelers representation.01:00:00 – Upcoming timeline for Finalist announcements and the vote.Which snub surprised you the most: Ricky Waters falling off the ballot or the continued wait for Sterling Sharpe? Let us know your "Class of 2026" predictions in the comments below!

The Ultimate All-90s MLB Team Debate! Pudge vs. Piazza, Ripken vs. Larkin

Play Episode Listen Later Nov 25, 2025 44:44


Welcome back to a special episode of The Buck Stops Here! Kirk Buchner and Rob the Yankee (Robert Dobek) are on the show to talk baseball and draft their ultimate All-1990s Major League Baseball team, position by position. The hosts dive deep into the differences between 90s hitters and the modern game, with the minimum expectation of a starter being seven innings back then.In this episode, they break down:Catcher: The tough battle between Ivan "Pudge" Rodriguez and Mike Piazza, with defense being the deciding factor. First Base: Debating whether Frank Thomas (The Big Hurt) or Jeff Bagwell deserves the nod, considering Frank Thomas's argument as the best all-around hitter in the 90s.Second Base: The no-brainer choice of Roberto Alomar. Shortstop: Cal Ripken Jr. vs. Barry Larkin, and whether games played should outweigh a great prime. Third Base: Why Matt Williams gets the pick over Chipper Jones for the decade. Outfield: Easy selections like Barry Bonds (pre-juicing era dominance) and Ken Griffey Jr., and the debate for the final spot between Tony Gwynn and Albert Belle. They even discuss Tony Gwynn's innovative use of video to study his at-bats.You'll hear the hosts' final All-90s lineups, and get a sneak peek at their next potential debate: an All-Time Yankees team vs. an All-Time Blue Jays team.00:01:14 Comparing 90s hitters to modern MLB and the expectation of a starter going seven innings00:04:12 The Catcher Debate: Ivan Rodriguez vs. Mike Piazza, and defense as the deciding factor00:06:36 The First Base Pick: Frank Thomas vs. Jeff Bagwell00:09:56 The easiest choice of the lineup: Roberto Alomar at second base00:11:44 Shortstop Showdown: Cal Ripken Jr. vs. Barry Larkin, and the weight of "games played"00:14:51 Why Matt Williams gets the pick over Chipper Jones for the decade at third base00:17:47 Locking in Barry Bonds (pre-juicing era dominance) and Ken Griffey Jr. in the Outfield00:19:45 Why Tony Gwynn gets the final Outfield spot (contact vs. power)00:22:49 Tony Gwynn's groundbreaking use of video to analyze his swing00:33:03 Kirk and Rob reveal their final All-90s Lineups00:34:45 Teasing a future debate: Could the Yankees' second all-time team win a championship?00:36:44 Robert asks Kirk for his "Franchise Four" for the Toronto Blue Jays00:38:03 Kirk names his Blue Jays Franchise Four: Stieb, Halladay, Bautista, Delgado00:42:08 Discussion on Blue Jays pitcher Alex Manoah and whether the team should "cut bait"00:44:09 Podcast hosts' closing remarks and final thoughtWho made your All-90s team that we missed? Let us know your favorite 90s players and your full lineup in the comments!If you enjoyed the debate, please Like this video, Subscribe to The Buck Stops Here for more special episodes, and hit the Notification Bell so you never miss a new episode! Make today count, because it never comes again!#MLB #Baseball #All90sTeam #90sBaseball #IvanRodriguez #Pudge #MikePiazza #FrankThomas #JeffBagwell #RobertoAlomar #CalRipkenJr #BarryLarkin #ChipperJones #TonyGwynn #KenGriffeyJr #BarryBonds #Podcast #TheBuckStopsHere

Top 10 Active MLB Players Who Are Hall of Famers Right Now | w/ Robert Dobek

Play Episode Listen Later Nov 22, 2025 55:08


In this special episode of The Buck Stops Here, Kirk Buchner and special guest Robert Dobek discuss the most pressing question in baseball: Which active players are already Hall of Fame worthy?They debate which current superstars have built a Cooperstown-worthy career if they retired today, regardless of service time or eligibility.From the incomparable unicorn Shohei Ohtani to the dominant trio of Cy Young winners (Kershaw, Verlander, Scherzer), Kirk and Rob break down the stats, awards, and narratives that make these active players future first-ballot inductees.Key Topics Discussed:• Is Shohei Ohtani a Hall of Famer before reaching the 10-year requirement? • The tragic career of Mike Trout on the Angels • The case for Freddie Freeman as the best all-around hitter of the last five years • Why Mookie Betts' willingness to play multiple positions earns him huge respect • The controversial take that Clayton Kershaw is the best Dodger of all time • The legacy of the Astros' engine, Jose Altuve • Is Bryce Harper built for the big moments and the postseason? 00:02:41 The Hall of Fame criteria: Discussing active players whose careers end today 00:04:04 Shohei Ohtani: Three MVPs and the 10-year service time hurdle 00:07:23 Mike Trout: Three MVPs and why injuries and the Angels organization have hurt his legacy 00:10:37 Freddie Freeman: MVP, postseason prowess, and his standing among first basemen 00:12:45 Mookie Betts: The defensive genius and versatile player who the Red Sox let go 00:15:37 Clayton Kershaw: Three Cy Youngs, 3,000 strikeouts, and the controversial "Best Dodger Ever" take 00:20:05 Justin Verlander: His dominance, MVP, and reinventing himself later in his career 00:22:15 Jose Altuve: The heart of the Astros and the debate around his place in history 00:26:13 Paul Goldschmidt: The case for the power hitter and great fielder 00:30:40 Max Scherzer: Completing the legendary Cy Young trio 00:39:27 Bryce Harper: Two MVPs and being "built for the big game" 00:44:38 Salvador Perez: A position player argument based on positional rarity (catcher) and longevity 00:50:22 Wrap-up and Next Episode Idea: A discussion on the Hockey Hall of Fame #MLB #BaseballHallofFame #Cooperstown #ShoheiOhtani #MikeTrout #MookieBetts #ClaytonKershaw #JustinVerlander #JoseAltuve #FreddieFreeman #MaxScherzer #BryceHarper #BaseballPodcast #TheBuckStopsHere #ActiveHOFCandidates #BaseballPicks #Dodgers #Astros #Angels• What active player did we miss? Drop your full top 10 list below and let us know!• Hit the like button if you agree with any of these picks, and subscribe to The Buck Stops Here for more in-depth Hall of Fame discussions across all sports!• Be sure to follow Robert Dobek for more of his insights and great baseball picks!

October 2025 Hall of Fame Elevator – Hall of Fame Heat Check

Play Episode Listen Later Nov 11, 2025 46:28


In this October edition of the Sports Elevator from Not in Hall of Fame, Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian debate which athletes and coaches are rising, falling, or stalling in their Hall of Fame trajectories. From Mookie Betts' postseason stumble to Dave Roberts' managerial mastery, Keenan Allen's milestone, and Ja Morant's off-court spiral, the hosts deliver sharp takes across MLB, NFL, and NBA.Plus: a final push to vote for the United States Athletic Hall of Fame—no email required, just your picks.

Pro Football Hall of Fame Cuts: Surprises, Snubs & Senior Shakeups Buck Stops Here Special

Play Episode Listen Later Nov 6, 2025 49:37


In this special episode of The Buck Stops Here, host Kirk Buchner is joined by Hall of Fame process guru Paul Lawrence to break down the latest Pro Football Hall of Fame cutdowns. From shocking quarterback omissions to the curious disappearance of Lester Hayes from the senior pool, Kirk and Paul dissect the modern, senior, and contributor categories with insight, candor, and a touch of reverence.They also reflect on the legacy of Nick Mangold following his untimely passing and explore how emotional timing can influence Hall of Fame voting. With transparency improving and ballots evolving, this episode is a must-watch for fans of football history, Hall of Fame politics, and the art of sports storytelling.

Rick Gosselin on the Chiefs, AFL Legacy & Hall of Fame Controversies

Play Episode Listen Later Oct 31, 2025 35:32


NFL historian and Hall of Fame selector Rick Gosselin joins Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian for a deep dive into his new book The Team That History Forgot, chronicling the overlooked greatness of the AFL-era Kansas City Chiefs. From Lamar Hunt's founding vision to Super Bowl redemption, Gosselin shares rare interviews, untold stories, and candid reflections on the Hall of Fame's senior selection process.

The Buck Stops Here -- Bill Belichick, Hall of Fame Chaos & Hockey Legends

Play Episode Listen Later Oct 24, 2025 92:48


In this jam-packed episode of The Buck Stops Here, Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan dive deep into Hall of Fame season madness—from the Pro Football Hall of Fame's coaching ballot shakeup to the latest inductees in the U.S. Hockey Hall of Fame. They debate Bill Belichick's legacy, mourn the loss of sports and music icons, and celebrate the unexpected rise of fan voting in the United States Athletic Hall of Fame.Plus: tributes to Sister Jean, Ace Frehley, and Robert Redford, and a look at the wild expansion draft history of the NHL. It's sports, pop culture, and irreverent commentary at its finest.

MLB LCS Breakdown: Dodgers vs Brewers, Jays vs Mariners + World Series Wildcards!

Play Episode Listen Later Oct 14, 2025 25:28


Kirk Buchner and Dave Whitlock return with a special edition of The Buck Stops Here to dissect the League Championship Series matchups. From the star-studded Dodgers to the gritty Brewers, and the unpredictable Blue Jays facing the powerhouse Mariners, this episode dives deep into playoff dynamics, pitching matchups, and the underdog narratives that could shape the World Series. Plus, Kirk shares his excitement about attending Game 3 in Toronto!

Play Episode Listen Later Oct 9, 2025 45:24


Welcome to the September edition of The Elevator Show from NotInHallOfFame.com! Hosts Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian ride the Hall of Fame elevator—tracking which athletes are moving up, down, or stuck between floors.This month's episode features:• Dennis Schröder's EuroBasket MVP and international legacy• Russell Wilson's career obituary: Hall of Fame or Hall of Forgotten?• Milestone moments for Justin Jefferson, Christian McCaffrey & Danielle Hunter• Tyreek Hill's ACL injury and off-field concerns• Nick Bosa's second major injury and political baggage• Melissa Jefferson-Wooden's double gold sprint into track history• A blanket “elevator down” for pre-Super Bowl era senior candidates

Inside the Hall of Fame: Clark Judge on Snubs, Politics & Legacy

Play Episode Listen Later Oct 2, 2025 50:23


Hall of Fame voter Clark Judge joins Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian for a no-holds-barred conversation about the Pro Football Hall of Fame selection process. From overlooked legends like Jerry Smith and Neil Smith to the politics behind contributor snubs like Ralph Hay, this episode dives deep into the stories that shape football history—and the ones that get left behind.Judge opens up about the emotional toll of the process, the impact of Zoom vs. in-person presentations, and why some candidates may never get another shot. If you care about football legacy, this is essential listening.

Kawhi's $50M Mystery & Hall of Fame Chaos

Play Episode Listen Later Oct 1, 2025 38:39


Kirk Buchner welcomes Ron Katz—former Broncos Fan of the Year and Hall of Fame insider—for a deep dive into two explosive topics: the shady $50 million Kawhi Leonard sponsorship deal and the baffling inconsistencies in the Pro Football Hall of Fame senior list. From money laundering red flags to forgotten legends like Rich “Tombstone” Jackson, this episode pulls no punches.

MLB Wildcard Preview: Upsets, Predictions & Playoff Chaos!

Play Episode Listen Later Sep 30, 2025 40:12


It's the most unpredictable time of the year—MLB Wildcard Week! Kirk Buchner and Dave Whitlock break down every matchup, from bullpen depth to breakout stars, and share their bold predictions for who survives the chaos. Will the Reds shock the Dodgers? Can Cleveland ride house money to glory? And is this the year Chapman cements his Hall of Fame case?⚾ Full breakdowns of all 4 Wildcard series

Top 30 NFL Hall of Fame Hopefuls: Kirk Buchner's Ultimate Countdown

Play Episode Listen Later Sep 25, 2025 98:11


The Buck Stops Here -- Hall of Fame Draft: Legends, Longshots & Living Props

Play Episode Listen Later Sep 16, 2025 86:01


Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan return with a vengeance in this jam-packed episode of The Buck Stops Here, diving headfirst into the 2026 Hall of Fame draft across sports, music, and even toys. From Drew Brees and Patrice Bergeron to Alicia Keys and the humble slide, they predict who's getting enshrined next—and who's getting snubbed again. Plus, tributes to recently departed legends, a spirited debate on Rock Hall backdoors, and a miniature dachshund named Winnie who steals the show.00:00:34 Kirk and Evan reunite—Winnie joins the show00:01:53 Introducing the first annual Hall of Fame draft00:02:49 Blackhawks launch their own Hall of Fame00:10:45 Premier League Hall of Fame nominees00:14:44 Draft rules explained—16 picks across 8 categories00:17:13 First picks: Drew Brees & Patrice Bergeron00:24:20 Roger Federer enters the Tennis Hall of Fame00:29:52 Alicia Keys leads Rock Hall predictions00:42:21 Oasis and Motorhead: Rock Hall backdoor contenders00:48:58 Serena Williams joins the Hall of Fame conversation01:00:17 Full draft recap—who picked who01:04:00 Tribute to Ken Dryden and other sports legends01:21:14 Farewell to Rick Davies of Supertramp01:24:50 Final call to action and site updatesVote now for the United States Athletic Hall of Fame at theUSAHoF.com ! And if you've got a Hall of Fame hot take, reach out—we might just feature you on the next episode.#HallOfFameDraft #TheBuckStopsHere #DrewBrees #PatriceBergeron #AliciaKeys #RockHall #SportsLegends #WinnieTheDog #NotInHallOfFame #PodcastLife #HallOfFame2026 #ChrisJericho #SerenaWilliams #SlideForTheWin

Hall of Fame Highs & Lows: August's Elevator Ride | Not in Hall of Fame Show

Play Episode Listen Later Sep 14, 2025 50:17


This month on The Elevator Show, Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian break down the biggest movers in the Hall of Fame conversation. From Rafael Devers' confusing trade impact to Jacob deGrom's elite sabermetrics case, we explore who's rising, who's falling, and who's stuck between floors.

Pete Rose, Shoeless Joe & the Hall of Fame: Redemption or Rejection?

Play Episode Listen Later Sep 6, 2025 47:34


Kirk Buchner and Robert Dobek dive deep into one of baseball's most enduring debates: Should Pete Rose and Shoeless Joe Jackson be inducted into the Hall of Fame? With MLB lifting bans on 18 individuals, the conversation expands into the ethics of legacy, the steroid era, MVP controversies, and how Hall of Fame standards vary across sports.From the 1919 Black Sox scandal to modern PED suspensions, this episode explores whether greatness on the field can—or should—outweigh flaws off it. Plus, the guys go off-script with hot takes on football, hockey, and the business behind Hall of Fame voting.________________________________________• 00:00 – Opening banter: New York vs. Long Island & USA Hockey nostalgia• 00:01 – MLB reinstates 18 individuals: What it means for Rose & Jackson• 00:03 – Shoeless Joe's 1919 stats and the case for innocence• 00:06 – Gambling, snitching, and the ethics of silence• 00:07 – Jackson's background and literacy: Was he exploited?• 00:08 – Hall of Fame eligibility in 2027 and the Veterans Committee• 00:10 – Pete Rose's off-field controversies and public perception• 00:13 – Comparing Rose to Ty Cobb: Grit vs. grace• 00:15 – What “fame” really means in Hall of Fame• 00:17 – Should Rose's playing career outweigh his flaws?• 00:20 – Steroid era breakdown: Bonds, A-Rod, Manny, and hypocrisy• 00:23 – MVP snubs and Hall of Fame inconsistencies• 00:28 – The business of Hall of Fame weekends: Cooperstown vs. Canton• 00:31 – Big Hall vs. Small Hall: Where do you draw the line?• 00:34 – Cross-sport comparisons: Gretzky, Ovechkin, Vince Carter, Drew Brees• 00:42 – Final predictions: Will Rose and Jackson get in?• 00:44 – Bonus NFL talk: Saints, Jameis Winston, and QB chaos________________________________________#PeteRose #ShoelessJoeJackson #MLBHallOfFame #BaseballControversy #SteroidEra #SportsDebate #Cooperstown #FootballTalk #HockeyLegends #JameisWinston #DrewBrees #BarryBonds #Arod #SportsEthics________________________________________If you love sports history, hot takes, and debates that go beyond the box score, smash that like button and subscribe. Drop your thoughts in the comments—should Pete Rose and Shoeless Joe finally be honored in Cooperstown?

Why the Pro Football Hall of Fame Is Broken | Kirk Buchner & Paul Lawrence Tell All

Play Episode Listen Later Aug 27, 2025 43:15


In this candid and insightful episode of The Buck Stops Here, Kirk Buchner sits down with Hall of Fame expert Paul Lawrence to dissect the evolving—and controversial—selection process of the Pro Football Hall of Fame. From rule changes and vote-splitting chaos to the overlooked legends of the pre-Super Bowl era, this conversation pulls no punches.They explore:• Why the 2025 class was the smallest in decades• The math behind the voting system• The impact of Bill Belichick and Robert Kraft's eligibility• The fading recognition of senior candidates• The economic ripple effect on Canton

Interview With Mark Baughan -- Maxie Baughan's Legacy: A Son's Fight for Hall of Fame Recognition

Play Episode Listen Later Aug 14, 2025 25:18


In this heartfelt episode of The Buck Stops Here, host Kirk Buchner welcomes Mark Baughan, son of football legend Maxie Baughan. Together, they explore the life and legacy of Maxie—his humility at home, his quiet dominance on the field, and the frustrating journey toward Pro Football Hall of Fame recognition. Mark shares personal stories, celebrity encounters, and his candid thoughts on the Hall's changing rules and overlooked legends.

The Hall of Fame Elevator -- July 2025

Play Episode Listen Later Aug 9, 2025 37:08


Welcome to the July 2025 edition of the NotInHallOfFame.com Elevator Show! Hosts Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian break down which athletes and personalities have moved up or down in their Hall of Fame trajectories over the past 30 days. From surprise WWE returns to Olympic hopefuls and baseball legends in the making—or fading—this episode covers it all.

Hall of Fame News

Play Episode Listen Later Aug 1, 2025 79:49


In this emotionally charged episode of The Buck Stops Here Hall of Fame Show, Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan reflect on the lives and legacies of dozens of athletes, entertainers, and cultural icons we've recently lost. From the impact of Ryne Sandberg on the Chicago Cubs to the complicated legacy of Hulk Hogan and the groundbreaking artistry of Ozzy Osbourne, this episode dives deep into Hall of Fame moments, personal memories, and historical significance.Tune in to hear heartfelt tributes, sharp commentary, and fascinating facts about names that shaped sports, music, and entertainment. Whether you're a Hall of Fame voter, fan, or trivia junkie — this one's for you.

Vinny Makes the Hall of Fame Case For... Tom Green

Play Episode Listen Later Jul 30, 2025 23:35


Vinny Lospinuso dives into the wild and boundary-pushing legacy of Canadian comedian Tom Green, making a compelling case for his induction into the Canadian Walk of Fame. From MTV trailblazing to envelope-pushing films and unpredictable public antics, Vinny explores how Tom Green challenged norms and changed comedy forever.

The Hall of Fame Elevator -- June 2025 -- From Giannis Drama to Panthers Dynasty

Play Episode Listen Later Jul 12, 2025 43:31


The Elevator Show is back for June 2025 as Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian break down who's trending up—or plummeting down—in the race to sports immortality. From the highs and lows of the NBA and NHL Finals to pivotal offseason trades and Hall of Fame implications, they examine how the past month has reshaped legacies.

Albert Belle: Baseball's Most Misunderstood Hall of Fame Candidate?

Play Episode Listen Later Jul 7, 2025 40:08


In this compelling episode of The Buck Stops Here, Kirk Buchner welcomes baseball analyst and historian Robert Dobek for an unfiltered, in-depth conversation about Albert Belle—one of the most explosive and controversial figures in 1990s baseball. They unpack Belle's unrivaled offensive dominance, his tumultuous relationship with the media, the infamous bat-corking incident, and the legacy that's keeping him out of Cooperstown.Expect stats, storytelling, and some heated takes as Kirk and Robert ask: is it time to forgive Belle's persona and honor his performance?

From Dominican Sandlots to Giants Dugouts: Gill Florentino's Wild Baseball Ride

Play Episode Listen Later Jun 29, 2025 52:53


In this special episode of The Buck Stops Here, host Kirk Buchner dives deep with Gill Florentino—former pitcher, entrepreneur, and proud son of San Pedro de Macorís. From milk-carton gloves in the Dominican Republic to brushing shoulders with Hall of Famers in MLB clubhouses, Florentino shares an incredible journey of grit, culture, and baseball history. Learn how Dominican sugar plantations birthed a baseball Mecca, why Barry Bonds deserves better Hall of Fame treatment, and what really happened behind Rafael Devers' trade from the Boston Red Sox. This is not just a baseball story—it's a human one.

Hall of Fame News

Play Episode Listen Later Jun 16, 2025 58:47


Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan return with another compelling episode of The Buck Stops Here! In Season 6, Episode 10, they celebrate fresh inductees, debate the growing U.S. Athletic Hall of Fame class, and pay heartfelt tributes to sports and pop culture figures we've lost.

Play Episode Listen Later Jun 12, 2025 68:33


Welcome to the official announcement of the United States Athletics Hall of Fame 2025 nominees! This year, we introduce the new contenders who will replace the inductees from 2024, bringing fresh faces to the ballot for one of the most prestigious sports honors in the country.Join Kirk Buchner, Evan Nolan, and special guests as they unveil the list, discuss each nominee's achievements, and reflect on some legendary careers. Don't forget to vote daily at TheUSAHOF.com to help decide who will be inducted this year!✅ Vote daily at TheUSAHOF.com to make your voice heard!

The Hall of Fame Elevator -- May 2025

Play Episode Listen Later Jun 8, 2025 48:36


Welcome to the *May Hall of Fame Elevator Show*, where Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian dive deep into the latest Hall of Fame conversations! Who's rising toward greatness, and who's plummeting into obscurity? From *hockey legends* to *basketball hopefuls*, *college football coaching shakeups* to *controversial comebacks*, this episode is packed with insights, debates, and surprises!

Vinny Makes the Hall of Fame Case For... Pete Rose & Shoeless Joe Jackson

Play Episode Listen Later May 23, 2025 48:27


Hall of Fame News

Play Episode Listen Later May 19, 2025 54:53


Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan break down one of the most historic moments in MLB history—the reinstatement of Pete Rose, Shoeless Joe Jackson, and 16 others who were previously banned from Major League Baseball.⚾ What does this decision mean for baseball's future?

The Hall of Fame Elevator -- April 2025

Play Episode Listen Later May 6, 2025 38:52


Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian break down who helped—or hurt—their Hall of Fame case this past month across NHL, MLB, NBA, and WNBA. From rising stars to unexpected slumps, they tackle the performances shaping sports history.

Hall of Fame News

Play Episode Listen Later May 3, 2025 89:01


In Season 6, Episode 8, Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan dive deep into the latest Hall of Fame inductions, the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame's newest class, and some head-turning moments in the NFL Draft. Expect strong opinions, insightful breakdowns, and plenty of humor along the way!

Hall of Fame News

Play Episode Listen Later Apr 30, 2025 46:01


Welcome to **Season 6, Episode 7** of the longest-running show in the **Buchnerverse**—the Hall of Fame Show!

Vinny Makes the Hall of Fame Case For... Robert Cade

Play Episode Listen Later Apr 29, 2025 13:48


Join Vinny Lospinuso and Kirk Buchner as they delve into the incredible story of Robert Cade, the inventor of Gatorade, and why he deserves to be enshrined in the Florida Sports Hall of Fame.

The Buck Stops Here -- Pro Football Hall of Fame: 2029 & 2030 Preview – Legends Discussed!

Play Episode Listen Later Apr 28, 2025 49:07


Join Kirk Buchner and Paul Lawrence in a detailed exploration of NFL legends and Hall of Fame prospects. As retirements unfold, they examine who stands out as future inductees for the Pro Football Hall of Fame, including big names like Zack Martin, Tyron Smith, Julio Jones, Patrick Peterson, Von Miller, and Aaron Rodgers.The discussion also touches on challenges like the logjam at wide receiver, smaller Hall of Fame classes, and the legacy of offensive linemen in NFL history. Kirk and Paul offer thoughtful predictions, breakdowns of career stats, and dynamic conversation about what these retirements mean for the Hall of Fame's future.- **00:00:34** - Episode intro: Kirk and Paul dive into Hall of Fame retirements as the NFL Draft looms - **00:04:01** - Zack Martin's retirement: A look at his legendary career and first-ballot potential - **00:09:42** - Tyron Smith's retirement: Outstanding offensive tackle's Hall chances and challenges - **00:19:04** - Hall logjam: Wide receivers face a tough path—how Julio Jones fits in - **00:27:46** - Patrick Peterson: Career highs and whether he could be a finalist in 2029 - **00:32:09** - Von Miller's status: If this is it, would he be a first-ballot Hall inductee? - **00:34:28** - Aaron Rodgers discussion: Public perception, career legacy, and uncertain future - **01:25:04** - Closing thoughts: Preview of exciting projects in the Buchnerverse! #NFLLegends #ProFootballHallofFame #HallOfFame2029 #HallOfFame2030 #JulioJones #AaronRodgers #NFLDraft #WideReceiverLogjamWhat's YOUR take on these NFL retirements? Share your thoughts in the **comments**, hit **LIKE** to support our content, and don't forget to **SUBSCRIBE** for more insightful Hall of Fame discussions!

The Buck Stops Here -- Hall of Fame News -- Season 6 Episode 6

Play Episode Listen Later Apr 12, 2025 89:32


Welcome to Season Six, Episode Six of the “Not In Hall of Fame” show—a no-holds-barred, irreverent dive into how we sometimes question the process for honoring sports legends. In this episode, hosts Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan explore:-The controversial shifts in eligibility rules for the Basketball Hall of Fame—debating how recency bias, active-player inductions, and unexpected replacement nominees (think Sue Bird and Carmelo Anthony) are reshaping the landscape.-The heated discussion over the Football Hall of Fame, with a special focus on cases like Julio Jones' retirement, the Patriots' legacy, and the mix of personalities from Bill Parcells to Logan Mankins.-Tributes and in‐memoriam segments where the hosts honor departed icons from across sports and entertainment—from revered athletes and coaches to influential music and film stars.-Teasers for upcoming shows and deep-dive projects that will feature guest interviews and behind‑the‑scenes insights on the unscripted world of sports history and legacy.- **00:00:00 | Episode Kickoff & Nominee Speculation** - **00:02:41 | Travel Tales & Anecdotes** - **00:03:34 | Basketball Hall of Fame Insights & Legacy Debates** - **00:09:04 | Spotlight on Legends: From Sue Bird to Carmelo & Dwight** - **00:15:30 | Transition to Football & Team Legacy Discussions** - **00:21:03 | Football Hall of Fame Debates & Patriots Focus** - **00:29:05 | Deep Dive: Committee Processes & Tactical Banter** - **00:35:11 | In Memoriam – Tributes to Lost Sports & Entertainment Legends**- **00:51:18 | Extended Remembrances: More Obituaries Across Sports & Music** - **01:05:07 | Celebrating Cultural Icons: Jazz, Film, & More** - **01:18:06 | Favorite Films, Future Shows & Final Banter** - **01:25:07 | Closing Remarks & Sign-Off** #NotInHallOfFame #HallOfFameDebate #SportsTalk #BasketballLegends #FootballHOF #HockeyHistory #SueBird #CarmeloAnthony #DwightHoward #JulioJones #PatriotsHistory #SportsTributes #LegacyDebate #SportsCulture #DeepDiveIf you enjoyed our unfiltered debate on what defines a true sports legend—and if you appreciate our mix of humor, hard-hitting analysis, and heartfelt tributes—please **like** and **subscribe** for more episodes.

The Buck Stops Here: Jim Tyrer's Legacy—A Tale of Tragedy, Triumph, and the Hall of Fame Debate

Play Episode Listen Later Apr 6, 2025 31:19


Join host Kirk Buchner and guest journalist/filmmaker Kevin Patrick Allen in this in-depth episode of The Buck Stops Here as they explore the complex and untold story of Jim Tyrer—once among the very best offensive linemen who never made it into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. In their candid conversation, they cover everything from Tyrer's tragic off-field events and evolving discussions on concussions and CTE, to the investigative breakthroughs behind Kevin's upcoming documentary Beneath the Shadow. They also delve into the support system around Tyrer's family, the intricacies of the Hall of Fame voting process, and the challenges of untangling myth from fact. This episode is a must-watch for football history enthusiasts and anyone interested in the real stories behind the legends.You can see more about Kevin Patrick Allen's documentary *Beneath the Shadow* at this link: https://www.kppllc.net/beneath-the-shadow/- **0:00 – Introduction & Welcome** Kirk kicks off the episode and introduces the special guest, Kevin Patrick Allen.- **0:40 – Kevin's Background** Kevin shares insights into his journey as a journalist and filmmaker, shaped by his unique upbringing.- **1:30 – The Controversial Legacy of Jim Tyrer** The conversation turns to Jim Tyrer—his stellar career, the tragic events surrounding his life, and how it impacted his Hall of Fame eligibility.- **3:30 – New Perspectives on Concussions & CTE** Kirk and Kevin discuss how evolving research into concussions and CTE has reshaped our understanding of Tyrer's fate.- **4:20 – Investigative Breakthroughs & Evidence** Kevin explains his in-depth investigation, revealing that 90% of the key evidence was uncovered, which dramatically changed the narrative.- **5:00 – The Hall of Fame Voting Dilemma** A look at how Tyrer's personal tragedy affected his status as a finalist and the broader implications of the voting process.- **7:10 – Support from the Chiefs Organization** Kevin recounts how the Chiefs' historians and the old-guard players have offered unwavering support to Tyrer's family.- **14:15 – Behind the Documentary “Beneath the Shadow”** An exclusive preview of Kevin's upcoming documentary, including the emotional journey of the Tyrer family and the complex research behind the film.- **16:30 – Impact on Tyrer's Children** A heartfelt discussion about the traumatic experience for Tyrer's children and the resilience they've shown in the aftermath.- **20:30 – Family Resilience & Grandparents' Support** Insights into the remarkable role that grandparents played in helping the children cope with their loss.- **21:20 – Documentary Release & Voter Insights** Kevin reveals plans for the documentary's release, sharing how interviews with Hall of Fame voters provided crucial perspectives.- **24:20 – Debunking Myths & Voting Misconceptions** The duo examines how misinformation around the Hall of Fame process has muddied the waters when assessing Tyrer's legacy.- **26:10 – Cognitive Impairment & Moral Reasoning** A deep dive into how CTE impacts decision-making and behavior, challenging our conventional notions of premeditation.- **28:00 – Reflecting on Football History & Legacy** Kirk and Kevin discuss the enduring debate over how best to honor football legends amid complex personal histories.- **30:40 – Final Thoughts & What's Next** The conversation winds down with reflections on the future of Tyrer's narrative, upcoming projects, and a final word on the legacy of this storied figure.#JimTyrer #BuckStopsHere #NFLHistory #FootballLegacy #InvestigativeJournalism #KirkBuchner #KevinPatrickAllen #HallOfFame #CTE #DocumentaryIf Jim Tyrer's story resonates with you, please hit **like**, leave a comment sharing your thoughts, and subscribe for more in-depth discussions on football's untold stories. Let's keep the conversation going as we honor the legacies that shape the game!

Jeff Kent's Hall of Fame Case: Breaking Down MLB's Toughest Debates with Robert Dobek

Play Episode Listen Later Apr 4, 2025 16:49


Join Kirk Buchner and Robert Dobek for a compelling deep dive into Hall of Fame debates in this special episode of The Buck Stops Here. Kicking off with a case for Jeff Kent's enshrinement, Robert presents his argument for why Kent deserves a spot in Cooperstown, backed by unparalleled power numbers for a second baseman and his standout performance in San Francisco.The conversation touches on topics like Kent's offensive dominance compared to other Hall of Fame second basemen, his fielding progression, and his interactions with the media. The duo also explores the nuances of the Baseball Hall of Fame voting process, including ballot dynamics and comparisons with other players such as Chase Utley, Scott Rolen, and Andruw Jones. As they discuss, Kirk and Robert dissect the loaded 2025 ballot, controversies surrounding PEDs, and the evolving criteria for Hall of Fame selection.Packed with insights, this is a must-watch for baseball enthusiasts and anyone intrigued by the inner workings of Hall of Fame voting.00:00:34 - Opening remarks and introducing the episode format.00:01:19 - Robert Dobek's passion for baseball history and Hall of Fame debates.00:01:48 - Making the case for Jeff Kent: MLB's offensive powerhouse at second base.00:03:06 - Kent's stellar numbers and MVP season—despite playing during the steroid era.00:05:20 - Does Kent's strained relationship with the media affect his Hall of Fame chances?00:06:29 - Comparisons with other legends: Barry Bonds, Lou Gehrig, and David Ortiz.00:08:02 - Hall of Fame ballot dynamics: Are rule changes punishing players unfairly?00:11:14 - Elevator pitch for Jeff Kent's Hall of Fame candidacy.00:13:00 - Gut reactions to the 2025 ballot: Beltran, Ichiro, Andrew Jones, and PED debates.00:16:08 - Kirk's updates on future Not in Hall of Fame projects and lists.00:16:56 - Closing remarks and a heartfelt reflection on the importance of baseball history.#BaseballHallOfFame #JeffKent #MLBHistory #BaseballLegends #CooperstownDebate #HallOfFameVoting #KirkBuchner #TheBuckStopsHere #RobertDobek #NotInHallOfFame #SportsHistory #MLBDebate #SecondBaseStats #ScottRolen #ChaseUtley #BarryBonds #PEDControversy #AndruwJones #BaseballEnthusiastsWho belongs in Cooperstown? Drop your thoughts in the comments! Did Jeff Kent's numbers make you reconsider his Hall of Fame case? Subscribe to Not in Hall of Fame for more riveting conversations and updates on baseball history. Don't forget to hit the like button and share with fellow baseball enthusiasts!

The Hall of Fame Elevator -- March 2025

Play Episode Listen Later Apr 4, 2025 28:05


In this fast-paced episode of the Elevator Show, hosts Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian cut through the noise of the past 30 days in sports with their trademark blend of witty banter and deep-dive analysis. They kick off by dissecting a controversial 80-game suspension and exploring new MLB playoff roster rules while playfully ribbing athletes like Jurickson Profar. The conversation then pivots to hot topics such as Pete Rose's potential Hall of Fame comeback, James Harden's late-season resurgence with the Clippers, and the emergence of Cleveland's young star, Evan Mobley, on the NBA radar.The show also dives into college sports, discussing coaching legacies, NCAA controversies, and Final Four ambitions that shape the future of basketball. And for hockey fans, there's a thrilling recap of the Wisconsin Badgers Women's Frozen Four—featuring a clutch penalty shot and overtime game-winner by Kristen Simms—that highlights the rising prominence of women's sports.Whether you're a die-hard baseball fan, basketball buff, or hockey enthusiast, this episode is packed with insights and debate that capture the ever-evolving dynamics of sports.00:00:15: - Introduction to the Elevator Show's theme with a humorous jab at Jurickson Profar.00:00:40: - Discussion on an 80-game suspension for PEDs and new MLB playoff roster rules that shake up the status quo.00:02:22: - Banter about shifting sports narratives as hosts revisit the legacy of figures like Paul George.00:06:29: - Dive into the ongoing debate over Pete Rose's Hall of Fame eligibility, spurred by controversial remarks and evolving MLB policies.00:10:56: - Update on James Harden's resurgence--exploring his journey towards a potential first-ballot Hall of Fame nod.00:14:05: - Spotlight on Cleveland Cavaliers' rising star Evan Mobley, highlighting his breakout performance as an emerging All-Star and defensive force.00:19:08: - Thrilling recap of the Wisconsin Badgers Women's Frozen Four, featuring Kristen Simms' clutch penalty shot and game-winning overtime goal.00:22:04: - In-depth analysis of college basketball coaching legacies and NCAA controversies, with insights on figures like Kelvin Sampson and Bruce Pearl.00:27:56: - Wrap-up with a look ahead to upcoming Hall of Fame voting and future episodes that promise even more spirited sports debates.#ElevatorShow #SportsTalk #MLB #Hockey #NBA #CollegeSports #FinalFour #HallOfFame #PeteRose #JamesHarden #EvanMobley #FrozenFour #BadgersHockey #sportsdebate If you love deep-dives into the hottest sports debates, make sure to subscribe to our channel and hit the notification bell so you never miss an episode of the Elevator Show. Join the conversation—drop your thoughts and predictions in the comments and share this video with fellow sports fans. And don't forget to vote for your favorite athletes on NotInHallOfFame.com, because every voice counts in shaping sports history. Make today count!

Hall of Fame News

Play Episode Listen Later Mar 18, 2025 91:47


Welcome to Season 6, Episode 5 of the Hall of Fame Show—the official program of NotInHallOfFame.com.. Join hosts Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan for a profound journey through the world of Hall of Fame legacies, sports, entertainment, and personal memories.This episode packs everything from heartfelt tributes and candid banter to deep dives into wrestling, football, music, and more. Together, Kirk and Evan discuss:-The latest Hall of Fame inductions, including WWE legends Triple H and Lex Luger.-Reflections on iconic figures, from musical great Roberta Flack to unforgettable actors like Gene Hackman.-The complex careers of NFL standouts like Zack Martin and Dwight Howard.-Honest and sometimes humorous takes on the lives, careers, and untimely losses of numerous legends.The episode also offers poignant moments, as the hosts grapple with the personal losses that have shaped their perspectives. This installment is not just an exploration of greatness but a celebration of resilience, creativity, and human connection.#HallOfFameShow #NotInHallOfFame #WWEHallOfFame #MusicLegends #GeneHackman #NFLHallOfFame #SportsPodcast #EntertainmentLegends #PodcastLife00:00:34 – Introduction & Welcome: Kirk and Evan kick off the show and tease upcoming topics, from WWE inductions to U.S. Athletics updates.00:03:34 – WWE Hall of Fame Inductions: The hosts discuss wrestling legends, including Triple H and Lex Luger's well-deserved recognition.00:09:32 – Shock Master Memories: Kirk pauses for a laugh about the infamous debut of Shock Master and other tag team nostalgia.00:13:44 – Lex Luger's Legacy: A heartfelt dive into Luger's inspiring journey, from hardships to WWE's overdue acknowledgment.00:16:16 – NFL Legacy Focus: Zack Martin's retirement and his Hall of Fame prospects, alongside discussions of legendary guards.00:22:10 – Tributes to Music Greats: Reflecting on the incredible contributions of Jerry Butler, Roberta Flack, and Angie Stone, among others.00:41:05 – Dwight Howard's Orlando Magic Legacy: Kirk and Evan explore Dwight Howard's career, from his dominance in the early years to his challenges adapting to the changing game of basketball.00:48:11 – Hockey Reflections: A discussion of Brad Marchand's trade and the shifting dynamics of the Boston Bruins.00:53:04 – Sports Figures We Lost: Honoring notable sports figures who recently passed away, including Craig Wolfley, Meg Collier, and Joe Fusco.01:12:00 – Gene Hackman's Legacy: A tribute to Hackman's incredible career, spanning movies like The French Connection and Unforgiven.If you loved our exploration of legendary figures and Hall of Fame greatness, make sure to LIKE this video, COMMENT with your favorite memory or figure discussed, and SUBSCRIBE to our channel for more engaging episodes. Don't forget to ring the BELL ICON to stay updated on future uploads!

Play Episode Listen Later Mar 5, 2025 66:05


Welcome to a special episode of The Buck Stops Here! Join Kirk Buchner and Jack Moore as they dive deep into Jack's incredible journey as a lifelong Washington Redskins fan, his thoughts on the team's name change, and his optimism for the Commanders' future. From childhood memories of attending games to insightful discussions on football legends and the Hall of Fame, this episode is packed with nostalgia, passion, and thought-provoking conversations.Jack shares his unique perspective on the evolution of the NFL, the impact of legendary players, and the cultural shifts within the sport. Whether you're a die-hard football fan or just love a good story, this episode is a must-listen!

Hall of Fame News -- part 2

Play Episode Listen Later Feb 22, 2025 69:21


Join hosts Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan for an insightful and comprehensive discussion on various sports topics and hall of fame nominations. From the latest updates on the United States Athletics Hall of Fame and the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame nominees, to in-depth explorations of individuals like Carmelo Anthony, Dwight Howard, and Mariah Carey, this episode covers it all. Expect historical anecdotes, memorable moments, and significant contributions from various sports figures. The hosts also pay tribute to notable figures who have recently passed away, honoring their lasting impact.Episode Highlights: [00:00:35 - 00:01:02] Introduction to Season 6, Episode 4 [00:01:02 - 00:01:18] United States Athletics Hall of Fame digital ballot announcement [00:01:32 - 00:01:55] Rock and Roll Hall of Fame nominees discussion [00:09:40 - 00:09:59] NBA vs. NHL All-Star systems comparison [00:17:30 - 00:17:53] Speculation on the Hall of Fame selection process [00:19:01 - 00:19:18] Dušan Ivković's career and achievements [00:20:03 - 00:20:18] Impact of notable inductees on attendance [00:26:23 - 00:26:47] Influence of Kobe vs. LeBron [00:31:22 - 00:31:56] Sue Bird's legendary career [00:34:42 - 00:35:30] Tal Brody's influence on Israeli basketball [00:38:42 - 00:39:10] Analysis of Dwight Howard's career and controversies [00:43:04 - 00:43:36] Reflection on Carmelo Anthony's impact and candidacy [00:45:49 - 00:46:32] Predictions for Hall of Fame inductees [00:46:32 - 00:46:44] Necessity of inducting the 2008 team [00:46:44 - 00:47:04] Consideration of additional inductees and their significance [00:47:04 - 00:47:11] Last year's surprising inductees [00:47:11 - 00:47:24] Reflection on the increasing number of inductees [00:48:04 - 00:48:39] Future topics, including the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame [00:51:00 - 00:51:24] Tribute to notable figures who recently passed away

Claim The Buck Stops Here

In order to claim this podcast we'll send an email to with a verification link. Simply click the link and you will be able to edit tags, request a refresh, and other features to take control of your podcast page!

Claim Cancel